Migration from plasticized poly(vinyl chloride) into fatty media: importance of simulant selectivity for the choice of volatile fatty simulants

Spectroscopic and chemometric evaluation of cling films used for wrapping of foodstuff and illicit drugs

Thin films of various polymers are currently used for wrapping various food products and illicit drugs worldwide. In thin films, polyvinyl chloride is the third most widely used polymer after the polyethylene and polypropylene. These films usually contain harmful plasticizers such as adipates, phthalates, and citrates along with other additives. Plasticizers adversely affect the human health and therefore, their migration in foodstuff must be monitored carefully. By considering all these facts, this study summarizes the utilities of non-destructive ATR-FTIR spectroscopy in the identification of base polymer as well as plasticizers in various cling films and application of multivariate analysis in the identification and classification of the cling films to their respective groups. In the present research, a considerable transfer of plasticizers from the wrapping material is observed. A spectral library is developed for all 22 cling film samples for further comparison of the unknown sample. The obtained results are promising, especially for classification purposes. The multivariate method significantly provides 100% of cross-validation classification along with 99.13% discrimination. In this study, we have developed a method to compare or link a cling film which somebody uses and found that there is a transfer of plasticizers and other additives into the food and if the manufacturing company disown that this specific cling film does not belong to our company. In such type of cases, this method could link the suspected cling film to their manufacturers with precision and accurateness. The chronic effect of plasticizers on human health can also be linked to the type of cling film the accused was using consistently.

What is and what should never be: artifacts, improbable phytochemicals, contaminants and natural products

The scope of this review is to sensitize the natural product chemists to the underestimated problem related to artifact, comprising contaminants and improbable natural compounds. This review wants to give an overview about the various facets of this problem and to provide some hints to avoid incurring these situations. It does not pretend to report exhaustively about all the cases available in literature. The issue of artifacts has always existed and is quite impossible to completely eliminate because the results of phytochemical analysis are known only at the end of the work and in many cases there is not the possibility to compare the results. Therefore, it is important to take the necessary precautions during the workout in order to minimize the possibility that an unexpected event may occur. In second instance, anyone involved in these studies should increase the level of self-criticism with respect to the obtained experimental results.

Migration of di(2-ethylhexyl) adipate and acetyltributyl citrate plasticizers from food-grade PVC film into sweetened sesame paste (halawa tehineh): Kinetic and penetration study

Food-grade polyvinyl chloride (PVC) cling-film containing 5.3% (w/w) di(2-ethylhexyl) adipate (DEHA) and 3.0% (w/w) acetyltributyl citrate (ATBC) plasticizers was used to wrap halawa tehineh (halva) samples. Samples were split into two groups and stored at 25+/-1 degrees C. One group was analyzed for DEHA and ATBC content at intervals between 0.5 and 240h of contact (kinetic study) and a second group was cut into slices (1.5mm thick) after 240h of halva/PVC contact and was analyzed for DEHA and ATBC content (penetration study). Determination of both plasticizers was performed using a direct gas chromatographic (GC) method after extraction of DEHA from halva samples. DEHA readily migrated into halva samples: the equilibrium amount of DEHA in halva (3.31mg/dm(2) film or 81.4mg/kg halva) corresponding to a loss of 54.7% (w/w) DEHA from PVC film. This value is slightly higher than the limit of 3mg/dm(2) of film surface set by the European Union for DEHA. The equilibrium amount of ATBC in halva was 1.46mg/dm(2) (36.1mg/kg) corresponding to a loss of 42.7% ATBC from PVC film. With regard to the penetration of both placticizers into halva samples, migration of DEHA was detectable up to the 7th slice beneath the surface of halva (total depth 10.5mm) while the migration of ATBC was detectable up to the 5th slice (total depth 7.5mm).

Migration and sensory properties of plastics-based nets used as food-contacting materials under ambient and high temperature heating conditions

Overall migration from a wide range of commercial plastics-based netting materials destined to be used as either meat or vegetable packaging materials into the fatty food simulant isooctane or the aqueous simulant distilled water, respectively, was studied. In addition, sensory tests of representative netting materials were carried out in bottled water in order to investigate possible development of off-odour/taste and discoloration in this food simulant as a result of migration from the netting material. Sensory tests were supplemented by determination of the volatile compounds' profile in table water exposed to the netting materials using SPME-GC/MS. Test conditions for packaging material/food simulant contact and method of overall migration analysis were according to European Union Directives 90/128 (EEC, 1990) and 2002/72 (EEC, 2002). The results showed that for both PET and polyethylene-based netting materials, overall migration values into distilled water ranged between 11.5 and 48.5 mg l(-1), well below the upper limit (60 mg l(-1)) for overall migration values from plastics-packaging materials set by the European Union. The overall migration values from netting materials into isooctane ranged between 38.0 and 624.0 mg l(-1), both below and above the European Union upper limit for migration. Sensory tests involving contact of representative samples with table water under refluxing (100 degrees C/4 h) conditions showed a number of the netting materials produced both off-odour and/or taste as well as discoloration of the food simulant rendering such materials unfit for the packaging of foodstuffs in applications involving heating at elevated temperatures. GC/MS analysis showed the presence of numerous volatile compounds being produced after netting materials/water contact under refluxing conditions. Although it is extremely difficult to establish a clear correlation between sensory off-odour development and GC/MS volatile compounds' profile, it may be postulated that plastics oxidation products such as hexanal, heptanal, octanal and 2,6 di-tert-butylquinone may contribute to off-odour development using commercially bottled table water as a food simulant. Likewise, compounds such as carbon disulfide, [1,1'-biphenyl]-2-ol and propanoic acid, 2 methyl 1-(1,1-dimethyl)-2-methyl-1,3-propanediyl ester probably originating from cotton and rubber components of netting materials may also contribute to off-odour/taste development.

Partition coefficients in food/packaging systems: a review

Food contamination can result from various interactions between food and packaging materials. Migration of volatiles, additives, monomers and oligomers from packaging materials into food or adsorption of volatile compounds from the food by the polymer are important considerations from safety, hygienic and economic points of view. The term 'migration' includes two phenomena (partition and diffusion) that can be important in determining the concentration of contaminants in a food system at any time. An estimation of the partition coefficient, K, in food/packaging systems has been the major objective of numerous different studies. Various parameters can influence K such as temperature, pH, the chemical structure of the migrant, molecular size and structure, fat content, and degrees of crystallinity. Some theoretical approaches such as the quantitative structure-property relationship method could be of interest in the near future.

Physicochemical and mechanical properties of experimental coextruded food-packaging films containing a buried layer of recycled low-density polyethylene

Migrational, permeation, and tensile properties of experimental five- and eight-layer coextruded and laminated films containing a middle buried layer of recycled low-density polyethylene (LDPE) comprising 40-50% bw of the multilayer structure were determined. Respective films containing 100% virgin LDPE as the buried layer were taken as controls. Results showed that the percentage of recycled LDPE in the multilayer structure did not affect overall migration values to distilled water, 3% acetic acid, and iso-octane. In all cases, overall migration values were lower than the upper acceptable limit (10 mg/dm(2)) set by the European Union. Transmission rate values to O(2), CO(2), and water vapor were also not affected by the percentage of recycled LDPE in the multilayer structure. On the basis of O(2) transmission rates, low-barrier, barrier, and high-barrier multilayer structures were produced. Likewise, tensile properties (tensile strength, percent elongation at break, and Young's modulus) were not affected by the percentage of recycled material in the multilayer structure. Finally, all experimental films produced no adverse effects in taste or odor of the food-contacting phase tested. The above findings are discussed in relation to the high quality of the primary LDPE scrap used throughout this work in combination with the functional barrier hypothesis. On the basis of the present results it is proposed that primary LDPE scrap may be used as a middle layer comprising 40-50% bw of multilayer food-packaging films without any compromise in migrational, barrier, mechanical, and organoleptic properties.

Tailoring fatty food simulants made from solvent mixtures (2): determining the equivalent migration behaviour of olive oil and of solvents in the case of polyolefins

It is suggested that solvent mixtures consisting of an ester and of an inert solvent can be used as fatty food simulants capable of having the same migration behaviour as olive oil with plastics. Migration tests carried out with low-density polyethylene for 20 and 48 h in an 8 and 5% mixture of tert-butyl acetate in ethanol respectively gave results equivalent to those obtained with olive oil after 10 days at 40 degrees C. The use of solvent mixtures facilitated the analysis and improved detection limits, giving good repeatability. Furthermore, the more rapid migration in solvent mixtures can be particularly useful for industrial controls as alternative test methods.

Food aroma partition between packaging materials and fatty food simulants

By means of thermal desorption experiments, the partition equilibrium (partition coefficient, K) was analysed for six food aroma components (d-limonene, n-decane, ethyl caproate, phenylethanol, n-hexanol and hexanal) between three sealable pollymer films suitable for direct food contact (ultra-low density polyethylene, ULDPE; ionomer, ION; and polyester, PET) and four fatty food simulants (ethanol 95%, EtOH; sunflower oil, Oil; n-heptane, HEP, and iso-octane, OCT). The results showed that aroma scalping is highly dependent on the fatty food simulant utilized. Polar aroma components were more sorbed into polymers in the presence of a non-polar fatty food simulant, and vice versa. K values in the presence of Oil were always between those in EtOH and in HEP or OCT. In general, PET was the packaging film which showed the lowest partition coeffecient for non-polar components while ULDPE showed the lowest partition for polar aromas. The partition equilibrium of mixed d-limonene, ethyl caproate, and n-hexanol was also determined. The differences in K values between isolated aromas and mixed aromas were small. In general, the most sorbed aroma showed increased partition by mixture while the partition of the least sorbed was reduced.

Tailoring fatty food simulants made from solvent mixtures (1): comparison of methanol, ethanol and isopropanol behaviour with polystyrene

To investigate the use of solvent mixtures as test media replacing olive oil in migration tests, the interaction of polystyrene with mixtures composed of various amounts of tert.butyl acetate (mimicking the ester functions of oil) and of a low molecular weight alcohol (methanol, ethanol and isopropanol as inert co-solvent) was studied, using FTIR. Isopropanol, which has a lesser tendency to form hydrogen bonds in the plastic, can be used as main component of alternative fatty test media, its aggressiveness to polystyrene being tailored by adjusting the concentration of tert.butyl acetate. Concentrations below 20% seem useful on the basis of the mechanism of displacement of the alcohols.

A study on the equivalence of olive oil and the EU official substitute test media for migration testing at high temperatures

As a consequence of an increasing awareness and findings about the technical and analytical difficulties related to the employment of triglycerides as fatty food simulants in migration testing, EU Directive 82/711/EEC on the basic rules of migration has been amended for the second time and adapted with the recent Commission Directive 97/48/EC. The major merit of this important amendment is to authorize alternative tests such as extraction tests and to allow substitute tests for the fat test with concrete indication of corresponding test conditions to be applied. As a novelty in food law compliance testing it authorizes a modified polyphenylene oxide (MPPO), well-known as Tenax, a thermostable and highly adsorptive porous polymer, as a 'solid' matrix to substitute fat simulant D at temperatures equal to or higher than 100 degrees C. In the study presented here, comparative migration testing--overall and specific--was carried out between fat simulants olive oil and 14C-labelled HB 307 and the substitute test media iso-octane, 95% ethanol and MPPO using polypropylene materials as examples at test temperatures of 100 degrees C to 120 degrees C and prescribed corresponding substitute test conditions. As a consequence, a number of conclusions were drawn which are relevant for overall and/or specific migration testing under the investigated test conditions. One of the major findings was that MPPO was generally more equivalent to the fat test than the other two substitute test media. The presence of volatile hydrocarbons in the test samples was found to play a crucial role with respect to the equivalence of the iso-octane-based substitute test. At high volatile concentrations in the test sample the iso-octane test underestimated the olive oil benchmark whereas low volatile concentrations led to satisfying equivalence. It is therefore recommended that the procedure is modified and GC-FID screening of the isooctane extract is carried out. As a logical consequence, the possibility of quantitative determination of the overall extract by GC-FID is recommendable and should be investigated in more depth. Concerning the overall migration test procedure in olive oil, the vacuum pre-conditioning at 60 degrees C should be given re-consideration to avoid the possibility of loss of volatile migrants whose determination should be within the scope of the overall migration test method itself. Finally, the specific migration related equivalence between olive oil, MPPO and iso-octane needs further investigations to clarify the net effect of strongly increased diffusion rates at the regular high temperature versus the substitute test solvent accelerated extraction effect at 60 degrees C. Stability aspects of migrants at the different test temperatures deserve further consideration.

Food and packaging interactions: determination of the kinetic parameters of olive oil diffusion in polypropylene using concentration profiles

The penetration of olive oil into polypropylene was studied in order to allow a complete modellization of food and packaging interactions. Oil concentration profiles through polypropylene food trays were determined by FTIR-microscopy measurements along the thickness at various times. Calculations of the relevant parameters characterizing Fickian diffusion, namely constant diffusivity, coefficient of convective mass transport on the surface and concentration at equilibrium were carried out. This way of working has proven to be considerably shorter and more accurate than the method consisting of recording the global absorbance of the substance absorbed, especially when the amount of diffusing fat is low. Major conclusions are: that absorption of olive oil is strongly influenced by convection; the diffusion coefficient of olive oil in polypropylene is constant. Possible consequences to simplify global migration testing are discussed.

Alternative test methods to control the compliance of polyolefin food packaging materials with the European Union regulation: the case of aromatic antioxidants and of bis(ethanolamine) antistatics based on 1H-NMR and UV-visible spectrophotometry

In order to decide whether a plastic food packaging material complies with the European Communities (EC) regulation on migration, a quick analysis of two functional classes of plastics additives (aromatic antioxidants and antistatic agents) from polyolefin materials by 1H-NMR and UV-visible spectrophotometry is presented. The scope of spectroscopic methods for alternative and migration tests is presented. 1H-NMR can be used in several ways, from a simple fingerprint of the potential migrants to an identification procedure. Extraction is optimized using UV spectrophotometry. Optimization relies on extraction kinetics, which include the demonstration that extraction is more severe than migration. Only a few hours are required to conclude whether a material complies with the regulation. The specific migration limits are expressed as specific absorbance limit values, alpha. These data can be annexed by food industries to specifications of a plastic packaging material.

Quick methods to control compliance of plastic materials with food packaging regulations

A general strategy is presented, aiming to provide plastics manufacturers, food industries and enforcement laboratories with quick methods to check whether migration from materials for food contact will be acceptable during the time of use. The strategy involves several steps, with increasing time demand and cost. Monitoring extraction kinetics allows both the optimization of the extraction time, and the selection of conditions where extraction is more severe than migration. The influence of the extracting solvent is discussed. It may give rise to specific non-extraction of some migrants, which may change the conclusions when the solvent is used in replacement of a fatty food simulant. Factors ruling this effect at a given temperature are identified: the affinity to the solvent with the migrant (selectivity), its ability to reach molecules entangled in the polymeric network (accessibility) and its interaction with the polymer (penetration). The kinetic parameters of the penetration of olive oil into polypropylene have been determined by the determination of profiles of concentration.

Magnetic resonance imaging studies of diffusion in polymers

For a number of polymer/penetrant systems, for example fatty foods in direct contact with plastic wrapping, the migration of substances from the polymer is governed by the amount of penetrant entering the polymer. For food packaging this means that the rate of migration of substances into the food can be governed by the uptake of food into the packaging itself. To develop predictive models of migration under various conditions there is therefore a need to understand the mechanism of the penetration of the food into the packaging. In this paper a summary of recent Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) studies is reported. Uptake of simulant, as measured by MRI, is quantitative and agrees well with gravimetric uptake data. Data are shown for a comparison of olive oil and isooctane penetration into low density polyethylene at various temperatures. Further, the rate of ingress of isooctane into a variety of commercial polyethylene plaques has been shown to differ widely. These data also allow us to probe the molecular interactions between polymer and penetrant. Finally MRI is combined with a Pulsed Gradient Spin Echo (PGSE) technique to provide spatially resolved measurements of penetrant diffusivity within a polymer. Diffusivity as a function of volume fraction of penetrant can also be measured. These data provide invaluable insights into diffusion in polymers which will aid development of more accurate models of polymer/penetrant interactions and small molecule mobility.

Prediction of worst case migration from packaging to food using mathematical models

Prediction of migration from packaging to food is often made using equations which are not always designed specifically for the problem. At least, these equations should overestimate migration, in order to be on the safe side. Integration of Fick's equation under the assumption of 'infinite packaging' provides an equation which is very practical since it requires only a few experimental data. It is shown here that, unfortunately, the use of this equation leads to a systematic underestimation of the diffusivity, by the square of the percentage of migration at steady state. In contrast to widely accepted opinion, this model is not conservative. A conservative approach requires that the diffusivity is determined under 'finite packaging' assumptions, associated with very large volumes of food and with long term experiments. These equations are applied to the migration of a phenolic antioxidant from polypropylene.