Frequency of reciprocal translocations and dicentrics induced in human blood lymphocytes by X-irradiation as determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization

Three-Color Chromosome Painting as Seen through the Eyes of mFISH: Another Look at Radiation-Induced Exchanges and Their Conversion to Whole-Genome Equivalency

Whole-chromosome painting (WCP) typically involves the fluorescent staining of a small number of chromosomes. Consequently, it is capable of detecting only a fraction of exchanges that occur among the full complement of chromosomes in a genome. Mathematical corrections are commonly applied to WCP data in order to extrapolate the frequency of exchanges occurring in the entire genome [whole-genome equivalency (WGE)]. However, the reliability of WCP to WGE extrapolations depends on underlying assumptions whose conditions are seldom met in actual experimental situations, in particular the presumed absence of complex exchanges. Using multi-fluor fluorescence in situ hybridization (mFISH), we analyzed the induction of simple exchanges produced by graded doses of ¹³⁷Cs gamma rays (0–4 Gy), and also 1.1 GeV ⁵⁶Fe ions (0–1.5 Gy). In order to represent cytogenetic damage as it would have appeared to the observer following standard three-color WCP, all mFISH information pertaining to exchanges that did not specifically involve chromosomes 1, 2, or 4 was ignored. This allowed us to reconstruct dose–responses for three-color apparently simple (AS) exchanges. Using extrapolation methods similar to those derived elsewhere, these were expressed in terms of WGE for comparison to mFISH data. Based on AS events, the extrapolated frequencies systematically overestimated those actually observed by mFISH. For gamma rays, these errors were practically independent of dose. When constrained to a relatively narrow range of doses, the WGE corrections applied to both ⁵⁶Fe and gamma rays predicted genome-equivalent damage with a level of accuracy likely sufficient for most applications. However, the apparent accuracy associated with WCP to WGE corrections is both fortuitous and misleading. This is because (in normal practice) such corrections can only be applied to AS exchanges, which are known to include complex aberrations in the form of pseudosimple exchanges. When WCP to WGE corrections are applied to true simple exchanges, the results are less than satisfactory, leading to extrapolated values that underestimate the true WGE response by unacceptably large margins. Likely explanations for these results are discussed, as well as their implications for radiation protection. Thus, in seeming contradiction to notion that complex aberrations be avoided altogether in WGE corrections – and in violation of assumptions upon which these corrections are based – their inadvertent inclusion in three-color WCP data is actually required in order for them to yield even marginally acceptable results.

Radiation signature on exposed cells: Relevance in dose estimation

The radiation is considered as a double edged sword, as its beneficial and detrimental effects have been demonstrated. The potential benefits are being exploited to its maximum by adopting safe handling of radionuclide stipulated by the regulatory agencies. While the occupational workers are monitored by personnel monitoring devices, for general publics, it is not a regular practice. However, it can be achieved by using biomarkers with a potential for the radiation triage and medical management. An ideal biomarker to adopt in those situations should be rapid, specific, sensitive, reproducible, and able to categorize the nature of exposure and could provide a reliable dose estimation irrespective of the time of the exposures. Since cytogenetic markers shown to have many advantages relatively than other markers, the origins of various chromosomal abnormalities induced by ionizing radiations along with dose-response curves generated in the laboratory are presented. Current status of the gold standard dicentric chromosome assay, micronucleus assay, translocation measurement by fluorescence in-situ hybridization and an emerging protein marker the γ-H2AX assay are discussed with our laboratory data. With the wide choice of methods, an appropriate assay can be employed based on the net.

Unstable chromosome aberrations do not accumulate in normal human fibroblast after fractionated x-irradiation

We determined the frequencies of dicentric chromosomes per cell in non-dividing confluent normal human fibroblasts (MRC-5) irradiated with a single 1 Gy dose or a fractionated 1 Gy dose (10X0.1 Gy, 5X0.2 Gy, and 2X0.5 Gy). The interval between fractions was between 1 min to 1440 min. After the completion of X-irradiation, the cells were incubated for 24 hours before re-plating at a low density. Then, demecolcine was administrated at 6 hours, and the first mitotic cells were collected for 42 hours. Our study demonstrated that frequencies of dicentric chromosomes in cells irradiated with a 1 Gy dose at different fractions were significantly reduced if the fraction interval was increased from 1 min to 5 min (p<0.05, χ2-test). Further increasing the fraction interval from 5 up to 1440 min did not significantly affect the frequency of dicentric chromosomes. Since misrejoining of two independent chromosome breaks introduced in close proximity gives rise to dicentric chromosome, our results indicated that such circumstances might be quite infrequent in cells exposed to fractionated X-irradiation with prolonged fraction intervals. Our findings should contribute to improve current estimation of cancer risk from chronic low-dose-rate exposure, or intermittent exposure of low-dose radiation by medical exposure.

Inter-chromosomal variation in aberration frequencies in human lymphocytes exposed to charged particles of LET between 0.5 and 55 keV/μm

PURPOSE

To investigate the distribution of chromosomal aberrations in chromosomes 2, 8 and 14 induced by charged particles, using the fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) technique.

METHODS

Irradiation of peripheral blood from six healthy volunteers (four male and two female) was performed at the accelerators of the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR) in Dubna (Russia). Whole blood samples were irradiated with 2 and 3 Gy of protons (170 MeV/nucleon (n), linear energy transfer (LET) ≈ 0.5 keV/μm), 3.5 Gy of (12)C ions (480 MeV/n, LET = 10.6 keV/μm), 3 Gy of (12)C ions 500 MeV/n, LET = 12 keV/μm), 4 Gy of (7)Li ions (30 MeV/n, LET ≈ 20 keV/μm) and 3 Gy of (11)B ions (32 MeV/n, LET ≈ 55 keV/μm). Chromosomal aberrations were analysed in metaphase and prematurely condensed chromosomes (PCC) induced in G(2)-cells using calyculin A. Chromosomes 2, 8 and 14 were painted in different colours and aberrations scored with the help of an image-analysis system.

RESULTS

Chromosome 2 was generally less sensitive than expected on the basis of its DNA content. A higher than expected frequency of exchanges was found in chromosomes 8 and 14. On average, the dicentric frequency in chromosome 2 was higher than the translocation frequency, whereas variable dicentric to translocation ratios were observed in chromosomes 8 and 14. When aberrations in all painted chromosomes were summed up the ratio was close to 1. The frequency of complex aberrations correlated with LET.

CONCLUSION

In lymphocytes of donors studied in this work chromosome 2 appears to be consistently less sensitive to protons and heavy ions than chromosomes 8 and 14. Complex aberrations appear to be a potential marker of radiation quality.

The radiation sensitivity of human chromosomes 2, 8 and 14 in peripheral blood lymphocytes of seven donors

PURPOSE

To investigate if deviations from DNA-proportional distribution of radiation-induced chromosomal aberrations are individually variable.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Peripheral blood lymphocytes were collected from seven healthy donors and exposed to different doses of gamma rays. Chromosomes 2, 8 and 14 were painted in different colors and aberrations scored with the help of an image-analysis system.

RESULTS

Chromosome 2 was generally less sensitive than expected on the basis of DNA-proportional distribution and the extent of inter-donor variability was minimal. A higher than expected frequency of aberrations was found in chromosome 14 of five donors, while a higher than expected frequency of aberrations was found in chromosome 8 of two donors.

CONCLUSIONS

Inter-donor variability may explain some of the controversies regarding the inter-chromosomal distribution of radiation-induced aberrations.

Influence of dose rate on the induction of simple and complex chromosome exchanges by gamma rays

Single-color painting of whole chromosomes, or protocols in which only a few chromosomes are distinctively painted, will always fail to detect a proportion of complex exchanges because they frequently produce pseudosimple painting patterns that are indistinguishable from those produced by bona fide simple exchanges. When 24-color multi-fluor FISH (mFISH) was employed for the purpose of distinguishing (truly) simple from pseudosimple exchanges, it was confirmed that the acute low-LET radiation dose-response relationship for simple exchanges lacked significant upward curvature. This result has been interpreted to indicate that the formation of simple exchanges requires only one chromosome locus be damaged (e.g. broken) by radiation to initiate an exchange-not two, as classical cytogenetic theory maintains. Because a one-lesion mechanism implies single-track action, it follows that the production of simple exchanges should not be influenced by changes in dose rate. To examine this prediction, we irradiated noncycling primary human fibroblasts with graded doses of (137)Cs gamma rays at an acute dose rate of 1.10 Gy/min and compared, using mFISH, the yield of simple exchanges to that observed after exposure to the same radiation delivered at a chronic dose rate of 0.08 cGy/min. The shape of the dose response was found to be quasi-linear for both dose rates, but, counter to providing support for a one-lesion mechanism, the yield of simple aberrations was greatly reduced by protracted exposure. Although chronic doses were delivered at rates low enough to produce damage exclusively by single-track action, this did not altogether eliminate the formation of complex aberrations, an analysis of which leads to the conclusion that a single track of low-LET radiation is capable of inducing complex exchanges requiring up to four proximate breaks for their formation. For acute exposures, the ratio of simple reciprocal translocations to simple dicentrics was near unity.

Preferential reduction of dicentrics in reciprocal exchanges due to the combination of the size of broken chromosome segments by radiation

Induction rates of the dicentrics and translocations involving chromosomes 2 and 4 in peripheral lymphocytes irradiated with X-rays at a dose of 3 Gy were examined using a conventional Giemsa staining method and a chromosome painting method. In total, 228 reciprocal exchanges detected in 982 metaphases were classified into three groups according to the break points of the original chromosomes. The incidence of both acentric fragments being larger than half of the original chromosome (combination 1) was only seven (3%) and did not contribute significantly to induction rates. When the broken acentric fragments of two affected chromosomes were smaller than half of the original chromosomes (combination 2), which was found in 175 (77%) rearrangements, the induction rates of dicentrics and translocations were about the same (86:89). But if the sizes of the broken segments were unequal in both chromosomes (combination 3: one with a larger acentric part and the other with a smaller acentric part), the yield of dicentrics was significantly lower than that of translocations (16:30). It was suggested that there was a special mechanism causing preferential reduction of dicentrics in reciprocal exchanges originated from the heteromorphic size of broken chromosomes in the last combination.

Imperceptible effect of radiation based on stable type chromosome aberrations accumulated in the lymphocytes of residents in the high background radiation area in China

Cytogenetic investigation of stable type aberrations (translocations) was performed with our improved methods in 6 children and 15 elderly persons in a high background radiation area (HBRA) in China, and in 8 children and 11 elderly persons in a control area. The total numbers of cells analyzed in elderly persons were 68,297 in HBRA and 35,378 in controls and in children were 45,535 in HBRA and 56,198 in controls. On average 5138 cells per subject were analyzed. The variation in the frequencies of translocations per 1000 cells was small in children while it was large in elderly persons. No significant difference was found in the frequencies between HBRA and control (P > 0.05, Mann-Whitney U test). On the other hand, correlation between age and translocation frequencies was significant at the 1% level (rs = 0.658 with 37DF, Spearman rank correlation test). The contribution of an elevated level of natural radiation in HBRA in China to the induction of stable type chromosome aberrations does not have a significant effect compared with the contribution of chemical mutagens and/or metabolic factors. The present study suggests that the probability of the risk of causing malignant and/or congenital diseases by the increased amount of radiation is imperceptible in HBRA where the level of natural radiation is 3 to 5 times higher than that in the control area.

Is there reliable experimental evidence for a low-dose RBE of about 4 for mammography X rays relative to 200 kV X rays?

recently reported, on the basis of observations of neoplastic transformation in human hybrid CGL1 cells, a low-dose relative biological effectiveness (RBE(M)) of 4.3 for mammography X rays (29 kV) relative to 200 kV X rays. With reference to data in the literature, they inferred a factor of about 8 relative to 60Co gamma rays and concluded that this result is relevant to risk estimation. However, the conclusions do not appear to be valid. The data from the transformation study exhibit uncertainties in the statistical analysis that preclude any generalization of the inferred RBE(M). The data selected or inferred from the literature are likewise insufficient to support the stated RBEs. Our own uniform data set for the yields of dicentrics was obtained for widely varying photon energies with blood samples from the same donor, and it avoids interindividual variations in sensitivity as well as the differences in methodology that are associated with interlaboratory comparisons. Our data provide RBE(M) values for 29 kV X rays of 1.64 +/- 0.27 relative to 220 kV X rays and 4.75 +/- 1.67 and 6.12 +/- 2.51 relative to 60Co gamma rays.

Chromosomal aberrations: formation, identification and distribution

Chromosomal aberrations (CA) are the microscopically visible part of a wide spectrum of DNA changes generated by different repair mechanisms of DNA double strand breaks (DSB). The method of fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) has uncovered unexpected complexities of CA and this will lead to changes in our thinking about the origin of CA. The inter- and intrachromosomal distribution of breakpoints is generally not random. CA breakpoints occur preferentially in active chromatin. Deviations from expected interchromosomal distributions of breakpoints may result from the arrangement of chromosomes in the interphase nucleus and/or from different sensitivities of chromosomes with respect to the formation of CA. Telomeres and interstitial telomere repeat like sequences play an important role in the formation of CA. Subtelomeric regions are hot spots for the formation of symmetrical exchanges between homologous chromatids and cryptic aberrations in these regions are associated with human congenital abnormalities.

Radiosensitivity of ataxia telangiectasia and Nijmegen breakage syndrome homozygotes and heterozygotes as determined by three-color FISH chromosome painting

A three-color chromosome painting technique was used to examine the spontaneous and radiation-induced chromosomal damage in peripheral lymphocytes and lymphoblastoid cells from 11 patients with ataxia telangiectasia (AT) and from 14 individuals heterozygous for an AT allele. In addition, cells from two homozygous and six obligate heterozygous carriers of mutations in the Nijmegen breakage syndrome gene (NBS) were investigated. The data were compared to those for chromosome damage in 10 unaffected control individuals and 48 cancer patients who had not yet received therapeutic treatment. Based on the well-documented radiation sensitivity of AT and NBS patients, it was of particular interest to determine whether the FISH painting technique used in these studies allowed the reliable detection of an increased sensitivity to in vitro irradiation of cells from heterozygous carriers. Peripheral blood lymphocytes and lymphoblastoid cells from both the homozygous AT and NBS patients showed the highest cytogenetic response, whereas the cells from control individuals had a low number of chromosomal aberrations. The response of cells from heterozygous carriers was intermediate and could be clearly differentiated from those of the other groups in double-coded studies. AT and NBS heterozygosity could be distinguished from other genotypes by the total number of breakpoints per cell and also by the number of the long-lived stable aberrations in both AT and NBS. Only AT heterozygosity could be distinguished by the fraction of unstable chromosome changes. The slightly but not significantly increased radiosensitivity that was found in cancer patients was apparently due to a higher trend toward rearrangements compared to the controls. Thus the three-color painting technique presented here proved to be well suited as a supplement to conventional cytogenetic techniques for the detection of heterozygous carriers of these diseases, and may be superior method.

Complex chromosome exchanges induced by gamma rays in human lymphocytes: an mFISH study

Loucas, B. D. and Cornforth, M. N. Complex Chromosome Exchanges Induced by Gamma Rays in Human Lymphocytes: An mFISH Study. Radiat. Res. 155, 660-671 (2001). Combinatorial multi-fluor fluorescence in situ hybridization (mFISH) allows the simultaneous painting of each pair of homologous chromosomes, thereby eliminating many of the difficulties previously associated with the analysis of complex rearrangements. We employed mFISH to visualize exchanges in human lymphocytes and found significant frequencies of these aberrations after gamma-ray doses of 2 and 4 Gy. At 4 Gy, roughly half of the cells contained at least one complex exchange that required anywhere from 3 to 11 initial chromosome breaks. At this dose, more than 40% of gross cytogenetic damage, as measured by the total number of exchange breakpoints, was complex in origin. Both simple and complex exchanges were found to have nonlinear dose responses, although the latter showed significantly more upward curvature. In many cases, it could be deduced that the initial breaks leading to a particular complex exchange were proximate, meaning that the resulting broken chromosome ends all must have been capable of interacting freely during the exchange process. For other complex exchanges, the rearrangement could just as well have resulted from two or more simpler exchanges that occurred sequentially. The results demonstrate the utility of mFISH in visualizing intricacies of the exchange process, but also highlight the various sources of ambiguity concerning cytogenetic analysis that remain despite the power of this approach.

Chromosome painting for cytogenetic monitoring of occupationally exposed and non-exposed groups of human individuals

The suitability of a three-color fluorescence in situ suppression hybridization technique was examined for monitoring five different groups of individuals: 30 occupied in radiology, 26 occupied in nuclear medicine or radiation physics, 32 patients with breast cancer, 26 occupied with military waste disposal, all presumably exposed to low doses of radiation or chemical mutagens and a non-exposed control group (N=29). The average frequency of breaks constituting the various aberrations did not significantly differ between the groups of medical radiation appliers and the control group. However, breast tumor patients and military waste disposers, as groups, showed a higher aberration rate than did healthy controls. Stable rearrangements mainly characterized the groups of controls, tumor patients, and radiation appliers, while a higher proportion of unstable aberrations was found in the chemically exposed individuals. Individuals with an increased frequency of aberrations could be detected within each examined group, which clearly determined the average values of the whole group. With respect to interchromosomal distribution of the breakpoints constituting the found aberrations and the involvement of the labeled chromosomes in rearrangements, the observed values were very close to the expected ones in the controls. A rather similar trend of deviations from expectation was observed in all other groups. Chromosome 4 was slightly over-affected, while chromosome 2 was slightly underrepresented in all analyzed groups (except tumor patients). Rearrangements of the labeled chromosomes with the unlabeled ones exceeded expectation. In conclusion, chromosome painting if included in further attempts of human population monitoring will broaden the basis of argumentation with respect to health risks introduced by mutagen exposure.

Frequencies of X-ray induced chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes of xeroderma pigmentosum and Fanconi anemia patients estimated by Giemsa and fluorescence in situ hybridization staining techniques

Blood lymphocytes from xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) and Fanconi anemia (FA) patients were assessed for their sensitivity to ionizing radiation by estimating the frequency of X-ray (1 and 2 Gy)-induced chromosome aberrations (CA). The frequencies of aberrations in the whole genome were estimated in Giemsa-stained preparations of lymphocytes irradiated at G0 or G2 stages. The frequencies of translocations and dicentrics involving chromosomes 1 and 3 as well as the X-chromosome were determined in slides stained by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) technique. An increase in all types of CA was observed in XP and FA lymphocytes irradiated at G0 when compared to controls. The frequency of dicentrics and rings was 6 to 27% higher (at 1 and 2 Gy) in XP lymphocytes and 37% higher (at 2 Gy) in FA lymphocytes than in controls, while chromosome deletions were higher in irradiated (30% in 1 Gy and 72% in 2 Gy) than in control XP lymphocytes and 28 to 102% higher in FA lymphocytes. In G2-irradiated lymphocytes the frequency of CA was 24 to 55% higher in XP lymphocytes than in controls. In most cases the translocation frequencies were higher than the frequencies of dicentrics (21/19).

Chromosome translocation in residents of the high background radiation areas in southern China

We performed a cytogenetical study using chromosome painting analysis on 9 residents of the naturally high background radiation areas (HBRA) and 8 residents of the control areas in southern China. The estimated dose (air kerma) of each resident measured by an electric pocket dosimeter showed 2.20-4.23 mGy/year in HBRA and 0.56-0.70 mGy/year in the control areas. A total of 14,096 cells (1,566 cells/case) in the former and 17,522 cells (2,190 cells/case) in the latter were analyzed. Children, both in HBRA and in the control areas, had translocations at low frequencies. The frequency of translocations among elder individuals varied widely and it was not possible to detect dose effect although it was detected in dicentrics. The effect of radiation on the induction of chromosome aberrations, which have a statistically potential risk of causing malignant or congenital diseases, seems to be less significant than those of metabolic factors and/or mutagenic agents (excluding radiation) even in HBRA in China.

Improvement of accuracy of chromosome aberration analysis for biological radiation dosimetry

The frequency of chromosome aberrations in circulating lymphocytes is accepted as being the most reliable indicator of the absorbed dose of radiation. Researches done to improve the accuracy of cytogenetic analysis are described in this review. These include investigations of in vitro factors that affect the yield of radiation-induced aberrations and of in vivo factors that affect the chromosomal radiosensitivity of individuals. Improved chromosome-painting methods for accurate judgment of dicentrics and translocations are introduced. The practicality of these advanced cytogenetic techniques is shown by examinations of individuals exposed in the radiation accident at Tokaimura in 1999.

Analysis by FISH of the spectrum of chromosome aberrations induced by X-rays in G0 human lymphocytes and their fate through mitotic divisions in culture

The induction, distribution, and persistence of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes exposed to X-rays in G0 were analyzed in 48-, 70-, and 94-hr cultures by conventional metaphase analysis and painting of chromosomes 1, 2, and 4 by FISH. All cells that had been scored by FISH were relocated to determine by differential staining of chromatids whether they had passed through 1, 2, or > or =3 divisions. FISH revealed a dose-dependent induction of stable and unstable aberrations, while chromatid labeling showed mitotic lag caused by irradiation in G0. Relative to their DNA contents, there was a small but significant overrepresentation of chromosome 4 and underrepresentation of chromosome 2 among the aberrations involving chromosomes 1, 2, and 4. FISH slightly underestimated the genomic frequency of unstable aberrations measured by conventional metaphase analysis. There was a slight excess of translocations relative to dicentrics, but the data are compatible with the 1:1 ratio expected from cytogenetic theory. Many of the translocations were apparently incomplete (i.e., nonreciprocal). Incomplete translocations were more frequent at higher X-ray dose and in first division, suggesting that they may be associated with complex damage and are more apt to be lost in mitosis than complete translocations. Among the incomplete translocations, t(Ab) outnumbered t(Ba) -- a difference ascribable to the FISH technique. Aberration frequencies declined as the cells divided in culture. The overall decline in the frequency of aberrant cells (approximately 29% per cell generation) reflects a rapid decline in dicentrics and fragments (approximately 60% per cell generation) and the relative stability of translocations. The frequency of translocation-bearing cells underwent a modest decline in culture (approximately 13% per cell generation).

137Cesium-induced chromosome aberrations analyzed by fluorescence in situ hybridization: eight years follow up of the Goiânia radiation accident victims

The radiation accident in focus here occurred in a section of Goiânia (Brazil) where more than a hundred individuals were contaminated with 137Cesium on September 1987. In order to estimate the absorbed radiation doses, initial frequencies of dicentrics and rings were determined in 129 victims [A.T. Ramalho, PhD Thesis, Subsidios a tecnica de dosimetria citogenetica gerados a partir da analise de resultados obtidos com o acidente radiologico de Goiânia, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 1992]. We have followed some of these victims cytogenetically over the years seeking for parameters that could be used as basis for retrospective radiation dosimetry. Our data on translocation frequencies obtained by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) could be directly compared to the baseline frequencies of dicentrics available for those same victims. Our results provided valuable information on how precise these estimates are. The frequencies of translocations observed years after the radiation exposure were two to three times lower than the initial dicentrics frequencies, the differences being larger at higher doses (>1 Gy). The accuracy of such dose estimates might be increased by scoring sufficient amount of cells. However, factors such as the persistence of translocation carrying lymphocytes, translocation levels not proportional to chromosome size, and inter-individual variation reduce the precision of these estimates.

A high yield of translocations parallels the high yield of sister chromatid exchanges in the CHO mutant EM9

The fluorescence plus Giemsa (FPG) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) techniques have been used to determine, respectively, the frequencies of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) and stable chromosome aberrations (translocations) induced by different concentrations of BrdU in the Chinese hamster ovary cell mutant EM9 and its parental line AA8. The results indicate that BrdU induced a high frequency of SCEs and translocations in EM9 as compared with AA8, and that the translocation/dicentric ratio was also higher in the mutant cell line than in the parental cell line in both untreated and BrdU-treated cultures. These observations may indicate a possible relationship between the molecular mechanisms involved in the formation of SCEs and translocations.

Estimation of minimal size of translocated chromosome segments detectable by fluorescence in situ hybridization

Apparent non-reciprocal translocations are commonly observed using fluorescence in situ hybridization. We hypothesize that these are 'hidden' reciprocals due to one translocated segment being too small to detect. Assuming that the translocation breakpoints distribute randomly, the proportion of reciprocal to non-reciprocal exchanges can be used to estimate the minimal detectable size of translocated segments. To estimate segment size in this study, cytogenetic data for 120 A-bomb survivors were used. Among 2295 aberrant metaphases, 1629 exhibited reciprocal translocations and 666 non-reciprocal. Of the non-reciprocal translocations, 501 showed only a painted chromosome segment, translocated to an unpainted chromosome with centromere, and 165 showed only an unpainted chromosome segment, translocated to a painted chromosome with centromere. On the basis of the above two assumptions, we obtained the most likely estimates for minimal detectable sizes: 11.1 +/- 0.8 Mb for the painted and 14.6 +/- 0.6 Mb for the unpainted chromosomes. The implications of these findings are discussed.

Methods for improving the yield and quality of metaphase preparations for FISH probing of human lymphocyte chromosomes

Procedures are described for the in vitro culture of human lymphocytes, which have been concentrated by density gradient centrifugation, and for a modified slide-making technique for the fixed cells. The method yields improved percentages of mitotic cells which are largely synchronized at harvest. Controlled placement of fixed cells on slides produces well-spread metaphase preparations with little background material to interfere with fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) probe procedures. The FISH reagents and microscope scanning time required are minimized by concentrating cells in a defined area of the slide.

Paternally inherited chromosomal structural aberrations detected in mouse first-cleavage zygote metaphases by multicolour fluorescence in situ hybridization painting

We describe a fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) procedure for assessing zygotic risk of paternal exposure to endogenous or exogenous agents. The procedure employs multicolour FISH with chromosome-specific DNA painting probes plus DAPI staining for detecting both balanced and unbalanced chromosomal aberrations in mouse first-cleavage (1-Cl) zygote metaphases. Four composite probes specific for chromosomes 1, 2, 3 or X, each labelled with biotin, plus a composite probe specific for chromosome Y labelled with digoxigenin, were used. We applied this method to evaluate the effects of paternal exposure to acrylamide, a model germ cell clastogen. First-cleavage zygote metaphases, collected from untreated females mated to males whose sperm or late spermatids were treated with acrylamide, were scored for the induction of structural aberrations using both chromosome painting (PAINT analysis) and DAPI analysis. Structural chromosomal aberrations were observed in the sperm-derived, but not in the egg-derived, pronuclei. While 59.4% of the zygotes had structural aberrations by DAPI analysis, 94.1% of the same zygotes had structural aberrations by PAINT analysis (P < 0.001), illustrating the increased sensitivity for detecting translocations and insertions obtained by adding chromosome painting. These findings show that FISH painting of mouse 1-Cl zygotes when used in conjunction with DAPI analysis is a powerful model for investigating the cytogenetic defects transmitted from father to offspring.

DNA content proportionality and persistence of radiation-induced chromosomal aberrations studied by FISH

Chromosome aberrations induced by radiation have been used for the purpose of dosimetry for a long time. Translocations are especially useful for retrospective dosimetry, since they are assumed to be stable. The method of chromosome painting (FISH) has facilitated objective scoring of aberrations considerably. Translocation frequencies, obtained by FISH, for retrospective dosimetry rely on the main assumptions of neutral selection value and that the distribution of aberrations over the chromosomes is a known function of the DNA content of the chromosomes. Data scrutinising the two above-mentioned assumptions indicate deviations from both. Other factors potentially causing problems for retrospective dosimetry, such as inter-individual variations in background and induction patterns, are discussed. Finally, a brief analysis of the statistical power of dosimetry studies shows that establishing low doses (approximately 0.25 Gy) with good precision requires a great effort, which is probably unrealistic for individual dose estimates in epidemiological studies.

Analysis of chromosome aberrations in human peripheral lymphocytes induced by in vitro alpha-particle irradiation

Irradiation of human lymphocytes by alpha-particles under different conditions has been seen to be substantially more effective in the induction of dicentric chromosomes than irradiation by gamma-rays. However, the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) determined in these studies differed by a factor of more than 10. These variations in RBE are likely to be due in part to differing exposure conditions. Therefore, a technique designed to insure uniformity of irradiation was developed in the present study, and complications due to the cell cycle kinetics were controlled. After stimulation with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA), separated lymphocytes were allowed to attach for 3 h to the thin foil bottom of an irradiation chamber. Cell monolayers were exposed with alpha-particles from Am. Strong over-dispersion was noted for the cell-to-cell variance of the number of dicentrics. The dose response of dicentrics was linear, with a yield of 0.27 dicentrics per cell and per Gy. This corresponds to a low dose RBE of 15 relative to Cs gamma-ray exposure under the same experimental conditions.

Theoretical predictions on the equality of radiation-produced dicentrics and translocations detected by chromosome painting

Existing models of chromosome aberrations produced by ionizing-radiation predict equal numbers of dicentrics and translocations if the dose is so low that complex aberrations can be ignored. We show that, for a specific subset of aberrations detected by FISH, dicentric/translocation equality is predicted even at higher doses. Assuming one-colour whole-chromosome painting (with unpainted chromosomes counterstained and centromeres recognizable) the relevant restriction is that the final metaphase pattern be, in the terminology of Simpson and Savage, 'apparently simple'. This means that the painted pattern is required to have the colour/centromere appearance corresponding to a single complete reciprocal exchange but its actual formation, as reflected for example in lengths, is allowed to be more complicated. The restriction to apparent simplicity is significantly less limiting than ignoring all complex aberrations. Our analysis of predicted dicentric/translocation equality in this case uses examples, a combinatorial counting method, Monte Carlo computer programs, and a duality proof. However, we argue that for 'visibly complex' dicentrics or translocations, no similar equality is expected in general. Corresponding experimental results are briefly surveyed. Checking dicentric/translocation equality experimentally can provide a significant test of current chromosome aberration models.

Comparison of gamma-ray induced dicentric yields in human lymphocytes measured by conventional analysis and FISH

In an earlier work stable aberrations and dicentrics were determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) after various doses of 137Cs gamma-rays. No corresponding calibration curve for dicentrics is available for determinations in terms of the conventional analysis as performed in our laboratory. In view of the potential for the application of chromosome painting to human biological dosimetry, it is desirable to determine such a calibration curve and this and the comparison of the resulting data to those obtained in terms of the FISH method is the objective of the present communication. In the study it is found that the linear-quadratic dose response curves for dicentrics, that are determined by the two methods, are significantly different, although the different target sizes are accounted for. A similar problem was found earlier for X-rays. It does not appear that the difference is due to technical difficulties in the FISH method, that has been improved by employing in addition to the whole chromosome DNA probes, a pan-centromeric DNA probe.

The effects of age and lifestyle factors on the accumulation of cytogenetic damage as measured by chromosome painting

Individual responses to the aging process are variable and are affected by genetic as well as environmental factors. Fluorescent in situ hybridization with whole chromosome probes ('chromosome painting') provides an efficient approach for detecting structural chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes. This rapid and sensitive technique is an effective tool for quantifying chronic exposure to environmental agents which may result in an accumulation of cytogenetic damage with age. We have applied this technology to a normal, putatively unexposed, population to document the relationship between age and the accumulation of cytogenetic damage, as well as to establish a baseline frequency of stable aberrations. Using probes for chromosomes 1, 2 and 4 simultaneously, the equivalent of 1000 metaphases was scored for stable and unstable aberrations from each of 91 subjects ranging in age from newborns (umbilical cord bloods; n = 14) to adults aged 19 to 79 years. Each subject (or one parent of each newborn) completed an extensive questionnaire to identify possible lifestyle factors that may influence the frequency of cytogenetic damage. Our findings show a significant increase in stable aberrations (translocations and insertions) with age (p < 0.0001). We also observed age-related increases with dicentrics (p < 0.0001) and acentric fragments (p < 0.0001). Relative to the frequencies observed in cord bloods, the frequencies of stable aberrations, dicentrics, and acentric fragments in adults aged 50 and over were elevated 10.6-fold, 3.3-fold, and 2.9-fold, respectively. Nine variables other than age are significantly associated with the frequency of stable aberrations; these are: smoking (two variables), consumption of diet drinks and/or diet sweeteners (4 variables), exposure to asbestos or coal products (1 variable each), and having a previous major illness (1 variable). Newborns whose mothers smoked during pregnancy had a 1.5-fold increase in stable aberrations (p = 0.029). Repeat samples from a subset of the adults indicate that for most subjects there is little change in individual translocation frequencies over a period of two to three years. These results support the hypothesis that stable chromosome aberrations show a greater accumulation with age than do unstable aberrations and suggest that lifestyle factors contribute to the accumulation of cytogenetic damage.

Application of automation to the detection of radiation damage using FISH technology

A whole chromosome painting approach was employed to highlight the damaging effects of low-to-moderate doses of ionizing radiation. A detailed tally of damage involving the painted chromosomes 1 and 2 was compiled from visual analysis and compared with the results of an automatic image processing approach, where the possible outcomes were 'normal', 'abnormal', or 'rejected'. The performance of the automatic approach was tested using a set of 9000 bicolour metaphase images harvested from whole-blood cell culture following irradiation levels of 0.0, 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 Gy. Every metaphase image in the set was analysed visually. The automatic analysis model was based on two simple image criteria to distinguish normal from abnormal; either an increase in the number of painted objects or a large asymmetry in the area distribution of the expected number of painted objects. A result was obtained without a full karyotype analysis. In practice, automatic analysis produced a set of images for review that were enriched by a factor of 3-4 in true abnormal images. Fast visual review of these images (approximately 200/h) selected the true abnormals. A comparison of the automatic analysis with the visual analysis showed that automated analysis correctly identified 60% of normal cells, 59% of abnormal cells and 73% of rejected cells.

Frequencies of complex chromosome exchange aberrations induced by 238Pu alpha-particles and detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization using single chromosome-specific probes

We undertook an analysis of chromosome-type exchange aberrations induced by alpha-particles using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with whole chromosome-specific probes for human chromosomes 1 or 4, together with a pan-centromeric probe. Contact-inhibited primary human fibroblasts (in G1) were irradiated with 0.41-1.00 Gy 238Pu alpha-particles and aberrations were analysed at the next mitosis following a single chromosome paint. Exchange and aberration painting patterns were classified according to Savage and Simpson (1994a). Of exchange aberrations, 38-47% were found to be complex derived, i.e. resulting from three or more breaks in two or more chromosomes, and the variation with dose was minimal. The class of complex aberrations most frequently observed were insertions, derived from a minimum of three breaks in two chromosomes. There was also an elevated frequency of rings. The high level of complex aberrations observed after alpha-particle irradiation indicates that, when chromosome domains are traversed by high linear energy transfer alpha-particle tracks, there is an enhanced probability of production of multiple localized double-strand breaks leading to more complicated interactions.

X-ray biological dosimetry performed by selective painting of human chromosomes 1 and 2

Fluorescence in situ hybridization with a cocktail of whole-chromosome probes, specific for human chromosomes 1 and 2, was performed to analyze the induction of translocations and dicentrics in human peripheral blood lymphocytes exposed to 100 KVp X-rays and cultured for 48 h. The dose-response curves for both aberration types were linear-quadratic, with similar coefficients, and after correction for genome content were a little lower than the dose-response curve for dicentrics established by conventional analysis. Three doses were also assessed after 76-h culture. The dicentric yield at 76 h was reduced compared with that at 48 h because of the existence of second and third division metaphases. The translocation yield did not reduce except at 4 Gy. The frequency of cells containing both dicentrics and translocations suggested that their occurrence is not correlated. The importance of stating the scoring criteria and of specifying the different types of aberrations is stressed.

Estimating the true frequency of X-ray-induced complex chromosome exchanges using fluorescence in situ hybridization

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with a series of composite probes for human chromosomes 1, 4, 5, 7 and 13, applied separately with a total centromere probe, was used to identify X-ray-induced, chromosome-type aberrations in primary untransformed human fibroblasts. Visible complex exchanges, i.e. those involving three or more breaks in two or more chromosomes, were classified with reference to possible complex FISH patterns derived from a set of theoretical interactions. At 4 Gy, approximately 20% of all exchanges we observed were visibly complex. Using an interaction scheme, which allows either loose end of a break to restitute with its partner, or join with any other loose end within the potential complex, we modelled a set of interactions that matched the frequencies of the complex FISH patterns identified. The direct score of visible complex patterns is an under-estimate of the true frequency because some apparently 'simple' two-break exchanges (dicentrics and translocations) are actually derived from three or more breaks. Using the model we estimate that these account for 20% of the simples scored. Taking this into account, we estimate the true frequency of complexes at 4 Gy to be 35% of all exchanges scored and we believe that the majority of these involve five breaks in four chromosomes.

Validation of chromosome painting. II. A detailed analysis of aberrations following high doses of ionizing radiation in vitro

Fluorescence in situ hybridization with chromosome-specific composite DNA probes ('chromosome painting') is useful for quantifying radiation-induced cytogenetic damage. Recently we showed that the frequency of aberrations observed with painting is similar to that seen with conventional cytogenetic methods, at least at doses of < or = 2 Gy. Above this dose, however, the agreement was not as good. We describe here the results of additional work designed to clarify our earlier findings, and provide a detailed analysis of the type and frequency of aberrations induced in human peripheral lymphocytes following acute exposure to 137Cs at doses of 0 (unexposed control), 1, 2, 3 and 4 Gy. The newly-developed nomenclature for chromosome aberrations detected by painting (Protocol for Aberration Identification and Nomenclature Terminology, 'PAINT') was used to classify all aberrations. Our results indicate that if the guidelines of the PAINT system are followed, chromosome painting can provide meaningful biodosimetry at high doses, and that the observation of complicated rearrangements not only does not interfere with dose estimation, but also the information provided by these exchanges can be easily broken down into the component aberrations and included in the dose estimate. We also show that the inequality between translocations and dicentrics that we previously observed can be explained by an excess of one class of translocated chromosomes, specifically those in which the centromere is from an unpainted chromosome. Translocated chromosomes in which the centromere is painted were found to occur at a frequency equal to dicentrics. These results should help clarify the use of painting for radiation biodosimetry by improving our understanding of the frequencies of various types of stable aberrations observed shortly after exposure. This will improve our ability to perform meaningful biodosimetry long after the frequencies of unstable aberrations have ceased to be informative.

Use of multicolour chromosome painting to identify chromosomal rearrangements in human lymphocytes exposed to bleomycin: a comparison with conventional cytogenetic analysis of Giemsa-stained chromosomes

Exchange aberrations induced by bleomycin were identified by multicolour fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) with probes for chromosomes 1, 2, and 3. The frequency and distribution of aberration types were compared to conventional metaphase analysis of Giemsa-stained chromosomes from the same human lymphocyte cultures. The total percentage of exchanges detectable by painting three pairs of chromosomes with separate colours was calculated as 40%. Giemsa staining revealed predominantly asymmetric chromosome exchanges, which are expected to comprise 50% of the total induced exchanges. Genomic exchange frequencies were, therefore, determined by multiplying the observed frequencies from FISH analysis by 2.5 and the number of asymmetric exchanges identified in Giemsa-stained slides by 2.0. By these calculations, the genomic exchange frequency calculated from chromosome painting exceeded that estimated by Giemsa-staining. This difference was due to the identification by chromosome painting of a unique class of cells in which chromosomes had undergone complex exchanges (nonreciprocal exchanges involving multiple mutual sites). The percentage of cells exhibiting exchanges was similar for both methods.