HIV suppressors against LINE-1: one functions as two

Nef Suppresses LINE-1 Retrotransposition through Two Distinct Mechanisms

Long interspersed element type 1 (LINE-1) is the only known type of retroelement that can replicate autonomously, and its retrotransposition activity can trigger interferon (IFN) production. IFN production suppresses the infectivity of exogenous viruses, such as human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). As a counteraction, HIV has been reported to use multiple proteins and mechanisms to suppress LINE-1 replication. However, the mechanisms of HIV-mediated LINE-1 regulation are not fully understood. In this study, we discovered that Nef protein, which is expressed by HIV and is important for HIV pathogenesis, inhibits LINE-1 retrotransposition. Two distinct mechanisms have been uncovered for Nef-induced LINE-1 suppression. Without direct interaction with LINE-1 DNA, Nef potently inhibits the promoter activity of the LINE-1 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR) and reduces the expression levels of LINE-1 RNA and proteins. Alternatively, although Nef does not bind to the LINE-1 open reading frame 1 protein (ORF1p) or LINE-1 RNA, it significantly compromises the ORF1p-LINE-1 RNA interaction, which is essential for LINE-1 retrotransposition. Both mechanisms can be suppressed by the G2A mutation, which abolishes myristoylation of Nef, suggesting that membrane attachment is essential for Nef to suppress LINE-1. Consequently, through LINE-1 inhibition, Nef downregulates IFN production in host cells. Therefore, our data revealed that Nef is a potent LINE-1 suppressor and an effective innate immune regulator, which not only provides new information on the intricate interaction between HIV, LINE-1, and IFN signaling systems but also strengthens the importance of Nef in HIV infection and highlights the potential of designing novel Nef-targeting anti-HIV drugs. IMPORTANCE Human immunodeficiency viruses are pathogens of AIDS that were first discovered almost 40 years ago and continue to threaten human lives to date. While currently used anti-HIV drugs are sufficient to suppress viral loads in HIV-infected patients, both drug-resistant HIV strains and adverse side effects triggered by the long-term use of these drugs highlight the need to develop novel anti-HIV drugs targeting different viral proteins and/or different steps in viral replication. To achieve this, more information is required regarding HIV pathogenesis and especially its impact on cellular activities in host cells. In this study, we discovered that the Nef protein expressed by HIV potently inhibits LINE-1 retrotransposition. During our attempt to determine the mechanism of Nef-mediated LINE-1 suppression, two additional functions of Nef were uncovered. Nef effectively repressed the promoter activity of LINE-1 5'-UTR and destabilized the interaction between ORF1p and LINE-1 RNA. Consequently, Nef not only compromises LINE-1 replication but also reduces LINE-1-triggered IFN production. The reduction in IFN production, in theory, promotes HIV infectivity. Together with its previously known functions, these findings indicate that Nef is a potential target for the development of novel anti-HIV drugs. Notably, the G2 residue, which has been reported to be essential for most Nef functions, was found to be critical in the regulation of innate immune activation by Nef, suggesting that compromising myristoylation or membrane attachment of Nef may be a good strategy for the inhibition of HIV infection.

Recurrent evolution of an inhibitor of ESCRT-dependent virus budding and LINE-1 retrotransposition in primates

Most antiviral proteins recognize specific features of viruses. In contrast, the recently described antiviral factor retroCHMP3 interferes with the "host endosomal complexes required for transport" (ESCRT) pathway to inhibit the budding of enveloped viruses. RetroCHMP3 arose independently on multiple occasions via duplication and truncation of the gene encoding the ESCRT-III factor CHMP3. However, since the ESCRT pathway is essential for cellular membrane fission reactions, ESCRT inhibition is potentially cytotoxic. This raises fundamental questions about how hosts can repurpose core cellular functions into antiviral functions without incurring a fitness cost due to excess cellular toxicity. We reveal the evolutionary process of detoxification for retroCHMP3 in New World monkeys using a combination of ancestral reconstructions, cytotoxicity, and virus release assays. A duplicated, full-length copy of retroCHMP3 in the ancestors of New World monkeys provides modest inhibition of virus budding while exhibiting subtle cytotoxicity. Ancient retroCHMP3 then accumulated mutations that reduced cytotoxicity but preserved virus inhibition before a truncating stop codon arose in the more recent ancestors of squirrel monkeys, resulting in potent inhibition. In species where full-length copies of retroCHMP3 still exist, their artificial truncation generated potent virus-budding inhibitors with little cytotoxicity, revealing the potential for future antiviral defenses in modern species. In addition, we discovered that retroCHMP3 restricts LINE-1 retrotransposition, revealing how different challenges to genome integrity might explain multiple independent origins of retroCHMP3 in different species to converge on new immune functions.

BST2 suppresses LINE-1 retrotransposition by reducing the promoter activity of LINE-1 5'-UTR

Endogenous retrotransposons are considered the “molecular fossils” of ancient retroviral insertions. Several studies have indicated that host factors restrict both retroviruses and retrotransposons through different mechanisms. Type 1 long interspersed elements (LINE-1 or L1) are the only active retroelements that can replicate autonomously in the human genome. A recent study reported that LINE-1 retrotransposition is potently suppressed by BST2, a host restriction factor that prevents viral release mainly by physically tethering enveloped virions (such as HIV) to the surface of producer cells. However, no endoplasmic membrane structure has been associated with LINE-1 replication, suggesting that BST2 may utilize a distinct mechanism to suppress LINE-1. In this study, we showed that BST2 is a potent LINE-1 suppressor. Further investigations suggested that BST2 reduces the promoter activity of LINE-1 5′ untranslated region (UTR) and lowers the levels of LINE-1 RNA, proteins, and events during LINE-1 retrotransposition. Surprisingly, although BST2 apparently uses different mechanisms against HIV and LINE-1, two membrane-associated domains that are essential for BST2-mediated HIV tethering also proved important for BST2-induced inhibition of LINE-1 5′ UTR. Additionally, by suppressing LINE-1, BST2 prevented LINE-1-induced genomic DNA damage and innate immune activation. Taken together, our data uncovered the mechanism of BST2-mediated LINE-1 suppression and revealed new roles of BST2 as a promoter regulator, genome stabilizer, and innate immune suppressor.

IMPORTANCE BST2 is a potent antiviral protein that suppresses the release of several enveloped viruses, mainly by tethering the envelope of newly synthesized virions and restraining them on the surface of producer cells. In mammalian cells, there are numerous DNA elements replicating through reverse transcription, among which LINE-1 is the only retroelement that can replicate autonomously. Although LINE-1 retrotransposition does not involve the participation of a membrane structure, BST2 has been reported as an efficient LINE-1 suppressor, suggesting a different mechanism for BST2-mediated LINE-1 inhibition and a new function for BST2 itself. We found that BST2 specifically represses the promoter activity of LINE-1 5′ UTR, resulting in decreased levels of LINE-1 transcription, translation, and subsequent retrotransposition. Additionally, by suppressing LINE-1 activity, BST2 maintains genome stability and regulates innate immune activation. These findings expand our understanding of BST2 and its biological significance.

The Interplay Among HIV, LINE-1, and the Interferon Signaling System

Human immunodeficiency viruses (HIVs) are retroviruses that replicate effectively in human CD4⁺ cells and cause the development of acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS). On the other hand, type 1 long interspersed elements (LINE-1s or L1s) are the only active retroelements that can replicate autonomously in human cells. They, along with other active yet nonautonomous retroelements, have been associated with autoimmune diseases. There are many similarities between HIV and LINE-1. Being derived (or evolved) from ancient retroviruses, both HIV and LINE-1 replicate through a process termed reverse transcription, activate endogenous DNA and RNA sensors, trigger innate immune activation to promote interferon (IFN) expression, and are suppressed by protein products of interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs). However, these similarities make it difficult to decipher or even speculate the relationship between HIV and LINE-1, especially regarding the involvement of the IFN signaling system. In this review, we summarize previous findings on the relationships between HIV and innate immune activation as well as between LINE-1 and IFN upregulation. We also attempt to elucidate the interplay among HIV, LINE-1, and the IFN signaling system in hopes of guiding future research directions for viral suppression and immune regulation.