Adaptive tracking of human ECoG network dynamics

Event detection and classification from multimodal time series with application to neural data

The detection of events in time-series data is a common signal-processing problem. When the data can be modeled as a known template signal with an unknown delay in Gaussian noise, detection of the template signal can be done with a traditional matched filter. However, in many applications, the event of interest is represented in multimodal data consisting of both Gaussian and point-process time series. Neuroscience experiments, for example, can simultaneously record multimodal neural signals such as local field potentials (LFPs), which can be modeled as Gaussian, and neuronal spikes, which can be modeled as point processes. Currently, no method exists for event detection from such multimodal data, and as such our objective in this work is to develop a method to meet this need. Here we address this challenge by developing the multimodal event detector (MED) algorithm which simultaneously estimates event times and classes. To do this, we write a multimodal likelihood function for Gaussian and point-process observations and derive the associated maximum likelihood estimator of simultaneous event times and classes. We additionally introduce a cross-modal scaling parameter to account for model mismatch in real datasets. We validate this method in extensive simulations as well as in a neural spike-LFP dataset recorded during an eye-movement task, where the events of interest are eye movements with unknown times and directions. We show that the MED can successfully detect eye movement onset and classify eye movement direction. Further, the MED successfully combines information across data modalities, with multimodal performance exceeding unimodal performance. This method can facilitate applications such as the discovery of latent events in multimodal neural population activity and the development of brain-computer interfaces for naturalistic settings without constrained tasks or prior knowledge of event times.

Multimodal subspace identification for modeling discrete-continuous spiking and field potential population activity

Objective.Learning dynamical latent state models for multimodal spiking and field potential activity can reveal their collective low-dimensional dynamics and enable better decoding of behavior through multimodal fusion. Toward this goal, developing unsupervised learning methods that are computationally efficient is important, especially for real-time learning applications such as brain-machine interfaces (BMIs). However, efficient learning remains elusive for multimodal spike-field data due to their heterogeneous discrete-continuous distributions and different timescales.Approach.Here, we develop a multiscale subspace identification (multiscale SID) algorithm that enables computationally efficient learning for modeling and dimensionality reduction for multimodal discrete-continuous spike-field data. We describe the spike-field activity as combined Poisson and Gaussian observations, for which we derive a new analytical SID method. Importantly, we also introduce a novel constrained optimization approach to learn valid noise statistics, which is critical for multimodal statistical inference of the latent state, neural activity, and behavior. We validate the method using numerical simulations and with spiking and local field potential population activity recorded during a naturalistic reach and grasp behavior.Main results.We find that multiscale SID accurately learned dynamical models of spike-field signals and extracted low-dimensional dynamics from these multimodal signals. Further, it fused multimodal information, thus better identifying the dynamical modes and predicting behavior compared to using a single modality. Finally, compared to existing multiscale expectation-maximization learning for Poisson-Gaussian observations, multiscale SID had a much lower training time while being better in identifying the dynamical modes and having a better or similar accuracy in predicting neural activity and behavior.Significance.Overall, multiscale SID is an accurate learning method that is particularly beneficial when efficient learning is of interest, such as for online adaptive BMIs to track non-stationary dynamics or for reducing offline training time in neuroscience investigations.

Unsupervised learning of stationary and switching dynamical system models from Poisson observations

Objective. Investigating neural population dynamics underlying behavior requires learning accurate models of the recorded spiking activity, which can be modeled with a Poisson observation distribution. Switching dynamical system models can offer both explanatory power and interpretability by piecing together successive regimes of simpler dynamics to capture more complex ones. However, in many cases, reliable regime labels are not available, thus demanding accurate unsupervised learning methods for Poisson observations. Existing learning methods, however, rely on inference of latent states in neural activity using the Laplace approximation, which may not capture the broader properties of densities and may lead to inaccurate learning. Thus, there is a need for new inference methods that can enable accurate model learning.Approach. To achieve accurate model learning, we derive a novel inference method based on deterministic sampling for Poisson observations called the Poisson Cubature Filter (PCF) and embed it in an unsupervised learning framework. This method takes a minimum mean squared error approach to estimation. Terms that are difficult to find analytically for Poisson observations are approximated in a novel way with deterministic sampling based on numerical integration and cubature rules.Main results. PCF enabled accurate unsupervised learning in both stationary and switching dynamical systems and largely outperformed prior Laplace approximation-based learning methods in both simulations and motor cortical spiking data recorded during a reaching task. These improvements were larger for smaller data sizes, showing that PCF-based learning was more data efficient and enabled more reliable regime identification. In experimental data and unsupervised with respect to behavior, PCF-based learning uncovered interpretable behavior-relevant regimes unlike prior learning methods.Significance. The developed unsupervised learning methods for switching dynamical systems can accurately uncover latent regimes and states in population spiking activity, with important applications in both basic neuroscience and neurotechnology.

Post-stimulus encoding of decision confidence in EEG: toward a brain-computer interface for decision making

Objective.When making decisions, humans can evaluate how likely they are to be correct. If this subjective confidence could be reliably decoded from brain activity, it would be possible to build a brain-computer interface (BCI) that improves decision performance by automatically providing more information to the user if needed based on their confidence. But this possibility depends on whether confidence can be decoded right after stimulus presentation and before the response so that a corrective action can be taken in time. Although prior work has shown that decision confidence is represented in brain signals, it is unclear if the representation is stimulus-locked or response-locked, and whether stimulus-locked pre-response decoding is sufficiently accurate for enabling such a BCI.Approach.We investigate the neural correlates of confidence by collecting high-density electroencephalography (EEG) during a perceptual decision task with realistic stimuli. Importantly, we design our task to include a post-stimulus gap that prevents the confounding of stimulus-locked activity by response-locked activity and vice versa, and then compare with a task without this gap.Main results.We perform event-related potential and source-localization analyses. Our analyses suggest that the neural correlates of confidence are stimulus-locked, and that an absence of a post-stimulus gap could cause these correlates to incorrectly appear as response-locked. By preventing response-locked activity from confounding stimulus-locked activity, we then show that confidence can be reliably decoded from single-trial stimulus-locked pre-response EEG alone. We also identify a high-performance classification algorithm by comparing a battery of algorithms. Lastly, we design a simulated BCI framework to show that the EEG classification is accurate enough to build a BCI and that the decoded confidence could be used to improve decision making performance particularly when the task difficulty and cost of errors are high.Significance.Our results show feasibility of non-invasive EEG-based BCIs to improve human decision making.

Multimodal subspace identification for modeling discrete-continuous spiking and field potential population activity

Learning dynamical latent state models for multimodal spiking and field potential activity can reveal their collective low-dimensional dynamics and enable better decoding of behavior through multimodal fusion. Toward this goal, developing unsupervised learning methods that are computationally efficient is important, especially for real-time learning applications such as brain-machine interfaces (BMIs). However, efficient learning remains elusive for multimodal spike-field data due to their heterogeneous discrete-continuous distributions and different timescales. Here, we develop a multiscale subspace identification (multiscale SID) algorithm that enables computationally efficient modeling and dimensionality reduction for multimodal discrete-continuous spike-field data. We describe the spike-field activity as combined Poisson and Gaussian observations, for which we derive a new analytical subspace identification method. Importantly, we also introduce a novel constrained optimization approach to learn valid noise statistics, which is critical for multimodal statistical inference of the latent state, neural activity, and behavior. We validate the method using numerical simulations and spike-LFP population activity recorded during a naturalistic reach and grasp behavior. We find that multiscale SID accurately learned dynamical models of spike-field signals and extracted low-dimensional dynamics from these multimodal signals. Further, it fused multimodal information, thus better identifying the dynamical modes and predicting behavior compared to using a single modality. Finally, compared to existing multiscale expectation-maximization learning for Poisson-Gaussian observations, multiscale SID had a much lower computational cost while being better in identifying the dynamical modes and having a better or similar accuracy in predicting neural activity. Overall, multiscale SID is an accurate learning method that is particularly beneficial when efficient learning is of interest.

Predictive neuromodulation of cingulo-frontal neural dynamics in major depressive disorder using a brain-computer interface system: A simulation study

Introduction

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a promising therapy for treatment-resistant major depressive disorder (MDD). MDD involves the dysfunction of a brain network that can exhibit complex nonlinear neural dynamics in multiple frequency bands. However, current open-loop and responsive DBS methods cannot track the complex multiband neural dynamics in MDD, leading to imprecise regulation of symptoms, variable treatment effects among patients, and high battery power consumption.

Methods

Here, we develop a closed-loop brain-computer interface (BCI) system of predictive neuromodulation for treating MDD. We first use a biophysically plausible ventral anterior cingulate cortex (vACC)-dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) neural mass model of MDD to simulate nonlinear and multiband neural dynamics in response to DBS. We then use offline system identification to build a dynamic model that predicts the DBS effect on neural activity. We next use the offline identified model to design an online BCI system of predictive neuromodulation. The online BCI system consists of a dynamic brain state estimator and a model predictive controller. The brain state estimator estimates the MDD brain state from the history of neural activity and previously delivered DBS patterns. The predictive controller takes the estimated MDD brain state as the feedback signal and optimally adjusts DBS to regulate the MDD neural dynamics to therapeutic targets. We use the vACC-dlPFC neural mass model as a simulation testbed to test the BCI system and compare it with state-of-the-art open-loop and responsive DBS treatments of MDD.

Results

We demonstrate that our dynamic model accurately predicts nonlinear and multiband neural activity. Consequently, the predictive neuromodulation system accurately regulates the neural dynamics in MDD, resulting in significantly smaller control errors and lower DBS battery power consumption than open-loop and responsive DBS.

Discussion

Our results have implications for developing future precisely-tailored clinical closed-loop DBS treatments for MDD.

Modeling and inference methods for switching regime-dependent dynamical systems with multiscale neural observations

Objective.Realizing neurotechnologies that enable long-term neural recordings across multiple spatial-temporal scales during naturalistic behaviors requires new modeling and inference methods that can simultaneously address two challenges. First, the methods should aggregate information across all activity scales from multiple recording sources such as spiking and field potentials. Second, the methods should detect changes in the regimes of behavior and/or neural dynamics during naturalistic scenarios and long-term recordings. Prior regime detection methods are developed for a single scale of activity rather than multiscale activity, and prior multiscale methods have not considered regime switching and are for stationary cases.Approach.Here, we address both challenges by developing a switching multiscale dynamical system model and the associated filtering and smoothing methods. This model describes the encoding of an unobserved brain state in multiscale spike-field activity. It also allows for regime-switching dynamics using an unobserved regime state that dictates the dynamical and encoding parameters at every time-step. We also design the associated switching multiscale inference methods that estimate both the unobserved regime and brain states from simultaneous spike-field activity.Main results.We validate the methods in both extensive numerical simulations and prefrontal spike-field data recorded in a monkey performing saccades for fluid rewards. We show that these methods can successfully combine the spiking and field potential observations to simultaneously track the regime and brain states accurately. Doing so, these methods lead to better state estimation compared with single-scale switching methods or stationary multiscale methods. Also, for single-scale linear Gaussian observations, the new switching smoother can better generalize to diverse system settings compared to prior switching smoothers.Significance.These modeling and inference methods effectively incorporate both regime-detection and multiscale observations. As such, they could facilitate investigation of latent switching neural population dynamics and improve future brain-machine interfaces by enabling inference in naturalistic scenarios where regime-dependent multiscale activity and behavior arise.

A multivariate comparison of electroencephalogram and functional magnetic resonance imaging to electrocorticogram using visual object representations in humans

Today, most neurocognitive studies in humans employ the non-invasive neuroimaging techniques functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and electroencephalogram (EEG). However, how the data provided by fMRI and EEG relate exactly to the underlying neural activity remains incompletely understood. Here, we aimed to understand the relation between EEG and fMRI data at the level of neural population codes using multivariate pattern analysis. In particular, we assessed whether this relation is affected when we change stimuli or introduce identity-preserving variations to them. For this, we recorded EEG and fMRI data separately from 21 healthy participants while participants viewed everyday objects in different viewing conditions, and then related the data to electrocorticogram (ECoG) data recorded for the same stimulus set from epileptic patients. The comparison of EEG and ECoG data showed that object category signals emerge swiftly in the visual system and can be detected by both EEG and ECoG at similar temporal delays after stimulus onset. The correlation between EEG and ECoG was reduced when object representations tolerant to changes in scale and orientation were considered. The comparison of fMRI and ECoG overall revealed a tighter relationship in occipital than in temporal regions, related to differences in fMRI signal-to-noise ratio. Together, our results reveal a complex relationship between fMRI, EEG, and ECoG signals at the level of population codes that critically depends on the time point after stimulus onset, the region investigated, and the visual contents used.

Non-invasive transcranial electrical brain stimulation guided by functional near-infrared spectroscopy for targeted neuromodulation: A review

One of the primary goals in cognitive neuroscience is to understand the neural mechanisms on which cognition is based. Researchers are trying to find how cognitive mechanisms are related to oscillations generated due to brain activity. The research focused on this topic has been considerably aided by developing non-invasive brain stimulation techniques. The dynamics of brain networks and the resultant behavior can be affected by non-invasive brain stimulation techniques, which make their use a focus of interest in many experiments and clinical fields. One essential non-invasive brain stimulation technique is transcranial electrical stimulation (tES), subdivided into transcranial direct and alternating current stimulation. tES has recently become more well-known because of the effective results achieved in treating chronic conditions. In addition, there has been exceptional progress in the interpretation and feasibility of tES techniques. Summarizing the beneficial effects of tES, this article provides an updated depiction of what has been accomplished to date, brief history, and the open questions that need to be addressed in the future. An essential issue in the field of tES is stimulation duration. This review briefly covers the stimulation durations that have been utilized in the field while monitoring the brain using functional-near infrared spectroscopy-based brain imaging.

Designing and Validating a Robust Adaptive Neuromodulation Algorithm for Closed-Loop Control of Brain States

OBJECTIVE

Neuromodulation systems that use closed-loop brain stimulation to control brain states can provide new therapies for brain disorders. To date, closed-loop brain stimulation has largely used linear time-invariant controllers. However, nonlinear time-varying brain network dynamics and external disturbances can appear during real-time stimulation, collectively leading to real-time model uncertainty. Real-time model uncertainty can degrade the performance or even cause instability of time-invariant controllers. Three problems need to be resolved to enable accurate and stable control under model uncertainty. First, an adaptive controller is needed to track the model uncertainty. Second, the adaptive controller additionally needs to be robust to noise and disturbances. Third, theoretical analyses of stability and robustness are needed as prerequisites for stable operation of the controller in practical applications.

APPROACH

We develop a robust adaptive neuromodulation algorithm that solves the above three problems. First, we develop a state-space brain network model that explicitly includes nonlinear terms of real-time model uncertainty and design an adaptive controller to track and cancel the model uncertainty. Second, to improve the robustness of the adaptive controller, we design two linear filters to increase steady-state control accuracy and reduce sensitivity to high-frequency noise and disturbances. Third, we conduct theoretical analyses to prove the stability of the neuromodulation algorithm and establish a trade-off between stability and robustness, which we further use to optimize the algorithm design. Finally, we validate the algorithm using comprehensive Monte Carlo simulations that span a broad range of model nonlinearity, uncertainty, and complexity.

MAIN RESULTS

The robust adaptive neuromodulation algorithm accurately tracks various types of target brain state trajectories, enables stable and robust control, and significantly outperforms state-of-the-art neuromodulation algorithms.

SIGNIFICANCE

Our algorithm has implications for future designs of precise, stable, and robust closed-loop brain stimulation systems to treat brain disorders and facilitate brain functions.

Modeling multiscale causal interactions between spiking and field potential signals during behavior

Objective. Brain recordings exhibit dynamics at multiple spatiotemporal scales, which are measured with spike trains and larger-scale field potential signals. To study neural processes, it is important to identify and model causal interactions not only at a single scale of activity, but also across multiple scales, i.e. between spike trains and field potential signals. Standard causality measures are not directly applicable here because spike trains are binary-valued but field potentials are continuous-valued. It is thus important to develop computational tools to recover multiscale neural causality during behavior, assess their performance on neural datasets, and study whether modeling multiscale causalities can improve the prediction of neural signals beyond what is possible with single-scale causality. Approach. We design a multiscale model-based Granger-like causality method based on directed information and evaluate its success both in realistic biophysical spike-field simulations and in motor cortical datasets from two non-human primates (NHP) performing a motor behavior. To compute multiscale causality, we learn point-process generalized linear models that predict the spike events at a given time based on the history of both spike trains and field potential signals. We also learn linear Gaussian models that predict the field potential signals at a given time based on their own history as well as either the history of binary spike events or that of latent firing rates. Main results. We find that our method reveals the true multiscale causality network structure in biophysical simulations despite the presence of model mismatch. Further, models with the identified multiscale causalities in the NHP neural datasets lead to better prediction of both spike trains and field potential signals compared to just modeling single-scale causalities. Finally, we find that latent firing rates are better predictors of field potential signals compared with the binary spike events in the NHP datasets. Significance. This multiscale causality method can reveal the directed functional interactions across spatiotemporal scales of brain activity to inform basic science investigations and neurotechnologies.

Hierarchical Decoding Model of Upper Limb Movement Intention From EEG Signals Based on Attention State Estimation

Decoding the motion intention of the human upper limb from electroencephalography (EEG) signals has important practical values. However, existing decoding models are built under the attended state while subjects perform motion tasks. In practice, people are often distracted by other tasks or environmental factors, which may impair decoding performance. To address this problem, in this paper, we propose a hierarchical decoding model of human upper limb motion intention from EEG signals based on attention state estimation. The proposed decoding model includes two components. First, the attention state detection (ASD) component estimates the attention state during the upper limb movement. Next, the motion intention recognition (MIR) component decodes the motion intention by using the decoding models built under the attended and distracted states. The experimental results show that the proposed hierarchical decoding model performs well under the attended and distracted states. This work can advance the application of human movement intention decoding and provides new insights into the study of brain-machine interfaces.

Multi-scale neural decoding and analysis

Objective.

Complex spatiotemporal neural activity encodes rich information related to behavior and cognition. Conventional research has focused on neural activity acquired using one of many different measurement modalities, each of which provides useful but incomplete assessment of the neural code. Multi-modal techniques can overcome tradeoffs in the spatial and temporal resolution of a single modality to reveal deeper and more comprehensive understanding of system-level neural mechanisms. Uncovering multi-scale dynamics is essential for a mechanistic understanding of brain function and for harnessing neuroscientific insights to develop more effective clinical treatment.

Approach.

We discuss conventional methodologies used for characterizing neural activity at different scales and review contemporary examples of how these approaches have been combined. Then we present our case for integrating activity across multiple scales to benefit from the combined strengths of each approach and elucidate a more holistic understanding of neural processes.

Main results.

We examine various combinations of neural activity at different scales and analytical techniques that can be used to integrate or illuminate information across scales, as well the technologies that enable such exciting studies. We conclude with challenges facing future multi-scale studies, and a discussion of the power and potential of these approaches.

Significance.

This roadmap will lead the readers toward a broad range of multi-scale neural decoding techniques and their benefits over single-modality analyses. This Review article highlights the importance of multi-scale analyses for systematically interrogating complex spatiotemporal mechanisms underlying cognition and behavior.

Adaptive latent state modeling of brain network dynamics with real-time learning rate optimization

Objective. Dynamic latent state models are widely used to characterize the dynamics of brain network activity for various neural signal types. To date, dynamic latent state models have largely been developed for stationary brain network dynamics. However, brain network dynamics can be non-stationary for example due to learning, plasticity or recording instability. To enable modeling these non-stationarities, two problems need to be resolved. First, novel methods should be developed that can adaptively update the parameters of latent state models, which is difficult due to the state being latent. Second, new methods are needed to optimize the adaptation learning rate, which specifies how fast new neural observations update the model parameters and can significantly influence adaptation accuracy.Approach. We develop a Rate Optimized-adaptive Linear State-Space Modeling (RO-adaptive LSSM) algorithm that solves these two problems. First, to enable adaptation, we derive a computation- and memory-efficient adaptive LSSM fitting algorithm that updates the LSSM parameters recursively and in real time in the presence of the latent state. Second, we develop a real-time learning rate optimization algorithm. We use comprehensive simulations of a broad range of non-stationary brain network dynamics to validate both algorithms, which together constitute the RO-adaptive LSSM.Main results. We show that the adaptive LSSM fitting algorithm can accurately track the broad simulated non-stationary brain network dynamics. We also find that the learning rate significantly affects the LSSM fitting accuracy. Finally, we show that the real-time learning rate optimization algorithm can run in parallel with the adaptive LSSM fitting algorithm. Doing so, the combined RO-adaptive LSSM algorithm rapidly converges to the optimal learning rate and accurately tracks non-stationarities.Significance. These algorithms can be used to study time-varying neural dynamics underlying various brain functions and enhance future neurotechnologies such as brain-machine interfaces and closed-loop brain stimulation systems.

The Argo: a high channel count recording system for neural recording in vivo

OBJECTIVE

Decoding neural activity has been limited by the lack of tools available to record from large numbers of neurons across multiple cortical regions simultaneously with high temporal fidelity. To this end, we developed the Argo system to record cortical neural activity at high data rates.

APPROACH

Here we demonstrate a massively parallel neural recording system based on platinum-iridium microwire electrode arrays bonded to a CMOS voltage amplifier array. The Argo system is the highest channel count in vivo neural recording system, supporting simultaneous recording from 65 536 channels, sampled at 32 kHz and 12-bit resolution. This system was designed for cortical recordings, compatible with both penetrating and surface microelectrodes.

MAIN RESULTS

We validated this system through initial bench testing to determine specific gain and noise characteristics of bonded microwires, followed by in-vivo experiments in both rat and sheep cortex. We recorded spiking activity from 791 neurons in rats and surface local field potential activity from over 30 000 channels in sheep.

SIGNIFICANCE

These are the largest channel count microwire-based recordings in both rat and sheep. While currently adapted for head-fixed recording, the microwire-CMOS architecture is well suited for clinical translation. Thus, this demonstration helps pave the way for a future high data rate intracortical implant.

Modelling and prediction of the dynamic responses of large-scale brain networks during direct electrical stimulation

Direct electrical stimulation can modulate the activity of brain networks for the treatment of several neurological and neuropsychiatric disorders and for restoring lost function. However, precise neuromodulation in an individual requires the accurate modelling and prediction of the effects of stimulation on the activity of their large-scale brain networks. Here, we report the development of dynamic input-output models that predict multiregional dynamics of brain networks in response to temporally varying patterns of ongoing microstimulation. In experiments with two awake rhesus macaques, we show that the activities of brain networks are modulated by changes in both stimulation amplitude and frequency, that they exhibit damping and oscillatory response dynamics, and that variabilities in prediction accuracy and in estimated response strength across brain regions can be explained by an at-rest functional connectivity measure computed without stimulation. Input-output models of brain dynamics may enable precise neuromodulation for the treatment of disease and facilitate the investigation of the functional organization of large-scale brain networks.

Multiscale low-dimensional motor cortical state dynamics predict naturalistic reach-and-grasp behavior

Motor function depends on neural dynamics spanning multiple spatiotemporal scales of population activity, from spiking of neurons to larger-scale local field potentials (LFP). How multiple scales of low-dimensional population dynamics are related in control of movements remains unknown. Multiscale neural dynamics are especially important to study in naturalistic reach-and-grasp movements, which are relatively under-explored. We learn novel multiscale dynamical models for spike-LFP network activity in monkeys performing naturalistic reach-and-grasps. We show low-dimensional dynamics of spiking and LFP activity exhibited several principal modes, each with a unique decay-frequency characteristic. One principal mode dominantly predicted movements. Despite distinct principal modes existing at the two scales, this predictive mode was multiscale and shared between scales, and was shared across sessions and monkeys, yet did not simply replicate behavioral modes. Further, this multiscale mode's decay-frequency explained behavior. We propose that multiscale, low-dimensional motor cortical state dynamics reflect the neural control of naturalistic reach-and-grasp behaviors.

Modeling behaviorally relevant neural dynamics enabled by preferential subspace identification

Neural activity exhibits complex dynamics related to various brain functions, internal states and behaviors. Understanding how neural dynamics explain specific measured behaviors requires dissociating behaviorally relevant and irrelevant dynamics, which is not achieved with current neural dynamic models as they are learned without considering behavior. We develop preferential subspace identification (PSID), which is an algorithm that models neural activity while dissociating and prioritizing its behaviorally relevant dynamics. Modeling data in two monkeys performing three-dimensional reach and grasp tasks, PSID revealed that the behaviorally relevant dynamics are significantly lower-dimensional than otherwise implied. Moreover, PSID discovered distinct rotational dynamics that were more predictive of behavior. Furthermore, PSID more accurately learned behaviorally relevant dynamics for each joint and recording channel. Finally, modeling data in two monkeys performing saccades demonstrated the generalization of PSID across behaviors, brain regions and neural signal types. PSID provides a general new tool to reveal behaviorally relevant neural dynamics that can otherwise go unnoticed.