Regulatory concerns in human gene therapy

Non-viral Gene Delivery Methods for Bone and Joints

Viral carrier transport efficiency of gene delivery is high, depending on the type of vector. However, viral delivery poses significant safety concerns such as inefficient/unpredictable reprogramming outcomes, genomic integration, as well as unwarranted immune responses and toxicity. Thus, non-viral gene delivery methods are more feasible for translation as these allow safer delivery of genes and can modulate gene expression transiently both in vivo, ex vivo, and in vitro. Based on current studies, the efficiency of these technologies appears to be more limited, but they are appealing for clinical translation. This review presents a summary of recent advancements in orthopedics, where primarily bone and joints from the musculoskeletal apparatus were targeted. In connective tissues, which are known to have a poor healing capacity, and have a relatively low cell-density, i.e., articular cartilage, bone, and the intervertebral disk (IVD) several approaches have recently been undertaken. We provide a brief overview of the existing technologies, using nano-spheres/engineered vesicles, lipofection, and in vivo electroporation. Here, delivery for microRNA (miRNA), and silencing RNA (siRNA) and DNA plasmids will be discussed. Recent studies will be summarized that aimed to improve regeneration of these tissues, involving the delivery of bone morphogenic proteins (BMPs), such as BMP2 for improvement of bone healing. For articular cartilage/osteochondral junction, non-viral methods concentrate on targeted delivery to chondrocytes or MSCs for tissue engineering-based approaches. For the IVD, growth factors such as GDF5 or GDF6 or developmental transcription factors such as Brachyury or FOXF1 seem to be of high clinical interest. However, the most efficient method of gene transfer is still elusive, as several preclinical studies have reported many different non-viral methods and clinical translation of these techniques still needs to be validated. Here we discuss the non-viral methods applied for bone and joint and propose methods that can be promising in clinical use.

Validation of a quality assurance program for autologous cultured chondrocyte implantation

The use of living human cells to facilitate repair of defects in structural tissues is a rapidly emerging treatment option. A quality assurance program based on U.S. Food and Drug Administration good manufacturing practice regulations and other guidance was established and implemented in a program to use autologous cultured chondrocytes for repair of articular defects of the knee. The development of ex vivo cell therapies presents novel issues of quality assurance. The implementation and evaluation of this quality program was based on the implantation of 303 patients with autologous cultured chondrocytes, in which we analyzed a number of quantifiable parameters and which meets the unique challenges of autologous cell therapy within a rigorous regulatory framework. Application of well-accepted principles of quality assurance and quality control coupled with a thorough understanding of the cell culturing processes will result in a safe and efficacious cell therapy product.

Gene therapy approaches to Parkinson's disease: preclinical to clinical trials, or what steps to take to get there from here?

Do "gene therapies" offer new approaches to the treatment of Parkinson's disease? The presentations of this symposium, as well as numerous published articles, suggest that they might. This article describes a preclinical in vivo gene therapy study in parkinsonian monkeys and briefly reviews the history of studies with novel cellular implantation approaches to Parkinson's disease as a basis for evaluating when and how gene therapy trials in Parkinson's patients might be appropriate. A number of concerns are raised.

Regulatory review of cellular and gene therapies: an overview of the process

Cell and gene therapies, using several different approaches, have been proposed for a variety of genetic diseases, cancer and AIDS. The major regulatory review process in the US consists of an institutional review board, the recombinant DNA advisory committee (RAC) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Within the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, the Division of Cellular and Gene Therapies has been formed to primarily review investigational new drug applications (INDs) for cellular and gene therapies. Several appropriate "points to consider" documents have been prepared and the RAC has approved over 40 clinical protocols. Advances in biotechnology and the scientific basis for these advances are changing rapidly. Although a flexible, case-by-case approach is necessitated by these rapid changes, regulatory concerns common to all biologicals administered to human subjects remain unchanged. These include safety, efficacy, purity, potency, quality control and assessment, and reproducibility of individual lots. The goal of the review process is a prompt, complete and meticulous review. The emphasis of a pre-IND meeting is toward a working relationship between the sponsor and the FDA prior to the phase I, II and III clinical trials. A timely and ongoing evaluation of pre-clinical testing cannot be overemphasized in this rapidly growing and changing field. The development of a working relationship at this stage will ensure a seamless integration of the IND process with the product and establishment license applications. Because replication-competent retrovirus (RCR) represents a potential for pathogenicity, the FDA is recommending a conservative approach to RCR testing.

Overview of a quality assurance/quality control compliance program consistent with FDA regulations and policies for somatic cell and gene therapies: a four year experience

Somatic cell and gene therapy involve the application of biological technologies to an individual patient through the use of living cells which provide a therapeutic benefit (Aliski, 1991). Various forms of cellular and gene therapies are being developed and evaluated in an increasing number of clinical trials for congenital and acquired disorders. The potential and progress of these therapeutic applications have resulted in an increasing effort by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to develop the regulatory framework under which these therapeutic approaches would insure safety and efficacy, the primary mandate of the FDA. Over five years ago Cellcor began to define the parameters, specifications, and conditions relevant to a Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) program that has evolved to insure safety and maximize the efficacy of applications of the company's ex vivo technology, autolymphocyte therapy. Autolymphocyte therapy is an outpatient form of somatic cell immunotherapy based upon the infusion of T cells that have been activated ex vivo using a combination of previously generated autologous cytokines and an anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody. We have been able to demonstrate the feasibility for the safe, controlled, and consistent preparation and delivery of a cellular therapy by application of relevant GMP regulations. This presentation reviews aspects of this program and chronicles our experience which at present amounts to over 4400 in fusions for over 700 patients. This program provides a high degree of assurance that a cellular therapy program can be carried out in a multisite mode involving hundreds of patients through the strict adherence to cGMP as set forth in existing regulations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Gene therapy of cancer

Retroviral-mediated gene transfer has permitted the development of clinical protocols for the study and treatment of cancer. These protocols can be divided into gene-labeling and gene therapy proposals. Labeling studies include the tracking of tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) following the administration of those cells, and the detection, at the time of relapse, of tumor cells from transplanted autologous bone marrow. Most gene therapy protocols are designed to induce an immune attack against the tumor by inserting genes into tumor cells themselves. Although uncertainty about the safety of the procedure still exists, gene therapy of cancer holds much promise as an effective treatment modality.