Electrospun Template Architecture and Composition Regulate Neutrophil NETosis In Vitro and In Vivo<sup/>

Properties of Electrospun Fibers That Influence Foreign Body Response Modulation

Improving the utility of biomedical devices implanted in subcutaneous tissue by modulating the innate immune response common to these implants is of great interest to improve their utility. Uncontrolled, most biomedical devices produce an immune reaction known broadly as the foreign body response (FBR), which ultimately isolates the device from the native tissue. The use of electrospun fibers to create a porous surface that promotes tissue in-growth and regeneration represents a new paradigm in FBR modulation. A vast number of parameters can be adjusted in the electrospinning process to tune the type and quality of the resulting electrospun matrix, which in turn has varying outcomes with respect to the FBR. In this review, the fabrication and utility of electrospun fiber scaffolds for mitigating the FBR are described, with details of how fiber properties and surface modifications alter immune response for specific biomedical applications.

Methyl Syringate: A Primary Driving Factor in Manuka Honeys Ability to Ameliorate Neutrophil Intracellular ROS Activity and NETosis

BACKGROUND

Neutrophils use both the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and a specialized process called NETosis to defend the body from material deemed foreign. While these neutrophil behaviors are critical in preventing infection, a dysregulated response can lead to tissue damage and fibrosis at host-biomaterial interfaces. It was hypothesized that applying the flavonoids found in Manuka honey: chrysin, pinocembrin, and pinobanksin, and the phenolic compound methyl syringate to neutrophils exhibiting pro-inflammatory behavior will reduce ROS activity and prevent NETosis in primary human neutrophils.

METHODS

Using primary human neutrophils isolated from donor (n = 5) peripheral blood, concentrations between 1 nM and 10 µM of each flavonoid, 10 µM and 2 mM of methyl syringate, 0.1% v/v and 10% v/v Manuka honey, and combinations of both 1 nM-10 µM of each flavonoid and 10 µM-2 mM of methyl syringate were assayed for reductions in NETosis using Sytox orange extracellular DNA staining and reduction in intracellular ROS activity via standard dichloro-dihydro-fluorescein diacetate (DCFH-DA) oxidation assay.

RESULTS

Compared to positive control levels, individual flavonoids showed moderate effect sizes. Higher concentrations of flavonoids, especially in combination, stimulated ROS activity by up to 105%. Whole Manuka honey reduced neutrophil extracellular trap (NET) levels by up to 91% but only reduced ROS activity by 36%. However, methyl syringate reduced NET levels by up to 68% and ROS activity by 66%.

CONCLUSIONS

Methyl syringate and whole Manuka honey are potent inhibitors of neutrophil intracellular ROS activity and NET formation. Methyl syringate potentially drives the anti-inflammatory capabilities of Manuka honey demonstrated by previous studies.

Biomaterials for immunomodulation in wound healing

The substantial economic impact of non-healing wounds, scarring, and burns stemming from skin injuries is evident, resulting in a financial burden on both patients and the healthcare system. This review paper provides an overview of the skin's vital role in guarding against various environmental challenges as the body's largest protective organ and associated developments in biomaterials for wound healing. We first introduce the composition of skin tissue and the intricate processes of wound healing, with special attention to the crucial role of immunomodulation in both acute and chronic wounds. This highlights how the imbalance in the immune response, particularly in chronic wounds associated with underlying health conditions such as diabetes and immunosuppression, hinders normal healing stages. Then, this review distinguishes between traditional wound-healing strategies that create an optimal microenvironment and recent peptide-based biomaterials that modulate cellular processes and immune responses to facilitate wound closure. Additionally, we highlight the importance of considering the stages of wounds in the healing process. By integrating advanced materials engineering with an in-depth understanding of wound biology, this approach holds promise for reshaping the field of wound management and ultimately offering improved outcomes for patients with acute and chronic wounds.

Electrospun fiber-based immune engineering in regenerative medicine

Immune engineering, a burgeoning field within regenerative medicine, involves a spectrum of strategies to optimize the intricate interplay between tissue regenerative biomaterials and the host tissue. These strategies are applied across different types of biomaterials and various disease models, which encompasses finely modulating the immune response at the levels of immune cells and factors, aiming to mitigate adverse effects like fibrosis and persistent inflammation that may arise at the injury site and consequently promote tissue regeneration. With the continuous progress in electrospinning technology, the immunoregulatory capabilities of electrospun fibers have gained substantial attention over the years. Electrospun fibers, with their extracellular matrix-like characteristics, high surface-area-to-volume ratio, and reliable pharmaceutical compound capacity, have emerged as key players among tissue engineering materials. This review specifically focuses on the role of electrospun fiber-based immune engineering, emphasizing their unique design strategies. Notably, electrospinning actively engages in immune engineering by modulating immune responses through four essential strategies: (i) surface modification, (ii) drug loading, (iii) physicochemical parameters, and (iv) biological grafting. This review presents a comprehensive overview of the intricate mechanisms of the immune system in injured tissues while unveiling the key strategies adopted by electrospun fibers to orchestrate immune regulation. Furthermore, the review explores the current developmental trends and limitations concerning the immunoregulatory function of electrospun fibers, aiming to drive the advancements in electrospun fiber-based immune engineering to its full potential.

Fiber configuration determines foreign body response of electrospun scaffolds:in vitroandin vivoassessments

Biomaterial scaffolds boost tissue repair and regeneration by providing physical support, delivering biological signals and/or cells, and recruiting endogenous cells to facilitate tissue-material integration and remodeling. Foreign body response (FBR), an innate immune response that occurs immediately after biomaterial implantation, is a critical factor in determining the biological outcomes of biomaterial scaffolds. Electrospinning is of great simplicity and cost-effectiveness to produce nanofiber scaffolds with well-defined physicochemical properties and has been used in a variety of regenerative medicine applications in preclinical trials and clinical practice. A deep understanding of causal factors between material properties and FBR of host tissues is beneficial to the optimal design of electrospun scaffolds with favorable immunomodulatory properties. We herein prepared and characterized three electrospun scaffolds with distinct fiber configurations and investigated their effects on FBR in terms of immune cell-material interactions and host responses. Our results show that electrospun yarn scaffold results in greater cellular immune reactions and elevated FBR inin vivoassessments. Although the yarn scaffold showed aligned fiber bundles, it failed to induce cell elongation of macrophages due to its rough surface and porous grooves between yarns. In contrast, the aligned scaffold showed reduced FBR compared to the yarn scaffold, indicating a smooth surface is also a contributor to the immunomodulatory effects of the aligned scaffold. Our study suggests that balanced porousness and smooth surface of aligned fibers or yarns should be the key design parameters of electrospun scaffolds to modulate host responsein vivo.

Clinical relevance of cell-free DNA during venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation

BACKGROUND

Thrombosis remains a critical complication during venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (VV ECMO). The involvement of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) in thrombogenesis has to be discussed. The aim was to verify NETs in the form of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) in the plasma of patients during ECMO.

METHODS

A fluorescent DNA-binding dye (QuantifFluor®, Promega) was used to detect cell-free DNA in plasma samples. cfDNA concentrations from volunteers (n = 21) and patients (n = 9) were compared and correlated with clinical/technical data before/during support, ECMO end and time of a system exchange.

RESULTS

Before ECMO, patients with a median (IQR) age of 59 (51/63) years, SOFA score of 11 (10/15), and ECMO run time of 9.0 (7.0/19.5) days presented significantly higher levels of cfDNA compared to volunteers (6.4 (5.8/7.9) ng/μL vs. 5.9 (5.4/6.3) ng/μL; p = 0.044). Within 2 days after ECMO start, cfDNA, inflammatory, and hemolysis parameters remained unchanged, while platelets decreased (p = 0.005). After ECMO removal at the end of therapy, cfDNA, inflammation, and coagulation data (except antithrombin III) remained unchanged. The renewal of a system resulted in known alterations in fibrinogen, d-dimers, and platelets, while cfDNA remained unchanged.

CONCLUSION

Detection of cfDNA in plasma of ECMO patients was not an indicator of acute and circuit-induced thrombogenesis.

Functional regeneration at the blood-biomaterial interface

The use of cardiovascular implants is commonplace in clinical practice. However, reproducing the key bioactive and adaptive properties of native cardiovascular tissues with an artificial replacement is highly challenging. Exciting new treatment strategies are under development to regenerate (parts of) cardiovascular tissues directly in situ using immunomodulatory biomaterials. Direct exposure to the bloodstream and hemodynamic loads is a particular challenge, given the risk of thrombosis and adverse remodeling that it brings. However, the blood is also a source of (immune) cells and proteins that dominantly contribute to functional tissue regeneration. This review explores the potential of the blood as a source for the complete or partial in situ regeneration of cardiovascular tissues, with a particular focus on the endothelium, being the natural blood-tissue barrier. We pinpoint the current scientific challenges to enable rational engineering and testing of blood-contacting implants to leverage the regenerative potential of the blood.

Reduction of neutrophil extracellular traps accelerates inflammatory resolution and increases bone formation on titanium implants

Neutrophils are the most abundant immune cells in the blood and the first cells to be recruited to the biomaterial implantation site. Neutrophils are fundamental in recruiting mononuclear leukocytes to mount an immune response at the injury site. Neutrophils exert significant pro-inflammatory effects through the release of cytokines and chemokines, degranulation and release of myeloperoxidase (MPO) and neutrophil elastase (NE), and the production of large DNA-based networks called neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs). Neutrophils are initially recruited and activated by cytokines and pathogen- and damage-associated molecular patterns, but little is known about how the physicochemical composition of the biomaterial affects their activation. This study aimed to understand how ablating neutrophil mediators (MPO, NE, NETs) affected macrophage phenotype in vitro and osseointegration in vivo. We discovered that NET formation is a crucial mediator of pro-inflammatory macrophage activation, and inhibition of NET formation significantly suppresses macrophage pro-inflammatory phenotype. Furthermore, reducing NET formation accelerated the inflammatory phase of healing and produced greater bone formation around the implanted biomaterial, suggesting that NETs are essential regulators of biomaterial integration. Our findings emphasize the importance of the neutrophil response to implanted biomaterials and highlight innate immune cells' regulation and amplification signaling during the initiation and resolution of the inflammatory phase of biomaterial integration. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Neutrophils are the most abundant immune cells in blood and are the first to be recruited to the injury/implantation site where they exert significant pro-inflammatory effects. This study aimed to understand how ablating neutrophil mediators affected macrophage phenotype in vitro and bone apposition in vivo. We found that NET formation is a crucial mediator of pro-inflammatory macrophage activation. Reducing NET formation accelerated the inflammatory phase of healing and produced greater appositional bone formation around the implanted biomaterial, suggesting that NETs are essential regulators of biomaterial integration.

Study on the influence of scaffold morphology and structure on osteogenic performance

The number of patients with bone defects caused by various bone diseases is increasing yearly in the aging population, and people are paying increasing attention to bone tissue engineering research. Currently, the application of bone tissue engineering mainly focuses on promoting fracture healing by carrying cytokines. However, cytokines implanted into the body easily cause an immune response, and the cost is high; therefore, the clinical treatment effect is not outstanding. In recent years, some scholars have proposed the concept of tissue-induced biomaterials that can induce bone regeneration through a scaffold structure without adding cytokines. By optimizing the scaffold structure, the performance of tissue-engineered bone scaffolds is improved and the osteogenesis effect is promoted, which provides ideas for the design and improvement of tissue-engineered bones in the future. In this study, the current understanding of the bone tissue structure is summarized through the discussion of current bone tissue engineering, and the current research on micro-nano bionic structure scaffolds and their osteogenesis mechanism is analyzed and discussed.

Immunomodulatory biomaterials for implant-associated infections: from conventional to advanced therapeutic strategies

Implant-associated infection (IAI) is increasingly emerging as a serious threat with the massive application of biomaterials. Bacteria attached to the surface of implants are often difficult to remove and exhibit high resistance to bactericides. In the quest for novel antimicrobial strategies, conventional antimicrobial materials often fail to exert their function because they tend to focus on direct bactericidal activity while neglecting the modulation of immune systems. The inflammatory response induced by host immune cells was thought to be a detrimental force impeding wound healing. However, the immune system has recently received increasing attention as a vital player in the host's defense against infection. Anti-infective strategies based on the modulation of host immune defenses are emerging as a field of interest. This review explains the importance of the immune system in combating infections and describes current advanced immune-enhanced anti-infection strategies. First, the characteristics of traditional/conventional implant biomaterials and the reasons for the difficulty of bacterial clearance in IAI were reviewed. Second, the importance of immune cells in the battle against bacteria is elucidated. Then, we discuss how to design biomaterials that activate the defense function of immune cells to enhance the antimicrobial potential. Based on the key premise of restoring proper host-protective immunity, varying advanced immune-enhanced antimicrobial strategies were discussed. Finally, current issues and perspectives in this field were offered. This review will provide scientific guidance to enhance the development of advanced anti-infective biomaterials.

Harnessing Biomaterials for Immunomodulatory-Driven Tissue Engineering

Abstract

The immune system plays a crucial role during tissue repair and wound healing processes. Biomaterials have been leveraged to assist in this in situ tissue regeneration process to dampen the foreign body response by evading or suppressing the immune system. An emerging paradigm within regenerative medicine is to use biomaterials to influence the immune system and create a pro-reparative microenvironment to instigate endogenously driven tissue repair. In this review, we discuss recent studies that focus on immunomodulation of innate and adaptive immune cells for tissue engineering applications through four biomaterial-based mechanisms of action: biophysical cues, chemical modifications, drug delivery, and sequestration. These materials enable augmented regeneration in various contexts, including vascularization, bone repair, wound healing, and autoimmune regulation. While further understanding of immune-material interactions is needed to design the next generation of immunomodulatory biomaterials, these materials have already demonstrated great promise for regenerative medicine.

Lay Summary

The immune system plays an important role in tissue repair. Many biomaterial strategies have been used to promote tissue repair, and recent work in this area has looked into the possibility of doing repair by tuning. Thus, we examined the literature for recent works showcasing the efficacy of these approaches in animal models of injuries. In these studies, we found that biomaterials successfully tuned the immune response and improved the repair of various tissues. This highlights the promise of immune-modulating material strategies to improve tissue repair.

Electrospun fiber-based strategies for controlling early innate immune cell responses: Towards immunomodulatory mesh designs that facilitate robust tissue repair

Electrospun fibrous meshes are widely used for tissue repair due to their ability to guide a host of cell responses including phenotypic differentiation and tissue maturation. A critical factor determining the eventual biological outcomes of mesh-based regeneration strategies is the early innate immune response following implantation. The natural healing process involves a sequence of tightly regulated, temporally varying and delicately balanced pro-/anti-inflammatory events which together promote mesh integration with host tissue. Matrix designs that do not account for the immune milieu can result in dysregulation, chronic inflammation and fibrous capsule formation, thus obliterating potential therapeutic outcomes. In this review, we provide systematic insights into the effects of specific fiber/mesh properties and mechanical stimulation on the responses of early innate immune modulators viz., neutrophils, monocytes and macrophages. We identify matrix characteristics that promote anti-inflammatory immune phenotypes, and we correlate such responses with pro-regenerative in vivo outcomes. We also discuss recent advances in 3D fabrication technologies, bioactive functionalization approaches and biomimetic/bioinspired immunomodulatory mesh design strategies for tissue repair and wound healing. The mechanobiological insights and immunoregulatory strategies discussed herein can help improve the translational outcomes of fiber-based regeneration and may also be leveraged for intervention in degenerative diseases associated with dysfunctional immune responses. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The crucial role played by immune cells in promoting biomaterial-based tissue regeneration is being increasingly recognized. In this review focusing on the interactions of innate immune cells (primarily neutrophils, monocytes and macrophages) with electrospun fibrous meshes, we systematically elucidate the effects of the fiber microenvironment and mechanical stimulation on biological responses, and build upon these insights to inform the rational design of immunomodulatory meshes for effective tissue repair. We discuss state-of-the-art fabrication methods and mechanobiological advances that permit the orchestration of temporally controlled phenotypic switches in immune cells during different phases of healing. The design strategies discussed herein can also be leveraged to target several complex autoimmune and inflammatory diseases.

Methods for Quantifying Neutrophil Extracellular Traps on Biomaterials

Neutrophils rapidly accumulate at sites of inflammation, including biomaterial implantation sites, where they can modulate the microenvironment toward repair through a variety of functions, including superoxide generation, granule release, and extrusion of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs). NETs are becoming increasing implicated as a central player in the host response to a biomaterial, and as such, there is a need for reliable in vitro methods to evaluate the relative degree of NETs and quantify NETs on the surface of biomaterials. Such methods should be relatively high throughput and minimize sampling bias. In this chapter, we describe two procedures, (1) fluorescent image analysis and (2) a NETs-based ELISA, both of which have been specifically optimized to quantify NETs generated from human neutrophils on electrospun polydioxanone templates. Both methods are valid and also compatible with tissue culture plastic, but have a variety of advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, both methods can be used to concomitantly study NETs on the surface of a biomaterial. Finally, while these methods were developed for electrospun templates in a 96-well cell culture plate, they may be easily adapted to a large scale and for other biomaterials, including but not limited to metallics, ceramics, and natural and synthetic polymers.

Immuno-regenerative biomaterials for in situ cardiovascular tissue engineering - Do patient characteristics warrant precision engineering?

In situ tissue engineering using bioresorbable material implants - or scaffolds - that harness the patient's immune response while guiding neotissue formation at the site of implantation is emerging as a novel therapy to regenerate human tissues. For the cardiovascular system, the use of such implants, like blood vessels and heart valves, is gradually entering the stage of clinical translation. This opens up the question if and to what extent patient characteristics influence tissue outcomes, necessitating the precision engineering of scaffolds to guide patient-specific neo-tissue formation. Because of the current scarcity of human in vivo data, herein we review and evaluate in vitro and preclinical investigations to predict the potential role of patient-specific parameters like sex, age, ethnicity, hemodynamics, and a multifactorial disease profile, with special emphasis on their contribution to the inflammation-driven processes of in situ tissue engineering. We conclude that patient-specific conditions have a strong impact on key aspects of in situ cardiovascular tissue engineering, including inflammation, hemodynamic conditions, scaffold resorption, and tissue remodeling capacity, suggesting that a tailored approach may be required to engineer immuno-regenerative biomaterials for safe and predictive clinical applicability.

Control of innate immune response by biomaterial surface topography, energy, and stiffness

As the focus of implantable biomaterials has shifted from bioinert implants to bioactive designs, recent research has highlighted the complex interactions between cell physiologic systems and material properties, particularly physical cues. From the cells known to interact with implanted biomaterials, the response of the immune system has been a critical target of study recently. Here, we review studies characterizing the response of innate immune cells to various material cues, particularly of those at the surface of implanted materials.The innate immune system consists of cell types with various roles in inflammation. Neutrophils and macrophages serve both phagocytic and signaling roles, especially early in the inflammatory phase of biomaterial implantation. These cell types ultimately dictate the outcome of implants as chronic inflammation, fibrosis, or integration. Other cell types like dendritic cells, mast cells, natural killer cells, and innate lymphoid cells may also serve an immunomodulatory role in the biomaterial context. This review highlights recent advances in our understanding of the role of innate immunity in the response to implantable biomaterials as well as key mechanobiological findings in innate immune cells underpinning these advances. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: This review highlights recent advances in the understanding of the role of innate immunity in the response to implantable biomaterials, especially in neutrophils and macrophages, as well as key mechanobiological findings in innate immune cells underpinning these advances. Here we discuss how physicochemical properties of biomaterials control innate immune cell behavior.

Immunomodulatory Biomaterials for Tissue Repair

All implanted biomaterials are targets of the host's immune system. While the host inflammatory response was once considered a detrimental force to be blunted or avoided, in recent years, it has become a powerful force to be leveraged to augment biomaterial-tissue integration and tissue repair. In this review, we will discuss the major immune cells that mediate the inflammatory response to biomaterials, with a focus on how biomaterials can be designed to modulate immune cell behavior to promote biomaterial-tissue integration. In particular, the intentional activation of monocytes and macrophages with controlled timing, and modulation of their interactions with other cell types involved in wound healing, have emerged as key strategies to improve biomaterial efficacy. To this end, careful design of biomaterial structure and controlled release of immunomodulators can be employed to manipulate macrophage phenotype for the maximization of the wound healing response with enhanced tissue integration and repair, as opposed to a typical foreign body response characterized by fibrous encapsulation and implant isolation. We discuss current challenges in the clinical translation of immunomodulatory biomaterials, such as limitations in the use of in vitro studies and animal models to model the human immune response. Finally, we describe future directions and opportunities for understanding and controlling the biomaterial-immune system interface, including the application of new imaging tools, new animal models, the discovery of new cellular targets, and novel techniques for in situ immune cell reprogramming.

Mechanical characterization and neutrophil NETs response of a novel hybrid geometry polydioxanone near-field electrospun scaffold

Near-field electrospinning (NFES) is a direct fiber writing sub-technique derived from traditional electrospinning (TES) by reducing the air gap distance to the magnitude of millimeters. In this paper, we demonstrate a NFES device designed from a commercial 3D printer to semi-stably write polydioxanone (PDO) microfibers. The print head was then programmed to translate in a stacking grid pattern, which resulted in a scaffold with highly aligned grid fibers that were intercalated with low density, random fibers. As the switching process can be considered random, increasing the grid size results in both a lower density of fibers in the center of each grid cell as well as a lower density of 'rebar-like' stacked fibers. These scaffolds resulted in tailorable as well as greater surface pore sizes as given by scanning electron micrographs and 3D permeability as indicated by fluorescent microsphere filtration compared to TES scaffolds of the same fiber diameter. Furthermore, ultimate tensile strength, percent elongation, yield stress, yield elongation, and Young's modulus were all tailorable compared to the static TES scaffold characterization. Lastly, the innate immune response of neutrophil extracellular traps was attenuated on NFES scaffolds compared to TES scaffolds. These results suggest that this novel NFES scaffold architecture of PDO can be highly tailored as a function of programming for a variety of biomedical and tissue engineering applications.

Human neutrophil FcγRIIIb regulates neutrophil extracellular trap release in response to electrospun polydioxanone biomaterials

During the acute inflammatory response, the release of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) is a pro-inflammatory, preconditioning event on a biomaterial surface. Therefore, regulation of NET release through biomaterial design is one strategy to enhance biomaterial-guided in situ tissue regeneration. In this study, IgG adsorption on electrospun polydioxanone biomaterials with differing fiber sizes was explored as a regulator of in vitro human neutrophil NET release. The propensity to release NETs was increased and decreased by modulating adsorbed IgG, suggesting a functional link between IgG and NET formation. Fiber-size dependent NET release was reduced by blocking FcγRIIIb, but not FcγRI, FcγRIIa, or Mac-1 (CD11b/CD18), indicating a specific receptor mediated neutrophil response. Inhibition of transforming growth factor-β-activated kinase 1 (TAK1), which is activated downstream of FcγRIIIb, significantly reduced the release of NETs in a fiber size-independent manner. These results indicate that in vitro electrospun biomaterial-induced NET release is largely regulated by IgG adsorption, engagement of FcγRIIIb, and signaling through TAK1. Modulation of this pathway may have beneficial therapeutic effects for regulating neutrophil-mediated inflammation by avoiding the adverse effects of NETs and increasing the potential for in situ tissue regeneration. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Electrospun biomaterials have great potential for in situ tissue engineering because of their versatility and biomimetic properties. However, understanding how to design the biomaterial to regulate acute inflammation, dominated by neutrophils, remains a great challenge for successful tissue integration and regeneration. In this work, we demonstrate for the first time how protein adsorption on the biomaterial surface and engagement of a specific neutrophil receptor induces intracellular signals that regulate the pro-inflammatory release of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs). Given the deleterious effects of NETs during the acute inflammatory response to a biomaterial, our work highlights the importance of considering biomaterial-neutrophil interactions on degradable and non-degradable biomaterials to achieve the desired biological outcome.

Neutrophil Extracellular Traps: Inflammation and Biomaterial Preconditioning for Tissue Engineering

Tissue injury initiates a tissue repair program, characterized by acute inflammation and recruitment of immune cells, dominated by neutrophils. Neutrophils prevent infection in the injured tissue through multiple effector functions, including the production of reactive oxygen species, the release of granules, the phagocytosis of invaders, and the extrusion of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs). However, these canonical protective mechanisms can also have detrimental effects both in the context of infection and in response to sterile injuries. Of particular interest to biomaterials and tissue engineering is the release of NETs, which are extracellular structures composed of decondensed chromatin and various toxic nuclear and granular components. These structures and their dysregulated release can cause collateral tissue damage, uncontrolled inflammation, and fibrosis and prevent the neutrophil from exerting its prohealing functions. This review discusses our knowledge of NETs, including their composition and morphology, signaling pathways, inhibitors, and contribution to inflammatory pathologies, as well as their role in the resolution of inflammation. In addition, we summarize what is known about the release of NETs as a preconditioning event in the response to biomaterials and highlight future considerations to target the neutrophil response and enhance biomaterial-guided tissue repair and regeneration. Impact statement Neutrophil extracellular trap (NET) release is an active process programmed into the neutrophil's molecular machinery to prevent infection. However, the release of NETs on biomaterials appears to be a significant preconditioning event that influences the potential for tissue healing with largely detrimental consequences. Given their contribution to inflammatory pathologies, this review highlights the role of NETs in the response to biomaterials. Together, the studies discussed in this review suggest that biomaterials should be designed to regulate NET release to avoid maladaptive immune responses and improve the therapeutic potential of tissue-engineered biomaterials and their applications in the clinical setting.

Electrospun Polydioxanone Loaded With Chloroquine Modulates Template-Induced NET Release and Inflammatory Responses From Human Neutrophils

The implantation of a biomaterial quickly initiates a tissue repair program initially characterized by a neutrophil influx. During the acute inflammatory response, neutrophils release neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) and secrete soluble signals to modulate the tissue environment. In this work, we evaluated chloroquine diphosphate, an antimalarial with immunomodulatory and antithrombotic effects, as an electrospun biomaterial additive to regulate neutrophil-mediated inflammation. Electrospinning of polydioxanone was optimized for rapid chloroquine elution within 1 h, and acute neutrophil-biomaterial interactions were evaluated in vitro with fresh human peripheral blood neutrophils at 3 and 6 h before quantifying the release of NETs and secretion of inflammatory and regenerative factors. Our results indicate that chloroquine suppresses NET release in a biomaterial surface area–dependent manner at the early time point, whereas it modulates signal secretion at both early and late time points. More specifically, chloroquine elution down-regulates interleukin 8 (IL-8) and matrix metalloproteinase nine secretion while up-regulating hepatocyte growth factor, vascular endothelial growth factor A, and IL-22 secretion, suggesting a potential shift toward a resolving neutrophil phenotype. Our novel repurposing of chloroquine as a biomaterial additive may therefore have synergistic, immunomodulatory effects that are advantageous for biomaterial-guided in situ tissue regeneration applications.

Combating Implant Infections: Shifting Focus from Bacteria to Host

The widespread use of biomaterials to support or replace body parts is increasingly threatened by the risk of implant-associated infections. In the quest for finding novel anti-infective biomaterials, there generally has been a one-sided focus on biomaterials with direct antibacterial properties, which leads to excessive use of antibacterial agents, compromised host responses, and unpredictable effectiveness in vivo. This review sheds light on how host immunomodulation, rather than only targeting bacteria, can endow biomaterials with improved anti-infective properties. How antibacterial surface treatments are at risk to be undermined by biomaterial features that dysregulate the protection normally provided by critical immune cell subsets, namely, neutrophils and macrophages, is discussed. Accordingly, how the precise modification of biomaterial surface biophysical cues, or the incorporation of immunomodulatory drug delivery systems, can render biomaterials with the necessary immune-compatible and immune-protective properties to potentiate the host defense mechanisms is reviewed. Within this context, the protective role of host defense peptides, metallic particles, quorum sensing inhibitors, and therapeutic adjuvants is discussed. The highlighted immunomodulatory strategies may lay a foundation to develop anti-infective biomaterials, while mitigating the increasing threat of antibacterial drug resistance.

Manuka Honey Reduces NETosis on an Electrospun Template Within a Therapeutic Window

Manuka honey, a topical wound treatment used to eradicate bacteria, resolve inflammation, and promote wound healing, is a focus in the tissue engineering community as a tissue template additive. However, its effect on neutrophil extracellular trap formation (NETosis) on a tissue engineering template has yet to be examined. As NETosis has been implicated in chronic inflammation and fibrosis, the reduction in this response within the wound environment is of interest. In this study, Manuka honey was incorporated into electrospun templates with large (1.7–2.2 µm) and small (0.25–0.5 µm) diameter fibers at concentrations of 0.1%, 1%, and 10%. Template pore sizes and honey release profiles were quantified, and the effect on the NETosis response of seeded human neutrophils was examined through fluorescence imaging and myeloperoxidase (MPO) analysis. The incorporation of 0.1% and 1% Manuka honey decreased NETosis on the template surface at both 3 and 6 h, while 10% honey exacerbated the NETosis response. Additionally, 0.1% and 1% Manuka honey reduced the MMP-9 release of the neutrophils at both timepoints. These data indicate a therapeutic window for Manuka honey incorporation into tissue engineering templates for the reduction in NETosis. Future in vivo experimentation should be conducted to translate these results to a physiological wound environment.

Neutrophils in Biomaterial-Guided Tissue Regeneration: Matrix Reprogramming for Angiogenesis

Biomaterial-guided in situ tissue regeneration uses biomaterials to stimulate and guide the body's endogenous, regenerative processes to drive functional tissue repair and regeneration. To be successful, cell migration into the biomaterials is essential, which requires angiogenesis to maintain cell viability. Neutrophils, the first cells responding to an implanted biomaterial, are now known to play an integral part in angiogenesis in multiple tissues and exhibit considerable potential for driving angiogenesis in the context of tissue regeneration. In terms of biomaterial-guided in situ tissue regeneration, harnessing the proangiogenic potential of the neutrophil through its robust secretion of matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9) may provide a mechanism to improve biomaterial performance by initiating matrix reprogramming. This review will discuss neutrophils as matrix reprogrammers and what is currently known about their ability to create a microenvironment that is more conducive for angiogenesis and tissue regeneration through the secretion of MMP-9. It will first review a set of ground-breaking studies in tumor biology and then present an overview of what is currently known about neutrophils and MMP-9 in biomaterial vascularization. Finally, it will conclude with potential strategies and considerations to engage neutrophils in biomaterial-guided angiogenesis and in situ tissue regeneration. Impact statement This review draws attention to a highly neglected topic in tissue engineering, the role of neutrophils in biomaterial-guided tissue regeneration and angiogenesis. Moreover, it highlights their abundant secretion of matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9) for matrix reprogramming, a topic with great potential yet to be vetted in the literature. It presents strategies and considerations for designing the next generation of immunomodulatory biomaterials. While there is literature discussing the overall role of neutrophils in angiogenesis, there are a limited number of review articles focused on this highly relevant topic in the context of biomaterial integration and tissue regeneration, making this a necessary and impactful article.

Manuka honey modulates the release profile of a dHL-60 neutrophil model under anti-inflammatory stimulation

Manuka honey, a wound treatment used to eradicate bacteria, resolve inflammation, and promote wound healing, is a current focus in the tissue engineering community as a tissue template additive. However, Manuka honey's effect on neutrophils during the inflammation-resolving phase has yet to be examined. This study investigates the effect of 0.5% and 3% Manuka honey on the release of cytokines, chemokines, and matrix-degrading enzymes from a dHL-60 neutrophil model in the presence of anti-inflammatory stimuli (TGF-β, IL-4, IL-4 +IL-13). We hypothesized that Manuka honey would reduce the output of pro-inflammatory signals and increase the release of anti-inflammatory signals. The results of this study indicate that 0.5% honey significantly increases the release of CXCL8/IL-8, CCL2/MCP-1, CCL4/MIP-1β, CCL20/MIP-3α, IL-4, IL-1ra, and FGF-13 while reducing Proteinase 3 release in the anti-inflammatory-stimulated models. However, 3% honey significantly increased the release of TNF-α and CXCL8/IL-8 while reducing the release of all other analytes. We replicated a subset of the most notable findings in primary human neutrophils, and the consistent results indicate that the HL-60 data are relevant to the performance of primary cells. These findings demonstrate the variable effects of Manuka honey on the release of cytokines, chemokines, and matrix-degrading enzymes of this model of neutrophil anti-inflammatory activity. This study reinforces the importance of tailoring the concentration of Manuka honey in a wound or tissue template to elicit the desired effects during the inflammation-resolving phase of wound healing. Future in vivo investigation should be undertaken to translate these results to a physiologically-relevant wound environment.

Bowlin G. Characterization of Polydioxanone in Near-Field Electrospinning

Electrospinning is a popular method for creating random, non-woven fibrous templates for biomedical applications, and a subtype technique termed near-field electrospinning (NFES) was devised by reducing the air gap distance to millimeters. This decreased working distance paired with precise translational motion between the fiber source and collector allows for the direct writing of fibers. We demonstrate a near-field electrospinning device designed from a MakerFarm Prusa i3v three-dimensional (3D) printer to write polydioxanone (PDO) microfibers. PDO fiber diameters were characterized over the processing parameters: Air gap, polymer concentration, translational velocity, needle gauge, and applied voltage. Fiber crystallinity and individual fiber uniformity were evaluated for the polymer concentration and translational fiber deposition velocity. Fiber stacking was evaluated for the creation of 3D templates to guide the alignment of human gingival fibroblasts. The fiber diameters correlated positively with polymer concentration, applied voltage, and needle gauge; and inversely correlated with translational velocity and air gap distance. Individual fiber diameter variability decreases, and crystallinity increases with increasing translational fiber deposition velocity. These data resulted in the creation of tailored PDO 3D templates, which guided the alignment of primary human fibroblast cells. Together, these results suggest that NFES of PDO can be scaled to create precise geometries with tailored fiber diameters for biomedical applications.

Altered processing enhances the efficacy of small-diameter silk fibroin vascular grafts

Current synthetic vascular grafts are not suitable for use in low-diameter applications. Silk fibroin is a promising natural graft material which may be an effective alternative. In this study, we compared two electrospun silk grafts with different manufacturing processes, using either water or hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP) as solvent. This resulted in markedly different Young's modulus, ultimate tensile strength and burst pressure, with HFIP spun grafts observed to have thicker fibres, and greater stiffness and strength relative to water spun. Assessment in a rat abdominal aorta grafting model showed significantly faster endothelialisation of the HFIP spun graft relative to water spun. Neointimal hyperplasia in the HFIP graft also stabilised significantly earlier, correlated with an earlier SMC phenotype switch from synthetic to contractile, increasing extracellular matrix protein density. An initial examination of the macrophage response showed that HFIP spun conduits promoted an anti-inflammatory M2 phenotype at early timepoints while reducing the pro-inflammatory M1 phenotype relative to water spun grafts. These observations demonstrate the important role of the manufacturing process and physical graft properties in determining the physiological response. Our study is the first to comprehensively study these differences for silk in a long-term rodent model.

Surface Area to Volume Ratio of Electrospun Polydioxanone Templates Regulates the Adsorption of Soluble Proteins from Human Serum

Neutrophils, the first cells that interact with surface-adsorbed proteins on biomaterials, have been increasingly recognized as critical maestros in the foreign body response for guided tissue regeneration. Recent research has shown that small diameter (SD) fibers of electrospun tissue regeneration templates, which have a high surface area to volume ratio (SAVR), enhance the release of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) compared to large diameter (LD) fibers, resulting in impaired tissue regeneration. In this study, we evaluated the adsorption of eight human serum proteins on the surface of electrospun templates to investigate how protein adsorption may regulate the release of NETs. Electrospun polydioxanone templates made from SD fibers with high SAVR and LD fibers with low SAVR, were incubated with 0.2% human serum and in situ protein adsorption was quantified with infrared-based immunodetection. Of the detected proteins, IgM and vitronectin adsorbed at low levels, suggesting that they do not play a central role in the release of NETs. Contrastingly, albumin and IgG adsorbed rapidly to the surface of the templates. One-hundred to 200 times more IgG adsorbed on the templates compared to albumin, with significantly greater adsorption occurring on the SD templates with high SAVR. Given that neutrophils express receptors that interact with IgG during phagocytosis and NET release, these results suggest that SAVR-dependent adsorption of IgG on the SD electrospun templates may contribute to the up-regulated release of NETs. Overall, this study may aid in the design of immunomodulatory biomaterials that regulate NET release and thus the potential for neutrophil-driven tissue regeneration.

A Polymorphonuclear Leukocyte Assay to Assess Implant Immunocompatibility

IMPACT STATEMENT

Polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) are essential in the first infection and host-versus-graft reactions. Strategies for adequate and standardized assays to test PMN activation by diverse types of matrices such as cardiovascular implants are urgently needed. To overcome this limitation, we established a straightforward PMN activation assay and validated lipopolysaccharide (LPS) as a reliable PMN activator that induces defined changes in surface marker expression and cytokine release. Biological "proof-of-principle" matrices demonstrated the feasibility of this PMN assay. Overall, this assay provides an instrument conducting an initial immunological assessment of biological implants prior their clinical application.

Quickening: Translational design of resorbable synthetic vascular grafts

Traditional tissue-engineered vascular grafts have yet to gain wide clinical use. The difficulty of scaling production of these cell- or biologic-based products has hindered commercialization. In situ tissue engineering bypasses such logistical challenges by using acellular resorbable scaffolds. Upon implant, the scaffolds become remodeled by host cells. This review describes the scientific and translational advantages of acellular, synthetic vascular grafts. It surveys in vivo results obtained with acellular synthetics over their fifty years of technological development. Finally, it discusses emerging principles, highlights strategic considerations for designers, and identifies questions needing additional research.

Localized Delivery of Cl-Amidine From Electrospun Polydioxanone Templates to Regulate Acute Neutrophil NETosis: A Preliminary Evaluation of the PAD4 Inhibitor for Tissue Engineering

Upon interaction, neutrophils can potentially release neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) on the surface of an implanted electrospun template, which may be a significant preconditioning event for implantable biomaterials of yet unknown consequences. In this study, we investigated the potential of polydioxanone templates as a delivery vehicle for Cl-amidine, an inhibitor of peptidyl arginase deiminase 4 (PAD4), and if drug elution could attenuate PAD4-mediated NETosis in the vicinity of implanted templates. Electrospun polydioxanone templates were fabricated with distinct architectures, small diameter (0.4 μm) or large diameter (1.8 μm) fibers, and incorporated with 0-5 mg/mL Cl-amidine to examine dose-dependent effects. Acute neutrophil-template interactions were evaluated in vitro with freshly isolated human neutrophils and in vivo with a rat subcutaneous implant model. The in vitro results suggest large diameter templates with 0 mg/mL Cl-amidine significantly attenuate NETosis compared to small diameter templates. As the drug concentration increased, NETosis was significantly decreased on small diameter templates in a dose-dependent manner. The opposite was observed for large diameter templates, indicating multiple mechanisms of NETosis may be regulating neutrophil template preconditioning. Similar results were observed in vivo, verifying local NETosis inhibition by Cl-amidine eluting templates in a physiological environment. Importantly, large diameter templates with Cl-amidine enhanced neutrophil invasion and survival, supporting the potential for long-term modulation of tissue integration and regeneration. This preliminary study demonstrates a novel delivery vehicle for Cl-amidine that can be used to regulate acute NETosis as the potential critical link between the innate immune response, inflammation, and template-guided tissue regeneration.