Regenerative Repair of Volumetric Muscle Loss Injury is Sensitive to Age

Age-associated functional healing of musculoskeletal trauma through regenerative engineering and rehabilitation

Traumatic musculoskeletal injuries that lead to volumetric muscle loss (VML) are challenged by irreparable soft tissue damage, impaired regenerative ability, and reduced muscle function. Regenerative rehabilitation strategies involving the pairing of engineered therapeutics with exercise have guided considerable advances in the functional repair of skeletal muscle following VML. However, few studies evaluate the efficacy of regenerative rehabilitation across the lifespan. In the current study, young and aged mice are treated with an engineered muscle, consisting of nanofibrillar-aligned collagen laden with myogenic cells, in combination with voluntary running activity following a VML injury. Overall, young mice perform at higher running volumes and intensities compared to aged mice but exhibit similar volumes relative to age-matched baselines. Additionally, young mice are highly responsive to the dual treatment showing enhanced force production (p < 0.001), muscle mass (p < 0.05), and vascular density (p < 0.01) compared to age-matched controls. Aged mice display upregulation of circulating inflammatory cytokines and show no significant regenerative response to treatment, suggesting a diminished efficacy of regenerative rehabilitation in aged populations. These findings highlight the restorative potential of regenerative engineering and rehabilitation for the treatment of traumatic musculoskeletal injuries in young populations and the complimentary need for age-specific interventions and studies to serve broader patient demographics.

Impact of Passaging Primary Skeletal Muscle Cell Isolates on the Engineering of Skeletal Muscle

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) is a clinical state that results in impaired skeletal muscle function. Engineered skeletal muscle can serve as a treatment for VML. Currently, large biopsies are required to achieve the cells necessary for the fabrication of engineered muscle, leading to donor-site morbidity. Amplification of cell numbers using cell passaging may increase the usefulness of a single muscle biopsy for engineering muscle tissue. In this study, we evaluated the impact of passaging cells obtained from donor muscle tissue by analyzing characteristics of in vitro cellular growth and tissue-engineered skeletal muscle unit (SMU) structure and function. Human skeletal muscle cell isolates from three separate donors (P0-Control) were compared with cells passaged once (P1), twice (P2), or three times (P3) by monitoring SMU force production and determining muscle content and structure using immunohistochemistry. Data indicated that passaging decreased the number of satellite cells and increased the population doubling time. P1 SMUs had slightly greater contractile force and P2 SMUs showed statistically significant greater force production compared with P0 SMUs with no change in SMU muscle content. In conclusion, human skeletal muscle cells can be passaged twice without negatively impacting SMU muscle content or contractile function, providing the opportunity to potentially create larger SMUs from smaller biopsies, thereby producing clinically relevant sized grafts to aid in VML repair.

Tenascin-C-enriched regeneration-specific extracellular matrix guarantees superior muscle regeneration in Ambystoma mexicanum

Severe muscle injury causes distress and difficulty in humans. Studying the high regenerative ability of the axolotls may provide hints for the development of an effective treatment for severe injuries to muscle tissue. Here, we examined the regenerative process in response to a muscle injury in axolotls. We found that axolotls are capable of complete regeneration in response to a partial muscle resection called volumetric muscle loss (VML), which mammals cannot perfectly regenerate. We investigated the mechanisms underlying this high regenerative capacity in response to VML, focusing on the migration of muscle satellite cells and the extracellular matrix (ECM) formed during VML injury. Axolotls form tenascin-C (TN-C)-enriched ECM after VML injury. This TN-C-enriched ECM promotes the satellite cell migration. We confirmed the importance of TN-C in successful axolotl muscle regeneration by creating TN-C mutant animals. Our results suggest that the maintenance of a TN-C-enriched ECM environment after muscle injury promotes the release of muscle satellite cells and supports eventually high muscle regenerative capacity. In the future, better muscle regeneration may be achieved in mammals through the maintenance of TN-C expression.

Local IL-10 delivery modulates the immune response and enhances repair of volumetric muscle loss muscle injury

This study was designed to test the hypothesis that in addition to repairing the architectural and cellular cues via regenerative medicine, the delivery of immune cues (immunotherapy) may be needed to enhance regeneration following volumetric muscle loss (VML) injury. We identified IL-10 signaling as a promising immunotherapeutic target. To explore the impact of targeting IL-10 signaling, tibialis anterior (TA) VML injuries were created and then treated in rats using autologous minced muscle (MM). Animals received either recombinant rat IL-10 or phosphate buffered saline (PBS) controls injections at the site of VML repair beginning 7 days post injury (DPI) and continuing every other day (4 injections total) until 14 DPI. At 56 DPI (study endpoint), significant improvements to TA contractile torque (82% of uninjured values & 170% of PBS values), TA mass, and myofiber size in response to IL-10 treatment were detected. Whole transcriptome analysis at 14 DPI revealed activation of IL-10 signaling, muscle hypertrophy, and lymphocytes signaling pathways. Expression of ST2, a regulatory T (T_reg) cell receptor, was dramatically increased at the VML repair site in response to IL-10 treatment when compared to PBS controls. The findings suggest that the positive effect of delayed IL-10 delivery might be due to immuno-suppressive T_reg cell recruitment.

Extracellular vesicle-derived miRNAs improve stem cell-based therapeutic approaches in muscle wasting conditions

Skeletal muscle holds an intrinsic capability of growth and regeneration both in physiological conditions and in case of injury. Chronic muscle illnesses, generally caused by genetic and acquired factors, lead to deconditioning of the skeletal muscle structure and function, and are associated with a significant loss in muscle mass. At the same time, progressive muscle wasting is a hallmark of aging. Given the paracrine properties of myogenic stem cells, extracellular vesicle-derived signals have been studied for their potential implication in both the pathogenesis of degenerative neuromuscular diseases and as a possible therapeutic target. In this study, we screened the content of extracellular vesicles from animal models of muscle hypertrophy and muscle wasting associated with chronic disease and aging. Analysis of the transcriptome, protein cargo, and microRNAs (miRNAs) allowed us to identify a hypertrophic miRNA signature amenable for targeting muscle wasting, consisting of miR-1 and miR-208a. We tested this signature among others in vitro on mesoangioblasts (MABs), vessel-associated adult stem cells, and we observed an increase in the efficiency of myogenic differentiation. Furthermore, injections of miRNA-treated MABs in aged mice resulted in an improvement in skeletal muscle features, such as muscle weight, strength, cross-sectional area, and fibrosis compared to controls. Overall, we provide evidence that the extracellular vesicle-derived miRNA signature we identified enhances the myogenic potential of myogenic stem cells.

Temporal changes in the muscle extracellular matrix due to volumetric muscle loss injury

PURPOSE/AIM

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) is a devastating orthopedic injury resulting in chronic persistent functional deficits, loss of joint range of motion, pathologic fibrotic deposition and lifelong disability. However, there is only limited mechanistic understanding of VML-induced fibrosis. Herein we examined the temporal changes in the fibrotic deposition at 3, 7, 14, 28, and 48 days post-VML injury.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Adult male Lewis rats (n = 39) underwent a full thickness ~20% (~85 mg) VML injury to the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle unilaterally, the contralateral TA muscle served as the control group. All TA muscles were harvested for biochemical and histologic evaluation.

RESULTS

The ratio of collagen I/III was decreased at 3, 7, and 14 days post-VML, but significantly increased at 48 days. Decorin content followed an opposite trend, significantly increasing by day 3 before dropping to below control levels by 48 days. Histological evaluation of the defect area indicates a shift from loosely packed collagen at early time points post-VML, to a densely packed fibrotic scar by 48 days.

CONCLUSIONS

The shift from early wound healing efforts to a fibrotic scar with densely packed collagen within the skeletal muscle occurs around 21 days after VML injury through dogmatic synchronous reduction of collagen III and increase in collagen I. Thus, there appears to be an early window for therapeutic intervention to prevent pathologic fibrous tissue formation, potentially by targeting CCN2/CTGF or using decorin as a therapeutic.

Epimorphic regeneration of the mouse digit tip is finite

Background

Structural regeneration of amputated appendages by blastema-mediated, epimorphic regeneration is a process whose mechanisms are beginning to be employed for inducing regeneration. While epimorphic regeneration is classically studied in non-amniote vertebrates such as salamanders, mammals also possess a limited ability for epimorphic regeneration, best exemplified by the regeneration of the distal mouse digit tip. A fundamental, but still unresolved question is whether epimorphic regeneration and blastema formation is exhaustible, similar to the finite limits of stem-cell mediated tissue regeneration.

Methods

In this study, distal mouse digits were amputated, allowed to regenerate and then repeatedly amputated. To quantify the extent and patterning of the regenerated digit, the digit bone as the most prominent regenerating element in the mouse digit was followed by in vivo µCT.

Results

Analyses revealed that digit regeneration is indeed progressively attenuated, beginning after the second regeneration cycle, but that the pattern is faithfully restored until the end of the fourth regeneration cycle. Surprisingly, when unamputated digits in the vicinity of repeatedly amputated digits were themselves amputated, these new amputations also exhibited a similarly attenuated regeneration response, suggesting a systemic component to the amputation injury response.

Conclusions

In sum, these data suggest that epimorphic regeneration in mammals is finite and due to the exhaustion of the proliferation and differentiation capacity of the blastema cell source.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13287-022-02741-2.

Nandrolone supplementation does not improve functional recovery in an aged animal model of volumetric muscle loss injury

Aging hinders the effectiveness of regenerative medicine strategies targeting the repair of volumetric muscle loss (VML) injury. Anabolic steroids have been shown to improve several factors which contribute to the age-related decline in muscle's regenerative capacity. In this study, the impact of exogenous nandrolone decanoate (ND) administration on the effectiveness of a VML regenerative repair strategy was explored using an aged animal model. Unilateral tibialis anterior VML injuries were repaired in 18-month-aged animal models (male Fischer 344 rat) using decellularized human skeletal muscle scaffolds supplemented with autologous minced muscle. The contralateral limb was left untreated/uninjured. Following repair, ND(+) or a carrier control (ND-) was delivered via weekly injection for a period of 8 weeks. At 8 weeks, muscle isometric torque, gene expression, and tissue structure were assessed. ND(+) treatment did not improve contractile torque recovery following VML repair when compared to carrier only ND(-) injection controls. Peak isometric torque in the ND(+) VML repair group remained significantly below contralateral uninjured control values (4.69 ± 1.18vs. 7.46 ± 1.53 N mm/kg) and was statistically indistinguishable from carrier only ND(-) VML repair controls (4.47 ± 1.18 N mm/kg). Gene expression for key myogenic genes (Pax7, MyoD, MyoG, IGF-1) were not significantly elevated in response to ND injection, suggesting continued age related myogenic impairment even in the presence of ND(+) treatment. ND injection did reduce the histological appearance of fibrosis at the site of VML repair, and increased expression of the collagen III gene, suggesting some positive effects on repair site matrix regulation. Overall, the results presented in this study suggest that a decline in regenerative capacity with aging may present an obstacle to regenerative medicine strategies targeting VML injury and that the delivery of anabolic stimuli via ND administration was unable to overcome this decline.

Repairing Volumetric Muscle Loss in the Ovine Peroneus Tertius Following a 6-Month Recovery

Tissue-engineered skeletal muscle is a promising novel therapy for the treatment of volumetric muscle loss (VML). Our laboratory has developed tissue-engineered skeletal muscle units (SMUs) and engineered neural conduits (ENCs), and modularly scaled them to clinically relevant sizes for the treatment of VML in a large animal (sheep) model. In a previous study, we evaluated the effects of the SMUs and ENCs in treating a 30% VML injury in the ovine peroneus tertius muscle after a 3-month recovery period. The goal of the current study was to expand on our 3-month study and evaluate the SMUs and ENCs in restoring muscle function after a 6-month recovery period. Six months after implantation, we found that the repair groups with the SMU (VML+SMU and VML+SMU+ENC) restored muscle mass to a level that was statistically indistinguishable from the uninjured contralateral muscle. In contrast, the muscle mass in the VML-Only group was significantly less than groups repaired with an SMU. Following the 6-month recovery from VML, the maximum tetanic force was significantly lower for all VML injured groups compared to the uninjured contralateral muscle. However, we did demonstrate the ability of our ENCs to effectively regenerate nerve between the distal stump of the native nerve and the repair site in 93% of the animals.

Advanced Glycation End Products Are Retained in Decellularized Muscle Matrix Derived from Aged Skeletal Muscle

Decellularized tissues are biocompatible materials that engraft well, but the age of their source has not been explored for clinical translation. Advanced glycation end products (AGEs) are chemical cross-links that accrue on skeletal muscle collagen in old age, stiffening the matrix and increasing inflammation. Whether decellularized biomaterials derived from aged muscle would suffer from increased AGE collagen cross-links is unknown. We characterized gastrocnemii of 1-, 2-, and 20-month-old C57BL/6J mice before and after decellularization to determine age-dependent changes to collagen stiffness and AGE cross-linking. Total and soluble collagen was measured to assess if age-dependent increases in collagen and cross-linking persisted in decellularized muscle matrix (DMM). Stiffness of aged DMM was determined using atomic force microscopy. AGE levels and the effect of an AGE cross-link breaker, ALT-711, were tested in DMM samples. Our results show that age-dependent increases in collagen amount, cross-linking, and general stiffness were observed in DMM. Notably, we measured increased AGE-specific cross-links within old muscle, and observed that old DMM retained AGE cross-links using ALT-711 to reduce AGE levels. In conclusion, deleterious age-dependent modifications to collagen are present in DMM from old muscle, implying that age matters when sourcing skeletal muscle extracellular matrix as a biomaterial.

Administration of a selective retinoic acid receptor-γ agonist improves neuromuscular strength in a rodent model of volumetric muscle loss

PURPOSE

Volumetric muscle loss is a uniquely challenging pathology that results in irrecoverable functional deficits. Furthermore, a breakthrough drug or bioactive factor has yet to be established that adequately improves repair of these severe skeletal muscle injuries. This study sought to assess the ability of an orally administered selective retinoic acid receptor-γ agonist, palovarotene, to improve recovery of neuromuscular strength in a rat model of volumetric muscle loss.

METHODS

An irrecoverable, full thickness defect was created in the tibialis anterior muscle of Lewis rats and animals were survived for 4 weeks. Functional recovery of the tibialis anterior muscle was assessed in vivo via neural stimulation and determination of peak isometric torque. Histological staining was performed to qualitatively assess fibrous scarring of the defect site.

RESULTS

Treatment with the selective retinoic acid receptor-γ agonist, palovarotene, resulted in a 38% improvement of peak isometric torque in volumetric muscle loss affected limbs after 4 weeks of healing compared to untreated controls. Additionally, preliminary histological assessment suggests that oral administration of palovarotene reduced fibrous scarring at the defect site.

CONCLUSIONS

These results highlight the potential role of selective retinoic acid receptor-γ agonists in the design of regenerative medicine platforms to maximize skeletal muscle healing. Additional studies are needed to further elucidate cellular responses, optimize therapeutic delivery, and characterize synergistic potential with adjunct therapies.

Immunomodulation and Biomaterials: Key Players to Repair Volumetric Muscle Loss

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) is defined as a condition in which a large volume of skeletal muscle is lost due to physical insult. VML often results in a heightened immune response, resulting in significant long-term functional impairment. Estimates indicate that ~250,000 fractures occur in the US alone that involve VML. Currently, there is no active treatment to fully recover or repair muscle loss in VML patients. The health economics burden due to VML is rapidly increasing around the world. Immunologists, developmental biologists, and muscle pathophysiologists are exploring both immune responses and biomaterials to meet this challenging situation. The inflammatory response in muscle injury involves a non-specific inflammatory response at the injured site that is coordination between the immune system, especially macrophages and muscle. The potential role of biomaterials in the regenerative process of skeletal muscle injury is currently an important topic. To this end, cell therapy holds great promise for the regeneration of damaged muscle following VML. However, the delivery of cells into the injured muscle site poses a major challenge as it might cause an adverse immune response or inflammation. To overcome this obstacle, in recent years various biomaterials with diverse physical and chemical nature have been developed and verified for the treatment of various muscle injuries. These biomaterials, with desired tunable physicochemical properties, can be used in combination with stem cells and growth factors to repair VML. In the current review, we focus on how various immune cells, in conjunction with biomaterials, can be used to promote muscle regeneration and, most importantly, suppress VML pathology.

Mini review: Biomaterials in repair and regeneration of nerve in a volumetric muscle loss

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) following a severe trauma or injury is beyond the intrinsic regenerative capacity of muscle tissues, and hence interventional therapy is required. Extensive muscle loss concomitant with damage to neuromuscular components overwhelms the muscles' remarkable regenerative capacity. The loss of nervous and vascular tissue leads to further damage and atrophy, so a combined treatment for neuromuscular junction (NMJ) along with the volumetric muscle regeneration is important. There have been immense advances in the field of tissue engineering for skeletal muscle tissue and peripheral nerve regeneration, but very few address the interdependence of the tissues and the need for combined therapies to repair and regenerate fully functional muscle tissue. This review addresses the problem and presents an overview of the biomaterials that have been studied for tissue engineering of neuromuscular tissues associated with skeletal muscles.

The effect of autologous repair and voluntary wheel running on force recovery in a rat model of volumetric muscle loss

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? Following large traumatic loss of muscle tissue (volumetric muscle loss; VML), permanent functional and cosmetic deficits present themselves and regenerative therapies alone have not been able to generate a robust regenerative response: how does the addition of rehabilitative therapies affects the regenerative response? What is the main finding and its importance? Using exercise along with autologous muscle repair, we demonstrated accelerated muscle force recovery response post-VML. The accentuated force recovery 2 weeks post-VML would allow patients to return home sooner than allowed with current therapies.

ABSTRACT

Skeletal muscle can regenerate from damage but is overwhelmed with extreme tissue loss, known as volumetric muscle loss (VML). Patients suffering from VML do not fully recover force output in the affected limb. Recent studies show that replacement tissue (i.e., autograph) into the VML defect site plus physical activity show promise for optimizing force recovery post-VML. The purpose of this study was to measure the effects of autologous repair and voluntary wheel running on force recovery post-VML. Thirty-two male Sprague-Dawley rats had 20% of their left tibialis anterior (LTA) excised then replaced and sutured into the intact muscle (autologous repair). The right tibialis anterior (RTA) acted as the contralateral control. Sixteen rats were given free access to a running wheel (Wheel) whereas the other 16 remained in a cage with the running wheel locked (Sed). At 2 and 8 weeks post-VML, the LTA underwent force testing; then the muscle was removed and morphological and gene expression analysis was conducted. At 2 weeks post-injury, normalized LTA force was 58% greater in the Wheel group compared to the Sed group. At 8 weeks post-VML, LTA force was similar between the Wheel and Sed groups but was still lower than the uninjured RTA. Gene expression analysis at 2 weeks post-VML showed the wheel groups had lower mRNA content of interleukin (IL)-1β, IL-6 and tumour necrosis factor α compared to the Sed group. Overall, voluntary wheel running promoted early force recovery, but was not sufficient to fully restore force. The accentuated early force recovery is possibly due to a more pro-regenerative microenvironment.

New Surgical Model for Bone-Muscle Injury Reveals Age and Gender-Related Healing Patterns in the 5 Lipoxygenase (5LO) Knockout Mouse

Signaling lipid mediators released from 5 lipoxygenase (5LO) pathways influence both bone and muscle cells, interfering in their proliferation and differentiation capacities. A major limitation to studying inflammatory signaling pathways in bone and muscle healing is the inadequacy of available animal models. We developed a surgical injury model in the vastus lateralis (VL) muscle and femur in 129/SvEv littermates mice to study simultaneous musculoskeletal (MSK) healing in male and female, young (3 months) and aged (18 months) WT mice compared to mice lacking 5LO (5LOKO). MSK defects were surgically created using a 1-mm punch device in the VA muscle followed by a 0.5-mm round defect in the femur. After days 7 and 14 post-surgery, the specimens were removed for microtomography (microCT), histopathology, and immunohistochemistry analyses. In addition, non-injured control skeletal muscles along with femur and L5 vertebrae were analyzed. Bones were microCT phenotyped, revealing that aged female WT mice presented reduced BV/TV and trabecular parameters compared to aged males and aged female 5LOKO mice. Skeletal muscles underwent a customized targeted lipidomics investigation for profiling and quantification of lipid signaling mediators (LMs), evidencing age, and gender related-differences in aged female 5LOKO mice compared to matched WT. Histological analysis revealed a suitable bone-healing process with osteoid deposition at day 7 post-surgery, followed by woven bone at day 14 post-surgery, observed in all young mice. Aged WT females displayed increased inflammatory response at day 7 post-surgery, delayed bone matrix maturation, and increased TRAP immunolabeling at day 14 post-surgery compared to 5LOKO females. Skeletal muscles of aged animals showed higher levels of inflammation in comparison to young controls at day 14 post-surgery; however, inflammatory process was attenuated in aged 5LOKO mice compared to aged WT. In conclusion, this new model shows that MSK healing is influenced by age, gender, and the 5LO pathway, which might serve as a potential target to investigate therapeutic interventions and age-related MSK diseases. Our new model is suitable for bone-muscle crosstalk studies.