Chromosomal imbalances and DNA amplifications in SV40 large T antigen-induced primitive neuroectodermal tumor cell lines of the rat

Karyotype alteration generates the neoplastic phenotypes of SV40-infected human and rodent cells

BACKGROUND

Despite over 50 years of research, it remains unclear how the DNA tumor viruses SV40 and Polyoma cause cancers. Prevailing theories hold that virus-coded Tumor (T)-antigens cause cancer by inactivating cellular tumor suppressor genes. But these theories don't explain four characteristics of viral carcinogenesis: (1) less than one in 10,000 infected cells become cancer cells, (2) cancers have complex individual phenotypes and transcriptomes, (3) recurrent tumors without viral DNA and proteins, (4) preneoplastic aneuploidies and immortal neoplastic clones with individual karyotypes.

RESULTS

As an alternative theory we propose that viral carcinogenesis is a form of speciation, initiated by virus-induced aneuploidy. Since aneuploidy destabilizes the karyotype by unbalancing thousands of genes it catalyzes chain reactions of karyotypic and transcriptomic evolutions. Eventually rare karyotypes evolve that encode cancer-specific autonomy of growth. The low probability of forming new autonomous cancer-species by random karyotypic and transcriptomic variations predicts individual and clonal cancers. Although cancer karyotypes are congenitally aneuploid and thus variable, they are stabilized or immortalized by selections for variants with cancer-specific autonomy. Owing to these inherent variations cancer karyotypes are heterogeneous within clonal margins. To test this theory we analyzed karyotypes and phenotypes of SV40-infected human, rat and mouse cells developing into neoplastic clones. In all three systems we found (1) preneoplastic aneuploidies, (2) neoplastic clones with individual clonal but flexible karyotypes and phenotypes, which arose from less than one in 10,000 infected cells, survived over 200 generations, but were either T-antigen positive or negative, (3) spontaneous and drug-induced variations of neoplastic phenotypes correlating 1-to-1 with karyotypic variations.

CONCLUSIONS

Since all 14 virus-induced neoplastic clones tested contained individual clonal karyotypes and phenotypes, we conclude that these karyotypes have generated and since maintained these neoplastic clones. Thus SV40 causes cancer indirectly, like carcinogens, by inducing aneuploidy from which new cancer-specific karyotypes evolve automatically at low rates. This theory explains the (1) low probability of carcinogenesis per virus-infected cell, (2) the individuality and clonal flexibility of cancer karyotypes, (3) recurrence of neoplasias without viral T-antigens, and (4) the individual clonal karyotypes, transcriptomes and immortality of virus-induced neoplasias - all unexplained by current viral theories.

Nuclear IRS-1 and cancer

The family of insulin receptor substrates (IRS) consists of four proteins (IRS-1-IRS-4), which were initially characterized as typical cytosolic adaptor proteins involved in insulin receptor (IR) and insulin-like growth factor I receptor (IGF-IR) signaling. The first cloned and characterized member of the IRS family, IRS-1, has a predicted molecular weight of 132 kDa, however, as a result of its extensive serine phosphorylation it separates on a SDS gel as a band of approximately 160-185 kDa. In addition to its metabolic and growth-promoting functions, IRS-1 is also suspected to play a role in malignant transformation. The mechanism by which IRS-1 supports tumor growth is not fully understood, and the argument that IRS-1 merely amplifies the signal from the IGF-1R and/or IR requires further investigation. Almost a decade ago, we reported the presence of nuclear IRS-1 in medulloblastoma clinical samples, which express viral oncoprotein, large T-antigen of human polyomavirus JC (JCV T-antigen). This first demonstration of nuclear IRS-1 was confirmed by several other laboratories. Nuclear IRS-1 was also detected by cells expressing the SV40 T-antigen, v-Src, in immortalized fibroblasts stimulated with IGF-I, in hepatocytes, 32D cells, and in an osteosarcoma cell line. More recently, nuclear IRS-1 was detected in breast cancer cells in association with estrogen receptor alpha (ERα), and in JC virus negative medulloblastoma cells expressing estrogen receptor beta (ERβ), further implicating nuclear IRS-1 in cellular transformation. Here, we discuss how nuclear IRS-1 acting on DNA repair fidelity, transcriptional activity, and cell growth can support tumor development and progression.

The role of viral and bacterial pathogens in gastrointestinal cancer

The association of Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori) with gastric cancer is thus far the best understood model to comprehend the causal relationship between a microbial pathogen and cancer in the human gastrointestinal tract. Besides H. pylori, a variety of other pathogens are now being recognized as potential carcinogens in different settings of human cancer. In this context, viral causes of human cancers are central to the issue since these account for 10-20% of cancers worldwide. In the case of H. pylori and gastric cancer, as well as the human papillomavirus and anal cancer, the causal relationship between the infectious agent and the related cancer in the gastrointestinal tract has been clearly confirmed by epidemiological and experimental studies. Similarly, Epstein-Barr virus and the oncogenic JC virus are being suggested as possible causative agents for cancers in the upper and lower gastrointestinal tract. This review discusses various viral and microbial pathogens and their oncogenic properties in the evolution of gastrointestinal carcinogenesis and summarizes the available experimental data make a convincing agreement favoring the associations between infectious agents and specific human cancers.

IRS-1-Rad51 nuclear interaction sensitizes JCV T-antigen positive medulloblastoma cells to genotoxic treatment

The large T-antigen from human polyomavirus JC (JCV T-antigen) is suspected to play a role in malignant transformation. Previously, we reported that JCV T-antigen requires the presence of a functional insulin-like growth factor I receptor (IGF-IR) for transformation of fibroblasts and for survival of medulloblastoma cell lines; that IGF-IR is phosphorylated in medulloblastoma biopsies and that JCV T-antigen inhibits homologous recombination-directed DNA repair, causing accumulation of mutations. Here we are evaluating whether JCV T-antigen positive and negative mouse medulloblastoma cell lines, which significantly differ in their tumorigenic properties, are also different in their abilities to repair double strand breaks of DNA (DSBs). Our results show that despite much stronger tumorigenic potential, JCV T-antigen positive medulloblastoma cells are more sensitive to genotoxic agents (cisplatin and gamma-irradiation). Subsequent analysis of DNA repair of DSBs indicated that homologous recombination-directed DNA repair (HRR) was selectively attenuated in JCV T-antigen positive medulloblastoma cells. JCV T-antigen did not affect HRR directly. In the presence of JCV T-antigen, insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS-1) translocated to the nucleus where it co-localized with Rad51, possibly attenuating HRR.

T-antigen of the human polyomavirus JC attenuates faithful DNA repair by forcing nuclear interaction between IRS-1 and Rad51

JC polyomavirus (JCV), which infects 90% of the human population, is detectable in human tumors. Its early protein, JCV T-antigen, transforms cells in vitro and is tumorigenic in experimental animals. Although T-antigen-mediated transformation involves genetic alterations of the affected cells, the mechanism underlying this genomic instability is not known. We show that JCV T-antigen inhibits homologous recombination DNA repair (HRR), which results in an accumulation of mutations. T-antigen does not operate directly but utilizes a cytosolic molecule, insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS-1). Following T-antigen-mediated nuclear translocation, IRS-1 binds Rad51 at the site of damaged DNA. This T-antigen-mediated inhibition of HRR does not function in cells lacking IRS-1, and can be reproduced in the absence of T-antigen by IRS-1 with artificial nuclear localization signal. Our observations define a new mechanism by which viral protein utilizes cytosolic molecule to inhibit faithful DNA repair, and suggest how polyomaviruses could compromise stability of the genome. (c) 2005 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

JC virus large T-antigen and IGF-I signaling system merge to affect DNA repair and genomic integrity

The progression of cancer is often associated with genomic instability, which may develop as a result of compromised defense mechanisms responsible for the maintenance of chromosomal integrity. These include defects in telomere preservation, chromosomal segregation, and DNA repair. In this review, we discuss molecular interactions between viral and cellular signaling components, which interfere with DNA repair mechanisms, and possibly contribute to the development of a mutagenic phenotype. Our studies indicate that large T-antigen from the human polyomavirus JC (JCV T-antigen) inhibits homologous recombination directed DNA repair (HRR)-causing accumulation of mutations in the affected cells (JCP 2005, in press). Surprisingly, T-antigen does not operate directly, but utilizes insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS-1), which is the major signaling molecule for insulin-like growth factor I receptor (IGF-IR). Following T-antigen-mediated nuclear translocation, IRS-1 binds Rad51 at the site of damaged DNA. This T-antigen-mediated inhibition of HRR does not function in cells lacking IRS-1, and can be reproduced in the absence of T-antigen by IRS-1 with an artificial nuclear localization signal. The interplay described between the IGF-IR signaling system and JCV T-antigen in the process of DNA repair could be relevant, since nearly 90% of the human population is seropositive for JC virus, JCV T-antigen transforms cells in vitro, is tumorigenic in experimental animals, and the presence of JC virus has been shown in an increasing number of biopsies of human cancer.

Expression of human neurotropic polyomavirus JCV late gene product agnoprotein in human medulloblastoma

BACKGROUND

The human neurotropic polyomavirus, JCV, contains an open reading frame within the late region of the viral genome that encodes a 71-amino-acid protein, agnoprotein. Because accumulating evidence supports an association between JCV infection and human brain tumors, including medulloblastomas, we assessed the presence of JCV Agno gene sequences and the expression of agnoprotein in a series of 20 well-characterized medulloblastomas.

METHODS

Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tumor tissue samples were used for Agno gene amplification and for immunohistochemical analysis. Adjacent sections were stained with an antibody to agnoprotein and with antibodies to cellular structural and regulatory proteins, including the JCV early gene product, T antigen.

RESULTS

Analysis of amplified DNA from paraffin-embedded samples revealed the presence of the Agno gene in 11 (69%) of 16 samples. Immunohistochemical analysis showed cytoplasmic localization and widespread distribution of agnoprotein in the neoplastic cells in 11 (55%) of 20 samples. The JCV early gene product, T antigen, was present in the nucleus of some, but not all, of the neoplastic cells. Some medulloblastoma samples that expressed agnoprotein had no sign of T-antigen expression. p53 was detected in only six of the 11 tumors in which agnoprotein was expressed. None of the 20 samples showed expression of the viral late capsid proteins, ruling out productive infection of the tumor cells with JCV.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data provide evidence that the JCV late gene encoding the auxiliary agnoprotein is expressed in tumor cells. The finding of agnoprotein expression in the absence of T-antigen expression suggests a potential role for agnoprotein in pathways involved in the development of JCV-associated medulloblastomas.

Identification of amplified genes from SV40 large T antigen-induced rat PNET cell lines by subtractive cDNA analysis and radiation hybrid mapping

Primitive neuroectodermal tumors (PNETs) such as human medulloblastomas are genetically heterogeneous and therefore poorly understood. In a rat model the SV40 large T antigen was used to induce neoplasms with characteristic features of PNETs. Tumor development requires a latency period of 8-11 months implicating secondary genetic alterations. To identify such secondary alterations we performed comparative analyses of two phenotypically identical PNET-derived cell lines. Indeed, these cell lines displayed distinct high-level amplification sites. Using a combination of subtractive cDNA analysis and radiation hybrid mapping we have now identified genes in the amplicon regions of the two cell lines. Interestingly, one of these genes encodes the rat homolog of a cytosolic branched chain aminotransferase (BCAT(C)) previously shown to be amplified in a mouse teratocarcinoma cell line. We propose that this simple cloning strategy may serve as a powerful tool for the isolation of genes implicated in known chromosomal aberrations in primary tumors and tumor cell lines.

Lens epithelial cells derived from alphaB-crystallin knockout mice demonstrate hyperproliferation and genomic instability

alphaB-crystallin is a member of the small heat shock protein family and can act as a molecular chaperone preventing the in vitro aggregation of other proteins denatured by heat or other stress conditions. Expression of alphaB-crystallin increases in cells exposed to stress and enhanced in tumors of neuroectodermal origin and in many neurodegenerative diseases. In the present study, we examined the properties of lens epithelial cells derived from mice in which the alphaB-crystallin gene had been knocked out. Primary rodent cells immortalize spontaneously in tissue culture with a frequency of 10(-5) to 10(-6). Primary lens epithelial cells derived from alphaB-crystallin-/- mice produced hyperproliferative clones at a frequency of 7.6 x 10(-2), four orders of magnitude greater than predicted by spontaneous immortalization (1). Hyperproliferative alphaB-crystallin-/- cells were shown to be truly immortal since they have been passaged for more than 100 population doublings without any diminution in growth potential. In striking contrast to the wild-type cells, which were diploid, the alphaB-crystallin-/- cultures had a high proportion of tetraploid and higher ploidy cells, indicating that the loss of alphaB-crystallin is associated with an increase in genomic instability. Further evidence of genomic instability of alphaB-crystallin-/- cells was observed when primary cultures were infected with Ad12-SV40 hybrid virus. In striking contrast to wild-type cells, alphaB-crystallin-/- cells expressing SV40 T antigen exhibited a widespread cytocidal response 2 to 3 days after attaining confluence, indicating that SV40 T antigen enhanced the intrinsic genomic instability of alphaB-crystallin-/- lens epithelial cells. These observations suggest that the widely distributed molecular chaperone alphaB-crystallin may play an important nuclear role in maintaining genomic integrity.