Mutants affecting processing of DNA in macronuclear development in paramecium

One Cell, Two Gears: Extensive Somatic Genome Plasticity Accompanies High Germline Genome Stability in Paramecium

Mutation accumulation (MA) experiments are conventionally employed to study spontaneous germline mutations. However, MA experiments can also shed light on somatic genome plasticity in a habitual and genetic drift-maximizing environment. Here, we revisit an MA experiment that uncovered extraordinary germline genome stability in Paramecium tetraurelia, a single-celled eukaryote with nuclear dimorphism. Our re-examination of isogenic P. tetraurelia MA lines propagated in nutrient-rich medium for >40 sexual cycles reveals that their polyploid somatic genome accrued hundreds of intervening DNA segments (IESs), which are normally eliminated during germline-soma differentiation. These IESs frequently occupy a fraction of the somatic DNA copies of a given locus, producing IES excision/retention polymorphisms, and preferentially fall into a class of epigenetically controlled sequences. Relative to control lines, retained IESs are flanked by stronger cis-acting signals and interrupt an excess of highly expressed coding exons. These findings suggest that P. tetraurelia’s elevated germline DNA replication fidelity is associated with pervasive somatic genome plasticity. They show that MA regimes are powerful tools for investigating the role that developmental plasticity, somatic mutations, and epimutations have in ecology and evolution.

What's Genetic Variation Got to Do with It? Starvation-Induced Self-Fertilization Enhances Survival in Paramecium

The pervasiveness of sex despite its well-known costs is a long-standing puzzle in evolutionary biology. Current explanations for the success of sex in nature largely rely on the adaptive significance of the new or rare genotypes that sex may generate. Less explored is the possibility that sex-underlying molecular mechanisms can enhance fitness and convey benefits to the individuals that bear the immediate costs of sex. Here, we show that the molecular environment associated with self-fertilization can increase stress resistance in the ciliate Paramecium tetraurelia. This advantage is independent of new genetic variation, coupled with a reduced nutritional input, and offers fresh insights into the mechanistic origin of sex. In addition to providing evidence that the molecular underpinnings of sexual reproduction and the stress response are linked in P. tetraurelia, these findings supply an integrative explanation for the persistence of self-fertilization in this ciliate.

Environmentally induced plasticity of programmed DNA elimination boosts somatic variability in Paramecium tetraurelia

Can ecological changes impact somatic genome development? Efforts to resolve this question could reveal a direct link between environmental changes and somatic variability, potentially illuminating our understanding of how variation can surface from a single genotype under stress. Here, we tackle this question by leveraging the biological properties of ciliates. When Paramecium tetraurelia reproduces sexually, its polyploid somatic genome regenerates from the germline genome through a developmental process that involves the removal of thousands of ORF-interrupting sequences known as internal eliminated sequences (IESs). We show that exposure to nonstandard culture temperatures impacts the efficiency of this process of programmed DNA elimination, prompting the emergence of hundreds of incompletely excised IESs in the newly developed somatic genome. These alternative DNA isoforms display a patterned genomic topography, impact gene expression, and might be inherited transgenerationally. On this basis, we conclude that environmentally induced developmental thermoplasticity contributes to genotypic diversification in Paramecium.

Loss of a Fragile Chromosome Region leads to the Screwy Phenotype in Paramecium tetraurelia

A conspicuous cell-shape phenotype known as “screwy” was reported to result from mutations at two or three uncharacterized loci in the ciliate Paramecium tetraurelia. Here, we describe a new screwy mutation, Spinning Top, which appeared spontaneously in the cross of an unrelated mutant with reference strain 51. The macronuclear (MAC) genome of the Spinning Top mutant is shown to lack a ~28.5-kb segment containing 18 genes at the end of one chromosome, which appears to result from a collinear deletion in the micronuclear (MIC) genome. We tested several candidate genes from the deleted locus by dsRNA-induced silencing in wild-type cells, and identified a single gene responsible for the phenotype. This gene, named Spade, encodes a 566-aa glutamine-rich protein with a C₂HC zinc finger. Its silencing leads to a fast phenotype switch during vegetative growth, but cells recover a wild-type phenotype only 5–6 divisions after silencing is stopped. We analyzed 5 independently-obtained mutant alleles of the Sc1 locus, and concluded that all of them also lack the Spade gene and a number of neighboring genes in the MAC and MIC genomes. Mapping of the MAC deletion breakpoints revealed two different positions among the 5 alleles, both of which differ from the Spinning Top breakpoint. These results suggest that this MIC chromosome region is intrinsically unstable in strain 51.

Epigenetic control of chromosome breakage at the 5' end of Paramecium tetraurelia gene A

Macronuclei and micronuclei of ciliates have related genomes, with macronuclei developing from zygotic micronuclei through programmed DNA rearrangements. While Paramecium tetraurelia wild-type strain 51 and mutant strain d48 have the same micronuclear genome, qualitative differences between their macronuclear genomes have been described, demonstrating that programmed DNA rearrangements could be epigenetically controlled in ciliates. Macronuclear chromosomes end downstream of gene A (A51 Mac ends) and at the 5' end of gene A (Ad48 Mac ends) in strains 51 and d48, respectively. To gain further insight into the process of chromosome end formation, we performed an extensive analysis of locus A rearrangement in strains d48 and 51, in strain d12, which harbors a gene A deletion, and in interstrain cross progeny. We show that (i) allele Ad12 harbors a deletion of >16 kb, (ii) A51 Mac ends distribute over four rather than three DNA regions, (iii) strains d48 and 51 display only quantitative differences (rare Ad48 and A51 Mac ends do form in strains 51 and d48, respectively), (iv) the level of A51 Mac ends is severalfold enhanced in d12- and d48-derived progeny, and (v) this level inversely correlates with the level of Ad48 Mac ends in the d48 parent. Together, these data lead to a model in which the formation of Ad48 Mac ends is epigenetically controlled by a d48 factor(s). We propose that the d48 factor(s) may be derived from RNA molecules transcribed from the Ad48 Mac ends and encompassing the truncated A gene and telomeric repeats.

A member of a repeat family is the source of an insertion-deletion polymorphism inside a developmentally eliminated sequence of Tetrahymena thermophila

In Tetrahymena thermophila, the development of a transcriptionally active macronucleus from a transcriptionally inert micronucleus is accompanied by the elimination of numerous DNA segments, called internally eliminated sequences (IESs), many of which belong to dispersed repetitive sequence families. To examine the relationship between the insertion and deletion events expected to occur during evolution of the repeats and the developmental elimination process, IESs were compared among different Tetrahymena strains. A 600 base-pair DNA segment, the R Indel, was discovered inside the R IES, one of the ten sequenced IESs out of an estimated 6000 total in the Tetrahymena genome. The R Indel was found in strains B3 and C2 but not in several other strains examined, indicating that the Indel was probably present in a progenitor of strains B3 and C2. The R Indel was found to belong to a moderately large sequence family of about 200 members; however, BLAST searches did not reveal meaningful similarities with other mobile elements. Sequence comparisons revealed that a 300 base-pair stretch, very closely related to the first half of the R Indel, was present inside the previously described B IES, another of the ten sequenced IESs. This is the first example of shared sequences between two of the known IESs.

Epigenetic mechanisms affecting macronuclear development in Paramecium and Tetrahymena

Epigenetic inheritance includes all non-Mendelian inheritance, in fact any inheritance that does not arise from base changes. Ciliates, particularly Paramecium and Tetrahymena, undergo epigenetic changes to their macronuclei when they are formed at nuclear reorganization. Once set, however, they are reproduced in a constant fashion, except for allelic segregations, during vegetative fissions in Tetrahymena and certain life cycle changes in both Paramecium and Tetrahymena. This review is meant to be inclusive, discussing all the known cases of epigenetic changes in macronuclei. They involve virtually all traits. We find that these macronuclear changes are subject to a variety of modifications in the way that they are implemented. They constitute a major feature of ciliate genetics, probably because the separation of generative and vegetative functions to micronuclei and macronuclei makes such changes possible.

Analysis of the conserved cysteine periodicity of Paramecium variable surface antigens

The major surface antigens expressed by free-living and parasitic protozoa commonly contain repeating cysteine motifs. Despite the common occurrence of these repeats their functional significance remains largely unexplored. In this paper we investigate the conserved cysteine repeats within the variable surface antigens of Paramecium tetraurelia. We show that deletion of 2 entire repeating units or portions of repeats near the N-terminus does not prevent expression of the A51 variable surface antigen. Alteration of a single cysteine to serine residue also has no effect on A51 expression. In contrast, deletions near the C-terminus of the protein have identified a small segment within the repeats that is required for expression on the surface. The required region contains a number of conserved amino acid residues, yet site-directed mutagenesis of two residues (serine and threonine to alanine) did not prevent expression. These studies demonstrate the feasibility of using deletion analysis to identify regions critical for the expression of cysteine-rich surface antigens. The relationship of these results to the structure and expression of cysteine-rich surface proteins in other protozoa is discussed.

A mutation in the flanking 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide prevents excision of an internal eliminated sequence from the Paramecium tetraurelia genome

The germline chromosomes in Paramecium and other ciliated protozoa contain regions of DNA that are excised and eliminated during the development of a new macronuclear genome. Paramecium tetraurelia internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are invariably flanked by a 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide sequence that is part of a larger 8-bp terminal inverted-repeat consensus sequence. Both features, the absolutely conserved 5'-TA-3' and the remaining 6-bp terminal inverted repeat, are shared with the mariner/Tc1 class of transposons. In this article we describe a mutant cell line (AIM-2) defective in excision of a single IES from the coding region of the A51 surface antigen gene. Excision of the 370-bp IES6649 is prevented by a single A to G transition in the invariably conserved 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide. Failure to excise IES6649 also revealed a 29-bp IES located inside IES6649. Additional experiments with the previously isolated AIM-1 mutant, which also contains an internal IES, shows that alternate excision using the wild-type end of IES2591 with an end from the internal IES is extremely rare or nonexistent. These results indicate that IESs are discrete elements whose excision depends upon nucleotides located within the consensus sequence, but also suggest that additional information is required to match one end of an IES with its excision partner.

A mutation in Paramecium tetraurelia reveals functional and structural features of developmentally excised DNA elements

The excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs) from the germline micronuclear DNA occurs during the differentiation of a new macronuclear genome in ciliated protozoa. In Paramecium, IESs are generally short (28-882 bp), AT rich DNA elements that show few conserved sequence features with the exception of an inverted-terminal-repeat consensus sequence that has similarity to the ends of mariner/Tcl transposons (KLOBUTCHER and HERRICK 1995). We have isolated and analyzed a mutant cell line that cannot excise a 370-bp IESs (IES2591) from the coding region of the 51A variable surface protein gene. A single micronuclear C to T transition within the consensus sequence prevents excision. The inability to excise IES259 I has revealed a 28-bp IES inside the larger IES, suggesting that reiterative integration of these elements can occur. Together, the consensus sequence mutation and the evidence for reiterative integration support the theory that Paramecium IESs evolved from transposable elements. Unlike a previously studied Paramecium IES, the presence of this IES in the macronucleus does not completely inhibit excision of its Mild-type micronuclear copy through multiple sexual generations.

Epigenetic regulation of programmed genomic rearrangements in Paramecium aurelia

In ciliates, development of the polyploid somatic macronucleus after sexual events involves extensive and reproducible rearrangements of the germ-line genome, including chromosome fragmentation and precise excision of numerous internal sequence elements. In Paramecium aurelia, alternative macronuclear versions of the same germ-line genome can be maternally inherited across sexual generations, showing that rearrangement patterns are not strictly determined by the germ-line sequence. Homology-dependent maternal effects can be evidenced by transformation of the vegetative macronucleus with cloned macronuclear sequences: new fragmentation patterns or internal deletions are specifically induced during differentiation of a new macronucleus, in sexual progeny of transformed clones. Furthermore, transformation of the maternal macronucleus with germ-line sequences containing internal eliminated sequences (short single-copy elements) can result in a specific inhibition of the excision of the same elements in the zygotic macronucleus. These experiments show that the processing of many germ-line sequences in the developing macronucleus is sensitive to the structure and copy number of homologous sequences in the maternal macronucleus. The generality and sequence specificity of this trans-nuclear, epigenetic regulation of rearrangements suggest that it is mediated by pairing interactions between germ-line sequences and sequences imported from the maternal macronucleus.

The 5' coding region of Paramecium surface antigen genes controls mutually exclusive transcription

Paramecium tetraurelia stock 51 can express at least 11 different types of surface antigens, yet only a single type is expressed on the surface of an individual cell at any one time. The differential expression of stock 51 type A and B surface antigen genes (51A and 51B) is regulated at the level of transcription. Previously, we reported that nucleotide sequences upstream of position -26 (relative to the start of translation) in the 51A and 51B surface antigen genes are necessary for transcriptional activity but are not sufficient to direct differential transcriptional control. In this report we demonstrate that at least some of the critical elements necessary for differential transcription of the 51A and 51B genes lie within the 5' coding region. A hybrid gene that contains 51B upstream sequences (-475 to +1) attached to the ATG start codon of 51A is not cotranscribed with the 51B gene. In contrast, further substitution with 51B sequences (-1647 to +885) allows the chimeric gene to be coexpressed with 51B. A different hybrid gene containing a substitution of 51B sequence from -26 to +885 in the 51A gene is also coexpressed with 51B, revealing that the critical elements within the coding region of 51B do not require 51B upstream sequences for their effect. Coinjection of the 51A gene with the chimeric gene that contains 51B up to +885 showed that the same sequences that allow coexpression with 51B prevent cotranscription with 51A. Together, these results demonstrate that a region downstream of the transcriptional start site between nucleotide positions +1 and +885 (relative to translational start) is necessary to control differential transcriptional activity.

Analysis of the micronuclear B type surface protein gene in Paramecium tetraurelia

The micronuclear DNA of Paramecium contains sequences that are precisely excised during the formation of the macronuclear (somatic) genome. In this paper we show that four eliminated sequences ranging in size from 28 to 416 base pairs, are present in or near the micronuclear copy of the B surface protein gene. Each excised sequence is bounded by the dinucleotide 5'-TdA-3'. Comparison of the micronuclear B gene with the previously determined micronuclear sequence of the A surface protein gene shows that although the positions of at least three of the eliminated sequences are conserved in both genes, the sequences are highly divergent. Transformation of vegetative macronuclei with fragments of the micronuclear B gene results in replication and maintenance of the DNA, but the micronuclear specific sequences are not removed. Previous studies have shown that the correct incorporation of the B gene into the new macronucleus requires copies of the macronuclear B gene in the old macronucleus. Using macronuclear transformation, we show that the micronuclear B gene can substitute for the macronuclear B gene with regard to its role in DNA processing. This suggests that the macronuclear DNA is not acting as a guide for the excision of the micronuclear specific sequences.

Non-Mendelian inheritance of macronuclear mutations is gene specific in Paramecium tetraurelia

Paramecium tetraurelia contains two types of nuclei, a diploid germinal micronucleus and a large transcriptionally active macronucleus. The macronuclear genome is formed from the micronuclear DNA during sexual reproduction. Previous studies have shown that the processing of the A-type variable surface protein gene during formation of a new macronucleus is dependent on the presence of the A gene in the old macronucleus. It is not clear if this is a general feature that controls the formation of the Paramecium macronuclear genome or a unique feature of the A locus. Using micronuclear transplantation, we have constructed a strain that has a wild-type micronucleus but has macronuclear deletions of the A- and B-type surface protein genes. Neither the A nor the B gene is incorporated into the new macronucleus after sexual reproduction. Macronuclear transformation of this strain with the B gene rescues the B-gene deletion after formation of the next macronucleus but has not effect on the A deletion. Similarly, transformation with the A gene shows gene-specific rescue for A but not B. The effect of the old macronucleus on the processing of the new macronucleus results in a pattern of non-Mendelian inheritance of both macronuclear deletions. Progeny from the wild-type exconjugant are all wild type, and progeny from the A- B- exconjugant are mutant. The features of this A- B- non-Mendelian mutant demonstrate that the regulation of macronuclear DNA processing is gene specific, and our results open the possibility that this type of regulation affects many regions of the Paramecium genome.

The role of macronuclear DNA sequences in the permanent rescue of a non-mendelian mutation in Paramecium tetraurelia

The paramecium tetraurelia mutant called d48 has a complete copy of the A surface protein gene in its micronuclei, but lacks the A gene in the macronucleus. Previous experiments have shown that microinjection of a plasmid containing the entire A gene or a large portion of the gene into the macronucleus of d48 rescued the cell line after formation of a new macronucleus (autogamy). Here we show that several different regions of the A gene can rescue d48, but 100% of the activity cannot be localized to a single, defined region. Inversion of a sequence contained within an A gene plasmid had no measurable effect on rescue efficiency and co-injection of two different plasmids results in enhancement of rescue activity despite the non-contiguous form of the DNA sequences. Both these results suggest that no specific product (RNA or protein) with defined end points is made from the rescuing fragment. A unique restriction site was created in the A gene and used to demonstrate that the injected DNA does not serve as a direct template for the synthesis of the new macronuclear DNA. Models to explain the action of the injected DNA are discussed.

Non-Mendelian inheritance of macronuclear mutations is gene specific in Paramecium tetraurelia

Paramecium tetraurelia contains two types of nuclei, a diploid germinal micronucleus and a large transcriptionally active macronucleus. The macronuclear genome is formed from the micronuclear DNA during sexual reproduction. Previous studies have shown that the processing of the A-type variable surface protein gene during formation of a new macronucleus is dependent on the presence of the A gene in the old macronucleus. It is not clear if this is a general feature that controls the formation of the Paramecium macronuclear genome or a unique feature of the A locus. Using micronuclear transplantation, we have constructed a strain that has a wild-type micronucleus but has macronuclear deletions of the A- and B-type surface protein genes. Neither the A nor the B gene is incorporated into the new macronucleus after sexual reproduction. Macronuclear transformation of this strain with the B gene rescues the B-gene deletion after formation of the next macronucleus but has not effect on the A deletion. Similarly, transformation with the A gene shows gene-specific rescue for A but not B. The effect of the old macronucleus on the processing of the new macronucleus results in a pattern of non-Mendelian inheritance of both macronuclear deletions. Progeny from the wild-type exconjugant are all wild type, and progeny from the A- B- exconjugant are mutant. The features of this A- B- non-Mendelian mutant demonstrate that the regulation of macronuclear DNA processing is gene specific, and our results open the possibility that this type of regulation affects many regions of the Paramecium genome.

DNA sequence requirements for the regulation of immobilization antigen A expression in Paramecium tetraurelia

The Paramecium surface proteins (immobilization antigens) are expressed in a mutually exclusive manner; only one antigen is found on the cell surface at a time. Expression of these proteins is regulated in response to environmental cues such as temperature and pH. This regulation has been shown to be controlled at the level of mRNA abundance by transcriptional and post-transcriptional mechanisms. Here, we have studied the transcription and regulated expression of the immobilization antigen A gene in Paramecium tetraurelia by transforming an A-deficient strain, d12, with cloned portions of the A gene via microinjection. The A gene is approximately 8 kilobases (kb) long with the transcription start site at position -9 or -8 and the start of translation at position +1. Paramecia transformed with cloned DNA containing A-gene sequences beginning at position -264 and ending 63 base pairs (bp) past the gene's polyadenylation site show properly regulated expression of immobilization antigen A. Lines derived from paramecia transformed with a plasmid containing A-gene sequences starting at position -211, however, show markedly reduced A-gene mRNA levels, and rarely express the A antigen. Nevertheless, cells that do express the A protein exhibit mutual exclusion and normal responses to environmental stimuli. Thus, the 54 bp between -264 and -211, while important for transcription, are not involved in the control of mutual exclusion and responses to environmental changes. Further deletion to position -151 yields similar, but more extreme, results.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Molecular and genetic analyses of the B type surface protein gene from Paramecium tetraurelia

The gene encoding the B type variable surface protein from Paramecium tetraurelia stock 51 has been cloned and sequenced. The 7,182 nucleotide open reading frame contains no introns and encodes a cysteine-rich protein that has a periodic structure including three nearly perfect tandem repeats in the central region. Interestingly, the B gene is located near a macronuclear telomere as was shown previously for two other paramecium surface protein genes. In this paper, we characterize four independent mutants with complete macronuclear deletions of the B gene. Previous analysis of different macronuclear deletion mutants of the A surface protein gene demonstrated two types of inheritance: typical Mendelian segregation (as illustrated by d12) and cytoplasmic inheritance (shown by d48). F1 analysis of four B- mutants crossed with wild-type cells reveals heterozygous F1 cell lines derived from both parental cytoplasms contain approximately the same copy number of the B gene, as expected for a recessive Mendelian mutation. Analysis of F2 progeny from three of these four B- mutant crosses indicates that one of the three exhibits a Mendelian 1:1 segregation ratio of B+ and B- cell lines. The other two show a preponderance of B+ cells, but this is not correlated with the parental cytoplasmic type. In addition to having a large number of B+ individuals, the d12.144, A-, B- mutant produced some F2 progeny that stably maintain less than normal macronuclear amounts of the A gene and/or the B gene.

Micronuclear DNA from Paramecium tetraurelia: serotype 51 A gene has internally eliminated sequences

A method for the isolation of micronuclear DNA from Paramecium tetraurelia has been developed. After cell lysis, a low speed centrifugation at 1,000 g is used to remove all of the unbroken cells and macronuclei and approximately two thirds of the macronuclear fragments. Next a higher speed centrifugation of 9,000 g sediments the micronuclei and frees them from small particulates and soluble constituents. Advantage is then taken of the fact that micronuclei have a lower density than do macronuclear fragments in 45%-60% Percoll. Micronuclei float to the top during centrifugation at 24,000 g, while macronuclear fragments sediment. After several cycles of centrifugation in Percoll, the micronuclei, although heavily contaminated with cytoplasmic components, are essentially free of macronuclei and macronuclear fragments. Micronuclear DNA can then be extracted from the suspension. The whole procedure is very rapid and in about an hour micronuclear and macronuclear DNA can be separated. About 2 micrograms of micronuclear DNA can be obtained from 6 x 10(7) paramecia. We find that there are internal sequences in the micronuclear A gene DNA in wild type cells which are eliminated when the micronuclei develop into macronuclei. They yield unique restriction fragments for micronuclei and macronuclei. Therefore the purity of the preparations is easily monitored by probing Southern blots of restriction enzyme-digested DNA with the cloned A gene. No differences have been found between the micronuclear A gene in wild type and the d48 mutant.

A repetitive DNA sequence in Paramecium macronuclei is related to the beta subunit of G proteins

A repeated DNA sequence has been identified in the macronucleus of several Paramecium species. In P.tetraurelia the repeat was identified in the subtelomeric region of four randomly selected telomere clones, as well as downstream of the A type variable surface protein gene. The complete sequence of the A gene linked repeat consists of 15 tandem repeats of exactly 126 nucleotides that contain an open reading frame with significant similarity to the beta subunits of trimeric G proteins. The most striking consensus feature is the amino acid sequence DX omega WD where X is any amino acid and omega is I, L, or V spaced at precise 42 amino acids intervals. This sequence and spacing are found in G-protein beta subunits and other members of this protein motif family. Analysis of the five cloned telomeric restriction fragments showed the repeats can be found in either orientation with respect to the telomere. Poly(A) RNA transcripts containing this sequence have been identified in Paramecium tetraurelia. The conserved presence of this sequence in several species of Paramecium suggests an important physiological function, and the study of this repeat may reveal information about the evolution of this common protein motif.

Permanent rescue of a non-Mendelian mutation of Paramecium by microinjection of specific DNA sequences

The mutant Paramecium tetraurelia cell line d48 is unable to express the serotype A protein on its surface. Although the A gene is intact in the micronuclei of d48, the A gene copies in the macronucleus contain a large deletion eliminating virtually the entire coding sequence. Previous studies showed that microinjection of a plasmid containing the entire A gene into the macronucleus of d48 permanently restored A expression after autogamy. Together with other data, this result suggests that in wild type cells the A gene in the old macronucleus ensures the presence of a cytoplasmic factor that prevents A gene deletions at autogamy. In d48, where there are few, if any copies of the intact A gene in the old macronucleus, deletions occur during macronuclear formation. To elucidate the specific molecular mechanisms involved in this unusual phenomenon, we attempted to define the region(s) of the A gene necessary for rescuing d48. We show that microinjection of a 4.5-kb internal A gene fragment is sufficient for proper processing at autogamy and leads to permanent rescue of d48; i.e., the rescued strain is indistinguishable from wild type. Thus, rescue of d48 does not require upstream transcriptional control sequences, intact A mRNA or A serotype protein. We also show that various fragments of the A gene have the ability to rescue d48 to different extents, some being more efficient than others. We find no evidence to suggest that the A gene gives rise to a small stable RNA that might act as or encode a cytoplasmic factor. Molecular mechanisms that may be involved in the rescue of d48 are discussed.