ACVR1 p.Q207E causes classic fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva and is functionally distinct from the engineered constitutively active ACVR1 p.Q207D variant

Molecular Developmental Biology of Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva: Measuring the Giant by Its Toe

When a genetic disease is characterized by the abnormal activation of normal molecular pathways and cellular events, it is illuminating to critically examine the places and times of these activities both in health and disease. Therefore, because heterotopic ossification (HO) in fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is by far the disease's most prominent symptom, attention is also directed toward the pathways and processes of bone formation during skeletal development. FOP is recognizable by effects of the causative mutation on skeletal development even before HO manifests, specifically in the malformation of the great toes. This signature skeletal phenotype is the most highly penetrant, but is only one among several skeletal abnormalities associated with FOP. Patients may present clinically with joint malformation and ankylosis, particularly in the cervical spine and costovertebral joints, as well as characteristic facial features and a litany of less common, non-skeletal symptoms, all stemming from missense mutations in the ACVR1 gene. In the same way that studying the genetic cause of HO advanced our understanding of HO initiation and progression, insight into the roles of ACVR1 signaling during tissue development, particularly in the musculoskeletal system, can be gained from examining altered skeletal development in individuals with FOP. This review will detail what is known about the molecular mechanisms of developmental phenotypes in FOP and the early role of ACVR1 in skeletal patterning and growth, as well as highlight how better understanding these processes may serve to advance patient care, assessments of patient outcomes, and the fields of bone and joint biology.

Primary cilia mediate skeletogenic BMP and Hedgehog signaling in heterotopic ossification

Heterotopic ossification (HO), defined as the formation of extraskeletal bone in muscle and soft tissues, is a diverse pathological process caused by either genetic mutations or inciting trauma. Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a genetic form of HO caused by mutations in the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) type I receptor gene activin A receptor type 1 (ACVR1). These mutations make ACVR1 hypersensitive to BMP and responsive to activin A. Hedgehog (Hh) signaling also contributes to HO development. However, the exact pathophysiology of how skeletogenic cells contribute to endochondral ossification in FOP remains unknown. Here, we showed that the wild-type or FOP-mutant ACVR1 localized in the cilia of stem cells from human exfoliated deciduous teeth with key FOP signaling components, including activin A receptor type 2A/2B, SMAD family member 1/5, and FK506-binding protein 12kD. Cilia suppression by deletion of intraflagellar transport 88 or ADP ribosylation factor like GTPase 3 effectively inhibited pathological BMP and Hh signaling, subdued aberrant chondro-osteogenic differentiation in primary mouse or human FOP cells, and diminished in vivo extraskeletal ossification in Acvr1Q207D, Sox2-Cre; Acvr1R206H/+ FOP mice and in burn tenotomy-treated wild-type mice. Our results provide a rationale for early and localized suppression of cilia in affected tissues after injury as a therapeutic strategy against either genetic or acquired HO.

Pay Attention to the Osteochondromas in Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva

BACKGROUND

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is an extremely rare disease characterized by malformation of the bilateral great toes and progressive heterotopic ossification. The clinical features of FOP occur due to dysfunction of the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling pathway induced by the mutant activin A type I receptor/activin-like kinase-2 (ACVR1/ALK2) which contributes to the clinical features in FOP. Dysregulation of the BMP signaling pathway causes the development of osteochondroma. Poor awareness of the association between FOP and osteochondromas always results in misdiagnosis and unnecessary invasive operation.

CASE PRESENTATION

In this study, we present a case of classical FOP involving osteochondroma. An 18-year-old male adolescent, born with deformity of bilateral big toes, complained multiple masses on his back for 1 year. The mass initially emerged with a tough texture and did not cause pain. It was misdiagnosed as an osteochondroma. After two surgeries, the masses became hard and spread around the entire back region. Meanwhile, extensive heterotopic ossification was observed around the back, neck, hip, knee, ribs, and mandible during follow-up. Osteochondromas were observed around the bilateral knees. No abnormalities were observed in the laboratory blood test results. Whole exome sequencing revealed missense mutation of ACVR1/ALK2 (c.617G > A; p.R206H) in the patient and confirmed the diagnosis of FOP.

CONCLUSION

In summary, classical FOP always behaves as a bilateral deformity of the big toes, as well as progressive ectopic ossification and osteochondromas in the distal femur and proximal tibia. An understanding of the association between osteochondromas and FOP aids in diagnosis and avoids unnecessary invasive management in patients.

Navigating the Complex Landscape of Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva: From Current Paradigms to Therapeutic Frontiers

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is an enigmatic, ultra-rare genetic disorder characterized by progressive heterotopic ossification, wherein soft connective tissues undergo pathological transformation into bone structures. This incapacitating process severely limits patient mobility and poses formidable challenges for therapeutic intervention. Predominantly caused by missense mutations in the ACVR1 gene, this disorder has hitherto defied comprehensive mechanistic understanding and effective treatment paradigms. This write-up offers a comprehensive overview of the contemporary understanding of FOP's complex pathobiology, underscored by advances in molecular genetics and proteomic studies. We delve into targeted therapy, spanning genetic therapeutics, enzymatic and transcriptional modulation, stem cell therapies, and innovative immunotherapies. We also highlight the intricate complexities surrounding clinical trial design for ultra-rare disorders like FOP, addressing fundamental statistical limitations, ethical conundrums, and methodological advancements essential for the success of interventional studies. We advocate for the adoption of a multi-disciplinary approach that converges bench-to-bedside research, clinical expertise, and ethical considerations to tackle the challenges of ultra-rare diseases like FOP and comparable ultra-rare diseases. In essence, this manuscript serves a dual purpose: as a definitive scientific resource for ongoing and future FOP research and a call to action for innovative solutions to address methodological and ethical challenges that impede progress in the broader field of medical research into ultra-rare conditions.

Functional comparison of human ACVR1 and zebrafish Acvr1l FOP-associated variants in embryonic zebrafish

BACKGROUND

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP), a rare disease characterized by progressive heterotopic ossification of muscle and connective tissues, is caused by autosomal dominant activating mutations in the type I receptor, ACVR1/ALK2. The classic human FOP variant, ACVR1R206H , shows increased bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling and activation by activins.

RESULTS

Here, we performed in vivo functional characterization of human ACVR1R206H and orthologous zebrafish Acvr1lR203H using early embryonic zebrafish dorsoventral patterning as a phenotypic readout for receptor activity. Our results showed that human ACVR1R206H and zebrafish Acvr1lR203H exhibit functional differences in early embryonic zebrafish, and that human ACVR1R206H retained its signaling activity in the absence of a ligand-binding domain (LBD). We also showed, for the first time, that zebrafish Acvr2ba/Acvr2bb receptors are required for human ACVR1R206H signaling in early embryonic zebrafish.

CONCLUSIONS

Together, these data provide new insight into ACVR1R206H signaling pathways that may facilitate the design of new and effective therapies for FOP patients.

Transcriptomic Differences Underlying the Activin-A Induced Large Osteoclast Formation in Both Healthy Control and Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva Osteoclasts

Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP) is a very rare genetic disease characterized by progressive heterotopic ossification (HO) of soft tissues, leading to immobility and premature death. FOP is caused by a mutation in the Activin receptor Type 1 (ACVR1) gene, resulting in altered responsiveness to Activin-A. We recently revealed that Activin-A induces fewer, but larger and more active, osteoclasts regardless of the presence of the mutated ACVR1 receptor. The underlying mechanism of Activin-A-induced changes in osteoclastogenesis at the gene expression level remains unknown. Transcriptomic changes induced by Activin-A during osteoclast formation from healthy controls and patient-derived CD14-positive monocytes were studied using RNA sequencing. CD14-positive monocytes from six FOP patients and six age- and sex-matched healthy controls were differentiated into osteoclasts in the absence or presence of Activin-A. RNA samples were isolated after 14 days of culturing and analyzed by RNA sequencing. Non-supervised principal component analysis (PCA) showed that samples from the same culture conditions (e.g., without or with Activin-A) tended to cluster, indicating that the variability induced by Activin-A treatment was larger than the variability between the control and FOP samples. RNA sequencing analysis revealed 1480 differentially expressed genes induced by Activin-A in healthy control and FOP osteoclasts with p(adj) < 0.01 and a Log2 fold change of ≥±2. Pathway and gene ontology enrichment analysis revealed several significantly enriched pathways for genes upregulated by Activin-A that could be linked to the differentiation or function of osteoclasts, cell fusion or inflammation. Our data showed that Activin-A has a substantial effect on gene expression during osteoclast formation and that this effect occurred regardless of the presence of the mutated ACVR1 receptor causing FOP.

Midline brain hamartomatous lesions in fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva with ACVR1 mutations

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare genetic disorder characterized by extensive heterotopic ossification of soft tissue structures leading to severe limitations in movement. FOP is caused by a germline mutation in the activating receptor type IA (ACVR1) gene. Worrisome is the fact that up to a third of diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas (DIPG) also harbor the same point mutation in ACVR1. Radiological reports of central nervous system (CNS) involvement by FOP have described brainstem masses; however, the literature on the histopathology or pathogenesis of these lesions is scant. Here we present detailed neuropathologic findings of a brainstem mass in a patient with FOP and suggest that the tumor is hamartomatous in nature. This report, along with a literature review of radiographic and laboratory data, offers support for the idea that the ACVR1 mutation may incite CNS proliferation, predominantly in the brainstem, but is probably not an oncologic driver. These lesions may be seen at autopsy and are likely noncontributory to death.

Overexpression of Wild-Type ACVR1 in Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva Mice Rescues Perinatal Lethality and Inhibits Heterotopic Ossification

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a devastating disease of progressive heterotopic bone formation for which effective treatments are currently unavailable. FOP is caused by dominant gain-of-function mutations in the receptor ACVR1 (also known as ALK2), which render the receptor inappropriately responsive to activin ligands. In previous studies, we developed a genetic mouse model of FOP that recapitulates most clinical aspects of the disease. In this model, genetic loss of the wild-type Acvr1 allele profoundly exacerbated heterotopic ossification, suggesting the hypothesis that the stoichiometry of wild-type and mutant receptors dictates disease severity. Here, we tested this model by producing FOP mice that conditionally overexpress human wild-type ACVR1. Injury-induced heterotopic ossification (HO) was completely blocked in FOP mice when expression of both the mutant and wild-type receptor were targeted to Tie2-positive cells, which includes fibro/adipogenic progenitors (FAPs). Perinatal lethality of Acvr1^R206H/+ mice was rescued by constitutive ACVR1 overexpression, and these mice survived to adulthood at predicted Mendelian frequencies. Constitutive overexpression of ACVR1 also provided protection from spontaneous abnormal skeletogenesis, and the incidence and severity of injury-induced HO in these mice was dramatically reduced. Analysis of pSMAD1/5/8 signaling both in cultured cells and in vivo indicates that ACVR1 overexpression functions cell-autonomously by reducing osteogenic signaling in response to activin A. We propose that ACVR1 overexpression inhibits HO by decreasing the abundance of ACVR1(R206H)-containing signaling complexes at the cell surface while increasing the representation of activin-A-bound non-signaling complexes comprised of wild-type ACVR1. © 2022 The Authors. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of American Society for Bone and Mineral Research (ASBMR).

BMP signaling and skeletal development in fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP)

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is an ultra-rare genetic disease caused by increased BMP pathway signaling due to mutation of ACVR1, a bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) type 1 receptor. The primary clinical manifestation of FOP is extra-skeletal bone formation (heterotopic ossification) within soft connective tissues. However, the underlying ACVR1 mutation additionally alters skeletal bone development and nearly all people born with FOP have bilateral malformation of the great toes as well as other skeletal malformations at diverse anatomic sites. The specific mechanisms through which ACVR1 mutations and altered BMP pathway signaling in FOP influence skeletal bone formation during development remain to be elucidated; however, recent investigations are providing a clearer understanding of the molecular and developmental processes associated with ACVR1-regulated skeletal formation.

Challenges and Opportunities for Drug Repositioning in Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is an ultrarare congenital disease that progresses through intermittent episodes of bone formation at ectopic sites. FOP patients carry heterozygous gene point mutations in activin A receptor type I ACVR1, encoding the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) type I serine/threonine kinase receptor ALK2, termed activin receptor-like kinase (ALK)2. The mutant ALK2 displays neofunctional responses to activin, a closely related BMP cytokine that normally inhibits regular bone formation. Moreover, the mutant ALK2 becomes hypersensitive to BMPs. Both these activities contribute to enhanced ALK2 signalling and endochondral bone formation in connective tissue. Being a receptor with an extracellular ligand-binding domain and intrinsic intracellular kinase activity, the mutant ALK2 is a druggable target. Although there is no approved cure for FOP yet, a number of clinical trials have been recently initiated, aiming to identify a safe and effective treatment for FOP. Among other targeted approaches, several repurposed drugs have shown promising results. In this review, we describe the molecular mechanisms underlying ALK2 mutation-induced aberrant signalling and ectopic bone formation. In addition, we recapitulate existing in vitro models to screen for novel compounds with a potential application in FOP. We summarize existing therapeutic alternatives and focus on repositioned drugs in FOP, at preclinical and clinical stages.

Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva: What Have We Achieved and Where Are We Now? Follow-up to the 2015 Lorentz Workshop

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is an ultra-rare progressive genetic disease effecting one in a million individuals. During their life, patients with FOP progressively develop bone in the soft tissues resulting in increasing immobility and early death. A mutation in the ACVR1 gene was identified as the causative mutation of FOP in 2006. After this, the pathophysiology of FOP has been further elucidated through the efforts of research groups worldwide. In 2015, a workshop was held to gather these groups and discuss the new challenges in FOP research. Here we present an overview and update on these topics.

Genetic and Acquired Heterotopic Ossification: A Translational Tale of Mice and Men

Heterotopic ossification is defined as an aberrant formation of bone in extraskeletal soft tissue, for which both genetic and acquired conditions are known. This pathologic process may occur in many different sites such as the skin, subcutaneous tissue, skeletal muscle and fibrous tissue adjacent to joints, ligaments, walls of blood vessels, mesentery and other. The clinical spectrum of this disorder is wide: lesions may range from small foci of ossification to massive deposits of bone throughout the body, typical of the progressive genetically determined conditions such as fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva, to mention one of the most severe and disabling forms. The ectopic bone formation may be regarded as a failed tissue repair process in response to a variety of triggers and evolving towards bone formation through a multistage differentiation program, with several steps common to different clinical presentations and distinctive features. In this review, we aim at providing a comprehensive view of the genetic and acquired heterotopic ossification disorders by detailing the clinical and molecular features underlying the different human conditions in comparison with the corresponding, currently available mouse models.

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva: current concepts from bench to bedside

Heterotopic ossification (HO) is a disorder characterised by the formation of ectopic bone in soft tissue. Acquired HO typically occurs in response to trauma and is relatively common, yet its aetiology remains poorly understood. Genetic forms, by contrast, are very rare, but provide insights into the mechanisms of HO pathobiology. Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is the most debilitating form of HO. All patients reported to date carry heterozygous gain-of-function mutations in the gene encoding activin A receptor type I (ACVR1). These mutations cause dysregulated bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signalling, leading to HO at extraskeletal sites including, but not limited to, muscles, ligaments, tendons and fascia. Ever since the identification of the causative gene, developing a cure for FOP has been a focus of investigation, and studies have decoded the pathophysiology at the molecular and cellular levels, and explored novel management strategies. Based on the established role of BMP signalling throughout HO in FOP, therapeutic modalities that target multiple levels of the signalling cascade have been designed, and some drugs have entered clinical trials, holding out hope of a cure. A potential role of other signalling pathways that could influence the dysregulated BMP signalling and present alternative therapeutic targets remains a matter of debate. Here, we review the recent FOP literature, including pathophysiology, clinical aspects, animal models and current management strategies. We also consider how this research can inform our understanding of other types of HO and highlight some of the remaining knowledge gaps.

Summary: Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva is a rare disease characterised by progressive heterotopic bone formation. Here, we present a comprehensive summary of the recent literature on this debilitating condition and discuss approaches to solving this clinical puzzle.

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva mutant ACVR1 signals by multiple modalities in the developing zebrafish

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare human genetic disorder characterized by altered skeletal development and extraskeletal ossification. All cases of FOP are caused by activating mutations in the type I BMP/TGFβ cell surface receptor ACVR1, which over-activates signaling through phospho-Smad1/5 (pSmad1/5). To investigate the mechanism by which FOP-ACVR1 enhances pSmad1/5 activation, we used zebrafish embryonic dorsoventral (DV) patterning as an assay for BMP signaling. We determined that the FOP mutants ACVR1-R206H and -G328R do not require their ligand binding domain to over-activate BMP signaling in DV patterning. However, intact ACVR1-R206H has the ability to respond to both Bmp7 and Activin A ligands. Additionally, BMPR1, a type I BMP receptor normally required for BMP-mediated patterning of the embryo, is dispensable for both ligand-independent signaling pathway activation and ligand-responsive signaling hyperactivation by ACVR1-R206H. These results demonstrate that FOP-ACVR1 is not constrained by the same receptor/ligand partner requirements as WT-ACVR1.

Activin-A Induces Fewer, but Larger Osteoclasts From Monocytes in Both Healthy Controls and Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva Patients

Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP) is a rare genetic disease characterized by heterotopic ossification (HO) that occurs in muscle tissue, tendons, and ligaments. The disease is caused by mutations in the Activin receptor type I (ACVR1) gene resulting in enhanced responsiveness to Activin-A. Binding of this molecule to the mutated receptor induces HO. Bone metabolism normally requires the coupled action of osteoblasts and osteoclasts, which seems to be disturbed during HO. We hypothesize that Activin-A may also counteract the formation of osteoclasts in FOP patients. In this study we investigated the effect of Activin-A on osteoclast differentiation of CD14+ monocytes from FOP patients and healthy controls. The lymphocytic and monocytic cell populations were determined by FACS analysis. Expression of the mutated R206H receptor was assessed and confirmed by allele specific PCR. The effect of Activin-A on osteoclastogenesis was assessed by counting the number and size of multinucleated cells. Osteoclast activity was determined by culturing the cells on Osteo Assay plates. The influence of Activin-A on expression of various osteoclast related genes was studied with QPCR. Blood from FOP patients contained similar percentages of classical, intermediate, or non-classical monocytes as healthy controls. Addition of Activin-A to the osteoclastogenesis cultures resulted in fewer osteoclasts in both control and FOP cultures. The osteoclasts formed in the presence of Activin-A were, however, much larger and more active compared to the cultures without Activin-A. This effect was tempered when the Activin-A inhibitor follistatin was added to the Activin-A containing cultures. Expression of osteoclast specific genes Cathepsin K and TRAcP was upregulated, gene expression of osteoclastogenesis related genes M-CSF and DC-STAMP was downregulated by Activin-A. Since Activin-A is a promising target for inhibiting the formation of HO in FOP, it is important to know its effects on both osteoblasts and osteoclasts. Our study shows that Activin-A induces fewer, but larger and more active osteoclasts independent of the presence of the mutated ACVR1 receptor. When considering FOP as an Activin-A driven disease that acts locally, our findings suggest that Activin-A could cause a more pronounced local resorption by larger osteoclasts. Thus, when targeting Activin-A in patients with neutralizing antibodies, HO formation could potentially be inhibited, and osteoclastic activity could be slightly reduced, but then performed dispersedly by more and smaller osteoclasts.

Skeletal malformations and developmental arthropathy in individuals who have fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva

RATIONALE

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is primarily a disease of progressive heterotopic ossification (HO) leading to impaired mobility throughout life. An additional diagnostic feature is a characteristic malformation of the great toes. The culpable gene for FOP,ACVR1 (activin A receptor type 1) has a clear effect on the induction of extra-skeletal bone formation. However, this bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) pathway receptor is expressed widely throughout skeletal development and has a seminal role in axial and appendicular chondrogenesis, prompting suspicion of widespread bone and joint defects in those with ACVR1 mutations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We analyzed baseline whole body (minus skull) computed tomographic (CT) scans of 113 individuals with classic clinical features of FOP and the ACVR1 (R206H) mutation who were enrolled in a non-interventional natural history study ((NCT02322255)) for skeletal malformations, atypical morphology, intra-articular synovial osteochondromatosis, developmental arthropathy, and associated degenerative joint phenotypes. Individuals were evaluated in three age groups: 4-13; 14-25; and 25-56 years old, based on historical models of FOP disease progression.

RESULTS

We found widespread evidence of developmental arthropathy throughout the axial and appendicular skeleton in all age groups (61M, 52F; ages: 4-56 years). Asymmetric narrowing and subchondral sclerosis were present throughout the joints of the normotopic skeleton and osteophytes were common in the hips and knees of individuals who have FOP in all age groups. The costovertebral joints, intervertebral facet joints, and proximal tibio-fibular joints frequently showed partial or total intra-articular ankylosis, particularly after age 13. The hips of FOP subjects are frequently malformed and dysplastic. We also found evidence of degenerative joint phenotypes after age 13, particularly in the spine, sacro-iliac joints, and lower limbs.

CONCLUSIONS

The effects of ACVR1 mutation on the normotopic skeletons of individuals who have FOP extend beyond malformation of the great toes and include both morphological defects and developmental arthropathy. Associated degenerative joint disease occurring at multiple sites starts in adolescence and progresses throughout life. These phenotypes appear to be uncoupled from heterotopic bone formation, indicating a potential role for ACVR1 in the development and progression of degenerative joint disease.

SIGNIFICANCE

FOP is a disease of not only progressive heterotopic ossification, but also widespread and extensive developmental arthropathy and associated degenerative joint disease. These findings have relevance for understanding the natural history of FOP and for designing and evaluating clinical trials with emerging therapeutics.

ACVR1 Function in Health and Disease

Activin A receptor type I (ACVR1) encodes for a bone morphogenetic protein type I receptor of the TGFβ receptor superfamily. It is involved in a wide variety of biological processes, including bone, heart, cartilage, nervous, and reproductive system development and regulation. Moreover, ACVR1 has been extensively studied for its causal role in fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP), a rare genetic disorder characterised by progressive heterotopic ossification. ACVR1 is linked to different pathologies, including cardiac malformations and alterations in the reproductive system. More recently, ACVR1 has been experimentally validated as a cancer driver gene in diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG), a malignant childhood brainstem glioma, and its function is being studied in other cancer types. Here, we review ACVR1 receptor function and signalling in physiological and pathological processes and its regulation according to cell type and mutational status. Learning from different functions and alterations linked to ACVR1 is a key step in the development of interdisciplinary research towards the identification of novel treatments for these pathologies.

Inhibition of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase α (PI3Kα) prevents heterotopic ossification

Heterotopic ossification (HO) is the pathological formation of ectopic endochondral bone within soft tissues. HO occurs following mechanical trauma, burns, or congenitally in patients suffering from fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP). FOP patients carry a conserved mutation in ACVR1 that becomes neomorphic for activin A responses. Here, we demonstrate the efficacy of BYL719, a PI3Kα inhibitor, in preventing HO in mice. We found that PI3Kα inhibitors reduce SMAD, AKT, and mTOR/S6K activities. Inhibition of PI3Kα also impairs skeletogenic responsiveness to BMPs and the acquired response to activin A of the Acvr1^R206H allele. Further, the efficacy of PI3Kα inhibitors was evaluated in transgenic mice expressing Acvr1^Q207D . Mice treated daily or intermittently with BYL719 did not show ectopic bone or cartilage formation. Furthermore, the intermittent treatment with BYL719 was not associated with any substantial side effects. Therefore, this work provides evidence supporting PI3Kα inhibition as a therapeutic strategy for HO.

Evolution of heterotopic bone in fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva: An [18F]NaF PET/CT study

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare, autosomal dominant disorder characterized by heterotopic ossification (HO) in muscles, ligaments and tendons. Flare-ups often precede the formation of HO, resulting in immobilization of joints. Due to progression of the disease without signs of a flare-up, co-existence of a chronic progression of HO has been postulated, but conclusive evidence is lacking. Recently, it has been shown that [¹⁸F]NaF PET/CT is able to identify early ossifying disease activity during flare-ups. Therefore, the purpose of the present study was to assess whether [¹⁸F]NaF PET/CT might also be able to identify the possible presence of chronic progressive HO in FOP. A total of thirteen [¹⁸F]NaF PET/CT scans from five FOP patients were analysed. Scans were acquired over a period of 0.5 to 2 years. Volumes of HO and standardized uptake values (SUV) were obtained based on manual segmentation of CT images. SUV_peak values, defined as the average SUV value of a 1 mL sphere containing the hottest voxel pixels, were obtained. Two out of five patients experienced ≥1 active clinical flare-ups at the time of the [¹⁸F]NaF PET/CT scan. In addition, in four out of five patients, serial scans showed radiological progression of HO (3 to 8 cm³), as assessed by CT volume, in the absence of a clinical flare-up. This volumetric increase was present in 6/47 (12.8%) of identified HO structures and, in all cases, was accompanied by increased [¹⁸F]NaF uptake, with SUV_peak ranging from 8.4 to 17.9. In conclusion, HO may progress without signs of a flare-up. [¹⁸F]NaF PET/CT is able to identify these asymptomatic, but progressive HO lesions, thereby demonstrating the presence of chronic activity in FOP. Consequently, future drugs should not only target new HO formation, but also this chronic HO progression.

Molecular characterization of known and novel ACVR1 variants in phenotypes of aberrant ossification

Diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH) is a disorder principally characterized by calcification and ossification of spinal ligaments and entheses. Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare autosomal dominant disabling disorder characterized by progressive ossification of skeletal muscle, fascia, tendons, and ligaments. These conditions manifest phenotypic overlap in the ossification of tendons and ligaments. We describe herein a patient with DISH, exhibiting heterotopic ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament where clinical whole exome sequencing identified a variant within ACVR1, a gene implicated in FOP. This variant, p.K400E, is a novel variant, not identified previously, and occurs in a highly conserved region across orthologs. We used sequence-based predicative algorithms, molecular modeling, and molecular dynamics simulations, to test the potential for p.K400E to alter the structure and dynamics of ACVR1. We applied the same modeling and simulation methods to established FOP variants, to identify the detailed effects that they have on the ACVR1 protein, as well as to act as positive controls against which the effects of p.K400E could be evaluated. Our in silico molecular analyses support p.K400E as altering the behavior of ACVR1. In addition, functional testing to measure the effect of this variant on BMP-pSMAD 1/5/8 target genes was carried out which revealed this variant to cause increased ID1 and Msx2 expression compared with the wild-type receptor. This analysis supports the potential for the variant of uncertain significance to contribute to the patient's phenotype.

An Adult Zebrafish Model of Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare human skeletal disease caused by constitutively activating mutations in the gene ACVR1, which encodes a type I BMP/TGFβ family member receptor. FOP is characterized by progressive heterotopic ossification (HO) of fibrous tissues, including skeletal muscle, tendons, and ligaments, as well as malformation of the big toes, vertebral fusions, and osteochondromas. Surgical interventions in patients often result in enhanced HO, which can exacerbate rather than improve diagnostic outcomes. As a result of these difficulties, a variety of animal models are needed to study human FOP. Here we describe the methods for creating and characterizing zebrafish conditionally expressing Acvr1l^Q204D, the first adult zebrafish model for FOP.

ACVR1R206H FOP mutation alters mechanosensing and tissue stiffness during heterotopic ossification

An activating bone morphogenetic proteins (BMP) type I receptor ACVR1 (ACVR1^R206H) mutation enhances BMP pathway signaling and causes the rare genetic disorder of heterotopic (extraskeletal) bone formation fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva. Heterotopic ossification frequently occurs following injury as cells aberrantly differentiate during tissue repair. Biomechanical signals from the tissue microenvironment and cellular responses to these physical cues, such as stiffness and rigidity, are important determinants of cell differentiation and are modulated by BMP signaling. We used an Acvr1^R206H/+ mouse model of injury-induced heterotopic ossification to examine the fibroproliferative tissue preceding heterotopic bone and identified pathologic stiffening at this stage of repair. In response to microenvironment stiffness, in vitro assays showed that Acvr1^R206H/+ cells inappropriately sense their environment, responding to soft substrates with a spread morphology similar to wild-type cells on stiff substrates and to cells undergoing osteoblastogenesis. Increased activation of RhoA and its downstream effectors demonstrated increased mechanosignaling. Nuclear localization of the pro-osteoblastic factor RUNX2 on soft and stiff substrates suggests a predisposition to this cell fate. Our data support that increased BMP signaling in Acvr1^R206H/+ cells alters the tissue microenvironment and results in misinterpretation of the tissue microenvironment through altered sensitivity to mechanical stimuli that lowers the threshold for commitment to chondro/osteogenic lineages.

Injury of Adult Zebrafish Expressing Acvr1lQ204D Does Not Result in Heterotopic Ossification

Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP) is a rare, autosomal dominant genetic disorder in humans characterized by the gradual ossification of fibrous tissues, including skeletal muscle, tendons, and ligaments. In humans, mutations in the Type I BMP/TGFβ family member receptor gene, ACVR1, are associated with FOP. Zebrafish acvr1l, previously known as alk8, is the functional ortholog of human ACVR1. We previously created and characterized the first adult zebrafish model for FOP by generating animals harboring heat shock-inducible mCherry-tagged constitutively active Acvr1l (Q204D). Since injury is a known trigger for heterotopic ossification (HO) development in human FOP patients, in this study, we investigated several injury models in Acvr1l^Q204D-expressing zebrafish and the subsequent formation of HO. We performed studies of Activin A injection, cardiotoxin (CTX) injection, and caudal fin clip injury. We found that none of these methods resulted in HO formation at the site of injury. However, some of the cardiotoxin-injected and caudal fin-clipped animals did exhibit HO at distant sites, including the body cavity and along the spine. We describe these results in the context of new and exciting reports on FOP, and discuss future studies to better understand the etiology and progression of this disease.

Variable signaling activity by FOP ACVR1 mutations

Most patients with fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP), a rare genetic disorder of heterotopic ossification, have the same causative mutation in ACVR1, R206H. However, additional mutations within the ACVR1 BMP type I receptor have been identified in a small number of FOP cases, often in patients with disease of lesser or greater severity than occurs with R206H mutations. Genotype-phenotype correlations have been suggested in patients, resulting in classification of FOP mutations based on location within different receptor domains and structural modeling. However while each of the mutations induces increased signaling through the BMP-pSmad1/5/8 pathway, the molecular mechanisms underlying functional differences of these FOP variant receptors remained undetermined. We now demonstrate that FOP mutations within the ACVR1 receptor kinase domain are more sensitive to low levels of BMP than mutations in the ACVR1 GS domain. Our data additionally confirm responsiveness of cells with FOP ACVR1 mutations to both BMP and Activin A ligands. We also have determined that constructs with FOP ACVR1 mutations that are engineered without the ligand-binding domain retain increased BMP-pSmad1/5/8 pathway activation relative to wild-type ACVR1, supporting that the mutant receptors can function through ligand-independent mechanisms either directly through mutant ACVR1 or through indirect mechanisms.

Heterotopic ossification: Mechanistic insights and clinical challenges

Bone formation is exquisitely controlled both spatially and temporally. Heterotopic ossification (HO) is pathological bone formation in soft tissues that often leads to deleterious outcomes. Inherited genetic forms of HO can be life-threatening and can happen as early as in infancy. However, there is currently no effective treatment for HO as the underlying cellular and molecular mechanisms have not been completely elucidated. Trauma-induced non-genetic forms of HO often occur as a common complication after surgeries or accidents, and the location of HO occurrence largely determines the symptom and outcome. While it has been difficult to determine the complicated factors causing HO, recent advancement in identifying cellular and molecular mechanism causing the genetic forms of HO may provide important insights in all HO. Here in this review, we summarize recent studies on HO to provide a current status of both clinical options of HO treatments and mechanical understanding of HO.

Heterotopic bone induction via BMP signaling: Potential therapeutic targets for fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva

More than 50years ago, Marshal M. Urist detected "heterotopic bone-inducing activity" in demineralized bone matrix. This unique activity was referred to as "bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)" because it was sensitive to trypsin digestion. Purification of the bone-inducing activity from demineralized bone matrix using a bone-inducing assay in vivo indicated that the original "BMP" consisted of a mixture of new members of the transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) family. The establishment of new in vitro assay systems that reflect the bone-inducing activity of BMPs in vivo have revealed the functional receptors and downstream effectors of BMPs. Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare genetic disorder characterized by progressive heterotopic bone formation in soft tissues similar to the event induced by the transplantation of BMPs in skeletal muscle. In patients with FOP, genetic mutations have been identified in the ACVR1 gene, which encodes the BMP receptor ALK2. The mutations in ALK2 associated with FOP are hypersensitive to type II receptor kinases. Recently, activin A, a non-osteogenic member of the TGF-β family, was identified as the ligand of the mutant ALK2 in FOP, and various types of signaling inhibitors for mutant ALK2 are currently under development to establish effective treatments for FOP.

Stem cells and heterotopic ossification: Lessons from animal models

Put most simply, heterotopic ossification (HO) is the abnormal formation of bone at extraskeletal sites. HO can be classified into two main subtypes, genetic and acquired. Acquired HO is a common complication of major connective tissue injury, traumatic central nervous system injury, and surgical interventions, where it can cause significant pain and postoperative disability. A particularly devastating form of HO is manifested in the rare genetic disorder, fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP), in which progressive heterotopic bone formation occurs throughout life, resulting in painful and disabling cumulative immobility. While the central role of stem/progenitor cell populations in HO is firmly established, the identity of the offending cell type(s) remains to be conclusively determined, and little is known of the mechanisms that direct these progenitor cells to initiate cartilage and bone formation. In this review, we summarize current knowledge of the cells responsible for acquired HO and FOP, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of animal models used to interrogate the cellular origins of HO.

The Horizon of a Therapy for Rare Genetic Diseases: A "Druggable" Future for Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare genetic condition characterized by progressive extra-skeletal ossification leading to cumulative and severe disability. FOP has an extremely variable and episodic course and can be induced by trauma, infections, iatrogenic harms, immunization or can occur in an unpredictable way, without any recognizable trigger. The causative gene is ACVR1, encoding the Alk-2 type I receptor for bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). The signaling is initiated by BMP binding to a receptor complex consisting of type I and II molecules and can proceed into the cell through two main pathways, a canonical, SMAD-dependent signaling and a p38-mediated cascade. Most FOP patients carry the recurrent R206H substitution in the receptor Glycine-Serine rich (GS) domain, whereas a few other mutations are responsible for a limited number of cases. Mutations cause a dysregulation of the downstream BMP-dependent pathway and make mutated ACVR1 responsive to a non-canonical ligand, Activin A. There is no etiologic treatment for FOP. However, many efforts are currently ongoing to find specific therapies targeting the receptor activity and the downstream aberrant pathway at different levels or targeting cellular components and/or processes that are important in modifying the local environment leading to bone neo-formation.

Animal models of fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva

Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva is a rare human disease of heterotopic ossification. FOP patients experience progressive development of ectopic bone within fibrous tissues that contributes to a gradual loss of mobility and can lead to early mortality. Due to lack of understanding of the etiology and progression of human FOP, and the fact that surgical interventions often exacerbate FOP disease progression, alternative therapeutic methods are needed, including modeling in animals, to study and improve understanding of human FOP. In this review we provide an overview of the existing animal models of FOP and the key mechanistic findings from each. In addition, we highlight the specific advantages of a new adult zebrafish model, generated by our lab, to study human FOP. Developmental Dynamics 247:279-288, 2018. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cell Immunophenotyping in Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva Patients: Evidence for Monocyte DNAM1 Up-regulation

BACKGROUND

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare genetic disorder caused by sporadic heterozygous mutations in ACVR1 gene which progressively leads to severe heterotopic ossification. FOP is characterized by episodic flare-ups triggered by different factors such as viral infections, tissue injuries, vaccinations, or occurring without a recognizable cause. The sporadic course of the disease, the documented presence of an important inflammatory reaction in early lesions and the partial response to corticosteroids support the idea that the immune system, and in particular the innate component, may play a role in FOP pathogenesis. However, an extensive expression profile of the peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) of FOP patients has never been done.

METHODS

In this study, we carried out a wide PBMC immunophenotyping on a cohort of FOP patients and matching controls by multiparametric analysis of the expression of a panel of 37 markers associated with migration, adhesion, inhibition, activation, and cell death of circulating immune cells.

RESULTS

We observed a statistically significant increase of the expression of DNAM1 receptor in patients' monocytes as compared to controls, and little but significant differences in the expression profile of CXCR1 (CD181), CD62L, CXCR4 (CD184), and HLA-DR molecules.

CONCLUSIONS

DNAM1 had been previously shown to play a pivotal role in monocyte migration through the endothelial barrier and the increased expression detected in patients' monocytes might suggest a role of this surface receptor during the early phases of FOP flare-ups in which the activation of the immune response is believed to represent a crucial event. © 2017 International Clinical Cytometry Society.

The immunophilin FKBP12 inhibits hepcidin expression by binding the BMP type I receptor ALK2 in hepatocytes

The expression of the key regulator of iron homeostasis hepcidin is activated by the BMP-SMAD pathway in response to iron and inflammation and among drugs, by rapamycin, which inhibits mTOR in complex with the immunophilin FKBP12. FKBP12 interacts with BMP type I receptors to avoid uncontrolled signaling. By pharmacologic and genetic studies, we identify FKBP12 as a novel hepcidin regulator. Sequestration of FKBP12 by rapamycin or tacrolimus activates hepcidin both in vitro and in murine hepatocytes. Acute tacrolimus treatment transiently increases hepcidin in wild-type mice. FKBP12 preferentially targets the BMP receptor ALK2. ALK2 mutants defective in binding FKBP12 increase hepcidin expression in a ligand-independent manner, through BMP-SMAD signaling. ALK2 free of FKBP12 becomes responsive to the noncanonical inflammatory ligand Activin A. Our results identify a novel hepcidin regulator and a potential therapeutic target to increase defective BMP signaling in disorders of low hepcidin.

A Zebrafish Model of Human Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a rare, autosomal dominant genetic disorder in humans characterized by explosive inflammatory response to injury leading to gradual ossification within fibrous tissues, including skeletal muscle, tendons, and ligaments. A variety of animal models are needed to study and understand the etiology of human FOP. To address this need, here we present characterizations of the first adult zebrafish model for FOP. In humans, activating mutations in the Type I BMP/TGFβ family member receptor, ACVR1, are associated with FOP. Zebrafish acvr1l, previously known as alk8, is the functional ortholog of human ACVR1, and has been studied extensively in the developing zebrafish embryo, where it plays a role in early dorsoventral patterning. Constitutively active and dominant negative mutations in zebrafish acvr1l cause early lethal defects. Therefore, to study roles for activating acvr1l mutations in adult zebrafish, we created transgenic animals expressing mCherry-tagged, heat-shock-inducible constitutively active Acvr1l, Acvr1l^Q204D, to investigate phenotypes in juvenile and adult zebrafish. Our studies showed that adult zebrafish expressing heat-shock-induced Acvr1l^Q204D develop a number of human FOP-like phenotypes, including heterotopic ossification lesions, spinal lordosis, vertebral fusions, and malformed pelvic fins. Together, these results suggest that transgenic zebrafish expressing heat-shock-inducible Acvr1l^Q204D can serve as a model for human FOP.

The Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP) mutation p.R206H in ACVR1 confers an altered ligand response

Patients with Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP) suffer from ectopic bone formation, which progresses during life and results in dramatic movement restrictions. Cause of the disease are point mutations in the Activin A receptor type 1 (ACVR1), with p.R206H being most common. In this study we compared the signalling responses of ACVR1^WT and ACVR1^R206H to different ligands. ACVR1^WT, but not ACVR1^R206H inhibited BMP signalling of BMP2 or BMP4 in a ligand binding domain independent manner. Likewise, the basal BMP signalling activity of the receptor BMPR1A or BMPR1B was inhibited by ACVR1^WT, but enhanced by ACVR1^R206H. In comparison, BMP6 or BMP7 activated ACVR1^WT and caused a hyper-activation of ACVR1^R206H. These effects were dependent on an intact ligand binding domain. Finally, the neofunction of Activin A in FOP was tested and found to depend on the ligand binding domain for activating ACVR1^R206H. We conclude that the FOP mutation ACVR1^R206H is more sensitive to a number of natural ligands. The mutant receptor apparently lost some essential inhibitory interactions with its ligands and co-receptors, thereby conferring an enhanced ligand-dependent signalling and stimulating ectopic bone formation as observed in the patients.

Palovarotene Inhibits Heterotopic Ossification and Maintains Limb Mobility and Growth in Mice With the Human ACVR1(R206H) Fibrodysplasia Ossificans Progressiva (FOP) Mutation

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP), a rare and as yet untreatable genetic disorder of progressive extraskeletal ossification, is the most disabling form of heterotopic ossification (HO) in humans and causes skeletal deformities, movement impairment, and premature death. Most FOP patients carry an activating mutation in a bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) type I receptor gene, ACVR1(R206H) , that promotes ectopic chondrogenesis and osteogenesis and, in turn, HO. We showed previously that the retinoic acid receptor γ (RARγ) agonist palovarotene effectively inhibited HO in injury-induced and genetic mouse models of the disease. Here we report that the drug additionally prevents spontaneous HO, using a novel conditional-on knock-in mouse line carrying the human ACVR1(R206H) mutation for classic FOP. In addition, palovarotene restored long bone growth, maintained growth plate function, and protected growing mutant neonates when given to lactating mothers. Importantly, palovarotene maintained joint, limb, and body motion, providing clear evidence for its encompassing therapeutic potential as a treatment for FOP. © 2016 American Society for Bone and Mineral Research.

Mutant activin-like kinase 2 in fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva are activated via T203 by BMP type II receptors

Fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva (FOP) is a genetic disorder characterized by progressive heterotopic ossification in soft tissues, such as the skeletal muscles. FOP has been shown to be caused by gain-of-function mutations in activin receptor-like kinase (ALK)-2, which is a type I receptor for bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). In the present study, we examined the molecular mechanisms that underlie the activation of intracellular signaling by mutant ALK2. Mutant ALK2 from FOP patients enhanced the activation of intracellular signaling by type II BMP receptors, such as BMPR-II and activin receptor, type II B, whereas that from heart disease patients did not. This enhancement was dependent on the kinase activity of the type II receptors. Substitution mutations at all nine serine and threonine residues in the ALK2 glycine- and serine-rich domain simultaneously inhibited this enhancement by the type II receptors. Of the nine serine and threonine residues in ALK2, T203 was found to be critical for the enhancement by type II receptors. The T203 residue was conserved in all of the BMP type I receptors, and these residues were essential for intracellular signal transduction in response to ligand stimulation. The phosphorylation levels of the mutant ALK2 related to FOP were higher than those of wild-type ALK2 and were further increased by the presence of type II receptors. The phosphorylation levels of ALK2 were greatly reduced in mutants carrying a mutation at T203, even in the presence of type II receptors. These findings suggest that the mutant ALK2 related to FOP is enhanced by BMP type II receptors via the T203-regulated phosphorylation of ALK2.