A Systematic Review of Benefit-Finding and Growth in Pediatric Medical Populations

Longitudinal Dyadic Associations in Benefit Finding and in Fear of Cancer Recurrence Between Childhood Cancer Survivors and Their Parents: Examining Actor and Partner Effects

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Childhood cancer survivors and their parents report both positive and negative psychological late effects, such as fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) and benefit finding. The current study investigated longitudinal dyadic associations among childhood cancer survivors, their mothers, and fathers in benefit finding and FCR to obtain an in-depth understanding of family functioning after pediatric cancer.

METHODS

This three-wave longitudinal study (covering 2 years) included survivors (aged 14-24, time since diagnosis 2-22 years at T1) and their parents; all reported on benefit finding and FCR. Reciprocal effects in three dyads were examined: (1) survivor-mother dyad (n = 114 at T1), (2) survivor-father dyad (n = 82 at T1), and (3) mother-father dyad (n = 80 at T1). Cross-lagged panel models examined actor and partner effects across time for benefit finding and FCR separately.

RESULTS

Actor effects were significant in all models. Dyadic partner effects were found between parents. First, mothers' benefit finding predicted relative increases in fathers' benefit finding across both time intervals. Second, mothers' FCR predicted relative increases in fathers' FCR from T1 to T2, and fathers' FCR predicted relative increases in mothers' FCR from T2 to T3. Moreover, significant correlated changes were found between parents' FCR at T2 and T3.

CONCLUSION

Results support substantial actor effects and some dyadic partner effects between parents in experiencing psychological late effects. To improve survivorship care for families, psychological late effects of each family member and their interplay between members-especially among parents-needs to be taken into account, both in research and clinical practice.

Benefit Finding and Growth Among Family Caregivers of Individuals With Mental Illness: A Scoping Review

Benefit finding is a concept that represents finding positive changes or benefits through difficult experiences. To map the currently available studies on benefit finding and growth among family caregivers of individuals with mental illness, we conducted a scoping review based on methodological frameworks. A systematic search for studies published in English was conducted using MEDLINE, PsycINFO, PsycARTICLES, CINAHL, and PTSDpubs from inception to August 2023. After screening, 21 articles were included in the review. Of these, 11 studies were cross-sectional studies, 7 were qualitative studies, 2 were mixed-methods studies, and a randomized controlled trial (RCT). Family caregivers experienced various positive psychological changes, such as becoming compassionate/tolerant and resilient, stronger family bonds, change in perspective on life and hope, acquisition of knowledge and coping strategies, and leveraging their experiences and appreciation by others, following various struggles and negative changes. Some indicators of benefit finding and growth, such as positive personal traits, positive reappraisal, good relationships with patients, and social support, were also revealed. The quality assessment demonstrated an acceptable level of quality in most studies, with a few outliers. Future longitudinal studies would reveal the mechanism of benefit finding and growth among family caregivers of individuals with mental illness.

Benefit Finding in Craniofacial Conditions: A Qualitative Analysis of Patient and Parent Perspectives

OBJECTIVE

Craniofacial conditions (CFCs) can be associated with adverse effects on quality of life (QoL). However, few studies have examined perceived benefits related to CFCs. This study described perceived benefits in an international sample of children and adolescents with CFCs and their parents.

DESIGN

Semistructured qualitative interviews were completed in English or Spanish as part of a larger study. Deductive content analysis described and quantified perceived benefits associated with CFCs.

SETTING

Interviews were during standard visits at Rady Children's Hospital-San Diego in the USA and the Hospital Infantil de las Californias in Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients were ages 7 to 20 years (n = 32) with CFCs (cleft lip and/or palate, craniosynostosis, microtia, hemifacial microsomia, dermatologic conditions/neurovascular malformations, and trauma-acquired CFC), and parents (n = 71) had children ages 5 months to 23 years with CFCs. Of the total sample, there were 14 patient-parent dyads.

RESULTS

A total of 230 benefits were identified. Of the patients (47%) and parents (73%) who identified at least 1 benefit, themes included personal growth (40%), understanding or helping others facing challenges (25%), social relationships (23%), spiritual or religious beliefs (4%), philanthropy (4%), material or external gains (3%), and personal health (1%).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with CFCs and their parents report multiple positive effects of CFCs on their QoL. These findings indicate that benefit finding is a common experience in this population and may be leveraged by clinicians to help promote positive adjustment to living with a CFC.

Inclusive measure development: amplifying the voices of adolescents and young adults with spina bifida in a new measure of benefit-finding and growth

OBJECTIVE

Benefit-finding and growth is an important process across a range of medical populations. However, it has been understudied in the context of lifelong chronic conditions, such as spina bifida (SB). This study aimed to develop a new measure of benefit-finding and growth for youth with SB, confirm its factor structure, and examine its psychometric properties.

METHOD

To generate items for the new measure, 20 adolescents and young adults with SB completed qualitative interviews regarding their experience of living with SB. Interviews were coded for benefits. Questionnaire items were generated from these benefits, and an expert panel refined the wording of these items. The resultant 31-item measure was shared with six of the 20 participants for feedback and then piloted among 251 youth with SB. The factor structure of the measure was confirmed and reliability and convergent validity were assessed.

RESULTS

Both a one- and four-factor structure were supported. The four factors include: Life Perspectives and Priorities, Personal Characteristics and Traits, Connections and Opportunities, and Problem Solving. Higher total and factor scores represent greater benefit-finding and growth. The measure demonstrated excellent internal consistency (α = 0.95). The new measure also showed significant positive correlations with optimism, positive affect, and life satisfaction.

CONCLUSIONS

This study produced a measure of benefit-finding and growth for youth with SB. Clinically, information about what youth with SB perceive to be their areas of strength and growth from their condition provides crucial insight into which factors to enhance in this population.

Factors associated with positive mental health in Japanese young adults with a history of chronic diseases during childhood: A qualitative study

PURPOSE

Factors associated with positive mental health in children with chronic diseases remain unclear. Supporting the development of positive mental health in children with chronic diseases can enhance their mental health throughout childhood and adulthood. This study aimed to identify the factors associated with positive mental health among Japanese young adults with a history of chronic pediatric diseases.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Participants aged 18-25 years, with a history of chronic pediatric diseases, were recruited from a population of students at a university. Semi-structured interviews were conducted. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis. After the initial coding of each transcript, the researchers discussed and identified a set of main themes, categories, and subcategories.

RESULTS

Ten participants aged 19-22 years were interviewed. Their chronic diseases were diverse and included childhood cancers and allergic diseases. Seven themes (proactive coping, positive coping, negative coping, eudaimonia, hedonia, independence, and awareness) emerged from 21 categories and 70 subcategories identified. A thematic map was applied to two domains (protective factors and well-being factors) and to three inter-related constructs (individual, family, and community/society).

CONCLUSIONS

The findings indicated that within the well-being factors, meaning in life was prominent, and within the protective factors, stress coping was found to facilitate positive mental health among individuals with a history of chronic pediatric diseases.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

In children with chronic diseases, support for finding appropriate coping strategies that enhance their optimism and symbiotic relationships in the community/society are important, including valuing little things in their lives, such as play and learning.

Testing a model of benefit-finding and growth in youths with chronic health conditions

BACKGROUND

The experience of benefit-finding and growth (BFG), defined as perceiving positive life changes resulting from adversity, is increasingly studied among youths with chronic health conditions (CCs). However, empirical evidence is scarce for explaining individual differences in BFG. The study aimed to test a model of BFG, including an interplay of personal and environmental factors and coping processes.

METHODS

A sample of N = 498 youths (12-21 years) recruited from three German patient registries for CCs (type 1 diabetes: n = 388, juvenile idiopathic arthritis: n = 82, cystic fibrosis: n = 28) completed a questionnaire including self-reported optimism, social support from parents and peers, coping strategies, and BFG. The model was created to reflect the theoretical assumptions of the Life Crisis and Personal Growth model and current empirical evidence. Structural equation modeling was conducted to evaluate the incremental explanatory power of optimism, peer group integration, parental support, acceptance, cognitive reappraisal, and seeking social support over and above sociodemographic and disease-related characteristics.

RESULTS

The model (CFI = 0.93; RMSEA = 0.04; SRMR = 0.05) explained 32% of the variance in BFG. Controlling for sociodemographic and disease-related characteristics, acceptance, cognitive reappraisal, and seeking social support were directly and positively linked to BFG. All tested coping strategies significantly mediated the association between optimism and BFG, whereas seeking social support significantly mediated the relation between peer group integration and BFG.

DISCUSSION

The study stresses the prominent role of emotion-focused coping strategies and peer group integration in enhancing BFG in youths with CCs.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

German Clinical Trials Register (DRKS), no. DRKS00025125. Registered on May 17, 2021.

Profiles of Resilience, Distress, and Posttraumatic Growth in Parents of Children with Cancer and the Relation to Subsequent Parenting and Family Functioning

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to identify patterns of distress and growth in parents of children with cancer and examine associations with subsequent parenting, parent-child relationship, and family environment.

METHODS

Participants included children with cancer history (8-17 years) stratified by time since diagnosis and their parent. At enrollment, parents (n = 254) reported depression and anxiety, and post-traumatic stress symptoms, posttraumatic growth (PTG), and benefit finding in relation to their child's cancer. Three years later, children (n = 214) reported parenting behavior, parent reactions to their distress, and family environment. Parents reported their reaction to children's distress and qualities of the parent-child relationship.

RESULTS

Latent profile analysis empirically identified 3 cross-sectional profiles using baseline data: "Resilience, High Growth" (50%), characterized by the lowest distress and the highest PTG/benefit finding; "Moderate Distress with Growth" (33%), characterized by relatively high levels of all indicators; and "Resilience, Low Growth" (17%), characterized by relatively low distress with low PTG/benefit finding. Membership in profiles was associated with parent gender; parents' stressful life events; socioeconomic status; and child diagnosis, on versus off treatment status, and treatment intensity. Parent membership in the Moderate Distress with Growth profile was generally linked with poorer parenting behavior, parent-child relationship quality, and family functioning.

CONCLUSION

The majority of parents exhibited resilience and growth. However, a subset of parents displaying moderate distress may be at risk for subsequent parenting and family functioning challenges. Findings further highlight the importance of screening for even moderate parent distress and the possible impact of parent psychosocial interventions indirectly on parenting and family functioning.

Trajectories of Marital Satisfaction among Parents of Youth with Spina Bifida

OBJECTIVE

This study examined marital satisfaction among parents of youth with spina bifida (SB) over an 8-year period and investigated the usefulness of the double ABCX model for understanding factors that predict change in marital satisfaction across child age.

METHODS

Data from five time points of a longitudinal investigation of psychosocial outcomes in youth with SB were included. Mothers and fathers of children with SB (aged 8-17) reported on marital satisfaction and components of the double ABCX model. Change in marital satisfaction was examined across child age with components of the double ABCX model, as well as interactions between components, as predictors.

RESULTS

Marital satisfaction was significantly higher in the present sample than in a normative sample of married couples. Although there were no significant changes in marital satisfaction for either parent as a function of child age, there was significant variability for the intercept and slope of maternal and paternal marital satisfaction within the sample. Family support predicted a higher intercept, and mental health symptoms predicted a lower intercept, for maternal and paternal marital satisfaction. More stressors and SB-related family stress predicted a lower intercept for paternal marital satisfaction. Family support and family stress attributed to SB moderated the relationship between child vulnerability and maternal marital satisfaction. Observed family cohesion and child psychosocial quality of life moderated the relationship between family stressors and paternal marital satisfaction.

CONCLUSION

Findings demonstrate the usefulness of the double ABCX model for this population.