Renal cancer and malformations in relatives of patients with Bardet-Biedl syndrome

Ocular manifestations in renal diseases

The eyes and kidneys are the targets for end-organ damage in multiple pathologies. Both these organs develop during the same embryonic stage around the fourth to sixth week of gestation, thus sharing a strong correlation between both eye and kidney diseases. Both the eyes and kidneys can be the target of the systemic disease process; however, the eyes can also be affected as a consequence of renal disease or its treatment. Risk factors such as diabetes, hypertension, and smoking are commonly shared between kidney and eye diseases. Ocular manifestations can be predictive of renal disease, and/or patients with renal disease are at higher risk for developing ocular manifestations. Various congenital anomalies of the eyes and kidneys can also present as an oculorenal syndrome. This article summarizes the ocular pathology, which can be seen in renal diseases.

Bardet-Biedl Syndrome: Current Perspectives and Clinical Outlook

The Bardet Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a rare inherited disorder considered a model of non-motile ciliopathy. It is in fact caused by mutations of genes encoding for proteins mainly localized to the base of the cilium. Clinical features of BBS patients are widely shared with patients suffering from other ciliopathies, especially autosomal recessive syndromic disorders; moreover, mutations in cilia-related genes can cause different clinical ciliopathy entities. Besides the best-known clinical features, as retinal degeneration, learning disabilities, polydactyly, obesity and renal defects, several additional clinical signs have been reported in BBS, expanding our understanding of the complexity of its clinical spectrum. The present review aims to describe the current knowledge of BBS i) pathophysiology, ii) clinical manifestations, highlighting both the most common and the less described features, iii) current and future perspective for treatment.

Retinitis Pigmentosa and Polydactyly in a Patient with a Heterozygous Mutation on the BBS1 Gene

Purpose

To report retinitis pigmentosa and a history of polydactyly in a Bardet–Biedl syndrome mutation carrier.

Observations

A 25-year-old male presented to the clinic complaining of poor visual acuity since childhood, night-blindness, and progressive peripheral vision loss. The patient also had a history of polydactyly in both feet. Ophthalmic evaluation was remarkable for a best-corrected visual acuity of 20/400 in both eyes. Imaging revealed a “salt-and-pepper” appearance surrounding the macula, bone-spicule retinal pigment epithelium hyperplasia, paravenous retinal pigment epithelium hyperplasia, and arteriolar attenuation. In addition, bilateral macular autofluorescence with a surrounding granular hypoautofluorescence and an additional hyperautofluorescent zone was present. Full-field ERG results showed non-recordable scotopic ERG responses and diminished photopic ERG responses OU, consistent with progressive rod-cone dystrophy. Genetic testing was positive for a pathogenic heterozygous mutation in the BBS1 gene of the variant c.1169T>G (p.Met390Arg) and several variants of uncertain significance in other genes.

Conclusions and Importance

Ascertainment of the inheritance patterns in BBS is an evolving discussion. Our case, a BBS carrier with retinitis pigmentosa and a history of polydactyly, could support previous research suggesting non-Mendelian genetics in this ciliopathy. Furthermore, genetic testing and analyses of additional mutations and variants of uncertain significance could potentially explain the reason for BBS-like phenotype in presumed BBS carriers.

Bardet-Biedl Syndrome in rhesus macaques: A nonhuman primate model of retinitis pigmentosa

The development of therapies for retinal disorders is hampered by a lack of appropriate animal models. Higher nonhuman primates are the only animals with retinal structure similar to humans, including the presence of a macula and fovea. However, few nonhuman primate models of genetic retinal disease are known. We identified a lineage of rhesus macaques with a frameshift mutation in exon 3 of the BBS7 gene c.160delG (p.Ala54fs) that is predicted to produce a non-functional protein. In humans, mutations in this and other BBS genes cause Bardet-Biedl syndrome, a ciliopathy and a syndromic form of retinitis pigmentosa generally occurring in conjunction with kidney dysfunction, polydactyly, obesity, and/or hypogonadism. Three full- or half-sibling monkeys homozygous for the BBS7 c.160delG variant, at ages 3.5, 4 and 6 years old, displayed a combination of severe photoreceptor degeneration and progressive kidney disease. In vivo retinal imaging revealed features of severe macular degeneration, including absence of photoreceptor layers, degeneration of the retinal pigment epithelium, and retinal vasculature atrophy. Electroretinography in the 3.5-year-old case demonstrated loss of scotopic and photopic a-waves and markedly reduced and delayed b-waves. Histological assessments in the 4- and 6-year-old cases confirmed profound loss of photoreceptors and inner retinal neurons across the posterior retina, with dramatic thinning and disorganization of all cell layers, abundant microglia, absent or displaced RPE cells, and significant gliosis in the subretinal space. Retinal structure, including presence of photoreceptors, was preserved only in the far periphery. Ultrasound imaging of the kidneys revealed deranged architecture, and renal histopathology identified distorted contours with depressed, fibrotic foci and firmly adhered renal capsules; renal failure occurred in the 6-year-old case. Magnetic resonance imaging obtained in one case revealed abnormally low total brain volume and unilateral ventricular enlargement. The one male had abnormally small testes at 4 years of age, but polydactyly and obesity were not observed. Thus, monkeys homozygous for the BBS7 c.160delG variant closely mirrored several key features of the human BBS syndrome. This finding represents the first identification of a naturally-occurring nonhuman primate model of BBS, and more broadly the first such model of retinitis pigmentosa and a ciliopathy with an associated genetic mutation. This important new preclinical model will provide the basis for better understanding of disease progression and for the testing of new therapeutic options, including gene and cell-based therapies, not only for BBS but also for multiple forms of photoreceptor degeneration.

Screening for mutation hotspots in Bardet-Biedl syndrome patients from India

Background & objectives:

Bardet–Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a genetically heterogeneous autosomal recessive disorder characterized by multiple organ defects involving retina, kidney, liver and brain. Disease-causing mutations in BBS genes narrowed down by homozygosity mapping in small consanguineous and non-consanguineous pedigrees were reported in 80 per cent of the study population. This study was aimed to screen these genes (BBS3, BBS10) and specific exons of BBS genes (BBS1, BBS5, MKKS, BBS9, BBS11 and BBS12) for recurrent mutations in a selected sample of BBS patients.

Methods:

The recurrent mutations in BBS genes were screened in the BBS affected individuals by PCR based direct sequencing. The pathogenicity of the observed mutations were confirmed by co-segregation analysis, screening of healthy unrelated controls and in silico analysis.

Results:

In the 64 BBS patients (44 males, 20 females) were studied, mutations were predominant in BBS10 and ARL6 genes; the c.272T>C; p.(I91T) mutation in ARL6 gene was a recurrent mutation. One novel non-sense mutation c.425T>G; p(L142^*) was obtained in BBS5 gene (family BSI-31).

Interpretation & conclusions:

BBS10 gene mutations clustered in exon 2 of the gene suggesting the exon as a probable hotspot for mutations in Indian population. A cost- and time-effective strategy for the molecular diagnosis of BBS was designed based on these results.

Bardet-Biedl syndrome: Genetics, molecular pathophysiology, and disease management

Primary cilia play a key role in sensory perception and various signaling pathways. Any defect in them leads to group of disorders called ciliopathies, and Bardet–Biedl syndrome (BBS, OMIM 209900) is one among them. The disorder is clinically and genetically heterogeneous, with various primary and secondary clinical manifestations, and shows autosomal recessive inheritance and highly prevalent in inbred/consanguineous populations. The disease mapped to at least twenty different genes (BBS1-BBS20), follow oligogenic inheritance pattern. BBS proteins localizes to the centerosome and regulates the biogenesis and functions of the cilia. In BBS, the functioning of various systemic organs (with ciliated cells) gets deranged and results in systemic manifestations. Certain components of the disease (such as obesity, diabetes, and renal problems) when noticed earlier offer a disease management benefit to the patients. However, the awareness of the disease is comparatively low and most often noticed only after severe vision loss in patients, which is usually in the first decade of the patient's age. In the current review, we have provided the recent updates retrieved from various types of scientific literature through journals, on the genetics, its molecular relevance, and the clinical outcome in BBS. The review in nutshell would provide the basic awareness of the disease that will have an impact in disease management and counseling benefits to the patients and their families.

New frontiers: discovering cilia-independent functions of cilia proteins

In most vertebrates, mitotic spindles and primary cilia arise from a common origin, the centrosome. In non-cycling cells, the centrosome is the template for primary cilia assembly and, thus, is crucial for their associated sensory and signaling functions. During mitosis, the duplicated centrosomes mature into spindle poles, which orchestrate mitotic spindle assembly, chromosome segregation, and orientation of the cell division axis. Intriguingly, both cilia and spindle poles are centrosome-based, functionally distinct structures that require the action of microtubule-mediated, motor-driven transport for their assembly. Cilia proteins have been found at non-cilia sites, where they have distinct functions, illustrating a diverse and growing list of cellular processes and structures that utilize cilia proteins for crucial functions. In this review, we discuss cilia-independent functions of cilia proteins and re-evaluate their potential contributions to "cilia" disorders.

Functional aspects of primary cilia in signaling, cell cycle and tumorigenesis

Dysfunctional cilia underlie a broad range of cellular and tissue phenotypes and can eventually result in the development of ciliopathies: pathologically diverse diseases that range from clinically mild to highly complex and severe multi-organ failure syndromes incompatible with neonatal life. Given that virtually all cells of the human body have the capacity to generate cilia, it is likely that clinical manifestations attributed to ciliary dysfunction will increase in the years to come. Disputed but nevertheless enigmatic is the notion that at least a subset of tumor phenotypes fit within the ciliopathy disease spectrum and that cilia loss may be required for tumor progression. Contending for the centrosome renders ciliation and cell division mutually exclusive; a regulated tipping of balance promotes either process. The mechanisms involved, however, are complex. If the hypothesis that tumorigenesis results from dysfunctional cilia is true, then why do the classic ciliopathies only show limited hyperplasia at best? Although disassembly of the cilium is a prerequisite for cell proliferation, it does not intrinsically drive tumorigenesis per se. Alternatively, we will explore the emerging evidence suggesting that some tumors depend on ciliary signaling. After reviewing the structure, genesis and signaling of cilia, the various ciliopathy syndromes and their genetics, we discuss the current debate of tumorigenesis as a ciliopathy spectrum defect, and describe recent advances in this fascinating field.

Bardet-Biedl syndrome

Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a rare autosomal recessive ciliopathy characterised by retinal dystrophy, obesity, post-axial polydactyly, renal dysfunction, learning difficulties and hypogonadism. Many associated minor features can be helpful in making a diagnosis and are important in the clinical management of BBS. The diagnosis is based on clinical findings and can be confirmed by sequencing of known disease-causing genes in 80% of patients. BBS genes encode proteins that localise to the cilia and basal body and are involved in cilia biogenesis and function. Mutations lead to defective cilia accounting in part for the pleiotropic effects observed in BBS. We provide an overview of BBS including the clinical findings, current understanding of cilia biology, and a practical approach to diagnosis, genetic counselling and up-to-date management.

Phenotypic variability of Bardet-Biedl syndrome: focusing on the kidney

Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a multisystemic developmental disorder diagnosed on the basis of the presence of obesity, retinal defects, polydactyly, hypogonadism, renal dysfunction, and learning disabilities. The syndrome is genetically heterogeneous with 14 BBS genes identified to date. Since the cloning of the first gene in 2000, a combination of genetic, in vitro, and in vivo studies have highlighted ciliary dysfunction as a primary cause of BBS pathology. Pleiotropy of ciliopathy phenotypes and complex genetic interactions between causal and modifying alleles of ciliary genes contribute to phenotypic variability. In particular, kidney disease in BBS is clinically heterogeneous, but is now recognized as a cardinal feature and a major cause of mortality in BBS.

Obesity control and low protein diet preserve or even improve renal functions in Bardet-Biedl syndrome: a report of two cases

Background

Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a rare autosomal-recessive disorder characterized by abdominal obesity, mental retardation, dysmorphic extremities, retinal dystrophy, hypogonadism, and kidney structural abnormalities or functional impairment. It is now considered a significant cause of chronic and end-stage renal disease in children. To the best of our knowledge there have been no previous studies on the role of diet in the management of renal functions in patients with BBS.

Case Reports

Two siblings, aged 32 and 27 years, with BBS are presented. On admission both patients were obese, with body mass indexes (BMI) of 40 and 39 kg/m². Their creatinine clearances (CrCl) were 41 and 24 mL/min. After 2 years of follow-up with a diet consisting of 0.6 g/kg/day protein and 1400 kcal/day energy, their BMI’s were decreased to 29 and 27 kg/m², whereas their CrCl’s were increased to 44 and 32 mL/min, respectively. ^99mTc-MAG3 scintigraphy also revealed improved renal function.

Conclusions

Since this syndrome most likely results in end-stage renal disease, follow-up of renal dysfunction is essential. Low protein diet and/or obesity control may slow the progression of renal failure in patients with BBS.

Autosomal recessive Bardet-Biedl syndrome: first-degree relatives have no predisposition to metabolic and renal disorders

Bardet-Biedl Syndrome (BBS) is an autosomal recessive, multisystem, genetically heterogeneous, ciliopathic condition caused by mutations in multiple genes. Here we sought to determine if inheritance of a single BBS mutation increased the risks of frequent disorders of this syndrome such as obesity, hypertension, and diabetes. Various metabolic and renal diseases in a cohort of 46 patients with BBS, prospectively followed for up to 28 years, were compared to recent assessments of these factors in 96 relatives with a heterozygote mutation (carriers) and 37 relatives without a contributing mutation (non-carriers). Ten mutations in 6 genes causing this syndrome were identified in 21 families from whom DNA was obtained. The body mass index or the incidences of hypertension, diabetes, or stage 3 chronic kidney diseases were found to be similar between carriers and non-carriers but were all significantly less than those of family members with BBS. Similarly, the median age of onset of hypertension or diagnosis of stage 3 kidney disease, or the diagnosis of diabetes by age 70 were all significantly lower in those with BBS than in gene carriers or non-carriers. While our study shows that metabolic and renal events occurred frequently and at an early age in BBS, the heterozygous inheritance of any of the 10 described BBS mutations did not predispose family members to obesity, diabetes, hypertension, or renal impairment.

Loss of 16q in high grade breast cancer is associated with estrogen receptor status: Evidence for progression in tumors with a luminal phenotype?

Loss of the long arm of chromosome 16 (16q) is observed in the vast majority of low grade/grade I (GI) invasive ductal carcinomas of no special type (IDC-NSTs), whereas this event is uncommonly seen in high grade/grade III (GIII) IDC-NSTs. Together with data on the pathology and genetics of breast cancer recurrences, this has led to the proposal that GI and GIII breast cancers evolve through distinct genetic pathways and that progression from GI to GIII is an unlikely biological phenomenon. We compared the genomic profiles of GIII-IDC-NSTs with 16q whole arm loss (16qWL) according to estrogen receptor (ER) status. 16qWL was found in 36.5% of cases and was significantly associated with ER expression and luminal phenotype. ER+ GIII-IDC-NSTs with 16qWL displayed significantly higher levels of genomic instability than ER+ IDC-NSTs without 16qWL. Furthermore, ER+ and ER- IDC-NSTs stratified according to the presence of 16qWL harbored distinct patterns of genetic aberrations. Interestingly, ER+/16qWL tumors displayed genetic features usually found in tumors with homologous DNA repair defects and significantly more frequently harbored heterozygous loss of BRCA2 than the remaining ER+ cancers. Our results demonstrate that approximately one third of GIII tumors harbor 16qWL, confirming that progression from low to high grade breast cancer is not found in the majority of breast cancers. 16qWL was significantly more prevalent in ER+/luminal GIII-IDC-NSTs. Given that GI breast cancers harbor a luminal phenotype, our results suggest that if progression from GI to GIII breast cancer does happen, it may preferentially occur in breast cancers of luminal phenotype.

[Bardet-Biedl syndrome]

Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a ciliopathy causing multivisceral abnormalities. Its prevalence in Europe is from 1/125,000 to 1/175,000. This disorder is defined by a combination of clinical signs: obesity, pigmentary retinopathy, post-axial polydactyly, polycystic kidneys, hypogenitalism, and learning disabilities, many of which appearing after several years of evolution. Individual clinical phenotype is highly variable. Most signs are present in a majority of patients but only pigmentary retinopathy is constant after infancy. There are many other associated minor clinical signs including diabetes, blood hypertension, congenital cardiopathy or Hirschsprung disease. This broad clinical spectrum is associated to a great genetic heterogeneity, with mainly an autosomal recessive transmission and, sometimes cases of oligogenism. To date, mutations in 12 different genes (BBS1 to BBS12) are responsible for this phenotype. These genes code for proteins involved in the development and function of primary cilia. Absent or non functional BBS proteins affect cilia in certain organs such as kidney or eye. However, some symptoms are still not clearly related to cilia dysfunction. BB syndrome has to be recognized because a molecular diagnosis is possible and will lead to familial genetic counseling and possibly prenatal diagnosis. Patients with BBS will need a multidisciplinary medical care. The renal abnormalities are the main life-threatening features because they can lead to end-stage renal failure and renal transplantation. Retinal dystrophy leading to progressive vision loss, moderate mental retardation, and obesity will affect social life of these patients.

Asymptomatic renal cell carcinoma as a finding of Bardet Biedl syndrome

Retinitis pigmentosa represents a class of disorders that exhibit dystrophy of the photoreceptors, pigment epithelium, and often systemic abnormalities, Bardet-Biedl syndrome is a form of retinitis pigmentosa that has characteristic non-ocular findings including polydactyly, obesity, learning difficulties, male hypogonadism, and renal anomalies. Though none of these renal anomalies are neoplastic, there is a 17 fold increased risk for renal cell carcinoma in obligate carriers of Bardet-Biedl syndrome. Herein, we describe a case of metastatic renal cell carcinoma discovered in a patient with Bardet-Biedl syndrome.

Bardet-Biedl syndrome: beyond the cilium

The Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a significant genetic cause of chronic and end-stage renal failure in children. Despite being a relatively rare recessive condition, BBS has come to prominence during the past few years owing to revelations of primary cilia dysfunction underlying pathogenesis. The study of this multi-system disorder, which includes obesity, cognitive impairment, genito-urinary tract malformations and limb deformities, is beginning to reveal insights into several aspects of mammalian development and organogenesis. Involvement of BBS proteins in disparate pathways such as the non-canonical Wnt and Sonic Hedgehog pathways is highlighting their interplay in disease pathogenesis. Here we review the recent developments in this emerging field, with the emphasis on the renal component of the syndrome and potential future directions.

Risk for cancer in patients with Bardet-Biedl syndrome and their relatives

Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a rare, autosomal recessive disease with retinal dystrophy leading to blindness, postaxial polydactyly, truncal obesity, learning disabilities, male hypogenitalism, and renal anomalies. Heterozygous carriers of a BBS mutation are not thought to present symptoms of BBS; however, a previous study reported an increased risk of renal cancer among relatives of patients with BBS. This finding was based on the identification of three parents with renal cell carcinoma, representing a 17-fold increased risk. We performed a population-based study in Denmark to examine the incidence of cancer in 116 BBS patients and 428 relatives (96 families) through record linkage of information from files of the Retinitis Pigmentosa Registry, the Central Population Registry, and the Danish Cancer Registry. The clinical diagnosis of BBS was molecularly confirmed in 52% of the patients. Among the patients, two cancers were reported, with 4.3 expected. The cancers were an embryonal carcinoma of the testis in a 23-year-old man and an acoustic neuroma in a 51-year-old man. Among the relatives, 30 cancers were observed, with 45.2 expected. No renal cancers were observed in the two groups. These data do not support the suggested increased risk for renal cancer in relatives of patients with BBS.

Primary central nervous system lymphoma in a renal transplant recipient with Bardet-Biedl syndrome

Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder. End-stage renal failure has been reported as the most frequent cause of death in this disorder. There are few reports of kidney transplantation in these patients. Renal transplant patients are known to be at increased risk for the development of malignancies. Although a few patients with BBS have been described to develop malignant disease, there was no previous association with lymphoma. We report a 20-year-old patient in whom primary central nervous system lymphoma was diagnosed 20 months after renal transplantation.

[Update on Bardet-Biedl syndrome]

Until recently, Bardet-Biedl syndrome was considered as a classic autosomal recessive condition. The disorder is defined by the association of the following clinical features: retinitis pigmentosa, polydactyly, obesity, hypogonadism, and possible mental retardation. This syndrome leads to multiple handicaps (visual impairment, complications of obesity, kidney failure, endocrine dysfunction). This condition, apparently clearly defined from a clinical point of view, appears to be genetically heterogenous. To date, six different genes have been identified: BBS1, BBS2, BBS4, BBS6, BBS7 and BBS8. Interestingly, this condition has recently been linked to a failure of cellular ciliogenesis. Moreover, this disorder is characterized by an additional degree of complexity, as it is the first example of triallelic inheritance described in human beings. However, this new finding appears to be less frequent than expected in this syndrome.

High incidence of malformation syndromes in a series of 1,073 children with cancer

Constitutional molecular defects are known to play a role in oncogenesis, as shown by the increased incidence of embryonic cancers in children with Beckwith-Wiedemann syndrome (BWS) or of leukemia in children with Down syndrome. To establish the incidence and spectrum of malformation syndromes associated with childhood cancer we performed a clinical morphological examination on a series of 1,073 children with cancer. We diagnosed a syndrome in 42 patients (3.9%) and suspected the presence of a syndrome in another 35 patients (3.3%), for a total of 7.2%. This incidence of patients with a proven or suspected syndrome is high, and points to a possible association. We describe new syndrome-tumor associations in several entities: cleidocranial dysostosis (Wilms tumor), Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) (acute lymphoblastic leukemia), Kabuki syndrome (neuroblastoma), LEOPARD syndrome (neuroblastoma), Poland anomaly (osteosarcoma; Hodgkin disease), and blepharophimosis epicanthus inversus syndrome (Burkitt lymphoma). Twenty of the 42 syndrome diagnoses were not recognized in the patients prior to this study, indicating that these diagnoses are commonly missed. We propose that all children with a malignancy should be examined by a clinical geneticist or a pediatrician skilled in clinical morphology to determine if the patients have a malformation syndrome.