Holistic insights from pollen omics: co-opting stress-responsive genes and ER-mediated proteostasis for male fertility

The differential transpiration response of plants to stress

An increase in the frequency and intensity of heat waves, floods, droughts and other environmental stresses, resulting from climate change, is threatening agricultural food production worldwide. Heat waves are especially problematic to grain yields, as the reproductive processes of almost all our main grain crops are highly sensitive to heat. At times, heat waves can occur together with drought, high ozone levels, pathogen infection and/or waterlogging stress that suppress the overall process of plant cooling by transpiration. We recently reported that under conditions of heat and water-deficit stress combination, the stomata on sepals and pods of soybean (Glycine max) remain open, while the stomata on leaves close. This process, termed 'differential transpiration', enabled the cooling of reproductive organs, while leaf temperature increased owing to suppressed transpiration. In this review article, we focus on the impacts on crops of heat waves occurring in isolation and of heat waves combined with drought or waterlogging stress, address the main processes impacted in plants by these stresses and discuss ways to mitigate the negative effects of isolated heat waves and of heat waves that occur together with other stresses (i.e. stress combination), on crops, with a focus on the process of differential transpiration.This article is part of the theme issue 'Crops under stress: can we mitigate the impacts of climate change on agriculture and launch the 'Resilience Revolution'?'.

Differential transpiration occurs in soybean under a wide range of water deficit and heat stress combination conditions

Differential transpiration is a newly discovered acclimation strategy of annual plants that mitigates the negative impacts of combined water deficit (WD) and heat stress (HS) on plant reproduction. Under conditions of WD + HS, transpiration of vegetative tissues is suppressed in plants such as soybean and tomato, while transpiration of reproductive tissues is not (termed 'Differential Transpiration'; DT). This newly identified acclimation process enables the cooling of reproductive organs under conditions of WD + HS, limiting HS-induced damage to plant reproduction. However, the thresholds at which DT remains active and effectively cools reproductive tissues, as well as the developmental stages at which it is activated in soybean, remain unknown. Here, we report that DT occurs at most nodes (leaf developmental stages) of soybean plants subjected to WD + HS, and that it can function under extreme conditions of WD + HS (i.e., 18% of field water capacity and 42°C combined). Our findings reveal that DT is an effective acclimation strategy that protects reproductive processes from extreme conditions of WD + HS at almost all developmental stages. In addition, our findings suggest that, under field conditions, DT could also be active in plants subjected to low or mild levels of WD during a heat wave.

Deciphering the Vulnerability of Pollen to Heat Stress for Securing Crop Yields in a Warming Climate

Climate change is leading to more frequent and severe extreme temperature events, negatively impacting agricultural productivity and threatening global food security. Plant reproduction, the process fundamental to crop yield, is highly susceptible to heatwaves, which disrupt pollen development and ultimately affect seed-set and crop yields. Recent research has increasingly focused on understanding how pollen grains from various crops react to heat stress at the molecular and cellular levels. This surge in interest over the last decade has been driven by advances in genomic technologies, such as single-cell RNA sequencing, which holds significant potential for revealing the underlying regulatory reprogramming triggered by heat stress throughout the various stages of pollen development. This review focuses on how heat stress affects gene regulatory networks, including the heat stress response, the unfolded protein response, and autophagy, and discusses the impact of these changes on various stages of pollen development. It highlights the potential of pollen selection as a key strategy for improving heat tolerance in crops by leveraging the genetic variability among pollen grains. Additionally, genome-wide association studies and population screenings have shed light on the genetic underpinnings of traits in major crops that respond to high temperatures during male reproductive stages. Gene-editing tools like CRISPR/Cas systems could facilitate precise genetic modifications to boost pollen heat resilience. The information covered in this review is valuable for selecting traits and employing molecular genetic approaches to develop heat-tolerant genotypes.

Transcriptome dynamics in the Arabidopsis male germline during pollen-pistil interactions

When pollen lands on a receptive stigma, it germinates and extends a tube inside the transmitting tissue of the pistil to deliver the sperm cells for double fertilization. The growth of the pollen tube triggers significant alterations in its gene expression. The extent to which these changes occur in the vegetative cell or extend to the sperm cells transported by the tube is unclear but important to determine since sperm cells are believed to acquire a competency for fertilization during pollen-pistil interactions. To address these questions, we compared the transcriptomes of Arabidopsis thaliana sperm cells and vegetative nuclei isolated from mature pollen grains with those isolated from in vitro-grown pollen tubes. Importantly, we also compared transcriptomes of sperm cells obtained from pollen tubes grown under semi-in vivo conditions where tubes passed through a pistil section. Our data show that extensive transcriptomic changes occur in sperm cells during pollen tube growth, some of which are elicited only as sperms are carried through the pistil. Their analysis reveals a host of previously unidentified transcripts that may facilitate sperm maturation and gamete fusion. The vegetative cell undergoes even more extensive transcriptomic reprogramming during pollen tube growth, mainly through the upregulation of genes associated with pollen tube growth and vesicle-mediated transport. Interestingly, ATAC-seq data show that the promoters of genes upregulated in sperm during pollen tube growth are already accessible in sperm chromatin of mature pollen grains, suggesting pre-configured promoter accessibility. This study's expression data can be further explored here: https://bar.utoronto.ca/eFP-Seq_Browser/.

Bioimaging insights into structural pathways of cell-to-cell communication within the male (MGU) and female (FGU) germ units of Arabidopsis thaliana

KEY MESSAGE

Cytoplasmic connections are present between cells within male and female germ units (MGU, FGU), suggesting potential structural pathways for communication. Cell-to-cell communication within the male germ unit (MGU), which consists of two sperm cells and the vegetative cell nucleus, and the female germ unit (FGU), comprising the synergids, the egg cell, and the central cell, is crucial for gamete maturation, fertilization, and early embryogenesis in angiosperms. The MGU facilitates the transport and delivery of immotile sperm cells via the elongating pollen tube to the FGU/embryo sac, which is deeply embedded within the ovule and the ovary. Through applying various bioimaging techniques at both electron and light microscopy levels, we examine the structure and the function of these units in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana, with a particular focus on potential structural pathways for communication. In the MGU, this communication is facilitated by a cytoplasmic projection that connects the sperm cells to the lobed vegetative nucleus. In the FGU, the extracellular matrix adjacent to the egg cell, central cell, and synergids plays a similar role. We discuss our findings in the context of previous studies on Hyacinthus orientalis, where, in contrast to Arabidopsis-which possesses a tricellular pollen structure-sperm cells are formed within the growing pollen tube.

The translation initiation factor eIF3M2 upregulates HEAT SHOCK PROTEIN 70 to maintain pollen tube membrane integrity during heat shock

Pollen germination and pollen tube (PT) growth are extremely sensitive to high temperatures. During heat stress (HS), global translation shuts down and favors the maintenance of the essential cellular proteome for cell viability and protection against protein misfolding. Here, we demonstrate that under normal conditions, the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) eukaryotic translation initiation factor subunit eif3m1/eif3m2 double mutant exhibits poor pollen germination, loss of PT integrity and an increased rate of aborted seeds. Surprisingly, under HS at 37 °C, eif3m1 pollen germination outperformed wild-type Col-0, showing enhanced PT integrity. We established that the improved thermotolerance of the eif3m1 PT was due to increased expression of its putative paralog eIF3M2, which in turn upregulated Heat Shock protein 70 (HSP70) mRNA and protein levels. Indeed, eIF3M2 overexpression upregulated HSP70 expression, whereas eif3m2 knockdown showed reduced HSP70.1 promoter activity and increased in PT burst under HS conditions. Moreover, we show that eIF3M2 coimmunoprecipitates with HSP70 in PTs and directly interacts with cytoplasmic HSP70.1/2/4 and eIF4G in Nicotiana benthamiana pavement cells. Collectively, our data revealed that plants employ the eIF3M2-HSP70 module as a regulator of thermotolerance to maintain PT membrane integrity and improve fertilization and seed set adaptation under high temperatures.

Enhanced pollen tube performance at high temperature contributes to thermotolerant fruit production in tomato

Rising temperature extremes during critical reproductive periods threaten the yield of major grain and fruit crops. Flowering plant reproduction depends on development of sufficient numbers of pollen grains and on their ability to generate a cellular extension, the pollen tube, which elongates through the pistil to deliver sperm cells to female gametes for double fertilization. These critical phases of the life cycle are sensitive to temperature and limit productivity under high temperature (HT). Previous studies have investigated the effects of HT on pollen development, but little is known about how HT applied during the pollen tube growth phase affects fertility. Here, we used tomato as a model fruit crop to determine how HT affects the pollen tube growth phase, taking advantage of cultivars noted for fruit production in exceptionally hot growing seasons. We found that exposure to HT solely during the pollen tube growth phase limits fruit biomass and seed set more significantly in thermosensitive cultivars than in thermotolerant cultivars. Importantly, we found that pollen tubes from the thermotolerant Tamaulipas cultivar have enhanced growth in vivo and in vitro under HT. Analysis of the pollen tube transcriptome's response to HT allowed us to develop hypotheses for the molecular basis of cellular thermotolerance in the pollen tube and we define two response modes (enhanced induction of stress responses, and higher basal levels of growth pathways repressed by heat stress) associated with reproductive thermotolerance. Importantly, we define key components of the pollen tube stress response identifying enhanced ROS homeostasis and pollen tube callose synthesis and deposition as important components of reproductive thermotolerance in Tamaulipas. Our work identifies the pollen tube growth phase as a viable target to enhance reproductive thermotolerance and delineates key pathways that are altered in crop varieties capable of fruiting under HT conditions.

A wave of specific transcript and protein accumulation accompanies pollen dehydration

In flowering plants, male gametes are immotile and carried by dry pollen grains to the female organ. Dehydrated pollen is thought to withstand abiotic stress when grains are dispersed from the anther to the pistil, after which sperm cells are delivered via pollen tube growth for fertilization and seed set. Yet, the underlying molecular changes accompanying dehydration and the impact on pollen development are poorly understood. To gain a systems perspective, we analyzed published transcriptomes and proteomes of developing Arabidopsis thaliana pollen. Waves of transcripts are evident as microspores develop to bicellular, tricellular, and mature pollen. Between the "early"- and "late"-pollen-expressed genes, an unrecognized cluster of transcripts accumulated, including those encoding late-embryogenesis abundant (LEA), desiccation-related protein, transporters, lipid-droplet associated proteins, pectin modifiers, cysteine-rich proteins, and mRNA-binding proteins. Results suggest dehydration onset initiates after bicellular pollen is formed. Proteins accumulating in mature pollen like ribosomal proteins, initiation factors, and chaperones are likely components of mRNA-protein condensates resembling "stress" granules. Our analysis has revealed many new transcripts and proteins that accompany dehydration in developing pollen. Together with published functional studies, our results point to multiple processes, including (1) protect developing pollen from hyperosmotic stress, (2) remodel the endomembrane system and walls, (3) maintain energy metabolism, (4) stabilize presynthesized mRNA and proteins in condensates of dry pollen, and (5) equip pollen for compatibility determination at the stigma and for recovery at rehydration. These findings offer novel models and molecular candidates to further determine the mechanistic basis of dehydration and desiccation tolerance in plants.

The transcriptome of soybean reproductive tissues subjected to water deficit, heat stress, and a combination of water deficit and heat stress

Global warming and climate change are driving an alarming increase in the frequency and intensity of extreme climate events, such as droughts, heat waves, and their combination, inflicting heavy losses to agricultural production. Recent studies revealed that the transcriptomic responses of different crops to water deficit (WD) or heat stress (HS) are very different from that to a combination of WD + HS. In addition, it was found that the effects of WD, HS, and WD + HS are significantly more devastating when these stresses occur during the reproductive growth phase of crops, compared to vegetative growth. As the molecular responses of different reproductive and vegetative tissues of plants to WD, HS, or WD + HS could be different from each other and these differences could impact many current and future attempts to enhance the resilience of crops to climate change through breeding and/or engineering, we conducted a transcriptomic analysis of different soybean (Glycine max) tissues to WD, HS, and WD + HS. Here we present a reference transcriptomic dataset that includes the response of soybean leaf, pod, anther, stigma, ovary, and sepal to WD, HS, and WD + HS conditions. Mining this dataset for the expression pattern of different stress response transcripts revealed that each tissue had a unique transcriptomic response to each of the different stress conditions. This finding is important as it suggests that enhancing the overall resilience of crops to climate change could require a coordinated approach that simultaneously alters the expression of different groups of transcripts in different tissues in a stress-specific manner.

Differential transpiration between pods and leaves during stress combination in soybean

Climate change is causing an increase in the frequency and intensity of droughts, heat waves, and their combinations, diminishing agricultural productivity and destabilizing societies worldwide. We recently reported that during a combination of water deficit (WD) and heat stress (HS), stomata on leaves of soybean (Glycine max) plants are closed, while stomata on flowers are open. This unique stomatal response was accompanied by differential transpiration (higher in flowers, while lower in leaves) that cooled flowers during a combination of WD + HS. Here, we reveal that developing pods of soybean plants subjected to a combination of WD + HS use a similar acclimation strategy of differential transpiration to reduce internal pod temperature by approximately 4 °C. We further show that enhanced expression of transcripts involved in abscisic acid degradation accompanies this response and that preventing pod transpiration by sealing stomata causes a significant increase in internal pod temperature. Using an RNA-Seq analysis of pods developing on plants subjected to WD + HS, we also show that the response of pods to WD, HS, or WD + HS is distinct from that of leaves or flowers. Interestingly, we report that although the number of flowers, pods, and seeds per plant decreases under conditions of WD + HS, the seed mass of plants subjected to WD + HS increases compared to plants subjected to HS, and the number of seeds with suppressed/aborted development is lower in WD + HS compared to HS. Taken together, our findings reveal that differential transpiration occurs in pods of soybean plants subjected to WD + HS and that this process limits heat-induced damage to seed production.

Possible molecular mechanisms of persistent pollen tube growth without de novo transcription

The vegetative cell nucleus proceeds ahead of a pair of sperm cells located beneath the pollen tube tip during germination. The tip-localized vegetative nucleus had been considered to play a pivotal role in the control of directional pollen tube growth and double fertilization. However, we recently reported the female-targeting behavior of pollen tubes from mutant plants, of which the vegetative nucleus and sperm nuclei were artificially immotile. We showed that the apical region of the mutant pollen tubes became physiologically enucleated after the first callose plug formation, indicating the autonomously growing nature of pollen tubes without the vegetative nucleus and sperm cells. Thus, in this study, we further analyzed another Arabidopsis thaliana mutant producing physiologically enucleated pollen tubes and discussed the mechanism by which a pollen tube can grow without de novo transcription from the vegetative nucleus. We propose several possible molecular mechanisms for persistent pollen tube growth, such as the contribution of transcripts before and immediately after germination and the use of persistent transcripts, which may be important for a competitive race among pollen tubes.

Differential regulation of flower transpiration during abiotic stress in annual plants

Heat waves occurring during droughts can have a devastating impact on yield, especially if they happen during the flowering and seed set stages of the crop cycle. Global warming and climate change are driving an alarming increase in the frequency and intensity of combined drought and heat stress episodes, critically threatening global food security. Because high temperature is detrimental to reproductive processes, essential for plant yield, we measured the inner temperature, transpiration, sepal stomatal aperture, hormone concentrations and transcriptomic response of closed soybean flowers developing on plants subjected to a combination of drought and heat stress. Here, we report that, during a combination of drought and heat stress, soybean plants prioritize transpiration through flowers over transpiration through leaves by opening their flower stomata, while keeping their leaf stomata closed. This acclimation strategy, termed 'differential transpiration', lowers flower inner temperature by about 2-3°C, protecting reproductive processes at the expense of vegetative tissues. Manipulating stomatal regulation, stomatal size and/or stomatal density of flowers could serve as a viable strategy to enhance the yield of different crops and mitigate some of the current and future impacts of global warming and climate change on agriculture.

Rapid Transcriptional Reprogramming Associated With Heat Stress-Induced Unfolded Protein Response in Developing Brassica napus Anthers

Climate change associated increases in the frequency and intensity of extreme temperature events negatively impact agricultural productivity and global food security. During the reproductive phase of a plant's life cycle, such high temperatures hinder pollen development, preventing fertilization, and seed formation. At the molecular level, heat stress-induced accumulation of misfolded proteins activates a signaling pathway called unfolded protein response (UPR) in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and the cytoplasm to enhance the protein folding capacity of the cell. Here, we report transcriptional responses of Brassica napus anthers exposed to high temperature for 5, 15, and 30 min to decipher the rapid transcriptional reprogramming associated with the unfolded protein response. Functional classification of the upregulated transcripts highlighted rapid activation of the ER-UPR signaling pathway mediated by ER membrane-anchored transcription factor within 5 min of heat stress exposure. KEGG pathway enrichment analysis also identified "Protein processing in ER" as the most significantly enriched pathway, indicating that the unfolded protein response (UPR) is an immediate heat stress-responsive pathway during B. napus anther development. Five minutes of heat stress also led to robust induction of the cytosolic HSF-HSP heat response network. Our results present a perspective of the rapid and massive transcriptional reprogramming during heat stress in pollen development and highlight the need for investigating the nature and function of very early stress-responsive networks in plant cells. Research focusing on very early molecular responses of plant cells to external stresses has the potential to reveal new stress-responsive gene networks that can be explored further for developing climate change resilient crops.