Isotope ratio laser spectroscopy to disentangle xylem-transported from locally respired CO2 in stem CO2 efflux

The quandary of sources and sinks of CO2 efflux in tree stems-new insights and future directions

Stem respiration (RS) substantially contributes to the return of photo assimilated carbon to the atmosphere and, thus, to the tree and ecosystem carbon balance. Stem CO2 efflux (ECO2) is often used as a proxy for RS. However, this metric has often been challenged because of the uncertain origin of CO2 emitted from the stem due to post-respiratory processes. In this Insight, we (i) describe processes affecting the quantification of RS, (ii) review common methodological approaches to quantify and model RS and (iii) develop a research agenda to fill the most relevant knowledge gaps that we identified. Dissolution, transport and accumulation of respired CO2 away from its production site, reassimilation of respired CO2 via stem photosynthesis and the enzyme phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, axial CO2 diffusion in the gas phase, shifts in the respiratory substrate and non-respiratory oxygen (O2) consumption are the most relevant processes causing divergence between RS and measured stem gas exchange (ECO2 or O2 influx, IO2). Two common methodological approaches to estimate RS, namely the CO2 mass balance approach and the O2 consumption technique, circumvent some of these processes but have yielded inconsistent results regarding the fate of respired CO2. Stem respiration modelling has recently progressed at the organ and tree levels. However, its implementation in large-scale models, commonly operated from a source-driven perspective, is unlikely to reflect adequate mechanisms. Finally, we propose hypotheses and approaches to advance the knowledge of the stem carbon balance, the role of sap pH on RS, the reassimilation of respired CO2, RS upscaling procedures, large-scale RS modelling and shifts in respiratory metabolism during environmental stress.

Partitioning of respired CO2 in newly sprouted Moso bamboo culms

Stem respiration (R _s) plays a vital role in ecosystem carbon cycling. However, the measured efflux on the stem surface (E _s) is not always in situ R _s but only part of it. A previously proposed mass balance framework (MBF) attempted to explore the multiple partitioning pathways of R _s, including sap-flow-transported and internal storage of R _s, in addition to E _s. This study proposed stem photosynthesis as an additional partitioning pathway to the MBF. Correspondingly, a double-chamber apparatus was designed and applied on newly sprouted Moso bamboo (Phyllostachys edulis) in leafless and leaved stages. R _s of newly sprouted bamboo were twice as high in the leafless stage (7.41 ± 2.66 μmol m^-2 s^-1) than in the leaved stage (3.47 ± 2.43 μmol m^-2 s^-1). E _s accounted for ~80% of R _s, while sap flow may take away ~2% of R _s in both leafless and leaved stages. Culm photosynthesis accounted for ~9% and 13% of R _s, respectively. Carbon sequestration from culm photosynthesis accounted for approximately 2% of the aboveground bamboo biomass in the leafless stage. High culm photosynthesis but low sap flow during the leafless stage and vice versa during the leaved stage make bamboo an outstanding choice for exploring the MBF.

Efflux and assimilation of xylem-transported CO2 in stems and leaves of tree species with different wood anatomy

Determining the fate of CO₂ respired in woody tissues is necessary to understand plant respiratory physiology and to evaluate CO₂ recycling mechanisms. An aqueous ¹³ C-enriched CO₂ solution was infused into the stem of 3-4 m tall trees to estimate efflux and assimilation of xylem-transported CO₂ via cavity ring-down laser spectroscopy and isotope ratio mass spectrometry, respectively. Different tree locations (lower stem, upper stem and leafy shoots) and tissues (xylem, bark and leaves) were monitored in species with tracheid, diffuse- and ring-porous wood anatomy (cedar, maple and oak, respectively). Radial xylem CO₂ diffusivity and xylem [CO₂ ] were lower in cedar relative to maple and oak trees, thereby limiting label diffusion. Part of the labeled ¹³ CO₂ was assimilated in cedar (8.7%) and oak (20.6%) trees, mostly in xylem and bark tissues of the stem, while limited solution uptake in maple trees hindered the detection of label assimilation. Little label reached foliar tissues, suggesting substantial label loss along the stem-branch transition following reductions in the radial diffusive pathway. Differences in respiration rates and radial xylem CO₂ diffusivity (lower in conifer relative to angiosperm species) might reconcile discrepancies in efflux and assimilation of xylem-transported CO₂ so far observed between taxonomic clades.

Xylem transport of root-derived CO2 caused a substantial underestimation of belowground respiration during a growing season

Previous research has indicated that a potentially large portion of root-respired CO₂ can move internally through tree xylem, but these reports are relatively scarce and have generally been limited to short observations. Our main objective was to provide a continuous estimate of the quantity and variability of root-respired CO₂ that moves either internally through the xylem (F_T ) or externally through the soil to the atmosphere (F_S ) over most of a growing season. Nine trees were measured in a Populus deltoides stand for 129 days from early June to mid-October. We calculated F_T as the product of sap flow and dissolved [CO₂ ] in the xylem (i.e., [CO₂ *]) and calculated F_S using the [CO₂ ] gradient method. During the study, stem and soil CO₂ concentrations, temperature, and sap flow were measured continuously. We determined that F_T accounted for 33% of daily total belowground CO₂ flux (i.e., F_S  + F_T ; F_B ) during our observation period that spanned most of a growing season. Cumulative daily F_T was lower than F_S 74% of the time, equivalent to F_S 26% of the time, and never exceeded F_S . One-third of the total CO₂ released by belowground respiration over most of the growing season in this forest stand followed the F_T pathway rather than diffusing into the soil. The magnitude of F_T indicates that measurements of F_S alone substantially underestimate total belowground respiration in some forest ecosystems by systematically underestimating belowground autotrophic respiration. The variability in F_T observed during the growing season demonstrated the importance of making long-term, high-frequency measurements of different flux pathways to better understand physiological and ecological processes and their implications to global change.

Limited vertical CO2 transport in stems of mature boreal Pinus sylvestris trees

Several studies have suggested that CO2 transport in the transpiration stream can considerably bias estimates of root and stem respiration in ring-porous and diffuse-porous tree species. Whether this also happens in species with tracheid xylem anatomy and lower sap flow rates, such as conifers, is currently unclear. We infused 13C-labelled solution into the xylem near the base of two 90-year-old Pinus sylvestris L. trees. A custom-built gas exchange system and an online isotopic analyser were used to sample the CO2 efflux and its isotopic composition continuously from four positions along the bole and one upper canopy shoot in each tree. Phloem and needle tissue 13C enrichment was also evaluated at these positions. Most of the 13C label was lost by diffusion within a few metres of the infusion point indicating rapid CO2 loss during vertical xylem transport. No 13C enrichment was detected in the upper bole needle tissues. Furthermore, mass balance calculations showed that c. 97% of the locally respired CO2 diffused radially to the atmosphere. Our results support the notion that xylem CO2 transport is of limited magnitude in conifers. This implies that the concerns that stem transport of CO2 derived from root respiration biases chamber-based estimates of forest carbon cycling may be unwarranted for mature conifer stands.

Studying in vivo dynamics of xylem-transported 11CO2 using positron emission tomography

Respired CO2 in woody tissues can build up in the xylem and dissolve in the sap solution to be transported through the plant. From the sap, a fraction of the CO2 can either be radially diffuse to the atmosphere or be assimilated in chloroplasts present in woody tissues. These processes occur simultaneously in stems and branches, making it difficult to study their specific dynamics. Therefore, an 11C-enriched aqueous solution was administered to young branches of Populus tremula L., which were subsequently imaged by positron emission tomography (PET). This approach allows in vivo visualization of the internal movement of CO2 inside branches at high spatial and temporal resolution, and enables direct measurement of the transport speed of xylem-transported CO2 (vCO2). Through compartmental modeling of the dynamic data obtained from the PET images, we (i) quantified vCO2 and (ii) proposed a new method to assess the fate of xylem-transported 11CO2 within the branches. It was found that a fraction of 0.49 min-1 of CO2 present in the xylem was transported upwards. A fraction of 0.38 min-1 diffused radially from the sap to the surrounding parenchyma and apoplastic spaces (CO2,PA) to be assimilated by woody tissue photosynthesis. Another 0.12 min-1 of the xylem-transported CO2 diffused to the atmosphere via efflux. The remaining CO2 (i.e., 0.01 min-1) was stored as CO2,PA, representing the build-up within parenchyma and apoplastic spaces to be assimilated or directed to the atmosphere. Here, we demonstrate the outstanding potential of 11CO2-based plant-PET in combination with compartmental modeling to advance our understanding of internal CO2 movement and the respiratory physiology within woody tissues.

Woody tissue photosynthesis reduces stem CO2 efflux by half and remains unaffected by drought stress in young Populus tremula trees

A substantial portion of locally respired CO₂ in stems can be assimilated by chloroplast-containing tissues. Woody tissue photosynthesis (P_wt ) therefore plays a major role in the stem carbon balance. To study the impact of P_wt on stem carbon cycling along a gradient of water availability, stem CO₂ efflux (E_A ), xylem CO₂ concentration ([CO₂ ]), and xylem water potential (Ψ_xylem ) were measured in 4-year-old Populus tremula L. trees exposed to drought stress and different regimes of light exclusion of woody tissues. Under well-watered conditions, local P_wt decreased E_A up to 30%. Axial CO₂ diffusion (D_ax ) induced by distant P_wt caused an additional decrease in E_A of up to 25% and limited xylem [CO₂ ] build-up. Under drought stress, absolute decreases in E_A driven by P_wt remained stable, denoting that P_wt was not affected by drought. At the end of the dry period, when transpiration was low, local P_wt and D_ax offset 20% and 10% of stem respiration on a daily basis, respectively. These results highlight (a) the importance of P_wt for an adequate interpretation of E_A measurements and (b) homeostatic P_wt along a drought stress gradient, which might play a crucial role to fuel stem metabolism when leaf carbon uptake and phloem transport are limited.

TReSpire - a biophysical TRee Stem respiration model

Mechanistic models of plant respiration remain poorly developed, especially in stems and woody tissues where measurements of CO₂ efflux do not necessarily reflect local respiratory activity. We built a process-based model of stem respiration that couples water and carbon fluxes at the organ level (TReSpire). To this end, sap flow, stem diameter variations, xylem and soil water potential, stem temperature, stem CO₂ efflux and nonstructural carbohydrates were measured in a maple tree, while xylem CO₂ concentration and additional stem and xylem diameter variations were monitored in an ancillary tree for model validation. TReSpire realistically described: (1) turgor pressure to differentiate growing from nongrowing metabolism; (2) maintenance expenditures in xylem and outer tissues based on Arrhenius kinetics and nitrogen content; and (3) radial CO₂ diffusivity and CO₂ solubility and transport in the sap solution. Collinearity issues with phloem unloading rates and sugar-starch interconversion rates suggest parallel submodelling to close the stem carbon balance. TReSpire brings a breakthrough in the modelling of stem water and carbon fluxes at a detailed (hourly) temporal resolution. TReSpire is calibrated from a sink-driven perspective, and has potential to advance our understanding on stem growth dynamics, CO₂ fluxes and underlying respiratory physiology across different species and phenological stages.