HIV clearance in infants--a continuing saga

Discrepant test findings in early infant diagnosis of HIV in a national reference laboratory in Kenya: challenges and opportunities for programs

BACKGROUND

In Kenya, the availability of a cheap diagnostic service for HIV-exposed infants has helped scale-up access to treatment, and provided a means by which programs that support Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission of HIV can be evaluated. As expected for any large testing program, discrepant and indeterminate results present a significant challenge.

METHODS

Dried Blood Spots were collected from health centers countrywide and couriered to four laboratories for tests. Results were dispatched either by email, telephone, GSM SMS printer or courier. Between 2006 and 2009, tests were conducted with the Manual Roche v. 1.5 Assay. In 2010 the labs switched fully to the Cobas® AmpliPrep/ Cobas® TaqMan® HIV-1 Qual automated Roche Test.

RESULTS

Between 2006 and 2010, the KEMRI CVR EID Lab conducted 64 591 HIV tests in on children <18 months of age. HIV tests (38 834) used the manual assay, while 17 133 tests used the automated assay. Overall, 10.7% (6915) of the samples tested positive, while 86.6% (55 967) tested negative. A total of 1.6% (1041) tested indeterminate and required a re-bleed of the infant. Two hundred positive tests by the manual assay were retrieved randomly and retested using the automated assay. Among them, 192 (96%) remained positive, 5 (2.5%) were negative while 3 (1.5%) failed. A total of 160 negative samples by the manual assay were retrieved and retested with the automated assay. Among them, 154 (96.24%) remained negative, 3 (1.88%) tested positive while 3 (1.88%) failed. A total of 215 samples that gave indeterminate results by the manual assay were retested using the automated system. Among them, 62 (28.8%) gave positive results, 144 (66.97%) negative and 6 (2.8%) samples still gave discrepant results. Three (1.4%) did not amplify successfully. A few infants who were apparently positive appeared to test HIV negative with age.

CONCLUSIONS

Indeterminate results are a significant challenge for HIV diagnostic services, as seen in the Kenyan EID Program. In our experience, they are more often negative than they are positive. False positive and false negative results can arise from clerical error, contamination and limitations of the technologies available. To forestall the consequences of such outcomes, the sensitivity and specificity of available assays must be further improved. All HIV positive samples should be retested for confirmation, and if confirmed, a new sample must be drawn and tested for DNA at the time the infant receives their initial results or starts antiretroviral therapy. Viral clearance is a phenomenon that requires further studies.

Stone age diseases and modern AIDS

The great advantage of being a sexually transmitted disease is the ability to survive and specialize solely on a host species that is present in low numbers and widely distributed so that contact between infected and uninfected organisms by chance is rare. Pathogens of a sparse, but widely distributed host species, must either: i) have an alternative host; ii) be able to survive in a dormant state; or iii) be non-destructive to their host. For the pathogens of a diploid there is a particularly effective strategy, that of being sexually transmitted. Then the hosts' themselves transfer the pathogen.

Three cases of HIV-1 seroreversion

Three patients were enrolled, two as hemophiliacs, and one with acute EBV infection. Serial serum samples of each patient were tested with at least 3 different HIV antibody EIA tests, an immunofluo-rescent test and two western blots (WB). In the third case, PCR and reverse transcriptase enzyme activity measurement were also done. One of the regularly checked serum samples of hemophiliac patients was reactive with different HIV screening and confirmatory assays. Their next blood samples, two weeks and one month later, respectively, were negative with the same tests. In Case 3. two and a half years after the first examination, the EIA tests results changed to negative, but the WB was still indeterminate. In the case of the two hemophiliac patients, the patients may have been exposed to HIV containing blood products (before 1985), but were not infected. Regular treatment with factor VIII concentrate, in which HIV antigens may be present, can boost the immune response and results in transient seropositivity. In the case of the EBV infected patient, the transient HIV seropositivity may be the consequence of EBV induced proliferation of anti-HIV-antibody producing B cell clones. During our ten year HIV confirmatory practice we tested more than 40000 samples, from which transient seropositivity were observed only in the three cases summarized in this paper.

Progress in HIV vaccine research

The relentless expansion of the HIV pandemic has demonstrated that the need for a vaccine is desperate. However, the development of an effective vaccine against HIV is a formidable challenge. It is likely that a successful vaccine will have to induce an immune response consisting of not only neutralizing antibodies targeted to conserved epitopes of the viral envelope and cytotoxic T-lymphocytes targeted to a variety of viral antigens, but also local mucosal immunity. Furthermore, a vaccine should induce broad-spectrum immunity covering all HIV subtypes. It is unlikely that a single vaccine will achieve all this, and a combination of vaccines will probably be necessary. Although no efficacious HIV vaccine is available yet, definite progress has been made. It was demonstrated that chimpanzees could be protected from both cell-free and cell-associated HIV challenge. Protection from mucosal challenge was also demonstrated in several studies and limited cross-protection between HIV subtypes was observed in several animal models. In spite of these successes, much remains to be done. Prototype vaccines studied to date have only induced short-lived immune responses and elicited no antibodies able to neutralize clinical isolates of HIV-1. Novel ways of producing HIV-1 envelope antigens may lead to improved antibody responses and raise the chances of a vaccine inducing long-term protective immunity.

Pediatric HIV infection

Developments in the prevention and treatment of HIV infection in pregnant women and their children are encouraging. Perinatal ZDV therapy can reduce the maternal-infant transmission rate by two thirds in select populations. New therapies and the development of diagnostic assays to monitor HIV viral burden have renewed hope that, by aggressively controlling viremia, the progressive immunodeficiency can be delayed or even prevented. The general pediatric approach of preventing illnesses through aggressive vaccination and education policies must be actively incorporated into an approach to this epidemic. Success in controlling the pediatric HIV epidemic requires a concerted, coordinated effort by public policy makers, health care providers, basic science researchers, and those who are HIV-infected.