Phenotypic testing predicts virological response in successive protease inhibitor-based regimens

The investigation of patients with HIV infection: 10 years of progress

The past decade has seen great advances in the management of patients with HIV infection. The introduction of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) has resulted in a decrease in opportunistic infections but the development of new clinical entities such as lipodystrophy and immune reconstitution illnesses. The use of investigations such as lipid profiles and dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scanning to assess lipodystrophy have been necessitated by these changes in the epidemic. Technological advances have resulted in new techniques such as viral resistance assays and single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) scanning. The appropriate use of these investigations is subject to ongoing assessment.

A single-loop recombinant pseudotyped-virus-based assay to detect HIV-1 phenotypic resistance

HIV/AIDS is a leading public health concern throughout the world. Currently, treatment of HIV/AIDS still depends on highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART); however, there is increasing evidence showing the emergence of resistance to antiretroviral drugs in HIV-1 strains, making ART less effective over time. Intensive monitoring of HIV-1 drug resistance is therefore of great importance to evaluate the current sensitivity of antiretroviral agents and is urgently needed. The aim of this study was to develop a single-loop recombinant pseudotyped-virus-based assay to detect phenotypic resistance in clinical HIV-1 strains. HIV-1 RNA was extracted from HIV-1-infected human plasma samples, and an approximately 3-kb fragment containing p7/p1/p6 cleavage sites and full-length protease (PR), reverse transcriptase (RT), thermonuclease (TNase), and integrase (1-280 aa) genes was amplified by nested RT-PCR. A retroviral vector was constructed using the HIV-1 infectious molecular clone pLWJ to test antiretroviral drug susceptibility. pLWJ-SV40-Luc contained a luciferase expression cassette inserted within a deleted region of the envelope (env) gene as an indicator gene. Resistance test vectors (RTVs) were constructed by incorporating amplified target genes into pLWJ-SV40-Luc by using ApaI or AgeI and AarI restriction sites and conventional cloning methods. The virus stocks used for drug susceptibility test were produced by co-transfecting 293T cells with RTVs and a plasmid that provided vesicular stomatitis virus glycoprotein (VSV-G). Viral replication was monitored by measuring luciferase activity in infected target cells at approximately 48 h postinfection. A total of 35 clinical plasma samples from HIV-1-infected humans were tested, and target fragments were successfully amplified from 34 samples (97.1 %) and 33 RTVs were successfully constructed by directional cloning, with an overall success rate of 94.3 %. A clear-cut dose-dependent relationship was detected between virus production and luciferase activity in the constructed phenotypic resistance testing system. The highest coefficient of determination (R(2)) was found between luciferase activity and drug concentration and viral inhibition at 293T cell concentrations of 5 × 10(4) cells per well. The phenotypic profiles of the viruses from 29 clinical samples almost completely matched the observed genotypes. The results demonstrate that a single-loop recombinant pseudotyped-virus-based assay was successfully developed, and this testing system has high stability and appears to be applicable for testing phenotypic resistance of clinical HIV-1 strains to commonly used antiretroviral agents.

Steady-state pharmacokinetics of abacavir in plasma and intracellular carbovir triphosphate following administration of abacavir at 600 milligrams once daily and 300 milligrams twice daily in human immunodeficiency virus-infected subjects

Abacavir (ABC) is administered either at 600 mg once daily (ABC 600 mg QD) or 300 mg twice daily (ABC 300 mg BID) in anti-human immunodeficiency virus (anti-HIV) combination therapy. Although ABC plasma pharmacokinetics following each regimen has been well defined, no study has directly compared the regimens with respect to pharmacokinetics of ABC's active intracellular anabolite, carbovir-triphosphate (CBV-TP). In an open-label, two-period, crossover study, 34 HIV-infected male and female subjects stabilized on antiretroviral regimens containing either ABC 600 mg QD or ABC 300 mg BID received their usual doses on days -1 and 1 and then switched regimens for days 2 to 11. Serial blood samples collected on days 1 and 11 were assayed for plasma ABC and intracellular CBV-TP concentrations using validated high-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry methods. Pharmacokinetic parameters were calculated using noncompartmental methods. Analysis of variance with a mixed-effect model was performed for treatment and gender comparisons. In 27 evaluable subjects, the regimens provided bioequivalent ABC daily areas under the concentration-time curve from 0 to 24 h (AUC(0-24)) and comparable CBV-TP concentrations at the end of the dosing interval (C(tau)). As expected, ABC QD resulted in 109% higher ABC maximum concentrations of drug in plasma (C(max)) than did ABC BID. ABC QD also resulted in 32% higher CBV-TP AUC(0-24) and 99% higher CBV-TP C(max) than did ABC BID. Females had a 38% higher weight-adjusted ABC AUC(0-24) and 81% higher weight-adjusted CBV-TP AUC(0-24) than did males. Virologic suppression was maintained during regimen switch, and no tolerability differences between regimens were observed. In conclusion, this study showed that ABC 600 mg QD and ABC 300 mg BID regimens led to similar intracellular CBV-TP C(tau) values, thus providing pharmacokinetic support for the interchangeability of these two regimens. Women had higher intracellular CBV-TP exposure than did men.

Relationship between drug resistance and HIV-1 disease progression or death in patients undergoing resistance testing

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate factors associated with drug resistance detected by genotypic antiretroviral resistance testing (GART), and to determine the association between the level of resistance and subsequent human immunodeficiency type 1 (HIV-1) disease progression or death.

DESIGN

Observational cohort study.

METHODS

We identified highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART)-treated patients who had GART as part of clinical management. Factors associated with greater numbers of resistance mutations were assessed by ordinal logistic regression. Survival analysis was used to assess time to a new opportunistic condition or death following GART.

RESULTS

A total of 572 patients were identified who had GART: of these, 50% had 0-2 resistance mutations, 33% had 3-6 mutations, and 17% had >/= 7 mutations. In multivariate analysis, prolonged use of HAART in the setting of incomplete viral suppression was significantly associated with more drug resistance. Patients with fewer resistance mutations were significantly more likely to achieve viral suppression after GART than patients with more mutations. Compared to patients with two or less resistance mutations, those with three to six mutations, or seven or more mutations were not at higher risk of HIV-1 disease progression or death over a median follow-up of 15 months. In contrast, continued HAART use following GART was strongly associated with slower disease progression, particularly at lower CD4 cell counts.

CONCLUSION

These results support the hypothesis the drug-resistant HIV-1 may be less pathogenic than wild-type virus, and that continued use of HAART might provide clinical benefit, despite persistent viremia and HIV-1 drug resistance.

Transmission of HIV-1 drug resistance

BACKGROUND

The use of highly-active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) for treating HIV infections is increasing. Recent studies have demonstrated that HAART is improving both the length and quality of life in HIV-infected patients. Resistant strains of HIV arise when drug adherence is poor. This can lead to the transmission of drug-resistant strains of HIV to susceptible individuals. This can lead to suboptimal first-line therapy, if the resistance profile of the transmitted virus is unknown.

OBJECTIVES

To review the mechanisms of how drug resistance arises; the methods used to characterise drug resistance; the problems arising with compliance leading to the development of drug-resistant HIV strains; the evidence for the incidence, prevalence and trends in the transmission of resistant HIV strains in different risk groups; and the evidence of suboptimal response to first-line therapy where transmission of a resistant HIV strain has occurred. On the basis of this, a case is presented for the routine resistance testing of all newly diagnosed HIV-infected individuals.

STUDY DESIGN

Literature review.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

There is evidence, though limited at present, that transmission of drug-resistant HIV strains can lead to suboptimal response to first-line therapy in newly diagnosed HIV-infected individuals. As the use of HAART can only increase in the future, and compliance will always be a problem in such HAART-treated patients, baseline resistance testing should become a routine part of their management.

Efficacy of indinavir-ritonavir-based regimens in HIV-1-infected patients with prior protease inhibitor failures

OBJECTIVE

To assess responses to indinavir (IDV)-ritonavir (RTV)-based regimens among HIV-1 infected patients with prior failure of protease inhibitors, and to assess the effects of adherence to therapy and pre-existing genotypic and phenotypic resistance on this response.

METHODS

Twenty-eight patients initiating salvage regimens with IDV-RTV (800 mg and 200 mg twice daily, respectively) plus one or more reverse transcriptase inhibitor (RTI) were identified retrospectively. Genotypic and phenotypic susceptibilities to multiple antiretroviral agents were determined on viral samples collected at initiation of the salvage regimens, and adherence to therapy was determined through patient self-reporting. Response to therapy (viral RNA </= 400 copies/ml) was assessed at the end of and beyond 6 months of follow-up.

RESULTS

Based on responses measured in the first 6 months of follow-up, 16 responders and 12 non-responders were identified without differences in baseline demographic factors, laboratory parameters, extent of prior antiretroviral therapy, or characteristics of the RTI components of the new IDV-RTV-based regimens. Adequate adherence was associated with virologic responses (P = 0.005). There were trends for genotypic and phenotypic resistance to be associated with adequate adherence, and, surprisingly, phenotypic resistance to IDV was associated with virologic response rather than with therapeutic failure (P = 0.02). Beyond 6 months of follow-up (mean follow-up 69 weeks), adequate adherence was still associated with virologic response (P = 0.001), but genotypic or phenotypic resistance to IDV were not associated with therapeutic failure.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that IDV-RTV-based regimens may be able to overcome IDV resistance. This underscores the importance of drug adherence, potency, and exposure in determining virologic responses to antiretroviral therapy.

"All-in-One Assay", a direct phenotypic anti-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 drug resistance assay for three-drug combination therapies that takes into consideration in vivo drug concentrations

A novel phenotypic anti-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) drug resistance assay is described. Three drugs at concentrations equivalent to those determined in in vivo pharmacokinetics, were mixed in a well, serially diluted by 10-folds, and added to incubations of clinical HIV-1 isolates and CCR-5 expressing HeLa/CD4+ cells which was previously reported as the MAGIC-5 cells (Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 45 (2001) 495) to determine the 95% inhibitory dilution (ID(95)) of the combination regimens. The ID(95) of efavirenz (EFV)-containing regimens was ten-times lower than that of nevirapine (NVP)-containing regimens against HIV-1 isolated from antiviral therapy naive patients. However, the difference was not apparent by the conventional fold resistance measurement based on the 50% inhibitory concentration. Furthermore, the synergistic effects of drug combinations against clinical HIV-1 isolates can be evaluated by our assay. The ID(95)s of EFV- and nelfinavir (NFV)- containing regimens against HIV-1 from naive patients were less than 0.01 whereas those against resistant viruses were over 0.05, although the clinical cut-off values are to be determined in larger clinical studies. Our assay, designated "All-in-One Assay", that can examine resistance to three drugs simultaneously under consideration of in vivo drug concentrations described above might be useful in practice.

Selection of high-level resistance to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease inhibitors

Protease inhibitors represent some of the most potent agents available for therapeutic strategies designed to inhibit human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) replication. Under certain circumstances the virus develops resistance to the inhibitor, thereby negating the benefits of this therapy. We have carried out selections for high-level resistance to each of three protease inhibitors (indinavir, ritonavir, and saquinavir) in cell culture. Mutations accumulated over most of the course of the increasing selective pressure. There was significant overlap in the identity of the mutations selected with the different inhibitors, and this gave rise to high levels of cross-resistance. Virus particles from the resistant variants all showed defects in processing at the NC/p1 protease cleavage site in Gag. Selections with pairs of inhibitors yielded similar patterns of resistance mutations. A virus that could replicate at near-toxic levels of the three protease inhibitors combined was selected. The pro sequence of this virus was similar to that of the viruses that had been selected for high-level resistance to each of the drugs singly. Finally, a molecular clone carrying the eight most common resistance mutations seen in these selections was characterized. The sequence of this virus was relatively stable during selection for revertants in spite of displaying poor processing at the NC/p1 site and having significantly reduced fitness. These results reveal patterns of drug resistance that extend to near the limits of attainable selective pressure with these inhibitors and confirm the patterns of cross-resistance for these three inhibitors and the attenuation of virion protein processing and fitness that accompanies high-level resistance.

A neutravidin-based assay for reverse transcriptase suitable for high throughput screening of retroviral activity

A non-isotopic neutravidin-based reverse transcriptase (RT) assay adapted for high throughput screening of HIV activity is described. Using a 96-well microtitre plate, HIV particles are lysed and the RT enzyme released into a reaction mixture containing poly(A) RNA, biotinylated oligo d(T) and fluorescein-labelled dUTP (FI-dUTP). With poly(A) as a template and oligo d(T) as primer, the viron RT incorporates FI-dUTP into an elongating DNA strand. The resulting product is captured on a neutravidin-coated 96-well plate and the unincorporated nucleotides removed by a series of washing steps. A simple ELISA is subsequently performed using a monoclonal antifluorescein antibody conjugated to alkaline phosphatase. Quantification of RT activity is facilitated by a colorimetric readout. The assay was validated in the context of a diagnostic HIV-1 phenotyping assay. Using supernatants from HIV-1 infected lymphocyte cultures the assay was shown to be as sensitive as a radioactive assay and the RT activity correlated well with levels of cell-associated HIVp24. Importantly, even minor reductions of RT activity by virus variants with reduced fitness could be distinguished.

Phenotype or Virtual Phenotype for Choosing Antiretroviral Therapy after Failure: A Prospective, Randomized Study

Background

Resistance testing is useful in the management of virological failure patients, although the best method to be used in clinical practice has not been determined.

Methods

A prospective, randomized, double-blind, multicentre, controlled clinical trial was performed to compare the usefulness of drug resistance testing with a recombinant viral phenotype method or with a virtual phenotype, a genotyping interpretation system. Planned 300 HIV-infected adults failing their current antiretroviral therapy (HIV RNA >1000 copies/ml) were centrally randomized 1:1 to resistance testing with a recombinant viral phenotype method or with a virtual phenotype, after stratifying according to previous drug exposure (one or two versus three drug classes). Percent of patients with HIV RNA suppression (% <400 copies/ml) after 24 weeks was the primary outcome variable. Median HIV RNA concentration and change from baseline in HIV RNA concentration were also used to compare effectiveness. An extended analysis was performed at week 48.

Results

Of the 300 patients enrolled, a total of 276 patients could be analysed; 139 patients were randomized to the phenotype group and 137 patients were randomized to the virtual phenotype group. After 24 weeks of follow-up, 46.8 and 56.2% of patients had HIV RNA <400 copies/ml ( P=0.1) in the phenotype and virtual phenotype, respectively. Mean decrease from baseline in viral load was 1.0 and 1.3 log copies/ml in the phenotype and virtual phenotype groups, respectively ( P=0.017). In a multivariate linear regression analysis, after adjusting for baseline HIV RNA and adherence to treatment, the virtual phenotype was associated with a greater mean decrease in plasma HIV RNA ( P=0.0063). The results observed at week 48 were similar.

Conclusions

Virtual phenotype is at least as effective as phenotype when used to select an optimized treatment for patients who have failed one or more antiretroviral regimens.

HIV-1 genotype and phenotype correlate with virological response to abacavir, amprenavir and efavirenz in treatment-experienced patients

OBJECTIVE

To assess the safety and efficacy of three new drugs in patients with antiretroviral failure and to correlate retrospectively baseline factors with virological response.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Open-label, 48-week, single-arm, multi-center phase II trial conducted at nine US university or government clinics and private practices.

PATIENTS AND INTERVENTIONS

Patients with HIV-1 RNA > or =500 copies/ml despite > or =20 weeks of treatment with at least one protease inhibitor received abacavir 300 mg twice a day, amprenavir 1200 mg twice a day and efavirenz 600 mg once a day. Other antiretrovirals were prohibited until week 16 except for substitutions for possible abacavir hypersensitivity.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

HIV RNA at weeks 16 and 48.

RESULTS

A total of 101 highly treatment-experienced patients enrolled; 60 were naive to non-nucleoside analog reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTI). HIV RNA < 400 copies/ml was attained in 25 out of 101 (25%) patients at 16 weeks (35% of NNRTI-naive and 10% of -experienced patients) and 23 (23%) patients at 48 weeks (33% of naive and 7% of experienced patients). CD4 cells increased by a median of 15 x 10(6) and 43 x 10(6) cells/l at weeks 16 and 48, respectively. Drug-related rash occurred in 50 out of 99 (51%) of patients, and 17 out of 99 (17%) permanently discontinued one or more drugs as a result. Lower baseline viral load, fewer NNRTI-related mutations, absence of decreased abacavir (> or =4-fold) and efavirenz (> or =10-fold) susceptibility, and greater number of drugs to which virus was susceptible were associated with virological response at week 16.

CONCLUSIONS

Abacavir, amprenavir and efavirenz durably reduced HIV RNA and increased CD4 cell counts in a subset of treatment-experienced adults. Baseline viral load and some genotypic and phenotypic markers of resistance correlated with HIV RNA response.

Response to Antiretroviral Therapy among Patients Exposed to Three Classes of Antiretrovirals: Results from the Eurosida Study

There is an increasing proportion of HIV-positive patients exposed to all licensed classes of antiretrovirals, and the response to salvage regimens may be poor. Among over 8500 patients in EuroSIDA, the proportion of treated patients exposed to nucleosides, protease inhibitors (PIs) and non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI) increased from 0% in 1996 to 47% in 2001. Four-hundred-and-thirteen patients, who had failed virologically two highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) regimens and experienced all three main drug classes, started a salvage regimen of at least three drugs, in which at least one new PI or NNRTI was included. Median viral load was 4.7 log copies/ml [Interquartile range (IQR) 4.2–5.2], CD4 lymphocyte count 150/mm3 (IQR 60–274/mm3) and follow-up 14 months. Of these patients, 283 (69%) subsequently experienced at least a 1 log decline in viral load and 202 (49%) achieved a viral load <500 copies/ml. Conversely, the CD4 count halved from the baseline value in 88 (21%), and 45 (11%) experienced a new AIDS-defining disease. In multivariable analyses, a 1 log viral load reduction was related to baseline viral load [relative hazard (RH) 1.27 per 1 log higher; P=0.008], a previous viral load of less than 500 copies/ml (RH 1.69; P=0.002), more recent initiation of the regimen (RH 1.36 per year more recent; P=0.02), number of new drugs in the regimen (RH 1.20 per drug; P=0.02), time since start of antiretroviral therapy (RH 0.94 per extra year; P=0.035) and time spent on HAART with viral load >1000 copies/ml (RH 0.96 per extra month; P=0.0001). Analysis of factors associated with CD4 count decline and new AIDS disease also indicated improved outcomes in more recent times and a tendency for a better response in those starting more new drugs, but no relationship with the total number of drugs. Outcomes in people starting salvage regimens appear to depend on the number of new drugs started but not on the total number of drugs being used.

World-wide variation in HIV-1 phenotypic susceptibility in untreated individuals: biologically relevant values for resistance testing

OBJECTIVES

To examine the natural phenotypic variability in drug susceptibility among recombinant HIV-1 isolates from a large number of untreated HIV-positive individuals from wide-ranging geographic locations, and to use this information to establish biologically relevant cut-off values for phenotypic antiretroviral susceptibility testing.

METHODS

Phenotypic susceptibility to 14 antiretroviral agents was determined for HIV-1 samples from > 1000 treatment-naive individuals in seven clinical trials. Samples were from the USA (n = 351), Germany (n = 306), Canada (n = 265), and South Africa (n = 358). Geometric mean fold-resistance and confidence intervals were determined relative to a standard laboratory wild-type virus.

RESULTS

Baseline fold-resistance was approximately log-normally distributed for all antiretroviral agents examined. There was no evidence of large geographical differences in average antiviral susceptibility. Geometric mean fold-resistance for each of 14 antiviral agents was similar (+/- 0.5-fold) for samples derived from the USA, Canada, Germany, or South Africa. The non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTI) exhibited the broadest distribution of susceptibility; approximately 97.5% of all isolates had < 2.5-4.0, < 3.0-4.5, and < 5-10 fold-decrease in susceptibility to five protease inhibitors, six nucleoside analogues, and three NNRTI, respectively. No consistent geographic pattern or clade effect (B versus C) in either the mean or the distribution of baseline antiretroviral susceptibility was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Phenotypic drug susceptibility of HIV-1 in untreated individuals varies markedly from drug to drug, with broadly similar patterns world-wide. These results have important implications in defining the 'normal range' of phenotypic susceptibility to antiretroviral agents and establish biologically relevant cut-off values for this phenotypic drug susceptibility test.

Variants other than aspartic acid at codon 69 of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase gene affect susceptibility to nuleoside analogs

The T69D mutation in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase (RT) gene has been associated with reduced susceptibility to dideoxycytosine (ddC); however, several other mutations at codon 69 have been observed in antiretroviral drug-treated patients. The Stanford HIV RT and Protease Sequence Database was interrogated and showed that 23% of patients treated with nucleoside RT inhibitors (NRTI) had mutations at codon 69. These variants included T69N, -S, -A, -G, -E, -I, and -K mutations that were present in patients treated with NRTI but not in drug-naive patients. Treatment history information showed that a substantial percentage of these codon 69 changes occurred in patients administered non-ddC-containing regimens. Different and specific patterns of other RT gene mutations were associated with the various codon 69 mutations. Drug susceptibility assays showed that viral constructs containing codon 69 variants could have reduced susceptibility to ddC and other RT inhibitors. These results suggest that the T69D mutation is not the only codon 69 variant associated with drug resistance and that ddC is not the only drug affected.

Clinical and laboratory guidelines for the use of HIV-1 drug resistance testing as part of treatment management: recommendations for the European setting. The EuroGUidelines Group for HIV resistance

Viral drug susceptibility is associated with virologic response to new treatments. Standardized drug resistance tests are now available, and data from some clinical trials suggest that the use of drug resistance testing may be associated with improved virologic outcome. However, drug resistance testing is complex in terms of performance, interpretation and clinical application. HIV-1 drug resistance testing is used across Europe in patient management, but not in a consistent manner. This is due to differences in the national approaches to treatment, treatment management and reimbursement, as well as availability of tests. National guidelines only exist in some countries. In addition, the laboratory quality assurance and quality control standards are not applied uniformly. The EuroGuidelines Group was established to formulate clinical as well as laboratory guidelines for the use of HIV-1 drug resistance testing that are specific for the European setting. The group is comprised of academic clinicians and virologists, scientist from the industry and representatives of the patient community. The panel of experts will review these guidelines and update them on a yearly basis as new scientific evidence becomes available.