Marked mitigation of transplant vascular sclerosis in FasLgld (CD95L) mutant recipients. The role of alloantibodies in the development of chronic rejection

Pattern of organ remodeling in chronic non-communicable diseases is due to endogenous regulations and falls under the category of Kauffman's self-organization: A case of arterial neointimal pathology

Clinical diagnosis is based on analysis of pathologic findings that may result in perceived patterns. The same is true for diagnostic pathology: Pattern analysis is a foundation of the histopathology-based diagnostic system and, in conjunction with clinical and laboratory findings, forms a basis for the classification of diseases. Any histopathology diagnosis is based on the explicit assumption that the same diseased condition should result in formation of the same (or highly similar) morphologic patterns in different individuals; it is a standard approach in microscopic pathology, including that of non-communicable chronic diseases with organ remodeling. During fifty years of examining diseased tissues under microscopy, I keep asking the same question: Why is a similarity of patterns expected for chronic organ remodeling? For infection diseases, xenobiotic toxicity and deficiencies forming an identical pathologic pattern in different individuals is understandable and logical: The same infection, xenobiotic, or deficiency strikes the same target, which results in identical pathology. The same is true for Mendelian diseases: The same mutations lead to the same altered gene expressions and the same pathologic pattern. But why does this regularity hold true for chronic diseases with organ remodeling? Presumable causes (or risk factors) for a particular chronic disease differ in magnitude and duration between individuals, which should result in various series of transformations. Yet, mysteriously enough, pathological remodeling in a particular chronic disease always falls into a main dominating pattern, perpetuating and progressing in a similar fashion in different patients. Furthermore, some chronic diseases of different etiologies and dissimilar causes/risk factors manifest as identical or highly similar patterns of pathologic remodeling. HYPOTHESIS: I hypothesize that regulations governing a particular organ's chronic remodeling were selected in evolution as the safest response to various insults and physiologic stress conditions. This hypothesis implies that regulations directing diseased chronic remodeling always preexist but normally are controlled; this control can be disrupted by a diverse range of non-specific signals, liberating the pathway for identical pathologic remodeling. This hypothesis was tested in an analysis of arterial neointimal formation, the identical pathology occurring in different diseases and pathological conditions: graft vascular disease in organ transplantation, in-stent restenosis, peripheral arterial diseases, idiopathic intimal hyperplasia, Kawasaki disease, coronary atherosclerosis and as reaction to drugs. The hypothesis suggests that arterial intimal cells are poised between only two alternative pathways: the pathway with controlled intimal cell proliferation or the pathway where such control is disrupted, ultimately leading to the progressive neointimal pathology. By this property the arterial neointimal formation constitutes a special case of Kauffman's self-organization. This new hypothesis gives a parsimonious explanation for identical pathological patterns of arterial remodeling (neointimal formation), which occurs in diseases of different etiologies and due to dissimilar causes/risk factors, or without any etiology and causes/risk factors at all. This new hypothesis also suggests that regulation facilitating intimal cell proliferation cannot be overwritten or annulled because this feature is vital for arterial differentiation, cell renewal, and integrity. This hypothesis suggests that studying numerous, and likely interchangeable, non-specific signals that disrupt regulation controlling intimal cell proliferation is unproductive; instead, a study of the controlling regulation(s) itself should be a priority of our research.

Anti-HLA I antibodies induce VEGF production by endothelial cells, which increases proliferation and paracellular permeability

Anti-human leukocyte antigen class I (HLA I) antibodies were shown to activate several protein kinases in endothelial cells (ECs), which induces proliferation and cell survival. An important phenomenon in antibody-mediated rejection is the occurrence of interstitial edema. We investigated the effect of anti-HLA I antibodies on endothelial proliferation and permeability, as one possible underlying mechanism of edema formation. HLA I antibodies increased the permeability of cultured ECs isolated from umbilical veins. Anti-HLA I antibodies induced the production of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) by ECs, which activated VEGF receptor 2 (VEGFR2) in an autocrine manner. Activated VEGFR2 led to a c-Src-dependent phosphorylation of vascular endothelial (VE)-cadherin and its degradation. Aberrant VE-cadherin expression resulted in impaired adherens junctions, which might lead to increased endothelial permeability. This effect was only observed after cross-linking of HLA I molecules by intact antibodies. Furthermore, our results suggest that increased endothelial proliferation following anti-HLA I treatment occurs via autocrine VEGFR2 activation. Our data indicate the ability of anti-HLA I to induce VEGF production in ECs. Transactivation of VEGFR2 leads to increased EC proliferation and paracellular permeability. The autocrine effect of VEGF on endothelial permeability might be an explanation for the formation of interstitial edema after transplantation.

Analysis of arterial intimal hyperplasia: review and hypothesis

BACKGROUND

Despite a prodigious investment of funds, we cannot treat or prevent arteriosclerosis and restenosis, particularly its major pathology, arterial intimal hyperplasia. A cornerstone question lies behind all approaches to the disease: what causes the pathology?

HYPOTHESIS

I argue that the question itself is misplaced because it implies that intimal hyperplasia is a novel pathological phenomenon caused by new mechanisms. A simple inquiry into arterial morphology shows the opposite is true. The normal multi-layer cellular organization of the tunica intima is identical to that of diseased hyperplasia; it is the standard arterial system design in all placentals at least as large as rabbits, including humans. Formed initially as one-layer endothelium lining, this phenotype can either be maintained or differentiate into a normal multi-layer cellular lining, so striking in its resemblance to diseased hyperplasia that we have to name it "benign intimal hyperplasia". However, normal or "benign" intimal hyperplasia, although microscopically identical to pathology, is a controllable phenotype that rarely compromises blood supply. It is remarkable that each human heart has coronary arteries in which a single-layer endothelium differentiates early in life to form a multi-layer intimal hyperplasia and then continues to self-renew in a controlled manner throughout life, relatively rarely compromising the blood supply to the heart, causing complications requiring intervention only in a small fraction of the population, while all humans are carriers of benign hyperplasia. Unfortunately, this fundamental fact has not been widely appreciated in arteriosclerosis research and medical education, which continue to operate on the assumption that the normal arterial intima is always an "ideal" single-layer endothelium. As a result, the disease is perceived and studied as a new pathological event caused by new mechanisms. The discovery that normal coronary arteries are morphologically indistinguishable from deadly coronary arteriosclerosis continues to elicit surprise.

CONCLUSION

Two questions should inform the priorities of our research: (1) what controls switch the single cell-layer intimal phenotype into normal hyperplasia? (2) how is normal (benign) hyperplasia maintained? We would be hard-pressed to gain practical insights without scrutinizing our premises.

Anti–LFA-1 Monotherapy Prevents Neointimal Formation in a Murine Model of Transplant Intimal Hyperplasia

BACKGROUND

Cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) is the pre-eminent cause of late cardiac allograft failure. It is characterized by a concentric intimal hyperplasia, which we designate transplant intimal hyperplasia (TIH). To date, blockade of the adhesion molecule lymphocyte function-associated antigen-1 (LFA-1) has been shown to be effective in preventing TIH in experimental models of transplantation, but only when combined with other immunosuppressants. In this study we explored the impact of monotherapy against LFA-1 in a carotid artery allograft model of TIH.

METHODS

B10A(2R) (H-2(h2)) mice were used as donors and C57BL/6 (H-2(b)) mice used as recipients. The recipients were treated with a monoclonal antibody against LFA-1alpha (M17/4) or isotype-matched control immunoglobulin. Grafts were harvested after 35 days and analyzed by histomorphometry and immunohistochemistry. Blood samples were taken and analyzed by differential cell count and alloantibody levels.

RESULTS

We found that treatment with M17/4 resulted in a significant reduction in TIH compared with controls. Immunostaining revealed that LFA-1alpha blockade inhibited CD45+ leukocyte infiltration, prevented intimal smooth muscle cell (SMC) proliferation, and preserved the medial SMC population. Finally, we demonstrated a reduction in the serum alloantibody titer in the group treated with anti-LFA-1alpha when compared with controls.

CONCLUSIONS

We have demonstrated for the first time that LFA-1alpha blockade on its own can prevent development of TIH in an experimental model. The concept of modulating LFA-1alpha-mediated leukocyte migration and T-cell activation may therefore be of relevance to clinical cardiac transplantation and, as such, represents a potential target for therapeutic intervention against clinical CAV.

Smooth muscle cell proliferation but not neointimal formation is dependent on alloantibody in a murine model of intimal hyperplasia

Transplant coronary artery disease is the pre-eminent cause of late cardiac allograft failure. It is primarily characterized by a concentric intimal hyperplasia, which we designate transplant intimal hyperplasia (TIH). Although the pathogenesis of TIH is predominately immune driven, the specific role of alloantibodies in the disease process remains undefined. In this study we investigated the contribution of alloantibodies to the development of TIH in a murine model. Orthotopic, carotid artery transplantation was performed between B10A(2R) (H-2(h2)) donor mice and B-cell deficient muMT(-/-) knockout or wild-type C57BL/6 (H-2(b)) recipients in the absence of immunosuppression. Grafts were harvested at 35 days and subjected to planimetry and immunohistochemistry. Alloantibodies were detectable in wild-type recipients within 7 days of transplantation and recipients developed marked TIH at 35 days. Allografts harvested from B-cell deficient recipient mice also developed TIH, which was comparable in severity with wild-type recipients. However, whereas allografts from wild-type recipients showed marked intimal smooth muscle cell (SMC) proliferation, the neointima in B-cell deficient recipients lacked SMCs. Post-transplantation administration of anti-donor serum to muMT(-/-) recipients restored neointimal SMC population but did not influence the severity of TIH. Significant neointimal formation occurs in the absence of alloantibodies but lacks a SMC component. Therefore, SMC migration and proliferation is antibody dependent.

Role of alloantibodies in the pathogenesis of graft arteriosclerosis in cardiac transplantation

Graft arteriosclerosis (GA) remains the leading obstacle to long-term survival of cardiac allografts. The pathogenesis of this chronic disease, though perceived to be multifactorial, is most likely immune-driven. Based on clinical and experimental observations, the humoral arm of the immune system has long been suspected to play a pivotal role in the disease process. In this article, we shall review the evidence generated from key clinical and experimental studies on the role of alloantibodies in GA. We will argue that although the strong correlation between the presence of anti-donor antibodies in clinical and experimental GA is highly suggestive of a pathogenic role for alloantibodies, a direct causal link between GA and the humoral arm of the alloresponse cannot yet be established based on the currently available evidence, and may in fact be one of a number of pathogenic processes that potentiate this vasculopathy. Finally, in this article, we shall discuss some of the potential mechanisms by which alloantibodies may exert their pathogenic effect in GA.

Impairment of recipient cytolytic activity attenuates allograft vasculopathy

We investigated the role of CD4+ and CD8+ T subsets as well as T cell cytolytic effector mechanisms in the aortic allograft model of allograft vasculopathy using CD4 and CD8 gene knockout mice (CD4(-/-), CD8(-/-)) and mice deficient in cytolytic effector pathways. Medial apoptosis at 2 weeks was reduced in CD8(-/-) mice and in mice where cytotoxic T cell activity was compromised. At 8 weeks, substantial medial damage was observed in wild-type (WT) and CD4(-/-) recipients but medial preservation was evident in CD8(-/-) mice and in mice with impaired cytotoxic T cell activity. The intima/media ratio, a comprehensive measure of allograft vasculopathy, was similar in WT and CD4(-/-) recipients but was significantly reduced in CD8(-/-) mice and mice with impaired cytotoxic T cell activity. These data indicate that CD8+ T cells contribute to the vascular remodeling that is characteristic of allograft vasculopathy. They also show that CD8+ T cells participate in allograft vasculopathy in the absence of CD4+ T cell help. We further demonstrated that WT mice exhibited robust allograft vasculopathy in the presence of cyclosporin A immunosuppression but that allograft vasculopathy was ablated in cyclosporin-treated CD8(-/-) mice. This supports the hypothesis that non-CD8+ T cell effector mechanisms are sensitive to calcineurin inhibitor therapy but that CD8+ T cell-mediated allograft vasculopathy is refractory to such treatment. Taken together, our data suggest that CD8+ T cells contribute to the induction of vascular remodeling in allograft vasculopathy and provide evidence that novel therapies which target CD8+ T cell effector function might be effective in mitigating AV in the clinical setting.

Induction of donor-specific allograft tolerance by short-term treatment with LF15-0195 after transplantation. Evidence for a direct effect on T-cell differentiation

A 20-day treatment with LF15-0195, a deoxyspergualine analog, induced long-term heart allograft survival in the rat without signs of chronic rejection. LF15-0195-treated recipients did not develop an anti-donor alloantibody response. Analysis of graft-infiltrating cells, IL10, TNFalpha, IFNgamma mRNA and iNOS protein expression in allografts, 5 days after transplantation, showed that they were markedly decreased in allografts from LF15-0195-treated recipients compared with allografts from untreated recipients. Surprisingly, spleen T cells from LF15-0195 recipients, 5days after grafting, were able to proliferate strongly in vitro, when stimulated with donor cells, but had reduced mRNA expression for IFNy compared with spleen T cells from untreated graft recipients. Furthermore, when T cells from naive animals were stimulated in vitro, using anti-CD3 and anti-CD28, LF15-0195 also increased T-cell proliferation in a dose-dependent fashion: however, these cells expressed less of the Th1 -related cytokines, IFNgamma and IL2, compared with untreated cells, suggesting that LF15-0195 could act on T-cell differentiation. In conclusion, we show here that a short-term treatment with LF15-0195 induced long-term allograft tolerance, decreasing the in situ anti-donor response, and we illustrate evidence for the development of regulatory mechanisms.

Use of recombinase activation gene-2 deficient mice to ascertain the role of cellular and humoral immune responses in the development of chronic rejection

INTRODUCTION

Given its multifactorial etiology, the relative contribution of anti-donor cellular and humoral immune responses in the pathogenesis of chronic rejection is as yet ambiguous. We hypothesized that alloreactive T and B cells play a seminal role in the development of this lesion.

METHODS

To address this hypothesis, RAG-2(-/-) mice were used as donors and recipients in a well-established murine model of aortic transplantation. Grafts were transplanted across the following groups: Group I: C3H --> C3H; Group II: Wild-type [WT] 129Sv (H-2(b)) --> C3H (H-2(k)); Group III: C3H --> WT 129Sv; Group IV: 129SvEv RAG-2(-/-) --> C3H; and Group V: C3H --> 129SvEv RAG-2(-/-). Grafts were harvested at d40 to 146 post-transplantation for morphologic and immunohistochemical analyses and semi-quantitative RT-PCR was employed to evaluate the intragraft mRNA expression of various immune mediators. Mixed lymphocyte reaction and complement-mediated alloantibody cytotoxicity assays were performed to determine anti-donor proliferative and humoral responses, respectively.

RESULTS

Unlike that across the syngeneic combination (Group I), marked intimal thickening with corresponding luminal narrowing was observed in the majority of the aortic allografts (Groups II-IV). On the contrary, the morphology of C3H aortic allografts harvested from the majority of the RAG-2(-/-) was remarkably preserved. Correspondingly, anti-donor proliferative and humoral immune responses were undetectable in C3H --> RAG-2(-/-) recipients as was the intragraft mRNA expression of the Th(1) and the Th(2)-type cytokines.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, these data suggest that in this murine model of aortic allotransplantation, donor-specific cellular and humoral responses play a dominant role in the initiation and perpetuation of chronic rejection.

Interleukin-17 antagonism inhibits acute but not chronic vascular rejection

BACKGROUND

Blocking the action of interleukin (IL) 17 with an IL-17 receptor (R):Fc fusion protein inhibits T-cell proliferative responses to alloantigens and prolongs vascularized heart graft survival. In this study, we examined whether IL-17 antagonism could suppress the development of chronic rejection.

METHODS

A 0.6-cm section of C57BL10 (H2b) thoracic aorta was transplanted to recipient C3H (H2k) abdominal aorta. IL-17R:Fc or control human immunoglobulin G was administered i.p. (500 microg/day) from days 0 to 6 or from days 0 to 29. Mice were killed on days 7 or 30. Grafts were examined histologically and stained for alpha-smooth muscle actin (alpha-smA). Antidonor mixed leukocyte reaction, cytotoxic T cell, and alloantibody responses were quantified.

RESULTS

On day 7, control grafts showed mononuclear cell (MNC) infiltration, pronounced endothelial damage, and apoptosis of intimal and medial cell compartments. By day 30, there was concentric intimal thickening, accumulation of alpha-smA+ cells, and collagen deposition. Patchy destruction of the elastic membranes and loss of alpha-smA expression in media were evident. IL-17R:Fc for 6 days decreased MNC infiltration in the intimal and medial compartments at day 7. The endothelium was preserved (completely or partially) in all grafts. The medial compartment showed normal alpha-smA expression. Irrespective of IL-17R:Fc treatment for either 6 days or continuously, allografts harvested at day 30 showed circumferential intimal thickening, with accumulation of alpha-smA+ cells and collagen deposition. There was no effect on circulating alloantibody levels.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings support a role for IL-17 in the immunopathogenesis of acute vascular rejection and demonstrate the potential of IL-17 antagonism for therapy. By contrast, IL-17 antagonism does not appear to prevent ensuing chronic graft vascular disease, in particular neointimal formation.

Chronic humoral rejection: identification of antibody-mediated chronic renal allograft rejection by C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries

The pathogenesis of chronic renal allograft rejection (CR) remains obscure. The hypothesis that a subset of CR is mediated by antidonor antibody was tested by determining whether C4d is deposited in peritubular capillaries (PTC) and whether it correlates with circulating antidonor antibodies. All cases (from January 1, 1990, to July 31, 1999) that met histologic criteria for CR and had frozen tissue (28 biopsies, 10 nephrectomies) were included. Controls were renal allograft biopsies with chronic cyclosporine toxicity (n = 21) or nonspecific interstitial fibrosis (n = 10), and native kidneys with end-stage renal disease (n = 10) or chronic interstitial fibrosis (n = 5). Frozen sections were stained by two-color immunofluorescence for C4d, type IV collagen and Ulex europaeus agglutinin I. Antidonor HLA antibody was sought by panel-reactive antibody analysis and/or donor cross matching in sera within 7 wk of biopsy. Overall, 23 of 38 CR cases (61%) had PTC staining for C4d, compared with 1 of 46 (2%) of controls (P < 0.001). C4d in PTC was localized at the interface of endothelium and basement membrane. Most of the C4d-positive CR tested had antidonor HLA antibody (15 of 17; 88%); none of the C4d-negative CR tested (0 of 8) had antidonor antibody (P < 0.0002). The histology of C4d-positive CR was similar to C4d-negative CR, and 1-yr graft survival rates were 62% and 25%, respectively (P = 0.05). Since August 1998, five of six C4d-positive CR cases have been treated with mycophenolate mofetil +/- tacrolimus with a 100% 1-yr graft survival, versus 40% before August 1998 (P < 0.03). These data support the hypothesis that a substantial fraction of CR is mediated by antibody (immunologically active). C4d can be used to separate this group of CR from the nonspecific category of chronic allograft nephropathy and may have the potential to guide successful therapeutic intervention.