Surgical management of Gartland type III supracondylar humerus fractures in older children: a retrospective study

Analysis of risk factors for failed closed reduction in pediatric Gartland Type III supracondylar humerus fracture

BACKGROUND

Gartland Type III supracondylar humerus fractures (SCHFs) are commonly treated using closed reduction followed by percutaneous pin fixation. However, conversion to open reduction may be necessary if closed reduction fails. This study aimed to identify risk factors associated with failed closed reduction and provide a theoretical basis for clinical decision-making in the treatment of Gartland Type III fractures.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was conducted on children with Gartland Type III SCHF who underwent surgical treatment between April 2017 and June 2018. Based on whether or not the closed reduction was successful, patients were split into the open reduction group and the closed reduction group. Within the closed reduction group, subgroup analysis based on surgery duration was carried out. Data were collected from medical records and X-ray images. Univariate and multivariate regression analyses were utilized to evaluate the relationship between variables and failed closed reduction.

RESULTS

The study included 36 patients in the open reduction group and 135 patients in the closed reduction group. Multivariate analysis revealed that the presence of angle (P = .024, OR = 3.199), rotation (P = .000, OR = 6.359), skin creases (P = .013, OR = 4.077), anterior-posterior displacement ratio (P = .011, OR = 4.337), fracture angle in the anteroposterior view (P = .014, OR = 0.939), and fracture distal displacement direction (P = .002, OR = 5.384) were independent risk factors for failed closed reduction. Subgroup analysis showed that fracture distal displacement direction (P = .013), skin folds (P = .013), lateral displacement ratio (P = .016), and anterior-posterior displacement value (P = .005) significantly influenced the duration of closed reduction surgery.

CONCLUSION

The presence of sharp angle or rotation at the fracture ends, skin folds on the anterior elbow, minor anterior-posterior displacement of the fracture, higher medial inclination of the fracture plane, and distal fracture displacement toward the radial side are independent risk factors for failed closed reduction in pediatric Gartland Type III SCHF.

SUPRACONDYLAR FRACTURES IN CHILDREN: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF TREATMENT OPTIONS

OBJECTIVE

To compare the outcomes of surgical stabilization of pediatric supracondylar humeral fractures with the use of crossed Kirschner wires versus divergent lateral pinning wires.

METHODS

This is a systematic review with meta-analysis carried out by searching the MEDLINE/PubMed, Science Direct and Scielo databases. In these, the search for journals was carried out between January and August 2023, where 695 studies were found. To assess the quality of the studies, the Jadad and the MINORS scales were used.. The selection and reading of relevant articles were carried out by the researchers and 11 studies met the selection criteria.

RESULTS

From the 11 selected studies, 963 patients who met the criteria for the surgical treatment of these fractures were grouped. After the statistical analysis, we found that the ulnar nerve injury had a higher incidence when the crossed-K wire technique was used; and the lateral fixation is safer for the ulnar nerve.

CONCLUSION

Both fixation techniques determine good functional results. However, fixation with lateral Kirschner wires proves to be safer considering the risk of iatrogenic injury to the ulnar nerve. Crossed-K wire fixation is more effective in terms of stability and maintenance of fracture reduction. Level of Evidence II, Systematic Review of Level II or Level I Studies with discrepant results.

Treatment and Outcome of Supracondylar Humeral Fractures in Children Over 10 Years of Age at the Time of Injury: A Review of 60 Cases

OBJECTIVES

To assess the treatment and outcomes of supracondylar humeral fractures (SHFs) in children older than 10 years of age at the time of injury.

METHODS

The study analyzed clinical data from 60 patients who sustained SHF, all over the age of 10 years, were analyzed. The patients included 49 males and 11 females with a mean age of 10.9 ± 0.9 years (range, 10 to 14.5). All patients underwent surgical treatment under general anesthesia. Closed reduction (CR) and percutaneous fixation were the primary treatment, with open reduction and internal fixation being employed only in cases CR was unsuccessful. The study assessed the healing of fractures by measuring the radiographic angles, including the carrying angle (RCA), Baumann's angle (BA), and metaphyseal-diaphyseal angle (MDA) on anteroposterior radiographs of the elbow joint. In addition, the study evaluated whether the anterior humeral line (AHL) appropriately passed through the middle third of the capitellum. The final follow-up visit used the Mayo Elbow Performance Index score (MEPI) and Flynn's criteria to analyze the recovery of elbow function.

RESULTS

There were 15 (25%) SHF type II, 17 (28.3%) type III and 28 (46.7%) type IV. Of the 60 patients, 56 (93.3%) underwent successful CR, whereas 4 (6.7%) required open reduction and internal fixation because of an unsuccessful CR. The final follow-up showed the average BA as 72° ± 5.3°, the average MDA as 88.3° ± 2.8°, and the average RCA as 9.6° ± 3.9°. The AHL bisected accurately the capitellum in 59 cases (98.3%). The average range of elbow flexion-extension was 146.6° ± 8.6°, whereas the average MEPI score was 99.9 ± 0.6; 98.3% (n=59) were rated as excellent and 1.7% (n=1) were rated as good. According to Flynn's criteria, 86.7% had an excellent outcome (n=52), 10% had a good outcome (n=6), and 3.3% had a poor outcome (n=2). Only 1 patient (1.7%) experienced redisplacement. Eight cases of nerve injury were reported, with 7 involving the radial nerve and 1 involving the ulnar nerve; all resolved spontaneously.

CONCLUSIONS

CR and percutaneous fixation have been shown to be effective in treating SHF in 93.3% of children aged 10 years old and older at the time of injury, with favorable radiographic and functional outcomes and a low risk of secondary displacement. Open reduction should only be considered when CR is ineffective.

Finite element analysis of modified Slongo's external fixation in the treatment of supracondylar humeral fractures in older children

Older children over 8 years old are at higher risk of elbow joint stiffness after treatment of supracondylar humeral fractures. The objective of this study was to improve the Slongo's external fixation system for treating supracondylar humeral fractures in older children. This would be achieved by increasing fixation strength and providing a theoretical basis through finite element analysis and mechanical testing. A 13-year-old female patient with a history of previous fracture was selected for CT data processing to create a three-dimensional model of the distal humerus fracture. Two internal fixation models were established, using the Slongo's external fixation method with Kirschner wire (Group A) and modifying the Slongo's external fixation (Kirschner wire tail fixation) (Group B). The fracture models were then subjected to mechanical loading analysis using Finite Element Analysis Abaqus 6.14 software to simulate separation, internal rotation, and torsion loads. A PVC humeral bone model was used to create a supracondylar fracture model, and the A and B internal fixation methods were applied separately. The anterior-posterior and torsional stresses were measured using the Bose Electroforce3510 testing system, followed by a comparative analysis. The finite element simulation results showed that under the same tensile, torsion, and inversion forces, the osteotomy model fixed with Kirschner wire at the distal end in Group B exhibited smaller tensile stress and deformation compared to the unfixed osteotomy model in Group A. This indicated that the fixation strength of Group B was superior to that of Group A. According to the test results of the Bose Electroforce3510 testing system, a simple linear regression analysis was conducted using SPSS software. The K values of rotation angle-torque tests and front and rear displacement-stress tests were calculated for Groups A and B, with Group B showing higher values than Group A. The results of this study supported the significantly enhanced biomechanical reliability and stability of fracture fixation in Group B, which utilized the modified Slongo's external fixation (Kirschner wire tail fixation). This optimized method provides a new choice for the clinical treatment of supracondylar humeral fractures in older children, backed by both clinical evidence and theoretical basis.

A Systemic Review of Adolescent Supracondylar Fractures: What Is the Surgical Treatment, Open Reduction With Internal Fixation (ORIF) or Closed Reduction With Percutaneous Pinning (CRPP)?

Supracondylar humerus (SCH) fractures represent the most frequent elbow injury in young children. These fractures can be treated through either closed reduction with percutaneous pinning (CRPP) or open reduction with internal fixation (ORIF). Yet, the optimal treatment option for adolescents remains unclear. This research contrasts the results of CRPP and ORIF treatments for distal humerus fractures in adolescents. In June 2023, we conducted a comprehensive search of PUBMED, OVID MEDLINE, Web of Science, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and various trial registries without any time restrictions. We evaluated the quality of qualifying studies using the Methodological Index for Non-randomized Studies (MINORS) and Cochrane risk measures for bias. We extracted data particularly related to patient demographics, fracture details, medical procedures followed, complications encountered, and the resulting outcomes. Out of the 488 studies identified, only four satisfied the inclusion criteria. Both methods illustrated comparable outcomes in terms of range of motion, averaging approximately 118 degrees in the ORIF group versus a span of 114 to 128 degrees in the CRPP group. The immobilization period varied, spanning 10 to 13 days for ORIF versus 24 to 29 days for CRPP. Despite this, CRPP displayed a decreased necessity for additional surgery. Notably, one study indicated a higher frequency of heterotopic ossification within the ORIF group. This review indicates that both CRPP and ORIF are effective for treating supracondylar fractures in adolescents, yielding similar results. However, CRPP has a lower need for follow-up surgery. Future studies with larger sample sizes are needed to solidify these findings, providing stronger guidance for treatment.

Double joystick technique - a modified method facilitates operation of Gartlend type-Ⅲ supracondylar humeral fractures in children

Gartland type-Ⅲ supracondylar humerus fracture (SCHF) is a severe lesion with the feature of difficult reduction. Due to the high failure rate of traditional reduction, a more practical and safer method is needed. This retrospective study aimed to explore the effectiveness of the double joystick technique during the closed reduction of children with type-III fractures. Forty-one children with Gartland type-Ⅲ SCHF underwent closed reduction and percutaneous fixation using the double joystick technique at our hospital between June 2020 and June 2022, and 36 (87.80%) patients were successfully followed up. The affected elbow was evaluated by the joint motion, radiographs, and Flynn's criteria then contrasted with the contralateral elbow at the last follow-up. A group of 29 boys and seven girls with an average age of 6.33 ± 2.68 years. The mean time of surgery and hospital stay was 26.61 ± 7.51 min and 4.64 ± 1.23 days, respectively. After a mean follow-up of 12.85 months, the average Baumann angle was 73.43 ± 3.78°, although the average carrying angle (11.33 ± 2.17°), flexion angle (143.03 ± 5.15°), and extension angle (0.89 ± 3.23°) of the affected elbow were less than those of the contralateral elbow ( P  < 0.05), the mean range of motion difference between two sides is only 3.39 ± 1.59°, with no complications. Furthermore, 100% of patients recovered satisfactorily, with excellent outcomes (91.67%) and good outcomes (8.33%). The double joystick technique is a safe and effective method that facilitates the closed reduction of Gartland type-Ⅲ SCHF in children without raising the risk of complications.

Anterior Versus Posterior Surgical Approaches to Pediatric Supracondylar Humerus Fracture

OBJECTIVES

Gartland type III supracondylar humerus fractures frequently occur as traumatic injuries in children and often require surgical intervention. This study aimed to compare the efficacy of anterior and posterior surgical approaches to treating these fractures.

METHODS

This retrospective study analyzed 48 patients under the age of 10 with Gartland type III fractures. These patients were treated with either the anterior (n=23) or the posterior approach (n=25). At three and six months post-surgery, elbow range of motion (ROM), complications, and functional/cosmetic outcomes were assessed using Flynn's criteria.

RESULTS

No significant differences were found between the groups regarding age or gender. At three months, the anterior group showed significantly better extension (-8.26° vs. -13.20°, P=0.032), but this difference was not significant at six months. No significant differences were observed in flexion, pronation, or supination at any time point. Both groups showed significant ROM improvements from three to six months (P<0.001); however, these improvements were slightly below the normative values (P<0.05). The overall complication rates were low and comparable between the two approaches (anterior: 8.70%; posterior: 12.00%; P=0.700), primarily comprising reversible ulnar nerve injuries and superficial infections. Furthermore, based on Flynn's criteria, there were no significant differences in functional or cosmetic outcomes, with most patients achieving excellent or good results in both groups.

CONCLUSION

Both anterior and posterior approaches for pediatric Gartland type III supracondylar humerus fractures resulted in satisfactory outcomes. Therefore, the choice of surgical approach will depend on patient-related factors and surgeons' preferences.

A NEW FLUOROSCOPY TECHNIQUE FOR SUPRACONDYLAR HUMERUS FRACTURES

Introduction

To compare two different intraoperative fluoroscopy techniques used for closed reduction and percutaneous pinning (CRPP) in pediatric patients with supracondylar humerus fractures (SHF).

Materials and Methods

Thirty-six patients who underwent SHF surgery from May 2011 to June 2019 were included in the study. During surgery, the classical fluoroscopy method (CFM) was used in 21 patients and the new fluoroscopy method (NFM) was used in the remaining 15 patients.

Results

The mean age was 5.14±1.13 years in the NFM group and 5.38±1.36 years in the CFM group. Mean operative time was 38.14±5.92 minutes in the CFM group and 21.54±3.48 minutes in the NFM group (p=0.001), while mean fluoroscopy times were 25.65±3.91 seconds and 39.84±7.50 seconds in the NFM and CFM groups, respectively (p=0.001). The NFM and CFM groups demonstrated similar functional capacity as measured by the Mayo Elbow Score (p=0.168). Direct radiographs obtained to measure Baumann's angle also showed that the two groups had similar results (p=0.848).

Conclusions

The NFM is a reliable and successful technique as it leads to shorter operative and fluoroscopy times, as well as providing improvement in functional scores and radiological outcomes in short-term follow-up. Level of Evidence III, Therapeutic Studies-Investigating the Results Level of Treatment.

The outcome of loose bone fragments in pediatric supracondylar humerus fractures: a retrospective study

We evaluated the clinical and imaging outcomes of loose bone fragments in children with supracondylar humerus fractures after closed reduction with percutaneous pin (CRPP) fixation. A retrospective review was conducted on 12 children with fragments on imaging after closed reduction of displaced humeral supracondylar fractures (Gartland III). Primary radiographic assessment included fragment outcome, postoperative Baumann angle, carrying angle and loss of reduction. Clinical outcome included the elbow range of motion (ROM), Flynn grade and other complications. Between January 2015 and January 2018, 460 children (2-14 years old) with supracondylar humerus fractures were treated at our center, including 12 (2.6%) with loose bone fragments on postoperative X-ray. Union or absorption of fragments was noted in all 12 patients at 1 year postoperatively, with good radiographic and clinical outcomes. The mean Baumann angle was 15.5° ± 4.3° and the mean carrying angle was 11.2° ± 2.8°. All patients had a normal elbow ROM. Ten patients achieved an excellent and two a good result according to the Flynn criteria. Good results were achieved after CRPP fixation in 12 children with supracondylar humerus fractures and loose bone fragments. The fragments were mainly absorbed or achieved union to the humerus within 1 year.

Treatment and outcomes of pediatric supracondylar humeral fractures in Korle Bu Teaching Hospital

Objectives:

Supracondylar humeral fractures (SCHF) are the most common elbow injury in the pediatric population. The treatment, outcome, and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) following these injuries are described.

Methods:

Patients with SCHF who were treated depending on the fracture type were evaluated. Medical records stored in the REDCap database were reviewed to obtain information on demographics, mechanisms of injury, neurovascular status, infection rates, and postoperative complications. Outcomes were assessed using Flynn's criteria and Pediatric Quality of Life (PedsQL) version 4.0. Follow-up was for 6 months.

Results:

A total of 101 patients with a mean age of 5.2 years (SD ± 2.3) were seen. Most of the injuries occurred at home (64.3%). The left-arm (nondominant) was the most injured (62%), though 92% of patients were right hand dominant. Ninety-six percent of the fractures were the extension type. A total of 98% had satisfactory outcomes using Flynn's criteria and older patients were likely to sustain Gartland type III SCHF (P = .01). There was a significant difference in mean scores of PedsQL (all P values < .01) at 6 months.

Conclusions:

In this prospective study, the quality of life of patients following SCHF diminished at the time of the injury and returned to the population normal 6 months after. There was no significant difference in HRQoL scores between patients who presented early and those who presented late. The delayed presentation and management did not also affect the functional outcome and complications. Therefore, surgical management of these injuries after late presentation is still safe.

Modified Closed Reduction and Percutaneous Kirschner Wires Internal Fixation for Treatment of Supracondylar Humerus Fractures in Children

OBJECTIVE

Supracondylar humerus fractures are the most frequent fractures of the paediatric elbow. The present study introduced a modified surgical procedure for treatment of supracondylar humerus fractures in children.

METHODS

From February 2015 to August 2019, 73 patients with Gartland's type II and III supracondylar fractures were treated with this modified method. Totally, 68 of all patients were followed up for 3-12 months (mean 8.25 months). The evaluation results included fracture nonunion, ulnar nerve injury, pin track infection, carrying angle and elbow joint Flynn score.

RESULTS

The results showed that bone union was observed in all children, one case had an iatrogenic ulnar nerve injury, and the symptoms were completely relieved in 4 months after removing of the medial-side pin. All children had no cubitus varus deformity and no pin track infection, and the rate of satisfactory results according to Flynn's criteria score was 100%.

CONCLUSION

The modified closed reduction and Kirschner wires internal fixation could effectively reduce the rate of open reduction, the risk of iatrogenic ulnar nerve injury, and the incidence of cubitus varus deformity in treatment of supracondylar humerus fractures in children.

Lateral entry pins and Slongo's external fixation: which method is more ideal for older children with supracondylar humeral fractures?

Objective

The standard surgical treatment for supracondylar humeral fractures in children is closed reduction and percutaneous pinning. Given the need for greater fixation strength and higher risk of joint stiffness for children older than 8 years, external fixation is often performed for treating supracondylar humeral fractures in older children. The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of lateral entry pins and Slongo’s external fixation for treating supracondylar humeral fractures in older children.

Methods

Children older than 8 years who underwent surgery for supracondylar humeral fractures at our hospital for surgery from January 2016 to December 2020 are to be retrospectively assessed. One group (n = 36) underwent internal fixation and percutaneous pinning with three lateral Kirschner wires, and the other group (n = 32) underwent Slongo’s external fixator surgery. The demographic data, operation duration, number of fluoroscopies, and fracture healing time were compared between both groups. The elbow joint function was evaluated 6 months after the surgery on the basis of fracture healing time, lifting angle, elbow joint range of motion (ROM), and Flynn score. The incidence of postoperative complications was also recorded.

Results

There was no significant difference between the two patient groups in terms of the demographic parameters. Compared to external fixation surgery, Kirschner wire surgery required shorter duration and fewer fluoroscopies (P < 0.05). Nevertheless, the fracture healing time was significantly less (P < 0.05), and the elbow ROM and Flynn scores were higher in the external fixator group compared to the Kirschner wire fixation group (P < 0.05). There was one case of secondary fracture displacement in the Kirschner wire group and one of pin tract infection in the external fixator group. No other iatrogenic injuries or complications were observed.

Conclusion

Maybe Slongo’s external fixator is a suitable alternative treatment option for supracondylar humeral fractures in children older than 8 years since it can achieve better fixation strength and early restoration of elbow joint movement with a lower risk of joint stiffness.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13018-021-02541-z.

Supracondylar Humerus Fractures in Older Children: Success of Closed Reduction and Percutaneous Pinning

BACKGROUND

The incidence of supracondylar humerus (SCH) fracture declines and fracture types change as children grow. Optimal treatment method is unclear in older children. The aim of the study was to determine if fracture type and configuration of distal humerus fractures changes as patients approach skeletal maturity, and to assess the success of closed reduction and percutaneous pin (CRPP) in extra-articular SCH fractures in this transitional age group.

METHODS

Inclusion criteria for this retrospective review were (1) distal humerus fractures with extension types 2 and 3, flexion type, T-type; (2) surgically managed, and (3) modified Sauvegrain score ≥1. Reviewed parameters included fracture type and configuration, grade of skeletal maturity, fixation technique, and loss of reduction. Primary analysis was to determine the distribution of fracture type and configuration with age or grade of skeletal maturity. Secondary analysis was used to determine the factors affecting treatment success of CRPP in extra-articular fractures.

RESULTS

A total of 142 patients were included (58 males and 84 females). Fracture types revealed significant changes with increased age (P=0.031) and skeletal maturity grade (P<0.005). Skeletal maturity was a better predictor of changing fracture type than chronological age. T-type fractures were only seen in patients with modified Sauvegrain score ≥6 and flexion-type fractures were only seen in patients with modified Sauvegrain score ≤4. Loss of reduction rate after CRPP was 5%. The success of CRPP was not affected by age, sex, modified Sauvegrain score, fracture type, direction of displacement, coronal fracture pattern, number of pins or medial pin use. Fracture obliquity in the sagittal plane (P=0.05), suboptimal pin spread (P<0.01), and lack of bicolumnar fixation (P<0.01) were found as statistically significant factors associated with failed CRPP.

CONCLUSION

The distribution of fracture type changed with increased age and skeletal maturity. CRPP of extra-articular fractures in older children is a reliable option regardless of the stage of skeletal maturity. Determinants of a good outcome include optimal pinning technique with adequate pin spread at the fracture site and bicolumnar fixation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV-retrospective case series.

Functional outcome of supracondylar humerus fracture in children with the use of pin configuration as per Bahk classification

INTRODUCTION

A variety of fracture patterns are seen in supracondylar humerus fractures in children and these are well described by Bahk et al. Currently followed treatment protocol doesn't recognize these common fracture patterns and pin placement is done at the discretion of the treating surgeon. The aim of the study is to evaluate the usefulness of Bahk classification system in deciding the pin configuration for the specific fracture patterns and thereby assess the functional outcome in the management of supracondylar fractures in children.

METHOD

The study was done on 100 children of 2-12 years of age from February 2019 to January 2020. After closed reduction under general anesthesia, fractures were classified and pin configuration was decided according to Bahk classification. In the follow-up, patients were assessed for clinicoradiological outcomes based on Modified Flynn's criteria, Baumann angle, and anterior humeral line.

RESULTS

In our study Typical transverse and low sagittal fracture were the most common fracture patterns. In the final follow up as per Flynn's criteria, 93% of the patients showed excellent results. Mean Baumann's angle was not significantly different from the uninjured side and anterior humeral line passed through anterior or middle third of the capitulum in 95% patients.

CONCLUSION

Using pin configuration suitable to fracture pattern as per Bahk classification improves functional outcome in supracondylar humerus fractures in children and minimizes complications.

Temporary Fixation of Reduction with Fabric Adhesive Bandage in the Surgical Treatment of Pediatric Supracondylar Humerus Fractures

Background and objectives: Supracondylar humerus fractures are common in children and can be surgically treated. However, the general surgical procedures involving reduction and fixation might lead to reduction loss, failure to direct the Kirschner (K)-wire toward the desired position, prolonged surgery, or chondral damage. This study aimed to show that temporary fixation of closed reduction with a fabric adhesive bandage in pediatric supracondylar humerus fractures could maintain reduction so that surgical treatment can be easily performed by a single physician. Materials and Methods: Forty-six patients with Gartland type 3 supracondylar humerus fractures who underwent surgical treatment between May 2017 and June 2018 were retrospectively evaluated. Fluoroscopy-guided reduction and fixation were performed from the distal third of the forearm to the proximal third of the humerus using a fabric adhesive bandage. Two crossed pins were applied on the fracture line by first inserting a lateral-entry K-wire and then inserting another K-wire close to the anterior aspect of the medial epicondyle and diverging from the ulnar nerve tunnel. A tourniquet was not applied in any patient and no patients required open reduction. Results: The study included 32 boys (69.6%) and 14 girls (30.4%) (mean age, 7.1; range, 2–16 years). The mean hospital stay and follow-up duration were 4.3 ± 3.9 days and 48.1 ± 14.3 weeks, respectively. Heterotopic ossification was detected in one patient, and ulnar nerve neuropraxia was detected in another patient. Functional (according to Flynn criteria) and cosmetic outcomes were excellent in 95.6%, moderate in 2.2%, and poor in 2.2% of patients. The mean duration of fixation of the closed reduction with a fabric adhesive bandage was 8.1 ± 3.9 min, and the mean duration of pinning was 7.9 ± 1.4 min. Conclusions: Temporary preoperative fixation of supracondylar humerus fractures that require surgical treatment with a fabric adhesive bandage may be significantly convenient in practice.