The Association Between Concussion History and Increased Symptom Severity Reporting Is Independent of Common Medical Comorbidities, Personality Factors, and Sleep Quality in Collegiate Athletes

Long-Term Brain Health Outcomes in Females With a History of Contact Sports: A Cross-Sectional Survey Analysis

OBJECTIVE

To assess whether female sex is associated with higher lifetime concussion risk and if years of contact sport participation and/or concussion history are associated with negative long-term cognitive and psychiatric difficulties in females compared with males.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional survey.

SETTING

ResearchMatch, a national health-based volunteer registry.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 330 participants (111 females) with contact sport exposure.

INTERVENTIONS

Participants reported lifetime concussion history, age of first exposure, and duration of contact sport exposure.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Lifetime concussion history, depressive symptoms (PHQ-9), anxiety symptoms (GAD-7), and cognitive symptoms (BC-CCI).

RESULTS

Of 330 participants (N = 111 females), 57.1% of females reported at least one concussion. Females had fewer years of contact sport exposure than males (6.0 ± 4.5 vs 8.5 ± 8.9 years; P < 0.001). Age of first exposure was similar between sexes (females: 11.7 ± 8.9 years; males: 11.5 ± 5.3 years; P = 0.779). Female sex was not associated with a positive lifetime concussion history (OR = 1.13; 95% CI, 0.66-1.93; P = 0.662). Total years of contact sport exposure did not predict lifetime concussion history in females (OR = 1.02; 95% CI, 0.94-1.11; P = 0.667) but did in males (OR = 1.05; 95% CI, 1.01-1.10; P = 0.020). Increased lifetime concussions predicted increased late-life depressive, anxiety, and cognitive symptoms in both sexes.

CONCLUSIONS

Female sex was not associated with a higher likelihood of having a lifetime concussion history. Total years of contact sport exposure did not predict lifetime concussion risk in females but did in males. Increased lifetime concussions were associated with higher late-life depressive, anxiety, and cognitive symptoms in both sexes.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

These findings highlight the importance of considering sex-specific differences in assessing long-term cognitive and psychiatric risks in former athletes.

Long-term neurobehavioral and neuroimaging outcomes in athletes with prior concussion(s) and head impact exposure

Objective: The long-term health of former athletes with a history of multiple concussions and/or repetitive head impact (RHI) exposure has been of growing interest among the public. The true proportion of dementia cases attributable to neurotrauma and the neurobehavioral profile/sequelae of multiple concussion and RHI exposure among athletes has been difficult to determine. Methods: Across three exposure paradigms (i.e. group comparisons of athletes vs. controls, number of prior concussions, and level of RHI exposure), this review characterizes the prevalence of neurodegenerative/neurological disease, changes in cognitive and psychiatric function, and alterations on neuroimaging. We highlight sources of variability across studies and provide suggested directions for future investigations. Results: The most robust finding reported in the literature suggests a higher level of symptom endorsement (general, psychiatric, and cognitive) among those with a greater history of sport-related concussion from adolescence to older adulthood. Pathological processes (e.g. atrophy, tau deposition, and hypometabolism) may be more likely to occur within select regions (frontal and temporal cortices) and structures (thalamus and hippocampus). However, studies examining concussion(s) and RHI exposure with imaging outcomes have yet to identify consistent associations or evidence of a dose-response relationship or a threshold at which associations are observed. Discussion: Studies have not observed a simple dose-response relationship between multiple concussions and/or RHI exposure with cognitive, psychiatric, or in vivo neurobiological outcomes, particularly at lower levels of play. The relationship between prior concussion and RHI exposure with long-term outcomes in former athletes is complex and likely influenced by -several non-injury-related factors.

Comparing peer relationship ratings among adolescents with sport and Non-sport Related Concussions

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate if peer relationship ratings differ among adolescents who sustain a sport-related concussion compared to those who sustain a non-sport-related concussion.

STUDY DESIGN

We conducted a cross-sectional investigation of 123 adolescents who sustained a concussion within 21 days before their initial post-injury evaluation (mean = 9.2 ± 3.9 days post-concussion). Participants reported whether their injury occurred during organized sport participation (sport-related concussion group) or not (non-sport-related concussion group). Participants completed the PROMIS Global Pediatric 25 assessment, as well as the Post-Concussion Symptom Inventory (PCSI) to rate concussion symptom severity and a background/demographic intake form during the evaluation. We compared PROMIS peer relationship ratings between groups using independent t-tests and evaluated the association between peer relationship ratings and sport-related concussion using multiple linear regression after adjusting for covariates including PROMIS anxiety rating, age, sex, concussion and musculoskeletal injury history, loss of consciousness at time of concussion, physical activity participation prior to study evaluation, and concussion symptom severity.

RESULTS

Most (N = 96, 78%) participants reported sustaining a concussion during sports. The group who sustained sport-related concussion reported significantly better post-concussion peer relationship ratings compared to the group who sustained a non-sport-related concussion (52.7 ± 7.7 vs. 47.7 ± 10.4; p = 0.009, Cohen's d = 0.60). After covariate adjustment, those who sustained a sport-related concussion had a significantly greater post-concussion peer relationship rating than those who sustained a non-sport-related concussion (β = 4.19, 95% CI = 0.39, 8.00; p = 0.03). Higher peer relationship ratings were also associated with lower anxiety ratings following concussion (β= -0.21, 95% CI= -0.38, -0.04; p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

Adolescents who sustained a concussion during sports reported significantly greater post-concussion peer relationship ratings than those in non-sport settings. Better peer relationship ratings were associated with less anxiety in the post-injury period. These findings suggest the potential effects of contextual factors (e.g. peer support) to facilitate improved outcomes following adolescent concussion.

Protective effect of helmet use on mortality in bicycle crashes: A matched case-control study

INTRODUCTION

In 2022; South Korea had 3.3 million daily bicycle users and around 13,000 crashes with 190 fatalities annually. While helmets are known to prevent head injuries, research on their effectiveness in preventing fatalities is lacking. This study explores factors influencing bicycle-related fatalities and examines if helmets reduce the risk of death in road traffic incidents.

METHODS

This case-control study used data from the Emergency Department-based Injury In-depth Surveillance (EDIIS) from 2011 to 2021; analyzing 76,983 bicycle injury cases. Of these, 282 fatalities were identified as the case group, and 1,112 controls were randomly selected based on gender, age, and year of visit. The study examined risk factors for bicycle fatalities and used conditional logistic regression to assess the impact of helmet use on traumatic brain injury and in-hospital mortality.

RESULTS

In this study of 1,394 patients (282 cases and 1,112 controls), 11.1% were wearing helmets at the time of the crash. The majority of cases involved males (88%) and individuals aged 60-79 years (58.6%). Cases were more likely to occur between 00:00-06:00 and 18:00-00:00 and involved a higher proportion of non-helmeted riders (96.1% vs. 87.1%). Bicycle fatalities were more often due to collisions with automobiles (67.7%), while non-fatal injuries were mainly from crashes without a collision (45.8%). Head injuries were common in both groups, but traumatic brain injury (TBI) was significantly higher among cases (41.5% vs. 11.9%). Key factors associated with ED mortality included the time of injury, alcohol use, crashes on national highways, no helmet use, and collisions with automobiles. Helmet use was associated with a non-significant 35% lower risk of TBI and a significant 63% lower risk of ED mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

Key risk factors for fatal bicycle injuries included being aged 60-79, male, involved in nighttime crashes, collisions with automobiles, not wearing a helmet, and sustaining a traumatic brain injury (TBI). Helmet use was linked to lower rates of TBIs and reduced mortality. To decrease bicycle-related deaths, stronger legal regulations, educational efforts, and improved infrastructure are essential, along with further interventions and research to effectively tackle these issues.

Baseline Evaluation of Concussion-Like Symptoms and Modifying Factors in Collegiate Club-Sport Athletes

CONTEXT

Collegiate club-sport athletes participate in a variety of competitive sports and have been understudied in the concussion literature. Baseline performance measures are warranted to better understand assessment and management.

OBJECTIVE

To quantify normative values and the effects of modifying factors sex, concussion history, diagnosed attention disabilities (attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder [ADHD]), and sport type on baseline symptom evaluation among collegiate club-sport athletes.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Retrospective chart review.

PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS

A total of 1034 collegiate club-sport athletes (N = 649 males, 62.7%) from 29 sports at a single institution.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Chart reviews were conducted for club-sport athletes who completed athlete background and symptom information on the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool-5th edition as a baseline concussion assessment during a single academic year. Demographics (eg, age, sex, sport), background medical information (eg, concussion history, ADHD), and symptom evaluation, consisting of individual 22-item symptom reports, the total number of symptoms, symptom severity scores, and symptom factors (eg, physical, cognitive, insomnia, and emotional), were analyzed.

RESULTS

On baseline symptom reporting, 68% of club-sport athletes were asymptomatic, with mild symptoms described by 3% to 12% and moderate or severe symptoms by ≤4%. Modifier groups differed with a higher total number of symptoms and symptom severity in females (P < .001), individuals reporting a history of concussion (P < .001), and those with ADHD (total number P = .04, symptom severity P = .02). Similar significant findings were noted for females and the history of concussion group on all 4 symptom factors; however, those in collision or contact sports also indicated greater cognitive (P = .03) and insomnia (P = .02) factors. Those with ADHD endorsed more cognitive (P < .001) factors.

CONCLUSIONS

Normative symptoms for a collegiate club-sport sample revealed approximately 70% were asymptomatic. Higher total number of symptoms and symptom severity were demonstrated by females and those with a history of concussion. Cognitive-specific symptoms were greater in those diagnosed with ADHD and those who participated in collision or contact sports.

Diffusion tensor imaging in the courtroom: Distinction between scientific specificity and legally admissible evidence

Interest and uptake of science and medicine peer-reviewed literature by readers outside of a paper’s topical subject, field or even discipline is ever-expanding. While the application of knowledge from one field or discipline to others can stimulate innovative solutions to problems facing modern society, it is also fraught with danger for misuse. In the practice of law in the United States, academic papers are submitted to the courts as evidence in personal injury litigation from both the plaintiff (complainant) and defendant. Such transcendence of an academic publication over disciplinary boundaries is immediately met with the challenge of application by a group that inherently lacks in-depth knowledge on the scientific method, the practice of evidence-based medicine, or the publication process as a structured and internationally synthesized process involving peer review and guided by ethical standards and norms. A modern-day example of this is the ongoing conflict between the sensitivity of diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) and the legal standards for admissibility of evidence in litigation cases of mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). In this review, we amalgamate the peer-reviewed research on DTI in mTBI with the court’s rationale underlying decisions to admit or exclude evidence of DTI abnormalities to support claims of brain injury. We found that the papers which are critical of the use of DTI in the courtroom reflect a primary misunderstanding about how diagnostic biomarkers differ legally from relevant and admissible evidence. The clinical use of DTI to identify white matter abnormalities in the brain at the chronic stage is a valid methodology both clinically as well as forensically, contributes data that may or may not corroborate the existence of white matter damage, and should be admitted into evidence in personal injury trials if supported by a clinician. We also delve into an aspect of science publication and peer review that can be manipulated by scientists and clinicians to publish an opinion piece and misrepresent it as an unbiased, evidence-based, systematic research article in court cases, the decisions of which establish precedence for future cases and have implications on future legislation that will impact the lives of every citizen and erode the integrity of science and medicine practitioners.

Subtle impairments of perceptual-motor function and well-being are detectable among military cadets and college athletes with self-reported history of concussion

Introduction

A lack of obvious long-term effects of concussion on standard clinical measures of behavioral performance capabilities does not preclude the existence of subtle neural processing impairments that appear to be linked to elevated risk for subsequent concussion occurrence, and which may be associated with greater susceptibility to progressive neurodegenerative processes. The purpose of this observational cohort study was to assess virtual reality motor response variability and survey responses as possible indicators of suboptimal brain function among military cadets and college athletes with self-reported history of concussion (HxC).

Methods

The cohort comprised 75 college students (20.7 ± 2.1 years): 39 Reserve Officer Training Corp (ROTC) military cadets (10 female), 16 football players, and 20 wrestlers; HxC self-reported by 20 (29.2 ± 27.1 months prior, range: 3-96). A virtual reality (VR) test involving 40 lunging/reaching responses to horizontally moving dots (filled/congruent: same direction; open/incongruent: opposite direction) was administered, along with the Sport Fitness and Wellness Index (SFWI) survey. VR Dispersion (standard deviation of 12 T-scores for neck, upper extremity, and lower extremity responses to congruent vs. incongruent stimuli originating from central vs. peripheral locations) and SFWI response patterns were the primary outcomes of interest.

Results

Logistic regression modeling of VR Dispersion (range: 1.5-21.8), SFWI (range: 44-100), and an interaction between them provided 81% HxC classification accuracy (Model χ ²[2] = 26.03, p < .001; Hosmer & Lemeshow χ ²[8] = 1.86, p = .967; Nagelkerke R ²= .427; Area Under Curve = .841, 95% CI: .734, .948). Binary modeling that included VR Dispersion ≥3.2 and SFWI ≤86 demonstrated 75% sensitivity and 86% specificity with both factors positive (Odds Ratio = 17.6, 95% CI: 5.0, 62.1).

Discussion/Conclusion

Detection of subtle indicators of altered brain processes that might otherwise remain unrecognized is clearly important for both short-term and long-term clinical management of concussion. Inconsistency among neck, upper extremity, and lower extremity responses to different types of moving visual stimuli, along with survey responses suggesting suboptimal well-being, merit further investigation as possible clinical indicators of persisting effects of concussion that might prove to be modifiable.