Significance of hemorrhages at the origin of the sternocleidomastoid muscles in hanging

Conventional and machine learning-based analysis of age, body weight and body height significance in knot position-related thyrohyoid and cervical spine fractures in suicidal hangings

The thyrohyoid complex and cervical spine fracture distribution patterns may reflect the knot position as the force distribution by the noose to different neck regions may vary depending on it. Recently, machine learning models (MLm) were used to classify knot position through these fractures. The contribution of aging on the fracture susceptibility is better demonstrated, but data on body weight (BW) and height (BH) significance on this is more doubtful and MLm did not consider them. A retrospectively obtained autopsy data on sex, age, BW, BH and distribution of greater hyoid bone horn (GHH), superior thyroid cartilage horn (STH), and cervical spine fractures in 368 suicidal hangings were analyzed by standard statistics to determine association of the anthropometrics (age, BW, and BH) with the fracture occurrence, and by machine learning algorithms to determine if body weight and height improved MLm classification of hanging cases with typical and atypical knot positions. In the sample, unilateral GHH fracture was significantly more common in atypical hangings, while isolated STH fractures were more common in typical hangings. Age was a predictor of GHH fractures and BW of STH fractures, but BW poorly correlated with their number. BH was not a predictor of any thyrohyoid fracture. On the ROC curve analysis, the MLm that considered BW and BH did not perform statistically better than MLm that did not consider them. The study indicates that body weight and height are of no detrimental value in assessing the thyrohyoid and cervical spine fracture patterns in suicidal hangings.

Diagnostic Value of Sternocleidomastoid Muscle Hemorrhage on Clavicular Periosteum in Hanging Deaths

BACKGROUND

Suicide remains a significant global public health challenge, with hanging as the most prevalent suicide method in South Korea. This study aimed to determine diagnostic markers confirming suicidal hanging-associated deaths.

METHODS

In this prospective study, hemorrhages at the periosteal-clavicular origin of the sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscles were compared among suicidal hanging, manual strangulation, and ligature strangulation cases. This study included 211 cases of suicide by hanging, and a control group of 50 individuals who underwent cardiopulmonary resuscitation but died of other causes. Additionally, nine cases of ligature strangulation and six cases of manual strangulation were analyzed. Postmortem examinations were conducted, and clavicular hemorrhages were histologically evaluated. Statistical analyses were performed using the χ² test.

RESULTS

Hemorrhages at the periosteal-clavicular origin of the SCM were observed in 178 of the 211 hanging cases (84.4%). The highest frequency of clavicular hemorrhage was found in typical hanging cases with complete suspension. Among the 50 control cases, only three showed hemorrhages in the clavicular region, but these were extravasations in the adjoining soft tissue, not in the periosteum. In cases of manual and ligature strangulation, SCM hemorrhages were found within the muscle tissue and were not of periosteal-clavicular origin.

CONCLUSION

Hemorrhage at the periosteal-clavicular origin of the SCM is a significant finding in suicidal hanging and serves as a potential pathognomonic marker for confirming cases of suicidal hanging. The study revealed a statistically significant association between the type of hanging, completeness of body suspension, and the occurrence of these hemorrhages. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation does not cause a hemorrhage at this location.

A case of hemorrhage at the junctions of the posterior intercostal arteries-a vital sign?

The authors present the case of a 58-year-old man found hanging from a radiator by his shoelaces. The time of death was approximately 6 h before the body was discovered. An autopsy was performed approximately 24 h after the body was found, which revealed hemorrhages in the thoracic aorta at the junctions of the posterior intercostal arteries. Before autopsy, a routine whole-body CT scan was performed. Histologic examination of the aorta and the posterior intercostal arteries revealed a fresh hemorrhage into the tunica adventitia of the aorta. To our knowledge, there is no case description of such findings in hanged persons in the literature. Conclusion: Hemorrhages into the tunica adventitia of the junction of the posterior costal arteries may occur in association with suicidal hanging. The significance of these hemorrhages as a sign of vitality may be debated.

Assessing the knot in a noose position by thyrohyoid and cervical spine fracture patterns in suicidal hangings using machine learning algorithms: A new insight into old dilemmas

Hanging is one of the most common suicide methods worldwide. Neck injuries that occur upon such neck compression - fractures of the thyrohyoid complex and cervical spine, occupy forensic pathologists for a long time. However, research failed to identify particular patterns of these injuries corresponding to the force distribution a ligature applies to the neck: the issue of reconstructing the knot in a noose position persists. So far, machine learning (ML) models were not utilized to classify knot positions and reconstruct this event. We conducted a single-institutional, retrospective study on 1235 autopsy cases of suicidal hanging, developed several ML models, and assessed their classification performance in a stepwise manner to discriminate between: 1. typical ('posterior) and atypical ('anterior' and 'lateral') hangings, 2. anterior and lateral hangings, and 3. left and right lateral hangings. The variable coding was based on the presence/absence of fractures of greater hyoid bone horns (GHH), superior thyroid cartilage horns (STH), and cervical spine. Subject age was considered. The models' parameters were optimized by the Genetic Algorithm. The accuracy of ML models in the first step was very modest (c. 60%) but increased subsequently: Multilayer Perceptron - Artificial Neural Network and k-Nearest Neighbors performed excellently discriminating between left and right lateral hangings (accuracy 91.8% and 90.6%, respectively). The latter is of great importance for clarifying probable hanging fracture biomechanics. Alongside the conventional inferential statistical analysis we performed, our results further indicate the association of the knot position with ipsilateral GHH and contralateral STH fractures in lateral hangings. Moreover, odds for unilateral GHH fracture, simultaneous GHH and STH fractures, and cervical spine fracture were significantly higher in atypical ('anterior' and 'lateral') hangings, compared to typical ('posterior') hangings.

[Forensic assessment of neck organs alterations in hanging depending on the noose position]

OBJECTIVE

To reveal statistical patterns in the localization of alterations in organs and tissues of the neck in hanging depending on the noose location.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In this study 222 forensic examination reports of corpses of those who died from hanging, conducted in the Bureau of Forensic Medical Expertise of Moscow Oblast for 2019, were investigated. Standard methods of mathematical statistics, including Mann-Whitney U Test and the Fisher's Exact Test, were used for calculations. Sex and age characteristics of hanging cases were given.

RESULTS

Retrospective statistical analysis has shown that the pattern of injuries revealed in organs and tissues of the neck both depends (in cases of Amussat's sign) and does not depend (in cases of hemorrhages in the legs of sternocleidomastoid muscle, fractures of the hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage, Martin's sign) on the noose position.

CONCLUSION

The obtained results can be used to develop measures aimed at improving the quality of forensic examination of hanging cases.

Ligature Mark: Crime or Suicide?

Identifying the morphological findings of vitality is crucial when determining if a lesion was inflicted in life or postmortem [...].

Rektale Blutungen beim Erhängen – seltene Befunde mit Verwechslungsgefahr

Bei der Obduktion von erhängt aufgefundenen Personen kommt dem Nachweis der Vitalität des Hängens und dem Ausschluss der Beteiligung von dritter Hand eine besondere Bedeutung zu. Jedoch kann es in einigen Fällen durch die Position des Leichnams zu postmortalen Befunden kommen, die für die Obduzenten erschwert zu interpretieren sein können. So sind in der Literatur seltene Fälle von rektaler Blutstauung mit Schleimhauteinrissen beschrieben, die als Folgen sexueller Handlungen fehlinterpretiert werden können.

Es wird über zwei Fälle von jungen Männern berichtet, die jeweils in sitzender Position an einer Türklinke erhängt aufgefunden wurden. Sowohl bei der polizeilichen als auch der rechtsmedizinischen Leichenschau fielen rektale Blutantragungen und Befunde auf, die zunächst an eine möglicherweise auch gewaltsame anale Penetration denken ließen.

Bei den durchgeführten gerichtlichen Sektionen konnte dann festgestellt werden, dass diese Befunde durch eine ausgeprägte rektale Blutstauung hervorgerufen wurden. Zusätzlich zeigten sich bei einem Leichnam Einblutungen der Dünndarmwand und eines Hodens.

Es werden sowohl die makroskopischen als auch die histologischen Befunde vorgestellt und in Zusammenschau mit der Auffindesituation und den bereits in der Literatur beschriebenen Fällen diskutiert.

Autopsy findings of suicidal hanging in Mugla, Turkey

Introduction: External and internal autopsy findings of suicidal hanging were evaluated retrospectively in Muğla, Turkey. The relations between macroscopic autopsy findings and age, gender, nature of the ligature, position of the knot, and the ligature marks were assessed. The aim of this study was to describe autopsy findings of the hangings and discuss the regional differences. Method: The reports of 175 hanging autopsies between 2013 to 2018 were evaluated retrospectively. Macroscopic external and internal findings were evaluated and compared statistically. Results: Among the 2534 autopsies, the cause of death was suicide by hanging in 175 cases (6.9%). The male-to-female ratio was 3:1, 76%(n = 133) of the cases were male, 24% (n = 42) were female, the mean age was 44.9(SD = 19.3) years. Suicide by hanging was most prevalent in the 25-44 age group and among men. Complete hanging was more common than incomplete hanging, and softer materials were more commonly used in incomplete hangings. Females utilized soft materials more than males. Males used atypical hanging more than females. Bilateral hemorrhage in the neck muscles was more common with typical hanging. There was a significant relationship between tongue protrusion and hemorrhage at the clavicular head of sternocleidomastoid muscle. Conclusion: In this study, which includes a large series, some regional and gender differences were observed. Careful and detailed macroscopic examination was important to diagnose antemortem vitality findings.

An Overview on Actual Knowledge About Immunohistochemical and Molecular Features of Vitality, Focusing on the Growing Evidence and Analysis to Distinguish Between Suicidal and Simulated Hanging

In forensic practice, the pathologist is often asked to determine whether a hanging was committed as suicide or as a simulated hanging (when a dead body is suspended after death). When exterior evidence of violence is absent and the crime scene investigation fails to identify useful proof, it is nearly impossible to tell whether the dead body was suspended or not. As a result, determining whether the ligature mark was created during life or not should rely on the research and demonstration of vital reactions on the ligature mark. The main purpose of this review article is to provide a summary of current knowledge about the histological and immunohistochemical characteristics of vitality in hanging. The authors also aim to identify the most significant vitality markers on ligature marks for further scientific validation and to propose a standardized diagnostic protocol for hanging. The study was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review (PRISMA) Protocol. Relevant scientific papers were found from PubMed up to April 2021, using the following keywords: hanging AND skin AND vitality. Three main points were studied: ligature mark dehydration, immunological response to mechanical injury, and apoptosis induction as a result of the previous points. An increase in apoptosis is evident in the ligature mark (due to physical and chemical processes involved), as demonstrated by FLICE-inhibitory protein (FLIP) depletion. Immunohistochemical detection of Aquaporin 3 (AQP3) and increase in the concentration of different electrolytes rely solely on ligature mark dehydration. Also, microRNAs (MiRNAs) could become reliable forensic biomarkers for ligature mark vitality diagnosis in the near future. To ensure high reliability in court cases, forensic investigation in hanging should rely on modern and proven markers, even a mix of several markers.

Entrapment within an ottoman storage bed: an unusual accidental asphyxial death

Herein, we present an uncommon forensic case of death by asphyxia. The victim was a woman whose body at death scene investigation (DSI) was discovered beside an ottoman storage bed. According to the rescue team, who had moved the body before our arrival, the body was originally found in the prone position and stuck with the neck, thorax and arms within the bed. Examination of the body showed hypostasis that was mainly distributed to the face and the lower chest while sparing the neck and the upper chest. The face was markedly swollen, and the eyes were congested with blood. Dissection and histology revealed pulmonary oedema and emphysema of both lungs. Integrating circumstantial, radiology and autopsy data, it was established that the victim, while trapped between the mattress and the edge of the ottoman storage bed, died by mechanical asphyxia due to cervical-thoracic compression and postural asphyxia acting simultaneously.

Gender differences in completed suicidal hangings from 2013 to 2018 in Muğla, Turkey

BACKGROUND

Hanging is the most preferred among suicide methods. Although methods vary based on age groups and social and cultural conditions, many studies have reported it as the most common suicide method in Turkey.

OBJECTIVE

Assess autopsy findings of suicidal hangings according to gender differences.

DESIGN

Retrospective, cross-sectional.

SETTING

Local morgue.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

The autopsy reports of hanging autopsies between 2013-2018. Data was retrospectively collected from autopsy reports. Sociodemographic features, reasons, suicide notes, the news media, and macroscopic autopsy findings were evaluated. Findings were statistically compared by gender.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Gender differences in autopsy findings.

SAMPLE SIZE AND CHARACTERISTICS

175 autopsy reports of suicide by hanging.

RESULTS

Among 2534 autopsies, 175 (6.9%) cases involved hanging. Most (76%, n=133) were males; the median (interquartile range) age was 42.0 (29.5), the male/female ratio was 3:1. Suicide notes were found in 42 cases; 81 (24%) were from men. The most common reason for suicide was a mental illness (n=51, 29.2%), followed by family problems (n=26, 14.9%), but the cause was unknown in 42 cases (24.0%). More than half of the events were covered in the news media (58.9%). Rope was most commonly used with women preferring a softer material. Men were more frequently single than women. Men were more frequently single and not actively working than women (P=.026 and P≤.001, respectively). The incidence of atypical hanging was higher for males than females (P<.05).

CONCLUSION

The findings showed that there were some statistically significant differences in socioeconomic and mental health factors between men and women in hanging suicide. This study may serve as the basis for more comprehensive studies to investigate the causes of suicide.

LIMITATIONS

Single-center, retrospective.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

None.

Fatal strangulation during consensual BDSM activity: three case reports

Autoerotic accidents are well-known occurrences in forensic casework. Reports about unintentional deaths in a sexual context involving other persons are much rarer. Three cases of fatal incidents related to asphyxiophilia during consensual BDSM activity are reported. Two men died while visiting a dominatrix, the third one in the presence of a male casual sexual partner. Paraphernalia associated with BDSM/fetishism were found at the scene in all cases. Autopsy findings were compatible with death by strangulation. The cases are compared with published autoerotic accidents and similar unintentional deaths involving other individuals. The difficulties concerning the forensic assessment and reconstruction of the cases are discussed.

Anthropological analysis of trauma in throat bone and cartilage: A review

In their analysis of recovered human remains, forensic anthropologists encounter structures of the throat (hyoid bone, thyroid cartilage/bone, cricoid cartilage/bone) that may present evidence of trauma. The recent published literature provides guidelines for the detection and interpretation of fractures in these tissues. Such traumatic injury frequently is associated with victims of hanging and strangulation, but many other causes have been recognized. Although the hyoid is not always recovered in skeletonized remains, it can reveal evidence of perimortem trauma and must be interpreted appropriately.

Traumatic rupture of deep neck structures in hanging: two case reports

Injuries to the neck structures are various in case of hanging. Soft tissue lesions generally consist in sternocleidomastoid and subhyoid muscle hemorrhages. Traumatic ruptures of deep neck structures are rare. We report 2 cases of partial and complete ruptures of sternocleidomastoid muscles after suicidal hanging. Both were typical and complete hanging. In 1 case, muscle laceration was associated with common carotid rupture on the same side. Hemorrhage at the rupture site was only found at the microscopic level. Such injuries may result from the ligature's compression and depend on duration of suspension. Heavy body weight, rigid rope material, and fall after a jump may promote their occurrence.