Spatial genome organization: contrasting views from chromosome conformation capture and fluorescence in situ hybridization

Interferon-gamma rescues dendritic cell calcineurin-dependent responses to Aspergillus fumigatus via Stat3 to Stat1 switching

Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis is a lethal opportunistic fungal infection in transplant recipients receiving calcineurin inhibitors. We previously identified a role for the calcineurin pathway in innate immune responses to A. fumigatus and have used exogenous interferon-gamma successfully to treat aspergillosis in this setting. Here we show that calcineurin inhibitors block dendritic cell maturation in response to A. fumigatus, impairing the Th1 polarization of CD4 cells. Interferon gamma, an immunotherapeutic option for invasive aspergillosis, restored maturation and promoted Th1 polarization via a dendritic cell dependent effect that was co-dependent on T cell interaction. We find that interferon gamma activates alternative transcriptional pathways to calcineurin-NFAT for the augmentation of pathogen handling. Histone modification ChIP-Seq analysis revealed dominant control by an interferon gamma induced regulatory switch from STAT3 to STAT1 transcription factor binding underpinning these observations. These findings provide key insight into the mechanisms of immunotherapy in organ transplant recipients with invasive fungal diseases.

Mapping the 3D genome architecture

The spatial organization of the genome plays a critical role in regulating gene expression, cellular differentiation, and genome stability. This review provides an in-depth examination of the methodologies, computational tools, and frameworks developed to map the three-dimensional (3D) architecture of the genome, focusing on both ligation-based and ligation-free techniques. We also explore the limitations of these methods, including biases introduced by restriction enzyme digestion and ligation inefficiencies, and compare them to more recent ligation-free approaches such as Genome Architecture Mapping (GAM) and Split-Pool Recognition of Interactions by Tag Extension (SPRITE). These techniques offer unique insights into higher-order chromatin structures by bypassing ligation steps, thus enabling the capture of complex multi-way interactions that are often challenging to resolve with traditional methods. Furthermore, we discuss the integration of chromatin interaction data with other genomic layers through multimodal approaches, including recent advances in single-cell technologies like sci-HiC and scSPRITE, which help unravel the heterogeneity of chromatin architecture in development and disease.

Enhancers: A Focus on Synthetic Biology and Correlated Gene Expression

Enhancers are central for the regulation of metazoan transcription but have proven difficult to study, primarily due to a myriad of interdependent variables shaping their activity. Consequently, synthetic biology has emerged as the main approach for dissecting mechanisms of enhancer function. We start by reviewing simple but highly parallel reporter assays, which have been successful in quantifying the complexity of the activator/coactivator mechanisms at enhancers. We then describe studies that examine how enhancers function in the genomic context and in combination with other enhancers, revealing that they activate genes through a variety of different mechanisms, working together as a system. Here, we primarily focus on synthetic reporter genes that can quantify the dynamics of enhancer biology through time. We end by considering the consequences of having many genes and enhancers within a 'local environment', which we believe leads to correlated gene expression and likely reports on the general principles of enhancer biology.

Cell type- and transcription-independent spatial proximity between enhancers and promoters

Cell type-specific enhancers are critically important for lineage specification. The mechanisms that determine cell-type specificity of enhancer activity, however, are not fully understood. Most current models for how enhancers function invoke physical proximity between enhancer elements and their target genes. Here, we use an imaging-based approach to examine the spatial relationship of cell type-specific enhancers and their target genes with single-cell resolution. Using high-throughput microscopy, we measure the spatial distance from target promoters to their cell type-specific active and inactive enhancers in individual pancreatic cells derived from distinct lineages. We find increased proximity of all promoter-enhancer pairs relative to non-enhancer pairs separated by similar genomic distances. Strikingly, spatial proximity between enhancers and target genes was unrelated to tissue-specific enhancer activity. Furthermore, promoter-enhancer proximity did not correlate with the expression status of target genes. Our results suggest that promoter-enhancer pairs exist in a distinctive chromatin environment but that genome folding is not a universal driver of cell-type specificity in enhancer function.

Heterochromatic 3D genome organization is directed by HP1a- and H3K9-dependent and independent mechanisms

Whether and how histone post-translational modifications and the proteins that bind them drive 3D genome organization remains unanswered. Here, we evaluate the contribution of H3K9-methylated constitutive heterochromatin to 3D genome organization in Drosophila tissues. We find that the predominant organizational feature of wild-type tissues is the segregation of euchromatic chromosome arms from heterochromatic pericentromeres. Reciprocal perturbation of HP1a⋅H3K9me binding, using a point mutation in the HP1a chromodomain or replacement of the replication-dependent histone H3 with H3K9R mutant histones, revealed that HP1a binding to methylated H3K9 in constitutive heterochromatin is required to limit contact frequency between pericentromeres and chromosome arms and regulate the distance between arm and pericentromeric regions. Surprisingly, the self-association of pericentromeric regions is largely preserved despite the loss of H3K9 methylation and HP1a occupancy. Thus, the HP1a⋅H3K9 interaction contributes to but does not solely drive the segregation of euchromatin and heterochromatin inside the nucleus.

Transcription decouples estrogen-dependent changes in enhancer-promoter contact frequencies and spatial proximity

How enhancers regulate their target genes in the context of 3D chromatin organization is extensively studied and models which do not require direct enhancer-promoter contact have recently emerged. Here, we use the activation of estrogen receptor-dependent enhancers in a breast cancer cell line to study enhancer-promoter communication at two loci. This allows high temporal resolution tracking of molecular events from hormone stimulation to efficient gene activation. We examine how both enhancer-promoter spatial proximity assayed by DNA fluorescence in situ hybridization, and contact frequencies resulting from chromatin in situ fragmentation and proximity ligation, change dynamically during enhancer-driven gene activation. These orthogonal methods produce seemingly paradoxical results: upon enhancer activation enhancer-promoter contact frequencies increase while spatial proximity decreases. We explore this apparent discrepancy using different estrogen receptor ligands and transcription inhibitors. Our data demonstrate that enhancer-promoter contact frequencies are transcription independent whereas altered enhancer-promoter proximity depends on transcription. Our results emphasize that the relationship between contact frequencies and physical distance in the nucleus, especially over short genomic distances, is not always a simple one.

Super-enhancers: drivers of cells' identities and cells' debacles

Precise spatiotemporal regulations of gene expression are essential for determining cells' fates and functions. Enhancers are cis-acting DNA elements that act as periodic transcriptional thrusters and their activities are cell type specific. Clusters of enhancers, called super-enhancers, are more densely occupied by transcriptional activators than enhancers, driving stronger expression of their target genes, which have prominent roles in establishing and maintaining cellular identities. Here we review the current knowledge on the composition and structure of super-enhancers to understand how they robustly stimulate the expression of cellular identity genes. We also review their involvement in the development of various cell types and both noncancerous and cancerous disorders, implying the therapeutic interest of targeting them to fight against various diseases.

Increased enhancer-promoter interactions during developmental enhancer activation in mammals

Remote enhancers are thought to interact with their target promoters via physical proximity, yet the importance of this proximity for enhancer function remains unclear. Here we investigate the three-dimensional (3D) conformation of enhancers during mammalian development by generating high-resolution tissue-resolved contact maps for nearly a thousand enhancers with characterized in vivo activities in ten murine embryonic tissues. Sixty-one percent of developmental enhancers bypass their neighboring genes, which are often marked by promoter CpG methylation. The majority of enhancers display tissue-specific 3D conformations, and both enhancer-promoter and enhancer-enhancer interactions are moderately but consistently increased upon enhancer activation in vivo. Less than 14% of enhancer-promoter interactions form stably across tissues; however, these invariant interactions form in the absence of the enhancer and are likely mediated by adjacent CTCF binding. Our results highlight the general importance of enhancer-promoter physical proximity for developmental gene activation in mammals.

Differential roles of positive and negative supercoiling in organizing the E. coli genome

This study aims to explore whether and how positive and negative supercoiling contribute to the three-dimensional (3D) organization of the bacterial genome. We used recently published Escherichia coli GapR ChIP-seq and TopoI ChIP-seq (also called EcTopoI-seq) data, which marks positive and negative supercoiling sites, respectively, to study how supercoiling correlates with the spatial contact maps obtained from chromosome conformation capture sequencing (Hi-C and 5C). We find that supercoiled chromosomal loci have overall higher Hi-C contact frequencies than sites that are not supercoiled. Surprisingly, positive supercoiling corresponds to higher spatial contact than negative supercoiling. Additionally, positive, but not negative, supercoiling could be identified from Hi-C data with high accuracy. We further find that the majority of positive and negative supercoils coincide with highly active transcription units, with a minor group likely associated with replication and other genomic processes. Our results show that both positive and negative supercoiling enhance spatial contact, with positive supercoiling playing a larger role in bringing genomic loci closer in space. Based on our results, we propose new physical models of how the E. coli chromosome is organized by positive and negative supercoils.

Dispersal of PRC1 condensates disrupts polycomb chromatin domains and loops

Polycomb repressive complex 1 (PRC1) strongly influences 3D genome organization, mediating local chromatin compaction and clustering of target loci. Several PRC1 subunits have the capacity to form biomolecular condensates through liquid-liquid phase separation in vitro and when tagged and over-expressed in cells. Here, we use 1,6-hexanediol, which can disrupt liquid-like condensates, to examine the role of endogenous PRC1 biomolecular condensates on local and chromosome-wide clustering of PRC1-bound loci. Using imaging and chromatin immunoprecipitation, we show that PRC1-mediated chromatin compaction and clustering of targeted genomic loci-at different length scales-can be reversibly disrupted by the addition and subsequent removal of 1,6-hexanediol to mouse embryonic stem cells. Decompaction and dispersal of polycomb domains and clusters cannot be solely attributable to reduced PRC1 occupancy detected by chromatin immunoprecipitation following 1,6-hexanediol treatment as the addition of 2,5-hexanediol has similar effects on binding despite this alcohol not perturbing PRC1-mediated 3D clustering, at least at the sub-megabase and megabase scales. These results suggest that weak hydrophobic interactions between PRC1 molecules may have a role in polycomb-mediated genome organization.

Multiplex-GAM: genome-wide identification of chromatin contacts yields insights overlooked by Hi-C

Technology for measuring 3D genome topology is increasingly important for studying gene regulation, for genome assembly and for mapping of genome rearrangements. Hi-C and other ligation-based methods have become routine but have specific biases. Here, we develop multiplex-GAM, a faster and more affordable version of genome architecture mapping (GAM), a ligation-free technique that maps chromatin contacts genome-wide. We perform a detailed comparison of multiplex-GAM and Hi-C using mouse embryonic stem cells. When examining the strongest contacts detected by either method, we find that only one-third of these are shared. The strongest contacts specifically found in GAM often involve 'active' regions, including many transcribed genes and super-enhancers, whereas in Hi-C they more often contain 'inactive' regions. Our work shows that active genomic regions are involved in extensive complex contacts that are currently underestimated in ligation-based approaches, and highlights the need for orthogonal advances in genome-wide contact mapping technologies.

On the Advent of Super-Resolution Microscopy in the Realm of Polycomb Proteins

The genomes of metazoans are organized at multiple spatial scales, ranging from the double helix of DNA to whole chromosomes. The intermediate genomic scale of kilobases to megabases, which corresponds to the 50-300 nm spatial scale, is particularly interesting, as the 3D arrangement of chromatin is implicated in multiple regulatory mechanisms. In this context, polycomb group (PcG) proteins stand as major epigenetic modulators of chromatin function, acting prevalently as repressors of gene transcription by combining chemical modifications of target histones with physical crosslinking of distal genomic regions and phase separation. The recent development of super-resolution microscopy (SRM) has strongly contributed to improving our comprehension of several aspects of nano-/mesoscale (10-200 nm) chromatin domains. Here, we review the current state-of-the-art SRM applied to PcG proteins, showing that the application of SRM to PcG activity and organization is still quite limited and mainly focused on the 3D assembly of PcG-controlled genomic loci. In this context, SRM approaches have mostly been applied to multilabel fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). However, SRM data have complemented the maps obtained from chromosome capture experiments and have opened a new window to observe how 3D chromatin topology is modulated by PcGs.

Long range inter-chromosomal interaction of Oct4 distal enhancer loci regulates ESCs pluripotency

Nuclear architecture underlies the transcriptional programs within the cell to establish cell identity. As previously demonstrated, long-range chromatin interactions of the Oct4 distal enhancer (DE) are correlated with active transcription in naïve state embryonic stem cells. Here, we identify and characterize extreme long-range interactions of the Oct4 DE through a novel CRISPR labeling technique we developed and chromosome conformation capture to identify lethal giant larvae 2 (Llgl2) and growth factor receptor-bound protein 7 (Grb7) as putative functional interacting target genes in different chromosomes. We show that the Oct4 DE directly regulates expression of Llgl2 and Grb7 in addition to Oct4. Expression of Llgl2 and Grb7 closely correlates with the pluripotent state, where knock down of either result in loss of pluripotency, and overexpression enhances somatic cell reprogramming. We demonstrated that biologically important interactions of the Oct4 DE can occur at extreme distances that are necessary for the maintenance of the pluripotent state.

Simultaneous mapping of 3D structure and nascent RNAs argues against nuclear compartments that preclude transcription

Mammalian genomes are organized into three-dimensional DNA structures called A/B compartments that are associated with transcriptional activity/inactivity. However, whether these structures are simply correlated with gene expression or are permissive/impermissible to transcription has remained largely unknown because we lack methods to measure DNA organization and transcription simultaneously. Recently, we developed RNA & DNA (RD)-SPRITE, which enables genome-wide measurements of the spatial organization of RNA and DNA. Here we show that RD-SPRITE measures genomic structure surrounding nascent pre-mRNAs and maps their spatial contacts. We find that transcription occurs within B compartments-with multiple active genes simultaneously colocalizing within the same B compartment-and at genes proximal to nucleoli. These results suggest that localization near or within nuclear structures thought to be inactive does not preclude transcription and that active transcription can occur throughout the nucleus. In general, we anticipate RD-SPRITE will be a powerful tool for exploring relationships between genome structure and transcription.

The relevance of chromatin architecture to genome rearrangements in Drosophila

DNA within chromosomes in the nucleus is non-randomly organized into chromosome territories, compartments and topologically associated domains (TADs). Chromosomal rearrangements have the potential to alter chromatin organization and modify gene expression leading to selection against these structural variants. Drosophila pseudoobscura has a wealth of naturally occurring gene arrangements that were generated by overlapping inversion mutations caused by two chromosomal breaks that rejoin the central region in reverse order. Unlike humans, Drosophila inversion heterozygotes do not have negative effects associated with crossing over during meiosis because males use achiasmate mechanisms for proper segregation, and aberrant recombinant meiotic products generated in females are lost in polar bodies. As a result, Drosophila populations are found to harbour extensive inversion polymorphisms. It is not clear, however, whether chromatin architecture constrains which inversions breakpoints persist in populations. We mapped the breakpoints of seven inversions in D. pseudoobscura to the TAD map to determine if persisting inversion breakpoints are more likely to occur at boundaries between TADs. Our results show that breakpoints occur at TAD boundaries more than expected by chance. Some breakpoints may alter gene expression within TADs supporting the hypothesis that position effects contribute to inversion establishment. This article is part of the theme issue 'Genomic architecture of supergenes: causes and evolutionary consequences'.

The era of 3D and spatial genomics

Over a decade ago the advent of high-throughput chromosome conformation capture (Hi-C) sparked a new era of 3D genomics. Since then the number of methods for mapping the 3D genome has flourished, enabling an ever-increasing understanding of how DNA is packaged in the nucleus and how the spatiotemporal organization of the genome orchestrates its vital functions. More recently, the next generation of spatial genomics technologies has begun to reveal how genome sequence and 3D genome organization vary between cells in their tissue context. We summarize how the toolkit for charting genome topology has evolved over the past decade and discuss how new technological developments are advancing the field of 3D and spatial genomics.

Promoter and enhancer RNAs regulate chromatin reorganization and activation of miR-10b/HOXD locus, and neoplastic transformation in glioma

miR-10b is silenced in normal neuroglial cells of the brain but commonly activated in glioma, where it assumes an essential tumor-promoting role. We demonstrate that the entire miR-10b-hosting HOXD locus is activated in glioma via the cis-acting mechanism involving 3D chromatin reorganization and CTCF-cohesin-mediated looping. This mechanism requires two interacting lncRNAs, HOXD-AS2 and LINC01116, one associated with HOXD3/HOXD4/miR-10b promoter and another with the remote enhancer. Knockdown of either lncRNA in glioma cells alters CTCF and cohesin binding, abolishes chromatin looping, inhibits the expression of all genes within HOXD locus, and leads to glioma cell death. Conversely, in cortical astrocytes, enhancer activation is sufficient for HOXD/miR-10b locus reorganization, gene derepression, and neoplastic cell transformation. LINC01116 RNA is essential for this process. Our results demonstrate the interplay of two lncRNAs in the chromatin folding and concordant regulation of miR-10b and multiple HOXD genes normally silenced in astrocytes and triggering the neoplastic glial transformation.

enChIP-Seq Analyzer: A Software Program to Analyze and Interpret enChIP-Seq Data for the Detection of Physical Interactions between Genomic Regions

Accumulating evidence suggests that the physical interactions between genomic regions play critical roles in the regulation of genome functions, such as transcription and epigenetic regulation. Various methods to detect the physical interactions between genomic regions have been developed. We recently developed a method to search for genomic regions interacting with a locus of interest in a non-biased manner that combines pull-down of the locus using engineered DNA-binding molecule-mediated chromatin immunoprecipitation (enChIP) and next-generation sequencing (NGS) analysis (enChIP-Seq). The clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) system, consisting of a nuclease-dead form of Cas9 (dCas9) and a guide RNA (gRNA), or transcription activator-like (TAL) proteins, can be used for enChIP. In enChIP-Seq, it is necessary to compare multiple datasets of enChIP-Seq data to unambiguously detect specific interactions. However, it is not always easy to analyze enChIP-Seq datasets to subtract non-specific interactions or identify common interactions. To facilitate such analysis, we developed the enChIP-Seq analyzer software. It enables easy extraction of common signals as well as subtraction of non-specific signals observed in negative control samples, thereby streamlining extraction of specific enChIP-Seq signals. enChIP-Seq analyzer will help users analyze enChIP-Seq data and identify physical interactions between genomic regions.

Disruption of c-MYC Binding and Chromosomal Looping Involving Genetic Variants Associated With Ankylosing Spondylitis Upstream of the RUNX3 Promoter

Background: Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS) is a common form of inflammatory spinal arthritis with a complex aetiology and high heritability, involving more than 100 genetic associations. These include several AS-associated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) upstream of RUNX3, which encodes the multifunctional RUNT-related transcription factor (TF) 3. The lead associated SNP rs6600247 (p = 2.6 × 10⁻¹⁵) lies ∼13kb upstream of the RUNX3 promoter adjacent to a c-MYC TF binding-site. The effect of rs6600247 genotype on DNA binding and chromosome looping were investigated by electrophoretic mobility gel shift assays (EMSA), Western blotting-EMSA (WEMSA) and Chromosome Conformation Capture (3C).

Results: Interrogation of ENCODE published data showed open chromatin in the region overlapping rs6600247 in primary human CD14⁺ monocytes, in contrast to the Jurkat T cell line or primary human T-cells. The rs6600247 AS-risk allele is predicted to specifically disrupt a c-MYC binding-site. Using a 50bp DNA probe spanning rs6600247 we consistently observed reduced binding to the AS-risk “C” allele of both purified c-MYC protein and nuclear extracts (NE) from monocyte-like U937 cells. WEMSA on U937 NE and purified c-MYC protein confirmed these differences (n = 3; p < 0.05). 3C experiments demonstrated negligible interaction between the region encompassing rs6600247 and the RUNX3 promoter. A stronger interaction frequency was demonstrated between the RUNX3 promoter and the previously characterised AS-associated SNP rs4648889.

Conclusion: The lead SNP rs6600247, located in an enhancer-like region upstream of the RUNX3 promoter, modulates c-MYC binding. However, the region encompassing rs6600247 has rather limited physical interaction with the promoter of RUNX3. In contrast a clear chromatin looping event between the region encompassing rs4648889 and the RUNX3 promoter was observed. These data provide further evidence for complexity in the regulatory elements upstream of the RUNX3 promoter and the involvement of RUNX3 transcriptional regulation in AS.

Nuclear Architecture in the Nervous System

Neurons and glial cells in the nervous system exhibit different gene expression programs for neural development and function. These programs are controlled by the epigenetic regulatory layers in the nucleus. The nucleus is a well-organized subcellular organelle that includes chromatin, the nuclear lamina, and nuclear bodies. These subnuclear components operate together as epigenetic regulators of neural development and function and are collectively called the nuclear architecture. In the nervous system, dynamic rearrangement of the nuclear architecture has been observed in each cell type, especially in neurons, allowing for their specialized functions, including learning and memory formation. Although the importance of nuclear architecture has been debated for decades, the paradigm has been changing rapidly, owing to the development of new technologies. Here, we reviewed the latest studies on nuclear geometry, nuclear bodies, and heterochromatin compartments, as well as summarized recent novel insights regarding radial positioning, chromatin condensation, and chromatin interaction between genes and cis-regulatory elements.

High-Throughput DNA FISH (hiFISH)

High-throughput DNA fluorescence in situ hybridization (hiFISH) combines multicolor combinatorial DNA FISH staining with automated image acquisition and analysis to visualize and localize tens to hundreds of genomic loci in up to millions of cells. hiFISH can be used to measure physical distances between pairs of genomic loci, radial distances from genomic loci to the nuclear edge or center, and distances between genomic loci and nuclear structures defined by protein or RNA markers. The resulting large datasets of 3D spatial distances can be used to study cellular heterogeneity in genome architecture and the molecular mechanisms underlying this phenomenon in a variety of cellular systems. In this chapter we provide detailed protocols for hiFISH to measure distances between genomic loci, including all steps involved in DNA FISH probe design and preparation, cell culture, DNA FISH staining in 384-well imaging plates, automated image acquisition and analysis, and, finally, statistical analysis.

FISH Going Meso-Scale: A Microscopic Search for Chromatin Domains

The intimate relationships between genome structure and function direct efforts toward deciphering three-dimensional chromatin organization within the interphase nuclei at different genomic length scales. For decades, major insights into chromatin structure at the level of large-scale euchromatin and heterochromatin compartments, chromosome territories, and subchromosomal regions resulted from the evolution of light microscopy and fluorescence in situ hybridization. Studies of nanoscale nucleosomal chromatin organization benefited from a variety of electron microscopy techniques. Recent breakthroughs in the investigation of mesoscale chromatin structures have emerged from chromatin conformation capture methods (C-methods). Chromatin has been found to form hierarchical domains with high frequency of local interactions from loop domains to topologically associating domains and compartments. During the last decade, advances in super-resolution light microscopy made these levels of chromatin folding amenable for microscopic examination. Here we are reviewing recent developments in FISH-based approaches for detection, quantitative measurements, and validation of contact chromatin domains deduced from C-based data. We specifically focus on the design and application of Oligopaint probes, which marked the latest progress in the imaging of chromatin domains. Vivid examples of chromatin domain FISH-visualization by means of conventional, super-resolution light and electron microscopy in different model organisms are provided.

Biomolecular condensates at sites of DNA damage: More than just a phase

Protein recruitment to DNA break sites is an integral part of the DNA damage response (DDR). Elucidation of the hierarchy and temporal order with which DNA damage sensors as well as repair and signaling factors assemble around chromosome breaks has painted a complex picture of tightly regulated macromolecular interactions that build specialized compartments to facilitate repair and maintenance of genome integrity. While many of the underlying interactions, e.g. between repair factors and damage-induced histone marks, can be explained by lock-and-key or induced fit binding models assuming fixed stoichiometries, structurally less well defined interactions, such as the highly dynamic multivalent interactions implicated in phase separation, also participate in the formation of multi-protein assemblies in response to genotoxic stress. Although much remains to be learned about these types of cooperative and highly dynamic interactions and their functional roles, the rapidly growing interest in material properties of biomolecular condensates and in concepts from polymer chemistry and soft matter physics to understand biological processes at different scales holds great promises. Here, we discuss nuclear condensates in the context of genome integrity maintenance, highlighting the cooperative potential between clustered stoichiometric binding and phase separation. Rather than viewing them as opposing scenarios, their combined effects can balance structural specificity with favorable physicochemical properties relevant for the regulation and function of multilayered nuclear condensates.

Disruption of NIPBL/Scc2 in Cornelia de Lange Syndrome provokes cohesin genome-wide redistribution with an impact in the transcriptome

Cornelia de Lange syndrome (CdLS) is a rare disease affecting multiple organs and systems during development. Mutations in the cohesin loader, NIPBL/Scc2, were first described and are the most frequent in clinically diagnosed CdLS patients. The molecular mechanisms driving CdLS phenotypes are not understood. In addition to its canonical role in sister chromatid cohesion, cohesin is implicated in the spatial organization of the genome. Here, we investigate the transcriptome of CdLS patient-derived primary fibroblasts and observe the downregulation of genes involved in development and system skeletal organization, providing a link to the developmental alterations and limb abnormalities characteristic of CdLS patients. Genome-wide distribution studies demonstrate a global reduction of NIPBL at the NIPBL-associated high GC content regions in CdLS-derived cells. In addition, cohesin accumulates at NIPBL-occupied sites at CpG islands potentially due to reduced cohesin translocation along chromosomes, and fewer cohesin peaks colocalize with CTCF.

Single-cell imaging of genome organization and dynamics

Probing the architecture, mechanism, and dynamics of genome folding is fundamental to our understanding of genome function in homeostasis and disease. Most chromosome conformation capture studies dissect the genome architecture with population- and time-averaged snapshots and thus have limited capabilities to reveal 3D nuclear organization and dynamics at the single-cell level. Here, we discuss emerging imaging techniques ranging from light microscopy to electron microscopy that enable investigation of genome folding and dynamics at high spatial and temporal resolution. Results from these studies complement genomic data, unveiling principles underlying the spatial arrangement of the genome and its potential functional links to diverse biological activities in the nucleus.

The two waves in single-cell 3D genomics

For decades, biochemical methods for the analysis of genome structure and function provided cell-population-averaged data that allowed general principles and tendencies to be disclosed. Microscopy-based studies, which immanently involve single-cell analysis, did not provide sufficient spatial resolution to investigate the particularly small details of 3D genome folding. Nevertheless, these studies demonstrated that mutual positions of chromosome territories within cell nuclei and individual genomic loci within chromosomal territories can vary significantly in individual cells. The development of new technologies in biochemistry and the advent of super-resolution microscopy in the last decade have made possible the full-scale study of 3D genome organization in individual cells. Maps of the 3D genome build based on C-data and super-resolution microscopy are highly consistent and, therefore, biologically relevant. The internal structures of individual chromosomes, loci, and topologically associating domains (TADs) are resolved as well as cell-cycle dynamics. 3D modeling allows one to investigate the physical mechanisms underlying genome folding. Finally, joint profiling of genome topology and epigenetic features will allow 3D genomics to handle complex cell-to-cell heterogeneity. In this review, we summarize the present state of studies into 3D genome organization in individual cells, analyze the technical problems of single-cell studies, and outline perspectives of 3D genomics.

Super-resolution visualization and modeling of human chromosomal regions reveals cohesin-dependent loop structures

BACKGROUND

The 3D organization of the chromatin fiber in cell nuclei plays a key role in the regulation of gene expression. Genome-wide techniques to score DNA-DNA contacts, such as Hi-C, reveal the partitioning of chromosomes into epigenetically defined active and repressed compartments and smaller "topologically associated" domains. These domains are often associated with chromatin loops, which largely disappear upon removal of cohesin. Because most Hi-C implementations average contact frequencies over millions of cells and do not provide direct spatial information, it remains unclear whether and how frequently chromatin domains and loops exist in single cells.

RESULTS

We combine 3D single-molecule localization microscopy with a low-cost fluorescence labeling strategy that does not denature the DNA, to visualize large portions of single human chromosomes in situ at high resolution. In parallel, we develop multi-scale, whole nucleus polymer simulations, that predict chromatin structures at scales ranging from 5 kb up to entire chromosomes. We image chromosomes in G1 and M phase and examine the effect of cohesin on interphase chromatin structure. Depletion of cohesin leads to increased prevalence of loose chromatin stretches, increased gyration radii, and reduced smoothness of imaged chromatin regions. By comparison to model predictions, we estimate that 6-25 or more purely cohesin-dependent chromatin loops coexist per megabase of DNA in single cells, suggesting that the vast majority of the genome is enclosed in loops.

CONCLUSION

Our results provide new constraints on chromatin structure and showcase an affordable non-invasive approach to study genome organization in single cells.

Locus-Specific Genomic DNA Purification Using the CRISPR System: Methods and Applications

A multitude of molecular interactions with chromatin governs various chromosomal functions in cells. Insights into the molecular compositions at specific genomic regions are pivotal to deepen our understanding of regulatory mechanisms and the pathogenesis of disorders caused by the abnormal regulation of genes. The locus-specific purification of genomic DNA using the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) system enables the isolation of target genomic regions for identification of bound interacting molecules. This CRISPR-based DNA purification method has many applications. In this study, we present an overview of the CRISPR-based DNA purification methodologies as well as recent applications.

Three-dimensional chromatin ensemble reconstruction via stochastic embedding

We propose a comprehensive method for reconstructing the whole-genome chromatin ensemble from the Hi-C data. The procedure starts from Markov state modeling (MSM), delineating the structural hierarchy of chromatin organization with partitioning and effective interactions archetypal for corresponding levels of hierarchy. The stochastic embedding procedure introduced in this work provides the 3D ensemble reconstruction, using effective interactions obtained by the MSM as the input. As a result, we obtain the structural ensemble of a genome, allowing one to model the functional and the cell-type variability in the chromatin structure. The whole-genome reconstructions performed on the human B lymphoblastoid (GM12878) and lung fibroblast (IMR90) Hi-C data unravel distinctions in their morphologies and in the spatial arrangement of intermingling chromosomal territories, paving the way to studies of chromatin dynamics, developmental changes, and conformational transitions taking place in normal cells and during potential pathological developments.

Revisiting the organization of Polycomb-repressed domains: 3D chromatin models from Hi-C compared with super-resolution imaging

The accessibility of target gene, a factor critical for gene regulation, is controlled by epigenetic fine-tuning of chromatin organization. While there are multiple experimental techniques to study change of chromatin architecture with its epigenetic state, measurements from them are not always complementary. A qualitative discrepancy is noted between recent super-resolution imaging studies, particularly on Polycomb-group protein repressed domains in Drosophila cell. One of the studies shows that Polycomb-repressed domains are more compact than inactive domains and are segregated from neighboring active domains, whereas Hi-C and chromatin accessibility assay as well as the other super-resolution imaging studies paint a different picture. To examine this issue in detail, we analyzed Hi-C libraries of Drosophila chromosomes as well as distance constraints from one of the imaging studies, and modeled different epigenetic domains by employing a polymer-based approach. According to our chromosome models, both Polycomb-repressed and inactive domains are featured with a similar degree of intra-domain packaging and significant intermixing with adjacent active domains. The epigenetic domains explicitly visualized by our polymer model call for extra attention to the discrepancy of the super-resolution imaging with other measurements, although its precise physicochemical origin still remains to be elucidated.

Higher-Order Chromatin Organization Using 3D DNA Fluorescent In Situ Hybridization

A comprehensive analysis of the tridimensional (3D) organization of the genome is crucial to understand gene regulation. Three-dimensional DNA fluorescent in situ hybridization (3D-FISH) is a method of choice to study nuclear organization at the single-cell level. The labeling of DNA loci of interest provides information on their spatial arrangement, such as their location within the nucleus or their relative positioning. The single-cell information of spatial positioning of genomic loci can thus be integrated with functional genomic and epigenomic features, such as gene activity, epigenetic states, or cell population averaged chromatin interaction profiles obtained using chromosome conformation capture methods. Moreover, the development of a diversity of super-resolution (SR) microscopy techniques now allows the study of structural chromatin properties at subdiffraction resolution, making a finer characterization of shapes and volumes possible, as well as allowing the analysis of quantitative intermingling of genomic regions of interest. Here, we present and describe a 3D-FISH protocol adapted for both conventional and SR microscopy such as 3D structured illumination microscopy (3D-SIM), which can be used for the measurement of 3D distances between loci and the analysis of higher-order chromatin structures in cultured Drosophila and mammalian cells.

A novel cytogenetic method to image chromatin interactions at subkilobase resolution: Tn5 transposase-based fluorescence in situ hybridization

There is an increasing interest in understanding how three-dimensional organization of the genome is regulated. Different strategies have been used to identify genome-wide chromatin interactions. However, owing to current limitations in resolving genomic contacts, visualization and validation of these genomic loci at subkilobase resolution remain unsolved to date. Here, we describe Tn5 transposase-based fluorescence in situ hybridization (Tn5-FISH), a polymerase chain reaction-based, cost-effective imaging method, which can colocalize the genomic loci at subkilobase resolution, dissect genome architecture, and verify chromatin interactions detected by chromatin configuration capture-derived methods. To validate this method, short-range interactions in the keratin-encoding gene (KRT) locus in the topologically associated domain were imaged by triple-color Tn5-FISH, indicating that Tn5-FISH is very useful to verify short-range chromatin interactions inside the contact domain and TAD. Therefore, Tn5-FISH can be a powerful molecular tool for clinical detection of cytogenetic changes in numerous genetic diseases such as cancers.

Novel orthogonal methods to uncover the complexity and diversity of nuclear architecture

Recent years have seen a vast expansion of knowledge on three-dimensional (3D) genome organization. The majority of studies on chromosome topology consists of pairwise interaction data of bulk populations of cells and therefore conceals heterogenic and more complex folding patterns. Here, we discuss novel methodologies to study the variation in genome topologies between different cells and techniques that allow analysis of complex, multi-way interactions. These technologies will aid the interpretation of genome-wide chromosome conformation data and provide strategies to further dissect the interplay between genome architecture and transcription regulation.

Navigating the crowd: visualizing coordination between genome dynamics, structure, and transcription

The eukaryotic genome is hierarchically structured yet highly dynamic. Regulating transcription in this environment demands a high level of coordination to permit many proteins to interact with chromatin fiber at appropriate sites in a timely manner. We describe how recent advances in quantitative imaging techniques overcome caveats of sequencing-based methods (Hi-C and related) by enabling direct visualization of transcription factors and chromatin at high resolution, from single genes to the whole nucleus. We discuss the contribution of fluorescence imaging to deciphering the principles underlying this coordination within the crowded nuclear space in living cells and discuss challenges ahead.

Background-suppressed live visualization of genomic loci with an improved CRISPR system based on a split fluorophore

The higher-order structural organization and dynamics of the chromosomes play a central role in gene regulation. To explore this structure–function relationship, it is necessary to directly visualize genomic elements in living cells. Genome imaging based on the CRISPR system is a powerful approach but has limited applicability due to background signals and nonspecific aggregation of fluorophores within nuclei. To address this issue, we developed a novel visualization scheme combining tripartite fluorescent proteins with the SunTag system and demonstrated that it strongly suppressed background fluorescence and amplified locus-specific signals, allowing long-term tracking of genomic loci. We integrated the multicomponent CRISPR system into stable cell lines to allow quantitative and reliable analysis of dynamic behaviors of genomic loci. Due to the greatly elevated signal-to-background ratio, target loci with only small numbers of sequence repeats could be successfully tracked, even under a conventional fluorescence microscope. This feature enables the application of CRISPR-based imaging to loci throughout the genome and opens up new possibilities for the study of nuclear processes in living cells.

GSDB: a database of 3D chromosome and genome structures reconstructed from Hi-C data

Advances in the study of chromosome conformation capture technologies, such as Hi-C technique - capable of capturing chromosomal interactions in a genome-wide scale - have led to the development of three-dimensional chromosome and genome structure reconstruction methods from Hi-C data. The three dimensional genome structure is important because it plays a role in a variety of important biological activities such as DNA replication, gene regulation, genome interaction, and gene expression. In recent years, numerous Hi-C datasets have been generated, and likewise, a number of genome structure construction algorithms have been developed.

In this work, we outline the construction of a novel Genome Structure Database (GSDB) to create a comprehensive repository that contains 3D structures for Hi-C datasets constructed by a variety of 3D structure reconstruction tools. The GSDB contains over 50,000 structures from 12 state-of-the-art Hi-C data structure prediction algorithms for 32 Hi-C datasets.

GSDB functions as a centralized collection of genome structures which will enable the exploration of the dynamic architectures of chromosomes and genomes for biomedical research. GSDB is accessible at http://sysbio.rnet.missouri.edu/3dgenome/GSDB

Exonuclease combinations reduce noises in 3D genomics technologies

Chromosome conformation-capture technologies are widely used in 3D genomics; however, experimentally, such methods have high-noise limitations and, therefore, require significant bioinformatics efforts to extract reliable distal interactions. Miscellaneous undesired linear DNAs, present during proximity-ligation, represent a main noise source, which needs to be minimized or eliminated. In this study, different exonuclease combinations were tested to remove linear DNA fragments from a circularized DNA preparation. This method efficiently removed linear DNAs, raised the proportion of annulation and increased the valid-pairs ratio from ∼40% to ∼80% for enhanced interaction detection in standard Hi-C. This strategy is applicable for development of various 3D genomics technologies, or optimization of Hi-C sequencing efficiency.

Architectural proteins for the formation and maintenance of the 3D genome

Eukaryotic genomes are densely packaged into hierarchical three-dimensional (3D) structures that contain information about gene regulation and many other biological processes. With the development of imaging and sequencing-based technologies, 3D genome studies have revealed that the high-order chromatin structure is composed of hierarchical levels, including chromosome territories, A/B compartments, topologically associated domains, and chromatin loops. However, how this chromatin architecture is formed and maintained is not completely clear. In this review, we introduce experimental methods to investigate the 3D genome, review major architectural proteins that regulate 3D chromatin organization in mammalian cells, such as CTCF (CCCTC-binding factor), cohesin, lamins, and transcription factors, and discuss relevant mechanisms such as phase separation.

A central role for canonical PRC1 in shaping the 3D nuclear landscape

In this study from Boyle et al., the authors investigated the role of Polycomb-repressive complex 1 (PRC1) in shaping 3D genome organization in mouse embryonic stem cells. Using a combination of imaging and Hi-C analyses they show that PRC1-mediated long-range interactions are independent of CTCF and can bridge sites at a megabase scale, thus providing novel insights into the function of PRC1.

Polycomb group (PcG) proteins silence gene expression by chemically and physically modifying chromatin. A subset of PcG target loci are compacted and cluster in the nucleus; a conformation that is thought to contribute to gene silencing. However, how these interactions influence gross nuclear organization and their relationship with transcription remains poorly understood. Here we examine the role of Polycomb-repressive complex 1 (PRC1) in shaping 3D genome organization in mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs). Using a combination of imaging and Hi-C analyses, we show that PRC1-mediated long-range interactions are independent of CTCF and can bridge sites at a megabase scale. Impairment of PRC1 enzymatic activity does not directly disrupt these interactions. We demonstrate that PcG targets coalesce in vivo, and that developmentally induced expression of one of the target loci disrupts this spatial arrangement. Finally, we show that transcriptional activation and the loss of PRC1-mediated interactions are separable events. These findings provide important insights into the function of PRC1, while highlighting the complexity of this regulatory system.

Pericentromeric heterochromatin is hierarchically organized and spatially contacts H3K9me2 islands in euchromatin

Membraneless pericentromeric heterochromatin (PCH) domains play vital roles in chromosome dynamics and genome stability. However, our current understanding of 3D genome organization does not include PCH domains because of technical challenges associated with repetitive sequences enriched in PCH genomic regions. We investigated the 3D architecture of Drosophila melanogaster PCH domains and their spatial associations with the euchromatic genome by developing a novel analysis method that incorporates genome-wide Hi-C reads originating from PCH DNA. Combined with cytogenetic analysis, we reveal a hierarchical organization of the PCH domains into distinct “territories.” Strikingly, H3K9me2-enriched regions embedded in the euchromatic genome show prevalent 3D interactions with the PCH domain. These spatial contacts require H3K9me2 enrichment, are likely mediated by liquid-liquid phase separation, and may influence organismal fitness. Our findings have important implications for how PCH architecture influences the function and evolution of both repetitive heterochromatin and the gene-rich euchromatin.

The three dimensional (3D) organization of genomes in cell nuclei can influence a wide variety of genome functions. However, most of our understanding of this critical architecture has been limited to the gene-rich euchromatin, and largely ignores the gene-poor and repeat-rich pericentromeric heterochromatin, or PCH. PCH comprises a large part of most eukaryotic genomes, forms 3D membraneless PCH domains in nuclei, and plays a vital role in chromosome dynamics and genome stability. In this study, we developed a new method that overcomes the technical challenges imposed by the highly repetitive PCH DNA, and generated a comprehensive picture of its 3D organization. Combined with image analyses, we reveal a hierarchical organization of the PCH domains. Surprisingly, we showed that distant euchromatic regions enriched for repressive epigenetic marks also dynamically interact with the main PCH domains. These 3D interactions are likely mediated by liquid-liquid phase separation (similar to how oil and vinegar separate in salad dressing) and the resulting liquid-like fusion events, and can influence the fitness of individuals. Our discoveries have strong implications for how seemingly “junk” DNA could impact functions in the gene-rich euchromatin.

Lamina-Dependent Stretching and Unconventional Chromosome Compartments in Early C. elegans Embryos

Current models suggest that chromosome domains segregate into either an active (A) or inactive (B) compartment. B-compartment chromatin is physically separated from the A compartment and compacted by the nuclear lamina. To examine these models in the developmental context of C. elegans embryogenesis, we undertook chromosome tracing to map the trajectories of entire autosomes. Early embryonic chromosomes organized into an unconventional barbell-like configuration, with two densely folded B compartments separated by a central A compartment. Upon gastrulation, this conformation matured into conventional A/B compartments. We used unsupervised clustering to uncover subpopulations with differing folding properties and variable positioning of compartment boundaries. These conformations relied on tethering to the lamina to stretch the chromosome; detachment from the lamina compacted, and allowed intermingling between, A/B compartments. These findings reveal the diverse conformations of early embryonic chromosomes and uncover a previously unappreciated role for the lamina in systemic chromosome stretching.

Biased visibility in Hi-C datasets marks dynamically regulated condensed and decondensed chromatin states genome-wide

Background

Proximity ligation based techniques, like Hi-C, involve restriction digestion followed by ligation of formaldehyde cross-linked chromatin. Distinct chromatin states can impact the restriction digestion, and hence the visibility in the contact maps, of engaged loci. Yet, the extent and the potential impact of digestion bias remain obscure and under-appreciated in the literature.

Results

Through analysis of 45 Hi-C datasets, lamina-associated domains (LADs), inactive X-chromosome in mammals, and polytene bands in fly, we first established that the DNA in condensed chromatin had lesser accessibility to restriction endonucleases used in Hi-C as compared to that in decondensed chromatin. The observed bias was independent of known systematic biases, was not appropriately corrected by existing computational methods, and needed an additional optimization step. We then repurposed this bias to identify novel condensed domains outside LADs, which were bordered by insulators and were dynamically associated with the polycomb mediated epigenetic and transcriptional states during development.

Conclusions

Our observations suggest that the corrected one-dimensional read counts of existing Hi-C datasets can be reliably repurposed to study the gene-regulatory dynamics associated with chromatin condensation and decondensation, and that the existing Hi-C datasets should be interpreted with cautions.

Chromosome Conformation Capture and Beyond: Toward an Integrative View of Chromosome Structure and Function

Rapidly developing technologies have recently fueled an exciting era of discovery in the field of chromosome structure and nuclear organization. In addition to chromosome conformation capture (3C) methods, new alternative techniques have emerged to study genome architecture and biological processes in the nucleus, often in single or living cells. This sets an unprecedented stage for exploring the mechanisms that link chromosome structure and biological function. Here we review popular as well as emerging approaches to study chromosome organization, focusing on the contribution of complementary methodologies to our understanding of structures revealed by 3C methods and their biological implications, and discuss the next technical and conceptual frontiers.

Chromatin interactome mapping at 139 independent breast cancer risk signals

BACKGROUND

Genome-wide association studies have identified 196 high confidence independent signals associated with breast cancer susceptibility. Variants within these signals frequently fall in distal regulatory DNA elements that control gene expression.

RESULTS

We designed a Capture Hi-C array to enrich for chromatin interactions between the credible causal variants and target genes in six human mammary epithelial and breast cancer cell lines. We show that interacting regions are enriched for open chromatin, histone marks for active enhancers, and transcription factors relevant to breast biology. We exploit this comprehensive resource to identify candidate target genes at 139 independent breast cancer risk signals and explore the functional mechanism underlying altered risk at the 12q24 risk region.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrate the power of combining genetics, computational genomics, and molecular studies to rationalize the identification of key variants and candidate target genes at breast cancer GWAS signals.

Ligand dependent gene regulation by transient ERα clustered enhancers

Unliganded Estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) has been implicated in ligand-dependent gene regulation. Upon ligand exposure, ERα binds to several EREs relatively proximal to the pre-marked, unliganded ERα-bound sites and affects transient but robust gene expression. However, the underlying mechanisms are not fully understood. Here we demonstrate that upon ligand stimulation, persistent sites interact extensively, via chromatin looping, with the proximal transiently ERα-bound sites, forming Ligand Dependent ERα Enhancer Cluster in 3D (LDEC). The E2-target genes are regulated by these clustered enhancers but not by the H3K27Ac super-enhancers. Further, CRISPR-based deletion of TFF1 persistent site disrupts the formation of its LDEC resulting in the loss of E2-dependent expression of TFF1 and its neighboring genes within the same TAD. The LDEC overlap with nuclear ERα condensates that coalesce in a ligand and persistent site dependent manner. Furthermore, formation of clustered enhancers, as well as condensates, coincide with the active phase of signaling and their later disappearance results in the loss of gene expression even though persistent sites remain bound by ERα. Our results establish, at TFF1 and NRIP1 locus, a direct link between ERα condensates, ERα enhancer clusters, and transient, but robust, gene expression in a ligand-dependent fashion.

DNA Methylation Directs Polycomb-Dependent 3D Genome Re-organization in Naive Pluripotency

The DNA hypomethylation that occurs when embryonic stem cells (ESCs) are directed to the ground state of naive pluripotency by culturing in two small molecule inhibitors (2i) results in redistribution of polycomb (H3K27me3) away from its target loci. Here, we demonstrate that 3D genome organization is also altered in 2i, with chromatin decompaction at polycomb target loci and a loss of long-range polycomb interactions. By preventing DNA hypomethylation during the transition to the ground state, we are able to restore to ESC in 2i the H3K27me3 distribution, as well as polycomb-mediated 3D genome organization that is characteristic of primed ESCs grown in serum. However, these cells retain the functional characteristics of 2i ground-state ESCs. Our findings demonstrate the central role of DNA methylation in shaping major aspects of 3D genome organization but caution against assuming causal roles for the epigenome and 3D genome in gene regulation and function in ESCs.

Developmentally regulated Shh expression is robust to TAD perturbations

Topologically associating domains (TADs) have been proposed to both guide and constrain enhancer activity. Shh is located within a TAD known to contain all its enhancers. To investigate the importance of chromatin conformation and TAD integrity on developmental gene regulation, we have manipulated the Shh TAD - creating internal deletions, deleting CTCF sites, and deleting and inverting sequences at TAD boundaries. Chromosome conformation capture and fluorescence in situ hybridisation assays were used to investigate the changes in chromatin conformation that result from these manipulations. Our data suggest that these substantial alterations in TAD structure have no readily detectable effect on Shh expression patterns or levels of Shh expression during development - except where enhancers are deleted - and result in no detectable phenotypes. Only in the case of a larger deletion at one TAD boundary could ectopic influence of the Shh limb enhancer be detected on a gene (Mnx1) in the neighbouring TAD. Our data suggests that, contrary to expectations, the developmental regulation of Shh expression is remarkably robust to TAD perturbations.

Decreased Enhancer-Promoter Proximity Accompanying Enhancer Activation

Enhancers can regulate the promoters of their target genes over very large genomic distances. It is widely assumed that mechanisms of enhancer action involve the reorganization of three-dimensional chromatin architecture, but this is poorly understood. The predominant model involves physical enhancer-promoter interaction by looping out the intervening chromatin. However, studying the enhancer-driven activation of the Sonic hedgehog gene (Shh), we have identified a change in chromosome conformation that is incompatible with this simple looping model. Using super-resolution 3D-FISH and chromosome conformation capture, we observe a decreased spatial proximity between Shh and its enhancers during the differentiation of embryonic stem cells to neural progenitors. We show that this can be recapitulated by synthetic enhancer activation, is impeded by chromatin-bound proteins located between the enhancer and the promoter, and appears to involve the catalytic activity of poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase. Our data suggest that models of enhancer-promoter communication need to encompass chromatin conformations other than looping.

•

Super-resolution microscopy reveals increased enhancer-promoter separation upon activation

•

Synthetic enhancer activation supports decreased enhancer-promoter proximity

•

Enhancer-promoter separation can be driven by poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase 1

Conformational heterogeneity in human interphase chromosome organization reconciles the FISH and Hi-C paradox

Hi-C experiments are used to infer the contact probabilities between loci separated by varying genome lengths. Contact probability should decrease as the spatial distance between two loci increases. However, studies comparing Hi-C and FISH data show that in some cases the distance between one pair of loci, with larger Hi-C readout, is paradoxically larger compared to another pair with a smaller value of the contact probability. Here, we show that the FISH-Hi-C paradox can be resolved using a theory based on a Generalized Rouse Model for Chromosomes (GRMC). The FISH-Hi-C paradox arises because the cell population is highly heterogeneous, which means that a given contact is present in only a fraction of cells. Insights from the GRMC is used to construct a theory, without any adjustable parameters, to extract the distribution of subpopulations from the FISH data, which quantitatively reproduces the Hi-C data. Our results show that heterogeneity is pervasive in genome organization at all length scales, reflecting large cell-to-cell variations.

Studies comparing Hi-C and FISH data show that in some cases the distance between one pair of loci is paradoxically larger compared to another pair with a smaller value of the contact probability. Here the authors use a theory based on a Generalized Rouse Model for Chromosomes to resolve this paradox.