A novel fuzzy pain demand index derived from patient-controlled analgesia for postoperative pain

Moving towards the use of artificial intelligence in pain management

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

While the development of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies in medicine has been significant, their application to acute and chronic pain management has not been well characterized. This systematic review aims to provide an overview of the current state of AI in acute and chronic pain management.

DATABASES AND DATA TREATMENT

This review was registered with PROSPERO (ID# CRD42022307017), the international registry for systematic reviews. The search strategy was prepared by a librarian and run in four electronic databases (Embase, Medline, Central, and Web of Science). Collected articles were screened by two reviewers. Included studies described the use of AI for acute and chronic pain management.

RESULTS

From the 17,601 records identified in the initial search, 197 were included in this review. Identified applications of AI were described for treatment planning as well as treatment delivery. Described uses include prediction of pain, forecasting of individualized responses to treatment, treatment regimen tailoring, image-guidance for procedural interventions and self-management tools. Multiple domains of AI were used including machine learning, computer vision, fuzzy logic, natural language processing and expert systems.

CONCLUSION

There is growing literature regarding applications of AI for pain management, and their clinical use holds potential for improving patient outcomes. However, multiple barriers to their clinical integration remain including lack validation of such applications in diverse patient populations, missing infrastructure to support these tools and limited provider understanding of AI.

SIGNIFICANCE

This review characterizes current applications of AI for pain management and discusses barriers to their clinical integration. Our findings support continuing efforts directed towards establishing comprehensive systems that integrate AI throughout the patient care continuum.

Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices Among Anesthesia and Thoracic Surgery Medical Staff Toward Ai-PCA

Purpose

Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly influencing various medical fields, including anesthesiology. The Introduction of artificial intelligent patient-controlled analgesia (Ai-PCA) has been seen as a significant advancement in pain management. However, the adoption and practical application of Ai-PCA by medical staff, particularly in anesthesia and thoracic surgery, have not been extensively studied. This study aimed to investigate the knowledge, attitudes and practices (KAP) among anesthesia and thoracic surgery medical staff toward artificial intelligent patient-controlled analgesia (Ai-PCA).

Participants and Methods

This web-based cross-sectional study was conducted between November 1, 2023 and November 15, 2023 at Jiangsu Cancer Hospital. A self-designed questionnaire was developed to collect demographic information of anesthesia and thoracic surgery medical staff, and to assess their knowledge, attitudes and practices toward Ai-PCA.

Results

A total of 519 valid questionnaires were collected. Among the participants, 278 (53.56%) were female, 497 (95.76%) were employed in the field of anesthesiology, and 188 (36.22%) had participated in Ai-PCA training. The mean knowledge, attitude, and practice scores were 7.8±1.75 (possible range: 0-10), 37.43±4.16 (possible range: 9-45), and 28.38±9.27 (possible range: 9-45), respectively.

Conclusion

The findings revealed that anesthesia and thoracic surgery medical staff have sufficient knowledge, active attitudes, but poor practices toward the Ai-PCA. Comprehensive training programs are needed to improve anesthesia and thoracic surgery medical staff's practices in this area.

An Innovative EEG-Based Pain Identification and Quantification: A Pilot Study

OBJECTIVE

The present pilot study aimed to propose an innovative scale-independent measure based on electroencephalographic (EEG) signals for the identification and quantification of the magnitude of chronic pain.

METHODS

EEG data were collected from three groups of participants at rest: seven healthy participants with pain, 15 healthy participants submitted to thermal pain, and 66 participants living with chronic pain. Every 30 s, the pain intensity score felt by the participant was also recorded. Electrodes positioned in the contralateral motor region were of interest. After EEG preprocessing, a complex analytical signal was obtained using Hilbert transform, and the upper envelope of the EEG signal was extracted. The average coefficient of variation of the upper envelope of the signal was then calculated for the beta (13-30 Hz) band and proposed as a new EEG-based indicator, namely Piqβ, to identify and quantify pain.

MAIN RESULTS

The main results are as follows: (1) A Piqβ threshold at 10%, that is, Piqβ ≥ 10%, indicates the presence of pain, and (2) the higher the Piqβ (%), the higher the extent of pain.

CONCLUSIONS

This finding indicates that Piqβ can objectively identify and quantify pain in a population living with chronic pain. This new EEG-based indicator can be used for objective pain assessment based on the neurophysiological body response to pain.

SIGNIFICANCE

Objective pain assessment is a valuable decision-making aid and an important contribution to pain management and monitoring.

Towards the Objective Identification of the Presence of Pain Based on Electroencephalography Signals' Analysis: A Proof-of-Concept

This proof-of-concept study explores the potential of developing objective pain identification based on the analysis of electroencephalography (EEG) signals. Data were collected from participants living with chronic fibromyalgia pain (n = 4) and from healthy volunteers (n = 7) submitted to experimental pain by the application of capsaicin cream (1%) on the right upper trapezius. This data collection was conducted in two parts: (1) baseline measures including pain intensity and EEG signals, with the participant at rest; (2) active measures collected under the execution of a visuo-motor task, including EEG signals and the task performance index. The main measure for the objective identification of the presence of pain was the coefficient of variation of the upper envelope (CVUE) of the EEG signal from left fronto-central (FC5) and left temporal (T7) electrodes, in alpha (8-12 Hz), beta (12-30 Hz) and gamma (30-43 Hz) frequency bands. The task performance index was also calculated. CVUE (%) was compared between groups: those with chronic fibromyalgia pain, healthy volunteers with "No pain" and healthy volunteers with experimentally-induced pain. The identification of the presence of pain was determined by an increased CVUE in beta (CVUE_β) from the EEG signals captured at the left FC5 electrode. More specifically, CVUE_β increased up to 20% in the pain condition at rest. In addition, no correlation was found between CVUE_β and pain intensity or the task performance index. These results support the objective identification of the presence of pain based on the quantification of the coefficient of variation of the upper envelope of the EEG signal.

A Personalized Spatial-Temporal Cold Pain Intensity Estimation Model Based on Facial Expression

OBJECTIVE

Pain assessment is of great importance in both clinical research and patient care. Facial expression analysis is becoming a key part of pain detection because it is convenient, automatic, and real-time. The aim of this study is to present a cold pain intensity estimation experiment, investigate the importance of the spatial-temporal information on facial expression based cold pain, and study the performance of the personalized model as well as the generalized model.

METHODS

A cold pain experiment was carried out and facial expressions from 29 subjects were extracted. Three different architectures (Inception V3, VGG-LSTM, and Convolutional LSTM) were used to estimate three intensities of cold pain: No pain, Moderate pain, and Severe Pain. Architectures with Sequential information were compared with single-frame architecture, showing the importance of spatial-temporal information on pain estimation. The performances of the personalized model and the generalized model were also compared.

RESULTS

A mean F1 score of 79.48% was achieved using Convolutional LSTM based on the personalized model.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates the potential for the estimation of cold pain intensity from facial expression analysis and shows that the personalized spatial-temporal framework has better performance in cold pain intensity estimation.

SIGNIFICANCE

This cold pain intensity estimator could allow convenient, automatic, and real-time use to provide continuous objective pain intensity estimations of subjects and patients.

Continuous wavelet transform and higher-order spectrum: combinatory potentialities in breath sound analysis and electroencephalogram-based pain characterization

The combination of the continuous wavelet transform (CWT) with a higher-order spectrum (HOS) merges two worlds into one that conveys information regarding the non-stationarity, non-Gaussianity and nonlinearity of the systems and/or signals under examination. In the current work, the third-order spectrum (TOS), which is used to detect the nonlinearity and deviation from Gaussianity of two types of biomedical signals, that is, wheezes and electroencephalogram (EEG), is combined with the CWT to offer a time-scale representation of the examined signals. As a result, a CWT/TOS field is formed and a time axis is introduced, creating a time-bifrequency domain, which provides a new means for wheeze nonlinear analysis and dynamic EEG-based pain characterization. A detailed description and examples are provided and discussed to showcase the combinatory potential of CWT/TOS in the field of advanced signal processing.This article is part of the theme issue 'Redundancy rules: the continuous wavelet transform comes of age'.

Models for Nociception Stimulation and Memory Effects in Awake and Aware Healthy Individuals

OBJECTIVE

This paper introduces a primer in the health care practice, namely a mathematical model and methodology for detecting and analysing nociceptor stimulation followed by related tissue memory effects.

METHODS

Noninvasive nociceptor stimulus protocol and prototype device for measuring bioimpedance is provided. Various time instants, sensor location, and stimulus train have been analysed.

RESULTS

The method and model indicate that nociceptor stimulation perceived as pain in awake healthy volunteers is noninvasively detected. The existence of a memory effect is proven from data. Sensor location had minimal effect on detection level, while day-to-day variability was observed without being significant.

CONCLUSION

Following the experimental study, the model enables a comprehensive management of chronic pain patients, and possibly other analgesia, or pain related regulatory loops.

SIGNIFICANCE

A device and methodology for noninvasive for detecting nociception stimulation have been developed. The proposed method and models have been validated on healthy volunteers.

EEG-Based Tonic Cold Pain Characterization Using Wavelet Higher Order Spectral Features

A novel approach in tonic cold pain characterization, based on electroencephalograph (EEG) data analysis using wavelet higher order spectral (WHOS) features, is presented here. The proposed WHOS-based feature space extends the relative power spectrum-based (phase blind) approaches reported so far a step forward; this is realized via dynamic monitoring of the nonlinerities of the EEG brain response to tonic cold pain stimuli by capturing the change in the underlying quadratic phase coupling at the bifrequency wavelet bispectrum/bicoherence domain due to the change of the pain level. Three pain characterization scenarios were formed and experimentally tested involving WHOS-based analysis of EEG data, acquired from 17 healthy volunteers that were subjected to trials of tonic cold pain stimuli. The experimental and classification analysis results, based on four well-known classifiers, have shown that the WHOS-based features successfully discriminate relax from pain status, provide efficient identification of the transition from relax to mild and/or severe pain status, and translate the subjective perception of pain to an objective measure of pain endurance. These findings seem quite promising and pave the way for adopting WHOS-based approaches to pain characterization under other types of pain, e.g., chronic pain and various clinical scenarios.

Prediction of low back pain with two expert systems

Low back pain (LBP) is one of the common problems encountered in medical applications. This paper proposes two expert systems (artificial neural network and adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system) for the assessment of the LBP level objectively. The skin resistance and visual analog scale (VAS) values have been accepted as the input variables for the developed systems. The results showed that the expert systems behave very similar to real data and that use of the expert systems can be used to successfully diagnose the back pain intensity. The suggested systems were found to be advantageous approaches in addition to existing unbiased approaches. So far as the authors are aware, this is the first attempt of using the two expert systems achieving very good performance in a real application. In light of some of the limitations of this study, we also identify and discuss several areas that need continued investigation.