Role of geochemical protoenzymes (geozymes) in primordial metabolism: specific abiotic hydride transfer by metals to the biological redox cofactor NAD. FEBS J 2022;289:3148-3162. [PMID: 34923745 PMCID: PMC9306933 DOI: 10.1111/febs.16329]

Evidence for corrin biosynthesis in the last universal common ancestor

Corrinoids are cobalt-containing tetrapyrroles. They include adenosylcobalamin (vitamin B12) and cobamides that function as cofactors and coenzymes for methyl transfer, radical-dependent and redox reactions. Though cobamides are the most complex cofactors in nature, they are essential in the acetyl-CoA pathway, thought to be the most ancient CO2-fixation pathway, where they perform a pterin-to-cobalt-to-nickel methyl transfer reaction catalyzed by the corrinoid iron-sulphur protein (CoFeS). CoFeS occurs in H2-dependent archaeal methanogens, the oldest microbial lineage by measure of physiology and carbon isotope data, dating corrinoids to ca. 3.5 billion years. However, CoFeS and cobamides are also essential in the acetyl-CoA pathway of H2-dependent bacterial acetogens. To determine whether corrin biosynthesis was established before archaea and bacteria diverged, whether the pathways arose independently or whether cobamide biosynthesis was transferred from the archaeal to the bacterial lineage (or vice versa) during evolution, we investigated phylogenies and structural data for 26 enzymes of corrin ring and lower ligand biosynthesis. The data trace cobamide synthesis to the common ancestor of bacteria and archaea, placing it in the last universal common ancestor of all lifeforms (LUCA), while pterin-dependent methyl synthesis pathways likely arose independently post-LUCA in the lineages leading to bacteria and archaea. Enzymes of corrin biosynthesis were recruited from preexisting ancient pathways. Evolutionary forerunners of CoFeS function were likely Fe-, Ni- and Co-containing solid-state surfaces, which, in the laboratory, catalyze the reactions of the acetyl-CoA pathway from CO2 to pyruvate under serpentinizing hydrothermal conditions. The data suggest that enzymatic corrin biosynthesis replaced insoluble solid-state catalysts that tethered primordial CO2 assimilation to the Earth's crust, suggesting a role for corrin synthesis in the origin of free-living cells.

Nonenzymatic Hydration of Phosphoenolpyruvate: General Conditions for Hydration in Protometabolism by Searching Across Pathways

Numerous reactions within metabolic pathways have been reported to occur nonenzymatically, supporting the hypothesis that life arose upon a primitive nonenzymatic precursor to metabolism. However, most of those studies reproduce individual transformations or segments of pathways without providing a common set of conditions for classes of reactions that span multiple pathways. In this study, we search across pathways for common nonenzymatic conditions for a recurring chemical transformation in metabolism: alkene hydration. The mild conditions that we identify (Fe oxides such as green rust) apply to all hydration reactions of the rTCA cycle and gluconeogenesis, including the hydration of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) to 2-phosphoglycerate (2PGA), which had not previously been reported under nonenzymatic conditions. Mechanistic insights were obtained by studying analogous substrates and through anoxic and radical trapping experiments. Searching for nonenzymatic conditions across pathways provides a complementary strategy to triangulate conditions conducive to the nonenzymatic emergence of a protometabolism.

GTP before ATP: The energy currency at the origin of genes

Life is an exergonic chemical reaction. Many individual reactions in metabolism entail slightly endergonic steps that are coupled to free energy release, typically as ATP hydrolysis, in order to go forward. ATP is almost always supplied by the rotor-stator ATP synthase, which harnesses chemiosmotic ion gradients. Because the ATP synthase is a protein, it arose after the ribosome did. What was the energy currency of metabolism before the origin of the ATP synthase and how (and why) did ATP come to be the universal energy currency? About 27 % of a cell's energy budget is consumed as GTP during translation. The universality of GTP-dependence in ribosome function indicates that GTP was the ancestral energy currency of protein synthesis. The use of GTP in translation and ATP in small molecule synthesis are conserved across all lineages, representing energetic compartments that arose in the last universal common ancestor, LUCA. And what came before GTP? Recent findings indicate that the energy supporting the origin of LUCA's metabolism stemmed from H2-dependent CO2 reduction along routes that strongly resemble the reactions and transition metal catalysts of the acetyl-CoA pathway.

Conversion of pyridoxal to pyridoxamine with NH3 and H2 on nickel generates a protometabolic nitrogen shuttle under serpentinizing conditions

Serpentinizing hydrothermal vents are likely sites for the origin of metabolism because they produce H2 as a source of electrons for CO2 reduction while depositing zero-valent iron, cobalt, and nickel as catalysts for organic reactions. Recent work has shown that solid-state nickel can catalyze the H2-dependent reduction of CO2 to various organic acids and their reductive amination with H2 and NH3 to biological amino acids under the conditions of H2-producing hydrothermal vents and that amino acid synthesis from NH3, H2, and 2-oxoacids is facile in the presence of Ni0. Such reactions suggest a metallic origin of metabolism during early biochemical evolution because single metals replace the function of over 130 enzymatic reactions at the core of metabolism in microbes that use the acetyl-CoA pathway of CO2 fixation. Yet solid-state catalysts tether primordial amino synthesis to a mineral surface. Many studies have shown that pyridoxal catalyzes transamination reactions without enzymes. Here we show that pyridoxamine, the NH2-transferring intermediate in pyridoxal-dependent transamination reactions, is generated from pyridoxal by reaction with NH3 (as little as 5 mm) and H2 (5 bar) on Ni0 as catalyst at pH 11 and 80 °C within hours. These conditions correspond to those in hydrothermal vents undergoing active serpentinization. The results indicate that at the origin of metabolism, pyridoxamine provided a soluble, organic amino donor for aqueous amino acid synthesis, mediating an evolutionary transition from NH3-dependent amino acid synthesis on inorganic surfaces to pyridoxamine-dependent organic reactions in the aqueous phase.

Pinpointing Conditions for a Metabolic Origin of Life: Underlying Mechanisms and the Role of Coenzymes

Famously found written on the blackboard of physicist Richard Feynman after his death was the phrase, "What I cannot create, I do not understand." From this perspective, recreating the origin of life in the lab is a necessary condition for achieving a deep theoretical understanding of biology. The "metabolism-first" hypothesis is one of the leading frameworks for the origin of life. A complex self-organized reaction network is thought to have been driven into existence as a chemical path of least resistance to release free energy in the environment that could otherwise not be dissipated, rerouting energy from planetary processes to organic chemistry. To increase in complexity, the reaction network, initially under catalysis provided by its geochemical environment, must have produced organic catalysts that pruned the existing flux through the network or expanded it in new directions. This boot-strapping process would gradually lessen the dependence on the initial catalytic environment and allow the reaction network to persist using catalysts of its own making. Eventually, this process leads to the seemingly inseparable interdependence at the heart of biology between catalysts (coenzymes, enzymes, genes) and the metabolic pathways that synthesize them. Experimentally, the primary challenge is to recreate the conditions where such a network emerged. However, the near infinite number of microenvironments and sources of energy available on the early Earth or elsewhere poses an enormous combinatorial challenge. To constrain the search, our lab has been surveying conditions where the reactions making up the core of some of the most ancient chemolithoautotrophic metabolisms, which consist of only a small number of repeating chemical mechanisms, occur nonenzymatically. To give a fresh viewpoint in the first part of this account, we have organized the results of our search (along with important results from other laboratories) by reaction mechanism, rather than by pathway. We expect that identifying a common set of conditions for each type of reaction mechanism will help pinpoint the conditions for the emergence of a self-organized reaction network resembling core metabolism. Many of the reaction mechanisms were found to occur in a wide variety of nonenzymatic conditions. Others, such as carboxylate phosphorylation and C-C bond formation from CO2, were found to be the most constraining, and thus help narrow the scope of environments where a reaction network could emerge. In the second part of this account, we highlight examples where small molecules produced by metabolism, known as coenzymes, mediate nonenzymatic chemistry of the type needed for the coenzyme's own synthesis or that turn on new reactivity of interest for expanding a hypothetical protometabolic network. These examples often feature cooperativity between small organic coenzymes and metal ions, recapitulating the transition from inorganic to organic catalysis during the origin of life. Overall, the most interesting conditions are those containing a reducing potential equivalent to H2 gas (electrochemical or H2 itself), Fe in both reduced and more oxidized forms (possibly with other metals like Ni) and localized strong electric fields. Environments that satisfy these criteria simultaneously will be of prime interest for reconstructing a metabolic origin of life.

The evolutionary arch of bioenergetics from prebiotic mechanisms to the emergence of a cellular respiratory chain

This article proposes an evolutionary trajectory for the development of biological energy producing systems. Six main stages of energy producing system evolution are described, from early evolutionary pyrite-pulled mechanism through the Last Universal Common Ancestor (LUCA) to contemporary systems. We define the Last Pure Chemical Entity (LPCE) as the last completely non-enzymatic entity. LPCE could have had some life-like properties, but lacked genetic information carriers, thus showed greater instability and environmental dependence than LUCA. A double bubble model is proposed for compartmentalization and cellularization as a prerequisite to both highly efficient protein synthesis and transmembrane ion-gradient. The article finds that although LUCA predominantly functioned anaerobically, it was a non-exclusive anaerobe, and sulfur dominated metabolism preceded phosphate dominated one.

Chemical Antiquity in Metabolism

Life is an exergonic chemical reaction. The same was true when the very first cells emerged at life's origin. In order to live, all cells need a source of carbon, energy, and electrons to drive their overall reaction network (metabolism). In most cells, these are separate pathways. There is only one biochemical pathway that serves all three needs simultaneously: the acetyl-CoA pathway of CO2 fixation. In the acetyl-CoA pathway, electrons from H2 reduce CO2 to pyruvate for carbon supply, while methane or acetate synthesis are coupled to energy conservation as ATP. This simplicity and thermodynamic favorability prompted Georg Fuchs and Erhard Stupperich to propose in 1985 that the acetyl-CoA pathway might mark the origin of metabolism, at the same time that Steve Ragsdale and Harland Wood were uncovering catalytic roles for Fe, Co, and Ni in the enzymes of the pathway. Subsequent work has provided strong support for those proposals.In the presence of Fe, Co, and Ni in their native metallic state as catalysts, aqueous H2 and CO2 react specifically to formate, acetate, methane, and pyruvate overnight at 100 °C. These metals (and their alloys) thus replace the function of over 120 enzymes required for the conversion of H2 and CO2 to pyruvate via the pathway and its cofactors, an unprecedented set of findings in the study of biochemical evolution. The reactions require alkaline conditions, which promote hydrogen oxidation by proton removal and are naturally generated in serpentinizing (H2-producing) hydrothermal vents. Serpentinizing hydrothermal vents furthermore produce natural deposits of native Fe, Co, Ni, and their alloys. These are precisely the metals that reduce CO2 with H2 in the laboratory; they are also the metals found at the active sites of enzymes in the acetyl-CoA pathway. Iron, cobalt and nickel are relicts of the environments in which metabolism arose, environments that still harbor ancient methane- and acetate-producing autotrophs today. This convergence indicates bedrock-level antiquity for the acetyl-CoA pathway. In acetogens and methanogens growing on H2 as reductant, the acetyl-CoA pathway requires flavin-based electron bifurcation as a source of reduced ferredoxin (a 4Fe4S cluster-containing protein) in order to function. Recent findings show that H2 can reduce the 4Fe4S clusters of ferredoxin in the presence of native iron, uncovering an evolutionary precursor of flavin-based electron bifurcation and suggesting an origin of FeS-dependent electron transfer in proteins. Traditionally discussed as catalysts in early evolution, the most common function of FeS clusters in metabolism is one-electron transfer, also in radical SAM enzymes, a large and ancient enzyme family. The cofactors and active sites in enzymes of the acetyl-CoA pathway uncover chemical antiquity in metabolism involving metals, methyl groups, methyl transfer reactions, cobamides, pterins, GTP, S-adenosylmethionine, radical SAM enzymes, and carbon-metal bonds. The reaction sequence from H2 and CO2 to pyruvate on naturally deposited native metals is maximally simple. It requires neither nitrogen, sulfur, phosphorus, RNA, ion gradients, nor light. Solid-state metal catalysts tether the origin of metabolism to a H2-producing, serpentinizing hydrothermal vent.

A Magnesium Binding Site And The Anomeric Effect Regulate The Abiotic Redox Chemistry Of Nicotinamide Nucleotides

Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) is a redox active molecule that is universally found in biology. Despite the importance and simplicity of this molecule, few reports exist that investigate which molecular features are important for the activity of this ribodinucleotide. By exploiting the nonenzymatic reduction and oxidation of NAD+ by pyruvate and methylene blue, respectively, we were able to identify key molecular features necessary for the intrinsic activity of NAD+ through kinetic analysis. Such features may explain how NAD+ could have been selected early during the emergence of life. Simpler molecules, such as nicotinamide, that lack an anomeric carbon are incapable of accepting electrons from pyruvate. The phosphate moiety inhibits activity in the absence of metal ions but facilitates activity at physiological pH and model prebiotic conditions by recruiting catalytic Mg2+. Reduction proceeds through consecutive single electron transfer events. Of the derivatives tested, including nicotinamide mononucleotide, nicotinamide riboside, 3-(aminocarbonyl)-1-(2,3-dihydroxypropyl)pyridinium, 1-methylnicotinamide, and nicotinamide, only NAD+ and nicotinamide mononucleotide would be capable of efficiently accepting and donating electrons within a nonenzymatic electron transport chain. The data are consistent with early metabolic chemistry exploiting NAD+ or nicotinamide mononucleotide and not simpler molecules.

Ferredoxin reduction by hydrogen with iron functions as an evolutionary precursor of flavin-based electron bifurcation

Autotrophic theories for the origin of metabolism posit that the first cells satisfied their carbon needs from CO2 and were chemolithoautotrophs that obtained their energy and electrons from H2. The acetyl-CoA pathway of CO2 fixation is central to that view because of its antiquity: Among known CO2 fixing pathways it is the only one that is i) exergonic, ii) occurs in both bacteria and archaea, and iii) can be functionally replaced in full by single transition metal catalysts in vitro. In order to operate in cells at a pH close to 7, however, the acetyl-CoA pathway requires complex multi-enzyme systems capable of flavin-based electron bifurcation that reduce low potential ferredoxin-the physiological donor of electrons in the acetyl-CoA pathway-with electrons from H2. How can the acetyl-CoA pathway be primordial if it requires flavin-based electron bifurcation? Here, we show that native iron (Fe0), but not Ni0, Co0, Mo0, NiFe, Ni2Fe, Ni3Fe, or Fe3O4, promotes the H2-dependent reduction of aqueous Clostridium pasteurianum ferredoxin at pH 8.5 or higher within a few hours at 40 °C, providing the physiological function of flavin-based electron bifurcation, but without the help of enzymes or organic redox cofactors. H2-dependent ferredoxin reduction by iron ties primordial ferredoxin reduction and early metabolic evolution to a chemical process in the Earth's crust promoted by solid-state iron, a metal that is still deposited in serpentinizing hydrothermal vents today.

The Moon-Forming Impact and the Autotrophic Origin of Life

The Moon-forming impact vaporized part of Earth's mantle, and turned the rest into a magma ocean, from which carbon dioxide degassed into the atmosphere, where it stayed until water rained out to form the oceans. The rain dissolved CO2 and made it available to react with transition metal catalysts in the Earth's crust so as to ultimately generate the organic compounds that form the backbone of microbial metabolism. The Moon-forming impact was key in building a planet with the capacity to generate life in that it converted carbon on Earth into a homogeneous and accessible substrate for organic synthesis. Today all ecosystems, without exception, depend upon primary producers, organisms that fix CO2 . According to theories of autotrophic origin, it has always been that way, because autotrophic theories posit that the first forms of life generated all the molecules needed to build a cell from CO2 , forging a direct line of continuity between Earth's initial CO2 -rich atmosphere and the first microorganisms. By modern accounts these were chemolithoautotrophic archaea and bacteria that initially colonized the crust and still inhabit that environment today.

Serpentinization as the source of energy, electrons, organics, catalysts, nutrients and pH gradients for the origin of LUCA and life

Serpentinization in hydrothermal vents is central to some autotrophic theories for the origin of life because it generates compartments, reductants, catalysts and gradients. During the process of serpentinization, water circulates through hydrothermal systems in the crust where it oxidizes Fe (II) in ultramafic minerals to generate Fe (III) minerals and H2. Molecular hydrogen can, in turn, serve as a freely diffusible source of electrons for the reduction of CO2 to organic compounds, provided that suitable catalysts are present. Using catalysts that are naturally synthesized in hydrothermal vents during serpentinization H2 reduces CO2 to formate, acetate, pyruvate, and methane. These compounds represent the backbone of microbial carbon and energy metabolism in acetogens and methanogens, strictly anaerobic chemolithoautotrophs that use the acetyl-CoA pathway of CO2 fixation and that inhabit serpentinizing environments today. Serpentinization generates reduced carbon, nitrogen and - as newer findings suggest - reduced phosphorous compounds that were likely conducive to the origins process. In addition, it gives rise to inorganic microcompartments and proton gradients of the right polarity and of sufficient magnitude to support chemiosmotic ATP synthesis by the rotor-stator ATP synthase. This would help to explain why the principle of chemiosmotic energy harnessing is more conserved (older) than the machinery to generate ion gradients via pumping coupled to exergonic chemical reactions, which in the case of acetogens and methanogens involve H2-dependent CO2 reduction. Serpentinizing systems exist in terrestrial and deep ocean environments. On the early Earth they were probably more abundant than today. There is evidence that serpentinization once occurred on Mars and is likely still occurring on Saturn's icy moon Enceladus, providing a perspective on serpentinization as a source of reductants, catalysts and chemical disequilibrium for life on other worlds.

Electron transport chains as a window into the earliest stages of evolution

The origin and early evolution of life is generally studied under two different paradigms: bottom up and top down. Prebiotic chemistry and early Earth geochemistry allow researchers to explore possible origin of life scenarios. But for these "bottom-up" approaches, even successful experiments only amount to a proof of principle. On the other hand, "top-down" research on early evolutionary history is able to provide a historical account about ancient organisms, but is unable to investigate stages that occurred during and just after the origin of life. Here, we consider ancient electron transport chains (ETCs) as a potential bridge between early evolutionary history and a protocellular stage that preceded it. Current phylogenetic evidence suggests that ancestors of several extant ETC components were present at least as late as the last universal common ancestor of life. In addition, recent experiments have shown that some aspects of modern ETCs can be replicated by minerals, protocells, or organic cofactors in the absence of biological proteins. Here, we discuss the diversity of ETCs and other forms of chemiosmotic energy conservation, describe current work on the early evolution of membrane bioenergetics, and advocate for several lines of research to enhance this understanding by pairing top-down and bottom-up approaches.

Metals in Prebiotic Catalysis: A Possible Evolutionary Pathway for the Emergence of Metalloproteins

Proteinaceous catalysts found in extant biology are products of life that were potentially derived through prolonged periods of evolution. Given their complexity, it is reasonable to assume that they were not accessible to prebiotic chemistry as such. Nevertheless, the dependence of many enzymes on metal ions or metal-ligand cores suggests that catalysis relevant to biology could also be possible with just the metal centers. Given their availability on the Hadean/Archean Earth, it is fair to conjecture that metal ions could have constituted the first forms of catalysts. A slow increase of complexity that was facilitated through the provision of organic ligands and amino acids/peptides possibly allowed for further evolution and diversification, eventually demarcating them into specific functions. Herein, we summarize some key experimental developments and observations that support the possible roles of metal catalysts in shaping the origins of life. Further, we also discuss how they could have evolved into modern-day enzymes, with some suggestions for what could be the imminent next steps that researchers can pursue, to delineate the putative sequence of catalyst evolution during the early stages of life.