T lymphocyte sensitization and suppressor T lymphocyte defect in patients long after treatment for Graves' disease

An update on the pharmacological management of hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease

Pharmacological treatment, usually by thionamides (carbimazole, methimazole, propylthiouracil) is, in addition to radioiodine therapy and thyroidectomy, one of the available therapies for Graves' hyperthyroidism. Thionamides represent the treatment of choice in pregnant women, during lactation, in children and adolescents and in preparation for radioiodine therapy or thyroidectomy. Side effects are relatively frequent but are in general mild and transient. Two main regimens are available: titration method (use of the lowest dose maintaining euthyroidism; duration: 12-18 months) and block-and-replace method. Neither one has clear advantages in terms of outcome but the latter method is associated with more frequent side effects. Hyperthyroidism relapses in approximately 50% of patients, to whom ablative therapy should be offered.

The Pathogenesis of Graves’ Disease

We have hypothesized over many years that Graves' disease (GD) and the other autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) are each due to antigen-specific defects in suppressor (regulatory) T lymphocyte function. There have been several reports dealing with the role of regulatory T lymphocyte subsets, ie., that will prevent autoimmune disease in these and other organ-specific autoimmune diseases. In AITD, suppressor T cells have been shown to be less well activated by relevant antigen, but are normally activated by irrelevant antigen; suppressor T cells from normal persons react equally well to both. In GD, these cells have been shown to be inadequately activated by TSH receptor antigen, but are normally activated by irrelevant autoantigen. This reduction is partial only, and insufficient itself to precipitate the autoimmune disease; further insults from the environment are necessary to further reduce generalized regulatory cell activity, adding to the genetically induced specific regulatory cell dysfunction, which appears in turn to be due to a specific defect in the presentation of a specific antigen. This, in turn, may relate to abnormalities of the genes responsible for antigen presentation. The end result is activation of appropriate helper and effector T cells, the stimulation by these of appropriate B lymphocytes, and the concurrent production of cytokines. These events lead to functional changes within the target cell which itself will express Class II antigens, heat shock proteins, and intercellular adhesion molecules, all of which amplify the immune response. Moreover, the activation of helper T lymphocytes by specific antigen depends on the availability of normal amounts of antigen being presented to them by antigen-presenting cells. Thus, there is no need to invoke any primary abnormality or infection of the thyroid cell, or any cross-reacting antigen of microorganismic origin to initiate this process. What is required is an abnormality of antigen-presentation such that regulatory cells are not properly activated, plus some additive environmental disturbance acting on the immune system. GD specifically results from the production by B lymphocytes of an antibody directed against the TSH receptor which stimulates the thyrocyte in a manner similar to TSH, but for a much longer interval. There are also antibodies to the thyrotrophin (TSH) receptor which block the action of TSH. Thyroid stimulating antibody is typical of GD and is detectable in about 95% of cases, but is also seen in destructive thyroiditis transiently. It tends to decline with antithyoid drug therapy, and rises further (for several months) after 131 I treatment. It may slowly decline after subtotal thyroidectomy. It also declines in the third trimester of pregnancy but sometimes is sufficiently high to cause foetal and neonatal passive transfer GD. It tends to rebound in the mother after delivery and may result in postpartum GD. The blocking antibody may cause atrophic thyroiditis and hypothyroidism. Antimicrosomal antibody has now been shown to be antithyroperoxidase. It correlates moderately well with thyroid dysfunction in Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) and GD, while antithyroglobulin is of much less value. Graves' ophthalmopathy is still not well understood, and its precise relationship to Graves' hyperthyroidism has yet to be worked out. However the retroorbital fibroblast is now emerging as the most likely target cell, with retroorbital muscle involvement possibly secondary. A recent observation of a genomic point mutation on the TSH receptor on fibroblasts from patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy but not normal persons raises interesting possibilities.

Immunoregulation in autoimmune thyroid disease

We have postulated over many years that autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) are disorders of immunoregulation due to antigen specific defect(s) in suppressor (regulatory) T (Ts) lymphocyte function. Despite earlier skepticism, there is recent increased evidence to support this view. Several investigators working with animal models have demonstrated T lymphocyte subsets that are regulatory, i.e., will prevent AITD; conversely, depletion of these cells precipitates the lesion in the experimental models. These cells have been shown to be inadequately activated by specific antigen. In human AITD, recent studies have demonstrated that CD8+ (suppressor/cytotoxic) and CD8+CD11b+ ("pure suppressor") cells are activated by irrelevant antigen normally, but are significantly less well activated in response to thyroglobulin or thyroperoxidase. In further similar studies, CD8+ cells from patients with Graves' disease (GD) are induced normally in response to glutamic acid decarboxylase-65 (GAD-65), the putative beta cell antigen important in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), but significantly less to synthetic TSH receptor (TSHR). Conversely, CD8+ cells from patients with IDDM are activated normally in response to TSHR, but significantly less to GAD-65. While these reductions in activation are partial only, and other additive factors playing on the immune system may be necessary to precipitate AITD, this disorder in the activation of Ts cells may be fundamental to the development of these disorders. This in turn may be due to molecular disturbances in MHC-related genes that dictate the mechanisms of presentation of specific antigen.

Suppressor T-cell abnormality in NOD mice before onset of diabetes

To investigate the pathological role of suppressor T-cells in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice, we stimulated splenic T-lymphocytes from diabetes-prone NOD mice with concanavalin A (ConA) and then evaluated their ability to suppress the lymphocyte-proliferative responses to mitogen and allogenic cells. Lymphocytes from NOD mice showed significantly less suppressor ability than did those from BALB/c mice and non-obese non-diabetic (NON) mice, the corresponding non-diabetic sister strain of the NOD mouse, both in the mitogen response and in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). We used monoclonal antibodies and flow cytometry to analyze the lymphocytic surface phenotypes, and found markedly fewer Lyt2+ T-lymphocytes (suppressor/cytotoxic T-lymphocyte) in the NOD mice than in both controls after exposure to ConA. These results suggest that suppressor T-cell activity is already depressed in NOD mice before diabetes begins and that a substantial decrease in the number of suppressor T-cells induced by ConA may explain this depressed suppressor activity. This impairment may contribute to the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes in NOD mice.

The immunoregulatory disturbance in autoimmune thyroid disease

There is now considerable evidence for a genetically induced antigen-specific defect in suppressor T lymphocytes as the basis for AITD, derived from several laboratories and via different types of experimental techniques. In addition, there is now evidence for additive effects on reducing generalized suppressor T lymphocyte numbers and/or function by environmental factors as well as hyperthyroidism itself, and these effects would be superimposed upon the organ-specific defect. Such effects on generalized suppressor T lymphocyte numbers may act as precipitating and self-perpetuating factors, in Graves' disease at least. Presentation of the antigen by the thyroid cell via HLA-DR expression on its membrane does occur as a result of interferon gamma production by T lymphocytes. This in turn appears to be secondary to the initial specific immune assault and is not a primary inductive step. However, it may be important as an amplifying intermediate factor but cannot perpetuate the process in the absence of the underlying immune disorder. There is, however, no evidence for an underlying antigenic abnormality or stimulus in human autoimmune thyroid disease, and the initiating event would appear to be due to perturbation of the generalized immune system superimposed on the organ-specific abnormality. Variations in the serological and clinical expression of AITD would appear to depend on the severity of the original organ-specific disturbance in suppressor T lymphocyte function, plus the added factor of environmental influences playing upon generalized suppressor T lymphocyte function and numbers. Remissions in Graves' disease brought about by antithyroid drugs may well be via their effect on modulating the thyroid cell activity; this will then reduce thyrocyte-immunocyte signalling, allowing remission to occur in those patients with a partial organ-specific defect in suppressor T lymphocytes.

Autoimmune thyroid disease: immunological, pathological, and clinical aspects

Autoimmune thyroiditis, most notably Hashimoto's thyroiditis, appears to be increasing in prevalence and is now more easily detected by sensitive laboratory tests and more invasive procedures such as fine needle aspiration. During the last decade, marked progress has been made in the understanding of these diseases. There is a greater awareness of the interaction between the humoral and cell-mediated arms of the immune system in autoimmune thyroiditis. Recent studies implicate a subpopulation of suppressor T lymphocytes which have an antigen-specific defect, resulting in their suboptimal interaction with the helper T lymphocytes and subsequent autoimmune manifestations. There is some evidence that thyroid epithelial cells which inappropriately express HLA-DR may enhance presentation of thyroid antigens to the immune system, possibly significant in the initiation or enhancement of the autoimmune response. The presence of various antithyroid autoantibodies allows the use of laboratory assays to confirm the clinical diagnosis and predict the results of treatment. There appears to be predisposing genetic factors in the development of autoimmune thyroiditis, with some geographical and racial differences. Environmental factors, most notably dietary intake of iodine, have also been implicated in the pathogenesis of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Several animal models have been developed addressing such issues. Ongoing studies in the areas of postpartum thyroiditis and childhood thyroiditis are helpful in clarifying their relationship with Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Graves' disease and postpartum thyroiditis are being investigated as possible causes of postpartum depression. The association of Hashimoto's thyroiditis and carcinoma of the thyroid gland is still controversial, but its relationship with malignant lymphoma is now well accepted. Thus, although the pathogenesis of autoimmune thyroiditis remains elusive, there has been significant refinement of the clinical diagnosis, and immunological abnormalities of specific intrathyroidal lymphocytes have been identified. Hopefully, these new areas of knowledge will assist in the treatment of these diseases and in the prevention of the development of malignant lymphomas of the thyroid gland.

Partial characterization and clinical correlation of circulating human immunoglobulins directed against thyrotrophin binding sites in guinea pig fat cell membranes. Development of a direct enzyme immunoassay

To obviate several problems inherent in indirect thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) receptor antibody assays, we developed an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) that measures antibodies binding to guinea pig fat cell membrane, which contain high concentrations of TSH receptors. Solubilized guinea pig fat cell membranes were adsorbed to plastic microtiter plates and served as the solid-phase antigen. Test sera and affinity-purified alkaline phosphatase-conjugated anti-human IgG were co-incubated with membranes, after which p-nitrophenyl phosphate was added. Results were read when a positive control reached a standard color change (OD405nm). Specificity of this assay was demonstrated by the inability of albumin, insulin, TSH subunits, propranolol, or dexamethasone to block binding 30. normal subjects had a mean OD value of 0.080 +/- 0.050 (SD). 23 of 25 untreated Graves' patients had OD values at least 2 SD above the normal mean (Grave's mean +/- SD; 0.46 +/- 0.33, P less than 0.001) and in each case 10(-6) M TSH inhibited the binding by at least 60%, suggesting that the immunoglobulins were directed at the TSH receptor. Seven of 25 serum samples from patients with Hashimoto's disease, seven of 23 serum samples from patients with transient hyperthyroidism (subacute thyroiditis or painless thyrotoxic thyroiditis), and two of 10 samples from patients with thyroid carcinoma had significant elevations in the titers of membrane-directed immunoglobulins. Graves' patients who were treated with ablative therapy at least 6 mo earlier and who were euthyroid when restudied continued to have abnormally elevated membrane-directed immunoglobulins in six of eight samples studied. Further studies involved the substitution of affinity-purified alkaline phosphatase anti-IgM antisera for the anti-IgG antisera routinely used. Seven of 12 serum samples from patients with Graves' disease had significant elevations in binding which in every instance was inhibited by greater than 60% by 10(-6) M TSH. In sum, the present results indicate that (a) we have developed a sensitive, specific, reproducible, convenient ELISA for the measurement both of the total amount of circulating membrane-directed antibodies and of TSH-displaceable membrane-directed immunoglobulins. (b) This ELISA detected significant elevations in TSH-displaceable guinea pig membrane binding in 23 of 25 untreated Graves' patients as well as in approximately 30% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis and subacute thyroiditis. (c) Elevated membrane directed antibodies may continue to be present many months or years after restoration of the euthyroid state. (d) Circulating membrane binding IgM immunoglobulins have been detected in patients with Graves' disease. Further studies using this ELISA should prove useful in a variety of investigative and clinical studies.