DNA diagnosis of FRAXA and FRAXE in Chinese children with neurodevelopmental disorders and fragile X syndrome

A Systematic Review of Fragile X-Associated Neuropsychiatric Disorders

OBJECTIVE

Fragile X premutation carriers are reported to have increased neuropsychiatric problems, and thus the term fragile X-associated neuropsychiatric disorders (FXAND) has been proposed. Unfortunately, published prevalence estimates of these phenomena are inconsistent. This systematic review clarified this issue by reviewing both fragile X premutation prevalence in patients with neurodevelopmental disorders and psychiatric disorder prevalence in premutation carriers without fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome (FXTAS). Average prevalence was derived from studies that used semistructured clinical interviews, diagnostic criteria, and validated rating scales.

METHODS

Forty-six studies were reviewed. The rate of fragile X premutation in neurodevelopmental disorders was assessed from five studies. Probands with neurodevelopmental disorders were more likely than those in the general population to be premutation carriers. The rate of psychiatric disorders in premutation carriers was assessed from five studies for neurodevelopmental, 13 studies for mood, 12 studies for anxiety, and two studies for psychotic disorders. The phenotype and sex distribution among premutation carriers were similar to those with fragile X syndrome.

RESULTS

Compared to control group and general population estimates, the most prevalent psychiatric disorders were neurodevelopmental disorders, anxiety disorders, and bipolar II disorder. Psychiatric disorders were also more common in males. Most studies relied only on past medical history to define the prevalence of psychiatric disorders, yielding variability in results.

CONCLUSIONS

Future studies are needed to avoid bias by identifying cohorts from population-based sampling, to describe cohort demographic characteristics to elucidate differences in age and sex, and to prioritize the use of validated psychiatric assessment methods.

Screening for FMR1 CGG Repeat Expansion in Thai Patients with Autism Spectrum Disorder

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a complex disorder with a heterogeneous etiology. Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is recognized as the most common single gene mutation associated with ASD. FXS patients show some autistic behaviors and may be difficult to distinguish at a young age from autistic children. However, there have been no published reports on the prevalence of FXS in ASD patients in Thailand. In this study, we present a pilot study to analyze the CGG repeat sizes of the FMR1 gene in Thai autistic patients. We screened 202 unrelated Thai patients (168 males and 34 females) with nonsyndromic ASD and 212 normal controls using standard FXS molecular diagnosis techniques. The distributions of FMR1 CGG repeat sizes in the ASD and normal control groups were similar, with the two most common alleles having 29 and 30 CGG repeats, followed by an allele with 36 CGG repeats. No FMR1 full mutations or premutations were found in either ASD individuals or the normal controls. Interestingly, three ASD male patients with high normal CGG and intermediate CGG repeats (44, 46, and 53 CGG repeats) were identified, indicating that the prevalence of FMR1 intermediate alleles in Thai ASD patients was approximately 1% while these alleles were absent in the normal male controls. Our study indicates that CGG repeat expansions of the FMR1 gene may not be a common genetic cause of nonsyndromic ASD in Thai patients. However, further studies for mutations other than the CGG expansion in the FMR1 gene are required to get a better information on FXS prevalence in Thai ASD patients.

Review of evolution of clinical, training and educational services and research program for autism spectrum disorders in Hong Kong

The evolution of a local fragmented model of services for children with autism in Hong Kong emerged gradually over the past three decades with lack of government funding or support. This had been due to increasing number of children with autism being detected and referred for earlier assessment. With increasing pressure from parents due to long waiting time for assessment and training services and the increasing polarization by mass media there had been a gradual increasing public awareness over the past five years. Though still highly fragmented in the availability of services, there is a growing "business model" available in the community due to increasing need and lack of public funding for support. There is a lack of strategic planning for medical diagnostic and management issues in Hong Kong. Our University of Hong Kong based Autism Research Program was pioneered in 1985 based on the increasing load of autism cases referred for assessment for other developmental problems and diagnosed as Autism in the Duchess of Kent Children's Hospital. As the first author has been the staff of the University of Hong Kong, this program flourished as a research based program. The benefits of early identification and intervention of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) had been increasingly recognized, and with the increased public awareness and increasing trend of earlier diagnosis, there has been a continuously high demand from parents for earlier assessment and training for children suspected to have ASD. This model had not received extra funding for this integrated program for research, teaching and training in autism. We had to apply for various donations and grants to support the development of this pioneer program. The research output and organization of forums for public education and awareness are reviewed. The latter part of the paper reports the summary of clinical profile of autism cases (N=1441) assessed from 1985 to 2010 June under the University of Hong Kong. As the waiting time for initial developmental assessment for any children in Hong Kong is 12-24 months, we also report our preliminary experience with a newly launched triaging service provision for children suspected to be ASD since 2009, including multi-disciplinary assessment and parallel interim training in our university affiliated child assessment centre in Hong (N=89).

Autism spectrum disorder: FRAXE mutation, a rare etiology

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is characterized by impaired social interaction and communication, restricted interests and repetitive behaviors. Fragile X E is associated with X-linked non-specific mild intellectual disability (ID) and with behavioral problems. Most of the known genetic causes of ASD are also causes of ID, implying that these two identities share common genetic bases. We present a child with an ASD with a normal range of intelligence quotient, that later evolved to compulsive behavior. FRAXE locus analysis by polymerase chain reaction revealed a complete mutation of the FMR 2 gene. This report stresses the importance of clinicians being aware of the association between a full mutation of FMR2 and ASD associated with compulsive behavior despite normal intellectual level.

Implication of screening for FMR1 and FMR2 gene mutation in individuals with nonspecific mental retardation in Taiwan

Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is the most common form of familial mental retardation (MR), attributable to (CGG)n expansion in the FMR1 gene. FRAXE is less frequent, associated with a similar mutation of the FMR2 gene. This study attempted to ascertain the prevalence of both disorders in Taiwan, as well as to develop a method to effectively find carriers. A total of 321 patients with nonspecific MR were screened for the FMR1 and FMR2 mutation. Four of 206 boys and men (1.9%) and 1 in 115 girls and women (0.9%) were identified as having FXS. All four FXS boys or men could be identified by Southern blot analysis, as well as by a simple nonradioactive polymerase chain reaction analysis. None of the 206 boys or men had FMR2 full mutation. This confirmed the low incidence of FRAXE in Chinese. FXS appears to be more prevalent among patients with mild MR, because 4 of the 5 patients with FXS were from the 115 with mild MR (3.48%) and only 1 was from the other 206 with severe MR (0.49%). All five FXS cases were maternally inherited. Other family members were resistant to further searching for carriers. It is worth noting that none of these mothers had a discernible premarital family history of MR. Thus the negative family history could not preclude the possibility that a woman was a carrier. To identify female carriers of childbearing age, beyond the scope of family history, is thus worthy of further exploration. Screening men for carriers using this inexpensive method is probably feasible, even though normal transmitting men have no immediate risk of producing a child with the disease. Female carriers can then be effectively identified from these normal transmitting men and can take all preventive measures.

Molecular diagnosis of the fragile X and FRAXE syndromes in patients with mental retardation of unknown cause in Mexico

The fragile X syndrome (Fra-X) is the most common cause of inherited mental retardation with X-linked semi-dominant inheritance. The prevalence of Fra-X in the Mexican population is unknown. The aim of this population screening study was to determine if Fra-X or FRAXE mutations are the cause of a number of cases of mental retardation in a sample of Mexican children with mental retardation of unknown cause (MRUC) and to stress the importance of performing molecular analysis of the FMR-1 gene in all patients with MRUC. We report here the direct analysis of CGG and GCC repeats within the FMR-1 and FMR-2 genes, respectively, in 62 unrelated patients with MRUC. Two male index cases had the CGG expansion, although they did not express the Xq27.3 fragile site cytogenetically. Fra-X diagnosis was highly suspected on a clinical basis in one of the patients, but not in the other. Both mothers were found to be premutation carriers. The molecular studies of FMR-1 showed that the proportion of MRUC patients with Fra-X is 3.2%. This frequency was not significantly different to that reported in most populations. As reported in other series, no patients with FRAXE were found in our sample. Our findings confirm that the molecular analysis of the FMR-1 gene is necessary in MRUC patients to achieve unequivocal diagnosis of fragile X syndrome, carrier premutation detection and for accurate genetic counseling.

Fragile sites still breaking

Rare fragile sites on chromosomes are the archetypal dynamic mutations. They involve large expansions of the microsatellite CCG or AT-rich minisatellites. The mutation process is an increase in repeat-unit number from within a normal range, through a premutation range, up to full mutation where the fragile site is expressed. Full mutations can inactivate genes and are regions of genomic instability. Common fragile sites, in particular, might have a role in oncogensis by facilitating gene inactivation through chromosomal deletion or amplification, but this requires further exploration. The mechanisms behind the changes that give rise to the cytogenetic manifestation of chromosomal fragility are now beginning to be understood.