Differential IFN-alpha/beta production suppressing capacities of the leader proteins of mengovirus and foot-and-mouth disease virus

Comprehensive Elucidation of the Role of L and 2A Security Proteins on Cell Death during EMCV Infection

The EMCV L and 2A proteins are virulence factors that counteract host cell defense mechanisms. Both L and 2A exhibit antiapoptotic properties, but the available data were obtained in different cell lines and under incomparable conditions. This study is aimed at checking the role of these proteins in the choice of cell death type in three different cell lines using three mutants of EMCV lacking functional L, 2A, and both proteins together. We have found that both L and 2A are non-essential for viral replication in HeLa, BHK, and RD cell lines, as evidenced by the viability of the virus in the absence of both functional proteins. L-deficient infection led to the apoptotic death of HeLa and RD cells, and the necrotic death of BHK cells. 2A-deficient infection induced apoptosis in BHK and RD cells. Infection of HeLa cells with the 2A-deficient mutant was finalized with exclusive caspase-dependent death with membrane permeabilization, morphologically similar to pyroptosis. We also demonstrated that inactivation of both proteins, along with caspase inhibition, delayed cell death progression. The results obtained demonstrate that proteins L and 2A play a critical role in choosing the path of cell death during infection, but the result of their influence depends on the properties of the host cells.

[The role of the encephalomyocarditis virus type 1 proteins L and 2A in the inhibition of the synthesis of cellular proteins and the accumulation of viral proteins during infection]

INTRODUCTION

Infection of cells with encephalomyocarditis virus type 1 (EMCV-1, Cardiovirus A: Picornaviridae) is accompanied by suppression of cellular protein synthesis. The main role in the inhibition of cellular translation is assigned to the L and 2A «security» proteins. The mechanism of the possible influence of the L protein on cellular translation is unknown. There are hypotheses about the mechanism of influence of 2A protein on the efficiency of cap-dependent translation, which are based on interaction with translation factors and ribosome subunits. However, the available experimental data are contradictory, obtained using different approaches, and do not form a unified model of the interaction between the L and 2A proteins and the cellular translation machinery.

AIM

To study the role of L and 2A «security» proteins in the suppression of translation of cellular proteins and the efficiency of translation and processing of viral proteins in infected cells.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Mutant variants of EMCV-1 were obtained to study the properties of L and 2A viral proteins: Zfmut, which has a defective L; Δ2A encoding a partially deleted 2A; Zfmut&Δ2A containing mutations in both proteins. Translational processes in infected cells were studied by Western-blot and the pulse method of incorporating radioactively labeled amino acids (14C) into newly synthesized proteins, followed by radioautography.

RESULTS

The functional inactivation of the 2A protein does not affect the inhibition of cellular protein synthesis. A direct correlation was found between the presence of active L protein and specific inactivation of cellular protein synthesis at an early stage of viral infection. Nonspecific suppression of the translational processes of the infected cell, accompanied by phosphorylation of eIF2α, occurs at the late stage of infection. Partial removal of the 2A protein from the EMCV-1 genome does not affect the development of this process, while inactivation of the L protein accelerates the onset of complete inhibition of protein synthesis. Partial deletion of the 2A disrupts the processing of viral capsid proteins. Suppression of L protein functions leads to a decrease in the efficiency of viral translation.

CONCLUSION

A study of the role of EMCV-1 L and 2A proteins during the translational processes of an infected cell, first performed using infectious viral pathogens lacking active L and 2A proteins in one experiment, showed that 2A protein is not implicated in the inhibition of cellular translation in HeLa cells; L protein seems to play an important role not only in the specific inhibition of cellular translation but also in maintaining the efficient synthesis of viral proteins; 2A protein is involved not only in primary but also in secondary processing of EMCV-1 capsid proteins.

Regulation of cGAS/STING signaling and corresponding immune escape strategies of viruses

Innate immunity is the first line of defense against invading external pathogens, and pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) are the key receptors that mediate the innate immune response. Nowadays, there are various PRRs in cells that can activate the innate immune response by recognizing pathogen-related molecular patterns (PAMPs). The DNA sensor cGAS, which belongs to the PRRs, plays a crucial role in innate immunity. cGAS detects both foreign and host DNA and generates a second-messenger cGAMP to mediate stimulator of interferon gene (STING)-dependent antiviral responses, thereby exerting an antiviral immune response. However, the process of cGAS/STING signaling is regulated by a wide range of factors. Multiple studies have shown that viruses directly target signal transduction proteins in the cGAS/STING signaling through viral surface proteins to impede innate immunity. It is noteworthy that the virus utilizes these cGAS/STING signaling regulators to evade immune surveillance. Thus, this paper mainly summarized the regulatory mechanism of the cGAS/STING signaling pathway and the immune escape mechanism of the corresponding virus, intending to provide targeted immunotherapy ideas for dealing with specific viral infections in the future.

Advances in Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus Proteins Regulating Host Innate Immunity

Foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) is a highly contagious disease that affects cloven-hoofed animals such as pigs, cattle, and sheep. The disease is caused by the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) which has a non-enveloped virion with icosahedral symmetry that encapsulates a positive-sense, single-stranded RNA genome of ∼8.4 kb. FMDV infection causes obvious immunosuppressive effects on the host. In recent years, studies on the immunosuppressive mechanism of FMDV have become a popular topic. In addition, studies have shown that many FMDV proteins are involved in the regulation of host innate immunity and have revealed mechanisms by which FMDV proteins mediate host innate immunity. In this review, advances in studies on the mechanisms of interaction between FMDV proteins and host innate immunity are summarized to provide a comprehensive understanding of FMDV pathogenesis and the theoretical basis for FMD prevention and control.

Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus Leader Protease Cleaves G3BP1 and G3BP2 and Inhibits Stress Granule Formation

Like other viruses, the picornavirus foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV; genus Aphthovirus), one of the most notorious pathogens in the global livestock industry, needs to navigate antiviral host responses to establish an infection. There is substantial insight into how FMDV suppresses the type I interferon (IFN) response, but it is largely unknown whether and how FMDV modulates the integrated stress response. Here, we show that the stress response is suppressed during FMDV infection. Using a chimeric recombinant encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV), in which we functionally replaced the endogenous stress response antagonist by FMDV leader protease (L^pro) or 3C^pro, we demonstrate an essential role for L^pro in suppressing stress granule (SG) formation. Consistently, infection with a recombinant FMDV lacking L^pro resulted in SG formation. Additionally, we show that L^pro cleaves the known SG scaffold proteins G3BP1 and G3BP2 but not TIA-1. We demonstrate that the closely related equine rhinitis A virus (ERAV) L^pro also cleaves G3BP1 and G3BP2 and also suppresses SG formation, indicating that these abilities are conserved among aphthoviruses. Neither FMDV nor ERAV L^pro interfered with phosphorylation of RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) or eIF2α, indicating that L^pro does not affect SG formation by inhibiting the PKR-triggered signaling cascade. Taken together, our data suggest that aphthoviruses actively target scaffolding proteins G3BP1 and G3BP2 and antagonize SG formation to modulate the integrated stress response.IMPORTANCE The picornavirus foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is a notorious animal pathogen that puts a major economic burden on the global livestock industry. Outbreaks have significant consequences for animal health and product safety. Like many other viruses, FMDV must manipulate antiviral host responses to establish infection. Upon infection, viral double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is detected, which results in the activation of the RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR)-mediated stress response, leading to a stop in cellular and viral translation and the formation of stress granules (SG), which are thought to have antiviral properties. Here, we show that FMDV can suppress SG formation via its leader protease (L^pro). Simultaneously, we observed that L^pro can cleave the SG scaffolding proteins G3BP1 and G3BP2. Understanding the molecular mechanisms of the antiviral host response evasion strategies of FMDV may help to develop countermeasures to control FMDV infections in the future.

Innate Immune Detection of Cardioviruses and Viral Disruption of Interferon Signaling

Cardioviruses are members of the Picornaviridae family and infect a variety of mammals, from mice to humans. Replication of cardioviruses produces double stranded RNA that is detected by helicases in the RIG-I-like receptor family and leads to a signaling cascade to produce type I interferon. Like other viruses within Picornaviridae, however, cardioviruses have evolved several mechanisms to inhibit interferon production. In this review, we summarize recent findings that have uncovered several proteins enabling efficient detection of cardiovirus dsRNA and discuss which cell types may be most important for interferon production in vivo. Additionally, we describe how cardiovirus proteins L, 3C and L^∗ disrupt interferon production and antagonize the antiviral activity of interferon effector molecules.

Recombinant Encephalomyocarditis Viruses Elicit Neutralizing Antibodies against PRRSV and CSFV in Mice

Encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV) is capable of infecting a wide range of species and the infection can cause myocarditis and reproductive failure in pigs as well as febrile illness in human beings. In this study, we introduced the entire ORF5 of the porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) or the neutralization epitope regions in the E2 gene of the classical swine fever virus (CSFV), into the genome of a stably attenuated EMCV strain, T1100I. The resultant viable recombinant viruses, CvBJC3m/I-ΔGP5 and CvBJC3m/I-E2, respectively expressed partial PRRSV envelope protein GP5 or CSFV neutralization epitope A1A2 along with EMCV proteins. These heterologous proteins fused to the N-terminal of the nonstructural leader protein could be recognized by anti-GP5 or anti-E2 antibody. We also tested the immunogenicity of these fusion proteins by immunizing BALB/c mice with the recombinant viruses. The immunized animals elicited neutralizing antibodies against PRRSV and CSFV. Our results suggest that EMCV can be engineered as an expression vector and serve as a tool in the development of novel live vaccines in various animal species.

Cholesterol shuttling is important for RNA replication of coxsackievirus B3 and encephalomyocarditis virus

Picornaviruses are a family of positive-strand RNA viruses that includes important human and animal pathogens. Upon infection, picornaviruses induce an extensive remodelling of host cell membranes into replication organelles (ROs), which is critical for replication. Membrane lipids and lipid remodelling processes are at the base of RO formation, yet their involvement remains largely obscure. Recently, phosphatidylinositol-4-phosphate was the first lipid discovered to be important for the replication of a number of picornaviruses. Here, we investigate the role of the lipid cholesterol in picornavirus replication. We show that two picornaviruses from distinct genera that rely on different host factors for replication, namely the enterovirus coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3) and the cardiovirus encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV), both recruited cholesterol to their ROs. Although CVB3 and EMCV both required cholesterol for efficient genome replication, the viruses appeared to rely on different cellular cholesterol pools. Treatments that altered the distribution of endosomal cholesterol inhibited replication of both CVB3 and EMCV, showing the importance of endosomal cholesterol shuttling for the replication of these viruses. Summarizing, we here demonstrate the importance of cholesterol homeostasis for efficient replication of CVB3 and EMCV.

Regulation of RIG-I-like receptor signaling by host and viral proteins

Vertebrate innate immunity is characterized by an effective immune surveillance apparatus, evolved to sense foreign structures, such as proteins or nucleic acids of invading microbes. RIG-I-like receptors (RLRs) are key sensors of viral RNA species in the host cell cytoplasm. Activation of RLRs in response to viral RNA triggers an antiviral defense program through the production of hundreds of antiviral effector proteins including cytokines, chemokines, and host restriction factors that directly interfere with distinct steps in the virus life cycle. To avoid premature or abnormal antiviral and proinflammatory responses, which could have harmful consequences for the host, the signaling activities of RLRs and their common adaptor molecule, MAVS, are delicately controlled by cell-intrinsic regulatory mechanisms. Furthermore, viruses have evolved multiple strategies to modulate RLR-MAVS signal transduction to escape from immune surveillance. Here, we summarize recent progress in our understanding of the regulation of RLR signaling through host factors and viral antagonistic proteins.

Encephalomyocarditis virus Leader protein hinge domain is responsible for interactions with Ran GTPase

Encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV), a Cardiovirus, initiates its polyprotein with a short 67 amino acid Leader (L) sequence. The protein acts as a unique pathogenicity factor, with anti-host activities which include the triggering of nuclear pore complex hyperphosphorylation and direct binding inhibition of the active cellular transport protein, Ran GTPase. Chemical modifications and protein mutagenesis now map the Ran binding domain to the L hinge-linker region, and in particular, to amino acids 35-40. Large deletions affecting this region were shown previously to diminish Ran binding. New point mutations, especially K35Q, D37A and W40A, preserve the intact L structure, abolish Ran binding and are deficient for nucleoporin (Nup) hyperphosphorylation. Ran itself morphs through multiple configurations, but reacts most effectively with L when in the GDP format, preferably with an empty nucleotide binding pocket. Therefore, L:Ran binding, mediated by the linker-hinge, is a required step in L-induced nuclear transport inhibition.

Guanine-nucleotide exchange factor RCC1 facilitates a tight binding between the encephalomyocarditis virus leader and cellular Ran GTPase

The leader (L) protein of encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV) shuts off host cell nucleocytoplasmic trafficking (NCT) by inducing hyperphosphorylation of nuclear pore proteins. This dramatic effect by a nonenzymatic protein of 6 kDa is not well understood but clearly involves L binding to cellular Ran GTPase, a critical factor of active NCT. Exogenous GDP and GTP are inhibitory to L-Ran binding, but the guanine-nucleotide exchange factor RCC1 can relieve this inhibition. In the presence of RCC1, L binds Ran with a KD (equilibrium dissociation constant) of ≈ 3 nM and reaches saturation within 20 min. The results of fluorescently tagged nucleotide experiments suggest that L-Ran interactions affect the nucleotide-binding pocket of Ran.

Interferon induction and suppression in swine testicle cells by porcine parvovirus and its proteins

Porcine parvovirus (PPV) is a major causative agent of reproductive failure in swine, which currently affects the swine industry worldwide. Although PPV was identified several years ago, little is known about how it overcomes host innate immunity. In this study, we used quantitative real-time PCR and a luciferase reporter assay to determine whether PPV infection induces type I interferon (IFN-α and IFN-β) and whether PPV infection blocks dsRNA-induced IFN-β promoter activation in cell cultures. The results indicate that PPV does not induce type I interferon and that the NS2 protein of PPV could blocks dsRNA-induced IFN-β promoter activation.

Promyelocytic leukemia isoform IV confers resistance to encephalomyocarditis virus via the sequestration of 3D polymerase in nuclear bodies

Promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein is the organizer of nuclear matrix-associated nuclear bodies (NBs), and its conjugation to the small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) is required for the formation of these structures. Several alternatively spliced PML transcripts from a single PML gene lead to the production of seven PML isoforms (PML isoform I [PMLI] to VII [PMLVII]), which all share a N-terminal region that includes the RBCC (RING, B boxes, and a α-helical coiled-coil) motif but differ in the C-terminal region. This diversity of PML isoforms determines the specific functions of each isoform. There is increasing evidence implicating PML in host antiviral defense and suggesting various strategies involving PML to counteract viral production. We reported that mouse embryonic fibroblasts derived from PML knockout mice are more sensitive than wild-type cells to infection with encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV). Here, we show that stable expression of PMLIV or PMLIVa inhibited viral replication and protein synthesis, leading to a substantial reduction of EMCV multiplication. This protective effect required PMLIV SUMOylation and was not observed with other nuclear PML isoforms (I, II, III, V, and VI) or with the cytoplasmic PMLVII. We demonstrated that only PMLIV interacted with EMCV 3D polymerase (3Dpol) and sequestered it within PML NBs. The C-terminal region specific to PMLIV was required for both interaction with 3Dpol and the antiviral properties. Also, depletion of PMLIV by RNA interference significantly boosted EMCV production in interferon-treated cells. These findings indicate the mechanism by which PML confers resistance to EMCV. They also reveal a new pathway mediating the antiviral activity of interferon against EMCV.

The multifaceted poliovirus 2A protease: regulation of gene expression by picornavirus proteases

After entry into animal cells, most viruses hijack essential components involved in gene expression. This is the case of poliovirus, which abrogates cellular translation soon after virus internalization. Abrogation is achieved by cleavage of both eIF4GI and eIF4GII by the viral protease 2A. Apart from the interference of poliovirus with cellular protein synthesis, other gene expression steps such as RNA and protein trafficking between nucleus and cytoplasm are also altered. Poliovirus 2A^pro is capable of hydrolyzing components of the nuclear pore, thus preventing an efficient antiviral response by the host cell. Here, we compare in detail poliovirus 2A^pro with other viral proteins (from picornaviruses and unrelated families) as regard to their activity on key host factors that control gene expression. It is possible that future analyses to determine the cellular proteins targeted by 2A^pro will uncover other cellular functions ablated by poliovirus infection. Further understanding of the cellular proteins hydrolyzed by 2A^pro will add further insight into the molecular mechanism by which poliovirus and other viruses interact with the host cell.

Viral security proteins: counteracting host defences

Viral reproduction involves not only replication but also interactions with host defences. Although various viral proteins can take part in counteracting innate and adaptive immunity, many viruses possess a subset of proteins that are specifically dedicated to counter-defensive activities. These proteins are sometimes referred to as 'virulence factors', but here we argue that the term 'security proteins' is preferable, for several reasons.

The concept of security proteins of RNA-containing viruses can be considered using the leader (L and L^*) and 2A proteins of picornaviruses as examples. The picornaviruses are a large group of human and animal viruses that include important pathogens such as poliovirus, hepatitis A virus and foot-and-mouth disease virus. The genomes of different picornaviruses have a similar organization, in which the genes for L and 2A occupy fixed positions upstream and downstream of the capsid genes, respectively.

Both L and 2A are extremely heterogeneous with respect to size, sequence and biochemical properties. The similarly named proteins can be completely unrelated to each other in different viral genera, and the variation can be striking even among members of the same genus. A subset of picornaviruses lacks L altogether.

The properties and functions of L and 2A of many picornaviruses are unknown, but in those viruses that have been investigated sufficiently it has been found that these proteins can switch off various aspects of host macromolecular synthesis and specifically suppress mechanisms involved in innate immunity. Thus, notwithstanding their unrelatedness, the security proteins carry out similar biological functions. It is proposed that other picornavirus L and 2A proteins that have not yet been investigated should also be primarily involved in security activities.

The L, L^* and 2A proteins are dispensable for viral reproduction, but their elimination or inactivation usually renders the viruses less pathogenic. The phenotypic changes associated with inactivation of security proteins are much less pronounced in cells or organisms that have innate immunity deficiencies. In several examples, the decreased fitness of a virus in which a security protein has been inactivated could be rescued by the experimental introduction of an unrelated security protein.

It can be argued that L and 2A were acquired by different picornaviruses independently, and possibly by exploiting different mechanisms, late in the evolution of this viral family.

It is proposed that the concept of security proteins is of general relevance and can be applied to viruses other than picornaviruses. The hallmarks of security proteins are: structural and biochemical unrelatedness in related viruses or even absence in some of them; dispensability of the entire protein or its functional domains for viral viability; and, for mutated versions of the proteins, fewer detrimental effects on viral reproduction in immune-compromised hosts than in immune-competent hosts.

Viral security proteins are structurally and biochemically unrelated proteins that function to counteract host defences. Here, Agol and Gmyl consider the impact of the picornavirus security proteins on viral reproduction, pathogenicity and evolution.

Interactions with host defences are key aspects of viral infection. Various viral proteins perform counter-defensive functions, but a distinct class, called security proteins, is dedicated specifically to counteracting host defences. Here, the properties of the picornavirus security proteins L and 2A are discussed. These proteins have well-defined positions in the viral polyprotein, flanking the capsid precursor, but they are structurally and biochemically unrelated. Here, we consider the impact of these two proteins, as well as that of a third security protein, L^*, on viral reproduction, pathogenicity and evolution. The concept of security proteins could serve as a paradigm for the dedicated counter-defensive proteins of other viruses.

SUMOylation promotes PML degradation during encephalomyocarditis virus infection

The promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein is expressed in the diffuse nuclear fraction of the nucleoplasm and in matrix-associated structures, known as nuclear bodies (NBs). PML NB formation requires the covalent modification of PML to SUMO. The noncovalent interactions of SUMO with PML based on the identification of a SUMO-interacting motif within PML seem to be required for further recruitment within PML NBs of SUMOylated proteins. RNA viruses whose replication takes place in the cytoplasm and is inhibited by PML have developed various strategies to counteract the antiviral defense mediated by PML NBs. We show here that primary fibroblasts derived from PML knockout mice are more sensitive to infection with encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV), suggesting that the absence of PML results in an increase in EMCV replication. Also, we found that EMCV induces a decrease in PML protein levels both in interferon-treated cells and in PMLIII-expressing cells. Reduction of PML was carried out by the EMCV 3C protease. Indeed, at early times postinfection, EMCV induced PML transfer from the nucleoplasm to the nuclear matrix and PML conjugation to SUMO-1, SUMO-2, and SUMO-3, leading to an increase in PML body size where the viral protease 3C and the proteasome component were found colocalizing with PML within the NBs. This process was followed by PML degradation occurring in a proteasome- and SUMO-dependent manner and did not involve the SUMO-interacting motif of PML. Together, these findings reveal a new mechanism evolved by EMCV to antagonize the PML pathway in the interferon-induced antiviral defense.

SUMOylation promotes PML degradation during encephalomyocarditis virus infection

The promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein is expressed in the diffuse nuclear fraction of the nucleoplasm and in matrix-associated structures, known as nuclear bodies (NBs). PML NB formation requires the covalent modification of PML to SUMO. The noncovalent interactions of SUMO with PML based on the identification of a SUMO-interacting motif within PML seem to be required for further recruitment within PML NBs of SUMOylated proteins. RNA viruses whose replication takes place in the cytoplasm and is inhibited by PML have developed various strategies to counteract the antiviral defense mediated by PML NBs. We show here that primary fibroblasts derived from PML knockout mice are more sensitive to infection with encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV), suggesting that the absence of PML results in an increase in EMCV replication. Also, we found that EMCV induces a decrease in PML protein levels both in interferon-treated cells and in PMLIII-expressing cells. Reduction of PML was carried out by the EMCV 3C protease. Indeed, at early times postinfection, EMCV induced PML transfer from the nucleoplasm to the nuclear matrix and PML conjugation to SUMO-1, SUMO-2, and SUMO-3, leading to an increase in PML body size where the viral protease 3C and the proteasome component were found colocalizing with PML within the NBs. This process was followed by PML degradation occurring in a proteasome- and SUMO-dependent manner and did not involve the SUMO-interacting motif of PML. Together, these findings reveal a new mechanism evolved by EMCV to antagonize the PML pathway in the interferon-induced antiviral defense.