Score Model for the Evaluation of Dialysis Membrane Hemocompatibility

Comparative Study on Elution of Polyvinylpyrrolidone on Dialyzers Using Ultraviolet Analysis and Iodine Method

It is known that poly(arylethersulfone)-based dialyzers can elute poly( N -vinyl-2-pyrrolidone) (PVP). With regard to chronic renal replacement therapy, this is a burden for the patient, because PVP is deposited in different organs and cannot be degraded or released from there; so elutable PVP has to be minimized. Usually, the iodine method is used for quantification of extractable PVP. To overcome the chain length dependency of this method, we used an ultraviolet method that is independent from the PVP chain lengths; so the absolute amount of eluted PVP can be quantified. The current study shows the amount of eluted PVP on differently sterilized low flux dialyzers (1.6 m 2 , similar storage time, n = 12)-PS160 (Allmed, Egypt), F7HPS (Fresenius Medical Care, Germany), F16 (Wego, China), and B-16P (Bain, China). Using the ultraviolet method, the irradiated filters show a sum total of approximately 9 mg more eluted PVP compared with the steam-sterilized ones, whereas the iodine method shows a value about three times lower between different types of sterilization. The boundary conditions during the radiation sterilization could lead to PVP degradation instead of cross-linking. The resulting shorter PVP chains can be more easily rinsed out and can falsely decrease the calculated eluted PVP amount by using the iodine complexation method.

A Review of Commercial Developments and Recent Laboratory Research of Dialyzers and Membranes for Hemodialysis Application

Dialyzers have been commercially used for hemodialysis application since the 1950s, but progress in improving their efficiencies has never stopped over the decades. This article aims to provide an up-to-date review on the commercial developments and recent laboratory research of dialyzers for hemodialysis application and to discuss the technical aspects of dialyzer development, including hollow fiber membrane materials, dialyzer design, sterilization processes and flow simulation. The technical challenges of dialyzers are also highlighted in this review, which discusses the research areas that need to be prioritized to further improve the properties of dialyzers, such as flux, biocompatibility, flow distribution and urea clearance rate. We hope this review article can provide insights to researchers in developing/designing an ideal dialyzer that can bring the best hemodialysis treatment outcomes to kidney disease patients.

Polyvinylpyrrolidone in hemodialysis membranes: Impact on platelet loss during hemodialysis

INTRODUCTION

Hydrophilic modification with polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) increases the biocompatibility profile of synthetic dialysis membranes. However, PVP may be eluted into the patient's blood, which has been discussed as a possible cause for adverse reactions rarely occurring with synthetic membranes. We investigated the content of PVP and its elution from the blood-side surface from commercially available dialyzers, including the novel FX CorAL, with PVP-enriched and α-tocopherol-stabilized membrane, and link the results to the level of platelet loss during dialysis as a maker of biocompatibility.

METHODS

Six synthetic, PVP containing, dialyzers (FX CorAL, FX CorDiax [Fresenius Medical Care]; Polyflux, THERANOVA [Baxter]; ELISIO [Nipro]; xevonta [B. Braun]) were investigated in the present study. The content of PVP on blood-side surface was determined with X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The amount of elutable PVP was measured photometrically after 5 h recirculation. The level of platelet loss was evaluated in an ex vivo recirculation model with human blood.

FINDINGS

Highest PVP content on the blood-side surface was found for the polysulfone-based FX CorAL (26.3%), while the polyethersulfone-based THERANOVA (15.6%) had the lowest PVP content. Elution of PVP was highest for the autoclave steam-sterilized THERANOVA (9.1 mg/1.6 m² dialyzer) and Polyflux (9.0 mg/1.6 m² dialyzer), while the lowest PVP elution was found for the INLINE steam sterilized FX CorAL and FX CorDiax (<0.5 mg/1.6 m² dialyzer, for both). Highest platelet loss was found for xevonta (+164.4% compared to the reference) and the lowest for the FX CorAL (-225.2%) among the polysulfone-based dialyzers; among the polyethersulfone-based dialyzers, THERANOVA (+95.5%) had the highest and ELISIO (-52.1%) the lowest platelet loss.

DISCUSSION

Polyvinylpyrrolidone content and elution differ between commercially available dialyzers and were found to be linked to the membrane material and sterilization method. The amount of non-eluted PVP on the blood-side surface may be an important determinant for the biocompatibility of dialyzers.

Complement activation by dialysis membranes and its association with secondary membrane formation and surface charge

Activation of the complement system may occur during blood-membrane interactions in hemodialysis and contribute to chronic inflammation of patients with end-stage renal disease. Hydrophilic modification with polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) has been suggested to increase the biocompatibility profile of dialysis membranes. In the present study we compared the complement activation of synthetic and cellulose-based membranes, including the polysulfone membrane with α-tocopherol-stabilized PVP-enriched inner surface of the novel FX CorAL dialyzer, and linked the results to their physical characteristics. Eight synthetic and cellulose-based dialyzers (FX CorAL, FX CorDiax [Fresenius Medical Care]; Polyflux, THERANOVA [Baxter]; ELISIO, SUREFLUX [Nipro]; xevonta [B. Braun]; FDX [Nikkisio Medical]) were investigated in the present study. Complement activation (C3a, C5a, and sC5b-9) was evaluated in a 3 hours ex vivo recirculation model with human blood. Albumin sieving coefficients were determined over a 4 hours ex vivo recirculation model with human plasma as a surrogate of secondary membrane formation. Zeta potential was measured as an indicator for the surface charge of the membranes. The FX CorAL dialyzer induced the lowest activation of the three complement factors (C3a: -39.4%; C5a: -57.5%; and sC5b-9: -58.9% compared to the reference). Highest complement activation was found for the cellulose-based SUREFLUX (C3a: +154.0%) and the FDX (C5a: +335.0% and sC5b-9: +287.9%) dialyzers. Moreover, the FX CorAL dialyzer had the nearest-to-neutral zeta potential (-2.38 mV) and the lowest albumin sieving coefficient decrease over time. Albumin sieving coefficient decrease was associated with complement activation by the investigated dialyzers. Our present results indicate that the surface modification implemented in the FX CorAL dialyzer reduces the secondary membrane formation and improves the biocompatibility profile. Further clinical studies are needed to investigate whether these observations will result in a lower inflammatory burden of hemodialysis patients.

Is there a future for electrochemically assisted hemodialysis? Focus on the application of polypyrrole–nanocellulose composites

This work summarizes the various aspects of using electrochemically assisted solute removal techniques in hemodialysis with a focus on blood electrodialysis and electrochemically controlled uremic retention solute removal using polypyrrole. In particular, the feasibility of using highly porous conductive polypyrrole–Cladophora cellulose membranes for hemodialysis are overviewed as a part of our dedicated research efforts during the past 4 years. The potential benefits and the current limitations associated with using the electrochemically controlled uremic retention solute removal techniques are discussed in detail.

Activation of basophils is a new and sensitive marker of biocompatibility in hemodialysis

The hemodialysis procedure involves contact between peripheral blood and the surface of dialyzer membranes, which may lead to alterations in the pathways of innate and adaptive immunity. We aimed to study the effect of blood–membrane interaction on human peripheral basophils and neutrophils in hemodialysis with high- and low-permeability polysulfone dialyzers. The surface expression of CD203c (basophil selection marker) and CD63 (activation marker) after activation by the bacterial peptide formyl-methionyl-leucyl-phenylalanine (fMLP) or anti-Fcε receptor I (FcεRI) antibody and the absolute number of basophils was investigated before and after hemodialysis with each of the dialyzers. Moreover, the expression on neutrophils of CD11b, the CD11b active epitope, and CD88 was analyzed in the same groups of individuals. The expression of CD63 in basophils following activation by fMLP was significantly higher in the patient group compared with that in healthy controls, but no differences were observed after activation by anti-FcεRI. During the hemodialysis procedure, the low-flux membrane induced up-regulation of CD63 expression on basophils, while passage through the high-flux membrane did not significantly alter the responsiveness. In addition, the absolute number of basophils was unchanged after hemodialysis with either of the dialyzers and compared with healthy controls. We found no significant differences in the expression of the neutrophil activation markers (CD11b, the active epitope of CD11b, and CD88) comparing the two different dialyzers before and after dialysis and healthy controls. Together, these findings suggest that alterations in basophil activity may be a useful marker of membrane bioincompatibility in hemodialysis.

Obstacles in haemocompatibility testing

ISO 10993-4 is an international standard describing the methods of testing of medical devices for interactions with blood for regulatory purpose. The complexity of blood responses to biomaterial surfaces and the variability of blood functions in different individuals and species pose difficulties in standardisation. Moreover, in vivo or in vitro testing, as well as the clinical relevance of certain findings, is still matter of debate. This review deals with the major remaining problems, including a brief explanation of surface interactions with blood, the current ISO 10993 requirements for testing, and the role of in vitro test models. The literature is reviewed on anticoagulation, shear rate, blood-air interfaces, incubation time, and the importance of evaluation of the surface area after blood contact. Two test categories deserve further attention: complement and platelet function, including the effects on platelets from adhesion proteins, venipuncture, and animal derived- blood. The material properties, hydrophilicity, and roughness, as well as reference materials, are discussed. Finally this review calls for completing the acceptance criteria in the ISO standard based on a panel of test results.

Haemocompatibility and ion exchange capability of nanocellulose polypyrrole membranes intended for blood purification

Composites of nanocellulose and the conductive polymer polypyrrole (PPy) are presented as candidates for a new generation of haemodialysis membranes. The composites may combine active ion exchange with passive ultrafiltration, and the large surface area (about 80 m(2) g(-1)) could potentially provide compact dialysers. Herein, the haemocompatibility of the novel membranes and the feasibility of effectively removing small uraemic toxins by potential-controlled ion exchange were studied. The thrombogenic properties of the composites were improved by applying a stable heparin coating. In terms of platelet adhesion and thrombin generation, the composites were comparable with haemocompatible polymer polysulphone, and regarding complement activation, the composites were more biocompatible than commercially available membranes. It was possible to extract phosphate and oxalate ions from solutions with physiological pH and the same tonicity as that of the blood. The exchange capacity of the materials was found to be 600 ± 26 and 706 ± 31 μmol g(-1) in a 0.1 M solution (pH 7.4) and in an isotonic solution of phosphate, respectively. The corresponding values with oxalate were 523 ± 5 in a 0.1 M solution (pH 7.4) and 610 ± 1 μmol g(-1) in an isotonic solution. The heparinized PPy-cellulose composite is consequently a promising haemodialysis material, with respect to both potential-controlled extraction of small uraemic toxins and haemocompatibility.

Evaluation of three different methods to prevent dialyzer clotting without causing systemic anticoagulation effect

Thrombogenicity is one of the most important biocompatibility markers of artificial material. Anticoagulation is commonly used to reduce thrombogenicity of the extracorporeal circuit (ECC) during intermittent hemodialysis (IHD). In some situations, systemic anticoagulants are contraindicated. The aim of our study was to compare thrombogenicity parameters during IHD with three different methods without a systemic anticoagulation effect. In a prospective, randomized, and crossover study, we examined 10 stable patients during IHD with (i) regular saline flushes of ECC; (ii) regional citrate anticoagulation (RCA); and (iii) AN69 ST membrane after ECC priming according to the manufacturer's recommendations. Before IHD and after 10, 60, 120, and 240 min, we measured the platelet count and the plasma concentrations of platelet factor 4 (PF4) and thrombin/antithrombin complexes (TAT). All 10 procedures with RCA were successfully completed after 4 h, whereas 6/10 procedures with saline flushes and 5/10 procedures with AN69 ST were finished prematurely because of clotting (P < 0.05). The TAT production was significantly increased during saline flushes and AN69 ST compared with RCA (P < 0.05). Platelet activation demonstrated by rising PF4 was present during all three methods. Markers of coagulation cascade activation were progressively increasing during IHD with RCA, saline flushes, and AN69 ST. The activation was significantly lower during RCA, and according to thrombogenicity, RCA is the most effective among compared anticoagulation methods.

Hemocompatibility of silicon-based substrates for biomedical implant applications

Silicon membranes with highly uniform nanopore sizes fabricated using microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) technology allow for the development of miniaturized implants such as those needed for renal replacement therapies. However, the blood compatibility of silicon has thus far been an unresolved issue in the use of these substrates in implantable biomedical devices. We report the results of hemocompatibility studies using bare silicon, polysilicon, and modified silicon substrates. The surface modifications tested have been shown to reduce protein and/or platelet adhesion, thus potentially improving biocompatibility of silicon. Hemocompatibility was evaluated under four categories—coagulation (thrombin–antithrombin complex, TAT generation), complement activation (complement protein, C3a production), platelet activation (P-selectin, CD62P expression), and platelet adhesion. Our tests revealed that all silicon substrates display low coagulation and complement activation, comparable to that of Teflon and stainless steel, two materials commonly used in medical implants, and significantly lower than that of diethylaminoethyl (DEAE) cellulose, a polymer used in dialysis membranes. Unmodified silicon and polysilicon showed significant platelet attachment; however, the surface modifications on silicon reduced platelet adhesion and activation to levels comparable to that on Teflon. These results suggest that surface-modified silicon substrates are viable for the development of miniaturized renal replacement systems.