Surface and deep EEG correlates of surgical outcome in temporal lobe epilepsy

Simultaneous scalp EEG improves seizure lateralization during unilateral intracranial EEG evaluation in temporal lobe epilepsy

PURPOSE

To determine if simultaneous bilateral scalp EEG (scEEG) can accurately detect a contralateral seizure onset in patients with unilateral intracranial EEG (IEEG) implantation.

METHODS

We evaluated 39 seizures from 9 patients with bitemporal epilepsy who underwent simultaneous scEEG and IEEG (SSIEEG). To simulate conditions of unilateral IEEG implantation with a missed contralateral seizure onset, we analyzed the IEEG recording contralateral to the seizure onset (CL- IEEG), in conjunction with simultaneous scEEG. The following criteria were evaluated between scEEG and CL- IEEG (1) latency: the time to onset of EEG seizure (2) location: concordance of ictal onset zones and (3) pattern: congruence of EEG morphology and frequency.

RESULTS

SSIEEG correctly lateralized 36/39 (92.3%) seizures compared to 13/39 (33.3%) seizures using CL- IEEG alone (OR = 24.0, p < 0.01), 33 (84.6%) seizures using scEEG alone (OR = 2.2, p = 0.29) and 26 (66.9%) seizures using time of clinical onset alone (OR = 6.0, p = 0.01). For the three criteria evaluated, (1) 22/39 (56.4%) seizures had an earlier onset on the scEEG, compared to CL- IEEG; (2) lack of congruence of location of seizure onset was noted in 33/39 (84.6%) of the seizures; and (3) 22/39 (56.4%) seizures did not have a congruent ictal pattern.

CONCLUSIONS

The chronological, topographic and morphologic features of SSIEEG can accurately detect the hemisphere of seizure onset in most cases with unilateral IEEG implantation. SSIEEG is significantly better than, IEEG, scEEG or clinical onset alone in this scenario. We propose that SSIEEG should be considered in all cases of intractable focal epilepsy undergoing unilateral IEEG evaluation.

Features of Simultaneous Scalp and Intracranial EEG That Predict Localization of Ictal Onset Zone

OBJECTIVE

To assess the utility of simultaneous scalp EEG in patients with focal epilepsy undergoing intracranial EEG evaluation after a detailed presurgical testing, including an inpatient scalp video EEG evaluation.

METHODS

Patients who underwent simultaneous scalp and intracranial EEG (SSIEEG) monitoring were classified into group 1 or 2 depending on whether the seizure onset zone was delineated or not. Seizures were analyzed using the following 3 EEG features at the onset of seizures latency, location, and pattern.

RESULTS

The criteria showed at least one of the following features when comparing SSIEEG: prolonged latency, absence of anatomical congruence, lack of concordance of EEG pattern in 11.11% (1/9) of the patients in group 1 and 75 % (3/4) of the patients in group 2. These 3 features were not present in any of the 5 patients who had Engel class I outcome compared with 1 of the 2 patients (50%) who had seizure recurrence after resective surgery. The mean latency of seizure onset in scalp EEG compared with intracranial EEG of patients in group 1 was 17.48 seconds (SD = 16.07) compared with 4.33 seconds (SD = 11.24) in group 2 ( P = .03). None of the seizures recorded in patients in group 1 had a discordant EEG pattern in SSIEEG.

CONCLUSION

Concordance in EEG features like latency, location, and EEG pattern, at the onset of seizures in SSIEEG is associated with a favorable outcome after epilepsy surgery in patients with intractable focal epilepsy.

SIGNIFICANCE

Simultaneous scalp EEG complements intracranial EEG evaluation even after a detailed inpatient scalp video EEG evaluation and could be part of standard intracranial EEG studies in patients with intractable focal epilepsy.

Depth versus subdural temporal electrodes revisited: Impact on surgical outcome after resective surgery for epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

To study retrospectively the impact of electrode modality (subdural or depth electrodes) during presurgical assessment on surgical outcome after temporal lobectomy.

METHODS

The study included 17 patients assessed with depth electrodes and 57 with bitemporal subdural strips.

RESULTS

MRI showed a larger proportion of bilateral pathology in patients undergoing depth recordings (29.41% versus 3.5%, p=0.00069). Among the operated patients, those undergoing depth electrode recordings showed better outcome at one year after surgery (11/12 versus 22/33; p=0.046). This difference disappears at longest follow up (10/12 versus 22/33; p=0.138). Moreover, the probability of undergoing surgery and having good outcome after assessment with intracranial recordings is higher for the depth electrode group at one-year follow up (11/17 versus 22/57; p=0.029) but statistical differences decrease to a trend for the longest follow up (10/17 versus 22/57; p=0.069). No other statistical differences were noted between subdural and depth electrodes. Depth electrodes showed lower complication rates than subdural electrodes.

CONCLUSION

Both depth and subdural electrodes are effective for presurgical assessment of temporal lobe epilepsy.

SIGNIFICANCE

Assessment with depth electrodes is associated with slightly increased likelihood of surgery and marginally better surgical outcome at one year follow up which disappears for longer follow up periods. Initial assessment with depth electrodes would have avoided a second implantation in 15% of patients.

The role of the interictal EEG in selecting candidates for resective epilepsy surgery

The interictal EEG is a noninvasive and useful test for selecting candidates for resective epilepsy surgery, although it has many pitfalls. It is an essential test for the most common drug-resistant epilepsy, mesial temporal sclerosis, and predicts good outcome when interictal epileptiform discharges are concordant with unilateral hippocampal atrophy or sclerosis, and predicts poor outcome when interictal epileptic discharges are discordant with the lesion. Its role in other types of epilepsy surgery, including nonlesional cases and corpus callosotomy, is less clear. Future research gathering large multicenter prospective data is needed to maximize the role of this classic neurophysiological test in the evaluation of candidates for epilepsy surgery.

Distinct representations and theta dynamics in dorsal and ventral hippocampus

Although anatomical, lesion, and imaging studies of the hippocampus indicate qualitatively different information processing along its septo-temporal axis, physiological mechanisms supporting such distinction are missing. We found fundamental differences between the dorsal (dCA3) and the ventral-most parts (vCA3) of the hippocampus in both environmental representation and temporal dynamics. Discrete place fields of dCA3 neurons evenly covered all parts of the testing environments. In contrast, vCA3 neurons (1) rarely showed continuous two-dimensional place fields, (2) differentiated open and closed arms of a radial maze, and (3) discharged similar firing patterns with respect to the goals, both on multiple arms of a radial maze and during opposite journeys in a zigzag maze. In addition, theta power and the fraction of theta-rhythmic neurons were substantially reduced in the ventral compared with dorsal hippocampus. We hypothesize that the spatial representation in the septo-temporal axis of the hippocampus is progressively decreased. This change is paralleled with a reduction of theta rhythm and an increased representation of nonspatial information.

Cellular plasticity for group I mGluR-mediated epileptogenesis

Stimulation of group I metabotropic glutamate receptors (mGluRs) by the agonist (S)-dihydroxyphenylglycine in the hippocampus transforms normal neuronal activity into prolonged epileptiform discharges. The conversion is long lasting in that epileptiform discharges persist after washout of the inducing agonist and serves as a model of epileptogenesis. The group I mGluR model of epileptogenesis took on special significance because epilepsy associated with fragile X syndrome (FXS) may be caused by excessive group I mGluR signaling. At present, the plasticity mechanism underlying the group I mGluR-mediated epileptogenesis is unknown. I(mGluR(V)), a voltage-gated cationic current activated by group I mGluR agonists in CA3 pyramidal cells in the hippocampus, is a possible candidate. I(mGluR(V)) activation is associated with group I mGluR agonist-elicited epileptiform discharges. For I(mGluR(V)) to play a role in epileptogenesis, long-term activation of the current must occur after group I mGluR agonist exposure or synaptic stimulation. We observed that I(mGluR(V)), once induced by group I mGluR agonist stimulation in CA3 pyramidal cells, remained undiminished for hours after agonist washout. In slices prepared from FXS model mice, repeated stimulation of recurrent CA3 pyramidal cell synapses, effective in eliciting mGluR-mediated epileptiform discharges, also induced long-lasting I(mGluR(V)) in CA3 pyramidal cells. Similar to group I mGluR-mediated prolonged epileptiform discharges, persistent I(mGluR(V)) was no longer observed in preparations pretreated with inhibitors of tyrosine kinase, of extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1/2, or of mRNA protein synthesis. The results indicate that I(mGluR(V)) is an intrinsic plasticity mechanism associated with group I mGluR-mediated epileptogenesis.

Influence of magnetic source imaging for planning intracranial EEG in epilepsy

BACKGROUND

Magnetic source imaging (MSI) is used routinely in epilepsy presurgical evaluation and in mapping eloquent cortex for surgery. Despite increasing use, the diagnostic yield of MSI is uncertain, with reports varying from 5% to 35%. To add benefit, a diagnostic technique should influence decisions made from other tests, and that influence should yield better outcomes. We report preliminary results of an ongoing, long-term clinical study in epilepsy, where MSI changed surgical decisions.

METHODS

We determined whether MSI changed the surgical decision in a prospective, blinded, crossover-controlled, single-treatment, observational case series. Sixty-nine sequential patients diagnosed with partial epilepsy of suspected neocortical origin had video-EEG and imaging. All met criteria for intracranial EEG (ICEEG). At a surgical conference, a decision was made before and after presentation of MSI. Cases where MSI altered the decision were noted.

RESULTS

MSI gave nonredundant information in 23 patients (33%). MSI added ICEEG electrodes in 9 (13%) and changed the surgical decision in another 14 (20%). Based on MSI, 16 patients (23%) were scheduled for different ICEEG coverage. Twenty-eight have gone to ICEEG, 29 to resection, and 14 to vagal nerve stimulation, including 17 where MSI changed the decision. Additional electrodes in 4 patients covered the correct: hemisphere in 3, lobe in 3, and sublobar ictal onset zone in 1. MSI avoided contralateral electrodes in 2, who both localized on ICEEG. MSI added information to ICEEG in 1.

CONCLUSION

Magnetic source imaging (MSI) provided nonredundant information in 33% of patients. In those who have undergone surgery to date, MSI added useful information that changed treatment in 6 (9%), without increasing complications. MSI has benefited 21% who have gone to surgery.

Good surgical outcome in discordant ictal EEG-MRI unilateral mesial temporal sclerosis patients

PURPOSE

Video electroencephalography (vEEG) monitoring of patients with unilateral mesial temporal sclerosis (uMTS) may show concordant or discordant seizure onset in relation to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) evidence of MTS. Contralateral seizure usually leads to an indication of invasive monitoring. Contralateral seizure onset on invasive monitoring may contraindicate surgery. We evaluated long-term outcome after anteromesial temporal lobectomy (AMTL) in a consecutive series of uMTS patients with concordant and discordant vEEG findings, uniformly submitted to AMTL on the MRI evidence of MTS side without invasive monitoring.

METHODS

We compared surgical outcome of all uMTS patients undergoing vEEG monitoring between January 1999 and April 2005 in our service. Discordant cases were defined by at least one seizure onset contralateral to the MRI evidence of MTS. Good surgical outcome was considered as Engel's class I. We also evaluated ictal SPECT concordance to ictal EEG and surgical outcome.

RESULTS

Fifty-four patients had concordant (C) and 22 had discordant (D) scalp EEG and MRI. Surgical outcome was similar in both groups (C = 74% versus D = 86%). Duration of follow-up was comparable in both groups: C = 56.1 +/- 20.7 months versus D = 59.8 +/- 21.2 months (p = 0.83, nonsignificant). Discordant single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) results did not influence surgical outcome.

DISCUSSION

Surgical outcome was not influenced by contralateral vEEG seizure onset or contralateral increased flow on ictal SPECT. Although vEEG monitoring should still be performed in these patients, to rule out psychogenic seizures and extratemporal seizure onset, a potentially risky procedure such as invasive monitoring may not only not be indicated in this patient population, but may also lead to patients erroneously being denied surgery.

Progress in predicting seizure episodes with nonlinear methods

One of the most interesting and significant areas of epileptology has been the prediction of the onset of a seizure episode from preictal activity with nonlinear methods. Not only does this type of study have heuristic value for clinical neurophysiology, but it also has potential utilitarian value for the patient with seizures. In this review, 47 reports from 12 centers with multiple studies are presented in chronological order, as are single reports from 21 other centers. The chronological order was chosen to see if progress in the form of earlier prediction was made over time. Only 21% of these reports could provide specific times for the prediction of seizure onset. The range of values was several minutes to 4 hours, with an average (median) of 6-7 minutes. Some reports (16%) had negative or nonspecific findings that prediction times could not be provided. Thus, only limited progress has been made in predicting a seizure from preictal activity, but many other related phenomena have also been studied with nonlinear methods with some success.

The source of afterdischarge activity in neocortical tonic-clonic epilepsy

Tonic-clonic seizures represent a common pattern of epileptic discharges, yet the relationship between the various phases of the seizure remains obscure. Here we contrast propagation of the ictal wavefront with the propagation of individual discharges in the clonic phase of the event. In an in vitro model of tonic-clonic epilepsy, the afterdischarges (clonic phase) propagate with relative uniform speed and are independent of the speed of the ictal wavefront (tonic phase). For slowly propagating ictal wavefronts, the source of the afterdischarges, relative to a given recording electrode, switched as the wavefront passed by, indicating that afterdischarges are seeded from wavefront itself. In tissue that has experienced repeated ictal events, the wavefront generalizes rapidly, and the afterdischarges in this case show a different "flip-flop" pattern, with frequent switches in their direction of propagation. This same flip-flop pattern is also seen in subdural EEG recordings in patients suffering intractable focal seizures caused by cortical dysplasias. Thus, in both slowly and rapidly generalizing ictal events, there is not a single source of afterdischarge activity: rather, the source is continuously changing. Our data suggest a complex view of seizures in which the ictal event and its constituent discharges originate from distinct locations.

Complete change of seizure and spike lateralization in temporal lobe epilepsy at two separate monitorings

OBJECTIVE

To report complete change of seizure and spike lateralization over time in bilateral temporal lobe epilepsies (TLE).

METHODS

Repetition of video-EEG monitorings in 115 patients; 2 cases are reported in detail; 113 other severe partial epilepsies were included to estimate retrospectively the frequency of the reported phenomenon.

RESULTS

In 2 cases, two video-EEG monitorings, separated by several months, revealed the first time one unilateral TL (temporal lobe) seizure and spike focus and the second time a distinct seizure and spike focus located in the opposite TL. The second monitoring was planned for these two patients because of the presence of a discordant lesion or, in the absence of a lesion, of some bilateral or discordant functional (EEG, SPECT and PET) abnormalities. No patient among the other 113 cases had this video-EEG pattern.

CONCLUSIONS

In TLE, two video-EEG sessions may be necessary to disclose two opposite TL epileptogenic foci.

SIGNIFICANCE

In rare bilateral TLE cases, the expression of seizure and spike foci can alternate between hemispheres.

Correlation of transcriptome profile with electrical activity in temporal lobe epilepsy

The biology underlying epileptic brain activity in humans is not well understood and likely depends on changes in gene expression. We performed a microarray transcriptome profiling of 12 anterolateral temporal cortical samples originating from five individuals who suffered with temporal lobe epilepsy for at least 10 years. Prior to partial lobectomy, intraoperative electrocorticography was performed on the cortical surface of each patient. These recordings showed characteristic differences in frequency and amplitude that were defined as "spiking" (abnormal) or "non-spiking" (normal). Between the transcriptome of the two sample groups, transferrin (TF) was the most differentially expressed gene. Furthermore, gene expression profiling also revealed a downregulation of multiple GABA system-related genes (GABRA5, GABRB3, ABAT) in the spiking samples and an upregulation of oligodendrocyte and lipid metabolism transcripts (MOG, CA2, CNP, SCD, PLP1, FA2H, ABCA2). In addition, several transcripts related to the classical MAPK cascade showed expression level alterations between the spiking and non-spiking samples (G3BP2, MAPK1, PRKAR1A, and MAP4K4). Out of 12 genes chosen for verification by RT qPCR, 9 showed significant expression changes in the microarray-predicted direction. Furthermore, the microarray and qPCR data were highly correlated (r = 0.98; P < 0.001). We conclude that abnormal electrical brain activity in the spiking samples is strongly correlated with gene expression changes and we speculate that some of the observed transcriptome changes may be directly involved in the induction or prevention of the ictal events seen in epilepsy.

Vagus nerve stimulation: predictors of seizure freedom

OBJECTIVES

To identify predictive factors for the seizure-free outcome of vagus nerve stimulation (VNS).

METHODS

All 47 patients who had undergone VNS implantation at one centre and had at least one year of follow up were studied. They underwent complete presurgical evaluation including detailed clinical history, magnetic resonance imaging, and long term video-EEG with ictal and interictal recordings. After implantation, adjustment of stimulation parameters and concomitant antiepileptic drugs were at the discretion of the treating physician.

RESULTS

Mean (SD) age of the patients was 22.7 (11.6) years (range 7 to 53). Six patients (13%) became seizure-free after the VNS implantation. Only two variables showed a significant association with the seizure-free outcome: absence of bilateral interictal epileptiform discharges (IED) and presence of malformation of cortical development (MCD). Epilepsy duration showed a non-significant trend towards a negative association with outcome. By logistic regression analysis, only absence of bilateral IED correlated independently with successful VNS treatment (p<0.01, odds ratio = 29.2 (95% confidence interval, 2.4 to 353)). Bilateral IED (independent or bilateral synchronous) was found in one of six seizure-free patients and in 33 of 41 non-seizure-free patients. When bilateral IED were absent, the sensitivity for seizure-free outcome was 0.83 (0.44 to 0.97), and the specificity was 0.80 (0.66 to 0.90).

CONCLUSIONS

Bilateral IED was independently associated with the outcome of VNS. These results are preliminary because they were based on a small patient population. They may facilitate prospective VNS studies enrolling larger numbers of patients to confirm the results.

Analysis of electrical discharges made with the foramen ovale electrode recording technique in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy patients

Foramen ovale electrode (FOE) implantation is usually indicated in patients with mesial temporal lobe (MTL) epilepsy. The authors conducted this study to characterize the electrical discharge patterns obtained using FOE recording and evaluated their clinical significance. Interictal and ictal discharge patterns and their temporal relationships to EEGs were examined in 16 patients who had FOEs implanted bilaterally and had good recovery from surgery. After long-term telemetry recording with FOEs, all patients displayed clear seizure onsets originating in one or both sides of the MTL and underwent an anterior temporal lobectomy. Interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs) were lateralized to the operated side in 12 patients based on scalp EEGs and in 8 patients based on FOE recordings. Among the various possible IED patterns observed with the FOE recordings, a periodic pattern was dominant in the operated side (P = 0.001), whereas a polyspike pattern was dominant in the nonoperated side (P = 0.002). The number of patients with ictal onsets in the operated side was five based on the scalp EEG and 10 based on FOE recordings. Paroxysmal fast frequency activity, rhythmic spikes (>2 Hz), or sharp waves were dominant over other FOE seizure onset patterns in the operated side. By contrast, delta and theta slowing and positive spikes were prevalent in the nonoperated side. The start-stop-start pattern, previously described using subdural electrodes, was also found in FOE recordings and was concordant with the operated side in all cases. The interhemispheric propagation time recorded with bilateral FOEs was 22.6 +/- 20.0 seconds for ictal discharges initiated in the operated side and 7.0 +/- 8.4 seconds for those in the nonoperated side. Among various IED spreading patterns, the most prevalent progression was FOE --> contralateral FOE --> ipsilateral temporal lobe, or --> contralateral temporal lobe. In this series, FOE implantation caused no serious complications. FOE recording appears to be useful for confirming lateralization in patients with MTL epilepsy previously determined using clinical and neuroimaging methods. A thorough analysis of FOE recordings can provide information that may facilitate the differentiation of primary from secondary (nonepileptogenic) temporal lobes.

A review of neurophysiological testing

The rapid advances in the technology of, and accumulation of pertinent data in, electrophysiological testing has increased exponentially in the past decade. This is attributable to continued advances in computer technology, biomedical engineering, and now the coregistration of the electrophysiological data with neuroimaging results. Knowledge of normal function and electrophysiological response at rest or on stimulation of the central and peripheral nervous systems is important to the neurosurgeon. Only by a basic understanding of normal and abnormal recordings may diagnoses and localizations be achieved. Intraspinal and intracranial surgical procedures are predicated on nontrauma to the neuraxis. This can be accomplished by performing electrophysiological testing to monitor the function of the spinal and cranial nerves, spinal cord, brainstem, basal ganglia, and cerebrum. If the surgeon cannot delineate critical cortex or pathways, he or she will be unable to avoid these areas in the patient.

Wada memory performance predicts seizure outcome after epilepsy surgery in children

PURPOSE

Wada memory asymmetries were examined in children from four comprehensive epilepsy surgery centers who subsequently underwent epilepsy surgery to determine whether Wada memory performance could predict degree of seizure relief in children.

METHODS

One hundred fifty-six children (between ages 5 and 16 years) with intractable epilepsy underwent Wada testing before resective epilepsy surgery (93 within the left hemisphere, and 63 within the right hemisphere). Memory stimuli were presented soon after intracarotid amobarbital injection, and recognition memory for the items was assessed after return to neurologic baseline. Eighty-eight children underwent unilateral temporal lobe resection, and 68 had extratemporal lobe resections. One hundred four (67%) children were seizure free (Engel class I), and 52 (33%) were not seizure free (Engel classes II-IV) at follow-up (mean follow-up interval, 2.3 years).

RESULTS

Seizure-free children recalled 19.3% more Wada memory items after ipsilateral injection than did non-seizure-free children (p = 0.008). If analysis was restricted to youngsters with temporal lobectomies (TLs), seizure-free children recalled 27.7% more items after ipsilateral injection than did non-seizure-free TL children (p = 0.004). With regard to individual patient prediction, 75% of children who had memory score asymmetries consistent with the seizure focus were seizure free. In contrast, only 56% of children whose memory score asymmetries were inconsistent with the seizure focus were seizure free (p = 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Results suggest that Wada memory performance asymmetries are related to the degree of seizure relief after epilepsy surgery in children and adolescents.

Magnetoencephalographic yield of interictal spikes in temporal lobe epilepsy. Comparison with scalp EEG recordings

To compare magnetoencephalography (MEG) with scalp electroencephalography (EEG) in the detection of interictal spikes in temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), we simultaneously recorded MEG and scalp EEG with a whole-scalp neuromagnetometer in 46 TLE patients. We visually searched interictal spikes on MEG and EEG channels and classified them into three types according to their presentation on MEG alone (M-spikes), EEG alone (E-spikes), or concomitantly on both modalities (M/E-spikes). The M-spikes and M/E-spikes were localized with MEG equivalent current dipole modeling. We analyzed the relative contribution of MEG and EEG in the overall yield of spike detection and also compared M-spikes with M/E-spikes in terms of dipole locations and strengths. During the 30- to 40-min MEG recordings, interictal spikes were obtained in 36 (78.3%) of the 46 patients. Among the 36 patients, most spikes were M/E-spikes (68.3%), some were M-spikes (22.1%), and some were E-spikes (9.7%). In comparison with EEG, MEG gave better spike yield in patients with lateral TLE. Sources of M/E- and M-spikes were situated in the same anatomical regions, whereas the average dipole strength was larger for M/E- than M-spikes. In conclusion, some interictal spikes appeared selectively on either MEG or EEG channels in TLE patients although more spikes were simultaneously identified on both modalities. Thus, simultaneous MEG and EEG recordings help to enhance spike detection. Identification of M-spikes would offer important localization of irritative foci, especially in patients with lateral TLE.

Prognostic value of concordant seizure focus localizing data in the selection of temporal lobectomy candidates

This study was performed to test the hypotheses that (a) resection of the temporal lobe epileptic focus, amenable to noninvasive as opposed to invasive localization, is associated with superior seizure outcome and (b) that quadruple (versus lesser degrees of) concordance of seizure focus localizing data predicts superior seizure-free outcome. Eighty-three patients underwent invasive (subdural-EEG) and/or noninvasive (video/scalp-EEG, SPECT, PET, MRI, neuropsychological testing) evaluation. All patients underwent anterior temporal lobectomy and amygdalohippocampectomy (ATL/AH) and seizure outcome was assessed at minimum one-year follow-up. At 34.8 +/- 2.5 months following ATL/AH, outcome was superior for patients in whom the seizure focus was amenable to noninvasive compared to invasive localization (80% versus 40% seizure-free, X2 = 14.03, p < 0.05). Seizure outcome was superior for patients with quadruple, compared to all lesser degrees of, concordance of seizure focus localizing data (85% versus 51% seizure-free, X2 = 7.34, p < 0.05). Post-ATL/AH, seizure outcome is superior in patients (1) harboring an epileptic focus amenable to noninvasive localization and (2) with quadruple concordance of seizure focus localizing data. These findings support the development of temporal lobectomy selection criteria including up to four invasive and/or noninvasive concordant seizure focus localizing techniques.

Lateralization of temporal lobe foci: depth versus subdural electrodes

OBJECTIVES

Definitive localization of an epileptic focus correlates with a favorable outcome following epilepsy surgery. This study was undertaken to determine the incremental value of data yielded for surgical decision making when using subdural electrodes alone and in addition to depth electrodes for temporal lobe epilepsy.

METHODS

Standardized placement for intracranial electrodes included: (1) longitudinal placement of bilateral temporal lobe depth electrodes; (2) bilateral subtemporal subdural strips; and (3) bilateral orbitofrontal subdural strips. Sixty-three events were randomly reviewed for: (1) subdural electrodes alone; and (2) depth electrodes in conjunction with subdural electrodes.

RESULTS

Of the 63 seizures, 54 (85.7%) demonstrated congruent lateralization to ipsilateral subtemporal subdural strip electrodes (based on depth electrode localization) when subdural strip electrodes were utilized alone. In 3 of 22 patients, 7 seizures demonstrated 'false localization' on subdural electrode analysis alone when compared with depth recording and post-surgical outcome. For these 3 patients, retrospective review of neuroimaging demonstrated suboptimal ipsilateral placement of subtemporal subdural electrodes with the most mesial electrode lateral to the collateral sulcus. Four additional patients had suboptimal placement of subtemporal subdural electrodes. Two of these 4 patients had congruent localization with subdural electrodes to ipsilateral depth electrodes despite suboptimal placement. Subtemporal subdural electrodes accurately localized for all seizures from the mesial temporal lobe when the mesial electrodes of the subtemporal subdural strip recorded mesial to the collateral sulcus from the parahippocampal region.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that although there are high concordance rates between subdural and depth electrodes, localization of seizure onset based on subdural strip electrodes alone may result in inaccurate focus identification with potential for possible suboptimal treatment of temporal lobe epilepsy. When subtemporal subdural electrodes provide recording from the parahippocampal region, there is accurate localization of the seizure focus. If suboptimal placement occurs lateral to the collateral sulcus, the electroencephalographer cannot make a definitive identification of the seizure focus.

Interictal spikes in focal epileptogenesis

Interictal electroencephalography (EEG) potentials in focal epilepsies are sustained by synchronous paroxysmal membrane depolarization generated by assemblies of hyperexcitable neurons. It is currently believed that interictal spiking sets a condition that preludes to the onset of an ictal discharge. Such an assumption is based on little experimental evidence. Human pre-surgical studies and recordings in chronic and acute models of focal epilepsy showed that: (i) interictal spikes (IS) and ictal discharges are generated by different populations of neuron through different cellular and network mechanisms; (ii) the cortical region that generates IS (irritative area) does not coincide with the ictal-onset area; (iii) IS frequency does not increase before a seizure and is enhanced just after an ictal event; (iv) spike suppression is found to herald ictal discharges; and (v) enhancement of interictal spiking suppresses ictal events. Several experimental evidences indicate that the highly synchronous cellular discharge associated with an IS is generated by a multitude of mechanisms involving synaptic and non-synaptic communication between neurons. The synchronized neuronal discharge associated with a single IS induces and is followed by a profound and prolonged refractory period sustained by inhibitory potentials and by activity-dependent changes in the ionic composition of the extracellular space. Post-spike depression may be responsible for pacing interictal spiking periodicity commonly observed in both animal models and human focal epilepsies. It is proposed that the strong after-inhibition produced by IS protects against the occurrence of ictal discharges by maintaining a low level of excitation in a general condition of hyperexcitability determined by the primary epileptogenic dysfunction.

Neural network analysis of preoperative variables and outcome in epilepsy surgery

OBJECT

Because appropriate patient selection is essential for achieving successful outcomes after epilepsy surgery, the need for more robust methods of predicting postoperative seizure control has been created. Standard multivariate techniques have been only 75 to 80% accurate in this regard. Recent use of artificial intelligence techniques, including neural networks, for analyzing multivariate clinical data has been successful in predicting medical outcome.

METHODS

The authors applied neural network techniques to 80 consecutive patients undergoing epilepsy surgery in whom data on demographic, seizure, operative, and clinical variables to predict postoperative seizures were collected. Neural networks could be used to predict postoperative seizures in up to 98% of cases. Student's t-tests or chi-square analysis performed on individual variables revealed that only the preoperative medication index was significantly different (p = 0.02) between the two outcome groups. Six different combinations of input variables were used to train the networks. Neural network accuracies differed in their ability to predict seizures: using all data (96%); all data minus electroencephalography concordance and operative side (93%); all data except intra- or postoperative variables such as tissue pathological category (98%); all data excluding pathological category, intelligence quotient (IQ) data, and Wada results (84%); only demographics and tissue pathological category (65%); and only IQ data (63%).

CONCLUSIONS

Analysis of the results reveals that several networks that are trained with the usual accepted variables characterizing the typical evaluation of epilepsy patients can predict postoperative seizures with greater than 95% accuracy.

Prognostic factors in presurgical assessment of frontal lobe epilepsy

OBJECTIVES

To determine predictors for surgical outcome in the presurgical assessment of frontal lobe epilepsy.

METHODS

Thirty seven patients were operated on for frontal lobe epilepsy between 1975 and 1996. Their medical records were reviewed for ictal semiology, age at onset, duration of the epilepsy, age at operation, preoperative interictal and ictal encephalographic findings, and abnormalities on neuroimaging and neuropsychological testing. In addition, type of resection and pathology were compared with surgical outcome.

RESULTS

Univariate statistical analysis showed that the presence of a focal abnormality on neuroimaging was associated with favourable outcome. The presence of the following ictal findings was associated with poor outcome: autonomic manifestations, eye deviation, head version contralateral to the operated side, and bilateral or multifocal ictal onset. Fifteen patients had secondarily generalised interictal discharges and, interestingly, their presence was not associated with poor outcome. Multivariate logistic regression showed that the presence of a focal abnormality on neuroimaging was significantly associated with a favourable outcome while contralateral head version was the only variable significantly associated with poor surgical outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

A focal abnormality on neuroimaging was the only variable which was significantly associated with a favourable surgical outcome, whereas contralateral head version was the most significant predictor for a poor outcome. The presence of generalised discharges before surgery was not associated with poor outcome.

Outcome after temporal lobectomy in bilateral temporal lobe epilepsy

We determined how noninvasive presurgical data relate to prognosis after temporal lobectomy in patients with independent bilateral temporal lobe (IBTL) complex partial seizures on the intracranial electroencephalogram (EEG). Between 1986 and 1994, 28 patients had IBTL seizures on intracranial EEG. Fifteen of these 28 patients underwent temporal lobectomy and 13 were not offered surgery. Of the 15 patients who had surgery, 10 patients became seizure-free. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and the Wada test were the only variables associated with a seizure-free outcome. Seven of 10 seizure-free patients had a lateralized Wada result or the presence of unilateral hippocampal sclerosis, whereas none of the patients with persistent seizures had either of these findings. Variables not found to be predictive of a seizure-free outcome included location of scalp interictal spikes, degree of seizure-onset laterality, presence of early epilepsy risk factor, duration of epilepsy, and full-scale intelligence quotient. We conclude that MRI and the Wada test provide information of prognostic value in patients with bilateral temporal seizures independent of intracranial EEG data.

Altered seizure patterns after temporal lobectomy

PURPOSE

We compared features of seizures occurring after temporal lobectomy with those of preoperative seizures in the same patients to determine whether aspects of postoperative partial seizures presage ultimate seizure control.

METHODS

Seizure descriptions of 100 consecutive patients who underwent anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) were obtained by our epileptologists before and after surgery. Follow-up for seizure control for all patients was obtained for a median of 5.5 years.

RESULTS

Twenty-six of the 100 patients had at least one diurnal complex partial seizure (CPS) after lobectomy. The proportion of patients with an aura for their CPS decreased from 86% preoperatively to 58% postoperatively. Fifty-five percent had two or more aura features before surgery, as compared with 31% after lobectomy. Eleven of 18 (61%) with fewer than two postoperative aura features, as compared with 2 of 8 (25%) with two or more aura features ultimately had >90% seizure reduction postoperatively. Nineteen (95%) of 20 patients with only simple partial seizures (SPS) postoperatively ultimately obtained > or =90% reduction, and 7 (35%) of them became seizure-free. Although generalized tonic-clonic seizures (GTCS) decreased from 70% to 39% after lobectomy, 7 (23%) of 30 patients who had not had GTCS preoperatively had at least one after lobectomy, usually while receiving a lesser amount of antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy. Among the 27 patients with residual CPS, ultimate outcome was better among patients with removal of >6 cm as measured along the inferior temporal gyrus than among those with less extensive resections.

CONCLUSIONS

In addition to eliminating or reducing the frequency of temporal lobe seizures, lobectomy may simplify or eliminate the aura features of residual CPS. The number of CPS aura features correlated inversely with ultimate postoperative seizure reduction. Ultimate seizure control among patients with only SPS was better than that of patients with CPS postoperatively. First-ever GTCS may occur when AED dosages are reduced after surgery.

Non-invasive investigations successfully select patients for temporal lobe surgery

OBJECTIVES

There is controversy regarding the need for invasive monitoring in the preoperative assessment of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. The use of a series of non-invasive investigations in identifying the seizure focus is reported in 75 consecutive adults referred for epilepsy surgery.

METHODS

All had video-EEG monitoring using scalp electrodes, high resolution MRI, and neuropsychology assessment. Other investigations included volumetric MRI, PET, and ictal and interictal SPECT. The seizure focus was localised and surgery offered if MRI disclosed unilateral hippocampal atrophy or a foreign tissue lesion and other investigations were either concordant or not discordant.

RESULTS

In 68 patients the seizure focus was localised and three patients were inoperable. Sixty five patients have been offered surgery and 50 have undergone temporal lobe surgery and have a follow up of at least 12 months (mean 24 months). All had pathology: hippocampal sclerosis 34, dysembryoblastic neuroepithelial tumour six, cavernoma four, dysplasia two, low grade glioma two, ganglioglioma two. Thirty nine patients (78%) are seizure free postoperatively, 29/34 with hippocampal sclerosis and 10/16 with a foreign tissue lesion. Of the 11 patients with postoperative recurrent seizures, eight have a >90% reduction in seizure frequency and three have <90% reduction in seizure frequency but a worthwhile improvement.

CONCLUSIONS

Non-invasive investigations successfully select most patients for temporal lobe surgery.

Mesial temporal versus lateral temporal interictal epileptiform activity: comparison of chronic and acute intracranial recordings

Intracranial interictal epileptiform activity (EA) was recorded by chronic stereotactic depth electroencephalography (SDEEG) and acute electrocorticography (ECOG) in 22 patients with complex partial seizures of temporal lobe origin. Chronic SDEEG recordings defined two groups of patients with respect to the presence or absence of lateral temporal EA; 13 patients showed independent lateral temporal EA during chronic recordings and 9 patients did not. All patients had EA recorded from mesial temporal structures during SDEEG. The presence of lateral temporal EA was correlated with a higher pre-operative seizure frequency but not with ictal onset zones, structural pathology, age at onset of epilepsy, or duration of epilepsy. Results of acute ECOG recordings performed on the same patients 1-24 months after SDEEG accurately reproduced the mesial versus lateral distribution of EA within patients (P < 0.0003). Though ECOG was less sensitive than SDEEG in demonstrating EA confined to mesial structures, positive findings at ECOG were 100% specific with respect to SDEEG. These results suggest that, at least with respect to mesial temporal versus lateral temporal structures, there is a constancy within patients in the distribution of interictal EA recorded with chronic intracranial electrodes. In addition, acute ECOG provides an accurate representation of individual patients' interictal EA.

Preoperative clinical, EEG, and imaging findings do not predict seizure outcome following temporal lobectomy in childhood

Although certain clinical, electroencephalographic (EEG), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and pathologic findings in adults with intractable temporal lobe epilepsy predict seizure outcome following temporal lobectomy, predictors of seizure outcome have not been studied systematically in pediatric temporal lobectomy series. We retrospectively analyzed preoperative clinical, EEG, and neuroimaging findings with reference to seizure outcome (seizure free or non-seizure free) in 33 children (mean age, 9.3 years) who underwent tailored temporal lobe resections for intractable temporal lobe epilepsy. Trends were apparent with (1) younger age at seizure onset, younger age at surgery, shorter duration of epilepsy, localized unilateral temporal lesions on MRI, and right-sided surgery more frequently associated with a seizure-free outcome, and (2) significant prior history, daily preoperative seizures, generalized motor seizures, mental retardation, and localized unilateral temporal epileptiform EEG activity more frequently associated with a non-seizure-free outcome. However, none of these findings, alone or in combination, correlated with postoperative seizure status at a statistically significant level. Submitting the four variables generally considered to be most predictive of favorable outcome (ie, normal intelligence, unilateral ictal and interictal EEG discharges, and focal temporal MRI lesion) to a multiple-cutoff procedure did not predict seizure freedom. Our data indicate that predictors of outcome of temporal lobectomy in adults may not apply in children, perhaps due to inherent neurobiologic differences in the etiology and expression of temporal lobe epilepsy, and should therefore not be used as sole determinants of surgical candidacy in children.

The imaging of epilepsy

Based on the experience of a university neurological epilepsy center, the neurological classification and the gradation of neurological evaluation of patients with epilepsy are described. Into this the nature and the significance of the imaging of the brain are interwoven. The object, illustrated by several illustrative patients, is to stress the importance of the MRI and to note that based on the MRI findings and the clinical findings, the battery of sophisticated electroencephalographic evaluation is determined. Epilepsy is an area where imaging and all aspects of the clinical neurological evaluation integrate very well and in which correlation is most important.

Significance of spikes at temporal lobe electrocorticography

Among 87 consecutive patients operated on under local anesthesia, few aspects of pre- and posttemporal lobe resection electrocorticograms (ECoG) yielded prognostic data. Preresection spikes were most common in the hippocampus, followed in order of frequency by the anterior temporal convexity and the inferior temporal surface. Moderately frequent (>10 spikes/100 s) preresection spikes appeared beyond the subsequent resection line in the posterior temporal region in 16 of 87 (18%) and in orbital frontal cortex in 12 of 87 (14%). Although many hippocampus spikes portended a favorable outcome and rare spikes an unfavorable one, preresection spike quantity otherwise failed to distinguish outcome groups. Absolute quantity of postresection spikes and change from preresectrion quantity in any region did not correlate with outcome except for the insula, where relatively abundant spikes portended favorable outcomes. Postresection electrographic seizures were rare but occurred equally in all outcome groups. No significant change in spike incidence occurred between the first and last 10-min epoch of the 30-min postresection recording.

Preoperative EEG predicts memory and selective cognitive functions after temporal lobe surgery

Preoperative and postoperative cognitive and memory functions, psychiatric outcome, and EEGs were evaluated in 32 epileptic patients who underwent temporal lobe surgery. The presence and location of preoperative slow wave focus in routine EEG predicted memory functions of the non-resected side after surgery. Neuropsychological tests of the function of the frontal lobes also showed improvement. Moreover, psychiatric ratings showed that seizure free patients had significantly less affective symptoms postoperatively than those who were still exhibiting seizures. After temporal lobectomies, successful outcome in postoperative memory functions can be achieved in patients with unilateral slow wave activity in preoperative EEGs. This study suggests a new role for routine EEG in preoperative evaluation of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy.

The clinical and prognostic relevance of the postictal slow focus in the electrocorticogram

Electrocorticograms of 192 complex partial seizures which were recorded via chronically implanted subdural electrodes during presurgical evaluation of 64 patients with medically intractable epilepsy were visually analysed. The objective was to assess the diagnostic and prognostic relevance of postictal slow foci (PISF) in the electrocorticogram which were defined as focal isoelectric activity or as a focal burst-suppression pattern. The following results were obtained: (1) PISF were seen in a total of 114 of 192 seizures (59.4%), (2) 48 of 64 patients (75%) demonstrated at least 1 PISF in 3 seizures, (3) PISF were more frequent in seizures of temporal lobe origin (66%) than in those of extratemporal origin (33.3%), (4) no PISF developed if the electrographic seizure duration was < 32 sec, (5) PISF were (predominantly) localized in the lobe of seizure origin in 85% of the seizures, (6) there was a strong correlation between frequent occurrence of temporal PISF and favourable seizure outcome following temporal lobe surgery. In conclusion, PISF contribute valuable data as to the localization of the epileptogenic zone during presurgical evaluation of epilepsy and indicate favourable seizure outcome following temporal lobe surgery.

Postoperative EEG and electrocorticography: relation to clinical outcome in patients with temporal lobe surgery

To evaluate the role of different EEG methods with respect to postoperative clinical follow-up, 32 non-lesionary epilepsy patients who had undergone temporal lobectomy were studied preoperatively and at 2-week, 3-month, and 1-year postoperative follow-up. Routine, sleep, and sphenoidal EEG recordings as well as intraoperative electrocorticography (ECoG) were made for all patients. At 1-year follow-up, the EEGs with sphenoidal electrodes and with sleep deprivation procedure provided important prognostic information; the appearance of seizures was associated with the presence of interictal epileptiform abnormalities in EEG. In the postresection ECoG, however, epileptiform abnormalities were not associated with clinical outcome or with postoperative epileptiform EEG at 1 year. Routine EEG reliably reflects clinical outcome after temporal lobectomy; with sphenoidal electrodes as well as with sleep deprivation procedure, the diagnostic yield can be further improved.

Prognostic significance of ictal and interictal epileptiform activity in temporal lobe epilepsy

Long-term electrocorticograms (ECoG), recorded by chronically implanted subdural electrodes during preoperative evaluation of 59 patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) were analyzed retrospectively to assess the prognostic relevance of distribution of interictal epileptiform potentials (IEP) and seizure origin (SO) and to investigate factors affecting their lateralization. Subsequent to preoperative evaluation, a standardized two thirds anterotemporal lobectomy including subtotal hippocampectomy had been performed in all patients. The following results were obtained: (a) Only patients with 100% lateralization of SO and IEP had excellent seizure outcome (= 89% seizure-free); (b) patients with bitemporal SO were unlikely to benefit from surgical treatment (= 12.5% seizure-free); (c) 40-56% patients with unilateral temporal SO and bitemporal IEP, became seizure-free irrespective of the degree of lateralization of IEP; and (d) multidimensional analysis of variance showed that lateralization of SO, presence of a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-detectable lesion, presence of hippocampal sclerosis, presence of febrile seizures and seizures at age < or = 6 years are the five most important variables indicating abolition of seizures. Combined analysis of ECoG-recorded SO and IEP allows prediction of postoperative seizure control within close boundaries.

Temporal and spatial characteristics of intracerebral seizure propagation: predictive value in surgery for temporal lobe epilepsy

We examined the prognostic value of spatial and temporal characteristics of intracerebral propagation of seizures during temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) surgery. Seven TLE patients resistant to standard anterotemporal lobectomy who had no known causes of resistance [e.g., extratemporal (ET), lesions, multifocal epilepsy] were matched with 7 seizure-free patients and 7 others who were almost seizure-free after operation. Intracerebral ictal propagation pathways were not different in the three groups. Propagation was multidirectional, most frequently to the frontal lobes and sometimes to the contralateral temporal lobe (CTL). ET propagation delays were significantly shorter in resistant patients than in markedly improved patients. The resistant group also had more frequent propagation delays < 1.0 s, but propagation times > 1.0 s were equally likely in all groups. The extent of ET propagation and frequency of focal onsets were not different among the groups. Results suggest that very short propagation times predict reduced efficacy of operation, and that long propagation times are not related to surgical success.

Comparisons of MEG, EEG, and ECoG source localization in neocortical partial epilepsy in humans

In order to delineate the characteristics of epileptic spikes, 1946 different spikes were studied in 6 patients with complex partial epilepsy. Non-invasive MEG and EEG source analysis of interictal spikes were contrasted to ECoG localization, surgical outcome and presence of lesions on MRI. Results indicated that: (1) using the most frequent occurring spike topography patterns from a large sample of spikes improved goodness-of-fit values for both MEG and EEG localization, (2) when spike patterns could be appropriately matched on several successive MEG measurements to provide an adequate matrix (3 of 6 subjects), there was excellent agreement between MEG dipole sources and ECoG sources as well as surgical outcome and presence of MRI lesions, (3) EEG source analyses also gave good results but not as consistently as MEG.

Predictive factors for success in surgical treatment for partial epilepsy: a multivariate analysis

We conducted a longitudinal self-controlled study of 131 patients aged 4-60 treated with resective surgery for medically uncontrolled partial epilepsy from 1949 to 1988. Using multivariate logistic regression, we showed that pre- and perioperative variables can be used to predict "success" or "failure" of surgical resective treatment in approximately 79% of cases. If the predicted probability is > 0.75 or < 0.25, the model predicts a correct result in 87% of cases. Eight predictive factors emerged with a backward multivariate logistic regression model with the likelihood-ratio (LR) test to exclude variables from the equation: (a) the influence of the surgical team and surgical procedure, (b) the presence of paresis preoperatively, (c) duration of disease, (d) age at treatment, (e) positive neuroradiologic findings in preoperative investigations, (f) preoperative complex partial seizures (CPS), (g) nonepileptic EEG abnormalities, and (h) generalized spike activity in EEG preoperatively. Sex, age at first seizure, area of resection, presence of simple or generalized seizures preoperatively, preoperative seizure frequency, tissue pathology, use of computed tomography/nuclear magnetic resonance (CT/NMR) in preoperative investigations, degree of preoperative neurologic deficit, perioperative electrocorticographic results, and bilateral EEG spikes did not have predictive value in the model.

Epilepsy surgery: non-invasive versus invasive focus localization. What is needed from the neurosurgical point of view

This paper discusses the place of non-invasive and invasive methods of investigation in the selection of patients for temporal lobe resection. Two series from the same department are compared and the relationship of the outcome to pathology is also discussed.

Resection surgery for partial epilepsy. Relation of surgical outcome with some aspects of the epileptogenic process and surgical approach

In spite of the progressive improvement of the results of resective surgery for epilepsy, the number of not significantly benefited patients remains high. An attempt was made to find out a relation between outcome and some aspects of the pathophysiological organization of the epileptogenic process and of the surgical procedure. Chi-square and logistic regression statistic analyses were utilized. The study was retrospectively performed on 138 surgically treated patients having a minimum follow-up of three years. Three classes of surgical outcome were considered: completely seizure free (including aura; 86 cases, 62.3%), significant seizure reduction (31 cases, 22.5%), and no significant improvement (21 cases, 15.2%). What follows was brought into evidence by the study. 1) On the diagnostic side, the spatial arrangement (focal, unilateral, multifocal) of both the interictal and the ictal epileptic electrocerebral activities are significantly associated with the surgical outcome. Their relative impact on outcome is related to the presence of a structural lesion: when a lesion is documented, the interictal activity has the higher value: vice versa, when no lesion is apparent, the role of the ictal activity is prevalent. However, the presence, as well as the nature of the lesion, per se, are not significantly associated with outcome. 2) On the surgical side, the extent of resection of both the structural lesion and of the epileptogenic zone are highly associated with the surgical result; the extent of lesion resection prevails on that of the epileptogenic zone. The type of surgical approach (hemispherectomy: 17 cases; temporal lobectomy: 67 cases; extratemporal resection: 54 cases) has no significant relation to the outcome. The value and the limits of the results obtained are discussed.

Utility of stereoelectroencephalography in preoperative assessment of temporal lobe epilepsy

Of 269 consecutive patients entered into a preoperative assessment programme for possible surgical treatment of epilepsy, 33 had intracranial recording (SEEG) with combined subdural and depth electrodes for the purpose of localising a suspected temporal site of seizure onset. The findings in these patients are analysed with particular reference to: 1) the criteria of selection for SEEG and their validity; 2) information on SEEG compared with that obtained by less invasive means, including foramen ovale telemetry; 3) information on the use of intracerebral electrodes compared with subdural placements; 4) possible predictors of failure of localisation by SEEG and of surgical outcome. It was concluded that SEEG had usefully contributed to the management of 69% of the patients in whom it was used, establishing a previously unidentified site of seizure onset in 33%, correcting an erroneous localisation in 15%, and establishing inoperability in 21% of patients. No predictors of failure of SEEG or of surgery emerged; thus there was no evidence of unnecessary use of this procedure. Five patients were found with incorrect lateralisation of seizure onset on foramen ovale recording (of a total of 192 foramen ovale telemetries). Localisation of the ictal onset zone either by the distribution of inter-ictal discharges or by the initial ictal changes at subdural electrodes was unreliable, confirming the need for ictal, depth recordings.

Lumbar cerebral spinal fluid drainage during long-term electrocorticographic monitoring with subdural strip electrodes: elimination of cerebral spinal fluid leak

We performed this study to determine the efficacy of continuous lumbar cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) drainage in controlling CSF leak during subdural strip electrode monitoring of epilepsy patients. Subdural strip electrodes were placed in 14 patients. In seven patients, a lumbar sub-arachnoid catheter was placed for continuous CSF drainage. In seven patients, no lumbar drain was placed. The duration of scalp CSF leak during strip electrode monitoring was significantly reduced in patients undergoing lumbar CSF drainage compared to those without lumbar drains (chi 2 = 40.9, P < 0.05). In one patient spinal headache developed which resolved with lumbar drain removal. Lumbar drainage eliminates scalp CSF leakage and can improve patient comfort. This technique should be further studied to determine if it reduces infection risk during long-term invasive monitoring.

Temporal lobectomy for uncontrolled seizures: the role of positron emission tomography

We evaluated the role of positron emission tomography (PET) with [18F]deoxyglucose (FDG) (FDG-PET) for planning surgery in 53 patients who had temporal lobectomy for uncontrolled seizures at National Institutes of Health from 1981 to 1990. Investigators blinded to PET data used results of telemetered video-electroencephalographic ictal monitoring and other standard criteria to decide whether subdural electrodes (22 patients, i.e., the "invasive" group) should be implanted or surgery performed. PET scans were analyzed using a standard regional template. Mean lateral but not mesial temporal asymmetry was significantly higher in patients who became seizure free (p < 0.03). Patients with > or = 15% hypometabolism were significantly more likely to be seizure free in the entire study population and the invasive subgroup. Visual identification of hypometabolism was less accurate. When a clear temporal ictal surface electroencephalographic focus was present, FDG-PET provided less additional information. FDG-PET may be particularly valuable if the surface electroencephalographic scan is nonlocalizing. In addition to helping to identify the seizure focus, it may allow limitation of invasive electrode placement to those necessary for functional mapping. When PET is used to identify epileptic foci, quantitative measurements of asymmetry should be made.

Ictal EEG wave forms from epidural electrodes predictive of seizure control after temporal lobectomy

Ictal wave form characteristics--frequency, spatial distribution, and duration--were analyzed for 140 complex partial seizures recorded from epidural strip electrodes implanted in 28 patients. None had abnormalities on imaging studies. All had bilateral electrode placements, unilateral seizure onsets, temporal lobectomies, and were followed for a mean of 33 months postoperatively. Sixteen patients (57%) became free of complex partial seizures: 12 had reductions in seizure frequency of at least 50% but were not seizure-free. The only predictor of the seizure-free state was the presence of low voltage fast activity (LVF), in the alpha or beta ranges, localized to one gyrus. This phenomenon occurred in 14/16 seizure-free patients, 2/12 of others (P < 0.001). As seizures progressed, LVF typically increased in amplitude, propagated, and slowed into the theta range. Wave forms were classified into 8 categories based upon their frequency and morphology. Stepwise discriminant analysis of these wave forms, with consideration of whether they were localized or regional, revealed that both frequency and localization were critical for the post-surgical prognosis. The mere presence of a localized seizure onset was unreliable unless the wave form was taken into account. Well-localized rhythmic activity over 8 Hz at seizure onset from epidural subtemporal electrodes predicts surgical success. Slower rhythms imply greater separation in space and time from seizure onset.

A longitudinal assessment of seizure outcome and overall benefit from 100 cortectomies for epilepsy

Results of 100 cortical resections for 76 temporal, 23 frontal and one parietal lobe epilepsies were studied in terms of seizure relief and overall benefit. A non-homogenous Markov chain model was used to take into account both the intravariability of post-surgical outcome and the differences in duration of follow-up in a group of patients consecutively operated. The seizure free (SF) state was defined as no seizure in the previous five months at first follow up visit and none in the preceding 12 months at subsequent annual visits. For the whole of the population the SF probability was 82%, 66%, 61%, and 62% at six months, one year, two and five years respectively. A better outcome was found for temporal lobe epilepsy (SF probability: 68% at the fifth postoperative year) than for frontal lobe epilepsy (SF probability: 42% at the fifth postoperative year) with a statistically significant difference. Pre- and postoperative interictal signs and symptoms were classified according to their clinical significance: (a) mild handicap--symptoms recognisable but no interference with usual life, and (b) moderate or severe handicap--interference with some or all daily activities. The interictal state was considered more impaired after surgery than before in two situations: (a) either symptoms, absent before surgery, appeared in the postoperative period involving a moderate or severe handicap, or (b) symptoms present before surgery and answerable for a mild or moderate handicap that increased to involve a moderate or severe handicap respectively in the postoperative period. Surgery was considered a major benefit when two conditions were fulfilled-namely, a SF state and no deterioration of the interictal stage when compared with the preoperative period. The probability of obtaining such a benefit was 58%, 51%, 48% and 56% at six months, one year, two and five years respectively. The results suggest that surgery is an effective treatment for more than 50% of long lasting medically intractable epilepsies.

Long-term ictal monitoring with subdural strip electrodes: prognostic factors for selecting temporal lobectomy candidates

Long-term electrocorticographic (ECoG) monitoring data from subdural strip electrodes are analyzed to determine factors associated with seizure-free outcome from anterior temporal lobectomy. A total of 89 consecutive patients with complex partial seizures, in whom long-term ictal video/scalp electroencephalographic monitoring was insufficient to localize their epileptogenic focus, were subsequently evaluated with long-term ictal ECoG monitoring using subdural strip electrodes. Each patient underwent anterior temporal lobectomy based on the ictal ECoG data and has been followed for at least 1 year. The following parameters were found to be statistically significant in predicting a seizure-free outcome: unilateral onset, electrical onset pattern beginning as fast spike trains, absence of frontal lobe background desynchronization at onset, and an interhemispheric propagation time of greater than 8 seconds. Electrocorticographic criteria that were not associated with seizure outcome included: right- versus left-sided onset, time from electrical to clinical ictal onset, focality of onset (number of strip electrode contacts involved), and stereotypical ECoG onset. When present, the interictal focus was concordant with the ictal focus in most patients (96%), but was falsely lateralizing in 4% of cases. It is suggested that these data should improve patient selection for temporal lobectomy when subdural strip monitoring is used during preoperative evaluation.

Comparison and correlation of surface and sphenoidal electrodes with simultaneous intracranial recording: an interictal study

We prospectively compared and correlated interictal spikes recorded with simultaneous surface, sphenoidal, depth and subdural electrodes in 21 patients. Although the amplitude of sphenoidal spikes was often larger than that of surface spikes in patients with mesial basal temporal ictal and interictal foci, only 1 patient had exclusively sphenoidal spikes. Spikes with maximal amplitude at the sphenoidal electrode arose from mesial temporal, temporal neocortical and orbital frontal foci. An inferior vertical temporal dipole (hippocampal positive and inferior temporal neocortex negative) was associated with surface and sphenoidal spikes.