Caveat emptor

Evaluation of CD1a immunostaining in the diagnosis of cutaneous leishmaniasis caused by Leishmania donovani in Sri Lanka

Cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL) is a vector-borne parasitic disease, routinely diagnosed by direct light microscopy. The sensitivity of this method is dependent on the number of parasites present in the lesion. Immunoexpression of CD1a surface antigen by Leishmania amastigotes and its application as a diagnostic tool has been recently demonstrated in several species including Leishmania major, Leishmania tropica and Leishmania infantum. Leishmania donovani is the only reported species in Sri Lanka primarily causing CL and its CD1a status remains unexplored. We studied CD1a expression by amastigotes of L. donovani in skin biopsies from 116 patients with suspected CL. The biopsy sections were stained with CD1a clones O10 and MTB1 separately. Slit skin smear (SSS) results were considered the gold standard for diagnosis of CL. 103 cases were confirmed through SSS where 73 of them showed positive parasite staining for CD1a clone MTB1 with 70.9% sensitivity. Positivity was seen mostly in parasites closer to the epidermis. CD1a clone O10 failed to detect any amastigotes. Test sensitivity improved to 74.1% when the analysis was applied only to patients with low/no discernible Leishman-Donovan (LD) bodies in histology. Our findings show that CD1a clone MTB1 successfully stains amastigotes of L. donovani species and can be used as a supplementary diagnostic tool in detecting CL, especially when LD bodies are low in number. This method could be validated to detect other forms of leishmaniasis caused by L. donovani in Indian and sub-Saharan regions.

Histopathologic features of cutaneous leishmaniasis and use of CD1a staining for amastigotes in Old World and New World leishmaniasis

BACKGROUND

Positive CD1a staining of Leishmania has been reported in Old World leishmaniasis, but the sensitivity of such staining for other Leishmania species is unknown.

METHODS

A retrospective review was done on skin biopsies of proven cutaneous leishmaniasis based on histology, immunohistochemistry, culture and/or polymerase chain reaction (PCR). We assessed the pattern of inflammation present and assessed for CD1a (MTB1 clone) positivity in amastigotes. Patients without a clearly documented travel history to delineate Old vs New World leishmaniasis and cases without tissue for CD1a staining were excluded.

RESULTS

Various patterns of granulomatous inflammation were observed including sarcoidal (31%), diffuse (25%), suppurative and granulomatous (25%), palisaded (13%) and lichenoid (6%). CD1a staining was positive in amastigotes in 9 of 16 cases (56%). Five of 7 (71%) cases of Old World disease were CD1a positive, while 4 of 9 cases (44%) of New World cases were positive.

CONCLUSIONS

Multiple patterns of granulomatous inflammation occur in cutaneous leishmaniasis. Our results confirm CD1a (MTB1 clone) can be a diagnostic adjunct to highlight amastigotes in biopsies of cutaneous leishmaniasis, with variable positivity in both Old World and New World forms of the disease. As 44% of cases were CD1a negative in our cohort, there are significant limitations to this screening approach.

The immune microenvironment in cutaneous leishmaniasis

BACKGROUND

Cutaneous leishmaniasis is an infection that has spread to non-endemic regions, stimulating recent interest for the enhanced understanding of this disease. Downregulation of the CD1a receptor on Langerhans cells has been described in various cutaneous infections.

OBJECTIVE

In this study, the immune response across different Ridley patterns and parasitic indices is outlined in a case series of cutaneous leishmaniasis.

METHODS

Skin punch biopsies from the interface of normal and lesional cutaneous leishmaniasis were collected from 33 patients with molecularly confirmed Leishmania tropica or L. major infection. Ridley patterns (2-5) were assessed for various clinicopathological features including age, gender, disease duration, parasitic index and constituents of the inflammatory infiltrate. CD1a, CD68, CD3, CD4, CD8, CD20 and CD138 stains were performed on normal skin tissue, cutaneous leishmaniasis biopsies and cytospin/cell block cytology preparations of cultured leishmania promastigotes. CD1a was quantified per mm2 in the epidermis and dermis. The remaining stains were graded according to a 4-tiered grading system [0 (0-4%); 1 (5-24%); 2 (25-49%); 3 (50-74%) and 4 (75-100%).

RESULTS

Total CD1a expression significantly decreased (14-fold) from parasitic indices (0-2) to (5-6); (ρ < 0.001). CD1a expression in the epidermis was at least 5-fold lower than normal skin (58 vs. 400 cells/mm2), inversely correlating with the parasitic index. There was an increase in dermal CD1a Langerhans cells (33 vs. 0 cells/mm² in the dermis). CD1a and CD68 staining of amastigotes was strong and diffuse, whereas promastigotes were negative. The major inflammatory infiltrate, in all Ridley patterns, consisted of macrophages and double-negative CD3(+) CD4(-) CD8(-) T lymphocytes. The double-negative CD3 T cells formed a ring around the parasitic laden macrophages. Apart from CD1a, there was no significant difference in inflammatory markers between the various Ridley patterns and parasitic indices. Disease duration did not correlate with Ridley pattern.

CONCLUSION

The significant decrease in CD1a expression is postulated by two mechanisms; either via direct CD1a receptor uptake by leishmania amastigotes and/or negative feedback inhibition of CD1a Langerhans cells by double-negative CD3 T-regulatory cells. Modulation of the immune microenvironment in cutaneous leishmaniasis represents a potential therapeutic and prophylactic target.