Tumour promotion related effects by the cyclodiene insecticide endosulfan studied in vitro and in vivo

Predictive toxicology of chemical mixtures using proteome-wide thermal profiling and protein target properties

Our capability to predict the impact of exposure to chemical mixtures on environmental and human health is limited in comparison to the advances on the chemical characterization of the exposome. Current approaches, such as new approach methodologies, rely on the characterization of the chemicals and the available toxicological knowledge of individual compounds. In this study, we show a new methodological approach for the assessment of chemical mixtures based on a proteome-wide identification of the protein targets and revealing the relevance of new targets based on their role in the cellular function. We applied a proteome integral solubility alteration assay to identify 24 protein targets from a chemical mixture of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin, alpha-endosulfan, and bisphenol A among the HepG2 soluble proteome, and validated the chemical mixture-target interaction orthogonally. To define the range of interactive capability of the new targets, the data from intrinsic properties of the targets were retrieved. Introducing the target properties as criteria for a multi-criteria decision-making analysis called the analytical hierarchy process, the prioritization of targets was based on their involvement in multiple pathways. This methodological approach that we present here opens a more realistic and achievable scenario to address the impact of complex and uncharacterized chemical mixtures in biological systems.

Exposure to endosulfan can cause long term effects on general biology, including the reproductive system of mice

Increased infertility in humans is attributed to the increased use of environmental chemicals in the last several decades. Various studies have identified pesticides as one of the causes of reproductive toxicity. In a previous study, infertility was observed in male mice due to testicular atrophy and decreased sperm count when a sublethal dose of endosulfan (3 mg/kg) with a serum concentration of 23 μg/L was used. However, the serum concentration of endosulfan was much higher (up to 500 μg/L) in people living in endosulfan-exposed areas compared to the one used in the investigation. To mimic the situation in an experimental setup, mice were exposed to 5 mg/kg body weight of endosulfan, and reproductive toxicity and long-term impact on the general biology of animals were examined. HPLC analysis revealed a serum concentration of ∼50 μg/L of endosulfan after 24 h endosulfan exposure affected the normal physiology of mice. Histopathological studies suggest a persistent, severe effect on reproductive organs where vacuole degeneration of basal germinal epithelial cells and degradation of the interstitial matrix were observed in testes. Ovaries showed a reduction in the number of mature Graafian follicles. At the same time, mild vacuolation in liver hepatocytes and changes in the architecture of the lungs were observed. Endosulfan exposure induced DNA damage and mutations in germ cells at the molecular level. Interestingly, even after 8 months of endosulfan exposure, we observed increased DNA breaks in reproductive tissues. An increased DNA Ligase III expression was also observed, consistent with reported elevated levels of MMEJ-mediated repair. Further, we observed the generation of tumors in a few of the treated mice with time. Thus, the study not only explores the changes in the general biology of the mice upon exposure to endosulfan but also describes the molecular mechanism of its long-term effects.

Human health risk assessment of endosulfan. I: Toxicology and hazard identification

Endosulfan is persistent in the environment and toxic to wildlife. Legal mandates necessitate that a risk assessments be performed for endosulfan by the California Department of Pesticide Regulation (CDPR) and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). This hazard identification (hazard ID) compared critical no-observed effect levels (NOEL) for acute, subchronic and chronic exposure intervals between the agencies. NOELs were discussed in light of their application to numerous exposure scenarios (occupational, general population and dietary). Only the acute oral NOELs differed between CDPR (0.7 mg/kg/day) and USEPA (1.5 mg/kg/day). Pregnant rabbits were considered by CDPR to be more responsive to low gavage doses of endosulfan than non-pregnant female or male rats in the acute study selected by USEPA. NOELs for other exposure routes and durations were similar between agencies. CDPR and USEPA concurred that a Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA, 1996) Safety Factor is not needed after evaluating all studies including a Developmental Neurotoxicity study. The SF was reduced to 1x. NOELs generated from this hazard ID will be used to calculate the Margins of Exposure for all scenarios and subsequently the risk characterization for endosulfan.

In vitro effect of pesticides (dichlofluanid, endosulfan, simazine, tolylfluanid and triallate) on proliferative activity of animal derived cell cultures

In this study pesticides with different chemical structures (dichlofluanid, endosulfan, simazine, tolylfluanid and triallate) were examined for their potential cytotoxic effect on proliferative activity of cell cultures of mammalian origin. Cell lines Madin-Darby Bovine Kidney (MDBK), Rabbit Kidney (RK13), Porcine Kidney (PK15), and semicontinual line of Bovine Embryonic Pulmonary Cells (BEPC) were used in the study. From these cell cultures cell proliferative activity was suppressed most intensively in PK15 culture by endosulfan (10(-1) - 10(-6) M). The least effect on cell proliferation in all cell cultures tested, with the exception PK 15 (10(-1) - 10(-2) M), was recorded after simazine exposure. On the basis of IC50 values the cytotoxic effect was: dichlofluanid (IC50 = 10(-3.94) M) > tolylfluanid (IC50 = 10(-3.69) M) > endosulfan (IC50 = 10(-3.24) M) > triallate (IC50 = 10(-3.12) M) > simazine (IC50 = 10(-1.78) M). The comparison of average IC50 values of cell cultures revealed that the most sensitive cell lines were PK15 (IC50 = 10(-3.27) M) and RK13 (IC50 = 10(-3.21) M), whereas MDBK (IC50 = 10(-2.55) M) and BEPC (IC50 = 10(-2.52) M) were less sensitive to pesticide exposure.

Use of a cell transformation assay with established cell lines, and a metabolic cooperation assay with V79 cells for the detection of tumour promoters: a review

Extensive studies on the safety evaluation of chemicals have indicated that a considerable number of non-genotoxic chemicals are carcinogenic. Tumour promoters are likely to be among these non-genotoxic carcinogens, and their detection is considered to be an important approach to the prevention of cancer. In this review, the results are summarised for in vitro transformation assays involving established cell lines, and for an assay for inhibition of gap junctional intercellular communication for the detection of tumour promoters, which involves V79 cells. Although the number of chemicals examined is still too small to permit a full evaluation of the correlation between in vitro cell transformation and in vivo carcinogenicity, it is clear that the sensitivity of the focus formation assay is very high. In the case of the metabolic cooperation assay, the sensitivity appears to be rather poor, but the assay can be considered to be useful because of its simple procedure and its considerable database. These in vitro assays for tumour promoters are recommended as useful tools for the detection of non-genotoxic carcinogens.

Chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity studies with the insecticide endosulfan in rats and mice

The insecticide endosulfan was evaluated for chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity in long-term feeding studies in both Sprague-Dawley rats and NMRI mice. Dietary concentrations of the test substance were administered to rats at 0, 3, 7.5, 15 and 75 ppm and to mice at 0, 2, 6 and 18 ppm for 24 months each. In the rat study, only the treatment with the highest dose caused a significant reduction of body weight gains of the males and females at 75 ppm. The increased incidence of enlarged kidneys seen at autopsy at 75 ppm in females, and the slightly increased incidence of progressive glomerulonephrosis and slightly increased incidence of renal aneurysms seen histopathologically in the 75 ppm males, make the kidney the target organ in rats. On the basis of these findings a dietary concentration of 15 ppm is considered to be the no-observed-effect level (NOEL) in rats, equivalent to a daily test substance intake of 0.6 mg/kg body weight in males and 0.7 mg/kg body weight in females. In the mouse study, the treatment with 18 ppm caused a significant increase of mortality in the females and a slight (in the first third of the study, significant) reduction of body weight gain in males. Since there were no other substance-related findings, the dietary concentration of 6 ppm is considered to be the NOEL in mice, equivalent to a daily test substance intake of 0.84 mg/kg body weight in males and 0.97 mg/kg body weight in females. An evaluation of all relevant tumour data gained in both studies revealed no differences between control and treated groups. It was concluded, therefore, that endosulfan has no carcinogenic potential.

Inhibition of intercellular communication by condensates of high and low tar cigarettes

Inhibition of gap junctional intercellular communication (GJIC) is a predictive short term test for tumor promoting activity. A new metabolic cooperation assay has been developed, which takes the cytochrome P-450 metabolism into account. In this assay the inhibitory activity of tobacco smoke condensates (CSC) and CSC fractions from high and low tar cigarettes was tested. CSC of both high and low tar cigarettes and fractions thereof contained tumor promoting activity. The tar yield of the cigarettes did not closely reflect the effects in the GJIC assay and the major constituent nicotine had no effect. The effect was only marginally greater in cells expressing different cytochrome P-450 enzymes, indicating that the active substances are not metabolized by these enzymes. The activities of CSC fractions were considerably lower than the activities in the unfractionated CSC. This may indicate that compounds in the CSC act strongly synergistically. Furthermore, CSC and CSC fractions synergistically inhibit GJIC with the tumor promoter 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate, indicating different mechanisms of action.

Limitations of the scrape-loading/dye transfer technique to quantify inhibition of gap junctional intercellular communication

Gap junctional intercellular communication (GJIC) is recognized as playing an important role in normal cell proliferation and development. Chemically induced alteration of GJIC has been proposed to be associated with abnormal cellular growth and/or tumor promotion. Several in vitro assays are currently used to determine the effects of chemicals on GJIC between cultured mammalian cells. One of these assays, the scrape-loading dye transfer (SL/DT) technique, is based on monitoring the transfer of the fluorescent dye Lucifer yellow from one cell into adjacent cells via functional gap junctions. The objective of our study was to evaluate and compare various approaches for quantifying results obtained with the SL/DT technique. Confluent cultures of either WB rat liver epithelial cells or LC-540 rat leydig cells were exposed to the animal tumor promoter 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA), solvent (0.1% ethanol), or culture medium for one hour at 37 degrees C prior to analysis of GJIC. Inhibition of dye transfer was clearly evident following TPA exposure. Quantification of this dye transfer was assessed via four approaches: manually counting the number of labeled cells; measuring the distance of dye travel from the scrape line; quantifying the amount of cellular dye uptake; and determining the distribution of dye away from the scrape line. Our results suggest that while the SL/DT technique can be effectively used as a tool to determine the qualitative presence or absence of GJIC, its use in quantifying changes in GJIC following chemical exposure is limited. Since concentration-dependent responses are critical in chemical testing, application of the SL/DT method should be restricted to a screening assay for qualitatively assessing the presence or absence of GJIC.

Chlorobenzilate-induced effects on enzyme-altered foci in rat liver and intercellular communication in rat liver WB-F344 epithelial cells

The mouse liver carcinogen chlorobenzilate (CB), a DDT-related pesticide, was investigated for enhancement of enzyme altered foci incidence in partially hepatectomized, diethyl-nitrosamine-initiated rats. In this in vivo experiment, CB administered per os (25 or 100 mg/kg per day for 10 weeks) enhanced foci incidence at the high dose level. In order to study potential mechanisms involved, CB was investigated for inhibition of gap-junctional intercellular communication in rat liver epithelial WB-F344 cells and Chinese hamster V79 cells in vitro. CB abolished dye transfer in WB-F344 cells and inhibited metabolic cooperation in V79 cells. Two CB metabolites were unable to induce such tumor promotion related effects. The results of this investigation provide support for the involvement of an epigenetic, tumor promoting mechanism in CB-induced liver tumors in laboratory animals.