The operational implications of donor behaviors following enrollment in STRIDE (Strategies to Reduce Iron Deficiency in blood donors)

Iron supplementation: A qualitative study on the perception of blood donors, blood collection staff and donor physicians

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Iron supplementation is an effective strategy to mitigate donation-induced iron deficiency in blood donors. However, evidence on the perception of individuals involved in blood donation on iron supplementation as a blood service policy is lacking. This study aimed to evaluate the knowledge and perception of whole blood donors (donors), blood collection staff (collection staff) and donor physicians (physicians) regarding donation-induced iron loss and iron supplementation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Online focus group discussions had four to six participants and followed a structured questioning approach. All participants had to be fluent in Dutch to participate, and donors had donated at least five times. Sixteen donors, eight collection staff members and four physicians participated in this study. Recordings were transcribed, coded and analysed using a grounded theory approach.

RESULTS

Awareness of donation-induced iron loss was limited in donors. Donors and physicians were predominantly positive towards iron supplementation; the primary motivator for donors was to prevent deferral and reduce iron-deficiency-related symptoms. Improving donor health was the main argument for physicians to advocate iron supplementation. Staff had a critical view on iron supplementation as a policy, as they perceived it as unethical and possibly ineffective. A knowledge gap might underlie their concerns.

CONCLUSION

Most individuals involved in blood donation are positive towards iron supplementation as a blood service policy. If implemented, guidance and monitoring is desired and adequate education of all stakeholders is required.

Impact of donor ferritin testing on iron deficiency prevention and blood availability in France: A cohort simulation study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Implementing a ferritin testing policy for whole blood (WB) donors may prevent iron deficiency (ID, ferritin <26 ng/mL) and anaemia, but may induce donation losses. As part of a national prevention plan in France, we aimed to estimate its impact on ID, anaemias and WB donations among donors at high risk of ID.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A micro-simulation model was developed to evaluate different scenarios compared to the current situation without ferritin testing as a reference scenario. The following scenarios were simulated: a minimum scenario with a 6-month deferral for donors with absent iron store (AIS, ferritinemia <15 ng/ml), a main scenario with additional delayed invitations for donors with ferritinemia 15-25 ng/ml and a supplementation scenario with additional iron supplementation for 50% of the donors with AIS.

RESULTS

In the main scenario, 52,699 WB donations per year were estimated to be lost after 1 year (-8%), falling to 27,687 (-4.7%) after 5 years. IDs and anaemias were reduced by 13.6% and 29.3%, respectively, after 1 year. The supplementation scenario increased the number of prevented IDs and anaemias to 24.1% and 35.4%, respectively, after 1 year, and halved the number of anaemias at 5 years. The latter scenario also had the least impact on the number of donations (-3.2% after 5 years).

CONCLUSION

A ferritin testing policy resulting in delayed donations for ID donors is effective in reducing IDs and anaemias, but significantly impacts the number of donations, thereby posing a self-sufficiency challenge.

Eligibility Considerations for Female Whole Blood Donors: Hemoglobin Levels and Iron Status in a Nationally Representative Population

Blood collection from minority populations improves the transfusion support of patients with sickle cell disease and thalassemia, but efforts are challenged by high deferral rates for hemoglobin (Hb) eligibility thresholds. This study sought to evaluate hemoglobin and iron status of a representative US female population to assess the suitability of 12.0 g/dL as minimum hemoglobin. Data were extracted from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys (NHANES), 1999-2010. A national sample designed to reflect potential female blood donors (weight ≥110 lbs, not pregnant, no infectious marker reactivity, and no blood donation in past year) aged 16 to 49 years was analyzed for Hb and serum ferritin (SF) measures by race/ethnicity (N = 6937). Mean Hb and SF and the prevalence of iron deficiency ([ID] SF<12 ng/mL and SF<26 ng/mL) and low Hb (<12.5 g/dL and <12.0 g/dL) were estimated. Multivariable modified Poisson regression compared the prevalence for ID or low Hb at each cutoff by race/ethnicity. Mean SF values were higher and ID prevalence was lower in Non-Hispanic (NH) White (SF = 45.3 ng/mL, SF<12 ng/mL = 8.2%) than NH Black (SF = 39.6 ng/mL, SF<12 ng/mL = 14.2%) and Hispanic (SF = 36.5 ng/mL, SF<12 ng/mL = 12.7%) females. Compared to NH White females (13.7 g/dL), mean Hb was lower in NH Black (12.6 g/dL) and Hispanic females (13.4 g/dL). The percentage with Hb<12.5 g/dL was >4 times greater in NH Black (39.1%) and >2 times greater in Hispanic females (16.5%) compared to NH White (8.6%). Within 0.5 g/dL incremental categories of Hb, NH Black had higher mean SF levels and lower prevalence of SF<12 ng/mL or <26 ng/mL compared to NH White and Hispanic females. At Hb of 12.0 to 12.4g/dL, NH Black females had better measures of iron status (SF = 39.1 ng/mL, %SF<12 ng/mL = 12.0%) than NH White (SF = 33.6 ng/mL, %SF<12 ng/mL=15.8%) and Hispanic (SF = 30.4 ng/mL, %SF<12 ng/mL=15.5%) females whose Hb was 12.5 to 12.9 g/dL. Adjusting for age and Hb, the prevalence ratio for low SF was significantly lower in NH Black compared to NH White females at both SF<26 ng/mL (adjusted prevalence ratio [aPR] = 0.83, 95%CI = 0.76-0.92) and SF<12 ng/mL (aPR = 0.66, 95%CI = 0.52-0.83). NH Black females with Hb 12.0 to 12.4g/dL have better iron stores than NH White and Hispanic females whose Hb is 12.5 to 12.9 g/dL. The distribution of Hb and iron may support the safe collection of blood for female donors below the current Hb eligibility requirement of 12.5 g/dL.

Ferritin-guided iron supplementation in whole blood donors: optimal dosage, donor response, return and efficacy (FORTE)-a randomised controlled trial protocol

BACKGROUND

Frequent whole blood donors have an increased risk of developing iron deficiency. Iron deficiency can have detrimental health effects when left untreated. Donation intervals are commonly too short to replenish iron stores and extending these reduces donor availability. Oral iron supplementation is known to shorten iron store recovery time but may also induce gastrointestinal complaints. We aim to optimise the effectiveness of iron supplements while minimising the risks of side effects. Therefore, we will evaluate the impact of different iron supplementation protocols in terms of dosage and frequency on ferritin and haemoglobin levels, gastrointestinal side effects, iron deficiency-related symptoms and donor return compared with placebo supplementation.

METHODS

Twelve hundred whole blood donors with ferritin levels ≤30 µg/L are included into a double-blind, randomised controlled trial. Participants are randomly allocated to one of six arms, administering capsules containing 0 mg, 30 mg or 60 mg of iron, either on alternate days or daily for 56 days. At baseline and 56, 122 and 182 days of follow-up, ferritin and haemoglobin levels are measured, and compliance, donor return, dietary iron intake, gastrointestinal, iron deficiency-related symptoms and general health are assessed by questionnaire.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

This study will provide a comprehensive overview of the effects of different frequencies and dosages of administration of iron supplements on iron status and health effects, thereby considering individual differences in treatment adherence and lifestyle. The outcome will provide scientific evidence to guide the debate if and how oral iron supplements may support the recovery of whole blood donors with low ferritin levels.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NL8590; The Dutch trial registry.

Deferral due to low hemoglobin and predictors of permanence in the blood donation system of repeat female blood donors

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the deferral rate due to low hemoglobin (Hb) in repeat female blood donors and identify the factors affecting their permanence in the blood donation system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

8,368 repeat female blood donors who donated from January 2012 to December 2018 were included. Bivariate analysis and Kaplan-Meier curves were used to identify the covariates possibly associated with developing low Hb, and Cox proportional hazards modeling was used to adjust for all confounders.

RESULTS

The global deferral rate due to low Hb was 2.4 %. According to baseline Hb, the frequency of low Hb was 0.7-4.1 %, and it was higher in platelet donors (5.8-9.1 %) than in whole blood donors (1.9 %). The main predictors were baseline Hb (compared to the first quartile; hazard ratio [HR] = 0.487 for the second quartile; 0.234 for the third; and 0.095 for the fourth); change in Hb (HR = 2.689 for a >0.49 g/dL change, compared to smaller changes); the type of donation (compared to whole blood donors, HR = 2.317 for platelet donors); and donation interval (compared to >12.5 month intervals; HR = 2.220 for 8.0-12.5 months; HR = 5.658 for 5.4-8.0 months; and HR = 9.452 for <5.4 months).

CONCLUSIONS

In female blood donors at moderate altitude, the probability of developing low Hb increases with a baseline Hb of 13.5-14.0 g/dL, with a change in Hb >0.49 g/dL, in platelet donors, and with donation intervals <12.5 months. These four predictive factors can be used together for early identification of donors at risk of developing low Hb, to institute appropriate measures.

Iron status and self-reported fatigue in blood donors

Fatigue is a reported symptom of iron depletion, but studies in blood donors show no conclusive link. We conducted an observational analysis of data from the STRIDE randomized trial to evaluate association of iron status with self-reported fatigue.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Three blood centers randomly assigned 692 frequent donors to education or iron supplementation treatments. Biomarkers for iron status were measured during 20 to 24 months of follow-up. A fatigue score was derived from an 11-item questionnaire at baseline and final visits, and associations between iron status and fatigue were assessed.

RESULTS

Final lab and questionnaire data were evaluable from 337 subjects. At baseline, female sex, older age, and anemia were associated with fatigue, but iron status was not. Mean (±SD) fatigue score change was 0.0 (±0.5). Mean (±SD) increase in iron stores was 1.0 (±3.5) mg/kg, but changes in body iron stores were not associated with fatigue score changes (0.01 per mg/kg; 95% CI, -0.01 to 0.02) or with fatigue (RR, 1.01; 95% CI, 0.99 to 1.04). The only factor associated with fatigue score changes was baseline fatigue (0.36; 95% CI, 0.25 to 0.48).

CONCLUSION

Among high-frequency donors, neither iron status at baseline nor changes in iron status predicted fatigue during follow-up, with improvements limited to those with higher levels of baseline fatigue. Assessment of the association between iron and fatigue in blood donors benefits from careful consideration of study design and the study population.

Iron deficiency among French whole-blood donors: first assessment and identification of predictive factors

BACKGROUND

The objectives of this study are to estimate the prevalence of iron deficiency (ID) among French whole-blood (WB) donors to identify factors associated with ID and to generate decision trees.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A prospective National multicentre study was performed on WB donors from March 11, to April 5th, 2019. Samples were selected randomly to perform serum ferritin. ID was defined as ferritin value under 26 ng/ml. All results were stratified by sex. Factors associated with ID were analysed using multivariate logistic regression model. CART algorithm was used for decision trees.

RESULTS

Eleven thousand two hundred fifty eight WB donors were included. ID was more frequent in women (39·5%) than in men (18·0%). Among 7200 repeated donors, women below 50 yo had a higher risk (OR = 2·37; [1·97-2·85] IC95) than those above 50 yo. Factors associated with ID were: haemoglobin level under the threshold at donation n-1 except for women and n-2 donation; a low mean corpuscular haemoglobin at n-1 and n-2 donations; a shorter interval since n-1 donation and between n-1 and n-2 donations except for women; and women who had given three or four times in the last year. CART algorithm defined high risk of ID subgroups within three populations of donors, new female donors, repeated male donors and repeated female donors. In these identified subgroups, prevalence of ID was up to 72·1%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed the high prevalence of ID among French WB donors, identified well-known and new factors associated with ID and defined algorithms predicting ID in three populations.

Effectiveness of the post-donation instruction sheet in conveying information to repeat blood donors

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Written materials are commonly used for blood donor education. While pre-donation materials are largely standardized across US blood collectors, the post-donation instruction sheet (PDIS) is variable and few have been evaluated to assess their effectiveness in conveying information as reflected by donors' attention, understanding and recall.

METHODS

An online survey was sent to two independent randomly selected samples of repeat donors, before and after implementation of the enhanced PDIS.

RESULTS

A total of 12 935 blood donors responded (33·4% response rate). Most donors did not read the entire PDIS - 34·3% less than half and 18·1% none. Of the 10 593 donors who reported reading any of the PDIS, 97·8% recalled instructions about immediate post-donation care (e.g. extra fluids/no exercise) and 88·0% to call with questions/problems. However, only 50·1% remembered reading about what to do if you felt dizzy/faint and 32·4% about care for bruises. Recall rates in every area were similar before and after revision; except after revision, more donors remembered seeing information about maintaining iron and fewer that you should call the centre back with additional health information (P < 0·0001).

DISCUSSION

Blood collectors rely heavily on written materials to convey instructions to donors. Most repeat donors do not read the entire PDIS, and many do not recall important information. More donors recalled seeing how to maintain iron with the enhanced PDIS, but recall deficits remained on how to care for adverse reactions. Written materials alone appear to be insufficient to educate some donors about new or updated topics.

The effects of intravenous iron supplementation on fatigue and general health in non-anemic blood donors with iron deficiency: a randomized placebo-controlled superiority trial

We investigated whether intravenous iron supplementation improves fatigue and general health in non-anemic repeat adult blood donors with iron deficiency (ferritin ≤ 50 µg/L). Of 1,487 potentially eligible participants, 203 were randomly assigned to a single intravenous dose of 800 mg iron-carboxymaltose and 202 to placebo; 393 participants completed the trial. At 6 to 8 weeks after intervention, self-rated mean fatigue scores (numeric rating scale from 1-10, primary outcome) were 3.9 ± 1.8 in the iron supplementation group and 4.0 ± 2.2 in the placebo group, showing no group difference (p = 0.819). Pre-specified subgroup analyses of gender, ferritin < 25 µg/L and fatigue ≥ 4 points, as well as exploratory analyses of lower ferritin cut-offs did not reveal any between-group differences. In terms of secondary outcomes, the mean differences were 114.2 µg/L for ferritin (95% CI 103.1-125.3) and 5.7 g/L for hemoglobin (95% CI 4.3-7.2) with significantly higher values in the iron supplementation group. No group differences were observed for different measures of general well-being and other clinical and safety outcomes. Intravenous iron supplementation compared with placebo resulted in increase of ferritin and hemoglobin levels in repeat blood donors with low iron stores, yet had no effect on fatigue and general well-being.

Frequent blood donations alter susceptibility of red blood cells to storage- and stress-induced hemolysis

BACKGROUND

Frequent whole blood donations increase the prevalence of iron depletion in blood donors, which may subsequently interfere with normal erythropoiesis. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the associations between donation frequency and red blood cell (RBC) storage stability in a racially/ethnically diverse population of blood donors.

STUDY DESIGN

Leukoreduced RBC concentrate-derived samples from 13,403 donors were stored for 39 to 42 days (1-6°C) and then evaluated for storage, osmotic, and oxidative hemolysis. Iron status was evaluated by plasma ferritin measurement and self-reported intake of iron supplements. Donation history in the prior 2 years was obtained for each subject.

RESULTS

Frequent blood donors enrolled in this study were likely to be white, male, and of older age (56.1 ± 5.0 years). Prior donation intensity was negatively associated with oxidative hemolysis (p < 0.0001) in multivariate analyses correcting for age, sex, and race/ethnicity. Increased plasma ferritin concentration was associated with increased RBC susceptibility to each of the three measures of hemolysis (p < 0.0001 for all), whereas self-reported iron intake was associated with reduced susceptibility to osmotic and oxidative hemolysis (p < 0.0001 for both).

CONCLUSIONS

Frequent blood donations may alter the quality of blood components by modulating RBC predisposition to hemolysis. RBCs collected from frequent donors with low ferritin have altered susceptibility to hemolysis. Thus, frequent donation and associated iron loss may alter the quality of stored RBC components collected from iron-deficient donors. Further investigation is necessary to assess posttransfusion safety and efficacy in patients receiving these RBC products.