Kidney Organ Allocation System: How to Be Fair

Transplantation is a life-saving medical intervention that unfortunately is constrained by scarcity of available organs. An ideal system for allocating organs should seek to achieve the greatest good for the greatest number of people. It also must be fair and not disadvantage certain populations. However, policies aimed at reducing disparities also must be balanced with considerations of utility (graft outcomes), cost, efficiency, and any adverse effects on organ utilization. Here, we discuss the ethical challenges of creating a fair and equitable organ allocation system, focusing on the principles governing deceased donor kidney transplant waitlists around the world. The kidney organ allocation systems in the United States, Australia, and Hong Kong are used as illustrations.

Over ten-year kidney graft survival determinants

Kidney graft survival has been mainly evaluated using an up to 10-year threshold. Instead, in this study our aim was to evaluate predictive variables that impact long-term kidney graft survival (≥10 years). We enrolled 892 patients in our analysis: 638 patients with functioning graft at 10 years PT and 254 patients with graft failure at 10 years PT (considering patient death with a functioning graft <10 years PT as graft failure). Between groups comparisons were done using Mann-Whitney and chi-square test. To determine independent predictive variables for long-term graft survival a multivariate-adjusted logistic regression was performed. Significant predictors of long term graft survival were lower 12-month PT creatinine (OR = 0.26, P < 0.001), lower donor age (OR = 0.98, P = 0.004), shorter time on dialysis (OR = 0.93, P = 0.044), recipient positive CMV IgG (OR = 1.59, P = 0.040), absence of AR episodes (OR = 1.57, P = 0.047), 0 to 1 (versus 2) HLA-B mismatch (OR = 1.80, P = 0.004), and recipients male gender (OR = 1.84, P = 0.005). Our results show that an early KT, younger donor age, and an optimal first year graft function are of paramount importance for long-term graft survival. Measures that address these issues (careful donor selection, preemptive KT, and effective immunosuppressive protocols) are still warranted.

Class-, gene-, and group-specific HLA silencing by lentiviral shRNA delivery

HLA incompatibility is the most relevant immunologic barrier to cell-based therapies. Improvement of histocompatibility is essential to achieving better survival of allogeneic cells in the foreign organism. RNA interference technology can be used to selectively and stably reduce cellular HLA class I expression. In the present study, we designed small interfering RNA (siRNA) molecules that target either beta2-microglobulin (beta2m) or HLA-A heavy chain transcripts and identified sensitive sites on the target RNAs using an in vitro transcription/translation (IVTT) system. Transfection of siRNA into B-lymphocyte cell lines (B-LCLs) resulted in specific reduction of HLA class I or HLA-A antigen expression by 79% at the mRNA and protein levels. An allele-specific HLA silencing rate of 65% was achieved in a B-LCL heterozygous for HLA-A*24,*68 allospecificities using HLA-A*68-specific siRNA. Lentiviral delivery of short hairpin RNA into HeLa and B-LCL cells resulted in selective and permanent silencing of HLA class I or HLA-A by up to 90% even under inflammatory conditions. In cytotoxicity and proliferation assays, it was demonstrated that HLA class I knockdown was effective in preventing antibody-mediated cell lysis and CD8+ T cell response, while the residual HLA expression in HLA-silenced cells was protective against NK-cell-mediated lysis. The present data strongly suggest that silencing of HLA expression in a class-, gene-, and group-specific manner is an effective approach that may provide a new basis for developing new immunotherapies in the field of regenerative medicine.

Immunosuppression With Antithymocyte Globulin in Renal Transplantation: Better Long-Term Graft Survival

We analyzed the impact of antithymocyte globulin (ATG) in renal transplantation. We retrospectively studied 1217 recipients performed from July 83 to December 03. ATG-Fresenius-S (ATG-F) was used for induction therapy in 492 patients (40.4%; group I) and compared with group II, 725 patients (59.6%), without antilymphocyte induction. Groups were comparable in terms of recipient gender and race distribution; time on dialysis; cause of renal disease; number of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) mismatches; donor age, gender, and creatinine; and cold ischemia time. Patients with ATG-F were younger (35.8 +/- 13.8 vs 38.9 +/- 12.5 years, P < .001), more frequently hypersensitized (10% vs 3%, P < .001), and had more second transplants (15.7% vs 5.8%, P < .001). The incidence of acute rejection episodes was lower among ATG-F patients (23.6% vs 32.1%, P = .004). Admission time and incidence of delayed graft function (DGF) were similar in the two groups. Graft survival at 1, 5, 10, and 15 years was 88.9%, 80.7%, 71.3%, and 64.9% in group I and 86.4%, 77.4%, 60.7%, and 48.4% in group II (P = .003). The difference in patient survival over the same follow-up did not reach statistical significance. Multivariate analysis showed that the risk of graft failure was higher for those who did not receive ATG-F (HR = 1.51; 95% CI, 1.14 to 2.00; P = .004). Donor age and DGF were also independent predictors of graft failure. Our results showed a better long-term graft survival among patients who received ATG-F, despite their higher immunological risk. The absence of induction with ATG-F, donor age, and DGF were independent risk factors for graft failure.

Consequences of eliminating HLA-B in deceased donor kidney allocation to increase minority transplantation

HLA matching contributes to the disparity in Caucasian compared to minority kidney transplantation. HLA-B locus matching was eliminated from kidney allocation to shift a projected 166 organs from Caucasians to minorities annually. This study estimated the economic and quality-of-life impact of this policy. Cost-effectiveness analysis was performed using a Markov model. Data from the United States Renal Data System (USRDS) were used to estimate race-specific outcomes, patient and graft survival, quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) and medical costs in U.S. dollars. The greatest benefit is expected in African Americans, with expected savings of US 7.5 million dollars and 243 QALYs. Smaller cost and QALY benefits are seen in other minority groups. In Caucasians, a loss of 7.0 million dollars and a decrease of 967 QALYs are expected with the shift of organs. Overall, this policy is expected to save US 5400 dollars for each QALY that is lost. The same increase in minority transplantation would be expected from increasing Caucasian donation rates by 5.5%, or African-American donation by 29.0%, each producing large cost savings and QALY gains. Policies to increase minority transplants by increasing donation rates may prove more cost effective than the elimination of HLA-B matching from deceased donor kidney allocation.

Effect of partial HLA class I match on acute rejection in viral pre-infected human liver allograft recipients

BACKGROUND

Acute rejection in liver transplants is one of the commonest causes of liver dysfunction in the early postoperative period. However, the factors involved in liver graft rejection are still unknown. Our study was aimed at ascertaining whether the degree of HLA class I and class II compatibility or pretransplant viral infection have any influence on early acute liver graft rejection.

METHODS

We reviewed clinical and laboratory data in 190 consecutive patients who underwent a liver transplant. HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DR typing for the establishment of an HLA match score was performed by a standard microcytotoxicity method. The existence of pretransplant viral infection was investigated in sera and biopsy tissue by serologic (hepatitis B virus, hepatitis C virus) and polymerase chain reaction (cytomegalovirus) techniques, respectively. The influence of these two factors in acute rejection and the interaction between them was also analyzed.

RESULTS

A strong association between viral infection and acute rejection in the group with partial class I matching was found (odds ratio=7.75; P<0.0009), whereas no correlation was observed in the group with zero class I matching (odds ratio=0.98; P=0.81). The rejection percentage in the group in which partial class I match and viral infections coexisted was 60%, whereas in the partially class I-matched group without pretransplant viral presence it was 16%.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest a participation of partial HLA class I compatibility in triggering acute rejection in recipients suffering preoperative viral infections and support the idea that HLA class I antigen matching could play a role as a linking element between the MHC-restricted T cell-mediated response to viral infection and the allogenic response in liver transplantation.

Cytomegalovirus infection-enhanced chronic kidney allograft rejection is linked with intercellular adhesion molecule-1 expression

In human kidney allografts, association of acute rejection and glomerulopathy with cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection has been demonstrated. To investigate the effect of CMV infection on the development of experimental chronic kidney allograft rejection, heterotopic kidney allografts from DA (Ag-B4, RT1a1) rat donors to WF (Ag-B2, RT1u) rat recipients were used. The animals received cyclosporine A (CsA) 5 mg/kg/day s.c. either for 1 or 12 weeks. Two groups of recipients were infected with 10(5) plaque-forming units of rat CMV (RCMV) and two other groups were left noninfected and used as controls. The grafts were removed 12 weeks after transplantation for histology and immunohistochemistry. RCMV infection significantly enhanced the development of chronic kidney allograft rejection in rats on continuous CsA the intensity of interstitial inflammation (P < 0.025), particularly the degree of pyroninophilic cells in the inflammatory infiltrate (P < 0.025), the glomerular mesangial matrix increase (P < 0.05) and capillary basement membrane thickening (P < 0.01), the extent of endothelial cell swelling (P < 0.025) and intimal proliferation (P < 0.025) in the graft vasculature, and the extent of tubular epithelial atrophy (P < 0.025). Chronic allograft damage index (CADI) was significantly increased to 4.3 +/- 0.8 in RCMV-infected allografts, compared to 0.8 +/- 0.4 in noninfected (P < 0.02). In addition, RCMV infection significantly increased the number of acute rejection episodes (serum creatinine > 200 mumol/liter, P < 0.05) and almost doubled the end-stage serum creatinine. RCMV infection significantly increased ICAM-1 expression on the vascular endothelium (P < 0.05) and tubular epithelial cells (P < 0.01), and was linked with enhanced interstitial, glomerular, and tubular inflammation. In 80% of allografts on continuous CsA, RCMV antigens could be observed in sporadic inflammatory cells one week after infection and in tubular epithelial cells at 12 weeks. In heavily inflamed allografts where the CsA treatment was discontinued at one week, enhancement of RCMV infection on the histological changes attributable to chronic kidney allograft rejection could not be demonstrated. Our results show that during CsA immunosuppression, RCMV infection enhances chronic kidney allograft rejection associated with increased interstitial inflammation as well as vascular endothelial and tubular epithelial ICAM-1 expression.

Chronic renal allograft rejection can be predicted by area under the serum creatinine versus time curve (AUCCr)

Acute rejection is the most important single risk factor for chronic renal allograft rejection. Numerical quantitation of rejection episodes does not take into account the intensity and length of these episodes, both of which may contribute to the severity of chronic rejection. We propose a single numerical parameter for the frequency, intensity and length of acute rejections, the "Area Under the Serum Creatinine versus Time Curve" (AUCCr) using renal allografts between inbred rat strains. Twenty-seven renal transplantations were performed from the DA to WF rat strain. The rats were immunosuppressed with 5 mg/kg body weight of CyA injected s.c. for 1, 2, 3 and 12 weeks, resulting in differing numbers (0-4) of biopsy-confirmed acute rejections of varying intensity (s-cre: 100-448 mumol/L) and length (3-24 days), all of which were reversed with additional CyA treatment. The intensity of chronic changes in graft histology was quantitated using the "Chronic Allograft Damage Index" (CADI). End-point transplant function was quantitated as level of serum creatinine at sacrifice. The AUCCr from 0 to 3 weeks (AUCCr0-3), encompassing the recovery period after operation, free of rejections, did not correlate with the CADI (r = 0.230, P = 0.249). All AUCCr from 3 weeks onwards correlated with the CADI. The best correlation with the CADI was obtained with AUCCr from 3 to 12 weeks (AUCCr3-12) (r = 0.922, P = 0.0001). This interval coincides with the timing of all acute rejection episodes. AUCCr3-12 correlated equally well to end-point transplant function (r = 0.890, P = 0.0001).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Hyperlipidemia accelerates allograft arteriosclerosis (chronic rejection) in the rat

The relevance of hyperlipidemia in allograft arteriosclerosis (chronic rejection) is controversial. Isolated hypercholesterolemia induced with cholesterol-cholic acid-diet (CC-diet) or hypertriglyceridemia induced with glycerol-diet (G-diet) had no or only a protective effect on aortic allograft arteriosclerosis in the rat. Combined hyperlipidemia with both diets (CC+G-diet) enhanced allograft arteriosclerosis by doubling intimal thickness and cellularity (P < .05) but had no effect on host arteries. Compared with normolipidemic controls, the CC+G-diet increased the total serum cholesterol concentration 4.8-fold (P < .05). Levels of VLDL2 and IDL increased 4.8- and 18.1-fold (P < .05), and their composition changed from triglyceride-rich to cholesterol-rich lipoproteins in an atherogenic direction. The CC+G-diet had no effect on the structure of inflammation in the vascular wall. Instead, significant lipid deposits were observed, and the expression of epidermal growth factor and insulin-like growth factor-1 was significantly elevated in the vascular wall. Thus, elevations in VLDL and IDL lipoprotein levels and their cholesterol content associate with the generation of allograft arteriosclerosis in rats. Deposition of lipids in the vascular wall seems to induce local synthesis of certain growth factors, which ultimately leads to the induction of smooth muscle cell replication.

A method for typing polymorphism at the HLA-A locus using PCR amplification and immobilized oligonucleotide probes

We have developed a simple and rapid method for DNA typing of the HLA-A locus using PCR amplification and hybridization of the PCR product, labeled with biotinylated primers, to an array of immobilized oligonucleotide probes in a single hybridization reaction (reverse dot or line blot). A single primer set (RAP1007 and DB337) is used to specifically amplify a 990-bp fragment containing the HLA-A locus exons 1, 2, and 3 from genomic DNA. This primer set is locus-specific and amplifies all HLA-A alleles. A set of 51 sequence-specific oligonucleotide (SSO) probes, 25 for exon 2 and 26 for exon 3, was immobilized to a nylon membrane by UV-crosslinking oligonucleotide probes containing a poly-thymidine "tail" added with terminal transferase. In the line blot format, all 50 SSO probes plus a control probe are immobilized on a single nylon membrane strip. The probe array was used for typing in a hybridization reaction with DNA amplified from a variety of samples. These probes can identify 37 homozygous HLA-A alleles. In the analysis of heterozygous samples, 604 heterozygous types out of 633 (95.4%) possible heterozygous probe patterns can be detected as a unique probe reactivity pattern. A simple computer program has been developed to assign the alleles and genotypes based on the probe hybridization pattern.

Characteristics of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes after human heart transplantation. HLA mismatches and the cellular immune response within the transplanted heart

The influence of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient on the phenotypes, function, and specificity of T-lymphocyte cultures derived from endomyocardial biopsies was studied in 118 heart transplant recipients. In case of HLA-DR mismatches, the majority of the EMB-derived cultures were dominated by CD4+ T cells while, in patients with HLA-A and -B mismatches but without DR mismatches, CD8+ T cells comprised the predominant T-cell subset. Cytotoxicity against donor antigens was observed in 75% of the cultures. A significantly (p < 0.005) lower proportion of the cultures showed cytotoxicity against HLA-A antigens (36%) when compared with HLA-B (53%) or HLA-DR (49%). An HLA-A2 mismatch elicited a cytotoxic response that was comparable to that found against HLA-B and -DR antigens: 62% of the cultures from HLA-A2 mismatched donor-recipient combinations was reactive against A2. A higher number of A, B, or DR mismatches resulted in a higher number of cytotoxic cultures directed against these antigens. A higher number of HLA-B and -DR mismatches was associated with a lower freedom from rejection. Our data indicate that, despite the use of adequate immunosuppressive therapy, the degree of HLA matching plays a crucial role in the immune response against a transplanted heart, resulting in a significant effect on freedom from rejection.

The influence of HLA compatibility on graft survival after heart transplantation. The Collaborative Transplant Study

BACKGROUND

In cardiac transplantation, it is standard practice for donor hearts to be allocated to recipients without consideration of the extent of HLA matching. Because the HLA system is highly polymorphic, the likelihood that donor hearts will be well matched to their recipients by chance alone is extremely small. It has therefore not been possible in the past to analyze adequately the success rate of transplantation with HLA-matched hearts.

METHODS

We initiated a collaborative study in 1985 to evaluate the influence of HLA compatibility on graft survival in heart transplantation. Data were collected from 104 centers in 24 countries.

RESULTS

Of the 8331 patients, 128 received a graft with no HLA-A, B, or DR mismatches or only one mismatch. This frequency (1.5 percent) corresponds to the rate that would be expected from a random allocation of donor organs. The three-year rate of graft survival correlated strongly with HLA compatibility, decreasing from a mean (+/- SE) of 83 +/- 4 percent for the 128 donor hearts with no mismatches or only one mismatch to 76 +/- 2 percent for the 439 hearts with two mismatches and 71 +/- 1 percent for the 7764 hearts with three to six mismatches (P < 0.001). Multifactorial Cox regression analysis showed that this effect was independent of the age and sex of the donor and recipient, the type of underlying disease, the duration of cold ischemia, and the use of prophylaxis with antilymphocyte antibodies (P = 0.005).

CONCLUSIONS

Graft survival in heart transplantation is significantly influenced by the extent of HLA compatibility.