The three-spin intermediate at the O-O cleavage and proton-pumping junction in heme-Cu oxidases

High stability of the radical at the catalytic center of cytochrome c oxidase

In aerobic organisms, cellular respiration is associated with electron transfer through a respiratory system of membrane-bound complexes. This electron flow is terminated by the reduction of dioxygen to water by respiratory oxidases. Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is a widely distributed heme-copper-oxygen reductase (HCO) found in all mitochondria and some bacteria. However, the sequential reduction of O2 to water in CcO generates a protein-based radical at the catalytic heme a3-CuB site. To avoid the potential damage from the radical, CcO has apparently developed protective mechanisms. Protection by transfer of the highly oxidizing equivalent over considerable distances away from the catalytic site by redox-active Tyr/Trp chains has been previously demonstrated in bovine CcO. However, the rate of the radical migration from the catalytic center has not yet been determined for any HCO. In this work, we show that the radical escapes from the catalytic center of the ferryl PM intermediate of bovine CcO within minutes, which is much longer than the time of its functional reduction during cellular respiration. Apparently, this high stability has evolved to avoid the dissipation of energy released during the oxygen reduction with substrate electrons.

A Spectrochemical Series for Electron Spin Relaxation

Controlling the rate of electron spin relaxation in paramagnetic molecules is essential for contemporary applications in molecular magnetism and quantum information science. However, the physical mechanisms of spin relaxation remain incompletely understood, and new spectroscopic observables play an important role in evaluating spin dynamics mechanisms and structure-property relationships. Here, we use cryogenic magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) spectroscopy and pulse electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) in tandem to examine the impact of ligand field (d-d) excited states on spin relaxation rates. We employ a broad scope of square-planar Cu(II) compounds with varying ligand field strength, including CuS4, CuN4, CuN2O2, and CuO4 first coordination spheres. An unexpectedly strong correlation exists between spin relaxation rates and the average d-d excitation energy (R2 = 0.97). The relaxation rate trends as the inverse 11th power of the excited-state energies, whereas simplified theoretical models predict only an inverse second power dependence. These experimental results directly implicate ligand field excited states as playing a critical role in the ground-state spin relaxation mechanism. Furthermore, ligand field strength is revealed to be a particularly powerful design principle for spin dynamics, enabling formation of a spectrochemical series for spin relaxation.

Similarity between oxygen evolution in photosystem II and oxygen reduction in cytochrome c oxidase via proton coupled electron transfers. A unified view of the oxygenic life from four electron oxidation-reduction reactions

Basic concepts and theoretical foundations of broken symmetry (BS) and post BS methods for strongly correlated electron systems (SCES) such as electron-transfer (ET) diradical, multi-center polyradicals with spin frustration are described systematically to elucidate structures, bonding and reactivity of the high-valent transition metal oxo bonds in metalloenzymes: photosystem II (PSII) and cytochrome c oxidase (CcO). BS hybrid DFT (HDFT) and DLPNO coupled-cluster (CC) SD(T0) computations are performed to elucidate electronic and spin states of CaMn4Ox cluster in the key step for oxygen evolution, namely S4 [S3 with Mn(IV) = O + Tyr161-O radical] state of PSII and PM [Fe(IV) = O + HO-Cu(II) + Tyr161-O radical] step for oxygen reduction in CcO. The cycle of water oxidation catalyzed by the CaMn4Ox cluster in PSII and the cycle of oxygen reduction catalyzed by the CuA-Fea-Fea3-CuB cluster in CcO are examined on the theoretical grounds, elucidating similar concerted and/or stepwise proton transfer coupled electron transfer (PT-ET) processes for the four-electron oxidation in PSII and four-electron reduction in CcO. Interplay between theory and experiments have revealed that three electrons in the metal sites and one electron in tyrosine radical site are characteristic for PT-ET in these biological redox reaction systems, indicating no necessity of harmful Mn(V) = O and Fe(V) = O bonds with strong oxyl-radical character. Implications of the computational results are discussed in relation to design of artificial systems consisted of earth abundant transition metals for water oxidation.

A Bioinspired Nonheme FeIII-(O22-)-CuII Complex with an St = 1 Ground State

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is a heme copper oxidase (HCO) that catalyzes the natural reduction of oxygen to water. A profound understanding of some of the elementary steps leading to the intricate 4e-/4H+ reduction of O2 is presently lacking. A total spin St = 1 FeIII-(O22-)-CuII (IP) intermediate is proposed to reduce the overpotentials associated with the reductive O-O bond rupture by allowing electron transfer from a tyrosine moiety without the necessity of any spin-surface crossing. Direct evidence of the involvement of IP in the CcO catalytic cycle is, however, missing. A number of heme copper peroxido complexes have been prepared as synthetic models of IP, but all of them possess the catalytically nonrelevant St = 0 ground state resulting from antiferromagnetic coupling between the S = 1/2 FeIII and CuII centers. In a complete nonheme approach, we now report the spectroscopic characterization and reactivity of the FeIII-(O22-)-CuII intermediates 1 and 2, which differ only by a single -CH3 versus -H substituent on the central amine of the tridentate ligands binding to copper. Complex 1 with an end-on peroxido core and ferromagnetically (St = 1) coupled FeIII and CuII centers performs H-bonding-mediated O-O bond cleavage in the presence of phenol to generate oxoiron(IV) and exchange-coupled copper(II) and PhO• moieties. In contrast, the μ-η2:η1 peroxido complex 2, with a St = 0 ground state, is unreactive toward phenol. Thus, the implications for spin topology contributions to O-O bond cleavage, as proposed for the heme FeIII-(O22-)-CuII intermediate in CcO, can be extended to nonheme chemistry.

Membrane-Bound Redox Enzyme Cytochrome bd-I Promotes Carbon Monoxide-Resistant Escherichia coli Growth and Respiration

The terminal oxidases of bacterial aerobic respiratory chains are redox-active electrogenic enzymes that catalyze the four-electron reduction of O2 to 2H2O taking out electrons from quinol or cytochrome c. Living bacteria often deal with carbon monoxide (CO) which can act as both a signaling molecule and a poison. Bacterial terminal oxidases contain hemes; therefore, they are potential targets for CO. However, our knowledge of this issue is limited and contradictory. Here, we investigated the effect of CO on the cell growth and aerobic respiration of three different Escherichia coli mutants, each expressing only one terminal quinol oxidase: cytochrome bd-I, cytochrome bd-II, or cytochrome bo3. We found that following the addition of CO to bd-I-only cells, a minimal effect on growth was observed, whereas the growth of both bd-II-only and bo3-only strains was severely impaired. Consistently, the degree of resistance of aerobic respiration of bd-I-only cells to CO is high, as opposed to high CO sensitivity displayed by bd-II-only and bo3-only cells consuming O2. Such a difference between the oxidases in sensitivity to CO was also observed with isolated membranes of the mutants. Accordingly, O2 consumption of wild-type cells showed relatively low CO sensitivity under conditions favoring the expression of a bd-type oxidase.

Heme-copper and Heme O2-derived synthetic (bioinorganic) chemistry toward an understanding of cytochrome c oxidase dioxygen chemistry

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO), also widely known as mitochondrial electron-transport-chain complex IV, is a multi-subunit transmembrane protein responsible for catalyzing the last step of the electron transport chain, dioxygen reduction to water, which is essential to the establishment and maintenance of the membrane proton gradient that drives ATP synthesis. Although many intermediates in the CcO catalytic cycle have been spectroscopically and/or computationally authenticated, the specifics regarding the IP intermediate, hypothesized to be a heme-Cu (hydro)peroxo species whose O-O bond homolysis is supported by a hydrogen-bonding network of water molecules, are largely obscured by the fast kinetics of the A (FeIII-O2•-/CuI/Tyr) → PM (FeIV=O/CuII-OH/Tyr•) step. In this review, we have focused on the recent advancements in the design, development, and characterization of synthetic heme-peroxo‑copper model complexes, which can circumvent the abovementioned limitation, for the investigation of the formation of IP and its O-O cleavage chemistry. Novel findings regarding (a) proton and electron transfer (PT/ET) processes, together with their contributions to exogenous phenol induced O-O cleavage, (b) the stereo-electronic tunability of the secondary coordination sphere (especially hydrogen-bonding) on the geometric and spin state alteration of the heme-peroxo‑copper unit, and (c) a plausible mechanism for the Tyr-His cofactor biogenesis, are discussed in great detail. Additionally, since the ferric-superoxide and the ferryl-oxo (Compound II) species are critically involved in the CcO catalytic cycle, this review also highlights a few fundamental aspects of these heme-only (i.e., without copper) species, including the structural and reactivity influences of electron-donating trans-axial ligands and Lewis acid-promoted H-bonding.

Examination of 'high-energy' metastable state of the oxidized (OH) bovine cytochrome c oxidase: Proton uptake and reaction with H2O2

Reoxidized cytochrome c oxidase appears to be in a 'high-energy' metastable state (OH) in which part of the energy released in the redox reactions is stored. The OH is supposed to relax to the resting 'as purified' oxidized state (O) in a time exceeding 200 ms. The catalytic heme a3-CuB center of these two forms should differ in a protonation and ligation state and the transition of OH-to-O is suggested to be associated with a proton transfer into this center. Employing a stopped-flow and UV-Vis absorption spectroscopy we investigated a proton uptake during the predicted relaxation of OH. It is shown, using a pH indicator phenol red, that from the time when the oxidation of the fully reduced CcO is completed (∼25 ms) up to ∼10 min, there is no uptake of a proton from the external medium (pH 7.8). Moreover, interactions of the assumed OH, generated 100 ms after oxidation of the fully reduced CcO, and the O with H2O2 (1 mM), result in the formation of two ferryl intermediates of the catalytic center, P and F, with very similar kinetics and the amounts of the formed ferryl states in both cases. These results implicate that the relaxation time of the catalytic center during the OH-to-O transition is either shorter than 100 ms or there is no difference in the structure of heme a3-CuB center of these two forms.

Dioxygen and glucose force motion of the electron-transfer switch in the iron(III) flavohemoglobin-type nitric oxide dioxygenase

Kinetic and structural investigations of the flavohemoglobin-type NO dioxygenase have suggested critical roles for transient Fe(III)O2 complex formation and O2-forced movements affecting hydride transfer to the FAD cofactor and electron-transfer to the Fe(III)O2 complex. Stark-effect theory together with structural models and dipole and internal electrostatic field determinations provided a semi-quantitative spectroscopic method for investigating the proposed Fe(III)O2 complex and O2-forced movements. Deoxygenation of the enzyme causes Stark effects on the ferric heme Soret and charge-transfer bands revealing the Fe(III)O2 complex. Deoxygenation also elicits Stark effects on the FAD that expose forces and motions that create a more restricted NADH access to FAD for hydride transfer and switch electron-transfer off. Glucose also forces the enzyme toward an off state. Amino acid substitutions at the B10, E7, E11, G8, D5, and F7 positions influence the Stark effects of O2 on resting heme spin states and FAD consistent with the proposed roles of the side chains in the enzyme mechanism. Deoxygenation of ferric myoglobin and hemoglobin A also induces Stark effects on the hemes suggesting a common 'oxy-met' state. The ferric myoglobin and hemoglobin heme spectra are also glucose-responsive. A conserved glucose or glucose-6-phosphate binding site is found bridging the BC-corner and G-helix in flavohemoglobin and myoglobin suggesting novel allosteric effector roles for glucose or glucose-6-phosphate in the NO dioxygenase and O2 storage functions. The results support the proposed roles of a ferric O2 intermediate and protein motions in regulating electron-transfer during NO dioxygenase turnover.

A nucleotide-copper(II) complex possessing a monooxygenase-like catalytic function

The de novo design of artificial biocatalysts with enzyme-like active sites and catalytic functions has long been an attractive yet challenging goal. In this study, we present a nucleotide-Cu²⁺ complex, synthesized through a one-pot approach, capable of catalyzing ortho-hydroxylation reactions resembling those of minimalist monooxygenases. Both experimental and theoretical findings demonstrate that the catalyst, in which Cu²⁺ coordinates with both the nucleobase and phosphate moieties, forms a ternary-complex intermediate with H₂O₂ and tyramine substrates through multiple weak interactions. The subsequent electron transfer and hydrogen (or proton) transfer steps lead to the ortho-hydroxylation of tyramine, where the single copper center exhibits a similar function to natural dicopper sites. Moreover, Cu²⁺ bound to nucleotides or oligonucleotides exhibits thermophilic catalytic properties within the temperature range of 25 °C to 75 °C, while native enzymes are fully deactivated above 35 °C. This study may provide insights for the future design of oxidase-mimetic catalysts and serve as a guide for the design of primitive metallocentre-dependent enzymes.

Study and design of amino acid-based radical enzymes using unnatural amino acids

Radical enzymes harness the power of reactive radical species by placing them in a protein scaffold, and they are capable of catalysing many important reactions. New native radical enzymes, especially those with amino acid-based radicals, in the category of non-heme iron enzymes (including ribonucleotide reductases), heme enzymes, copper enzymes, and FAD-radical enzymes have been discovered and characterized. We discussed recent research efforts to discover new native amino acid-based radical enzymes, and to study the roles of radicals in processes such as enzyme catalysis and electron transfer. Furthermore, design of radical enzymes in a small and simple scaffold not only allows us to study the radical in a well-controlled system and test our understanding of the native enzymes, but also allows us to create powerful enzymes. In the study and design of amino acid-based radical enzymes, the use of unnatural amino acids allows precise control of pKa values and reduction potentials of the residue, as well as probing the location of the radical through spectroscopic methods, making it a powerful research tool. Our understanding of amino acid-based radical enzymes will allow us to tailor them to create powerful catalysts and better therapeutics.

Recent progress in experimental studies on the catalytic mechanism of cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) reduces molecular oxygen (O₂) to water, coupled with a proton pump from the N-side to the P-side, by receiving four electrons sequentially from the P-side to the O₂-reduction site-including Fe_a3 and Cu_B-via the two low potential metal sites; Cu_A and Fe_a. The catalytic cycle includes six intermediates as follows, R (Fe_a3 ²⁺, Cu_B ¹⁺, Tyr244OH), A (Fe_a3 ²⁺-O₂, Cu_B ¹⁺, Tyr244OH), P_m (Fe_a3 ⁴⁺ = O^2-, Cu_B ²⁺-OH^-, Tyr244O•), F (Fe_a3 ⁴⁺ = O^2-, Cu_B ²⁺-OH^-, Tyr244OH), O (Fe_a3 ³⁺-OH^-, Cu_B ²⁺-OH^-, Tyr244OH), and E (Fe_a3 ³⁺-OH^-, Cu_B ¹⁺-H₂O, Tyr244OH). CcO has three proton conducting pathways, D, K, and H. The D and K pathways connect the N-side surface with the O₂-reduction site, while the H-pathway is located across the protein from the N-side to the P-side. The proton pump is driven by electrostatic interactions between the protons to be pumped and the net positive charges created during the O₂ reduction. Two different proton pump proposals, each including either the D-pathway or H-pathway as the proton pumping site, were proposed approximately 30 years ago and continue to be under serious debate. In our view, the progress in understanding the reaction mechanism of CcO has been critically rate-limited by the resolution of its X-ray crystallographic structure. The improvement of the resolutions of the oxidized/reduced bovine CcO up to 1.5/1.6 Å resolution in 2016 provided a breakthrough in the understanding of the reaction mechanism of CcO. In this review, experimental studies on the reaction mechanism of CcO before the appearance of the 1.5/1.6 Å resolution X-ray structures are summarized as a background description. Following the summary, we will review the recent (since 2016) experimental findings which have significantly improved our understanding of the reaction mechanism of CcO including: 1) redox coupled structural changes of bovine CcO; 2) X-ray structures of all six intermediates; 3) spectroscopic findings on the intermediate species including the Tyr244 radical in the P_m form, a peroxide-bound form between the A and Pm forms, and F_r, a one-electron reduced F-form; 4) time resolved X-ray structural changes during the photolysis of CO-bound fully reduced CcO using XFEL; 5) a simulation analysis for the Pm→Pr→F transition.

Second-Sphere Hydrogen-Bond Donors and Acceptors Affect the Rate and Selectivity of Electrochemical Oxygen Reduction by Iron Porphyrins Differently

The factors that control the rate and selectivity of 4e^-/4H⁺ O₂ reduction are important for efficient energy transformation as well as for understanding the terminal step of respiration in aerobic organisms. Inspired by the design of naturally occurring enzymes which are efficient catalysts for O₂ and H₂O₂ reduction, several artificial systems have been generated where different second-sphere residues have been installed to enhance the rate and efficiency of the 4e^-/4H⁺ O₂ reduction. These include hydrogen-bonding residues like amines, carboxylates, ethers, amides, phenols, etc. In some cases, improvements in the catalysis were recorded, whereas in some cases improvements were marginal or nonexistent. In this work, we use an iron porphyrin complex with pendant 1,10-phenanthroline residues which show a pH-dependent variation of the rate of the electrochemical O₂ reduction reaction (ORR) over 2 orders of magnitude. In-situ surface-enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy reveals the presence of different intermediates at different pH's reflecting different rate-determining steps at different pH's. These data in conjunction with density functional theory calculations reveal that when the distal 1,10-phenanthroline is neutral it acts as a hydrogen-bond acceptor which stabilizes H₂O (product) binding to the active Fe^II state and retards the reaction. However, when the 1,10-phenanthroline is protonated, it acts as a hydrogen-bond donor which enhances O₂ reduction by stabilizing Fe^III-O₂^.- and Fe^III-OOH intermediates and activating the O-O bond for cleavage. On the basis of these data, general guidelines for controlling the different possible rate-determining steps in the complex multistep 4e^-/4H⁺ ORR are developed and a bioinspired principle-based design of an efficient electrochemical ORR is presented.

Second Sphere Interactions in Amyloidogenic Diseases

Amyloids are protein aggregates bearing a highly ordered cross β structural motif, which may be functional but are mostly pathogenic. Their formation, deposition in tissues and consequent organ dysfunction is the central event in amyloidogenic diseases. Such protein aggregation may be brought about by conformational changes, and much attention has been directed toward factors like metal binding, post-translational modifications, mutations of protein etc., which eventually affect the reactivity and cytotoxicity of the associated proteins. Over the past decade, a global effort from different groups working on these misfolded/unfolded proteins/peptides has revealed that the amino acid residues in the second coordination sphere of the active sites of amyloidogenic proteins/peptides cause changes in H-bonding pattern or protein-protein interactions, which dramatically alter the structure and reactivity of these proteins/peptides. These second sphere effects not only determine the binding of transition metals and cofactors, which define the pathology of some of these diseases, but also change the mechanism of redox reactions catalyzed by these proteins/peptides and form the basis of oxidative damage associated with these amyloidogenic diseases. The present review seeks to discuss such second sphere modifications and their ramifications in the etiopathology of some representative amyloidogenic diseases like Alzheimer's disease (AD), type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2Dm), Parkinson's disease (PD), Huntington's disease (HD), and prion diseases.

DFT Mechanistic Insights into Aldehyde Deformylations with Biomimetic Metal-Dioxygen Complexes: Distinct Mechanisms and Reaction Rules

Aldehyde deformylations occurring in organisms are catalyzed by metalloenzymes through metal-dioxygen active cores, attracting great interest to study small-molecule metal-dioxygen complexes for understanding relevant biological processes and developing biomimetic catalysts for aerobic transformations. As the known deformylation mechanisms, including nucleophilic attack, aldehyde α-H-atom abstraction, and aldehyde hydrogen atom abstraction, undergo outer-sphere pathways, we herein report a distinct inner-sphere mechanism based on density functional theory (DFT) mechanistic studies of aldehyde deformylations with a copper (II)-superoxo complex. The inner-sphere mechanism proceeds via a sequence mainly including aldehyde end-on coordination, homolytic aldehyde C-C bond cleavage, and dioxygen O-O bond cleavage, among which the C-C bond cleavage is the rate-determining step with a barrier substantially lower than those of outer-sphere pathways. The aldehyde C-C bond cleavage, enabled through the activation of the dioxygen ligand radical in a second-order nucleophilic substitution (S_N2)-like fashion, leads to an alkyl radical and facilitates the subsequent dioxygen O-O bond cleavage. Furthermore, we deduced the rules for the reactions of metal-dioxygen complexes with aldehydes and nitriles via the inner-sphere mechanism. Expectedly, our proposed inner-sphere mechanisms and the reaction rules offer another perspective to understand relevant biological processes involving metal-dioxygen cores and to discover metal-dioxygen catalysts for aerobic transformations.

Highly selective generation of singlet oxygen from dioxygen with atomically dispersed catalysts

Singlet oxygen (1O2) as an excited electronic state of O2 plays a significant role in the ubiquitous oxidative processes from enzymatic oxidative metabolism to industrial catalytic oxidation. Generally, 1O2 can...

The three-spin intermediate at the O-O cleavage and proton-pumping junction in heme-Cu oxidases

[Figure: see text].