Genomic and epigenomic BRCA alterations predict adaptive resistance and response to platinum-based therapy in patients with triple-negative breast and ovarian carcinomas

Advances in tumor subclone formation and mechanisms of growth and invasion

Tumor subclones refer to distinct cell populations within the same tumor that possess different genetic characteristics. They play a crucial role in understanding tumor heterogeneity, evolution, and therapeutic resistance. The formation of tumor subclones is driven by several key mechanisms, including the inherent genetic instability of tumor cells, which facilitates the accumulation of novel mutations; selective pressures from the tumor microenvironment and therapeutic interventions, which promote the expansion of certain subclones; and epigenetic modifications, such as DNA methylation and histone modifications, which alter gene expression patterns. Major methodologies for studying tumor subclones include single-cell sequencing, liquid biopsy, and spatial transcriptomics, which provide insights into clonal architecture and dynamic evolution. Beyond their direct involvement in tumor growth and invasion, subclones significantly contribute to tumor heterogeneity, immune evasion, and treatment resistance. Thus, an in-depth investigation of tumor subclones not only aids in guiding personalized precision therapy, overcoming drug resistance, and identifying novel therapeutic targets, but also enhances our ability to predict recurrence and metastasis risks while elucidating the mechanisms underlying tumor heterogeneity. The integration of artificial intelligence, big data analytics, and multi-omics technologies is expected to further advance research in tumor subclones, paving the way for novel strategies in cancer diagnosis and treatment. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of tumor subclone formation mechanisms, evolutionary models, analytical methods, and clinical implications, offering insights into precision oncology and future translational research.

Constitutional Epimutations: From Rare Events Toward Major Cancer Risk Factors?

Constitutional epimutations are epigenetic aberrations that arise in normal cells prenatally. Two major forms exist: secondary constitutional epimutations (SCEs), associated with cis-acting genetic aberrations, and primary constitutional epimutations (PCEs), for which no associated genetic aberrations were identified. Some SCEs have been associated with risk of cancer (MLH1 and MSH2 with colon or endometrial cancers, BRCA1 with familial breast and ovarian cancers), although such epimutations are rare, with a total of <100 cases reported. This contrasts recent findings for PCE, where low-level mosaic BRCA1 epimutations are recorded in 5%-10% of healthy females across all age groups, including newborns. BRCA1 PCEs predict an elevated risk of high-grade serous ovarian cancer and triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) and are estimated to account for about 20% of all TNBCs. A similarly high population frequency is observed for mosaic constitutional epimutations in MGMT, occurring as PCE or SCE, but not in MLH1. Contrasting BRCA1 and MLH1, a potential association with cancer risk for MGMT epimutations is yet unclear. In this review, we provide a summary of findings linking constitutional epimutations to cancer risk with emphasis on PCE. We also highlight challenges in detection of PCE exemplified by low-level mosaic epimutations in BRCA1 and indicate the need for further studies, hypothesizing that improved knowledge about PCE may add significantly to our understanding of cancer risk, carcinogenesis, and potentially development of other diseases as well.

Increased Synthetic Cytotoxicity of Combinatorial Chemoradiation Therapy in Homologous Recombination Deficient Tumors

PURPOSE

Homologous recombination deficient (HRD) tumors are exquisitely sensitive to platinum-based chemotherapy and when combined with radiation therapy (RT), leads to improved overall survival in multiple cancer types. Whether a subset of tumors with distinct molecular characteristics demonstrate increased benefit from cisplatin and RT (c-RT) is unclear. We hypothesized that HRD tumors, whether associated with BRCA mutations or genomic scars of HRD, exhibit exquisite sensitivity to c-RT, and that HRD may be a significant driver of c-RT benefit.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Sensitivity to c-RT was examined using isogenic and sporadic breast cancer cell lines. HRD was assessed using 4 assays: RT-induced Rad51 foci, a DR-GFP reporter assay, a genomic scar score (large-scale state transitions [LST]), and clonogenic survival assays. Whole-genome sequencing of 4 breast tumors from a phase 2 clinical trial of neoadjuvant c-RT in triple-negative breast cancer was performed and HRD was defined using HRDetect.

RESULTS

BRCA1/2 deficient cell lines displayed functional HRD based on the Rad51 functional assay, with c-RT to RT or cisplatin interaction ratios (IR) of 1.11 and 26.84 for the BRCA1 isogenic pair at 2 μM cisplatin and 6 Gy, respectively. The highest LST lines demonstrated HRD and synthetic cytotoxicity to c-RT with IR at 2 Gy and cisplatin 20 μM of 7.50, and the lowest LST line with IR of 0.65. Of 4 evaluable patients in the phase 2 trial, one achieved a pathologic complete response with corresponding HRD based on multiple genomic scar scores including HRDetect and LST scores, compared with patients without a pathologic complete response.

CONCLUSIONS

HRD breast cancers, whether identified by BRCA1/2 mutation status, functional tests, or mutational signatures, appear to be significantly more sensitive to c-RT compared with isogenic controls or tumors without HRD mutational signatures. HRD tumors may be exquisitely sensitive to c-RT which warrants further clinical investigation to guide a precision oncology approach.

Validation and Performance of Quantitative BRCA1 and RAD51C Promoter Hypermethylation Testing in Breast and Ovarian Cancers

Poly (adenosine diphosphate-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors represent a significant advancement in the treatment of epithelial ovarian cancer, triple-negative breast cancer, pancreatic cancer, and castrate-resistant prostate cancer, and they are poised to improve treatment in an increasing number of other cancer types. PARP inhibitor efficacy as monotherapy has been primarily observed in tumors with deleterious genetic variants in genes involved in the homologous recombination repair pathway. Tumors without these variants have also been shown to respond; notably, those with hypermethylation at all alleles of the BRCA1 or RAD51C promoter can respond to PARP inhibitors. These epigenetic biomarkers therefore represent a patient population that may also benefit from this targeted therapy. However, no robust test has been conducted to identify these biomarkers in routine clinical specimens that is amenable to implementation for decentralized testing. This study describes the analytical and clinical validation of a BRCA1 and RAD51C promoter methylation test that can be run with a single-day library preparation workflow for sequencing on any next-generation sequencing platform. The results show that this test can accurately quantitate the level of promoter methylation at the BRCA1 and RAD51C genes using formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded samples, even when the extracted DNA is extremely degraded or the input amount is limited. This test increases the precision of diagnostic tests aimed at identifying patients who are likely and unlikely to respond to PARP inhibitor therapy.

Patient-Derived Xenografts of Triple-Negative Breast Cancer Enable Deconvolution and Prediction of Chemotherapy Responses

Combination chemotherapy remains essential for clinical management of triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC). Consequently, responses to multiple single agents cannot be delineated at the single patient level, even though some patients might not require all drugs in the combination. Herein, we conduct multi-omic analyses of orthotopic TNBC patient-derived xenografts (PDXs) treated with single agent carboplatin, docetaxel, or the combination. Combination responses were usually no better than the best single agent, with enhanced response in only ~13% of PDX, and apparent antagonism in a comparable percentage. Single-omic comparisons showed largely non-overlapping results between genes associated with single agent and combination treatments that could be validated in independent patient cohorts. Multi-omic analyses of PDXs identified agent-specific biomarkers/biomarker combinations, nominating high Cytokeratin-5 (KRT5) as a general marker of responsiveness. Notably, integrating proteomic with transcriptomic data improved predictive modeling of pathologic complete response to combination chemotherapy. PDXs refractory to all treatments were enriched for signatures of dysregulated mitochondrial function. Targeting this process indirectly in a PDX with HDAC inhibition plus chemotherapy in vivo overcomes chemoresistance. These results suggest possible resistance mechanisms and therapeutic strategies in TNBC to overcome chemoresistance, and potentially allow optimization of chemotherapeutic regimens.

Mechanisms of tandem duplication in the cancer genome

Tandem duplications (TD) are among the most frequent type of structural variant (SV) in the cancer genome. They are characterized by a single breakpoint junction that defines the boundaries and the size of the duplicated segment. Cancer-associated TDs often increase oncogene copy number or disrupt tumor suppressor gene function, and thus have important roles in tumor evolution. TDs in cancer genomes fall into three classes, defined by the size of duplications, and are associated with distinct genetic drivers. In this review, we survey key features of cancer-related TDs and consider possible underlying mechanisms in relation to stressed DNA replication and the 3D organization of the S phase genome.

Patient-Derived Xenografts of Breast Cancer

Patient-derived xenografts (PDX) of breast cancer, obtained from the engraftment of tumour samples into immunodeficient mice, are the most effective preclinical models for studying the biology of human breast cancer and for the evaluation of new anti-cancer treatments. Notably, breast cancer PDX preserve the phenotypic and molecular characteristics of the donor tumours and reproduce the diversity of breast cancer. This preservation of breast cancer biology involves a number of different aspects, including tumour architecture and morphology, patterns of genomic alterations and gene expression, mutational status, and intra-tumour heterogeneity. For these reasons, these models have a strong predictive value in the translation of cancer therapeutics into clinical settings and can be considered as powerful and clinically relevant research tools for the identification of new treatments, mechanisms of drug resistance, and predictive biomarkers. PDX models have also been successfully used to analyse breast cancer metastasis and persister cancer cells surviving chemotherapy. Limitations of breast cancer PDX include the lack of a human immune system and the low take rate, especially for estrogen receptor (ER) and HER2-positive subtypes.

Molecular Subgroups of HRD Positive Ovarian Cancer and Their Prognostic Significance

Homologous recombination repair deficiency (HRD) is involved in the development of high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma (HGSOC) and its elevated sensitivity to platinum-based chemotherapy. To investigate the heterogeneity of the HRD-positive HGSOC we evaluated the HRD status, including BRCA mutations, genomic scar score, and methylation status of BRCA1/2 genes in 352 HGSOC specimens. We then divided the HRD-positive cohort into three molecular subgroups, the BRCA mutation cohort (BRCA+), BRCA1 methylation cohort (Meth+), and the rest of the HRD+ cohort (HRD+BRCA-Meth-), and evaluated their first-line chemotherapy response, benefit from olaparib, and progression-free survival (PFS). HRD-positive status was detected in 65% (228/352) of samples. The first group, BRCA+, accounted for 45% (102/228) of HRD positive cases and showed the best outcome in platinum therapy (ORR 96%), the highest olaparib benefit (p = 0.006) and the highest median PFS (46 months). The frequency of the second cohort, Meth+, among HRD-positive patients was 23% (52/228). Patients with Meth+ HGSOC showed a significantly poorer outcome, with a median PFS of 19 months, a significantly lower ORR to platinum therapy (84%) and a modest, but not significant, benefit from olaparib maintenance. The third HRD+BRCA-Meth- group accounted for 32% (74/228) of HRD-positive patients and showed an ORR to platinum therapy similar to that of the BRCA+ group (90%), a higher, but not statistically significant, benefit from olaparib and a median PFS of 23 months. In conclusion, Meth+ subgroup had poor outcomes in terms of chemotherapy response, olaparib benefit, and PFS compared to the other HRD+ subgroups, requiring a more thorough follow-up.

Genotype-Directed Synthetic Cytotoxicity of ATR Inhibition with Radiotherapy

PURPOSE

The importance of the DNA damage response in mediating effects of radiotherapy (RT) has galvanized efforts to target this pathway with radiosensitizers. Yet early clinical trials of this approach have failed to yield a benefit in unselected populations. We hypothesized that ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (Atm)-null tumors would demonstrate genotype-specific synergy between RT and an inhibitor of the DNA damage response protein ataxia-telangiectasia and Rad3-related (ATR) kinase.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We investigated the synergistic potential of the ATR inhibitor (ATRi) RP-3500 and RT in two Atm-null and isogenic murine models, both in vitro and in vivo. Staining of γ-H2AX foci, characterization of the immune response via flow cytometry, and tumor rechallenge experiments were performed to elucidate the mechanism of interaction. To examine genotype specificity, we tested the interaction of ATRi and RT in a Brca1-null model. Finally, patients with advanced cancer with ATM alterations were enrolled in a phase I/II clinical trial to validate preclinical findings.

RESULTS

Synergy between RP-3500 and RT was confirmed in Atm-null lines in vitro, characterized by an accumulation of DNA double-strand breaks. In vivo, Atm-null tumor models had higher rates of durable control with RT and ATRi than controls. In contrast, there was no synergy in tumors lacking Brca1. Analysis of the immunologic response indicated that efficacy is largely mediated by cell-intrinsic mechanisms. Lastly, early results from our clinical trial showed complete responses in patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Genotype-directed radiosensitization with ATRi and RT can unleash significant therapeutic benefit and could represent a novel approach to develop more effective combinatorial synthetic cytotoxic RT-based treatments. See related commentary by Schrank and Colbert, p. 5505.

Epigenetic editing of BRCA1 promoter increases cisplatin and olaparib sensitivity of ovarian cancer cells

Drug resistance is the primary contributor to the high mortality rate of ovarian cancer (OC). The loss of BRCA1/2 function is linked to drug sensitivity in OC cells. The aim of this study is to enhance the drug sensitivity of OC cells by inducing BRCA1 dysfunction through promoter epigenetic editing. Epigenetic regulatory regions within the BRCA1 promoter, affecting gene expression, were initially discerned through analysis of clinical samples. Subsequently, we designed and rigorously validated epigenetic editing tools. Ultimately, we evaluated the cisplatin and olaparib sensitivity of the OC cells after editing. The BRCA1 promoter contains two CpG-rich regions, with methylation of the region covering the transcription start site (TSS) strongly correlating with transcription and influencing OC development, prognosis, and homologous recombination (HR) defects. Targeting this region in OC cells using our designed epigenetic editing tools led to substantial and persistent DNA methylation changes, accompanied by significant reductions in H3K27ac histone modifications. This resulted in a notable suppression of BRCA1 expression and a decrease in HR repair capacity. Consequently, edited OC cells exhibited heightened sensitivity to cisplatin and olaparib, leading to increased apoptosis rates. Epigenetic inactivation of the BRCA1 promoter can enhance cisplatin and olaparib sensitivity of OC cells through a reduction in HR repair capacity, indicating the potential utility of epigenetic editing technology in sensitization therapy for OC.

A patient stratification signature mirrors the immunogenic potential of high grade serous ovarian cancers

BACKGROUND

While high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSC) has proven largely resistant to immunotherapy, sporadic incidents of partial and complete response have been observed in clinical trials and case reports. These observations suggest that a molecular basis for effective immunity may exist within a subpopulation of HGSC. Herein, we developed an algorithm, CONSTRU (Computing Prognostic Marker Dependencies by Successive Testing of Gene-Stratified Subgroups), to facilitate the discovery and characterization of molecular backgrounds of HGSC that confer resistance or susceptibility to protective anti-tumor immunity.

METHODS

We used CONSTRU to identify genes from tumor expression profiles that influence the prognostic power of an established immune cytolytic activity signature (CYTscore). From the identified genes, we developed a stratification signature (STRATsig) that partitioned patient populations into tertiles that varied markedly by CYTscore prognostic power. The tertile groups were then analyzed for distinguishing biological, clinical and immunological properties using integrative bioinformatics approaches.

RESULTS

Patient survival and molecular measures of immune suppression, evasion and dysfunction varied significantly across STRATsig tertiles in validation cohorts. Tumors comprising STRATsig tertile 1 (S-T1) showed no immune-survival benefit and displayed a hyper-immune suppressed state marked by activation of TGF-β, Wnt/β-catenin and adenosine-mediated immunosuppressive pathways, with concurrent T cell dysfunction, reduced potential for antigen presentation, and enrichment of cancer-associated fibroblasts. By contrast, S-T3 tumors exhibited diminished immunosuppressive signaling, heightened antigen presentation machinery, lowered T cell dysfunction, and a significant CYTscore-survival benefit that correlated with mutational burden in a manner consistent with anti-tumor immunoediting. These tumors also showed elevated activity of DNA damage/repair, cell cycle/proliferation and oxidative phosphorylation, and displayed greater proportions of Th1 CD4 + T cells. In these patients, but not those of S-T1 or S-T2, validated predictors of immunotherapy response were prognostic of longer patient survival. Further analyses showed that STRATsig tertile properties were not explained by known HGSC molecular or clinical subtypes or singular immune mechanisms.

CONCLUSIONS

STRATsig is a composite of parallel immunoregulatory pathways that mirrors tumor immunogenic potential. Approximately one-third of HGSC cases classify as S-T3 and display a hypo-immunosuppressed and antigenic molecular composition that favors immunologic tumor control. These patients may show heightened responsiveness to current immunotherapies.

High-level tumour methylation of BRCA1 and RAD51C is required for homologous recombination deficiency in solid cancers

In ovarian and breast cancer, promoter methylation of BRCA1 or RAD51C is a promising biomarker for PARP inhibitor response, as high levels lead to homologous recombination deficiency (HRD). Yet the extent and role of such methylation in other cancers is not clear. This study comprehensively investigated promoter methylation of eight homologous recombination repair genes across 23 solid cancer types. Here, we showed that BRCA1 methylated cancers were associated with reduced gene expression, loss of heterozygosity (LOH), TP53 mutations and genomic features of HRD. We identified BRCA1 methylation in 3% of the copy-number high subtype of endometrial cancer, and as a rare event in six other cancer types, including lung squamous cell, pancreatic, bladder and stomach cancer. RAD51C promoter methylation was widespread across multiple cancer types, but HRD features were only observed for cases which contained high-level tumour methylation and LOH of RAD51C. While RAD51C methylation was frequent in stomach adenocarcinoma (6%) and low-grade glioma (2.5%), it was mostly detected at a low tumour level, suggestive of heterozygous methylation, and was associated with CpG island methylator phenotype. Our findings indicate that high-level tumour methylation of BRCA1 and RAD51C should be explored as a PARP inhibitor biomarker across multiple cancers.

PARP Inhibitors for Breast Cancer Treatment: A Review

Importance

Poly(adenosine diphosphate-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors have revolutionized the treatment of patients with germline BRCA1/2-associated breast cancer, representing the first targeted therapy capable of improving outcomes in patients with hereditary tumors. However, resistance to PARP inhibitors occurs in almost all patients.

Observations

This narrative review summarizes the biological rationale behind the use of PARP inhibitors in breast cancer, as well as the available evidence, recent progress, and potential future applications of these agents. Recent studies have shown that the benefit of PARP inhibitors extends beyond patients with germline BRCA1/2-associated metastatic breast cancer to patients with somatic BRCA1/2 variants and to those with germline PALB2 alterations. Moreover, these agents proved to be effective both in the metastatic and adjuvant settings. However, patients with metastatic breast cancer usually do not achieve the long-term benefit from PARP inhibitors observed in other tumor types. Mechanisms of resistance have been identified, but how to effectively target them is largely unknown. Ongoing research is investigating both novel therapeutics and new combination strategies to overcome resistance. PARP1-selective inhibitors, by sparing the hematological toxic effects induced by the PARP2 blockade, are promising agents to be combined with chemotherapy, antibody-drug conjugates, and other targeted therapies.

Conclusions and Relevance

Although the efficacy of PARP inhibitors is well established, many questions persist. Future research should focus on identifying predictive biomarkers and therapeutic strategies to overcome resistance. Integrating well-designed translational efforts into all clinical studies is thereby crucial to laying the groundwork for future insights from ongoing research.

RAD51 as an immunohistochemistry-based marker of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor resistance in ovarian cancer

Objective

Effective functional biomarkers that can be readily used in clinical practice to predict poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor (PARPi) sensitivity are lacking. With the widespread adoption of PARPi maintenance therapy in ovarian cancer, particularly in patients with BRCA mutation or HR deficiencies, accurately identifying de novo or acquired resistance to PARPi has become critical in clinical practice. We investigated RAD51 immunohistochemistry (IHC) as a functional biomarker for predicting PARPi sensitivity in ovarian cancer.

Methods

Ovarian cancer patients who had received PARPi and had archival tissue samples prior to PARPi exposure ("pre-PARPi") and/or after progression on PARPi ("post-PARPi") were selected. RAD51 IHC expression was semi-quantitatively evaluated using the H-score in geminin (a G2/S phase marker)- and γH2AX (a DNA damage marker)-positive tissues. A RAD51 H-score of 20 was used as the cutoff value.

Results

In total, 72 samples from 56 patients were analyzed. The median RAD51 H-score was 20 (range: 0-90) overall, 10 (0-190) in pre-PARPi samples (n = 34), and 25 (1-170) in post-PARPi samples (n = 19). Among patients with BRCA mutations, RAD51-low patients had better progression-free survival (PFS) after PARPi treatment than RAD51-high patients (P = 0.029). No difference was found in PFS with respect to the genomic scar score (P = 0.930). Analysis of matched pre- and post-PARPi samples collected from 15 patients indicated an increase in the RAD51 H-score upon progression on PARPi, particularly among pre-PARPi low-RAD51-expressing patients.

Conclusion

RAD51 is a potential functional IHC biomarker of de novo and acquired PARPi resistance in BRCA-mutated ovarian cancer and can be used to fine-tune ovarian cancer treatment.

The Power and Promise of Patient-Derived Xenografts of Human Breast Cancer

In 2016, a group of researchers engaged in the development of patient-derived xenografts (PDXs) of human breast cancer provided a comprehensive review of the state of the field. In that review, they summarized the clinical problem that PDXs might address, the technical approaches to their generation (including a discussion of host animals and transplant conditions tested), and presented transplantation success (take) rates across groups and across transplantation conditions. At the time, there were just over 500 unique PDX models created by these investigators representing all three clinically defined subtypes (ER+, HER2+, and TNBC). Today, many of these PDX resources have at least doubled in size, and several more PDX development groups now exist, such that there may be well upward of 1000 PDX models of human breast cancer in existence worldwide. They also presented a series of open questions for the field. Many of these questions have been addressed. However, several remain open, or only partially addressed. Herein, we revisit these questions, and recount the progress that has been made in a number of areas with respect to generation, characterization, and use of PDXs in translational research, and re-present questions that remain open. These open questions, and others, are now being addressed not only by individual investigators, but also large, well-funded consortia including the PDXNet program of the National Cancer Institute in the United States, and the EuroPDX Consortium, an organization of PDX developers across Europe. Finally, we discuss the new opportunities in PDX-based research.

Single-Cell Unsaturated Lipid Profiling for Studying Chemoresistance Heterogeneity of Triple-Negative Breast Cancer Cells

Chemoresistance to triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) is a critical issue in clinical practice. Lipid metabolism takes a unique role in breast cancer cells; especially, unsaturated lipids involving cell membrane fluidity and peroxidation are highly remarked. At present, for the lack of a high-resolution molecular recognition platform at the single-cell level, it is still hard to systematically study chemoresistance heterogeneity based on lipid unsaturation proportion. By designing a single-cell mass spectrometry workflow based on CyESI-MS, we profiled the unsaturated lipids of TNBC cells to evaluate lipidomic remodeling under platinum stress. Profiling revealed the heterogeneity of the polyunsaturated lipid proportion of TNBC cells under cisplatin treatment. A cluster of cells identified by polyunsaturated lipid accumulation was found to be involved in platinum sensitivity. Furthermore, we found that the chemoresistance of TNBC cells could be regulated by fatty acid supplementation, which determinates the composition of unsaturated lipids. These discoveries provide insights for monitoring and controlling cellular unsaturated lipid proportions to overcome chemoresistance in breast cancer.

Wakefield M. The role of aberrant DNA methylation in cancer initiation and clinical impacts

Epigenetic alterations, including aberrant DNA methylation, are now recognized as bone fide hallmarks of cancer, which can contribute to cancer initiation, progression, therapy responses and therapy resistance. Methylation of gene promoters can have a range of impacts on cancer risk, clinical stratification and therapeutic outcomes. We provide several important examples of genes, which can be silenced or activated by promoter methylation and highlight their clinical implications. These include the mismatch DNA repair genes MLH1 and MSH2, homologous recombination DNA repair genes BRCA1 and RAD51C, the TERT oncogene and genes within the P15/P16/RB1/E2F tumour suppressor axis. We also discuss how these methylation changes might occur in the first place - whether in the context of the CpG island methylator phenotype or constitutional DNA methylation. The choice of assay used to measure methylation can have a significant impact on interpretation of methylation states, and some examples where this can influence clinical decision-making are presented. Aberrant DNA methylation patterns in circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA) are also showing great promise in the context of non-invasive cancer detection and monitoring using liquid biopsies; however, caution must be taken in interpreting these results in cases where constitutional methylation may be present. Thus, this review aims to provide researchers and clinicians with a comprehensive summary of this broad, but important subject, illustrating the potentials and pitfalls of assessing aberrant DNA methylation in cancer.

Hypermethylation of the BRCA2 gene promoter and its co-hypermethylation with the BRCA1 gene promoter in patients with breast cancer

BACKGROUND

The BRCA2 gene is an important tumour suppressor in breast cancer, and alterations in BRCA2 may lead to cancer progression. The aim of the study was to investigate the association of hypermethylation of the BRCA2 gene promoter and its co-hypermethylation with the BRCA1 gene promoter with the development and course of breast cancer in women.

METHODS

This study included 74 women with breast cancer (tumour tissue samples and peripheral blood) and 62 women without oncological pathology (peripheral blood) - control group.

RESULTS

Hypermethylation of the BRCA2 gene was significantly more frequently detected in the tumour tissue of women with breast cancer compared to their peripheral blood and peripheral blood of control subjects (p= 0.0006 and p= 0.00001, respectively). Hypermethylation of BRCA2 was more frequently detected in patients with breast cancer over the age of 50 and in patients with higher Ki67 expression levels (p= 0.045 and p= 0.045, respectively). There was a high frequency of unmethylated BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene combination in women of the control group compared to women with breast cancer, both in blood samples and tumour tissue samples (p= 0.014 and p= 0.00001, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Our study confirms the hypothesis that BRCA2 hypermethylation plays an important role in the pathogenesis of breast cancer and the importance of assessing its co-hypermethylation with BRCA1 in predicting the course of the disease.

Comparative Effectiveness Analysis of Treatment Strategies for Surgically Resectable Neuroendocrine Carcinoma of the Urinary Tract

BACKGROUND

Neoadjuvant chemotherapy (neoCTX) has been recommended as the optimal strategy in surgically resectable neuroendocrine carcinoma (NEC) of the urinary tract (NEC-URO).

OBJECTIVE

To determine the systemic therapy regimen and timing, which are most active against NEC-URO.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

We used our institutional historical clinical and pathological database to study 203 patients (cT2, 74%; cT3/4a, 22%; and cTx, 4%) with surgically resectable NEC-URO between November 1985 and May 2020. A total of 141 patients received neoCTX and 62 underwent initial radical surgery, 24 of whom received adjuvant CTX (adjCTX).

INTERVENTION

Neoadjuvant CTX with etoposide/cisplatin (EP), an alternating doublet of ifosfamide/doxorubicin (IA) and EP, dose-dense methotrexate/vinblastine/doxorubicin/cisplatin (MVAC), gemcitabine/cisplatin (GC), or others.

OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

Overall survival (OS), downstaging rate, and pathological complete response using a multivariable model adjusting for tumor- and patient-related factors.

RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS

Downstaging rate was significantly improved with neoCTX versus initial surgery (49.6% vs 14.5%, p < 0.0001), stage cT2N0 versus cT3/4N0 (44% vs 25%, p = 0.01), or presence of carcinoma in situ (47% vs 28%, p = 0.01). Downstaging was greatest with IA/EP (65%) versus EP (39%), MVAC/GC (27%), or others (36%, p = 0.04). After adjusting for age and Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status, IA/EP was still associated with improved downstaging (odds ratio = 3.7 [1.3-10.2], p = 0.01). At a median follow-up of 59.7 mo, 5-yr OS rates for neoCTX followed by surgery, surgery alone, and surgery followed by adjCTX were 57%, 22%, and 30%, respectively. An NEC regimen (IA/EP or EP) versus a urothelial regimen (MVAC/GC or others) was associated with improved survival (145.4 vs 42.5 mo, hazard ratio = 0.49, 95% confidence interval: 0.25-0.94).

CONCLUSIONS

Neoadjuvant CTX remains the standard-of-care treatment for NEC-URO with an advantage for NEC regimens over traditional urothelial regimens. IA/EP improves pathological downstaging at the time of surgery compared with EP, but is reserved for younger and higher function patients.

PATIENT SUMMARY

In this report, we looked at the outcomes from invasive neuroendocrine carcinoma of the urinary tract in a large US population. We found that the outcomes varied with treatment strategy. We conclude that the best outcomes are seen in patients treated with chemotherapy prior to surgery and regimens tailored to histology and tolerance.

The Impact of BRCA1 Expression on Survival Status in Ovarian Serous Carcinoma of Egyptian Patients

OBJECTIVES

The present study aimed to investigate the impact of BRCA1 protein expression on the patients' outcome of ovarian serous carcinoma, and its correlation with different clinicopathologic features.

METHODS

Immunohistochemistry with BRCA1 was done for 80 cases of ovarian serous carcinoma that had a positive family history. Correlation with clinico-pathologic variables and patients' outcomes was investigated.

RESULTS

BRCA1 expression was detected in 61.2% of the studied cases. A significant relation with patients' age, tumor grade and tumor stage was found (P<0.05). Also, there was a significant decrease in disease free survival (DFS) & overall survival (OS) in the positive BRCA1 group. Metastasis, recurrence, residual disease, and mortality rate showed significantly higher figures in patient with BRCA1 expression (P<0.05).

CONCLUSION

Positive BRCA1 expression had proven to be associated with advanced stage & grade of tumors, as well as worsened prognostic survival parameters (metastasis, recurrence, residual disease, and mortality) in patients with ovarian serous carcinoma.

Homologous Recombination Abnormalities Associated With BRCA1/2 Mutations as Predicted by Machine Learning of Targeted Next-Generation Sequencing Data

Background

Homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) is the hallmark of breast cancer gene 1/2 (BRCA1/2)-mutated tumors and the unique biomarker for predicting response to double-strand break (DSB)-inducing drugs. The demonstration of HRD in tumors with mutations in genes other than BRCA1/2 is considered the best biomarker of potential response to these DSB-inducer drugs.

Objectives

We explored the potential of developing a practical approach to predict in any tumor the presence of HRD that is similar to that seen in tumors with BRCA1/2 mutations using next-generation sequencing (NGS) along with machine learning (ML).

Design

We use copy number alteration (CNA) generated from routine-targeted NGS data along with a modified naïve Bayesian model for the prediction of the presence of HRD.

Methods

The CNA from NGS of 434 targeted genes was analyzed using CNVkit software to calculate the log2 of CNA changes. The log2 values of various sequencing reads (bins) were used in ML to train the system on predicting tumors with BRCA1/2 mutations and tumors with abnormalities similar to those detected in BRCA1/2 mutations.

Results

Using 31 breast or ovarian cancers with BRCA1/2 mutations and 84 tumors without mutations in any of 12 homologous recombination repair (HRR) genes, the ML demonstrated high sensitivity (90%, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 73%-97.5%) and specificity (98%, 95% CI = 90%-100%). Testing of 114 tumors with mutations in HRR genes other than BRCA1/2 showed 39% positivity for HRD similar to that seen in BRCA1/2. Testing 213 additional wild-type (WT) cancers showed HRD positivity similar to BRCA1/2 in 32% of cases. Correlation with proportional loss of heterozygosity (LOH) as determined using whole exome sequencing of 51 samples showed 90% (95% CI = 72%-97%) concordance. The approach was also validated in an independent set of 1312 consecutive tumor samples.

Conclusions

These data demonstrate that CNA when combined with ML can reliably predict the presence of BRCA1/2 level HRD with high specificity. Using BRCA1/2 mutant cases as gold standard, this ML can be used to predict HRD in cancers with mutations in other HRR genes as well as in WT tumors.

Immune checkpoint inhibitors in ovarian cancer: where do we go from here?

Epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC) is the most lethal gynaecological malignancy, and despite advancements in therapeutics, most women unfortunately still succumb to their disease. Immunotherapies, in particular immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI), have been therapeutically transformative in many tumour types, including gynaecological malignancies such as cervical and endometrial cancer. Unfortunately, these therapeutic successes have not been mirrored in ovarian cancer clinical studies. This review provides an overview of the ovarian tumour microenvironment (TME), particularly factors associated with survival, and explores current research into immunotherapeutic strategies in EOC, with an exploratory focus on novel therapeutics in navigating drug resistance.

Toward Practical Integration of Omic and Imaging Data in Co-Clinical Trials

Co-clinical trials are the concurrent or sequential evaluation of therapeutics in both patients clinically and patient-derived xenografts (PDX) pre-clinically, in a manner designed to match the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of the agent(s) used. The primary goal is to determine the degree to which PDX cohort responses recapitulate patient cohort responses at the phenotypic and molecular levels, such that pre-clinical and clinical trials can inform one another. A major issue is how to manage, integrate, and analyze the abundance of data generated across both spatial and temporal scales, as well as across species. To address this issue, we are developing MIRACCL (molecular and imaging response analysis of co-clinical trials), a web-based analytical tool. For prototyping, we simulated data for a co-clinical trial in "triple-negative" breast cancer (TNBC) by pairing pre- (T0) and on-treatment (T1) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) from the I-SPY2 trial, as well as PDX-based T0 and T1 MRI. Baseline (T0) and on-treatment (T1) RNA expression data were also simulated for TNBC and PDX. Image features derived from both datasets were cross-referenced to omic data to evaluate MIRACCL functionality for correlating and displaying MRI-based changes in tumor size, vascularity, and cellularity with changes in mRNA expression as a function of treatment.

Homologous recombination deficiency derived from whole-genome sequencing predicts platinum response in triple-negative breast cancers

The high frequency of homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) is the main rationale of testing platinum-based chemotherapy in triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC), however, the existing methods to identify HRD are controversial and there is a medical need for predictive biomarkers. We assess the in vivo response to platinum agents in 55 patient-derived xenografts (PDX) of TNBC to identify determinants of response. The HRD status, determined from whole genome sequencing, is highly predictive of platinum response. BRCA1 promoter methylation is not associated with response, in part due to residual BRCA1 gene expression and homologous recombination proficiency in different tumours showing mono-allelic methylation. Finally, in 2 cisplatin sensitive tumours we identify mutations in XRCC3 and ORC1 genes that are functionally validated in vitro. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that the genomic HRD is predictive of platinum response in a large cohort of TNBC PDX and identify alterations in XRCC3 and ORC1 genes driving cisplatin response.

Pyrosequencing Assay for BRCA1 Methylation Analysis: Results from a Cross-Validation Study

Epithelial ovarian cancers (EOCs) harboring germline or somatic pathogenic variants in BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes show sensitivity to poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibition. It has been suggested that BRCA1 promoter methylation is perhaps a better determinant of therapy response, because of its intrinsic dynamic feature, with respect to genomic scars or gene mutation. Conflicting evidence was reported so far, and the lack of a validated assay to measure promoter methylation was considered a main confounding factor in data interpretation. To contribute to the validation process of a pyrosequencing assay for BRCA1 promoter methylation, 109 EOCs from two Italian centers were reciprocally blindly investigated. By comparing two different pyrosequencing assays, addressing a partially overlapping region of BRCA1 promoter, an almost complete concordance of results was obtained. Moreover, the clinical relevance of this approach was also supported by the finding of BRCA1 transcript down-regulation in BRCA1-methylated EOCs. These findings could lead to the development of a simple and cheap pyrosequencing assay for diagnostics, easily applicable to formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues. This technique may be implemented in routine clinical practice in the near future to identify EOCs sensitive to poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor therapy, thus increasing the subset of women affected by EOCs who could benefit from such treatment.

BRCA1-methylated triple negative breast cancers previously exposed to neoadjuvant chemotherapy form RAD51 foci and respond poorly to olaparib

Background

About 15% of Triple-Negative-Breast-Cancer (TNBC) present silencing of the BRCA1 promoter methylation and are assumed to be Homologous Recombination Deficient (HRD). BRCA1-methylated (BRCA1-Me) TNBC could, thus, be eligible to treatment based on PARP-inhibitors or Platinum salts. However, their actual HRD status is discussed, as these tumors are suspected to develop resistance after chemotherapy exposure.

Methods

We interrogated the sensitivity to olaparib vs. carboplatin of 8 TNBC Patient-Derived Xenografts (PDX) models. Four PDX corresponded to BRCA1-Me, of which 3 were previously exposed to NeoAdjuvant-Chemotherapy (NACT). The remaining PDX models corresponded to two BRCA1-mutated (BRCA1-Mut) and two BRCA1-wild type PDX that were respectively included as positive and negative controls. The HRD status of our PDX models was assessed using both genomic signatures and the functional BRCA1 and RAD51 nuclear foci formation assay. To assess HR restoration associated with olaparib resistance, we studied pairs of BRCA1 deficient cell lines and their resistant subclones.

Results

The 3 BRCA1-Me PDX that had been exposed to NACT responded poorly to olaparib, likewise BRCA1-WT PDX. Contrastingly, 3 treatment-naïve BRCA1-deficient PDX (1 BRCA1-Me and 2 BRCA1-mutated) responded to olaparib. Noticeably, the three olaparib-responsive PDX scored negative for BRCA1- and RAD51-foci, whereas all non-responsive PDX models, including the 3 NACT-exposed BRCA1-Me PDX, scored positive for RAD51-foci. This suggested HRD in olaparib responsive PDX, while non-responsive models were HR proficient. These results were consistent with observations in cell lines showing a significant increase of RAD51-foci in olaparib-resistant subclones compared with sensitive parental cells, suggesting HR restoration in these models.

Conclusion

Our results thus support the notion that the actual HRD status of BRCA1-Me TNBC, especially if previously exposed to chemotherapy, may be questioned and should be verified using the BRCA1- and RAD51-foci assay.

Association between homologous recombination deficiency and outcomes with platinum and platinum-free chemotherapy in patients with triple-negative breast cancer

OBJECTIVE

The choice of chemotherapeutic regimen for triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) remains controversial. Homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) has attracted increasing attention in informing chemotherapy treatment. This study was aimed at investigating the feasibility of HRD as a clinically actionable biomarker for platinum-containing and platinum-free therapy.

METHODS

Chinese patients with TNBC who received chemotherapy between May 1, 2008 and March 31, 2020 were retrospectively analyzed with a customized 3D-HRD panel. HRD positivity was defined by an HRD score ≥ 30 or deleterious BRCA1/2 mutation. A total of 386 chemotherapy-treated patients with TNBC were screened from a surgical cohort (NCT01150513) and a metastatic cohort, and 189 patients with available clinical and tumor sequencing data were included.

RESULTS

In the entire cohort, 49.2% (93/189) of patients were identified as HRD positive (40 with deleterious BRCA1/2 mutations and 53 with BRCA1/2 intact with an HRD score of ≥ 30). In the first-line metastatic setting, platinum therapy was associated with longer median progression-free survival (mPFS) than platinum-free therapy [9.1 vs. 3.0 months; hazard ratio (HR), 0.43; 95% confidence interval 0.22-0.84; P = 0.01]. Among HRD-positive patients, the mPFS was significantly longer in those treated with platinum rather than platinum-free therapy (13.6 vs. 2.0 months; HR, 0.11; P = 0.001). Among patients administered a platinum-free regimen, HRD-negative patients showed a PFS significantly superior to that of HRD-positive patients (P = 0.02; treatment-biomarker P-interaction = 0.001). Similar results were observed in the BRCA1/2-intact subset. In the adjuvant setting, HRD-positive patients tended to benefit more from platinum chemotherapy than from platinum-free chemotherapy (P = 0.05, P-interaction = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

HRD characterization may guide decision-making regarding the use of platinum treatment in patients with TNBC in both adjuvant and metastatic settings.

Targeting Breast Cancer: An Overlook on Current Strategies

Breast cancer (BC) is one of the most widely diagnosed cancers and a leading cause of cancer death among women worldwide. Globally, BC is the second most frequent cancer and first most frequent gynecological one, affecting women with a relatively low case-mortality rate. Surgery, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy are the main treatments for BC, even though the latter are often not aways successful because of the common side effects and the damage caused to healthy tissues and organs. Aggressive and metastatic BCs are difficult to treat, thus new studies are needed in order to find new therapies and strategies for managing these diseases. In this review, we intend to give an overview of studies in this field, presenting the data from the literature concerning the classification of BCs and the drugs used in therapy for the treatment of BCs, along with drugs in clinical studies.

Distinct Mechanisms of Mismatch-Repair Deficiency Delineate Two Modes of Response to Anti-PD-1 Immunotherapy in Endometrial Carcinoma

Mismatch repair-deficient (MMRd) cancers have varied responses to immune-checkpoint blockade (ICB). We conducted a phase II clinical trial of the PD-1 inhibitor pembrolizumab in 24 patients with MMRd endometrial cancer (NCT02899793). Patients with mutational MMRd tumors (6 patients) had higher response rates and longer survival than those with epigenetic MMRd tumors (18 patients). Mutation burden was higher in tumors with mutational MMRd compared with epigenetic MMRd; however, within each category of MMRd, mutation burden was not correlated with ICB response. Pretreatment JAK1 mutations were not associated with primary resistance to pembrolizumab. Longitudinal single-cell RNA-seq of circulating immune cells revealed contrasting modes of antitumor immunity for mutational versus epigenetic MMRd cancers. Whereas effector CD8+ T cells correlated with regression of mutational MMRd tumors, activated CD16+ NK cells were associated with ICB-responsive epigenetic MMRd tumors. These data highlight the interplay between tumor-intrinsic and tumor-extrinsic factors that influence ICB response.

SIGNIFICANCE

The molecular mechanism of MMRd is associated with response to anti-PD-1 immunotherapy in endometrial carcinoma. Tumors with epigenetic MMRd or mutational MMRd are correlated with NK cell or CD8+ T cell-driven immunity, respectively. Classifying tumors by the mechanism of MMRd may inform clinical decision-making regarding cancer immunotherapy. This article is highlighted in the In This Issue feature, p. 247.

Epigenetic Mechanisms in Breast Adenocarcinoma: Novel DNA Methylation Patterns

Breast adenocarcinoma is a leading cause of death in females worldwide. A broad spectrum of genetic and epigenetic alterations has been already identified and reported in millions of examined cancerous substrates, evidence of a high-level genomic heterogeneity that characterizes these malignancies. Concerning epigenetic changes and imbalances that critically affect progression and prognosis in the corresponding patients, DNA methylation, histone modifications (acetylation), micro-RNAs (miRs) alterations and chromatin re-organization represent the main mechanisms. Referring to DNA methylation, promoter hyper-hypo methylation in critical tumour suppressor and oncogenes is implicated in normal epithelia transformation to their neoplastic and finally malignant cyto-phenotypes. The current review is focused on the different methylation patterns and mechanisms detected in breast adenocarcinoma and their impact on the corresponding groups of patient response to specific chemotherapeutic regimens and life span prognosis.

CDH1 (E-cadherin) Gene Methylation in Human Breast Cancer: Critical Appraisal of a Long and Twisted Story

Simple Summary

Genes can be inactivated by specific modifications of DNA bases, most often by adding a methyl group to the DNA base cytosine if it is followed by guanosine (CG methylation). This modification prevents gene expression and has been reported for many different genes in nearly all types of cancer. A prominent example is the gene CDH1, which encodes the cell-adhesion molecule E-cadherin. This is an important player in the spreading of tumor cells within the body (metastasis). Particularly in human breast cancer, many different research groups have studied the inactivation of the CDH1 gene via DNA methylation using various methods. Over the last 20 years, different, in part, even contradicting results have been published for the CDH1 gene in breast cancer. This review summarizes the most important publications and explains the bewildering heterogeneity of results through careful analysis of the methods which have been used.

Abstract

Epigenetic inactivation of a tumor suppressor gene by aberrant DNA methylation is a well-established defect in human tumor cells, complementing genetic inactivation by mutation (germline or somatic). In human breast cancer, aberrant gene methylation has diagnostic, prognostic, and predictive potential. A prominent example is the hypermethylation of the CDH1 gene, encoding the adhesion protein E-Cadherin (“epithelial cadherin”). In numerous publications, it is reported as frequently affected by gene methylation in human breast cancer. However, over more than two decades of research, contradictory results concerning CDH1 gene methylation in human breast cancer accumulated. Therefore, we review the available evidence for and against the role of DNA methylation of the CDH1 gene in human breast cancer and discuss in detail the methodological reasons for conflicting results, which are of general importance for the analysis of aberrant DNA methylation in human cancer specimens. Since the loss of E-cadherin protein expression is a hallmark of invasive lobular breast cancer (ILBC), special attention is paid to CDH1 gene methylation as a potential mechanism for loss of expression in this special subtype of human breast cancer. Proper understanding of the methodological basis is of utmost importance for the correct interpretation of results supposed to demonstrate the presence and clinical relevance of aberrant DNA methylation in cancer specimens.