Interactions between Brucella suis VirB8 and its homolog TraJ from the plasmid pSB102 underline the dynamic nature of type IV secretion systems

Uncovering the Hidden Credentials of Brucella Virulence

Bacteria in the genus Brucella are important human and veterinary pathogens. The abortion and infertility they cause in food animals produce economic hardships in areas where the disease has not been controlled, and human brucellosis is one of the world's most common zoonoses. Brucella strains have also been isolated from wildlife, but we know much less about the pathobiology and epidemiology of these infections than we do about brucellosis in domestic animals. The brucellae maintain predominantly an intracellular lifestyle in their mammalian hosts, and their ability to subvert the host immune response and survive and replicate in macrophages and placental trophoblasts underlies their success as pathogens. We are just beginning to understand how these bacteria evolved from a progenitor alphaproteobacterium with an environmental niche and diverged to become highly host-adapted and host-specific pathogens. Two important virulence determinants played critical roles in this evolution: (i) a type IV secretion system that secretes effector molecules into the host cell cytoplasm that direct the intracellular trafficking of the brucellae and modulate host immune responses and (ii) a lipopolysaccharide moiety which poorly stimulates host inflammatory responses. This review highlights what we presently know about how these and other virulence determinants contribute to Brucella pathogenesis. Gaining a better understanding of how the brucellae produce disease will provide us with information that can be used to design better strategies for preventing brucellosis in animals and for preventing and treating this disease in humans.

Conjugative Coupling Proteins and the Role of Their Domains in Conjugation, Secondary Structure and in vivo Subcellular Location

Type IV Coupling Proteins (T4CPs) are essential elements in many type IV secretion systems (T4SSs). The members of this family display sequence, length, and domain architecture heterogeneity, being the conserved Nucleotide-Binding Domain the motif that defines them. In addition, most T4CPs contain a Transmembrane Domain (TMD) in the amino end and an All-Alpha Domain facing the cytoplasm. Additionally, a few T4CPs present a variable domain at the carboxyl end. The structural paradigm of this family is TrwB_R388, the T4CP of conjugative plasmid R388. This protein has been widely studied, in particular the role of the TMD on the different characteristics of TrwB_R388. To gain knowledge about T4CPs and their TMD, in this work a chimeric protein containing the TMD of TraJ_pKM101 and the cytosolic domain of TrwB_R388 has been constructed. Additionally, one of the few T4CPs of mobilizable plasmids, MobB_CloDF13 of mobilizable plasmid CloDF13, together with its TMD-less mutant MobBΔTMD have been studied. Mating studies showed that the chimeric protein is functional in vivo and that it exerted negative dominance against the native proteins TrwB_R388 and TraJ_pKM101. Also, it was observed that the TMD of MobB_CloDF13 is essential for the mobilization of CloDF13 plasmid. Analysis of the secondary structure components showed that the presence of a heterologous TMD alters the structure of the cytosolic domain in the chimeric protein. On the contrary, the absence of the TMD in MobB_CloDF13 does not affect the secondary structure of its cytosolic domain. Subcellular localization studies showed that T4CPs have a unipolar or bipolar location, which is enhanced by the presence of the remaining proteins of the conjugative system. Unlike what has been described for TrwB_R388, the TMD is not an essential element for the polar location of MobB_CloDF13. The main conclusion is that the characteristics described for the paradigmatic TrwB_R388 T4CP should not be ascribed to the whole T4CP family. Specifically, it has been proven that the mobilizable plasmid-related MobB_CloDF13 presents different characteristics regarding the role of its TMD. This work will contribute to better understand the T4CP family, a key element in bacterial conjugation, the main mechanism responsible for antibiotic resistance spread.

VirB8 homolog TraE from plasmid pKM101 forms a hexameric ring structure and interacts with the VirB6 homolog TraD

The overproduction and purification of membrane proteins are intrinsically difficult, making their analysis challenging. We purified the TraE membrane protein from a bacterial conjugation system that is involved in plasmid transfer. Our results suggest that this protein forms hexamers with a central pore, and we also show that it binds to the TraD protein. The structure of TraE is completely different from that of the previously characterized periplasmic domain. This has intriguing implications for the role of TraE and of its interaction partner TraD in substrate translocation across the bacterial cell envelope. This work makes an important contribution to understanding of the mechanism of plasmid transfer, contributing to the design of approaches to inhibit the spread of antibiotic resistance genes.

Type IV secretion systems (T4SSs) are multiprotein assemblies that translocate macromolecules across the cell envelope of bacteria. X-ray crystallographic and electron microscopy (EM) analyses have increasingly provided structural information on individual T4SS components and on the entire complex. As of now, relatively little information has been available on the exact localization of the inner membrane-bound T4SS components, notably the mostly periplasmic VirB8 protein and the very hydrophobic VirB6 protein. We show here that the membrane-bound, full-length version of the VirB8 homolog TraE from the plasmid pKM101 secretion system forms a high-molecular-mass complex that is distinct from the previously characterized periplasmic portion of the protein that forms dimers. Full-length TraE was extracted from the membranes with detergents, and analysis by size-exclusion chromatography, cross-linking, and size exclusion chromatography (SEC) multiangle light scattering (MALS) shows that it forms a high-molecular-mass complex. EM and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) analysis demonstrate that full-length TraE forms a hexameric complex with a central pore. We also overproduced and purified the VirB6 homolog TraD and show by cross-linking, SEC, and EM that it binds to TraE. Our results suggest that TraE and TraD interact at the substrate translocation pore of the secretion system.

The type IV secretion system core component VirB8 interacts via the β1-strand with VirB10

In this work, we provide evidence for the interactions between VirB8 and VirB10, two core components of the type IV secretion system (T4SS). Using nuclear magnetic resonance experiments, we identified residues on the β1-strand of Brucella VirB8 that undergo chemical shift changes in the presence of VirB10. Bacterial two-hybrid experiments confirm the importance of the β1-strand, whereas phage display experiments suggest that the α2-helix of VirB8 may also contribute to the interaction with VirB10. Conjugation assays using the VirB8 homolog TraE as a model show that several residues on the β1-strand of TraE are important for T4SS function. Together, our results suggest that the β1-strand of VirB8-like proteins is essential for their interaction with VirB10 in the T4SS complex.

Use of chimeric type IV secretion systems to define contributions of outer membrane subassemblies for contact-dependent translocation

Recent studies have shown that conjugation systems of Gram-negative bacteria are composed of distinct inner and outer membrane core complexes (IMCs and OMCCs, respectively). Here, we characterized the OMCC by focusing first on a cap domain that forms a channel across the outer membrane. Strikingly, the OMCC caps of the Escherichia coli pKM101 Tra and Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB/VirD4 systems are completely dispensable for substrate transfer, but required for formation of conjugative pili. The pKM101 OMCC cap and extended pilus also are dispensable for activation of a Pseudomonas aeruginosa type VI secretion system (T6SS). Chimeric conjugation systems composed of the IMCpKM101 joined to OMCCs from the A. tumefaciens VirB/VirD4, E. coli R388 Trw, and Bordetella pertussis Ptl systems support conjugative DNA transfer in E. coli and trigger P. aeruginosa T6SS killing, but not pilus production. The A. tumefaciens VirB/VirD4 OMCC, solved by transmission electron microscopy, adopts a cage structure similar to the pKM101 OMCC. The findings establish that OMCCs are highly structurally and functionally conserved - but also intrinsically conformationally flexible - scaffolds for translocation channels. Furthermore, the OMCC cap and a pilus tip protein coregulate pilus extension but are not required for channel assembly or function.

Monomer-to-dimer transition of Brucella suis type IV secretion system component VirB8 induces conformational changes

Secretion systems are protein complexes essential for bacterial virulence and potential targets for antivirulence drugs. In the intracellular pathogen Brucella suis, a type IV secretion system mediates the translocation of virulence factors into host cells and it is essential for pathogenicity. VirB8 is a core component of the secretion system and dimerization is important for functionality of the protein complex. We set out to study dimerization and possible conformational changes of VirB8 from B. suis (VirB8s) using nuclear magnetic resonance, X-ray crystallography, and differential scanning fluorimetry. We identified changes of the protein induced by a concentration-dependent monomer-to-dimer transition of the periplasmic domain (VirB8sp). We also show that the presence of the detergent CHAPS alters several signals in the heteronuclear single quantum coherence (HSQC) spectra and some of these chemical shift changes correspond to those observed during monomer-dimer transition. X-ray analysis of a monomeric variant (VirB8sp^M102R ) demonstrates that significant structural changes occur in the protein's α-helical regions (α2 and α4). We localized chemical shift changes of residues at the dimer interface as well as to the α1 helix that links this interface to a surface groove that binds dimerization inhibitors. Fragment-based screening identified small molecules that bind to VirB8sp and two of them have differential binding affinity for wild-type and the VirB8sp^M102R variant underlining their different conformations. The observed chemical shift changes suggest conformational changes of VirB8s during monomer-dimer transition that may play a role during secretion system assembly or function and they provide insights into the mechanism of inhibitor action.

DATABASE

BMRB accession no. 26852 and PDB 5JBS.

Structural Analysis and Inhibition of TraE from the pKM101 Type IV Secretion System

Gram-negative bacteria use type IV secretion systems (T4SSs) for a variety of macromolecular transport processes that include the exchange of genetic material. The pKM101 plasmid encodes a T4SS similar to the well-studied model systems from Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Brucella suis Here, we studied the structure and function of TraE, a homolog of VirB8 that is an essential component of all T4SSs. Analysis by X-ray crystallography revealed a structure that is similar to other VirB8 homologs but displayed an altered dimerization interface. The dimerization interface observed in the X-ray structure was corroborated using the bacterial two-hybrid assay, biochemical characterization of the purified protein, and in vivo complementation, demonstrating that there are different modes of dimerization among VirB8 homologs. Analysis of interactions using the bacterial two-hybrid and cross-linking assays showed that TraE and its homologs from Agrobacterium, Brucella, and Helicobacter pylori form heterodimers. They also interact with heterologous VirB10 proteins, indicating a significant degree of plasticity in the protein-protein interactions of VirB8-like proteins. To further assess common features of VirB8-like proteins, we tested a series of small molecules derived from inhibitors of Brucella VirB8 dimerization. These molecules bound to TraE in vitro, docking predicted that they bind to a structurally conserved surface groove of the protein, and some of them inhibited pKM101 plasmid transfer. VirB8-like proteins thus share functionally important sites, and these can be exploited for the design of specific inhibitors of T4SS function.

VirB8-like protein TraH is crucial for DNA transfer in Enterococcus faecalis

Untreatable bacterial infections caused by a perpetual increase of antibiotic resistant strains represent a serious threat to human healthcare in the 21(st) century. Conjugative DNA transfer is the most important mechanism for antibiotic resistance and virulence gene dissemination among bacteria and is mediated by a protein complex, known as type IV secretion system (T4SS). The core of the T4SS is a multiprotein complex that spans the bacterial envelope as a channel for macromolecular secretion. We report the NMR structure and functional characterization of the transfer protein TraH encoded by the conjugative Gram-positive broad-host range plasmid pIP501. The structure exhibits a striking similarity to VirB8 proteins of Gram-negative secretion systems where they play an essential role in the scaffold of the secretion machinery. Considering TraM as the first VirB8-like protein discovered in pIP501, TraH represents the second protein affiliated with this family in the respective transfer operon. A markerless traH deletion in pIP501 resulted in a total loss of transfer in Enterococcus faecalis as compared with the pIP501 wild type (wt) plasmid, demonstrating that TraH is essential for pIP501 mediated conjugation. Moreover, oligomerization state and topology of TraH in the native membrane were determined providing insights in molecular organization of a Gram-positive T4SS.

Structural Biology of Bacterial Type IV Secretion Systems

Type IV secretion systems (T4SSs) are large multisubunit translocons, found in both gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria and in some archaea. These systems transport a diverse array of substrates from DNA and protein-DNA complexes to proteins, and play fundamental roles in both bacterial pathogenesis and bacterial adaptation to the cellular milieu in which bacteria live. This review describes the various biochemical and structural advances made toward understanding the biogenesis, architecture, and function of T4SSs.

The Brucella suis IbpA heat-shock chaperone is not required for virulence or for expression of the VirB type IV secretion system VirB8 protein

Brucella suis, facultative intracellular bacterial pathogen of mammals, and Agrobacterium tumefaciens, a plant pathogen, both use a VirB type IV secretion system (T4SS) to translocate effector molecules into host cells. HspL, an α-crystalline-type small heat-shock protein, acts as a chaperone for the Agrobacterium VirB8 protein, an essential component of the VirB system. An Agrobacterium mutant lacking hspL is attenuated due to a misfunctional T4SS. We have investigated whether IbpA (BRA0051), the Brucella HspL homologue, plays a similar role. Unlike HspL, IbpA does not interact with VirB8, and an IbpA mutant shows full virulence and no defect in VirB expression. These data show that the Brucella α-crystalline-type small heat-shock protein IbpA is not required for Brucella virulence.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF STUDY

Many bacteria use type IV secretion systems (T4SS), multi-protein machines, to translocate DNA and protein substrates across their envelope. Understanding how T4SS function is important as they play major roles in the spread of plasmids carrying antibiotic resistance and in pathogenicity. In the plant pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens, HspL, an α-crystalline-type small heat-shock protein, acts as a chaperone for the essential type IV secretion system component VirB8. Here, we show that this is not the case for all T4SS; in the zoonotic pathogen Brucella suis, IbpA, the protein most related to HspL, does not play this role.

Type IV secretion machinery: molecular architecture and function

Bacteria have evolved several secretion machineries to bring about transport of various virulence factors, nutrients, nucleic acids and cell-surface appendages that are essential for their pathogenesis. T4S (Type IV secretion) systems are versatile secretion systems found in various Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria and in few archaea. They are large multisubunit translocons secreting a diverse array of substrates varying in size and nature from monomeric proteins to nucleoprotein complexes. T4S systems have evolved from conjugation machineries and are implicated in antibiotic resistance gene transfer and transport of virulence factors in Legionella pneumophila causing Legionnaires’ disease, Brucella suis causing brucellosis and Helicobacter pylori causing gastroduodenal diseases. The best-studied are the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB/D4 and the Escherichia coli plasmid pKM101 T4S systems. Recent structural advances revealing the cryo-EM (electron microscopy) structure of the core translocation assembly and high-resolution structure of the outer-membrane pore of T4S systems have made paradigm shifts in the understanding of T4S systems. The present paper reviews the advances made in biochemical and structural studies and summarizes our current understanding of the molecular architecture of this mega-assembly.

Identification of the binding site of Brucella VirB8 interaction inhibitors

Secretion systems translocate virulence factors of many bacterial pathogens, enabling their survival inside the host organism. Consequently, inhibition strongly attenuates pathogenicity and can be considered a target for novel antimicrobial drugs. The type IV secretion system (T4SS) of the intracellular pathogen Brucella is a prerequisite for its virulence, and in this work we targeted the interactions of the essential assembly factor protein, VirB8, using small-molecule inhibitors. High-throughput screening identified several potent and specific inhibitors, and the target-binding site of these inhibitors was identified by X-ray crystallography, in silico docking, and analysis of the derivates of the inhibitor B8I-2. VirB8 interaction inhibitors bind to a surface groove opposite to the dimerization interface, and by varying the binding-site residues, we were able to determine which residues are required for inhibitor activity. E115 and K182 were found to be especially important, and changes at R114, Y229, and L151 also reduced inhibitor efficiency.

Restoring virulence to mutants lacking subunits of multiprotein machines: functional complementation of a Brucella virB5 mutant

Complementation for virulence of a non-polar virB5 mutant in Brucella suis 1330 was not possible using a pBBR-based plasmid but was with low copy vector pGL10. Presence of the pBBR-based replicon in wildtype B. suis had a dominant negative effect, leading to complete attenuation in J774 macrophages. This was due to pleiotropic effects on VirB protein expression due to multiple copies of the virB promoter region and over expression of VirB5. Functional complementation of mutants in individual components of multiprotein complexes such as bacterial secretion systems, are often problematic; this study highlights the importance of using a low copy vector.

The dimer interface of Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB8 is important for type IV secretion system function, stability, and association of VirB2 with the core complex

Type IV secretion systems are virulence factors used by many gram-negative bacteria to translocate macromolecules across the cell envelope. VirB8 is an essential inner membrane component of type IV secretion systems, and it is believed to form a homodimer. In the absence of VirB8, the levels of several other VirB proteins were reduced (VirB1, VirB3, VirB4, VirB5, VirB6, VirB7, and VirB11) in Agrobacterium tumefaciens, underlining its importance for complex stability. To assess the importance of dimerization, we changed residues at the predicted dimer interface (V97, A100, Q93, and E94) in order to strengthen or to abolish dimerization. We verified the impact of the changes on dimerization in vitro with purified V97 variants, followed by analysis of the in vivo consequences in a complemented virB8 deletion strain. Dimer formation was observed in vivo after the introduction of a cysteine residue at the predicted interface (V97C), and this variant supported DNA transfer, but the formation of elongated T pili was not detected by the standard pilus isolation technique. Variants with changes at V97 and A100 that weaken dimerization did not support type IV secretion system functions. The T-pilus component VirB2 cofractionated with high-molecular-mass core protein complexes extracted from the membranes, and the presence of VirB8 as well as its dimer interface were important for this association. We conclude that the VirB8 dimer interface is required for T4SS function, for the stabilization of many VirB proteins, and for targeting of VirB2 to the T-pilus assembly site.

Quantitative analysis of VirB8-VirB9-VirB10 interactions provides a dynamic model of type IV secretion system core complex assembly

Type IV secretion systems are multiprotein complexes that translocate macromolecules across the bacterial cell envelope. The type IV secretion system in Brucella species encodes 12 VirB proteins that permit this pathogen to translocate effectors into mammalian cells, where they contribute to its survival inside the host. The "core" complex proteins are conserved in all type IV secretion systems, and they are believed to form the channel for substrate translocation. We have investigated the in vitro interactions between the soluble periplasmic domains of three of these VirB components, VirB8, VirB9, and VirB10, using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays, circular dichroism, and surface plasmon resonance techniques. The in vitro experiments helped in the quantification of the self-association and binary interactions of VirB8, VirB9, and VirB10. Individually, distinct binding properties were revealed that may explain their biological functions, and collectively, we provide direct evidence of the in vitro formation of the VirB8-VirB9-VirB10 ternary complex. To assess the dynamics of these interactions in a simplified in vivo model of complex assembly, we applied the bacterial two-hybrid system in studying interactions between the full-length proteins. This approach demonstrated that VirB9 stimulates the self-association of VirB8 but inhibits VirB10-VirB10 and VirB8-VirB10 interaction. Analysis of a dimerization site variant of VirB8 (VirB8(M102R)) suggested that the interactions with VirB9 and VirB10 are independent of its self-association, which stabilizes VirB8 in this model assay. We propose a dynamic model for secretion system assembly in which VirB8 plays a role as an assembly factor that is not closely associated with the functional core complex comprising VirB9 and VirB10.

Biological diversity of prokaryotic type IV secretion systems

Type IV secretion systems (T4SS) translocate DNA and protein substrates across prokaryotic cell envelopes generally by a mechanism requiring direct contact with a target cell. Three types of T4SS have been described: (i) conjugation systems, operationally defined as machines that translocate DNA substrates intercellularly by a contact-dependent process; (ii) effector translocator systems, functioning to deliver proteins or other macromolecules to eukaryotic target cells; and (iii) DNA release/uptake systems, which translocate DNA to or from the extracellular milieu. Studies of a few paradigmatic systems, notably the conjugation systems of plasmids F, R388, RP4, and pKM101 and the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB/VirD4 system, have supplied important insights into the structure, function, and mechanism of action of type IV secretion machines. Information on these systems is updated, with emphasis on recent exciting structural advances. An underappreciated feature of T4SS, most notably of the conjugation subfamily, is that they are widely distributed among many species of gram-negative and -positive bacteria, wall-less bacteria, and the Archaea. Conjugation-mediated lateral gene transfer has shaped the genomes of most if not all prokaryotes over evolutionary time and also contributed in the short term to the dissemination of antibiotic resistance and other virulence traits among medically important pathogens. How have these machines adapted to function across envelopes of distantly related microorganisms? A survey of T4SS functioning in phylogenetically diverse species highlights the biological complexity of these translocation systems and identifies common mechanistic themes as well as novel adaptations for specialized purposes relating to the modulation of the donor-target cell interaction.