Messenger ribonucleic acid of dormant spores of Bacillus subtilis

Sporulation, Structure Assembly, and Germination in the Soil Bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis: Survival and Success in the Environment and the Insect Host

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) is a rod-shaped, Gram-positive soil bacterium that belongs to the phylum Firmicutes and the genus Bacillus. It is a spore-forming bacterium. During sporulation, it produces a wide range of crystalline proteins that are toxic to different orders of insects. Sporulation, structure assembly, and germination are essential stages in the cell cycle of B. thuringiensis. The majority of studies on these issues have focused on the model organism Bacillus subtilis, followed by Bacillus cereus and Bacillus anthracis. The machinery for sporulation and germination extrapolated to B. thuringiensis. However, in the light of recent findings concerning the role of the sporulation proteins (SPoVS), the germination receptors (Gr), and the cortical enzymes in Bt, the theory strengthened that conservation in sporulation, structure assembly, and germination programs drive the survival and success of B. thuringiensis in the environment and the insect host. In the present minireview, the latter pinpointed and reviewed.

Levels and Characteristics of mRNAs in Spores of Firmicute Species

Spores of firmicute species contain 100s of mRNAs, whose major function in Bacillus subtilis is to provide ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis when spores germinate. To determine if this is a general phenomenon, RNA was isolated from spores of multiple firmicute species and relative mRNA levels determined by transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq). Determination of RNA levels in single spores allowed calculation of RNA nucleotides/spore, and assuming mRNA is 3% of spore RNA indicated that only ∼6% of spore mRNAs were present at >1/spore. Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus atrophaeus, and Clostridioides difficile spores had 49, 42, and 51 mRNAs at >1/spore, and numbers of mRNAs at ≥1/spore were ∼10 to 50% higher in Geobacillus stearothermophilus and Bacillus thuringiensis Al Hakam spores and ∼4-fold higher in Bacillus megaterium spores. In all species, some to many abundant spore mRNAs (i) were transcribed by RNA polymerase with forespore-specific σ factors, (ii) encoded proteins that were homologs of those encoded by abundant B. subtilis spore mRNAs and are proteins in dormant spores, and (iii) were likely transcribed in the mother cell compartment of the sporulating cell. Analysis of the coverage of RNA-seq reads on mRNAs from all species suggested that abundant spore mRNAs were fragmented, as was confirmed by reverse transcriptase quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) analysis of abundant B. subtilis and C. difficile spore mRNAs. These data add to evidence indicating that the function of at least the great majority of mRNAs in all firmicute spores is to be degraded to generate ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis when spores germinate. IMPORTANCE Only ∼6% of mRNAs in spores of six firmicute species are at ≥1 molecule/spore, many abundant spore mRNAs encode proteins similar to B. subtilis spore proteins, and some abundant B. subtilis and C. difficile spore mRNAs were fragmented. Most of the abundant B. subtilis and other Bacillales spore mRNAs are transcribed under the control of the forespore-specific RNA polymerase σ factors, F or G, and these results may stimulate transcription analyses in developing spores of species other than B. subtilis. These findings, plus the absence of key nucleotide biosynthetic enzymes in spores, suggest that firmicute spores' abundant mRNAs are not translated when spores germinate but instead are degraded to generate ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis by the germinated spore.

Bacterial Spore mRNA - What's Up With That?

Bacteria belonging to the orders Bacillales and Clostridiales form spores in response to nutrient starvation. From a simplified morphological perspective, the spore can be considered as comprising a central protoplast or core, that is, enveloped sequentially by an inner membrane (IM), a peptidoglycan cortex, an outer membrane, and a proteinaceous coat. All of these structures are characterized by unique morphological and/or structural features, which collectively confer metabolic dormancy and properties of environmental resistance to the quiescent spore. These properties are maintained until the spore is stimulated to germinate, outgrow and form a new vegetative cell. Spore germination comprises a series of partially overlapping biochemical and biophysical events - efflux of ions from the core, rehydration and IM reorganization, disassembly of cortex and coat - all of which appear to take place in the absence of de novo ATP and protein synthesis. If the latter points are correct, why then do spores of all species examined to date contain a diverse range of mRNA molecules deposited within the spore core? Are some of these molecules "functional," serving as translationally active units that are required for efficient spore germination and outgrowth, or are they just remnants from sporulation whose sole purpose is to provide a reservoir of ribonucleotides for the newly outgrowing cell? What is the fate of these molecules during spore senescence, and indeed, are conditions within the spore core likely to provide any opportunity for changes in the transcriptional profile of the spore during dormancy? This review encompasses a historical perspective of spore ribonucleotide biology, from the earliest biochemical led analyses - some of which in hindsight have proved to be remarkably prescient - through the transcriptomic era at the turn of this century, to the latest next generation sequencing derived insights. We provide an overview of the key literature to facilitate reasoned responses to the aforementioned questions, and many others, prior to concluding by identifying the major outstanding issues in this crucial area of spore biology.

Integrative Analysis of Proteome and Transcriptome Dynamics during Bacillus subtilis Spore Revival

This study demonstrated the progress of macromolecular synthesis during Bacillus subtilis spore germination and outgrowth. The transcriptome analysis has additionally allowed us to trace gene expression during this transformation process. For the first time, the basic survival kit for spore-based life has been identified. In addition, in this analysis based on monitoring of protein levels in germinating and outgrowing spores, the transition from (ribo)nucleotide and amino acid biosynthesis to the restoration of all metabolic pathways can be clearly seen. The integrative multi-omics approach applied in this study thus has helped us to achieve a comprehensive overview of the molecular mechanisms at the basis of spore germination and outgrowth as well as to identify important knowledge gaps in need of further study.

Bacillus subtilis spores can reactivate their metabolism through germination upon contact with germinants and can develop into vegetative cells upon outgrowth. However, the mechanisms at the basis of the molecular machinery that triggers the spore germination and outgrowth processes are still largely unclear. To gain further insights into these processes, the transcriptome and proteome changes occurring during the conversion of spores to vegetative cells were analyzed in the present study. For each time point sampled, the changes in the spore proteome were quantitatively monitored relative to the proteome of metabolically ¹⁵N-labeled vegetative cells. Of the quantified proteins, 60% are shared by vegetative cells and spores, indicating that the spores have a minimal protein set, sufficient to resume metabolism upon completion of germination. These shared proteins thus represent the most basic “survival kit” for spore-based life. We observed no significant change in the proteome or the transcriptome until the spore’s completion of germination. Our analysis identified 34 abundant mRNA transcripts in the dormant spores, 31 of which are rapidly degraded after germination. In outgrowing spores, we identified 3,152 differentially expressed genes and have demonstrated the differential expression of 322 proteins with our mass spectrometry analyses. Our data also showed that 173 proteins from dormant spores, including both proteins unique to spores and proteins shared with vegetative cells, were lost after completion of germination. The observed diverse timings of synthesis of different protein sets in spore outgrowth revealed a putative core strategy underlying the revival of ‘life’ from the B. subtilis spore.

IMPORTANCE This study demonstrated the progress of macromolecular synthesis during Bacillus subtilis spore germination and outgrowth. The transcriptome analysis has additionally allowed us to trace gene expression during this transformation process. For the first time, the basic survival kit for spore-based life has been identified. In addition, in this analysis based on monitoring of protein levels in germinating and outgrowing spores, the transition from (ribo)nucleotide and amino acid biosynthesis to the restoration of all metabolic pathways can be clearly seen. The integrative multi-omics approach applied in this study thus has helped us to achieve a comprehensive overview of the molecular mechanisms at the basis of spore germination and outgrowth as well as to identify important knowledge gaps in need of further study.

Analysis of the mRNAs in Spores of Bacillus subtilis

Large-scale shotgun sequencing (RNA-seq) analysis of mRNAs in dormant Bacillus subtilis spores prepared on plates or in liquid generally found the same ∼46 abundant mRNA species, with >250 mRNAs detected at much lower abundances. Knowledge of the amount of phosphate in a single B. subtilis spore allowed calculation of the amount of mRNA in an individual spore as ∼10⁶ nucleotides (nt). Given the levels of abundant spore mRNAs compared to those of other mRNAs, it was calculated that the great majority of low-abundance mRNAs are present in only small fractions of spores in populations. Almost all of the most abundant spore mRNAs are encoded by genes expressed late in sporulation in the developing spore under the control of the forespore-specific RNA polymerase sigma factor, σ^G, and most of the encoded proteins are in spores. Levels of the most abundant spore mRNAs were also relatively stable for a week at 4°C after spore harvest. RNA-seq analysis of mRNAs in highly purified and less-well-purified spores made in liquid, as well as from spores that were chemically decoated to remove possible contaminating mRNA, indicated that low-abundance mRNAs in spores were not contaminants in purified spore preparations, and several sources of low-abundance mRNAs in spores are suggested. The function of at least the great majority of spore mRNAs seems most likely to be the generation of ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis by their degradation early in spore revival.IMPORTANCE Previous work indicates that dormant Bacillus subtilis spores have many hundreds of mRNAs, some of which are suggested to play roles in spores' "return to life" or revival. The present work finds only ∼46 mRNAs at ≥1 molecule spore, with others in only fractions of spores in populations, often very small fractions. Less-abundant spore mRNAs are not contaminants in spore preparations, but how spores accumulate them is not clear. Almost all abundant spore mRNAs are synthesized in the developing spore late in its development, most encode proteins in spores, and abundant mRNAs in spores are relatively stable at 4°C. These findings will have a major impact on thinking about the roles that spore mRNAs may play in spore revival.

TLR sensing of bacterial spore-associated RNA triggers host immune responses with detrimental effects

The spores of pathogenic bacteria are involved in host entry and the initial encounter with the host immune system. How bacterial spores interact with host immunity, however, remains poorly understood. Here, we show that the spores of Bacillus anthracis (BA), the etiologic agent of anthrax, possess an intrinsic ability to induce host immune responses. This immunostimulatory activity is attributable to high amounts of RNA present in the spore surface layer. RNA-sensing TLRs, TLR7, and TLR13 in mice and their human counterparts, are responsible for detecting and triggering the host cell response to BA spores, whereas TLR2 mediates the sensing of vegetative BA. BA spores, but not vegetative BA, induce type I IFN (IFN-I) production. Although TLR signaling in itself affords protection against BA, spore RNA-induced IFN-I signaling is disruptive to BA clearance. Our study suggests a role for bacterial spore-associated RNA in microbial pathogenesis and illustrates a little known aspect of interactions between the host and spore-forming bacteria.

Protein synthesis during cellular quiescence is inhibited by phosphorylation of a translational elongation factor

In nature, most organisms experience conditions that are suboptimal for growth. To survive, cells must fine-tune energy-demanding metabolic processes in response to nutrient availability. Here, we describe a novel mechanism by which protein synthesis in starved cells is down-regulated by phosphorylation of the universally conserved elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu). Phosphorylation impairs the essential GTPase activity of EF-Tu, thereby preventing its release from the ribosome. As a consequence, phosphorylated EF-Tu has a dominant-negative effect in elongation, resulting in the overall inhibition of protein synthesis. Importantly, this mechanism allows a quick and robust regulation of one of the most abundant cellular proteins. Given that the threonine that serves as the primary site of phosphorylation is conserved in all translational GTPases from bacteria to humans, this mechanism may have important implications for growth-rate control in phylogenetically diverse organisms.

Transcriptional analysis of temporal gene expression in germinating Clostridium difficile 630 endospores

Clostridium difficile is the leading cause of hospital acquired diarrhoea in industrialised countries. Under conditions that are not favourable for growth, the pathogen produces metabolically dormant endospores via asymmetric cell division. These are extremely resistant to both chemical and physical stress and provide the mechanism by which C. difficile can evade the potentially fatal consequences of exposure to heat, oxygen, alcohol, and certain disinfectants. Spores are the primary infective agent and must germinate to allow for vegetative cell growth and toxin production. While spore germination in Bacillus is well understood, little is known about C. difficile germination and outgrowth. Here we use genome-wide transcriptional analysis to elucidate the temporal gene expression patterns in C. difficile 630 endospore germination. We have optimized methods for large scale production and purification of spores. The germination characteristics of purified spores have been characterized and RNA extraction protocols have been optimized. Gene expression was highly dynamic during germination and outgrowth, and was found to involve a large number of genes. Using this genome-wide, microarray approach we have identified 511 genes that are significantly up- or down-regulated during C. difficile germination (p≤0.01). A number of functional groups of genes appeared to be co-regulated. These included transport, protein synthesis and secretion, motility and chemotaxis as well as cell wall biogenesis. These data give insight into how C. difficile re-establishes its metabolism, re-builds the basic structures of the vegetative cell and resumes growth.

Functional gene surveys from ocean drilling expeditions - a review and perspective

The vast majority of microbes inhabiting the subseafloor remain uncultivated and their energy sources unknown. Thus, a focus of ocean drilling expeditions over the past decade has been to characterize the distribution of microbes associated with specific metabolic reactions. An important question has been whether microbes involved in key microbial processes, such as sulfate reduction and methanogenesis, differ fundamentally from their counterparts in surface environments. To this end, functional genes of anaerobic methane cycling (mcrA), sulfate reduction (dsrAB), acetogenesis (fhs), and dehalorespiration (rdhA) have been examined. A compilation of existing functional gene data suggests that subseafloor microbes involved in anaerobic methane cycling, sulfate reduction, acetogenesis, and dehalorespiration are not fundamentally different from their counterparts in the surface world. Moreover, quantifications of mcrA and dsrAB suggest that, unless the majority of subseafloor microbes involved in methane cycling and sulfate reduction are too genetically divergent to be detected with conventional methods, these processes only support a small fraction (< 1%) of total microbial biomass in the deep biosphere. Ecological explanations for the observed trends, target processes and methods for future investigations, and strategies for tackling the unresolved issue of microbial contamination in samples obtained by ocean drilling are discussed.

Array-based transcriptional analysis of Clostridium sporogenes UC9000 during germination, cell outgrowth and vegetative life

The members of the genus Clostridium, including the spore-forming anaerobic bacteria, have a complex and strictly regulated life cycle, but very little is known about the genetic pathways involved in the different stages of their life cycle. Clostridium sporogenes, a Gram-positive bacterium usually involved in food spoilage and frequently isolated from late blowing cheese, is genetically indistinguishable from the proteolytic Clostridium botulinum. As the non-neurotoxic counterpart, it is often used as an exemplar for the toxic subtypes. In this work, we performed a microscopic study combined with a custom array-based analysis of the C. sporogenes cycle, from dormant spores to the early stationary phase. We identified a total of 211 transcripts in spores, validating the hypothesis that mRNAs are abundant in spores and the pattern of mRNA expression is strikingly different from that present in growing cells. The spore transcripts included genes responsible for different life-sustaining functions, suggesting there was transcript entrapment or basic poly-functional gene activation for future steps. In addition, 3 h after the beginning of the germination process, 20% of the total up-regulated genes were temporally expressed in germinating spores. The vegetative condition appeared to be more active in terms of gene transcription and protein synthesis than the spore, and genes coding for germination and sporulation factors seemed to be expressed at this point. These results suggest that spores are not silent entities, and a broader knowledge of the genetic pathways involved in the Clostridium life cycle could provide a better understanding of pathogenic clostridia types.

The genome and transcriptomes of the anti-tumor agent Clostridium novyi-NT

Bacteriolytic anti-cancer therapies employ attenuated bacterial strains that selectively proliferate within tumors. Clostridium novyi-NT spores represent one of the most promising of these agents, as they generate potent anti-tumor effects in experimental animals. We have determined the 2.55-Mb genomic sequence of C. novyi-NT, identifying a new type of transposition and 139 genes that do not have homologs in other bacteria. The genomic sequence was used to facilitate the detection of transcripts expressed at various stages of the life cycle of this bacterium in vitro as well as in infections of tumors in vivo. Through this analysis, we found that C. novyi-NT spores contained mRNA and that the spore transcripts were distinct from those in vegetative forms of the bacterium.

Two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of proteins synthesized during early germination of Bacillus subtilis 168 in the presence of actinomycin D

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to demonstrate the synthesis of approximately 65 [35S]-methionine-labelled soluble proteins between 0 and 10 min after the start of germination, of approximately 210 proteins at 10-20 min, and of approximately 260 proteins during vegetative growth of Bacillus subtilis. When actinomycin D and [35S]-methionine were administered at the onset of germination and the proteins synthesized during the subsequent 15 min were analyzed, two proteins were detected, and were designated protein I and protein II. Immunoblot analysis with an antiserum raised against RNA polymerase from Escherichia coli demonstrated that protein II corresponded to the sigma A factor of Bacillus subtilis. Thus, the sigma A factor is synthesized during early germination of Bacillus subtilis in the presence of actinomycin D.

Fractionation of ribonucleic acid transcripts synthesized during spore germination in Bacillus subtilis

Transcription was found to proceed stepwise during germination of Bacillus subtilis spores. Three distinct phases were evident with respect to pulse-labelled RNA synthesis and the RNA species synthesized. At the early stage of germination (Gm 1:0-15 min), RNA synthesis started in about 5 min and increased linearly when 1 min pulse-labelling with 3H-uridine was used. RNA molecules of relatively low molecular weight (LMW) 4S, 4.5S, 5S, LMW I, II, III, VII RNAs and so on were mainly synthesized during this stage. The relative synthesis of 16S and 23S rRNA was suppressed considerably at Gm 1. This suppression was eliminated by the mid stage of germination (Gm 2:15 to 40 min). Pulse-labelled RNA synthesis took on a constant level for about 20 min (Gm 2). The relative amounts of LMW I, II, III and VI RNAs in an aliquot (10,000 cpm) decreased at Gm 2. Gm 2 was followed by a tremendous increase in the pulse-labelled RNA synthesis (Gm 3 and outgrowth). The transition from Gm 1 to Gm 2 was inhibited by chloramphenicol. LMW I, III, and VI RNAs were densely banded at Gm 2 on administration of chloramphenicol. These results strongly suggested that transcription may be positively regulated at an early stage of germination. Possible positive factor(s) involved in this regulation are discussed.

[Molecular biology of the germination of Bacillus spores]

The review deals with recent results and problems of gene expression during germination of Bacillus spores. Three problems were selected: 1. The activation of metabolism as a prerequisite for the synthesis of nucleic acids and proteins. 2. The activation of nucleic acid and protein synthesis during germination. 3. The gene expression programme of germinating spores. Using the highly sensitive two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel analysis three major classes of proteins were distinguished, depending on the time of onset and duration of their syntheses: a) proteins made throughout germination (main class), b) proteins whose synthesis started only after a lag phase and then continued throughout germination, and c) proteins which are synthesized only during the early phases of germination. The programme of protein synthesis is an indicator for the control of gene expression during germination. The regulation of expression of these major gene groups during spore outgrowth is discussed.

Asymmetric transcription during post-germinative development of Bacillus subtilis spores. II. Hybrid competition analyses

Hybrid-competition analyses were done to estimate the relatedness of 3H-labeled mRNA species synthesized during spore germination and log-phase growth. The competitions showed that early in the germination process 10--15 and 1--3% of the RNA transcribed from the H and from the L strand, respectively, were unique and absent during log-phase growth. At later stages, the amounts of the germination-specific H transcripts decreased more rapidly than the L transcripts. The competitions with pulse-labeled log-phase RNAs showed that vegetative genes were transcribed more rapidly from the H strand than from the L strand. Most of the results could be correlated with the observed decrease in the H/L asymmetry ration during spore germination.

Hybridization analysis of restriction endonuclease DNA fragments of Bacillus cereus transcribed during spore outgrowth

Transcribing Bacillus cereus DNA was visualized by means of autoradiography of electrophoretically separated EcoRI restriction endonuclease DNA fragments hybridizing 32P-labeled RNA. Hybridization of RNA of dormant spores, vegetative cells, and outgrowing spores indicates the following. (i) A large fraction of the nonribosomal RNA in dormant spores is transcribed at a limited number of regions on the bacterial chromosome. (ii) After induction of spore germination, transcription activity is not limited to a single short region on the chromosome, but rather is distributed along the chromosome. The DNA/RNA hybridization technique has been used to identify restriction endonuclease DNA fragments homologous to RNA species that are present in dormant spores but absent from vegetative cells, RNA species that are synthesized immediately after germination induction and are present at a relatively low concentration in vegetative cells, and RNA species that are transcribed at a late stage of outgrowth but are absent or present at low concentration at an early stage of outgrowth.

Ribonucleic acid polymerase of germinating Bacillus cereus T

It appears that a de novo synthesis of the deoxyribonucleic acid-dependent ribonucleic acid-polymerase in Bacillus cereus T takes place fairly late in outgrowth, at the onset of the vegetative cycle. Therefore, the ribonucleic acid-polymerase used by germinating spores is the one carried on from sporulating cells. However, the sporal enzyme is less soluble that the vegetative one, and its "core" is bound to two extra peptides. This complexing to other molecules could play a role in the regulation of gene expression during germination.

Nucleic acid synthesis and ribonucleic acid polymerase specificity in germinating and outgrowing spores of Bacillus subtilis

Nucleic acid synthesis was studied during germination and outgrowth of normal spores of Bacillus subtilis, as well as of spores carrying the genome of phage phie. In a system in which development was restricted to the spore-darkening phase, synthesis of ribonucleic acid (RNA), but not deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), was detected. The extent of RNA synthesis and turnover, during this phase was similar for the two types of spores. In a partially darkened population of spores of either type, there was little RNA degradation, whereas there was considerable turnover in a fully darkened population. The DNA-dependent RNA polymerase of dormant or dark spores was not active in vitro with phi DNA as template, although a sigma-like factor could be separated from the polymerizing activity by zone centrifugation. Within 40 min after resuspension of dark spores in a medium that allows outgrowth, the enzyme acquired the ability to transcribe the phage DNA efficiently. During outgrowth, both normal and carrier spores synthesized DNA, but in carrier spores this DNA was almost entirely phage specific. The pattern of RNA accumulation in normal spores was in two distinct phase (0 to 60 min and 90 to 180 min). The second phase was absent in outgrowing carrier spores. The burst of phage in carrier spores occurred at 160 to 180 min.

New transfer ribonucleic acid species during sporulation of Bacillus subtilis

The transfer ribonucleic acid (tRNA) populations from log-phase cells, sporulating cells (stage III), and dormant spores were compared by tRNA-deoxyribonucleic acid hybridization techniques. New tRNA species not found in log-phase cells were observed in stage III cells. Some of the tRNA made during sporulation were also present in dormant spores. Although the role and function of these new tRNA species cannot be ascribed directly to the sporulation process, their presence indicates that new tRNA genes can be transcribed during sporulation and suggests that translational control may be exerted during sporulation by tRNA.