Nonrandom minichromosome replication in Escherichia coli K-12

Initiation of DNA Replication

In recent years it has become clear that complex regulatory circuits control the initiation step of DNA replication by directing the assembly of a multicomponent molecular machine (the orisome) that separates DNA strands and loads replicative helicase at oriC, the unique chromosomal origin of replication. This chapter discusses recent efforts to understand the regulated protein-DNA interactions that are responsible for properly timed initiation of chromosome replication. It reviews information about newly identified nucleotide sequence features within Escherichia coli oriC and the new structural and biochemical attributes of the bacterial initiator protein DnaA. It also discusses the coordinated mechanisms that prevent improperly timed DNA replication. Identification of the genes that encoded the initiators came from studies on temperature-sensitive, conditional-lethal mutants of E. coli, in which two DNA replication-defective phenotypes, "immediate stop" mutants and "delayed stop" mutants, were identified. The kinetics of the delayed stop mutants suggested that the defective gene products were required specifically for the initiation step of DNA synthesis, and subsequently, two genes, dnaA and dnaC, were identified. The DnaA protein is the bacterial initiator, and in E. coli, the DnaC protein is required to load replicative helicase. Regulation of DnaA accessibility to oriC, the ordered assembly and disassembly of a multi-DnaA complex at oriC, and the means by which DnaA unwinds oriC remain important questions to be answered and the chapter discusses the current state of knowledge on these topics.

Host controlled plasmid replication: Escherichia coli minichromosomes

Escherichia coli minichromosomes are plasmids replicating exclusively from a cloned copy of oriC, the chromosomal origin of replication. They are therefore subject to the same types of replication control as imposed on the chromosome. Unlike natural plasmid replicons, minichromosomes do not adjust their replication rate to the cellular copy number and they do not contain information for active partitioning at cell division. Analysis of mutant strains where minichromosomes cannot be established suggest that their mere existence is dependent on the factors that ensure timely once per cell cycle initiation of replication. These observations indicate that replication initiation in E. coli is normally controlled in such a way that all copies of oriC contained within the cell, chromosomal and minichromosomal, are initiated within a fairly short time interval of the cell cycle. Furthermore, both replication and segregation of the bacterial chromosome seem to be controlled by sequences outside the origin itself.

Feedback controls restrain the initiation of Escherichia coli chromosomal replication

In Escherichia coli, initiation of chromosomal replication is activated by a nucleoprotein complex formed primarily between the DnaA protein and oriC (replication origin) DNA. After replicational initiation, this complex has to be inactivated in order to repress the appearance of initiation events until the next scheduled round of initiation. Studies of the mechanisms responsible for this repression have recently revealed direct coupling between these mechanisms and key elements of the replication process, suggesting that feedback-type regulatory loops exist between the factors implicated in initiation and the elements yielded by the replication process. The loading of the ring-shaped beta-subunit of DNA polymerase III onto DNA plays a key role in the inactivation of the DnaA protein. Duplication of oriC DNA results in hemimethylated DNA, which is inert for reinitiation. Titration of large amounts of DnaA protein to a non-oriC locus can repress untimely initiations, and timely duplication of this locus is required for this repression in rapidly growing cells. All these systems functionally complement one another to ensure the maintenance of the interinitiation interval between two normal DNA replication cycles. The mechanisms that link the replication cycle to the progression of the cell cycle are also discussed.

The eclipse period of Escherichia coli

The minimal time between successive initiations on the same origin (the eclipse) in Escherichia coli was determined to be approximately 25-30 min. An inverse relationship was found between the length of the eclipse and the amount of Dam methyltransferase in the cell, indicating that the eclipse corresponds to the period of origin hemimethylation. The SeqA protein was absolutely required for the eclipse, and DnaA titration studies suggested that the SeqA protein prevented the binding of multiple DnaA molecules on oriC (initial complex formation). No correlation between the amount of SeqA and eclipse length was revealed, but increased SeqA levels affected chromosome partitioning and/or cell division. This was corroborated further by an aberrant nucleoid distribution in SeqA-deficient cells. We suggest that the SeqA protein's role in maintaining the eclipse is tied to a function in chromosome organization.

Distribution of minichromosomes in individual Escherichia coli cells: implications for replication control

A novel method was devised to measure the number of plasmids in individual Escherichia coli cells. With this method, involving measurement of plasmid-driven expression of the green fluorescent protein gene by flow cytometry, the copy number distribution of a number of different plasmids was measured. Whereas natural plasmids had fairly narrow distributions, minichromosomes, which are plasmids replicating only from a cloned oriC copy, have a wide distribution, suggesting that there is no copy number control for minichromosomes. When the selection pressure (kanamycin concentration) for minichromosomes was increased, the copy number of minichromosomes was also increased. At up to 30 minichromosomes per host chromosome, replication and growth of the host cell was unaffected. This is evidence that there is no negative element for initiation control in oriC and that there is no incompatibility between oriC located on the chromosome and minichromosome. However, higher copy numbers led to integration of the minichromosomes at the chromosomal oriC and to initiation asynchrony of the host chromosome. At a minichromosome copy number of approximately 30, the cell's capacity for synchronous initiation is exceeded and free minichromosomes will compete out the chromosome to yield inviable cells, unless the minichromosomes are incorporated into the chromosome.

Replication of lambda plasmid DNA in the Escherichia coli cell cycle

The Cro repressor autoregulatory loop has long been considered the main regulatory process in controlling lambda plasmid replication initiation in Escherichia coli. However, we found recently that lambda plasmids can be maintained at a constant copy number in the absence of Cro function. Here we demonstrate that shortly after inactivation of the Cro repressor, the synthesis of lambda plasmid DNA increases significantly but is then stabilized at a level similar to that observed in the presence of the Cro function. We found that replication initiation of lambda plasmids carrying a functional cro gene proceeds randomly in the host cell cycle, but in the absence of Cro function the replication initiation of lambda plasmid DNA appears to be cell cycle dependent. The host DnaA protein appears to be at least one of the factors involved in the cell-cycle-specific control of lambda cro- plasmid replication. Therefore, it seems that the lambda cro- plasmid may serve as an amazingly simple model for studies on the regulation of DNA replication in the cell cycle.

Ordered and sequential binding of DnaA protein to oriC, the chromosomal origin of Escherichia coli

DnaA protein of Escherichia coli acts in initiation of chromosomal DNA replication by binding specific sequences, termed DnaA boxes in the chromosomal origin, oriC. On binding, it induces a localized unwinding to create a structure recognized by other replication proteins that act subsequently in the initiation process. In this report, we examined the binding of DnaA protein to each of the DnaA boxes in oriC. By gel mobility shift assays, DnaA protein formed at least six discrete complexes. ATP or ADP included in the reaction mixture prior to electrophoresis was required. Chemical cleavage of isolated complexes with 1,10-phenanthroline-copper revealed that DnaA protein binds in an ordered manner to the DnaA boxes in oriC. Preferential binding to one DnaA box (R4) was confirmed by demonstration that a DNA fragment containing it was bound with greater affinity than another DnaA box sequence (R1). In vitro replication activity correlated with a complex formed at a ratio of 30 DnaA monomers/oriC in which all DnaA boxes are occupied. The last site bound is DnaA box R3. This event may be critical in promoting initiation from oriC as it correlates with in vivo observations that binding of DnaA protein to box R3 occurs at the time of initiation of chromosomal replication, whereas other DnaA boxes are bound by DnaA protein throughout the cell cycle (Cassler, M. R., Grimwade, J. E., and Leonard, A. C.(1995) EMBO J. 14, 5833-5841).

Cell-cycle-specific initiation of replication

The following characteristics are relevant when replication of chromosomes and plasmids is discussed in relation to the cell cycle: the timing or replication, the selection of molecules for replication, and the coordination of multiple initiation events within a single cell cycle. Several fundamentally different methods have been used to study these processes: Meselson-Stahl density-shift experiments, experiments with the so-called 'baby machine', sorting of cells according to size, and flow cytometry. The evidence for precise timing and co-ordination of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli is overwhelming. Similarly, the high-copy-number plasmid ColE1 and the low-copy-number plasmids R1/R100 without any doubt replicate randomly throughout the cell cycle. Data about the low-copy-number plasmids F and P1 are conflicting. This calls for new types of experiments and for a better understanding of how these plasmids control their replication and partitioning.

Different effects of mioC transcription on initiation of chromosomal and minichromosomal replication in Escherichia coli

The mioC gene, which neighbors the chromosomal origin of replication (oriC) in Escherichia coli, has in a number of studies been implicated in the control of oriC initiation on minichromosomes. The present work reports on the construction of cells carrying different mioC mutations on the chromosome itself. Flow cytometry was employed to study the DNA replication control and growth pattern of the resulting mioC mutants. All parameters measured (growth rate, cell size, DNA/cell, number of origins per cell, timing of initiation) were the same for the wild type and all the mioC mutant cells under steady state growth and after different shifts in growth medium and after induction of the stringent response. It may be concluded that the dramatic effects of mioC mutations reported for minichromosomes are not observed for chromosomal replication and that the mioC gene and gene product is of little importance for the control of initiation. The data demonstrate that a minichromosome is not necessarily a valid model for chromosomal replication.

Nonrandom F-plasmid replication in Escherichia coli K-12

Both the autonomous and chromosomally integrated F plasmids were found to replicate in a nonrandom fashion after a density transfer from heavy medium ([13C]glucose, 15NH4) to light medium ([12C]glucose, 14NH4). The data are consistent with the hypothesis that both the chromosome and the F plasmid are replicated in a cell cycle-specific manner. Thus, these data support the proposal (J. D. Keasling, B. O. Palsson, and S. Cooper, J. Bacteriol. 173:2673-2680, 1991) that plasmids replicate in a cell cycle-specific manner.

Analysis of a model for minichromosome segregation in Escherichia coli

The present article contains a theoretical, quantitative analysis of the implications of the Helmstetter-Leonard model (1987, J. molec. Biol. 197, 195-204.) for the segregation of chromosomal DNA in Escherichia coli, on the expected copy-number distribution of minichromosomes in a culture in steady-state exponential growth. According to the model, two determinants are involved in the mechanism of chromosome segregation: a partition system that assures the equal allotment of chromosomes between daughter cells at cell division, and a locus within the minimal oriC region that specifies the attachment site of the chromosomes to the cell envelope at initiation of replication. There are many parameters that must be taken into account in such a study, and since some of them are probabilistic in nature, a strictly analytical approach is not feasible and we had to resort to computer simulation. A wide range of parameter values was tested, in all combinations. The minichromosome copy-number distributions obtained all had a prominent mode equal to the number of oriC binding sites and their main features were determined essentially by that and very little by any of the other parameters of the model. In order to avoid the unrealistic situation in which this one feature completely dominates the results, the original model was modified so that each individual minichromosome is no longer required to replicate during every cell generation, by introducing a limit to the number of unsuccessful attempts to locate a suitable binding site. The copy-number distributions predicted by this version of the model are quantitatively and qualitatively very different and depend on all the components of the model. The simulation results are sufficiently well-behaved to allow consideration as to whether a particular empirical minichromosome copy-number distribution--when such data become available--could in fact be governed by the proposed model; it may even be possible to get a rough estimate for the different parameters involved.

Escherichia coli minichromosomes: random segregation and absence of copy number control

Minichromosomes, i.e. plasmids that can replicate from an integrated oriC, have been puzzling because of their high copy numbers compared to that of the chromosomal oriC, their lack of incompatibility with the chromosome and their high loss frequencies. Using single cell resistance to tetracycline or ampicillin as an indicator of copy number we followed the development of minichromosome distributions in Escherichia coli cells transformed with minichromosomes and then allowed to grow towards the steady state. The final copy number distribution was not reached within 15 to 20 generations. If the minichromosome carried the sop (partitioning) genes from plasmid F, the development of the copy number distribution was further drastically delayed. We conclude that E. coli cells have no function that directly controls minichromosomal copy numbers, hence the absence of incompatibility in the sense of shared copy number control. We suggest that minichromosomes are subject to the same replication control as the chromosome but segregate randomly in the absence of integrated partitioning genes. This, combined with evidence that the lowest copy number classes are normally present despite high average copy numbers, can account for the high loss frequencies.

E. coli oriC and the dnaA gene promoter are sequestered from dam methyltransferase following the passage of the chromosomal replication fork

We have examined individual GATC sites throughout the E. coli genome for their kinetics of remethylation by dam methyltransferase following the passage of the chromosomal replication fork. We present evidence for three major conclusions: that oriC is a single function unit that is specifically sequestered from dam methyltransferase for a significant period of time and then released; that the dnaA promoter region is subject to sequestration analogous to that observed at oriC and thus that hemimethylation-dependent sequestration is a general phenomenon; and that each round of replication initiation triggers a transient, temporally coordinate block in both reinitiation at oriC and expression of the dnaA gene. These and other observations are all consistent with the notion that hemimethylation in these two regions acts coordinately to ensure that every origin undergoes initiation once and only once per cell cycle; other possible roles for sequestration at dnaA are also considered.

DnaA protein overproduction abolishes cell cycle specificity of DNA replication from oriC in Escherichia coli

Initiation of DNA replication from oriC in Escherichia coli takes place at a specific time in the cell division cycle, whether the origin is located on a chromosome or a minichromosome, and requires participation of the product of the dnaA gene. The effects of overproduction of DnaA protein on the cell cycle specificity of the initiation event were determined by using minichromosome replication as the assay system. DnaA protein was overproduced by inducing the expression of plasmid-encoded dnaA genes under control of either the ptac or lambda pL promoter. Induction of DnaA protein synthesis caused a burst of minichromosome replication in cells at all ages in the division cycle. The magnitude of the burst was consistent with the initiation of one round of replication per minichromosome in all cells. The replication burst was followed by a period of reduced minichromosome replication, with the reduction being greater at 30 than at 41 degrees C. The results support the idea that the DnaA protein participates in oriC replication at a stage that is limiting for initiation. Excess DnaA protein enabled all cells to achieve the state required for initiation of DNA polymerization by either effecting or overriding the normal limiting process.

Coordination of chromosome replication initiation in Escherichia coli: effects of different dnaA alleles

The synchrony of initiation of chromosomal replication in single cells was determined in ten different dnaA(Ts) mutants. After inhibiting the initiation of replication but allowing initiated rounds of replication to terminate, we measured the number of fully replicated chromosomes per individual cell by flow cytometry. Synchronous initiation at the several independent origins (oriC) in single rapidly growing cells would give 2'' (n = 0,1,2,3,...) chromosomes per cell, whereas asynchronous initiation was indicated by the presence of a different number of chromosomes. Mutations mapping in the central part of the dnaA gene (dnaA5, dnaA46, dnaA601, dnaA602, and dnaA604) lead to a high degree of asynchrony (class I mutants), whereas mutations mapping in either of the distal parts of the gene (dnaA508, dnaA167, dnaA203, and dnaA204) yielded a low degree of asynchrony at the permissive temperature (class 2 mutants). The dnaA205 mutant exhibited an intermediate degree of asynchrony. Mutants dnaA203 and dnaA204 (promoter distal) differed from the other class 2 mutants (dnaA167, dnaA508; promoter proximal) in that asynchrony increased no more than twofold between 25 and 37 degrees C compared with the more-than-fourfold increase in the latter. The high degree of asynchrony in class 1 mutants was independent of temperature and was not due to insufficient functional DnaA protein, because overproduction of DnaA46 protein did not decrease the asynchrony. The data demonstrate that the DnaA protein has functions in addition to acting positively in the initiation process and negatively as its own repressor, namely in coordinating initiations at all oriC sites within a single cell.

Mechanism for chromosome and minichromosome segregation in Escherichia coli

A mechanism for the segregation of chromosomes and minichromosomes into daughter cells during division of Escherichia coli is presented. It is based on the idea that the cell envelope contains a large number of sites capable of binding to the chromosomal replication origin, oriC, and that a polymerizing DNA strand becomes attached to one of the sites at initiation of a round of replication. The attachment sites are distributed throughout the actively growing cell envelope, i.e. lateral envelope and septum, but not in the existing cell poles. This asymmetric distribution of oriC attachment sites accounts for the experimentally observed non-random chromosome and minichromosome segregation, and for the variation in the degree of non-random segregation with cell strain and growth rate. The multi-site attachment concept also accounts for the unstable maintenance of minichromosomes.

Coordinate initiation of chromosome and minichromosome replication in Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli minichromosomes harboring as little as 327 base pairs of DNA from the chromosomal origin of replication (oriC) were found to replicate in a discrete burst during the division cycle of cells growing with generation times between 25 and 60 min at 37 degrees C. The mean cell age at minichromosome replication coincided with the mean age at initiation of chromosome replication at all growth rates, and furthermore, the age distributions of the two events were indistinguishable. It is concluded that initiation of replication from oriC is controlled in the same manner on minichromosomes and chromosomes over the entire range of growth rates and that the timing mechanism acts within the minimal oriC nucleotide sequence required for replication.

OriC plasmids do not affect timing of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli K12

The variability of the time interval between successive rounds of chromosome replication was estimated by density-shift experiments, by measuring the conversion of heavy DNA to hybrid density and light DNAs upon transfer of a steady-state culture growing in medium with [13C]glucose and 15NH4Cl to medium with light isotopes. The coefficient of variation (CV%) for the interreplication time of the Escherichia coli K12 chromosome was found to be 17%, i.e. similar to that for interdivision time. The presence of additional copies of oriC in the cell on a high copy number plasmid did not increase the CV of interreplication time. It is concluded that a single rate-limiting event is unlikely to time the initiation of chromosome replication. The regulation of initiation at oriC and the coordination with cell division is discussed.

Mode of initiation of constitutive stable DNA replication in RNase H-defective mutants of Escherichia coli K-12

The alternative pathway of DNA replication in rnh mutants of Escherichia coli can be continuously initiated in the presence of chloramphenicol, giving rise to constitutive stable DNA replication (cSDR). We conducted a physiological analysis of cSDR in rnh-224 mutants in the presence or absence of the normal DNA replication system. The following results were obtained. cSDR allowed the cells to grow in the absence of the normal replication system at a 30 to 40% reduced growth rate and with an approximately twofold-decreased DNA content. cSDR initiation was random with respect to time in the cell cycle as well as choice of origins. cSDR initiation continued to increase exponentially for more than one doubling time when protein synthesis was inhibited by chloramphenicol. cSDR initiation was inhibited during amino acid starvation in stringent (relA+) but not in relaxed (relA1) strains, indicating its sensitivity to ppGpp. cSDR initiation was rifampin sensitive, demonstrating that RNA polymerase was involved. cSDR functioned in dnaA+ rnh-224 strains parallel to the normal oriC+ dnaA+-dependent chromosome replication system.