Spo0A mutants of Bacillus subtilis with sigma factor-specific defects in transcription activation

Abhyankar W, N. Swarge B, van der Wel N, Kramer G, Brul S, J. de Koning L. Artificial Sporulation Induction (ASI) by kinA Overexpression Affects the Proteomes and Properties of Bacillus subtilis Spores

To facilitate more accurate spore proteomic analysis, the current study focuses on inducing homogeneous sporulation by overexpressing kinA and assesses the effect of synchronized sporulation initiation on spore resistance, structures, the germination behavior at single-spore level and the proteome. The results indicate that, in our set up, the sporulation by overexpressing kinA can generate a spore yield of 70% within 8 h. The procedure increases spore wet heat resistance and thickness of the spore coat and cortex layers, whilst delaying the time to spore phase-darkening and burst after addition of germinant. The proteome analysis reveals that the upregulated proteins in the kinA induced spores, compared to spores without kinA induction, as well as the 'wildtype' spores, are mostly involved in spore formation. The downregulated proteins mostly belong to the categories of coping with stress, carbon and nitrogen metabolism, as well as the regulation of sporulation. Thus, while kinA overexpression enhances synchronicity in sporulation initiation, it also has profound effects on the central equilibrium of spore formation and spore germination, through modulation of the spore molecular composition and stress resistance physiology.

Regulation of sporulation initiation by NprR and its signaling peptide NprRB: molecular recognition and conformational changes

NprR belongs to the RNPP family of quorum-sensing receptors, a group of intracellular regulators activated directly by signaling oligopeptides in Gram-positive bacteria. In Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), nprR is located in a transcriptional cassette with nprRB that codes for the precursor of the signaling peptide NprRB. NprR is a transcriptional regulator activated by binding of reimported NprRB; however, several reports suggest that NprR also participates in sporulation but the mechanism is unknown. Our in silico results, based on the structural similarity between NprR from Bt and Spo0F-binding Rap proteins from Bacillus subtilis, suggested that NprR could bind Spo0F to modulate the sporulation phosphorelay in Bt. Deletion of nprR-nprRB cassette from Bt caused a delay in sporulation and defective trigger of the Spo0A∼P-activated genes spoIIA and spoIIIG. The DNA-binding domain of NprR was not necessary for this second function, since truncated NprRΔHTH together with nprRB gene was able to restore the sporulation wild type phenotype in the ΔnprR-nprRB mutant. Fluorescence assays showed direct binding between NprR and Spo0F, supporting that NprR is a bifunctional protein. To understand how the NprR activation by NprRB could result in two different functions, we studied the molecular recognition mechanism between the signaling peptide and the receptor. Using synthetic variants of NprRB, we found that SSKPDIVG displayed the highest affinity (Kd = 7.19 nM) toward the recombinant NprR and demonstrated that recognition involves conformational selection. We propose that the peptide concentration in the cell controls the oligomerization state of the NprR-NprRB complex for switching between its two functions.

Expression level of a chimeric kinase governs entry into sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Upon starvation, Bacillus subtilis cells switch from growth to sporulation. It is believed that the N-terminal sensor domain of the cytoplasmic histidine kinase KinA is responsible for detection of the sporulation-specific signal(s) that appears to be produced only under starvation conditions. Following the sensing of the signal, KinA triggers autophosphorylation of the catalytic histidine residue in the C-terminal domain to transmit the phosphate moiety, via phosphorelay, to the master regulator for sporulation, Spo0A. However, there is no direct evidence to support the function of the sensor domain, because the specific signal(s) has never been found. To investigate the role of the N-terminal sensor domain, we replaced the endogenous three-PAS repeat in the N-terminal domain of KinA with a two-PAS repeat derived from Escherichia coli and examined the function of the resulting chimeric protein. Despite the introduction of a foreign domain, we found that the resulting chimeric protein, in a concentration-dependent manner, triggered sporulation by activating Spo0A through phosphorelay, irrespective of nutrient availability. Further, by using chemical cross-linking, we showed that the chimeric protein exists predominantly as a tetramer, mediated by the N-terminal domain, as was found for KinA. These results suggest that tetramer formation mediated by the N-terminal domain, regardless of the origin of the protein, is important and sufficient for the kinase activity catalyzed by the C-terminal domain. Taken together with our previous observations, we propose that the primary role of the N-terminal domain of KinA is to form a functional tetramer, but not for sensing an unknown signal.

An A257V mutation in the bacillus subtilis response regulator Spo0A prevents regulated expression of promoters with low-consensus binding sites

In Bacillus species, the master regulator of sporulation is Spo0A. Spo0A functions by both activating and repressing transcription initiation from target promoters that contain 0A boxes, the binding sites for Spo0A. Several classes of spo0A mutants have been isolated, and the molecular basis for their phenotypes has been determined. However, the molecular basis of the Spo0A(A257V) substitution, representative of an unusual phenotypic class, is not understood. Spo0A(A257V) is unusual in that it abolishes sporulation; in vivo, it fails to activate transcription from key stage II promoters yet retains the ability to repress the abrB promoter. To determine how Spo0A(A257V) retains the ability to repress but not stimulate transcription, we performed a series of in vitro and in vivo assays. We found unexpectedly that the mutant protein both stimulated transcription from the spoIIG promoter and repressed transcription from the abrB promoter, albeit twofold less than the wild type. A DNA binding analysis of Spo0A(A257V) showed that the mutant protein was less able to tolerate alterations in the sequence and arrangement of its DNA binding sites than the wild-type protein. In addition, we found that Spo0A(A257V) could stimulate transcription of a mutant spoIIG promoter in vivo in which low-consensus binding sites were replaced by high-consensus binding sites. We conclude that Spo0A(A257V) is able to bind to and regulate the expression of only genes whose promoters contain high-consensus binding sites and that this effect is sufficient to explain the observed sporulation defect.

Bacillus subtilis RNA Polymerase Recruits the Transcription Factor Spo0A∼P to Stabilize a Closed Complex during Transcription Initiation

The Bacillus subtilis response regulator Spo0A approximately P activates transcription from the spoIIG promoter by stimulating a rate-limiting transition between the initial interaction of RNA polymerase with the promoter and initiation of RNA synthesis. Previous work showed that Spo0A exerts its effect on RNA polymerase prior to the formation of an open complex in which the DNA strands at the initiation site have been separated. To isolate the effect of Spo0A approximately P on events prior to DNA strand separation at spoIIG we studied RNA polymerase binding to DNA fragments that were truncated to contain only promoter sequences 5' to the -10 element by electrophoretic mobility shift assays. RNA polymerase bound to these fragments readily though highly reversibly, and polymerase-promoter complexes recruited Spo0A approximately P. Sequence-independent interactions between the RNA polymerase and the DNA upstream of the core promoter were important for RNA polymerase binding and essential for Spo0A approximately P recruitment, while sequence-specific Spo0A approximately P-DNA interactions positioned and stabilized RNA polymerase binding to the DNA. Spo0A approximately P decreased the dissociation rate of the complexes formed with truncated promoter templates which could contribute to the means by which Spo0A approximately P stimulates spoIIG expression.

Phosphorylation and functional analysis of the sporulation initiation factor Spo0A from Clostridium botulinum

The initiation of sporulation in aerobic Bacillus species is regulated by the phosphorelay consisting of several sensor histidine kinases, the Spo0F response regulator, the Spo0B phosphotransferase and the Spo0A transcription factor that upon phosphorylation represses genes for growth and activates the developmental process. Clostridium species lack both Spo0F and Spo0B and the identities of the sensor histidine kinases are unknown. The amino acid sequence of Spo0A is highly conserved in Clostridium botulinum relative to Bacillus subtilis but the cloned C. botulinum Spo0A was unable to complement a spo0A mutant of B. subtilis for sporulation. However, it was able to repress the abrB gene of B. subtilis. Active site mutations in Spo0A still repressed, indicating this activity was independent of phosphorylation. An orphan sensor histidine kinase of C. botulinum appeared to normally phosphorylate C. botulinum Spo0A and expression of this kinase in combination with C. botulinum Spo0A in B. subtilis was lethal, suggesting phosphorylation of C. botulinum Spo0A repressed essential growth genes as a prerequisite to sporulation but could not compensate for this effect by inducing sporulation. A chimera Spo0A consisting of a B. subtilis Spo0A response regulator domain fused to a C. botulinum DNA-binding domain was capable of restoring sporulation to a spo0A mutant of B. subtilis albeit at less than wild-type levels. The data suggest that induction of sporulation requires interactions of both domains of Spo0A with other conserved proteins and despite the high conservation of the amino acid sequence of C. botulinum Spo0A, some of these interactions have been lost.

Alpha-helix E of Spo0A is required for sigmaA- but not for sigmaH-dependent promoter activation in Bacillus subtilis

At the onset of endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis, the DNA binding protein Spo0A activates transcription from two types of promoters. The first type includes the spoIIG and spoIIE promoters, which are used by sigma(A)-RNA polymerase, whereas the second type includes the spoIIA promoter, which is used by RNA polymerase containing the secondary sigma factor sigma(H). Previous genetic analyses have identified specific amino acids in alpha-helix E of Spo0A that are important for activation of Spo0A-dependent, sigma(A)-dependent promoters. However, these amino acids are not required for activation of the sigma(H)-dependent spoIIA promoter. We now report the effects of additional single-amino-acid substitutions and the effects of deletions in alpha-helix E. The effects of alanine substitutions revealed one new position (239) in Spo0A that appears to be specifically required for activation of the sigma(A)-dependent promoters. Based on the effects of a deletion mutation, we suggest that alpha-helix E in Spo0A is not directly involved in interaction with sigma(H)-RNA polymerase.

The Bacillus subtilis response regulator Spo0A stimulates sigmaA-dependent transcription prior to the major energetic barrier

At the spoIIG promoter phosphorylated Spo0A (Spo0A approximately P) binds 0A boxes overlapping the -35 element, interacting with RNA polymerase to facilitate open complex formation. We have compared in vitro transcription from a series of heteroduplex templates containing denatured regions within the promoters. Transcription from heteroduplex templates with 12, 8, or 6 base pairs denatured was independent of Spo0A approximately P, but heteroduplexes with 4 or 2 base pairs denatured required Spo0A approximately P for maximal levels of transcription. Investigation of the thermal dependence of transcription suggested that strand separation was the primary thermodynamic barrier to transcription initiation but indicated that Spo0A approximately P does not reduce this energetic barrier. Kinetic assays revealed that Spo0A approximately P stimulated both the rate of formation of initiated complexes as well as increasing the number of complexes capable of initiating transcription. These results imply that Spo0A approximately P stimulates transcription at least in part by stabilizing the RNA polymerase-spoIIG complex until contacts between RNA polymerase and the -10 element induce strand separation.

Surfaces of Spo0A and RNA polymerase sigma factor A that interact at the spoIIG promoter in Bacillus subtilis

In Bacillus subtilis, the DNA binding protein Spo0A activates transcription from two classes of promoters, those used by RNA polymerase containing the primary sigma factor, sigma(A) (e.g., spoIIG), and those used by RNA polymerase containing the secondary sigma factor, sigma(H) (e.g., spoIIA). Several single amino acid substitutions in region 4 of sigma(A) define positions in sigma(A) that are specifically required for Spo0A-dependent promoter activation. Similarly, several single amino acid substitutions in Spo0A define positions in Spo0A that are required for sigma(A)-dependent promoter activation but not for other functions of Spo0A. It is unknown whether these amino acids in Spo0A interact directly with those in region 4 of sigma(A) or whether they interact with another subunit of RNA polymerase to effect promoter activation. Here we report the identification of a new amino acid in region 4 of sigma(A), arginine at position 355 (R355), that is involved in Spo0A-dependent promoter activation. To further investigate the role of R355, we used the coordinates of Spo0A and sigma region 4, each in complex with DNA, to build a model for the interaction of sigma(A) and Spo0A at the spoIIG promoter. We tested the model by examining the effects of amino acid substitutions in the putative interacting surfaces of these molecules. As predicted by the model, we found genetic evidence for interaction of R355 of sigma(A) with glutamine at position 221 of Spo0A. These results appear to define the surfaces of Spo0A and sigma(A) that directly interact during activation of the spoIIG promoter.

Two-vector assay as a tool for examining Spo0A gene transcription regulation

We have modified an assay using two compatible vectors that coexist in Escherichia coli cells and applied it in the investigation of the transcriptional activity of Spo0A, a key regulator of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis. We have chosen the promoters of the Spo0A dependent genes, spoIIE and spoIIA, involved in sporulation, in order to study the transcription activity solely of the DNA binding domain of Spo0A. We have prepared the two-vector system so that one vector contained the cloned C-Spo0A under the control of an inducible promoter, and the second vector (the promoter probe vector), was composed of the Spo0A dependent spoIIE and spoIIA promoters. Using this two-vector system in E. coli, we proved that C-Spo0A is able to interact with the E. coli transcription apparatus, recognizes both promoters and activates transcription from these promoters.

Asymmetric cell division in B. subtilis involves a spiral-like intermediate of the cytokinetic protein FtsZ

A fundamental feature of development in the spore-forming bacterium Bacillus subtilis is the switch from medial to asymmetric division. The switch is brought about by a change in the location of the cytokinetic Z ring, which is composed of the tubulin-like protein FtsZ, from the cell middle to the poles during sporulation. We report that the medial Z ring is replaced by a spiral-like filament of FtsZ that grows along the long axis of the cell. We propose that the filament mediates the switch by redeploying FtsZ to the poles. Spiral formation and the switch to polar Z rings are largely caused by a sporulation-specific increase in transcription of the gene for FtsZ and activation of the gene for the FtsZ-associated protein SpoIIE.

Lessons and questions from the structure of the Spo0A activation domain

The carboxy-terminal domain of Spo0A in Bacillus subtilis is one of the few response regulator activation domains for which the structure is known. Here, we discuss some of the mutational data and biological roles of Spo0A in light of its structure.

Mutational analysis of conserved residues in the putative DNA-binding domain of the response regulator Spo0A of Bacillus subtilis

The Spo0A protein of Bacillus subtilis is a DNA-binding protein that is required for the expression of genes involved in the initiation of sporulation. Spo0A binds directly to and both activates and represses transcription from the promoters of several genes required during the onset of endospore formation. The C-terminal 113 residues are known to contain the DNA-binding activity of Spo0A. Previous studies identified a region of the C-terminal half of Spo0A that is highly conserved among species of endospore-forming Bacillus and Clostridium and which encodes a putative helix-turn-helix DNA-binding domain. To test the functional significance of this region and determine if this motif is involved in DNA binding, we changed three conserved residues, S210, E213, and R214, to Gly and/or Ala by site-directed mutagenesis. We then isolated and analyzed the five substitution-containing Spo0A proteins for DNA binding and sporulation-specific gene activation. The S210A Spo0A mutant exhibited no change from wild-type binding, although it was defective in spoIIA and spoIIE promoter activation. In contrast, both the E213G and E213A Spo0A variants showed decreased binding and completely abolished transcriptional activation of spoIIA and spoIIE, while the R214G and R214A variants completely abolished both DNA binding and transcriptional activation. These data suggest that these conserved residues are important for transcriptional activation and that the E213 residue is involved in DNA binding.

Suppression of temperature-sensitive sporulation mutation in the Bacillus subtilis sigA gene by rpoB mutation

We isolated a temperature-sensitive sporulation defective mutant of the sigA gene, encoding a major sigma factor, sigma(A) protein, in Bacillus subtilis, and designated it as sigA21. The sigA21 mutation caused a single-amino acid substitution, E314K, in region 4 of the sigma(A) protein. In this mutant, expression of the spoIIG gene, whose transcription depends on both sigma(A) and the phosphorylated Spo0A protein, Spo0A approximately P, a major transcription factor during early stages of sporulation, was greatly reduced at 43 degrees C. To obtain further information on the mechanism of sigma(A) function during the early spore development, we isolated a spontaneous sporulation-proficient suppressor mutant at 43 degrees C. This extragenic suppressor mutation was mapped within the rpoB gene, encoding the beta subunit of RNA polymerase, and was found to have a single-amino acid substitution, A863G. In this mutant, the expression of the spoIIG is partially restored at 43 degrees C.

The trans-activation domain of the sporulation response regulator Spo0A revealed by X-ray crystallography

Sporulation in Bacillus involves the induction of scores of genes in a temporally and spatially co-ordinated programme of cell development. Its initiation is under the control of an expanded two-component signal transduction system termed a phosphorelay. The master control element in the decision to sporulate is the response regulator, Spo0A, which comprises a receiver or phosphoacceptor domain and an effector or transcription activation domain. The receiver domain of Spo0A shares sequence similarity with numerous response regulators, and its structure has been determined in phosphorylated and unphosphorylated forms. However, the effector domain (C-Spo0A) has no detectable sequence similarity to any other protein, and this lack of structural information is an obstacle to understanding how DNA binding and transcription activation are controlled by phosphorylation in Spo0A. Here, we report the crystal structure of C-Spo0A from Bacillus stearothermophilus revealing a single alpha-helical domain comprising six alpha-helices in an unprecedented fold. The structure contains a helix-turn-helix as part of a three alpha-helical bundle reminiscent of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP), suggesting a mechanism for DNA binding. The residues implicated in forming the sigmaA-activating region clearly cluster in a flexible segment of the polypeptide on the opposite side of the structure from that predicted to interact with DNA. The structural results are discussed in the context of the rich array of existing mutational data.

Identification of a second region of the Spo0A response regulator of Bacillus subtilis required for transcription activation

Deletion of the 10 C-terminal amino acids of the Bacillus subtilis response regulator Spo0A or valine substitution at D258 and L260 resulted in a sporulation-negative phenotype and loss of in vivo activation of the spoIIG and spoIIA operon promoters. Repression of the abrB promoter was not affected by the mutations. In combination with the previously characterized mutation (A257V), the results identify amino acids at positions 257, 258, and 260 as being required for transcription activation by Spo0A.

A role for Asp75 in domain interactions in the Bacillus subtilis response regulator Spo0A

Spo0A is a two-domain response regulator required for sporulation initiation in Bacillus subtilis. Studies on response regulators have focused on the activity of each domain, but very little is known about the mechanism by which the regulatory domain inhibits the activator domain. In this study, we created a single amino acid substitution in the regulatory domain, D75S, which resulted in a dramatic decrease in sporulation in vivo. In vitro studies with the purified Spo0AD75S protein demonstrated that phosphorylation and DNA binding were comparable with wild type Spo0A. However, the mutant was unable to stimulate transcription by final sigma(A)-RNA polymerase from the Spo0A-dependent spoIIG operon promoter. We suggest that the amino acid Asp(75) and/or the region within which it resides, the alpha3-beta4 loop, are involved in the inhibitory interaction between the regulatory and activator domains of Spo0A.

A new mutation in spo0A with intragenic suppressors in the effector domain

Spo0A is a two domain response regulator, a key protein in the initiation of sporulation of Bacillus subtilis. This protein controls a number of changes in gene expression that occur during the transition from stationary phase to the onset of sporulation. The phosphorylated form of Spo0A influences the transcription of a specific set of genes. In addition to others, it represses abrB and activates spoIIA and spoIIE transcription. Although the N-terminal phosphoacceptor domain is well characterised, there is limited information on the C-terminal, DNA-binding domain. Comparisons of Spo0A homologues from a number of Bacillus and Clostridium species show that the C-terminal domain contains three highly conserved regions. In this study, we have investigated the influence of spo0A mutations mapping within the C-terminal domain on transcription from the abrB, spoIIA and spoIIE promoters using lacZ fusions. Our results indicate that described mutations can be part of signalling between N- and C-terminal domains of the protein. Also, the increased expression observed from the spoIIE promoter in some Spo0A mutants might result from a stabilising function of these mutations on the transcriptional apparatus utilising sigma(A).

Regulation of synthesis of the Bacillus subtilis transition-phase, spore-associated antibacterial protein TasA

Previously, we identified a novel component of Bacillus subtilis spores, called TasA, which possesses antibacterial activity. TasA is made early in spore formation, as cells enter stationary phase, and is secreted into the medium as well as deposited into the spore. Here, we show that tasA expression can occur as cells enter stationary phase even under sporulation-repressing conditions, indicating that TasA is a transition-phase protein. tasA and two upstream genes, yqxM and sipW, likely form an operon, transcription of which is under positive control by the transition-phase regulatory genes spo0A and spo0H and negative control by the transition phase regulatory gene abrB. These results are consistent with the suggestion that yqxM, sipW, and tasA constitute a transition phase operon that could play a protective role in a variety of cellular responses to stress during late-exponential-phase and early-stationary-phase growth in B. subtilis.

The Spo0A sof mutations reveal regions of the regulatory domain that interact with a sensor kinase and RNA polymerase

Spo0A is a two-domain response regulator required for the initiation of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis. Spo0A is activated by phosphorylation of its regulatory domain by a multicomponent phosphorelay. To define the role of the regulatory domain in the activation of Spo0A, we have characterized four of the sof mutations in vitro. The sof mutations were identified previously as suppressors of the sporulation-negative phenotype resulting from a deletion of the gene for one of the phosphorelay components, spo0F. Like wild-type Spo0A, the transcription stimulation properties of all of the Sof proteins were dependent upon phosphorylation. Sof mutants from two classes were improved substrates for direct phosphorylation by the KinA sensor kinase, providing an explanation for their suppression properties. Two other Sof proteins showed a phosphorylation-dependent enhancement of the stability of the Sof approximately P-RNA polymerase-DNA complex. One of these mutants, Sof114, increased the stability of the Sof114 approximately P-RNAP-DNA complex without increasing its own affinity for the spoIIG promoter. A comparison of the location of the sof mutations with mutations in CheY suggests that phosphorylation of Spo0A results in the exposure of a region in the regulatory domain that interacts with RNA polymerase, thereby contributing to the signal transduction mechanism.

A region in Bacillus subtilis sigmaH required for Spo0A-dependent promoter activity

Spo0A activates transcription in Bacillus subtilis from promoters that are used by two types of RNA polymerase, RNA polymerase containing the primary sigma factor, sigmaA, and RNA polymerase containing a secondary sigma factor, known as sigmaH. The region of sigmaA near positions 356 to 359 is required for Spo0A-dependent promoter activation, possibly because Spo0A interacts with this region of sigmaA at these promoters. To determine if the amino acids in the corresponding region of sigmaH are also important in Spo0A-dependent promoter activation, we examined the effects of single alanine substitutions at 10 positions in sigmaH (201 to 210). Two alanine substitutions in sigmaH, at glutamine 201 (Q201A) and at arginine 205 (R205A), significantly decreased activity from the Spo0A-dependent, sigmaH-dependent promoter spoIIA but did not affect expression from the sigmaH-dependent, Spo0A-independent promoters citGp2 and spoVG. Therefore, promoter activation by Spo0A requires homologous regions in sigmaA and sigmaH. A mutant form of Spo0A, S231F, that suppresses the sporulation defect caused by several amino acid substitutions in sigmaA did not suppress the sporulation defects caused by the Q201A and R205A substitutions in sigmaH. This result and others indicate that different surfaces of Spo0A probably interact with sigmaA and sigmaH RNA polymerases.

A region in the Bacillus subtilis transcription factor Spo0A that is important for spoIIG promoter activation

Spo0A is a DNA binding protein in Bacillus subtilis required for the activation of spoIIG and other promoters at the onset of endospore formation. Activation of some of these promoters may involve interaction of Spo0A and the sigmaA subunit of RNA polymerase. Previous studies identified two single-amino-acid substitutions in sigmaA, K356E and H359R, that specifically impaired Spo0A-dependent transcription in vivo. Here we report the identification of an amino acid substitution in Spo0A (S231F) that suppressed the sporulation deficiency due to the H359R substitution in sigmaA. We also found that the S231F substitution partially restored use of the spoIIG promoter by the sigmaA H359R RNA polymerase in vitro. Alanine substitutions in the 231 region of Spo0A revealed an additional amino acid residue important for spoIIG promoter activation, I229. This amino acid substitution in Spo0A did not affect repression of abrB transcription, indicating that the alanine-substituted Spo0A was not defective in DNA binding. Moreover, the alanine-substituted Spo0A protein activated the spoIIA promoter; therefore, this region of Spo0A is probably not required for Spo0A-dependent, sigmaH-directed transcription. These and other results suggest that the region of Spo0A near position 229 is involved in sigmaA-dependent promoter activation.