Nonisotopic hybridization assay for determination of relative amounts of genotypic human immunodeficiency virus type 1 zidovudine resistance

Sustained high proportion of zidovudine-resistant HIV variants despite prolonged substitution of zidovudine by other nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors

The consequences of zidovudine (ZDV) replacement by other nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors on the expression of resistance mutations at codons 215 and 41 of the reverse transcriptase (RT) gene was investigated prospectively in 66 patients harboring mutant genotypes who were changed to an effective two- or three-drug combination antiretroviral regimen. Quantitation of mutant (MUT) viral populations at codon 215 by means of RT-PCR with differential hybridization of amplicons specific for MUT and wild (WT) variants revealed no difference in the proportion of 215 MUT variants prior to (93.5 +/- 2.4%) and 12 to 20 months after (96.9 +/- 1.9%) ZDV replacement, independently of a therapeutic change for stavudine. The fitness of the variants harboring the ZDV-resistant MUT 215 genotype following drug withdrawal was calculated to be 96 to 99% of that of the variants harboring the WT 215 genotype. The apparent stability of ZDV-resistant variants in the study population may have two main complementary explanations: persistent selective pressure secondary to partial cross-resistance due to the new regimens given after the therapeutic alteration and suppression of viral replication after the therapeutic alteration that could have hampered the replacement of less fit variants by fitter variants. These findings indicate that, at least within 15 months following discontinuation of ZDV, an effective antiretroviral therapy is insufficient to allow for ZDV-resistant strains to disappear, and thus to allow for the safe re-introduction of the drug.

A novel recombinant marker virus assay for comparing the relative fitness of hiv-1 reverse transcriptase variants

A novel recombinant marker virus assay (RMVA) has been developed to perform growth competition assays for assessing fitness of HIV-1. This assay allowed the generation of replication-competent viruses by homologous recombination of polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-derived reverse transcriptase (RT) coding sequences in RT-deleted proviral clones of HIV-1 in which the nef gene was replaced by the Salmonella typhimurium histidinol dehydrogenase (hisD) or human heat-stable placental alkaline phosphatase (PLAP) gene (pHIVDeltaRTBalIDeltanefhisD and pHIVDeltaRTBalIDeltanefPLAP, respectively). The proportion of a given RT species in a mixed culture was determined by quantifying the linked hisD or PLAP marker gene using real-time PCR. The RMVA was tested by comparing the relative fitness of wild-type and lamivudine-resistant recombinant viruses. The RMVA reproducibly detected differences in the fitness of these two viruses in growth competition assays. With appropriate modification of the recombination vectors, the RMVA should be useful for analyzing the fitness of viruses resistant to protease, integrase, or fusion inhibitors and should be applicable in clinical research.

A multiple-site-specific heteroduplex tracking assay as a tool for the study of viral population dynamics

Rapidly evolving entities, such as viruses, can undergo complex genetic changes in the face of strong selective pressure. We have developed a modified heteroduplex tracking assay (HTA) capable of detecting the presence of single, specific mutations or sets of linked mutations. The initial application of this approach, termed multiple-site-specific (MSS) HTA, was directed toward the detection of mutations in the HIV-1 pro gene at positions 46, 48, 54, 82, 84, and 90, which are associated with resistance to multiple protease inhibitors. We demonstrate that MSS HTA is sensitive and largely specific to all targeted mutations. The assay allows the accurate and reproducible quantitation of viral subpopulations comprising 3% or more of the total population. Furthermore, we used MSS HTA in longitudinal studies of pro gene evolution in vitro and in vivo. In the examples shown here, populations turned over rapidly and more than one population was present frequently. To demonstrate the versatility of MSS HTA, we also constructed a probe sensitive to changes at positions 181 and 184 of the RT coding domain. Changes at these positions are involved in resistance to nevirapine and 2',3'-dideoxy-3'-thiacytidine (3TC), respectively. This assay easily detected the evolution of resistance to 3TC. MSS HTA provides a rapid and sensitive approach for detecting the presence of and quantifying complex mixtures of distinct genotypes, including genetically linked mutations, and, as one example, represents a useful tool for following the evolution of drug resistance during failure of HIV-1 antiviral therapy.

A multiple-site-specific heteroduplex tracking assay as a tool for the study of viral population dynamics

Rapidly evolving entities, such as viruses, can undergo complex genetic changes in the face of strong selective pressure. We have developed a modified heteroduplex tracking assay (HTA) capable of detecting the presence of single, specific mutations or sets of linked mutations. The initial application of this approach, termed multiple-site-specific (MSS) HTA, was directed toward the detection of mutations in the HIV-1 pro gene at positions 46, 48, 54, 82, 84, and 90, which are associated with resistance to multiple protease inhibitors. We demonstrate that MSS HTA is sensitive and largely specific to all targeted mutations. The assay allows the accurate and reproducible quantitation of viral subpopulations comprising 3% or more of the total population. Furthermore, we used MSS HTA in longitudinal studies of pro gene evolution in vitro and in vivo. In the examples shown here, populations turned over rapidly and more than one population was present frequently. To demonstrate the versatility of MSS HTA, we also constructed a probe sensitive to changes at positions 181 and 184 of the RT coding domain. Changes at these positions are involved in resistance to nevirapine and 2',3'-dideoxy-3'-thiacytidine (3TC), respectively. This assay easily detected the evolution of resistance to 3TC. MSS HTA provides a rapid and sensitive approach for detecting the presence of and quantifying complex mixtures of distinct genotypes, including genetically linked mutations, and, as one example, represents a useful tool for following the evolution of drug resistance during failure of HIV-1 antiviral therapy.

A novel phenotypic drug susceptibility assay for human immunodeficiency virus type 1

Although combination antiretroviral therapy has resulted in a considerable improvement in the treatment of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 (HIV-1) infection, the emergence of resistant virus is a significant obstacle to the effective management of HIV infection and AIDS. We have developed a novel phenotypic drug susceptibility assay that may be useful in guiding therapy and improving long-term suppression of HIV replication. Susceptibility to protease (PR) and reverse transcriptase (RT) inhibitors is measured by using resistance test vectors (RTVs) that contain a luciferase indicator gene and PR and RT sequences derived from HIV-1 in patient plasma. Cells are transfected with RTV DNA, resulting in the production of virus particles that are used to infect target cells. Since RTVs are replication defective, luciferase activity is measured following a single round of replication. The assay has been automated to increase throughput and is completed in 8 to 10 days. Test results may be useful in facilitating the selection of optimal treatment regimens for patients who have failed prior therapy or drug-naive patients infected with drug-resistant virus. In addition, the assay can be used to evaluate candidate drugs and assist in the development of new drugs that are active against resistant strains of HIV-1.

HIV-1 genotypic resistance patterns predict response to saquinavir-ritonavir therapy in patients in whom previous protease inhibitor therapy had failed

BACKGROUND

Tests for resistance to HIV drugs are available for clinical use; however, their predictive value has not been fully assessed.

OBJECTIVES

To determine HIV-1 genotypic predictors of a virologic response to saquinavir-ritonavir therapy in patients in whom at least one previous protease inhibitor-containing regimen had failed and to compare the predictive value of baseline genotype with that of standard clinical evaluation.

DESIGN

Retrospective clinical cohort study.

SETTING

University-based HIV clinic.

PATIENTS

54 HIV-1-infected adults treated with saquinavir-ritonavir who had experienced virologic failure while receiving a protease inhibitor-containing regimen for at least 3 months.

MEASUREMENTS

HIV-1 reverse transcriptase and protease gene sequences, CD4 cell counts, clinical characteristics, detailed antiretroviral treatment history, and plasma HIV-1 RNA levels at baseline and at three follow-up time points (median, 4, 12, and 26 weeks). Virologic failure was defined as a plasma HIV RNA level greater than 1000 copies/mL.

RESULTS

In 22 patients (41%), a plasma HIV-1 RNA level less than 500 copies/mL was achieved by week 12; in 15 patients (28%), this response was maintained through week 26. Clinical characteristics predicting a poorer response included a diagnosis of AIDS, lower CD4 cell count, and higher plasma HIV RNA level (P<0.03). Number of previous nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors, previous protease inhibitor therapy, and duration of previous protease inhibitor therapy were predictors of poorer response (P<0.01). Multivariate regression models revealed that protease mutations present at the initiation of saquinavir-ritonavir therapy were the strongest predictors of virologic response. A model of clinical features explained up to 45% of the variation in virologic outcomes by week 12, whereas the explained variance was 71% when genotypic predictors were included.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients in whom protease inhibitor-containing antiretroviral therapy fails, HIV-1 genotype is predictive of virologic response to subsequent therapy. This predictive capacity adds to that of standard clinical evaluation.

Genotypic Analysis Methods for Detection of Drug Resistance Mutations in the HIV-1 Proteinase and Reverse Transcriptase Genes

Understanding the basis of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) drug resistance represents a key requirement for individualized HIV patient care. The genotypic data generated to date have already provided significant insight. However, it is clear that the relationship between genotype, phenotype and clinical outcome is complex and still poorly defined. In this review, we describe methods currently available to obtain genotypic data for the HIV-1 proteinase and reverse transcriptase genes. Different sample preparation strategies and DNA sequencing methods are discussed dividing the latter into two categories, those that give sequence information at specific positions and those that provide continuous sequence data for a particular region. In addition, we also address some of the broad biological and technical issues, which must be considered when interpreting the results of these tests and describe the advantages and disadvantages of individual methods.

Activity of a ritonavir plus saquinavir-containing regimen in patients with virologic evidence of indinavir or ritonavir failure

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the virologic activity of a ritonavir plus saquinavir-containing regimen in patients who have failed an indinavir or ritonavir-containing regimen.

DESIGN

Patients were identified through a retrospective study evaluating the incidence of indinavir or ritonavir failure in our clinic.

PATIENTS

Eighteen patients failing indinavir or ritonavir therapy and who switched to a ritonavir-saquinavir-containing regimen were evaluated. Indinavir or ritonavir failure was defined as a plasma viral load > 1500 copies/ml (branched DNA) after 16 weeks of continuous therapy.

INTERVENTIONS

All patients switched to ritonavir (400 mg twice daily) plus saquinavir (400 mg twice daily) and received concurrent therapy with two nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTI). Twelve of the 18 patients modified their NRTI regimen at the time ritonavir-saquinavir was initiated.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Plasma viral load was monitored using a branched DNA assay. Genotypic analysis was performed using a point mutation differential hybridization technique, and was confirmed with direct sequencing.

RESULTS

Fourteen out of 18 patients completed at least 24 weeks of therapy; the remaining four patients discontinued therapy after week 12 due to a lack of virologic response or intolerance. Plasma viral load decreased a median 1.4 log10 after 4 weeks of treatment with ritonavir-saquinavir. Only four patients had a greater than 0.5 log10 decrease in viral load after 24 weeks of therapy. In eight out of 10 patients evaluated, the V82A mutation was present at the time of the switch to ritonavir-saquinavir. Viral rebound on ritonavir-saquinavir was associated with the emergence of mutations at amino acids 46, 48, 54 and 90.

CONCLUSION

The combination of ritonavir, saquinavir and two NRTI resulted in a moderate but transient suppression of viral replication in patients who have failed indinavir or ritonavir therapy. Failure of ritonavir-saquinavir may be associated with the emergence of mutations associated with resistance to ritonavir/saquinavir monotherapy, particularly the L90M mutation.

Line probe assay for detection of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 mutations conferring resistance to nucleoside inhibitors of reverse transcriptase: comparison with sequence analysis

We compared the line probe assay (LiPA) to sequence analysis for the detection of mutations conferring resistance to nucleoside inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase (RT). Plasma samples from 40 patients who had received zidovudine, dideoxyinosine, and dideoxycytosine, alone or in combination, and who were enrolled in the ALTIS 2 clinical trial (lamivudine [3TC] plus stavudine) were tested at enrollment and at week 24. RT PCR products from plasma were used for LiPA, and DNA was used for sequence analysis. LiPA gave uninterpretable results for 8.5% of the analyzed codons corresponding to 63 samples, mainly for codons 41, 69, and 70. Several minor discrepancies between the two methods occurred, mainly due to the ability of LiPA to detect mixed populations while sequence analyses detect a single homogeneous population. LiPA is suitable for detecting mixed populations and easy to implement in clinical laboratories and might be useful for epidemiological surveys of primary HIV-1 resistance.

Genotypic changes in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 associated with loss of suppression of plasma viral RNA levels in subjects treated with ritonavir (Norvir) monotherapy

Ten subjects received 600 to 1,200 mg of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease inhibitor ritonavir per day. Following 2 weeks of therapy, plasma HIV RNA levels decreased by a mean of 1. 57 (range, 0.89 to 1.96) log units. With continued therapy, HIV RNA levels began to rise in eight subjects. The initial rise in plasma RNA levels was temporally associated with the development and quantitative increase in the V82 resistance mutation. Doubling times of the V82A mutant virus were estimated to be 2.4 to 4.8 days. An L63P/A mutation was commonly present at baseline even in subjects with a durable virologic response. The concomitant acquisition of an L63P/A mutation with the V82A/F mutation at the time when plasma RNA levels rebounded suggests a role for the L63P/A mutation in improving the fitness of the V82A/F mutation. Subsequent additional genotypic changes at codons 54 and 84 were often associated with further increases in plasma RNA levels. Ongoing viral replication in the presence of drugs resulted in the appearance of additional genotypic changes, including the L90M saquinavir resistance mutation, and decreased phenotypic susceptibility. The relative fitness of the protease V82A ritonavir resistance mutation and reverse transcriptase T215Y/F zidovudine resistance mutation following drug withdrawal were estimated to be 96 to 98% that of the wild type. Durability of the virologic response was associated with plasma RNA levels at the nadir. A virologic response beyond 60 days was not observed unless plasma HIV RNA levels were suppressed below 2,000 copies/ml, consistent with estimates from V82A doubling times for selection of a single resistance mutation to dominate the replicating population.

Line probe assay for rapid detection of drug-selected mutations in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase gene

Upon prolonged treatment with various antiretroviral nucleoside analogs such as 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine, 2',3'-dideoxyinosine, 2',3'-dideoxycytidine, (-)- beta-L-2', 3'dideoxy-3'thiacytidine and 2',3'-didehydro-3'-deoxythymidine, selection of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) strains with mutations in the reverse transcriptase (RT) gene has been reported. We designed a reverse hybridization line probe assay (LiPA) for the rapid and simultaneous characterization of the following variations in the RT gene: M41 or L41; T69, N69, A69, or D69; K70 or R70; L74 or V74; V75 or T75; M184, I184, or V184; T215, Y215, or F215; and K219, Q219, or E219. Nucleotide polymorphisms for codon L41 (TTG or CTG), T69 (ACT or ACA), V75 (GTA or GTG), T215 (ACC or ACT), and Y215 (TAC or TAT) could be detected. In addition to the codons mentioned above, several third-letter polymorphisms in the direct vicinity of the target codons (E40, E42, K43, K73, D76, Q182, Y183, D185, G213, F214, and L214) were found, and specific probes were selected. In total, 48 probes were designed and applied to the LiPA test strips and optimized with a well-characterized and representative reference panel. Plasma samples from 358 HIV-infected patients were analyzed with all 48 probes. The amino acid profiles could be deduced by LiPA hybridization in an average of 92.7% of the samples for each individual codon. When combined with changes in viral load and CD4+ T-cell count, this LiPA approach proved to be useful in studying genetic resistance in follow-up samples from antiretroviral agent-treated HIV-1-infected individuals.

Emergence of protease inhibitor resistance mutations in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 isolates from patients and rapid screening procedure for their detection

Patient human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) isolates that are resistant to protease inhibitors may contain amino acid substitutions L10I/V, M46L/I, G-48V, L63P, V82A/F/T, I84V, and L90M in the protease gene. Substitutions at positions 82 and/or 90 occur in variants that display high levels of resistance to certain protease inhibitors. Nucleotide substitutions at these two sites also lead to the loss of two HindII restriction enzyme digestion sites, and these changes make possible a rapid procedure for the detection of drug-resistant variants in patients on protease inhibitor therapy. This procedure was used to detect the emergence of mutated viruses at various times after the initiation of therapy with the HIV-1 protease inhibitor indinavir. The method includes viral RNA isolation from plasma and reverse transcription PCR amplification of the protease gene with fluorescence-tagged primers. The PCR product is digested with HindII, the cleavage products are separated on a urea-acrylamide gel in a DNA sequencer, and the extent of cleavage is automatically analyzed with commercially available software. In viruses from 34 blood samples from four patients, mutations leading to an amino acid change at residue 82 appeared as early as 6 weeks after the start of therapy and persisted throughout the course of the study period (48 weeks). Mutations leading to double substitutions at residues 82 and 90 were seen at a lower frequency and appeared later than the change at position 82. The changes detected by restriction enzyme cleavage were confirmed by DNA sequencing of the cloned protease genes by reverse transcription PCR amplification of viral RNA from isolates in plasma. In addition to the changes at positions 82 and 90, we have identified M46L/I, G48V, and I54V substitutions in isolates derived from indinavir-treated patients. HindII analysis of uncloned, PCR-amplified DNA offers a rapid screening procedure for the detection of virus isolates containing mutations at amino acid residues 82 and 90 in the HIV-1 protease gene. By using other restriction enzymes, the same method can be used to detect additional protease drug-resistant variants and is generally applicable for the detection of mutations.

Nevirapine-resistant human immunodeficiency virus: kinetics of replication and estimated prevalence in untreated patients

The nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor nevirapine rapidly selects for mutant human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) in vivo. The most common mutation occurs at amino acid residue 181 in patients receiving monotherapy. After the initiation of nevirapine therapy, plasma and peripheral blood mononuclear cell samples were collected at frequent intervals and assayed for HIV RNA levels and the proportion of virus containing a mutation at residue 181. HIV RNA levels remained stable for the first 24 h after initiation of therapy and rapidly declined between 1 and 7 days. There was a consistent maximum decrease of 2 log10 HIV RNA copies per ml of plasma (range, 1.96 to 2.43) from baseline after 2 weeks in all monotherapy subjects. The estimated median half-life of HIV RNA was 1.11 days (range, 0.63 to 1.61). After 14 days of therapy, HIV RNA levels began to increase and 181 mutant virus was detected. The estimated doubling time of the emerging virus population ranged from 1.80 to 5.73 days. Viral DNA in peripheral blood mononuclear cells turned over from wild type to the mutant with a mutation at residue 181 significantly more slowly than did HIV RNA in plasma. In two subjects, the calculated prevalence of the 181 mutant virus prior to treatment was 7 and 133 per 10,000 copies of plasma HIV RNA.

Interlaboratory comparison of sequence-specific PCR and ligase detection reaction to detect a human immunodeficiency virus type 1 drug resistance mutation. The AIDS Clinical Trials Group Virology Committee Drug Resistance Working Group

Sequence-specific PCR was used in six laboratories and a ligase detection reaction was used in one laboratory to detect the zidovudine-resistance mutation at codon 215 of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase DNA. The genotypes of 27 different clinical samples, including cultured HIV-1 isolates, peripheral blood mononuclear cells, and plasma, were correctly identified by 140 of 154 (91%) assays. The sensitivity for detecting a mutation was 96% for HIV-1 reverse transcriptase DNA clone mixtures containing 30% mutant DNA and 62% for mixtures containing 6% mutant DNA.

Randomized, controlled phase I/II, trial of combination therapy with delavirdine (U-90152S) and conventional nucleosides in human immunodeficiency virus type 1-infected patients

Delavirdine mesylate (DLV) is a potent nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor with activity specific for human immunodeficiency virus type 1. In the present phase I/II study we evaluated the safety, toxicity, pharmacokinetics, and antiretroviral activities of two-drug and three-drug combinations of DLV and conventional doses of nucleoside analogs compared with those of both DLV monotherapy and two-drug nucleoside analog therapy. A total of 85 human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infected patients with CD4 counts of 100 to 300 cells per mm3 were enrolled in two periods: in the first period patients were randomized to receive either zidovudine (ZDV) plus didanosine (group 1) or ZDV plus didanosine plus escalating doses (400 to 1,200 mg/day) of DLV (group 2). In the second period, patients were randomized to receive either 1,200 mg of DLV alone per day (group 3) or ZDV plus 1,200 mg of DLV per day (group 4). DLV demonstrated good oral bioavailability at all five doses tested. The major toxicity was a transient mild rash which appeared in 44% of all DLV recipients. Overall, group 2 patients demonstrated more sustained improvements in CD4 counts, percent CD4 cells, branched DNA levels, p24 antigen levels, and virus titers in plasma than group 1, 3, or 4 patients. The magnitude of the response correlated with the intensity of prior nucleoside analog treatment, the non-syncytium-inducing or syncytium-inducing viral phenotype at baseline, and the presence of a wild-type codon at amino acid position 215 in the baseline reverse transcriptase genotype. Despite a transient rash, DLV therapy was well tolerated. Combination therapy with DLV and nucleoside analogs appears promising, with the three-drug combination appearing to be more potent that either two-drug combinations or monotherapy.