Clinical evaluation of the enhanced Gen-Probe Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test for rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis in prison inmates

New insight in molecular detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the causative agent of tuberculosis, is a pathogenic bacterium that has claimed millions of lives since the Middle Ages. According to the World Health Organization's report, tuberculosis ranks among the ten deadliest diseases worldwide. The presence of an extensive array of genes and diverse proteins within the cellular structure of this bacterium has provided us with a potent tool for diagnosis. While the culture method remains the gold standard for tuberculosis diagnosis, it is possible that molecular diagnostic methods, emphasis on the identification of mutation genes (e.g., rpoB and gyrA) and single nucleotide polymorphisms, could offer a safe and reliable alternative. Over the past few decades, as our understanding of molecular genetics has expanded, methods have been developed based on gene expansion and detection. These methods typically commence with DNA amplification through nucleic acid targeted techniques such as polymerase chain reaction. Various molecular compounds and diverse approaches have been employed in molecular assays. In this review, we endeavor to provide an overview of molecular assays for the diagnosis of tuberculosis with their properties (utilization, challenges, and functions). The ultimate goal is to explore the potential of replacing traditional bacterial methods with these advanced molecular diagnostic techniques.

Transmission of Mycobacterium tuberculosis From Patients Who Are Nucleic Acid Amplification Test Negative

Background

Among adults with signs and symptoms of pulmonary tuberculosis (TB), recognition of transmissible TB has implications for airborne infection isolation and public health activities. Sputum smear-negative TB patients account for around one-fifth of tuberculosis transmission. The tuberculosis transmission risk of TB patients with negative results on nucleic acid amplification test (NAAT) of respiratory specimens has not been established. We sought to estimate the tuberculosis transmission risk of NAAT-negative TB patients.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed Maryland TB program data collected from 2004 to 2009, during which time NAAT using the Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD) was performed routinely. Patients with sputum Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M.tb) isolates having matching genotypes were assigned to clusters. Transmission sequence was approximated by collection order of individuals' first culture-positive specimens. Minimum transmission risks of NAAT (MTD)-negative TB patients and of smear-negative TB patients were estimated based on individuals' positions within clusters.

Results

Among 809 patients with culture-confirmed TB, M.tb genotypes were available for 782 (96.7%). For NAA-negative TB patients, the minimum transmission risk estimate was 5.1% (95% CI 0-11.4). For smear-negative TB patients, the minimum transmission risk estimate was 11.2% (95% CI 7.2-15.3).

Conclusions

Minimum transmission risk of NAAT-negative TB patients was lower than that of smear-negative TB patients. However, transmission risk of NAA-negative TB patients appears to not be negligible.

Implication of species change of Nontuberculous Mycobacteria during or after treatment

Background

Co-existence or subsequent isolation of multiple nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) species in same patient has been reported. However, clinical significance of these observations is unclear. The aim of this study was to determine clinical implications of changes of NTM species during or after treatment in patients with NTM lung disease.

Methods

Patients with NTM lung disease, who experienced changes of NTM species during treatment or within 2 years of treatment completion between January 1, 2009 and December 31, 2015, were included in the analysis. Demographic, clinical, microbiological, and radiographic data were reviewed and analyzed.

Results

During the study period, 473 patients were newly diagnosed with NTM lung disease. Treatment was started in 164 patients (34.6%). Among these 164 patients, 16 experienced changes of NTM species during or within 2 years of treatment completion. Seven showed changes from M. avium complex (MAC) to M. abscessus subspecies abscessus (MAA) and five patients displayed changes from M. abscessus subspecies massiliense (MAM) to MAC. With isolation of new NTM species, 6 out of 7 patients with change from MAC to MAA reported worsening of symptoms, whereas none of the five patients with change from MAM to MAC reported worsening of symptoms. All MAA isolated during or after treatment for MAC lung diseases showed inducible resistance to clarithromycin.

Conclusions

Change of NTM species may occur during or after treatment for NTM lung disease. Especially, changes from MAC to MAA is accompanied by symptomatic and radiographic worsening as well as inducible resistance to clarithromycin.

Clinical Impact of Nucleic Acid Amplification Testing in the Diagnosis of Mycobacterium Tuberculosis: A 10-Year Longitudinal Study

BACKGROUND

Nucleic acid amplification (NAA) testing for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) offers improved diagnostic accuracy, compared with smear microscopy, in differentiating MTB from other mycobacteria. We aimed to evaluate the reliability and projected impact of NAA testing in patients with acid-fast bacilli (AFB) smear-positive respiratory samples.

METHODS

We identified a retrospective cohort of all patients with AFB smear-positive respiratory specimens at Henry Ford Hospital from January 1, 2001 through December 31, 2011. We examined the association between patients' sociodemographic factors and clinical comorbidities with the likelihood of being diagnosed with MTB. We evaluated the projected change in duration of airborne isolation and unnecessary MTB treatment with introducing NAA testing into clinical decision making for AFB smear-positive patients.

RESULTS

One hundred thirty patients had AFB smear-positive respiratory specimens, 80 of these patients had a positive NAA test result, and 82 patients grew MTB on culture. Nucleic acid amplification testing had a sensitivity and specificity of 97.6% and 100%, respectively. Integrating NAA testing into clinical decision making for patients with AFB-positive smears was associated with a significantly shorter time in airborne isolation (6.0 ± 7.6 vs 23.1 ± 38.0, P < .001) and 9.5 ± 11.32 fewer days of unnecessary MTB treatment in patients with negative NAA test.

CONCLUSIONS

Nucleic acid amplification testing provided a rapid and accurate test in the diagnosis of MTB while significantly reducing the duration of isolation and unnecessary medications in patients with negative NAA test.

Discordance between MTB/RIF and Real-Time Tuberculosis-Specific Polymerase Chain Reaction Assay in Bronchial Washing Specimen and Its Clinical Implications

The prevalence and clinical implications of discordance between Xpert MTB/RIF assays and the AdvanSure TB/NTM real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for bronchial washing specimens have not been studied in pulmonary TB (PTB) patients. The discordant proportion and its clinical impact were evaluated in 320 patients from the bronchoscopy registry whose bronchial washing specimens were tested simultaneously with Xpert MTB/RIF and the TB/NTM PCR assay for three years, and the accuracy of the assays, including the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV), were studied. The clinical risk factors for discordance and false positivity of assays were also studied. Among 130 patients who were clinically diagnosed with PTB, 64 patients showed positive acid-fast bacilli culture results, 56 patients showed positive results in molecular methods and clinician diagnosed PTB without results of microbiology in 10 patients. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV were 80.0%, 98.95%, 98.1%, and 87.9%, respectively, for Xpert MTB/RIF and 81.5%, 92.6%, 88.3%, and 88.0%, respectively, for TB/NTM PCR. The discordant proportion was 16.9% and was higher in culture-negative PTB compared to culture-confirmed PTB (24.3% vs. 9.4%, p = 0.024). However, there were no significant differences in the clinical characteristics, regardless of the discordance. The diagnostic yield increased with an additional assay (7.7% for Xpert MTB/RIF and 9.2% for TB/NTM PCR). False positivity was less common in patients tested with Xpert MTB/RIF (1.05% vs. 7.37%, p = 0.0035). No host-related risk factor for false positivity was identified. The Xpert MTB/RIF and TB/NTM PCR assay in bronchial washing specimens can improve the diagnostic yields for PTB, although there were considerable discordant results without any patient-related risk factors.

Accuracy of a new rapid antigen detection test for pulmonary tuberculosis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Tuberculosis (TB) is a major problem in the world. Treatment and control of TB needs detection of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MT) in the proper samples. While smear doesn't have enough sensitivity, culture and PCR are expensive, time consuming and unavailable in many centers. Recent development of a rapid TB antigen detection test (PrTBK) at Pasteur Institute of Iran could give a simple way for diagnosis of TB in about two hours. In this test the antigen-antibody complex will change color when gold conjugated mouse anti-rabbit antibody detects specific MT cell wall antigen in suspected samples.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of PrTBK for diagnosis of pulmonary TB in comparison with smear, culture and PCR techniques in 56 consecutive samples (47 BAL and 13 sputum samples) obtained from patients with clinical suspicion of active TB.

RESULTS

Twentynine patients (52%) were female and seven patients were HIV positive. PrTBK was positive in 17 culture positive and 4 culture negative samples (100% sensitivity, 89% specificity and 92% accuracy in comparison with culture method). In two out of four patients with negative culture who were positive for PrTBK, PCR and anti-tuberculosis drugs trial therapy responses were in favor of tuberculosis. If we take this finding into account, the accuracy of PrTBK will rise.

CONCLUSION

High sensitivity and accuracy of PrTBK test enable us to initiate treatment on the basis of this convenient and rapid test.

Pulmonary Tuberculosis Diagnosis: Where We Are?

In recent years, in spite of medical advancement, tuberculosis (TB) remains a worldwide health problem. Although many laboratory methods have been developed to expedite the diagnosis of TB, delays in diagnosis remain a major problem in the clinical practice. Because of the slow growth rate of the causative agent Mycobacterium tuberculosis, isolation, identification, and drug susceptibility testing of this organism and other clinically important mycobacteria can take several weeks or longer. During the past several years, many methods have been developed for direct detection, species identification, and drug susceptibility testing of TB. A good understanding of the effectiveness and practical limitations of these methods is important to improve diagnosis. This review summarizes the currently-used advances in nonmolecular and molecular diagnostics.

A case of tuberculosis and adenocarcinoma coexisting in the same lung lobe

Tuberculosis and lung cancer rarely coincide together but have been proven to have a definitive link. In this case we describe tuberculosis and adenocarcinoma diagnosed together in the same lobe of the lung. The patient was found to have an epidermal growth factor receptor exon 19 deletion, which has been shown to have an association with tuberculosis.

Frequency and clinical implications of the isolation of rare nontuberculous mycobacteria

Background

To date, more than 125 species of nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) have been identified. In this study, we investigated the frequency and clinical implication of the rarely isolated NTM from respiratory specimens.

Methods

Patients with NTM isolated from their respiratory specimens between July 1, 2010 and June 31, 2012 were screened for inclusion. Rare NTM were defined as those NTM not falling within the group of eight NTM species commonly identified at our institution: Mycobacterium avium, M. intracellulare, M. abscessus, M. massiliense, M. fortuitum, M. kansasii, M. gordonae, and M. peregrinum. Clinical, radiographic and microbiological data from patients with rare NTM were reviewed and analyzed.

Results

During the study period, 73 rare NTM were isolated from the respiratory specimens of 68 patients. Among these, M. conceptionense was the most common (nine patients, 12.3%). The median age of the 68 patients with rare NTM was 68 years, while 39 of the patients were male. Rare NTM were isolated only once in majority of patient (64 patients, 94.1%). Among the four patients from whom rare NTM were isolated two or more times, only two showed radiographic aggravation caused by rare NTM during the follow-up period.

Conclusions

Most of the rarely identified NTM species were isolated from respiratory specimens only once per patient, without concomitant clinical aggravation. Clinicians could therefore observe such patients closely without invasive work-ups or treatment, provided the patients do not have decreased host immunity towards mycobacteria.

Evaluation of three rapid assays for Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex detection in a comprehensive hospital from West China

OBJECTIVES

To assess the capacity of rapid and accurate confirmation of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) in a Chinese clinical laboratory.

DESIGN AND METHODS

This prospective study investigated three rapid assays, the Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct (MTD) test, real-time PCR, and acid-fast bacilli (AFB) smear, for direct detection of MTBC in a large consecutive series of different clinical specimens. Performance parameters were estimated and compared overall and for separate specimen categories using a combined reference gold standard.

RESULTS

The overall sensitivities were similar for MTD and real-time PCR (62.26% vs. 58.49%), significantly higher than those of AFB smear (31.13%). Among three assays, MTD had a satisfactory sensitivity in respiratory specimen (73.33%) and a nearly perfect detection for smear-positive samples (96.97%). Real-time PCR showed a high positive rate (58.97%) in regard to nonrespiratory specimen. A combination of molecular assays with conventional methods reached marked additive diagnostic values (sensitivity up to 76.42%), higher than each method individually. All detection systems showed excellent specificities (>96.00%).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study indicated that our lab had a moderate diagnostic performance for tuberculosis. Quality guarantee for specimen pretreatment, as well as combination analysis, will enable these assays to better incorporate into the routine laboratory workflow in China.

Diagnostic accuracy and turnaround time of the Xpert MTB/RIF assay in routine clinical practice

The Xpert MTB/RIF assay was introduced for timely and accurate detection of tuberculosis (TB). The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic accuracy and turnaround time (TAT) of Xpert MTB/RIF assay in clinical practice in South Korea. We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of patients in whom Xpert MTB/RIF assay using sputum were requested. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) for the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) and detection of rifampicin resistance were calculated. In addition, TAT of Xpert MTB/RIF assay was compared with those of other tests. Total 681 patients in whom Xpert MTB/RIF assay was requested were included in the analysis. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of Xpert MTB/RIF assay for diagnosis of PTB were 79.5% (124/156), 100.0% (505/505), 100.0% (124/124) and 94.0% (505/537), respectively. Those for the detection of rifampicin resistance were 57.1% (8/14), 100.0% (113/113), 100.0% (8/8) and 94.9% (113/119), respectively. The median TAT of Xpert MTB/RIF assay to the report of results and results confirmed by physicians in outpatient settings were 0 (0–1) and 6 (3–7) days, respectively. Median time to treatment after initial evaluation was 7 (4–9) days in patients with Xpert MTB/RIF assay, but was 21 (7–33.5) days in patients without Xpert MTB/RIF assay. Xpert MTB/RIF assay showed acceptable sensitivity and excellent specificity for the diagnosis of PTB and detection of rifampicin resistance in areas with intermediate TB burden. Additionally, the assay decreased time to the initiation of anti-TB drugs through shorter TAT.

Novel real-time simultaneous amplification and testing method to accurately and rapidly detect Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex

The aim of this study was to establish and evaluate a simultaneous amplification and testing method for detection of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (SAT-TB assay) in clinical specimens by using isothermal RNA amplification and real-time fluorescence detection. In the SAT-TB assay, a 170-bp M. tuberculosis 16S rRNA fragment is reverse transcribed to DNA by use of Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MLV) reverse transcriptase, using specific primers incorporating the T7 promoter sequence, and undergoes successive cycles of amplification using T7 RNA polymerase. Using a real-time PCR instrument, hybridization of an internal 6-carboxyfluorescein-4-[4-(dimethylamino)phenylazo] benzoic acid N-succinimidyl ester (FAM-DABCYL)-labeled fluorescent probe can be used to detect RNA amplification. The SAT-TB assay takes less than 1.5 h to perform, and the sensitivity of the assay for detection of M. tuberculosis H37Rv is 100 CFU/ml. The TB probe has no cross-reactivity with nontuberculous mycobacteria or other common respiratory tract pathogens. For 253 pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) specimens and 134 non-TB specimens, the SAT-TB results correlated with 95.6% (370/387 specimens) of the Bactec MGIT 960 culture assay results. The sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the SAT-TB test for the diagnosis of PTB were 67.6%, 100%, 100%, and 62.0%, respectively, compared to 61.7%, 100%, 100%, and 58.0% for Bactec MGIT 960 culture. For PTB diagnosis, the sensitivities of the SAT-TB and Bactec MGIT 960 culture methods were 97.6% and 95.9%, respectively, for smear-positive specimens and 39.2% and 30.2%, respectively, for smear-negative specimens. In conclusion, the SAT-TB assay is a novel, simple test with a high specificity which may enhance the detection rate of TB. It is therefore a promising tool for rapid diagnosis of M. tuberculosis infection in clinical microbiology laboratories.

Bronchoscopy in suspected pulmonary TB with negative induced-sputum smear and MTD(®) Gen-probe testing

INTRODUCTION

In our institution, patients with suspected pulmonary TB undergo multiple induced-sputum sampling for microscopy, culture and nucleic acid amplification (NAA) with the MTD(®) Gen-probe assay. Those with negative induced-sputum results still suspected with TB are then referred for bronchoscopy. We sought to determine the diagnostic yield of bronchoscopy in these patients with negative initial induced-sputum results both via smear and NAA testing.

METHODS

We identified 30 consecutive cases of suspected pulmonary TB between 2001 and 2007, who had undergone a diagnostic bronchoscopy after negative results on induced-sputum smears and the MTD(®) Gen-probe on at least 2 samples.

RESULTS

The cohort (M = 20 & F = 10) had a median age of 37 (range 16-85 yrs); were predominantly foreign born (27/30); HIV-negative (29/30) individuals with strongly positive TST's (mean 18 + 5 mm). Induced-sputum cultures were negative for M-TB in all patients after a full 60-day incubation period. BAL was culture positive for M-TB in 3/30 cases (10%) with 2 strains being pan-sensitive and the third being INH resistant. BAL microscopy with acid-fast smear (n = 30) and BAL Gen-probe (n = 23) were negative in all cases. A third of the patients (9/27, 33%) with negative bronchoscopy results were treated for culture negative TB. Treatment for latent TB was initiated in 5/27 (18%) individuals whereas 13/27 (48%) received no further treatment.

CONCLUSION

Bronchoscopy provided diagnostic confirmation of pulmonary TB in 10% of subjects at least 2 negative induced-sputum samples by smear microscopy and NAA testing.

The incidence and clinical implication of sputum with positive acid-fast bacilli smear but negative in mycobacterial culture in a tertiary referral hospital in South Korea

Although it is not rare to find sputum that is positive acid-fast bacilli (AFB) smear but subsequent culture fails to isolate mycobacteria in clinical practice, the incidence and clinical implication of those sputa from new patients has not been clearly elucidated. The aim of this study was to determine the incidence and clinical implication of sputum with positive AFB smear but negative in mycobacterial culture. All sputa that were positive AFB smear requested during diagnostic work up for new patients visiting Seoul National University Hospital from 1 January 2005 through 31 December 2006 were included. Sputa producing a positive AFB smear but negative mycobacterial culture were classified into one of four categories: laboratory failure to isolate mycobacteria, false positive AFB smear, pathogen may show a positive AFB smear other than mycobacteria, and indeterminate results. Out of 447 sputa with a positive AFB smear, 29 (6.5%) failed to culture any organism. Among these 29 sputa, 18 were caused by laboratory failure to isolate mycobacteria, six were false positive smears, and five indeterminate. Although most sputum with a positive AFB smear but negative culture could be classified as a laboratory failure, clinicians should consider the possibility of false positive AFB smear.

Cost-effectiveness of different strategies for amplified Mycobacterium tuberculosis direct testing for cases of pulmonary tuberculosis

We conducted a decision analysis to assess and compare four algorithms for amplified Mycobacterium tuberculosis direct (MTD) testing of respiratory specimens in terms of cost-effectiveness. The most cost-effective strategy was one in which smear-positive specimens but not smear-negative specimens were diluted prior to MTD testing.

Nontuberculous mycobacterial infections

CONTEXT

Nontuberculous mycobacteria include numerous acid-fast bacilli species, many of which have only recently been recognized as pathogenic. The diagnosis of mycobacterial disease is based on a combination of clinical features, microbiologic data, radiographic findings, and histopathologic studies.

OBJECTIVE

To provide an overview of the clinical and pathologic aspects of nontuberculous mycobacteria infection, including diagnostic laboratory methods, classification, epidemiology, clinical presentation, and treatment.

DATA SOURCES

Review of the pertinent literature and published methodologies.

CONCLUSIONS

Nontuberculous mycobacteria include numerous acid-fast bacilli species, many of which are potentially pathogenic, and are classified according to the Runyon system based on growth rates and pigment production. Their slow growth hinders cultures, which require special medium and prolonged incubation. Although such methods are still used, newer nucleic acid-based technologies (polymerase chain reaction and hybridization assays) can rapidly detect and speciate some mycobacteria--most notably, distinguishing Mycobacterium tuberculosis from other species. Infections caused by these organisms can present as a variety of clinical syndromes, not only in immunocompromised patients but also in immunocompetent hosts. Most common among these are chronic pulmonary infections, superficial lymphadenitis, soft tissue and osteoarticular infections, and disseminated disease. Treatment of nontuberculous mycobacterial infections is difficult, requiring extended courses of multidrug therapy with or without adjunctive surgical intervention.

Commercial nucleic-acid amplification tests for diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in respiratory specimens: meta-analysis and meta-regression

Background

Hundreds of studies have evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of nucleic-acid amplification tests (NAATs) for tuberculosis (TB). Commercial tests have been shown to give more consistent results than in-house assays. Previous meta-analyses have found high specificity but low and highly variable estimates of sensitivity. However, reasons for variability in study results have not been adequately explored. We performed a meta-analysis on the accuracy of commercial NAATs to diagnose pulmonary TB and meta-regression to identify factors that are associated with higher accuracy.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We identified 2948 citations from searching the literature. We found 402 articles that met our eligibility criteria. In the final analysis, 125 separate studies from 105 articles that reported NAAT results from respiratory specimens were included. The pooled sensitivity was 0.85 (range 0.36–1.00) and the pooled specificity was 0.97 (range 0.54–1.00). However, both measures were significantly heterogeneous (p<.001). We performed subgroup and meta-regression analyses to identify sources of heterogeneity. Even after stratifying by type of commercial test, we could not account for the variability. In the meta-regression, the threshold effect was significant (p = .01) and the use of other respiratory specimens besides sputum was associated with higher accuracy.

Conclusions/Significance

The sensitivity and specificity estimates for commercial NAATs in respiratory specimens were highly variable, with sensitivity lower and more inconsistent than specificity. Thus, summary measures of diagnostic accuracy are not clinically meaningful. The use of different cut-off values and the use of specimens other than sputum could explain some of the observed heterogeneity. Based on these observations, commercial NAATs alone cannot be recommended to replace conventional tests for diagnosing pulmonary TB. Improvements in diagnostic accuracy, particularly sensitivity, need to be made in order for this expensive technology to be worthwhile and beneficial in low-resource countries.

Use of the amplified mycobacterium tuberculosis direct test in a public health laboratory: test performance and impact on clinical care

BACKGROUND

The Amplified Mycobacterium tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD; Gen-Probe; San Diego, CA) is a nucleic-acid amplification test for rapid pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) diagnosis. In a routine public health setting, test accuracy and impact on clinical decisions are unknown.

METHODS

Retrospectively, we evaluated MTD accuracy and impact on clinical decisions in a public health setting. To estimate MTD accuracy, mycobacterial culture was used as the "gold standard." To evaluate MTD impact on clinical decisions, concordance of clinician presumptive diagnosis (at time of MTD and smear availability) and definitive diagnosis, and duration of nonindicated tuberculosis therapy were determined for smear-positive PTB suspects in a period of MTD availability (MTD group) and a prior period of MTD nonavailability (non-MTD group).

RESULTS

A total of 1,151 respiratory specimens from 638 PTB suspects were analyzed. MTD sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value were 91.7%, 98.7%, 96.7%, and 96.5% overall, respectively; and 98.7%, 97.8%, 98.7%, and 97.8% for smear-positive patients; and 62.2%, 98.9%, 85.2%, and 96.1% for smear-negative patients. In the MTD group, concordance between definitive and clinician presumptive diagnoses was 78% (95% confidence interval [CI], 64 to 88%), similar to that for the non-MTD group (79%; 95% CI, 68.4 to 89.6%). However, concordance between definitive diagnosis and the MTD test was 98% (95% CI, 94.1 to 100%). Median duration of nonindicated tuberculosis treatment was 6 days for the MTD group vs 31 days for the non-MTD group (p = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

In this public health setting, MTD was accurate and rapidly detected more than half of the smear-negative PTB cases. For smear-positive PTB suspects, MTD had excellent concordance with definitive diagnosis, but clinicians often inappropriately initiated TB therapy despite a negative MTD result.

Current evidence on diagnostic accuracy of commercially based nucleic acid amplification tests for the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis

BACKGROUND

Even though commercial nucleic acid amplification tests (NAATs) have become the most frequently used molecular tests for laboratory diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (TB), published studies report variable estimates of their diagnostic accuracy. We analysed the accuracy of commercial NAATs for the diagnosis of pulmonary TB in smear positive and smear negative respiratory samples using culture as a reference standard.

METHODS

English language studies reporting data sufficient for calculating sensitivity and specificity of commercial NAATs on smear positive and/or smear negative respiratory samples were included. Meta-regression was used to analyse associations with reference test quality, the prevalence of TB, sample and test type. Predictive values for different levels of pre-test probability were quantified using Bayes' approach.

RESULTS

Sixty three journal articles published between 1995 and 2004 met the inclusion criteria. Pooled sensitivity and specificity were 0.96 and 0.85 among smear positive samples and 0.66 and 0.98 among smear negative samples. The number of culture media used as reference test, the inclusion of bronchial samples, and the TB prevalence were found to influence the reported accuracy. The test type had no effect on the diagnostic odds ratio but seemed to be correlated with sensitivity or specificity, probably via a threshold effect.

CONCLUSIONS

Commercial NAATs can be confidently used to exclude TB in patients with smear positive samples in which environmental mycobacteria infection is suspected and to confirm TB in a proportion of smear negative cases. The methodological characteristics of primary studies have a considerable effect on the reported diagnostic accuracy.

Reduction in turnaround time for laboratory diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis by routine use of a nucleic acid amplification test

Every first diagnostic specimen from suspected patients with pulmonary TB was tested by a nucleic acid amplification test (NAAT) to determine the reduction in turnaround time (TAT) for detecting Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) that was possible under normal laboratory operating conditions. NAAT (Gen-Probe Mycobacterium tuberculosis Direct Testtrade mark) was performed on the first specimen and liquid culture (BACTEC 460), solid culture (Lowenstein-Jensen [LJ] agar and selective 7H11 [7H11S] agar), and fluorescent acid-fast bacilli (AFB) smear were performed on all 3 specimens from each patient. Eighty-one (10.2%) of 797 patients tested were diagnosed with pulmonary TB. The sensitivity of NAAT, BACTEC, LJ, 7H11S, and smear for the first specimen was 90%, 85%, 67%, 53%, and 58%, respectively, whereas the sensitivity for the series of 3 specimens was 90%, 95%, 74%, 74%, and 70%, respectively. Positive predictive value was 100% for all tests except AFB smear, which was 79%. The time to detect 75% of all TB cases was 4 days for NAAT and 21 days for liquid culture; other tests had a sensitivity of less than 75%. Identification and testing every first diagnostic specimen by NAAT has the potential to reduce the overall TAT for laboratory TB diagnosis by approximately 2 weeks.

The diagnosis of tuberculosis

Diagnostic testing for tuberculosis has remained unchanged for nearly a century, but newer technologies hold the promise of a true revolution in tuberculosis diagnostics. New tests may well supplant the tuberculin skin test in diagnosing latent tuberculosis infection in much of the world. Tests such as the nucleic acid amplification assays allow more rapid and accurate diagnosing of pulmonary and extrapulmonary tuberculosis. The appropriate and affordable use of any of these tests depends on the setting in which they are employed.

Molecular genetic methods for diagnosis and antibiotic resistance detection of mycobacteria from clinical specimens

Mycobacteria comprise a diverse group of bacteria that are widespread in nature, some of which cause significant disease in humans. Members of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) are the most important human pathogens of the genus Mycobacterium. Traditional methods for detection and identification of mycobacteria include microscopy, culture and phenotypic tests. These methods either lack sensitivity, specificity, or are time consuming. Advances in the field of molecular biology have provided rapid diagnostic tools that have reduced the turnaround times for detecting MTBC and drug resistance in cultures and directly in clinical specimens from weeks to days. This review discusses the molecular genetic techniques for detecting and identifying MTBC as well as drug resistance of mycobacteria in clinical specimens.

Practical strategies for performance optimization of the enhanced gen-probe amplified mycobacterium tuberculosis direct test

The enhanced Gen-Probe Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct (MTD) test was evaluated using a combined set of 338 acid-fast smear-positive and smear-negative, respiratory and nonrespiratory clinical specimens received by the Massachusetts State Tuberculosis Laboratory from September 1999 through March 2002. Microbiological culture was used as the reference method; therefore, the sensitivity and specificity of the MTD test were calculated for culture-positive specimens only. The initial assessment indicated that the overall sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the MTD test for all specimens grouped together were 62, 98, 99, and 68%, respectively. A detailed discrepancy analysis revealed that two major factors causing negative MTD results in specimens that were culture positive for M. tuberculosis complex were patient treatment with antituberculosis drugs prior to testing and the presence of inhibitory substances in the specimen. Based on these findings, a protocol for optimizing MTD test performance in this setting is proposed in which (i) specimens from patients taking antituberculosis medications are excluded from testing and (ii) all initially MTD-negative or MTD-equivocal specimens are subjected to testing for inhibitors. If this strategy was followed, the MTD test sensitivity would be at least 91%, a significant improvement over the initial sensitivity of 62%. Accordingly, the negative predictive value would increase from 68 to 91%.

PCR-based diagnostics for infectious diseases: uses, limitations, and future applications in acute-care settings

Molecular diagnostics are revolutionising the clinical practice of infectious disease. Their effects will be significant in acute-care settings where timely and accurate diagnostic tools are critical for patient treatment decisions and outcomes. PCR is the most well-developed molecular technique up to now, and has a wide range of already fulfilled, and potential, clinical applications, including specific or broad-spectrum pathogen detection, evaluation of emerging novel infections, surveillance, early detection of biothreat agents, and antimicrobial resistance profiling. PCR-based methods may also be cost effective relative to traditional testing procedures. Further advancement of technology is needed to improve automation, optimise detection sensitivity and specificity, and expand the capacity to detect multiple targets simultaneously (multiplexing). This review provides an up-to-date look at the general principles, diagnostic value, and limitations of the most current PCR-based platforms as they evolve from bench to bedside.

Evaluation of the BDProbeTec strand displacement amplification assay in comparison with the AMTD II direct test for rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis

The BDProbeTec MTB assay for direct detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis was evaluated in comparison with the AMTD-II assay on 94 samples from different patients with clinical suspicion of tuberculosis. Using a combination of culture on Lowenstein-Jensen medium (with or without preculture in BACTEC 9000) and clinical diagnosis as the standard, BDProbeTec MTB showed high sensitivity and specificity (96.1% and 100%, respectively), similar to AMTD-II (96.1% and 97.1%, respectively), with significantly higher sensitivity than the Ziehl-Neelsen stain for acid-fast bacilli (73%, p < 0.05).

Evaluation of the BDProbeTec ET system as screening tool in the direct detection of mycobacterium tuberculosis complex in respiratory specimens

We evaluated the BDProbeTec ET System (Becton Dickinson) for the routine detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTC) in respiratory specimens and pleural fluids, comparing with microscopy (Ziehl Neelsen stain, ZN) and culture in liquid (BACTEC MGIT 960, MGIT) and solid (Löwenstein Jensen, LJ) media. Five hundred and two specimens, collected from 266 patients, of which 257 with suspected tuberculosis and 9 receiving anti-tuberculosis treatment, were investigated. Thirty-nine specimens were positive by any method, including false positives. Mycobacteria were isolated from 33 specimens (32 Mycobacterium tuberculosis and 1 Mycobacterium chelonae). Thirty-six specimens were BDProbeTec ET positive, 33 specimens were MGIT positive, 27 were LJ positive and 22 were ZN positive. With BDProbeTec ET, 2 specimens were false negative (culture positive), and 2 specimens from non-treated patients were false positive (culture negative). The overall sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for BDProbeTec ET compared to culture were 93.7, 98.7, 83.3, and 99.5%, respectively, while with smear-positive and smear-negative specimens the sensitivities were 100% and 81.5% respectively. In five treated patients the disappearance of MTC could be monitored using BDProbeTec ET in parallel with culture. The overall inhibition rate was 0.2%. BDProbeTec ET can be very useful for rapid detection of MTC, especially in smear-negative respiratory specimens.

Assessment of laboratory performance of nucleic acid amplification tests for detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

During implementation of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Mycobacterium tuberculosis nucleic acid amplification (NAA) evaluation program, 27.1% of participants used the same biological safety cabinet for NAA and specimen processing; 28.8% reported not using unidirectional workflow. An association between false positives and adverse responses to quality assurance questions (P = 0.04) illustrated the need for following NCCLS recommendations.

Role of clinical judgment in the application of a nucleic acid amplification test for the rapid diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis

BACKGROUND

Several nucleic acid amplification (NAA) tests for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) have been licensed for the rapid diagnosis of active pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) in respiratory secretions. There is uncertainty however regarding the practical application of these tests in clinical decision making.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the utility of the COBAS AMPLICOR assay (Roche Diagnostics; Singapore) for MTB as applied by specialists for the rapid diagnosis of PTB in the routine clinical setting.

DESIGN

A prospective study of consecutive patients suspected of PTB and tested with the AMPLICOR assay under the care of respiratory physicians. The final diagnosis was based on all relevant clinical information after at least 3 months of follow-up. Accuracy of the NAA test was compared with that of the initial expectant treatment. Expectant treatment was based on an integrated approach that incorporated clinical evaluation with results of direct smear and NAA tests.

RESULTS

The incidence of PTB in 168 patients was 32%. The basis for expectant treatment of PTB was positive smear result in 47%, clinical suspicion in 26%, and positive AMPLICOR result in 23%. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, and accuracy of the AMPLICOR test were 77%, 100%, 99%, 90%, and 93%, respectively. In comparison, they were 96%, 97%, 94%, 98%, and 97%, respectively, for the integrated clinical approach.

CONCLUSIONS

In the rapid diagnosis of PTB, the clinical judgment of specialists augmented the utility of the NAA test: (1) specialists selected patients with high-to-moderate pretest probabilities, (2) they commenced treatment promptly on a positive NAA test result, and (3) they were willing to start treatment in some patients on the basis of high clinical suspicion despite negative smear and negative NAA test results.

The evaluation of FASTPlaqueTB test for the rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis

FASTPlaqueTB (Biotec Laboratories Ltd., Ipswich, UK) is a rapid test which utilizes bacteriophage amplification technology for the detection of viable Mycobacterium tuberculosis in clinical specimens. We evaluated performance of the FASTPlaqueTB test by comparing with BACTEC 460 TB culture system (Becton Dickinson Co., Maryland, USA), polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and acid fast bacilli (AFB) smear methods. We investigated 192 sputum specimens collected from the patients suspected of having pulmonary TB by AFB smear, BACTEC 460 TB culture system, PCR and FASTPlaqueTB test. The sensitivity of AFB smear, PCR and FASTPlaqueTB test were 57.8%, 84.4% and 87.5% respectively when we accepted BACTEC 460 TB culture system as gold standard. We conclude that FASTPlaqueTB test has a good potential for rapid diagnosis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis as a result of the evaluation of these three tests by comparison to the BACTEC 460 TB culture system.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of the gen-probe amplified mycobacterium tuberculosis direct test as used routinely on smear-positive respiratory specimens

A decision analysis was conducted to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of programs in which the Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct test (MTD) (Gen-Probe) is used to rapidly exclude Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex as a cause of disease in smear-positive respiratory specimens. MTD sensitivity, specificity, and probability of inhibition for smear-positive specimens were estimated from literature reports. Costs and laboratory performance characteristics were determined from review of records and practices at an urban hospital in the mid-Atlantic United States. In the base case, 31.4% of smear-positive specimens were assumed to be culture positive for M. tuberculosis. Under these conditions, the marginal cost of the MTD testing program was estimated as $338 per smear-positive patient, or $494 per early exclusion of tuberculosis based on negative MTD results. By comparison, the cost of respiratory isolation ($27.77/day) and drugs ($5.66/day) averted by MTD testing was estimated at $201 per early tuberculosis exclusion. MTD testing was therefore not cost-effective in this scenario. Sensitivity analysis revealed that cost-effectiveness estimates are sensitive to the number of smear-positive specimens processed annually, the relative prevalence of M. tuberculosis in smear-positive specimens, and the marginal daily cost of respiratory isolation. A decision tool is therefore presented for assessing the cost-effectiveness of MTD under various combinations of those three variables. While routine MTD testing of smear-positive specimens is not expected to be cost-saving for most individual hospitals, centralized reference laboratories may be able to implement MTD in a cost-effective manner across a wide range of situations.

What is the optimal approach for using a direct amplification test in the routine diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis? A preliminary assessment

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to determine the most appropriate strategy for the rapid diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) using a nucleic acid amplification (NAA) test.

METHODOLOGY

This was a prospective study of 128 adult patients in whom respiratory secretions were tested for Mycobacterium tuberculosis by the AMPLICOR assay. The basis for starting PTB treatment was noted for each patient. The optimal approach was determined by using Bayes' theorem to compare different combinations of pretest probability, smear results with the AMPLICOR test.

RESULTS

The incidence of PTB was 15.6%. In only one patient was treatment for PTB commenced because of a positive AMPLICOR result. The rest were managed according to the conventional approach which relied upon clinical judgment and direct smear. The optimal approach was to treat patients with high or intermediate pretest risk for PTB who returned positive AMPLICOR tests. The overall accuracies of the conventional approach, AMPLICOR test and optimal approach were 89.8, 95.3 and 96.1%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This small study suggests that NAA testing be limited to patients with high or intermediate pretest risk of PTB. In this group, positive results demand treatment while the management of those with negative results still relies on clinical judgment.

Evaluation of the BDProbeTec ET DTB assay(1) for direct detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex from clinical samples

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the ability of BDProbeTec ET DTB system to detect Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex directly from clinical specimens. A total of 628 specimens (553 respiratory and 75 non respiratory specimens) were collected from 478 patients. These samples were tested with the BDProbeTec ET DTB assay and results were compared with acid fast microscopy and culture. Sixty eight out of 77 culture positive M. tuberculosis complex samples were detected with overall sensitivity and specificity of 89.5% and 98.2% respectively. Overall sensitivity was 100% in smear positive samples and 79% in smear negative samples. After resolution of discrepant results, sensitivity and specificity for respiratory samples were 91.6% and 98.7% respectively. BDProbeTec ET DTB assay demonstrated to be a rapid, sensitive and specific method for detection of M. tuberculosis complex.

The mycobacteriology laboratory and new diagnostic techniques

Use of the most rapid and reliable laboratory tests for mycobacterial detection, identification, and susceptibility testing is important for TB control. In 1993, CDC experts made recommendations regarding optimal methods of mycobacterial testing (i.e., stains for AFB, culture, identification, and susceptibility testing of M. tuberculosis) and turnaround times for reporting results. Various technical advances have enhanced the diagnostic capability of the laboratory and/or improved laboratory efficiency since then. The commercial NAA tests for direct detection of MTBC have the greatest potential to impact patient care. To assist physicians, CDC experts have published recommendations concerning use of the NAA tests for management of patients with suspected TB, with emphasis on the MTD assay, which is approved for both AFB smear-positive and smear-negative specimens. With regard to mycobacterial culture, totally automated, nonradiometric systems are commercially available. For mycobacterial identification, various molecular techniques have been developed, but at present, they are used predominantly in research or large reference laboratories. Molecular tests also have proved useful for better understanding the epidemiology of TB and investigating episodes of suspected laboratory cross-contamination. With regard to mycobacterial susceptibility testing, use of the new automated culture systems for testing MTBC is under evaluation, but only one such system has been approved for this purpose. In addition, laboratory guidelines for susceptibility testing of MTBC and certain NTM have recently been published by the NCCLS.

Rapid detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in contaminated BACTEC 12B broth cultures by testing with Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test

Contamination of broth cultures of acid-fast bacilli (AFB) by bacterial species other than Mycobacterium species frequently occurs. Many of these contaminated cultures require redecontamination and reincubation before the appropriate tests can be performed for identification, significantly affecting the turnaround time for reporting culture results. In this study, the Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD; Gen-Probe) was performed to detect the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) in 125 BACTEC 12B broth cultures with positive growth indices. Among these, 41 grew non-AFB bacteria only, and all 41 were negative by the MTD. The remaining 84 bottles contained contaminated cultures that grew both AFB and other bacteria or yeasts. Repeat decontamination and reincubation of these specimens required a mean time of 13 days (range, 3 to 40 days). The MTD results were positive for 10 samples, 9 of which were MTBC culture positive and 1 of which grew Myobacterium celatum, a species known to cross-react in the MTD. All cultures growing other mycobacterial species were negative by the MTD. The results of this study demonstrate that the MTD is both sensitive and specific in detecting MTBC in contaminated broth cultures and that, when used selectively, the MTD can potentially rule in or out a diagnosis of MTBC as much as 12 days earlier than using nonamplified DNA probe testing alone can.

Serological expression cloning and immunological evaluation of MTB48, a novel Mycobacterium tuberculosis antigen

Improved diagnostics are needed for the detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, especially for patients with smear-negative disease. To address this problem, we have screened M. tuberculosis (H37Rv and Erdman strains) genomic expression libraries with pooled sera from patients with extrapulmonary disease and with sera from patients with elevated reactivity with M. tuberculosis lysate. Both serum pools were reactive with clones expressing a recombinant protein referred to here as MTB48. The genomic sequence of the resulting clones was identical to that of the M. tuberculosis H37Rv isolate and showed 99% identity to the Mycobacterium bovis and M. bovis BCG isolate sequences. The genomic location of this sequence is 826 bp upstream of a region containing the esat-6 gene that is deleted in the M. bovis BCG isolate. The mtb48 1,380-bp open reading frame encodes a predicted 47.6-kDa polypeptide with no known function. Southern and Western blot analyses indicate that this sequence is present in a single copy and is conserved in the M. tuberculosis and M. bovis isolates tested but not in other mycobacterial species tested, including Mycobacterium leprae and Mycobacterium avium. In addition, the native protein was detected in the cytoplasm, as was a processed form that was also shed into the medium during culture. Serological analysis of recombinant MTB48 and the M. tuberculosis 38-kDa antigen with a panel of patient and control sera indicates that the inclusion of recombinant MTB48 in a prototype serodiagnostic test increases assay sensitivity for M. tuberculosis infection when it is combined with other known immunodominant antigens, such as the 38-kDa antigen.

Molecular Diagnosis of Mycobacteria

Tuberculosis is one of the leading infectious diseases in the world and is responsible for more than 2 million deaths and 8 million new cases annually. Because of the slow growth rate of the causative agent Mycobacterium tuberculosis, isolation, identification, and drug susceptibility testing of this organism and other clinically important mycobacteria can take several weeks or longer. During the past several years, many molecular methods have been developed for direct detection, species identification, and drug susceptibility testing of mycobacteria. These methods can potentially reduce the diagnostic time from weeks to days. Currently, two nucleic acid amplification methods, the Enhanced Mycobacterium tuberculosis Direct Test (Gen-Probe) and the Amplicor Mycobacterium tuberculosis Test (Roche Diagnostic Systems), have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration for direct detection of M. tuberculosis from clinical specimens. PCR-based sequencing has become commonly used to identify many mycobacterial species. DNA probes have been widely used for species determination of the most commonly encountered mycobacteria. High-density oligonucleotide arrays (DNA microarrays) also have been applied to simultaneous species identification and detection of mutations that confer rifampin resistance in mycobacteria.

Clinical Evaluation of the Gen-Probe amplified mycobacterium tuberculosis direct test for rapid detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in select nonrespiratory specimens

The performance of the Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD; Gen-Probe, Inc., San Diego, Calif.) for rapid diagnosis of extrapulmonary tuberculosis was evaluated by testing 178 nonrespiratory specimens from 158 patients. Criteria for specimen inclusion were (i) a positive smear for acid-fast bacilli (n = 54) and (ii) the source if the smear was negative (tissue biopsies and aspirates and abscess material were tested; n = 124). Results were compared to those of mycobacterial culture; clinical history was reviewed when MTD and culture results disagreed. Forty-eight specimens (27.0%) were positive for mycobacteria, including 23 Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex specimens; of which 21 were smear positive. Twenty-five specimens were MTD positive; 20 of these grew M. tuberculosis complex. All of the five MTD-positive, M. tuberculosis complex culture-negative specimens were considered truly positive, based on review of the medical record. Of the three MTD-negative, M. tuberculosis complex culture-positive specimens, two contained inhibitory substances; one of the two was smear positive. Excluding the latter specimen from analysis, after chart review, the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the MTD were 92.6, 100, 100, and 98.7%, respectively, by specimen and 89.5, 100, 100, and 98.6% by patient. Given the few smear-negative samples from patients with extrapulmonary tuberculosis in our study, additional similar studies that include more smear-negative, M. tuberculosis complex culture-positive specimens to confirm our data are desirable.

Molecular techniques in mycobacterial detection

OBJECTIVE

To assess the clinical utility of the commercial nucleic acid amplification (NAA) tests (ie, Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test, Gen-Probe, Inc and AMPLICOR Mycobacterium tuberculosis Test, Roche Molecular Systems, Inc) for direct detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex.

DATA SOURCES

Review of the English-language literature.

CONCLUSIONS

The performance of both NAA tests is excellent (sensitivity, > or = 95%; specificity, 100%) when testing respiratory specimens that are smear-positive for acid-fast bacilli (AFB). Only the Gen-Probe assay is approved for testing respiratory specimens regardless of the AFB smear result. Data from 3 studies showed that the sensitivity of the Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test in smear-negative patients ranged from 83% to 85%, and that the specificity was 99%. Both NAA tests have been used to test nonrespiratory specimens; in some studies, the performance was comparable to the performance obtained for respiratory specimens, whereas in others, it was lower. The NAA tests also appear to be reliable tools for rapid detection of M tuberculosis complex in positive broth cultures of all specimen types (except blood). The impact of the NAA tests on patient outcome varies based on the result of the AFB smear. In smear-positive patients, public health and hospital infection-control resources are predominantly affected. The potential for influencing patient outcome is much greater when the AFB smear is negative. In smear-negative patients, the NAA test could provide more rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis and subsequent initiation of therapy; eliminate the need for invasive diagnostic procedures, which are both costly and pose an added risk to the patient; and allow earlier discharge of hospitalized patients. Prospective studies concerning the cost-effectiveness of the NAA tests are needed.

Clinical evaluation of the BDProbeTec ET system for rapid detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

The performance of the BDProbeTec ET system (BD Biosciences, Sparks, Md.) for direct detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) in respiratory specimens was evaluated by comparing results to those of conventional mycobacterial culture performed with the BACTEC 460 TB system and Middlebrook 7H11 biplates. Patients known to have been on antituberculous therapy were excluded from the analysis. Of 600 evaluable specimens (4 specimens were excluded from the analysis due to failure of the internal amplification control [IAC]) from 332 patients, 57 grew mycobacteria; 16 were MTBC (from 12 patients), and 41 were nontuberculous mycobacteria. Of the 16 MTBC culture-positive specimens, 12 were smear positive and 4 were smear negative. BDProbeTec ET detected 14 of the 16 MTBC culture-positive specimens, resulting in initial overall sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of 87.5, 99.0, 70.0, and 99.7%, respectively. After resolution of discrepancies by review of medical records and retesting of samples yielding discordant MTBC culture and BDProbeTec ET results, the revised overall sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the BDProbeTec ET were respectively 93.8, 99.8, 93.8, and 99.8% by specimen and 91.7, 99.7, 91.7, and 99.7% by patient. The BDProbeTec ET System offers the distinct advantage of including an IAC in the specimen well. These data suggest that the test performance is very good, especially for smear-positive samples. However, the number of patients with tuberculosis in our study, especially those with smear-negative disease, was small; therefore, additional studies are needed.

Enhanced mycobacterium tuberculosis direct test for detection of M. tuberculosis complex in positive ESP II broth cultures of nonrespiratory specimens

The reliability of the Gen-Probe enhanced Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test (E-MTD) for identification of M. tuberculosis complex (MTBC) in ESP II broth cultures of nonrespiratory specimens was evaluated by testing aliquots from 262 signal-positive bottles. Cultures of blood were excluded from analysis because of the high rate (13/18 [72.2%]) of equivocal results for aliquots from cultures that were negative for MTBC. E-MTD results were compared to those obtained by usual laboratory protocol, whereby MTBC was identified by DNA probe (Gen-Probe, Inc.), testing colonies on a solid medium. For the first 112 cultures, from which 34 mycobacteria (including 8 MTBC) were recovered, both fresh and frozen aliquots were tested. E-MTD results on both fresh and frozen aliquots agreed with identification by usual protocol in all cases; so for the remaining 150 cultures, only frozen aliquots were tested. Of the total 262 ESP II cultures (158 patients) evaluated, 60 (22.9%) grew mycobacteria, including 17 MTBC. Of these 17 aliquots, 16 were E-MTD positive, as was one culture that was negative for mycobacteria. The latter culture was from a patient who had a specimen collected the following day from which MTBC was isolated; therefore, the E-MTD result was considered a true positive. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of E-MTD were 94.1, 100, 100, and 99.6%, respectively. The mean times (+/- SEM) from specimen receipt to identification of MTBC were 17 (+/- 2) days (range, 5-30 days) for ESP II plus E-MTD and 19 (+/- 1) days (range, 6-28 days) for the usual protocol (Student's t test, P, not significant). These data indicate that the performance of E-MTD for identification of MTBC in fresh or frozen aliquots of broth from positive ESP II cultures of nonrespiratory specimens, excluding blood, is excellent. However, because the E-MTD did not significantly reduce time to identification of MTBC in these cultures, limiting testing to those types of specimens most likely to yield MTBC is reasonable.

Molecular methods in the detection and identification of mycobacterial infections

Nucleic acid amplification (NAA) tests for direct detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex in respiratory specimens have the potential to provide a more rapid diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) than is currently possible by conventional stain, culture, and identification tests. Currently, 2 NAA tests-enhanced Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct (MTD) Test (Gen-Probe, Inc) and Amplicor Mycobacterium tuberculosis Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Inc)-have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration for testing respiratory specimens that are smear positive for acid-fast bacilli (AFB). This restriction to AFB smear-positive specimens was based on data from the initial clinical trials conducted to evaluate these products that showed low sensitivity (ie, 48%-53%) and less-than-optimal specificity (ie, 96%-99%) in AFB smear-negative specimens. Data from the clinical trial for the enhanced MTD test and from 2 subsequent studies, however, suggest that this version of the MTD test is a reliable tool for rapid diagnosis of pulmonary TB, regardless of the AFB smear result. Both NAA tests have been evaluated for diagnosis of extrapulmonary TB, and results were comparable to the results of tests performed with respiratory specimens. The NAA tests also appear to be reliable for rapid identification of M tuberculosis complex in positive broth cultures of all specimen types except blood. The impact of the NAA tests on patient outcome varies based on the AFB smear result. With smear-positive results, public health and hospital infection control resources are predominantly affected. With smear-negative results, however, the potential for affecting patient outcome is much greater. In patients with smear-negative results, the NAA test can result in earlier diagnosis of TB and subsequent initiation of therapy. Use of these tests also may eliminate the need for invasive diagnostic procedures, which are costly and pose an added risk to the patient, and they may allow earlier discharge of hospitalized patients.