Suppression of amber mutations of bacteriophage T4 gene 43 (DNA polymerase) by translational ambiguity

Suppressor Mutants: History and Today's Applications

For decades, biologist have exploited the near boundless advantages that molecular and genetic tools and analysis provide for our ability to understand biological systems. One of these genetic tools, suppressor analysis, has proven invaluable in furthering our understanding of biological processes and pathways and in discovering unknown interactions between genes and gene products. The power of suppressor analysis lies in its ability to discover genetic interactions in an unbiased manner, often leading to surprising discoveries. With advancements in technology, high-throughput approaches have aided in large-scale identification of suppressors and have helped provide insight into the core functional mechanisms through which suppressors act. In this review, we examine some of the fundamental discoveries that have been made possible through analysis of suppressor mutations. In addition, we cover the different types of suppressor mutants that can be isolated and the biological insights afforded by each type. Moreover, we provide considerations for the design of experiments to isolate suppressor mutants and for strategies to identify intergenic suppressor mutations. Finally, we provide guidance and example protocols for the isolation and mapping of suppressor mutants.

Bacteriophage T4 helicase loader protein gp59 functions as gatekeeper in origin-dependent replication in vivo

Bacteriophage T4 initiates origin-dependent replication via an R-loop mechanism in vivo. During in vitro reactions, the phage-encoded gp59 stimulates loading of the replicative helicase, gp41, onto branched intermediates, including origin R-loops. However, although gp59 is essential for recombination-dependent replication from D-loops, it does not appear to be required for origin-dependent replication in vivo. In this study, we have analyzed the origin-replicative intermediates formed during infections that are deficient in gp59 and other phage replication proteins. During infections lacking gp59, the initial replication forks from two different T4 origins actively replicated both leading- and lagging-strands. However, the retrograde replication forks from both origins were abnormal in the gp59-deficient infections. The lagging-strand from the initial fork was elongated as a new leading-strand in the retrograde direction without lagging-strand synthesis, whereas in the wild-type, leading- and lagging-strand synthesis appeared to be coupled. These results imply that gp59 inhibits the polymerase holoenzyme in vivo until the helicase-primase (gp41-gp61) complex is loaded, and we thereby refer to gp59 as a gatekeeper. We also found that all origin-replicative intermediates were absent in infections deficient in the helicase gp41 or the single-strand-binding protein gp32, regardless of whether gp59 was present or absent. These results argue that replication from the origin in vivo is dependent on both the helicase and single-strand-binding protein and demonstrate that the strong replication defect of gene 41 and 32 single mutants is not caused by gp59 inhibition of the polymerase.

Microarray analysis of gene expression during bacteriophage T4 infection

Genomic microarrays were used to examine the complex temporal program of gene expression exhibited by bacteriophage T4 during the course of development. The microarray data confirm the existence of distinct early, middle, and late transcriptional classes during the bacteriophage replicative cycle. This approach allows assignment of previously uncharacterized genes to specific temporal classes. The genomic expression data verify many promoter assignments and predict the existence of previously unidentified promoters.

Interacting fidelity defects in the replicative DNA polymerase of bacteriophage RB69

The DNA polymerases (gp43s) of the related bacteriophages T4 and RB69 are B family (polymerase alpha class) enzymes that determine the fidelity of phage DNA replication. A T4 whose gene 43 has been mutationally inactivated can be replicated by a cognate RB69 gp43 encoded by a recombinant plasmid in T4-infected Escherichia coli. We used this phage-plasmid complementation assay to obtain rapid and sensitive measurements of the mutational specificities of mutator derivatives of the RB69 enzyme. RB69 gp43s lacking proofreading function (Exo(-) enzymes) and/or substituted with alanine, serine, or threonine at the conserved polymerase function residue Tyr(567) (Pol(Y567(A/S/T)) enzymes) were examined for their effects on the reversion of specific mutations in the T4 rII gene and on forward mutation in the T4 rI gene. The results reveal that Tyr(567) is a key determinant of the fidelity of base selection and that the Pol and Exo functions are strongly coupled in this B family enzyme. In vitro assays show that the Pol(Y567A) Exo(-) enzyme generates mispairs more frequently but extends them less efficiently than does a Pol(+) Exo(-) enzyme. Other replicative DNA polymerases may control fidelity by strategies similar to those used by RB69 gp43.

Intron mobility in phage T4 occurs in the context of recombination-dependent DNA replication by way of multiple pathways

Numerous group I introns in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes behave as mobile genetic elements. The functional requirements for intron mobility were determined in the T4 phage system using an in vivo assay to measure intron homing with wild-type and mutant derivatives. Thus, it was demonstrated that intron mobility occurs in the context of phage recombination-dependent replication, a pathway that uses overlapping subsets of replication and recombination functions. The functional requirements for intron homing and the nature of recombinant products are only partially consistent with the accepted double-strand-break repair (DSBR) model for intron inheritance, and implicate additional homing pathways. Whereas ambiguities in resolvase requirements and underrepresentation of crossover recombination products are difficult to rationalize strictly by DSBR, these properties are most readily consistent with a synthesis-dependent strand annealing (SDSA) pathway. These pathways share common features in the strand invasion steps, but differ in subsequent repair synthesis and resolution steps, influencing the genetic consequences of the intron transfer event.

Mutational analysis of the mRNA operator for T4 DNA polymerase

Biosynthesis of bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase is autogenously regulated at the translational level. The enzyme, product of gene 43, represses its own translation by binding to its mRNA 5' to the initiator AUG at a 36-40 nucleotide segment that includes the Shine-Dalgarno sequence and a putative RNA hairpin structure consisting of a 5-base-pair stem and an 8-base loop. We constructed mutations that either disrupted the stem or altered specific loop residues of the hairpin and found that many of these mutations, including single-base changes in the loop sequence, diminished binding of purified T4 DNA polymerase to its RNA in vitro (as measured by a gel retardation assay) and derepressed synthesis of the enzyme in vivo (as measured in T4 infections and by recombinant-plasmid-mediated expression). In vitro effects, however, were not always congruent with in vivo effects. For example, stem pairing with a sequence other than wild-type resulted in normal protein binding in vitro but derepression of protein synthesis in vivo. Similarly, a C----A change in the loop had a small effect in vitro and a strong effect in vivo. In contrast, an A----U change near the base of the hairpin that was predicted to increase the length of the base-paired stem had small effects both in vitro and in vivo. The results suggest that interaction of T4 DNA polymerase with its structured RNA operator depends on the spatial arrangement of specific nucleotide residues and is subject to modulation in vivo.

Frameshift and double-amber mutations in the bacteriophage T4 uvsX gene: analysis of mutant UvsX proteins from infected cells

The bacteriophage T4 uvsX gene encodes a 43 kDa, single-stranded DNA-dependent ATPase, double-stranded DNA-binding protein involved in DNA recombination, repair and mutagenesis. Mutants of uvsX have a DNA-arrest phenotype and reduced burst size. Western blot immunoassay of UvsX peptides made by a number of amber mutants revealed amber peptides ranging from 25-32 kDa. Wild-type UvsX protein was also detected in lysates of cells infected with uvsX amber mutants, suggesting that their mutations are suppressed by translational ambiguity. We investigated the effects of mutations near the 5' end of uvsX. A frameshift mutation was engineered at codon 33. Western immunoblots for UvsX protein demonstrated that the frameshift mutant expresses no detectable wild-type UvsX; instead, a 37 kDa reactive peptide was detected. In order to determine if this peptide represents truncated UvsX protein, the mutation was regenerated in the cloned uvsX gene and expressed in transformed Escherichia coli. Endopeptidase digestion of the 37 kDa protein from the cloned gene generated peptide fragments indistinguishable from those obtained from wild-type UvsX. A double-amber mutant of uvsX was also generated by oligonucleotide site-directed mutagenesis. No UvsX protein was detected in lysates of cells infected with the uvsXam64am67 double mutant. Plaque size and sensitivity to UV inactivation for both the double-amber and the frameshift mutants were indistinguishable from those of other uvsX mutants. Mutations in uvsY had no demonstrable effect on efficiency of plating or UV sensitivity of uvsX mutants. Thus, null mutants of uvsX are viable.

Genetic evidence for two protein domains and a potential new activity in bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase

Intragenic complementation was detected within the bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase gene. Complementation was observed between specific amino (N)-terminal, temperature-sensitive (ts) mutator mutants and more carboxy (C)-terminal mutants lacking DNA polymerase polymerizing functions. Protein sequences surrounding N-terminal mutation sites are similar to sequences found in Escherichia coli ribonuclease H (RNase H) and in the 5'----3' exonuclease domain of E. coli DNA polymerase I. These observations suggest that T4 DNA polymerase, like E. coli DNA polymerase I, contains a discrete N-terminal domain.

Temperature sensitivity of the multiplication of bacteriophage T4 amber mutants on nonpermissive host: characterization of the phenomenon

The existence of temperature sensitivity of the multiplication of amber mutants on a nonpermissive host has been established for a considerable number of mutants in tail and head genes and for mutants in some other T4 genes as well. Temperature sensitivity of multiplication appears to be gene specific, and is typical of amber mutants in genes the products of which are not numerous per phage or which play the role of catalytic factor. Moreover, in most cases temperature sensitivity is characteristic of amber mutants in definite gene clusters.

Identification of two new bacteriophage T4 genes that may have roles in transcription and DNA replication

We have identified two bacteriophage T4 genes, 45.1 and 45.2, that map in the intergenic space between phage replication genes 46 (which encodes a recombination initiation protein) and 45 (which encodes a bifunctional protein required in replication and transcription). The existence of genes 45.1 and 45.2 had not been previously recognized by mutation analysis of the T4 genome. We cloned the T4 gene 45.1/45.2 segment, determined its nucleotide sequence, and expressed its two reading frames at high levels in bacterial plasmids. The results predicted molecular weights of 11,400 (100 amino acids) for gp45.1 and 7,500 (62 amino acids) for gp45.2. We also determined that in T4-infected Escherichia coli, genes 45.1 and 45.2 are cotranscribed with their distal neighbor, gene 45, by at least one mode of transcription. In an accompanying report (K. P. Williams, G. A. Kassavetis, F. S. Esch, and E. P. Geiduschek, J. Virol. 61:600-603, 1987), it is shown that the product of gene 45.1 is the so-called T4-induced 15K protein, an RNA polymerase-binding protein of unknown role in phage development. Possibly, T4 genes 45.2, 45.1, and 45 constitute an operon for host RNA polymerase-binding phage proteins. Jointly with Williams et al., we propose the term rpb (RNA polymerase-binding) to refer to T4 genes whose products bind to the host RNA polymerase and have adopted the name rpbA for T4 gene 45.1.

Functional interactions beween the DNA ligase of Escherichia coli and components of the DNA metabolic apparatus of T4 bacteriophage

T4 phage completely defective in both gene 30 (DNA ligase) and the rII gene (function unknown) require at least normal levels of host-derived DNA ligase (E. coli lig gene) for growth. Viable E. coli mutant strains that harbor less than 5% of the wild-type level of bacterial ligase do not support growth of T4 doubly defective in genes 30 and rII (T4 30- rII- mutants). We describe here two classes of secondary phage mutations that permit the growth of T4 30- rII- phage on ligase-defective hosts. One class mapped in T4 gene su30 (Krylov 1972) and improved T4 30- rII- phage growth on all E. coli strains, but to varying degrees that depended on levels of residual host ligase. Another class mapped in T4 gene 32 (helix-destabilizing protein) and improved growth specifically on a host carrying the lig2 mutation, but not on a host carrying another lig- lesion (lig4). Two conclusions are drawn from the work: (1) the role of DNA ligase in essential DNA metabolic processes in T4-infected E. coli is catalytic rather than stoichiometric, and (2) the E. coli DNA ligase is capable of specific functional interactions with components of the T4 DNA replication and/or repair apparatus.

Late effect of bacteriophage T4D on the permeability barrier of Escherichia coli

Cold centrifugation of lysis-inhibited Escherichia coli B infected with wild-type T4D results in extensive lysis beginning around 20 min after infection at 37 degrees C. Infection with an e mutant, which fails to make lysozyme, prevents lysis, but does not prevent a marked loss of K+ and Mg3+. The t gene product, thought to disrupt the cytoplasmic membrane in natural lysis, is not required for this handling-induced cation loss or lysis. Three lines of evidence argue that late protein synthesis is required to develop this potential for cation loss; the potential does not develop in infections by: (i) mutants defective in DNA synthesis, (ii) mutants defective in gene 55, and (iii) wild-type T4 when chloramphenicol is added at 6 min after infection. All late mutants examined, which are blocked in the major pathways of morphogenesis, do not prevent development of the potential. The evidence argues for a new, late effect of T4 infection on the cytoplasmic membrane.

In vivo functional interaction between DNA polymerase and dCMP-hydroxymethylase of bacteriophage T4

Some mutations in the structural gene for T4 DNA polymerase (gene 43) behave as suppressors of a deficiency in T4 dCMP-hydroxymethylase (gene 42). The suppression appears to involve a functional interaction between the two enzymes at the level of DNA replication. The hydroxymethylase deficiency caused DNA structural abnormalities in replication, and DNA polymerase lesions appeared to partially reverse these abnormalities. The results do not necessarily imply protein-protein interactions between the two enzymes, although both enzymes appear to play roles in controlling the fidelity of phage DNA replication.

Pleiotropic effects of mutants in gene A of bacteriophage phi chi 174

It has previously been established that the functional gene A product of phi chi X 174 is required for double-stranded DNA replication and that mutants in gene A affect the lysis of the host cell. We report here other alterations of normal phenotype for a subset of gene A mutants suggesting additional functions of gene A. Mutants in the subset failed to terminate cellular DNA synthesis and were unable to efficiently inactivate the colony-forming ability of the host. Two mutants in a second group retained the ability to kill the infected cell, although only one of these mutants efficiently terminated cellular DNA synthesis. Normal termination of cellular DNA synthesis did not occur by the production of random multiple breaks in the DNA, although it may have occurred by the selective production of breaks in newly synthesized DNA. It has previously been shown that two protein products are produced from the gene A region, the smaller of which is a C-terminal fragment of the larger. The separate phenotypes reported here for the two groups of mutants in gene A are consistent with separate functions for the two gene products previously reported.

Simultaneous initiation of synthesis of bacteriophage T4 DNA and of deoxyribonucleotides

In earlier reports we have suggested that bacteriophate T4 DNA replication occurs in a complex composed of the proteins required for polymerization and the system of enzymes synthesizing the deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate precursors of DNA. T4-induced dCMP hydroxymethylase and dTMP synthetase, though demonstrable in extracts soon after infection, are not active in vivo until about 5 min. The in vivo activities increase exponentially for approximately 15 min and then become constant. We have suggested that the exponential period represents the formation of the complexes. This paper shows that the initiation of DNA synthesis and of the two deoxyribonucleotide-synthesizing activities occurs simultaneously and with coinciding exponential kinetics. The in vivo activities of the two enzymes were tested after infection by a number of T4 amber Dna- mutants. Their activities were essentially unchanged compared to the wild-type phage, except on infection by mutants of gene 43 (T4 DNA nucleotidyltransferase or DNA polymerase). With these mutants the rate of increase of dTMP synthetase and dCMP hydroxymethylase activities was always substantially lower than after infection by wild-type phage. It is proposed that an intimate interaction occurs between T4-induced DNA polymerase and the complex of enzymes forming 5-hydroxymethyl-dCMP and dTMP.

Biochemistry of DNA-defective mutants of bacteriophage T4. VI. Biological functions of gene 42

Bacteriophage T4 gene 1 and 42 amber mutants (defective in deoxynucleoside monophosphate kinase and deoxycytidylate hydroxymethylase, respectively) are able to synthesize DNA in cell-free lysates prepared as described by Barry and Alberts (1972), in contrast to their inabliity to do so in plasmolyzed and toluenized cell systems. Addition of extracts containing an active gene 1 or 42 product has no effect on synthesis in lysates defective in the respective gene. Thus, if these enzymes do play additional direct roles in replication, these roles are not manifest in the lysed-cell system. The gene 42 mutant am N122/m, a double mutant bearing an additional defect in DNA polymerase, is unable to synthesize DNA in these lysates. This inability is overcome by addition of extracts containing an active T4 DNA polymerase. m is a leaky amber mutation which reduces DNA polymerase activity to a very low level. However, this level is high enough to allow positive genetic complementation tests with gene 43 mutants. Two other gene 42 amber mutants contain additional defects: am 269 induces only half the normal level of DNA polymerase, and am C87 fails to induce a detectable level of thymidylate synthetase. These defects do not result from pleiotropic effects of the gene 42 mutations. In plasmolyzed cells, temperature-sensitive gene 42 mutants fail to synthesize DNA under conditions where replication forks and 5-hydroxymethyl-dCTP are present. This supports the idea that the gene 42 protein is directly involved in DNA synthesis.

Level of specific prereplicative mRNA's during bacteriophage T4 regA-, 43- and T4 43- infection of Escherichia coli B

The role of the T4 bacteriophage regA gene in stabilizing early mRNA was investigated by assaying the level of functional mRNA from eight prereplicative genes (56 [dCMP hydroxymethylase], cd [dCMP deaminase], 1 [deoxynucleotide kinase], rIIA, rIIB, 46 [DNA arrest], and 45) during extended infection of Escherichia coli B with T4 regA-, 43- and T4 43- bacteriophage. The above gene-specific transcripts in RNA isolated from infected cells were quantitated by translation with an E. coli B cell-free system. Conditions were chosen to insure that the amount of gene product formed in vitro, measured either as an enzyme activity or as a radioactive band in acrylamide gel, was directly proportional to the level of mRNA present. The failure of T4 regA-, 43- phage to terminate prereplicative synthesis (Wiberg et al., 1973) resulted in an enhanced production of many early gene products over those formed during T4 43- infection. This increase did not appear to be associated with an increment in mRNA levels, since in the present study gene-specific early mRNA's were found to be only marginally elevated and slightly more stable in T4 regA-, 43-- than in T4 43--infected cells. Of interest was the observation that significant quantities of all of the mRNA's studied; with the exception of those from genes 45 and 46, could be isolated from T4 43--infected cells after synthesis of the respective gene products had ceased. On termination of normal prereplicative synthesis during infection with T4 43- phage, polyribosomes were found to be dissociated completely, a finding which suggests that the residual mRNA present in these cells is free in the cytoplasm. The persistence in T4 43--infected cells of translatable mRNA for many prereplicative genes after product synthesis ceased indicates that the impairment in protein synthesis is not due solely to regA-mediated messenger degradation or modification. Rather, the results suggest that the regA gene product may act either by interfering with early mRNA polypeptide chain initiation or by promoting prereplicative polysome dissociation.

Analysis of expression of the rII gene function of bacteriophage T4

Temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of the T4 phage rII gene were islated and used in temperature shift experiments that revelaed two different expressions for the normal rII (rII+) gene function in vivo: (i) an early expression (0 to 12 min postinfection at 30 C) that prevents restriction of T4 growth in Escherichia coli hosts lysogenic for gamma phage, and (ii) a later expression (12 to 18 min postinfection at 30 C) that results in restriction of T4 growth when the phage DNA ligase (gene 30) is missing. The earlier expression appeared to coincide with the period of synthesis of the protein product of the T4 rIIA cistron, whereas the later expression occurred after rIIA protein synthesis had stopped. The synthesis of the protein product of the rIIB cistron continues for several minutes after rIIA protein synthesis ceases (O'Farrell and Gold, 1973). The two rII+ gene expressions might require different molar ratios of the rIIA and rIIB proteins. It is possible that the separate expressions of rII+ gene function are manifestations of different associations between the two rII proteins and other T4-induced proteins that are synthesized or activated at different times after phage infection.

T4 DNA polymerase (gene 43) is required in vivo for repair of gaps in recombinants

Experiments with a mutant of T4, tsL97, temperature sensitive for gene 43, showed that T4 DNA polymerase was necessary in vivo to repair gaps in recombinant molecules. CsCl density gradient experiments showed that molecular recombinants were not repaired when the T4tsL97-infected cells were shifted to 42 C after replication and recombination had taken place. Repair was almost complete when the same procedure was followed with the wild-type T4, or when the T4tsL97-infected cells were incubated at the permissive temperature, 36 C. Long-single-strand production was also affected similarly by the T4tsL97 mutation. All the results were consistent with the theory that gaps exist in many recombinant molecules at the recombinant joint, that T4 DNA polymerase is the enzyme that repairs these gaps in vivo, and that covalent repair of the recombinants leads to extensive long-single-strand production.

Mutation to overproduction of bacteriophage T4 gene products

R9 was isolated as one of several mutations that enhanced the growth of a leaky amber (am) mutant of bacteriophage T4 gene 62 (product required for phage DNA synthesis) under conditions of partial suppression by ribosomal ambiguity. R9 also enhanced the growth of leaky am mutants of some, but not all, other T4 "early" gene functions. R9 mapped between mutations in genes 43 and 62. By using assays involving polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate, we observed the following. (i) R9 resulted in an overproduction of many T4 "early" proteins in infected cells. The most pronounced effects of R9 were observed when phage DNA synthesis and/or the functions of maturation genes 55 and 33 were not expressed. (ii) In rifampintreated infected cells, the capacity to synthesize T4 "early" proteins decayed more slowly in the presence of the R9 mutation than in the presence of the wild-type counterpart of R9. R9 appeared to have no effect on the rates of RNA synthesis either during early or late times after infection. The results suggest that the R9 mutation leads to increased functional stability of T4 "early" messengers.

Transcription units in bacteriophage T4

We have investigated the possibility of assigning genes of T4 bacteriophage to their units of transcription (scriptons) by studying gene expression from UV-irradiated DNA templates. Since RNA chains are prematurely terminated on UV-irradiated DNA templates and since the promotor distal part of the RNA chain is deleted, the expression of any gene is inversely proportional to the distance between the promotor and the promotor distal end of the gene. We find that the early genes, 43, 45 and rIIB, are promotor proximal. Since at least genes 43 and rIIB are classified as delayed early genes, these results suggest that their synthesis may require the recognition of new promotors. Additional early genes (44, 62, 42, 46, 47, 55, and rIIA) and some late genes (34, 37, and 38) have also been assigned positions relative to their promotors.