Effect of restrictions on prescribing patterns for dextropropoxyphene

Co-proxamol and suicide: preventing the continuing toll of overdose deaths

Restricting means for suicide is a key element in suicide prevention strategies of all countries where these have been introduced. Preventing deaths from analgesic overdoses is highlighted in the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England. The problem of self-poisoning with the prescription-only drug co-proxamol (dextropropoxyphene plus paracetamol) has received attention in several countries. We have conducted a review of the international literature related to possible strategies to tackle this problem. In England and Wales in 1997-1999, 18% of drug-related suicides involved co-proxamol; these constituted 5% of all suicides. Death usually results from the toxic effects of dextropropoxyphene on respiration or cardiac function. Death from co-proxamol overdose may occur rapidly, the lethal dose can be relatively low, and the effects are potentiated by alcohol and other CNS depressants. The majority of co-proxamol overdose deaths occur before hospital treatment can be received. The risk can extend to others in the household of the person for whom the drug is prescribed. While there is limited evidence that educational strategies have been effective in reducing deaths from co-proxamol poisoning, initiatives in Scandinavia, Australia and the UK to restrict availability of co-proxamol have produced promising results. Given the paucity of evidence for superior therapeutic efficacy of co-proxamol over other less toxic analgesics, there are good reasons to question whether it should continue to be prescribed.

A simple institutional educational intervention to decrease use of selected expensive medications

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether a simple educational intervention can influence use of prescription medications at an institution.

DESIGN

Cost-effectiveness analysis of prescribing behavior before and after an educational intervention.

SETTING

A large, urban, free-standing academic rehabilitation hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Physicians, residents, and physician extenders.

INTERVENTIONS

The hospital's pharmacy department provided simple written educational material about cost differences of various prescription medications to attending and resident physicians, nurse leaders, and case managers. Telephoned reminders were given when targeted medications were prescribed.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Total prescription medication use was recorded monthly for 12 months before and after the intervention. Pharmaceuticals monitored were subcutaneously administered anticoagulants, histamine type 2 (H2) blockers, and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs).

RESULTS

A 32% decrease in use of the more costly anticoagulant and a 20% increase in use of the less costly anticoagulant (p <.0001), representing an estimated annual savings of nearly $66,000. Use of more costly H2 antagonist decreased 50% and use of less costly H2 antagonist increased 128% (p <.0001). With written intervention only, use of more costly NSAIDs declined 28%, whereas use of less costly NSAIDs increased 58% (p <.0020).

CONCLUSION

Providing physicians with simple pharmaceutical cost information and telephone reminders decreased the use of targeted more costly medications.

[Drug regulation: theory and practice]

Regulation of drugs from the public administration is an activity which is produced in different countries independently from the sanitary model they own. In the field of public financing of drugs there have been several measures to improve the efficiency of their use. However, the analysis of the impact of these measures is complex and this may justify the shortage of objectivable results, especially at long term. The objective of this study is to perform a systematic review of such measures due to the need to have information about the different alternatives before making a decision. The introduction of an isolated measure is in many cases compensated by other changes in other regulating or aiding fields which suggests the creation of an integral strategy which affects different fields (supply/demand of drugs and prescribers). It seems necessary to suggest a social debate taking as a basis the scientific information available at the moment and promote the taking of decisions which lead to a rational use of the available pharmacological resources.

Benzodiazepine use in Chile: impact of availability on use, abuse, and dependence

This study tested the hypothesis whether over-the-counter benzodiazepine availability influenced patterns of benzodiazepine use, abuse, and dependence in Chile. If over-the-counter availability represents a major risk factor leading to benzodiazepine substance use disorders, rates of abuse, and dependence would be significantly higher among over-the-counter benzodiazepine users than among prescription drug users. The study was a household survey of a stratified sample (N = 1,500) of the Santiago (Chile) population performed by trained interviewers. Data were collected by structured questionnaires on demographic characteristics, drug use, psychoactive substance use disorders, and other psychosocial variables. Past-year prevalence of benzodiazepine use was 31.4%, daily use of benzodiazepines for > or = 12 months, 5.9%, and subjects who met DSM-III-R criteria for dependence, 3.3%. Seventy-four percent of subjects obtained the benzodiazepine over-the-counter (always 45%; sometimes 29%). No subject acknowledged recreational benzodiazepine use or met criteria for benzodiazepine abuse. Use, long-term use, and dependence occurred equally frequently among both over-the-counter and prescription benzodiazepine users. Results suggest that although over-the-counter availability increases benzodiazepine use, it is not a major risk factor that leads to benzodiazepine abuse and/or dependence.

Influencing prescribing in primary care: a comparison of two different prescribing feedback methods

This study evaluated two different methods of providing practice-based, antibiotic prescribing feedback to general practitioners (GPs). The impact of face-to-face prescribing discussion visits led by a pharmaceutical prescribing adviser were compared to the provision of practice specific prescribing analysis workbooks. Sixty-six practices within one Family Health Services Authority were randomly stratified into one of two groups (Group 1: visits; Group 2: workbooks). The 23 practices who did not wish to participate were used as a self selected control group (Group 3). Twelve months after the start of the programme, visits were extended to Group 2 and Group 3. Prescribing patterns were evaluated using five prescribing indicators, before and at 12 and 24 months after the start of the programme. Analysis of practice prescribing patterns at 12-months demonstrated that the desired changes in the selected five indicators were greater in Group 1 than Group 2 or Group 3; changes were statistically significant for indicators 5, 4 and 2 in each group, respectively. After 24 months all groups demonstrated significant changes in five indicators. Face-to-face visits proved the most successful of the two methods to influence GP prescribing, although the workbook promoted more change than that seen in the control group.

Assessing the impact of a regulatory intervention in Pakistan

In 1990 paediatric formulations of antimotility drugs were deregistered in Pakistan. Although preliminary research data suggests the incidence of paralytic ileus in children suffering from acute diarrhoea has fallen, cases continue to be recorded. A small-scale survey conducted in 1993 to assess the effectiveness of the regulatory intervention conclusively proved that while the deregistered products had been successfully withdrawn from the overwhelming majority of retail outlets, blackmarketing of a paediatric antimotility drug was taking place in one city. The results also indicated that throughout the country the deregistered formulations were being substituted by other irrational therapies, including the misuse of adult formulations. As a regulatory intervention, therefore, deregistration needs to be accompanied by efforts to change patient attitudes and physician prescribing habits.

Pharmacoeconomic consequences of measurement and modification of hospital drug use

Patterns of drug usage affect hospital-based delivery of healthcare in a variety of ways. Adverse reactions to drugs (ADR) precipitate some 5% of admissions and prejudice the care of some 20% of patients who are in hospital, while inadequate drug therapy prejudices outcomes and prolongs hospital stay. Conversely, appropriate application of drugs can promote recovery and increase the quality of care. Well documented examples include prevention of deep vein thrombosis and postoperative wound infections. Accordingly, optimisation of drug use represents a major quality assurance issue in addition to determining cost-efficiency of healthcare delivery. Drug utilisation review (DUR) requires all elements of the quality assurance process. In practice, therapeutically meaningful and cost-efficient exercises can only be mounted if there is knowledge of the linkage between patterns of drug use and clinical outcomes. These processes of measurement are currently rate-limiting in quality assurance. There are various ways that hospital drug usage can be measured. These range from readily available and relatively cheap quantitative methods to methods requiring the availability of expert staff. There is a sequence of methods involving increasing costs and increasing resource demands yielding increasing detail of information obtained. This sequence commences with pharmacy purchases, followed by pharmacy issues to particular clinical areas, prescription or treatment sheet survey, clinical record review, and finally the reports of trained investigators working in the clinical area. The simpler methods can provide useful information and an efficient basis for choosing and planning definitive studies. Once a category of drug use is appropriately targeted for intervention, drug use can be modified by planned intervention with improvement in clinical outcomes and reduced economic costs in many instances. The intervention strategies to modify drug usage may be classed as re-educative, persuasive, facilitative and power strategies. Other models for implementing behavioural change have been considered, including the impact of trained investigators and the use of online computer prescribing with interactive software with appropriate guidelines. The challenge is to achieve sustained change when interventions are implemented. Cost-efficient quality assurance of drug use is possible with modest resources if outcome-orientated activities are prioritised.

Therapeutic decision making of physicians

In this review the therapeutic decision-making process of physicians is described. This process is divided into two steps: the generation of a limited set of possible options (the 'evoked set') and the selection from this evoked set of a treatment for a specific patient. Factors that are important in both steps are reviewed. Behavioural and decision-making theories in general and decision-making analysis of physicians in particular are discussed to identify possible shortcomings in their decision-making process. Based on this information a model of the drug choice process is presented. With reference to this model possible ways of influencing drug choices of physicians are discussed.

A model of methods for influencing prescribing: Part I. A review of prescribing models, persuasion theories, and administrative and educational methods

The purpose of this literature review is to develop a model of methods to be used to influence prescribing. Four bodies of literature were identified as being important for developing the model: (1) Theoretical prescribing models furnish information concerning factors that affect prescribing and how prescribing decisions are made. (2) Theories of persuasion provide insight into important components of educational communications. (3) Research articles of programs to improve prescribing identify types of programs that have been found to be successful. (4) Theories of human inference describe how judgments are formulated and identify errors in judgment that can play a role in prescribing. This review is presented in two parts. This article reviews prescribing models, theories of persuasion, studies of administrative programs to control prescribing, and sub-optimally designed studies of educational efforts to influence drug prescribing.

The management of a hospital formulary

This paper describes the management of a hospital formulary that is operated by voluntary co-operation of prescribes. The organizational and philosophical factors associated with the formulary management system in a major teaching hospital environment are discussed. A combination of educative, re-educative, persuasive and facilitative strategies is used to influence prescribing behaviour. Both passive and active methods, including face-to-face intervention methods are practised. The formulary is reinforced with an extensive pharmacy monitoring operation which stimulates facilitative dialogue between pharmacists and prescribers and encourages medical self-audit and peer review. Evidence of compliance with recommended policies, and consequent control of drug expenditure are presented.

How physicians choose drugs

A drug choice model which includes the physician's attitudes, norms and personal experiences with drugs, was tested. One hundred and sixty-nine physicians were asked to estimate the model's components for the treatment of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and of renal colic. Given three drugs for both indications, the physicians gave their expectancies about the treatment outcomes, professional acceptability, patient demand and their personal experiences with the drugs. They also stated the value they assign to each of these components when choosing a drug for IBS and for renal colic. The influence of patient demand on the choice of a specific drug appeared to be negligible. The combined effect of the other three elements of the model predicted the stated drug of first choice correctly in 74% (for IBS) and 78% (for renal colic) of the cases, but further analysis showed that only the drug choices for renal colic were as reasoned as the model assumed. Expectancies and values about treatment outcomes determined the drug choice only in part. For choosing a drug for renal colic, the professional environment was more important. Moreover it was found that drug preferences were more related to expectancies about efficacy than to expectancies about side effects for both disorders. The findings can be useful when trying to change prescribing behaviour. Only a limited effect can be expected from the provision of technical drug information. Especially information about costs is unlikely to change prescribing easily, unless values and norms are changed as well. The importance of the professional environment implies that educational programmes in groups might be more effective than individual approaches.

Dextropropoxyphene overdose. Epidemiology, clinical presentation and management

This paper comprehensively reviews the worldwide situation regarding acute overdosage of dextropropoxyphene (propoxyphene). The changing epidemiology of this type of poisoning over the last 20 years is described with discussion of concurrent trends and, in particular, the effects of different preventive measures adopted in various countries. The clinical pharmacology of dextropropoxyphene relevant to the clinical toxic effects resulting from acute overdosage is described, and the management is detailed. In particular, the importance of early diagnosis and treatment is stressed in view of the potentially lethal complications that may suddenly occur with this poisoning. Recommendations for the correct use of the specific narcotic antagonist, naloxone, are made, together with other intensive supportive measures. As dextropropoxyphene is frequently taken together with other toxic agents, the concomitant effects of alcohol and sedative drugs are described and the treatment of paracetamol (acetaminophen) in combination with dextropropoxyphene is emphasised. The most effective preventive measures for the future are suggested, but caution is advised regarding the prescription for 'at risk' patients of alternative analgesics, which may be no safer in overdosage.

Mild analgesics and the accident and emergency department--cost and safety more important than potency?

A prospective controlled trial involving over 1000 patients did not reveal any difference between four drugs commonly used in accident and emergency departments for the relief of mild to moderate pain. There were no significant variations in therapeutic effect, side-effects or patient compliance. When considering the supply of analgesics which may be no more potent than those available without prescription from retail chemists, cost and safety are more important than analgesic effect. By restricting the choice of analgesics available, the accident and emergency department should be able to increase awareness among its staff of the actions and side-effects of a small number of prescribed drugs and to contain costs.

Improving patient care and pharmacy management: the effect of hospital formularies

A study of the organizational features and implementation procedures associated with formulary use in major acute-care hospitals throughout Australia was undertaken. Data were collected via a questionnaire mailed to 57 directors of pharmacy. An 86-percent response was obtained. A high proportion of formularies was found to rate poorly in terms of organizational features (e.g., content, compilation methods, format) and process variables (e.g., effectiveness as a communication document, prescribing aid, or management tool). Methods of improving formulary effectiveness are outlined in the context of practical and normative research, including improving the quality of drug therapy, use of formularies in cost control, and improving user acceptance. The results confirm previous research showing that methods of improving organizational features and implementation procedures associated with formulary compilation and use are neither widely applied nor widely known. There is an urgent need to reassess the usefulness of formularies and improve their effectiveness by adopting recommendations resulting from past research.

Dextropropoxyphene overdosage. Pharmacological considerations and clinical management

Dextropropoxyphene is a widely prescribed synthetic opiate-like drug of uncertain analgesic efficacy which, in acute overdosage, manifests all the features of opiate toxicity. It is rapidly absorbed and, in association with other central nervous system depressants such as alcohol or benzodiazepine drugs, may be rapidly fatal. Seriously overdosed patients are comatose with respiratory depression, vomiting, seizures and circulatory collapse; small pupils are a useful diagnostic marker. The first priority is to establish the airway and treat convulsions, if present. All the features of overdosage are then rapidly and safely reversed by the specific opiate antagonist naloxone given intravenously. High tissue concentrations and slow elimination of dextropropoxyphene metabolites make continued and intensive monitoring after resuscitation essential because sudden unpredictable deterioration may occur for up to 24 hours. Other more slowly toxic co-ingestants such as paracetamol (acetaminophen) are often present and should be detected and treated as necessary. Dextropropoxyphene poisoning is now probably one of the most common causes of self-poisoning death because, although there is an effective antidote, subjects frequently succumb before treatment can be made available.

Fixed combination drug therapy

Almost half of all marketed drugs are fixed combination preparations, yet the World Health Organization included only 7 in its list of 240 "essential' drugs. There has been little scientific study of these preparations but much emotion and rhetoric has been expended both for and against them. Potential advantages of fixed combination preparations include: increased compliance, synergy and increased efficacy, and reduced side effects and cost. Potential disadvantages include: inflexible fixed dose ratio, incompatible pharmacokinetics, increased toxicity, and physician and pharmacist ignorance of content. There are a few combinations of undisputed value such as oral contraceptives, levodopa with decarboxylase inhibitors, and pyrimethamine with sulphadoxine. In other cases fixed-dose combinations may have value in strictly specified circumstances, but are probably overprescribed. There is also widespread, unjustified use of combinations in over-the-counter preparations which may have unrecognised adverse effects. Combinations should only be used if each component is necessary for the desired effect and if the advantages outweigh the added risks of using 2 or more drugs. Before prescribing combination drugs, clinicians should always ask themselves a series of questions of which the most important is whether the patient needs each drug in a particular combination, or if 1 component alone would be adequate. In general, government regulatory bodies in "developed' countries are attempting to curb the use of combination drugs, but a more profitable approach might be to better educate doctors on both the advantages and disadvantages of fixed combination preparations leading to improved prescribing habits.

Consequences of legislative restriction on the sale of compound analgesics in Newcastle (N.S.W., Australia)

In June 1979 legislation was enacted in New South Wales to restrict the sale of compound analgesics. The consequences of this legislation were assessed by a household survey in Newcastle, New South Wales, during November 1979. This survey followed an identical survey in the same community in November 1977. After legislation, a marked decrease was found in the proportion of homes having compound analgesics. A small decrease in total analgesic usage was also observed, though this was not necessarily related to the legislative restrictions. The legislative restrictions did not result in any substantial increase in use of the doctor to obtain prescriptions for compound analgesics, or any substantial increase in reported health problems. The results suggest that legislation is an effective method of inducing rapid change in health-related behavior.

An oral buprenorphine and paracetamol combination compared with paracetamol alone: a single dose double-blind postoperative study

1 An oral combination of buprenorphine and paracetamol was compared with paracetamol alone in a single dose, double-blind postoperative study. One hundred and twenty patients undergoing elective minor orthopaedic operations were allocated to four groups of 30 patients. The four treatments were 1,1.5 or 2 mg of buprenorphine with paracetamol 1,000 mg or paracetamol 1,000 mg alone. 2 There were no significant differences between the groups in analgesia measured by the observer over the 6 h period of direct observations. The oral opiate produced a significant increase in duration of analgesia beyond the 6 h study period. A significant increase in side-effects was seen only at the highest buprenorphine dose compared with paracetamol. 3 The problems of trial design for analgesic combinations are considered. Drug mixtures create additional complexities which decrease the certainty of the conclusion that no real benefits result from such mixtures.