No linkage or association between multiple sclerosis and the myelin basic protein gene in affected sibling pairs

Linkage disequilibrium between the MBP tetranucleotide repeat and multiple sclerosis is restricted to a geographically defined subpopulation in Finland

We have previously found evidence for linkage as well as allelic and haplotype association between the myelin basic protein (MBP) gene and multiple sclerosis (MS). These findings have, however, not been reproduced in other populations. Here, we have analyzed association between MBP and MS in a new set of 349 Finnish triad families. Families with a parent born in the Southern Ostrobothnian region in western Finland (Bothnia families, n=98) were analyzed as a separate group since our previous studies included a high proportion of patients and families from this high-incidence region. Other families (n=251) were collected at five hospitals in southern, eastern, and northern Finland. The MBP short tandem repeat was genotyped, and haplotype patterns were verified by sequencing. In the Bothnia families, the previously detected associations with the 1.27 kb allele and haplotype 1.27-B10 were confirmed (P=0.01 and 0.02, respectively), whereas in the other families there was not even a trend toward association. These results demonstrate a geographic/genealogical restriction in the association between MS and the MBP short tandem repeat, highlight the importance of genealogical information in genetic studies of complex traits, and may provide an explanation why the association has not been found in many other populations.

Genomic sharing surrounding alleles identical by descent: effects of genetic drift and population growth

The number of identical deleterious mutations present in a population may become very large, depending on the combined effect of genetic drift, population growth and limited negative selection. The distribution of the length of the shared area between two random chromosomes carrying the mutations has been investigated for a number of generations varying from 20-100 since introduction. The consequences for investigations using association and haplotype sharing methods are discussed.

Linkage analysis of myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein-induced experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in the rat identifies a locus controlling demyelination on chromosome 18

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory and demyelinating disease of the central nervous system (CNS) with a complex etiology comprising a genetically determined predisposition and a suspected auto- immune pathogenesis. Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is an animal model for MS, which can be used to define susceptibility loci for autoimmune neuroinflammation. We have recently established a chronic relapsing EAE model characterized by inflammation and focal demyelination in the CNS by immunizing a variety of rat strains with the CNS-specific myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG). This model is more MS-like than any other rodent EAE model described up to now. Here we present the first systematic genome search for chromosomal regions linked to phenotypes of MOG-induced EAE in a (DA x ACI) F(2)intercross. A genome-wide significant susceptibility locus linked to demyelination was identified on chromosome 18. This region has not been described in inflammatory diseases affecting other organs and the responsible gene or genes may thus be nervous system specific. Other chromosomal regions showing suggestive linkage to phenotypes of MOG-induced EAE were identified on chromosomes 10, 12 and 13. The chromosome 10 and 12 regions have previously been linked to arthritis in DA rats, suggesting that they harbour immunoregulatory genes controlling general susceptibility to autoimmune diseases. We conclude that identification of susceptibility genes for MOG-induced EAE on rat chromosomes 10, 12, 13 and 18 may disclose important disease pathways for chronic inflammatory demyelinating diseases of the CNS such as MS.

The genetics of multiple sclerosis. A review

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is characterized by chronic inflammation and demyelination in the central nervous system (CNS). Although the etiology of MS is unknown, both genetic and environmental contributions to the pathogenesis are inferred from epidemiologic studies. Geographic distributions and epidemics of MS and data from migration studies provide evidence for some, thus far unidentified, environmental effects. The co-occurrence of MS with high and low frequencies in ethnic groups often sharing an environment, the increased recurrence rate in families, and the high concordance rate among identical twins point to inheritable determinants of susceptibility. Based on the autoimmune hypothesis of demyelination, genetic studies sought associations between MS and polymorphic alleles of candidate genes which regulate either the immune response or myelin production. The most consistent finding in case-control studies was the association with the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) (also called human leukocyte antigen--HLA) class II, DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype. Studies on other gene products encoded within or close to the MHC complex on chromosome 6p21.3 (e.g., HLA DP, complement components, transporter proteins, tumor necrosis factor, and myelin-oligodendrocyte glycoprotein) resulted in conflicting observations in different patient populations. The potential contribution of polymorphic alleles within the genes of the T-cell receptor alpha beta chains, immunoglobulins, cytokines, and oligodendrocyte growth factors or their receptors to MS susceptibility either remains equivocal or is rejected. Studies on families with multiple affected members have revealed that MS is a complex trait, that the contribution of individual genes to susceptibility is probably small, and that differences are possible between familial and sporadic forms. The development of molecular and computer technologies have facilitated the performance of comprehensive genomic scans in multiplex families, which have confirmed the possible linkage of multiple loci to susceptibility, each with a minor contribution. Several provisional sites were reported, but only 6p21 (MHC complex), 5p14, and 17q22 were positive in more than one study. The British update demonstrated segregation among regions of interest depending on DR15 sharing, and excluded a gene of major effect from 95%, and one with a moderate effect from 65% of the genome. The extended study by the US collaboration group revealed that the MHC linkage was limited to families segregating HLA DR2 alleles, which suggested that linkage to the MHC is related to the HLA DR2 association, and that sporadic and familial MS share at least one common susceptibility marker. Further identification of MS susceptibility loci may involve additional family sets, more polymorphic markers, and the exploration of telomeric chromosomal regions. Data from these studies may further elucidate pathogenic mechanisms of MS.

Comparison of clinical and demographic features between affected pairs of Italian multiple sclerosis multiplex families; relation to tumour necrosis factor genomic polymorphisms

We conducted a comparative analysis of clinical and demographic findings between pairs of relatives (36 sibling and 9 parent/child), concordant for Multiple Sclerosis (MS), from 40 MS Italian Multiplex families. A genetic TNF (alpha and beta) loci typing in 51 affected and 69 healthy relatives belonging to 25 of these families was also performed. The sib pairs resulted significantly concordant for age at onset (r=0.414, P<0.013), Progression Index (r=0.34, P<0.05) and sensory symptoms at onset (k=0.37), and significantly not concordant for sex (k=-0.37), whereas no concordance was found for year at onset and disease course. The only significant result in the small group of parent/child pairs was that parents developed MS at an age of 18.74 years significantly (P=0.020) greater than their children. Genomic analysis identified 13 variants of TNF-a alleles, 7 of TNF-b, 6 of TNF-d and 3 of TNF-e. No differences in the frequencies of the various TNF alleles were observed between affected and healthy relatives. The two-point lod-score analysis of the TNF locus showed not significant or negative results for the TNFalpha loci and slightly positive results (Zmax=0.4 at theta=0.2 cM) for the TNFbeta-b locus in the lowest penetrance dominant model. The Sib pair analysis, using combined TNFalpha and TNFbeta haplotypes, demonstrated a TNF allele sharing between affected sib-pairs which did not exceed the expected 50%. These results suggest that genetic factors may partially influence the disease onset and the progression rate in sibling pairs. A recall bias and/or an 'anticipation phenomenon' could explain the development of MS at an older age in parents than in their children. In this small-sized cohort of MS Italian families no significant associations were confirmed between TNF polymorphism and MS.

HLA associations with multiple sclerosis in the Canary Islands

The study of small island populations has proved informative with respect to the epidemiology and genetics of many complex traits including multiple sclerosis. The class II major histocompatibility antigen DR15 is associated with multiple sclerosis in all groups except Sardinians, where the primary association is with DR4. We compared HLA-DR and -DQ allele frequencies in a representative sample of patients with multiple sclerosis from the Canary Islands with appropriate controls. There was a significant association with DR15 (patients 21/53: 40%: controls 11/55; 20%: chi2=4.09; pc=0.04; relative risk [RR]=1.98). DRB1*1501-DRB5*0101 was present in 17/53 (32%) patients in whom sub-types could be identified compared with 6/55 (11%) controls (chi2=7.21; pc=< 0.01; RR=2.94). All DR15 positive controls carried the DQA1*0102, DQB1*0602 haplotype whereas this was only present in 26/30 patients, suggesting that the primary association is with HLA-DR and not -DQ. We also found a significant increase in HLA-DR4 (16/53 [30%] in patients compared with 7/55 [13%] in controls; pc=0.05). This study contributes a new point on the immunogenetic map of multiple sclerosis in Europe, confirming the primary DR15 association with multiple sclerosis in a previously unstudied population but again highlighting the importance of DR4 in Mediterranean peoples.

The myelin basic protein gene in multiple sclerosis: identification of discrete alleles of a 1.3 kb tetranucleotide repeat sequence

Myelin basic protein (MBP) is a potential autoantigen in multiple sclerosis (MS) and its gene therefore is an attractive candidate to confer genetic susceptibility to this disease. Linkage and association with certain alleles of a 1.2 kb tetranucleotide repeat region 5' to the MBP gene with MS have been reported in Finnish patients, and an association has been reported from Denmark. However, these findings have not been confirmed in subsequent analyses in other populations. A limitation of previous studies has been the low resolution of the typing procedure. We have investigated the same polymorphism in thirty-four Swedish nuclear families with 2 or 3 MS patients. and in 149 unrelated Swedish MS patients and 95 healthy controls using a fluorescence-based semi-automated technique which allowed the identification of discrete tetrarepeat numbers. Neither parametric two-point linkage analysis nor a nonparametric affected pedigree members analysis showed any sign of linkage. In addition, the distribution of alleles was similar in patients and controls. We conclude that the MBP gene does not influence susceptibility to MS in Swedish patients.

Golli-MBP gene in multiple sclerosis susceptibility

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an oligo- or polygenic disease but no specific susceptibility genes have been identified so far. In the Finnish population we have previously found evidence for linkage between MS and the myelin basic protein gene (here called Golli-MBP gene) suggesting that either Golli-MBP or another gene in its vicinity contributes to MS suceptibility. Here we have screened the Golli-MBP gene for nucleotide variations and carried out multipoint association analyses in a Finnish case-control data-set as well as in an independent data-set composed of 151 MS families from Finland and Sweden. In both data-sets we found association between MS and alleles in the 1.27 kilobase (kb) range at a tetranucleotide repeat element (TGGA)n which is located 1 kb upstream of the MBP exon 1. Haplotype analyses suggested that the MS-associated 1.27 kb alleles can be split into predisposing and non-predisposing variants and provided evidence that the candidate DNA region contributing to MS susceptibility should be located at the Golli-MBP gene within a 20-25 kb segment that was conserved in the predisposing haplotypes. These findings suggest a role for the Golli-MBP locus in MS susceptibility, at least in a subset of patients, and serve as a basis for highly focused attempts to identify predisposing mutation(s).

Genomewide scan of multiple sclerosis in Finnish multiplex families

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a neurological, demyelinating disorder with a putative autoimmune etiology. It is thought to be a multifactorial disease with a complex mode of inheritance. Here we report the results of a two-stage genomewide scan for loci predisposing to MS. The first stage of the screen, with a low-resolution map, was performed in a selection of 16 pedigrees collected from an isolated Finnish population. Multipoint, non-parametric linkage analysis of the 328 markers did not reveal statistically significant results. However, 10 slightly interesting regions (P = .1-.15) emerged, including our previous findings of the HLA complex on 6p21 and a putative locus on 5p14-p12. Eight of these novel regions were further analyzed by use of denser marker maps, in the second stage of the scan. For the chromosomal regions 4cen, 11tel, and 17q, the statistical significance increased, but not conclusively; for 2q32 and 10q21, the statistical significance did not change. Accordingly, genotyping of the high-density markers in these regions was performed, and the data were analyzed by use of two-point, parametric linkage analysis using the complete pedigree information of the 21 Finnish multiplex families. We detected suggestive evidence for a predisposing locus on chromosomal region 17q22-q24. Several markers on 17q22-q24 yielded positive LOD scores, with the maximum LOD score (Zmax) occurring with D17S807 (Zmax = 2.8, theta = .04; dominant model). Interestingly, a suggestive linkage between MS and the markers on 17q22-q24 was also revealed by a recent genomewide scan in MS families from the United Kingdom.

Role of myelin basic protein and proteolipid protein genes in multiple sclerosis: single strand conformation polymorphism analysis of the human sequences

Susceptibility to multiple sclerosis (MS) is widely held to have a strong genetic component. While the identities of genes conferring susceptibility are currently unknown, possible candidates include those genes coding for proteins which function in central nervous system (CNS) myelin. Two such genes are the human myelin basic protein (MBP) and proteolipid protein (PLP) genes, whose products make up approximately 80% of the total protein in CNS myelin. The association of a variable number tandem repeat (VNTR) 5' to the human MBP gene with MS has been the subject of conflicting reports. Here we test the hypothesis that mutations in the human MBP and PLP genes might be associated with MS by examining the entire expressed sequence of both genes by single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis, using a panel of 71 MS patients and 71 controls. We have also re-examined the VNTR region in patients and controls. Three base changes were found in the human PLP gene and nine base changes in the human MBP gene; these were essentially equally distributed between patients and controls. No preferential distribution of various alleles of the VNTR between patients and controls was found. Although intronic and regulatory regions have not been examined, it would appear unlikely that mutations in these genes coding for the two major CNS myelin proteins contribute significantly to genetic susceptibility to MS.

The genetic analysis of multiple sclerosis

Although monogenic diseases often show extreme clinical phenotypes, the major burden of genetic ill health lies in the more prevalent polygenic disorders, such as diabetes, hypertension and multiple sclerosis. These conditions affect many thousands of individuals and their management consumes vast amounts of health care resources: in the UK some 80,000 people have multiple sclerosis; the estimated financial cost to society of introducing treatments, such as beta interferon, could be as high as 250 million pounds per year. Knowledge on the genetics of these common diseases is poor, but has potentially received a considerable boost with the arrival of whole genome screening. The genome screen in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) reported in 1994 was the first in a human polygenic disease. Since this publication, whole genome screening has been performed in a variety of human polygenic diseases, including schizophrenia, bipolar affective disorder, non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM), inflammatory bowel disease, asthma and multiple sclerosis.

Tumour necrosis factor microsatellites show association with multiple sclerosis

The TNF alpha and beta genes are located between the class I and class III HLA loci and have been implicated in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis. We carried out allelic association analysis using four microsatellite markers localised within a 20 kb region around the TNF genes. The study was performed on DNA samples from 189 clinically definite MS patients and 206 normal controls, all of Northern Irish origin. The allele distributions for the TNFa and b markers were significantly different between the MS patients and controls (P = 0.014, df 8 and 0.0019, df 4, respectively). The difference could largely be attributed to increases in the TNFa 118 bp allele and the TNFb 127 bp allele in MS patients, with a conserved MS associated haplotype (130:118:127 TNF d:a:b). Of the 19 patients homozygous for this haplotype, 17 were HLA typed and results suggested that the TNF haplotype association can occur independently of inheritance of DR2. Transmission disequilibrium testing (TDT) also supported the TNFa 118 bp association. These results suggest that in this population TNF is possibly one of the genetic factors contributing to MS susceptibility.

A genome screen in multiple sclerosis reveals susceptibility loci on chromosome 6p21 and 17q22

The population prevalence of multiple sclerosis is 0.1%; however, the risk of the disease in the siblings of affected individuals is very much higher at 3-5%. The importance of genetic factors in accounting for this increased risk is confirmed by the results of twin and adoption studies. Despite the evidence for a strong genetic effect, a weak major histocompatibility complex (MHC) association is the only consistently observed feature in the genetics of multiple sclerosis. Other candidates have been proposed, including genes encoding the immunoglobulin heavy chain, T cell receptor beta chain and APOC2, but none has yet been confirmed. Evidence for linkage and association to the myelin basic protein gene has been reported in a genetically isolated Finnish population, but it has not been possible to reproduce these results in other populations. We used a two-stage approach to search the human genome for the genes causing susceptibility to multiple sclerosis. Two principal regions of linkage are identified, chromosomes 17q22 and 6p21 (MHC). Our results are compatible with genetic models involving epistatic interaction between these and several additional genes.

A full genome search in multiple sclerosis

The aetiology of multiple sclerosis (MS) is uncertain. There is strong circumstantial evidence to indicate it is an autoimmune complex trait. Risks for first degree relatives are increased some 20 fold over the general population. Twin studies have shown monozygotic concordance rates of 25-30% compared to 4% for dizygotic twins and siblings. Studies of adoptees and half sibs show that familial risk is determined by genes, but environmental factors strongly influence observed geographic differences. Studies of candidate genes have been largely unrewarding. We report a genome search using 257 microsatellite markers with average spacing of 15.2 cM in 100 sibling pairs (Table 1, data set 1 - DS1). A locus of lambda>3 was excluded from 88% of the genome. Five loci with maximum lod scores (MLS) of >1 were identified on chromosomes 2, 3, 5, 11 and X. Two additional data sets containing 44 (Table 1, DS2) and 78 sib pairs (Table 1, DS3) respectively, were used to further evaluate the HLA region on 6p21 and a locus on chromosome 5 with an MLS of 4.24. Markers within 6p21 gave MLS of 0.65 (non-significant, NS). However, D6S461, just outside the HLA region, showed significant evidence for linkage disequilibrium by the transmission disequilibrium test (TDT), in all three data sets (for DS1 chi2 = 10.8, adjusted P < 0.01)(DS2 and DS3 chi2 = 10.9, P < 0.0005), suggesting a modest susceptibility locus in this region. On chromosome 5p results from all three data sets (222 sib pairs) yielded a multipoint MLS of 1.6. The results support genetic epidemiological evidence that several genes interact epistatically to determine heritable susceptibility.

Genetics of demyelinating diseases

Multiple sclerosis (MS), the prototypic demyelinating disease in humans, is the most common cause of acquired neurological dysfunction arising between early to mid adulthood. MS is an inflammatory disorder and is believed to result from an autoimmune response, directed against myelin proteins and perhaps other antigens, resulting in demyelination and dense astrogliosis. A genetic component in MS is indicated by an increased relative risk to siblings compared to the general population (lambda s) of 20-40, and an increased concordance rate in monozygotic compared to dizygotic twins. Association and/or linkage studies to candidate genes have yielded a considerable number of reports showing significant genetic effects for the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), immunoglobulin heavy chain, T cell antigen receptor, and myelin basic protein loci. With the exception of the MHC, however, these results have been difficult to replicate or apply beyond isolated populations. Recently, a multi-analytical genomic screen effort was completed to identify genomic regions potentially harboring MS susceptibility genes. Nineteen such regions were identified. The data confirm the reported genetic effect of the MHC region. However, no single locus generated overwhelming evidence of linkage. These results suggest a multifactorial etiology, including both environmental and multiple genetic factors of moderate effect.

A repetitive DNA sequence 5' to the human myelin basic protein gene may be linked to MS in Danes

The myelin basic protein (MBP) gene is a candidate locus for disease susceptibility in multiple sclerosis (MS). In the present study a part of the tetranucleotide (TGGA)n repeat polymorphism 5' to the MBP gene was examined in 90 Danish MS patients and 106 controls. Lymphocyte DNA was isolated and used in PCR assay. The PCR fragments produced were separated by agarose and acrylamide electrophoresis. Hereby we found three different bandpatterns i.e. a homozygote with a 450 bp fragment, a homozygote with a fragment 375 bp and a heterozygote with both bands present. The 450 bp fragment occurred significantly more often among MS than in the control group and the 375 bp fragment was underrepresented among MS than in the control group. The differences between incidence of the three band pattern in the MS and the control group were significant different at 1% level. Our study thus indicate that there is an association between MS and a length polymorphism of the 5' end to the MBP gene in Danish MS patients.

Multiple sclerosis and the HLA-D region: linkage and association studies

Inheritance patterns of multiple sclerosis (MS) in multiplex families suggest a complex aetiology involving environmental and genetically determined components. The association between the HLA class II DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype and MS has been well documented in patients with ancestral origins in Northern Europe. Conversely, linkage analysis of this region in multiplex families, derived from a population base, has generated negative results. Thus, given the Dw2 specificity association, evidence implicating this locus in disease susceptibility appears contradictory. We have collected and determined the HLA-DR and -DQ haplotypes of 115 sibling pairs with multiple sclerosis, and confirm a significant association with the Dw2-associated haplotype, both in index cases and their affected siblings compared with controls. However, using a sibling pair linkage analysis that restricts haplotype sharing probabilities to defined genetic models, we have not observed linkage of this region to susceptibility in MS. We discuss the basis for association and linkage and conclude that the DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype does represent a susceptibility locus but its contribution to the pathogenesis is small; although it may interact epistatically with other susceptibility genes, this haplotype is not necessary for disease expression.

Genetic susceptibility to multiple sclerosis in the Shanghai Chinese is not linked to the myelin basic protein gene microsatellite

Aim-To investigate the role of myelin basic protein (MBP) gene polymorphisms in determining susceptibility to multiple sclerosis in a Shanghai Chinese population.Methods-Forty seven unrelated patients with multiple sclerosis and 94 healthy control subjects were included in the study. Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood lymphocytes and amplified using the polymerase chain reaction to characterise two adjacent tetranucleotide repeats ([ATGG](12) and [TGGA](9)) located 5' to exon 1 of the MBP gene.Results-Two polymorphic loci were identified: locus A, comprising both repeats, and locus B, comprising the [ATGG](12) repeat only. Nine allelic variants were identified at locus A and six at locus B, ranging from 212 to 244 and 122 to 146 base pairs, respectively. The 244 base pair allele at locus A has not been reported before. The allele frequencies observed in the controls differed from those seen in normal white populations.Conclusions-The present study demonstrates a race specific pattern of allelic distribution within the tetranucleotide repeat of the MBP gene. Further studies are needed to fully elucidate the role of the MBP gene in inherited susceptibility to multiple sclerosis.