Association between type I interferon pathway activation and clinical outcomes in rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases: a systematic literature review informing EULAR points to consider

Association of mitochondrial RNA expression levels in saliva and plasma with interferon signature gene expression and disease activity in patients with Sjögren disease

OBJECTIVE

To unveil the clinical implications of mitochondrial RNAs (mt-RNAs) in Sjögren disease (SjD), this study evaluated mt-RNA expression levels in the plasma and saliva of patients with SS and their association with SjD-related features.

METHODS

Plasma, saliva and/or peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were collected from 111 patients with SjD and 35 healthy controls (HCs), with 40 rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and 40 systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) disease controls. The expression levels of mt-RNAs and interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs) were quantified by real-time PCR. Composite mt-RNA and ISG scores were calculated using logistic regression models. Their discriminative power was evaluated using receiver operating characteristic curve analyses, and correlations with clinical data were explored.

RESULTS

Altered mt-RNA expression in saliva or plasma and ISG expression in PBMCs were detected in patients with SjD, compared with HCs. Saliva and plasma mt-RNA scores showed better discriminative ability (area under the curve values=0.847 and 0.789, respectively) than ISG scores in distinguishing SjD from HCs. Plasma mt-RNA scores were significantly higher in patients with SjD than in those with RA and SLE (p<0.05). Saliva mt-RNA scores were positively associated with objective disease activity measures and Raynaud phenomenon in patients with SjD, whereas plasma mt-RNA scores did not show this association. RA and SLE disease activity correlated with plasma mt-RNA scores.

CONCLUSIONS

Extracellular mt-RNA burden is elevated in SjD, and mt-RNA scores effectively discriminated patients with SjD from HCs. Saliva mt-RNA levels were associated with SjD disease activity, suggesting their potential utility in disease monitoring and stratification of SjD.

Profiling type I and II interferon responses reveals distinct subgroups of pediatric patients with autoinflammatory disorders

Background

Elevation of type I interferon (IFN-I) is characteristic of a group of diseases known as type I interferonopathies. Several technologies are available to monitor IFN-I, but there is no consensus on their routine use in medical laboratories.

Objective

We aimed to compare the performance of two technologies for this purpose: NanoString, which monitors messenger RNA expression of interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs), and Simoa, which quantifies IFN-α2 protein in an ultrasensitive way. We also designed a NanoString assay to monitor type II ISGs and tested its value to discriminate clinical conditions.

Methods

A total of 196 samples from patients with diseases associated or not with IFN-I pathway activation were analyzed by NanoString and Simoa.

Results

The comparison between NanoString IFN-I score and IFN-α2 Simoa revealed a r 2 coefficient of 0.55. We identified IFI27, IFI44L, and SIGLEC1 as the ISGs most closely related to IFN-α2 concentration. Nineteen samples had a positive IFN-I score but undetectable IFN-α2. These samples were also positive according to IFN-II score, pointing to IFN-II as the primary ISG inducer in corresponding patients. By measuring IFN-I and IFN-II scores in a subset of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and systemic juvenile idiopathic arthritis, we identified two subgroups of patients in whom IFN-I and IFN-II were dominant.

Conclusion

Both IFN-α2 quantification and NanoString reliably distinguish type I interferonopathies from other diseases. Type I and II interferons induce different transcriptomic signatures in vitro and in vivo, and our results highlight the value of monitoring both IFN-I and IFN-II in interferon-related diseases.

Novel association of chilblains with inflammatory arthritis- series of three cases and review of literature

Chilblains are well circumscribed erythrocyanotic lesions seen usually on limbs distally and triggered by cold and damp conditions; they can be primary or secondary. Association of SLE and chilblains is well established, and there are also reports of associations with vasculitis and antiphospholipid syndrome. There remain considerable gaps in literature about the management of secondary chilblains. Three studies looking at primary chilblains showed some benefit from corticosteroids, but this was inferior to pentoxifylline and tadalafil. There are no trials in secondary chilblains. Chilblains have not been described in the context of inflammatory arthritis- either Rheumatoid Arthritis or seronegative spondyloarthropathy. We report 3 patients with a combination of chilblains, seronegative inflammatory arthritis and phalangeal bone marrow oedema on MRI scans. These patients presented with joint symptoms alongside chilblains with conclusive evidence of inflammatory arthritis. Immunosuppressive treatment resulted in an excellent clinical response. Literature review did not identify any previous descriptions of chilblains together with inflammatory arthritis, whilst bone marrow oedema has primarily been described in children together with chilblains. This case series provides some support for managing secondary chilblains through immunosuppression such as corticosteroids and disease modifying drugs.

The prototypical interferonopathy: Aicardi-Goutières syndrome from bedside to bench

Aicardi-Goutières syndrome (AGS) is a progressive genetic encephalopathy caused by pathogenic mutations in genes controlling cellular anti-viral responses and nucleic acid metabolism. The mutations initiate autoinflammatory processes in the brain and systemically that are triggered by chronic overproduction of type I interferon (IFN), including IFN-alpha. Emerging disease-directed therapies aim to dampen autoinflammation and block cellular responses to IFN production, creating an urgent and unmet need to understand better which cells, compartments, and mechanisms underlying disease pathogenesis. In this review, we highlight existing pre-clinical models of AGS and our current understanding of how causative genetic mutations promote disease in AGS, to promote new model development and a continued focus on improving and directing future therapies.

Rare genetic interstitial lung diseases: a pictorial essay

The main monogenic causes of pulmonary fibrosis in adults are mutations in telomere-related genes. These mutations may be associated with extrapulmonary signs (hepatic, haematological and dermatological) and typically present radiologically as usual interstitial pneumonia or unclassifiable fibrosis. In children, the monogenic causes of pulmonary fibrosis are dominated by mutations in surfactant-related genes. These mutations are not associated with extrapulmonary signs and often manifest radiologically as unclassifiable fibrosis with cysts that can lead to chest wall deformities in adults. This review discusses these mutations, along with most of the monogenic causes of interstitial lung disease, including interferon-related genes, mutations in genes causing cystic lung disease, Hermansky-Pudlak syndrome, pulmonary alveolar proteinosis, lysinuric protein intolerance and lysosomal storage disorders, and their pulmonary and extrapulmonary manifestations.

Protein kinase R is highly expressed in dermatomyositis and promotes interferon-beta-induced muscle damage

OBJECTIVES

Dermatomyositis (DM) has been consistently linked to the type I interferon (IFN-I) pathway. However, the precise pathogenesis remains incompletely elucidated. We aimed to explore potential molecular mechanisms and identify promising therapeutic targets in DM.

METHODS

We employed bioinformatics analysis to investigate molecular signatures, aiming to shed light on the pathogenesis of DM. The expression of protein kinase R (PKR) in DM muscle tissues was determined by real-time quantitative PCR, western blot and immunohistochemistry (IHC) analysis. We then assessed the sensitivity and specificity of sarcoplasmic PKR expression by IHC in a consecutive DM cohort and other diseases in this retrospective study. Furthermore, IFN-β was used to stimulate myoblasts and myotubes, and the relationship between PKR and IFN-β-induced pathogenic molecules was investigated in vitro.

RESULTS

Bioinformatics analysis indicated two primary pathological processes: viral infection and the IFN-I signalling pathway. We subsequently verified that PKR was notably expressed in the cytoplasm of myofibers in DM patients. The sensitivity and specificity of sarcoplasmic PKR expression in DM were 84.6% and 97.6%, respectively. In vitro studies revealed that IFN-β upregulates the expression of PKR, along with several molecules associated with DM muscle damage. Conversely, inhibiting PKR has been shown to downregulate IFN-β-induced pathogenic molecules in both myoblasts and myotubes.

CONCLUSIONS

We observed that PKR exhibits specific expression in the cytoplasm of DM muscle and inhibiting PKR ameliorates IFN-β-induced muscle damage in vitro. These findings provide insights into the diagnostic and therapeutic roles of PKR in DM.

Type I interferon blockade with anifrolumab in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus modulates key immunopathological pathways in a gene expression and proteomic analysis of two phase 3 trials

INTRODUCTION

Anifrolumab is a type I interferon (IFN) receptor 1 (IFNAR1) blocking antibody approved for treating patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Here, we investigated the immunomodulatory mechanisms of anifrolumab using longitudinal transcriptomic and proteomic analyses of the 52-week, randomised, phase 3 TULIP-1 and TULIP-2 trials.

METHODS

Patients with moderate to severe SLE were enrolled in TULIP-1 and TULIP-2 and received intravenous anifrolumab or placebo alongside standard therapy. Whole-blood expression of 18 017 genes using genome-wide RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) (pooled TULIP; anifrolumab, n=244; placebo, n=258) and 184 plasma proteins using Olink and Simoa panels (TULIP-1; anifrolumab, n=124; placebo, n=132) were analysed. We compared treatment groups via gene set enrichment analysis using MetaBase pathway analysis, blood transcriptome modules, in silico deconvolution of RNA-seq and longitudinal linear mixed effect models for gene counts and protein levels.

RESULTS

Compared with placebo, anifrolumab modulated >2000 genes by week 24, with overlapping results at week 52, and 41 proteins by week 52. IFNAR1 blockade with anifrolumab downregulated multiple type I and II IFN-induced gene modules/pathways and type III IFN-λ protein levels, and impacted apoptosis-associated and neutrophil extracellular traps-(NET)osis-associated transcriptional pathways, innate cell activating chemokines and receptors, proinflammatory cytokines and B-cell activating cytokines. In silico deconvolution of RNA-seq data indicated an increase from baseline of mucosal-associated invariant and γδT cells and a decrease of monocytes following anifrolumab treatment.

DISCUSSION

Type I IFN blockade with anifrolumab modulated multiple inflammatory pathways downstream of type I IFN signalling, including apoptotic, innate and adaptive mechanisms that play key roles in SLE immunopathogenesis.

Targeting Interferon Signalling in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: Lessons Learned

The development of new medicines for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has not addressed unmet clinical need, with only three drugs receiving regulatory approval for SLE in the last 60 years, one of which was specifically licensed for lupus nephritis. In the last 20 years it has become clear that activation of type 1 interferons (IFN) is reproducibly detected in the majority of SLE patients, and the actions of IFN in the immune system and on target tissues is consistent with a pathogenic role in SLE. These findings led to considerable drug discovery activity, first with agents directly targeting IFN family cytokines, with results that were encouraging but underwhelming. In contrast, targeting the type I IFN receptor with the monoclonal antibody anifrolumab, thereby blocking all IFN family members, was effective in a phase II clinical trial. This led to a pair of phase III trials, one of which was negative and the other positive, reflecting the difficulty of obtaining outcomes from trials in this complex disease. Nonetheless, the balance of evidence resulted in approval of anifrolumab in multiple jurisdictions from 2021 onwards. Multiple approaches to targeting the type 1 IFN pathway have subsequently had positive phase II clinical trials, including antibodies targeting cells that produce IFN, and small molecules targeting the receptor kinase TYK2, required for IFN signalling. Despite multiple hurdles, it is clear that IFN targeting in SLE is here to stay. The story of IFN-targeting therapy in SLE has lessons for drug development overall in this disease.

Type I Interferons in Systemic Autoimmune Rheumatic Diseases: Pathogenesis, Clinical Features and Treatment Options

Type I interferon (IFN) pathway dysregulation plays a crucial role in the pathogenesis of several systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases (SARDs), including systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), Sjögren's disease (SjD), systemic sclerosis (SSc), dermatomyositis (DM) and rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Genetic and epigenetic alterations have been involved in dysregulated type I IFN responses in systemic autoimmune disorders. Aberrant type I IFN production and secretion have been associated with distinct clinical phenotypes, disease activity, and severity as well as differentiated treatment responses among SARDs. In this review, we provide an overview of the role of type I IFNs in systemic autoimmune diseases including SLE, RA, SjD, SSc, and DM focusing on pathophysiological, clinical, and therapeutical aspects.

Pathogenic role and clinical significance of neutrophils and neutrophil extracellular traps in idiopathic inflammatory myopathies

Idiopathic inflammatory myopathies (IIM) are a heterogeneous group of chronic autoimmune diseases characterized by muscle damage and extramuscular symptoms, including specific skin rash, arthritis, interstitial lung disease, and cardiac involvement. While the etiology and pathogenesis of IIM are not yet fully understood, emerging evidence suggests that neutrophils and neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) have a role in the pathogenesis. Recent research has identified increased levels of circulating and tissue neutrophils as well as NETs in patients with IIM; these contribute to the activation of the type I and type II interferons pathway. During active IIM disease, myositis-specific antibodies are associated with the formation and incomplete degradation of NETs, leading to damage in the lungs, muscles, and blood vessels of patients. This review focuses on the pathogenic role and clinical significance of neutrophils and NETs in IIM, and it includes a discussion of potential targeted treatment strategies.

An interactive web application for exploring systemic lupus erythematosus blood transcriptomic diversity

In the field of complex autoimmune diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), systems immunology approaches have proven invaluable in translational research settings. Large-scale datasets of transcriptome profiling have been collected and made available to the research community in public repositories, but remain poorly accessible and usable by mainstream researchers. Enabling tools and technologies facilitating investigators' interaction with large-scale datasets such as user-friendly web applications could promote data reuse and foster knowledge discovery. Microarray blood transcriptomic data from the LUPUCE cohort (publicly available on Gene Expression Omnibus, GSE49454), which comprised 157 samples from 62 adult SLE patients, were analyzed with the third-generation (BloodGen3) module repertoire framework, which comprises modules and module aggregates. These well-characterized samples corresponded to different levels of disease activity, different types of flares (including biopsy-proven lupus nephritis), different auto-antibody profiles and different levels of interferon signatures. A web application was deployed to present the aggregate-level, module-level and gene-level analysis results from LUPUCE dataset. Users can explore the similarities and heterogeneity of SLE samples, navigate through different levels of analysis, test hypotheses and generate custom fingerprint grids and heatmaps, which may be used in reports or manuscripts. This resource is available via this link: https://immunology-research.shinyapps.io/LUPUCE/. This web application can be employed as a stand-alone resource to explore changes in blood transcript profiles in SLE, and their relation to clinical and immunological parameters, to generate new research hypotheses.

Type I interferon pathway activation across the antiphospholipid syndrome spectrum: associations with disease subsets and systemic antiphospholipid syndrome presentation

Introduction

While the type I interferon (IFN-I) pathway is crucial in autoimmunity, its role in antiphospholipid antibody (aPL)-positive subjects, including aPL carriers and antiphospholipid syndrome (APS) patients, is poorly understood. This study aims at characterizing IFN-I pathway activation within the spectrum of aPL-positive subsets.

Methods

A total of 112 patients [29 aPL carriers, 31 primary APS (PAPS), 25 secondary APS (SAPS), 27 systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients without aPL, and 44 healthy controls (HCs)] were recruited. IFI6, IFI44, IFI44L, MX1, IFI27, OAS1, and RSAD2 gene expression was evaluated in whole blood, and a composite index (IFN score) was calculated.

Results

An overall activation of the IFN-I pathway was observed across the entire APS spectrum, with differences among genes based on the specific disease subset. The composite score revealed quantitative differences across subsets, being elevated in aPL carriers and PAPS patients compared to HCs (both p < 0.050) and increasing in SAPS (p < 0.010) and SLE patients (p < 0.001). An unsupervised cluster analysis identified three clusters, and correspondence analyses revealed differences in clusters usage across APS subsets (p < 0.001). A network analysis revealed different patterns characterizing different subsets. The associations between IFN-I pathway activation and clinical outcomes differed across APS subsets. Although no differences in gene expression were observed in systemic APS, the network analyses revealed specific gene-gene patterns, and a distinct distribution of the clusters previously identified was noted (p = 0.002).

Conclusion

IFN-I pathway activation is a common hallmark among aPL-positive individuals. Qualitative and quantitative differences across the APS spectrum can be identified, leading to the identification of distinct IFN-I signatures with different clinical values beyond traditional categorization.

Type 1 interferons: A target for immune-mediated inflammatory diseases (IMIDs)

The improved understanding of the molecular basis of innate immunity have led to the identification of type I interferons (IFNs), particularly IFN-α, as central mediators in the pathogenesis of several Immune-mediated inflammatory diseases (IMIDs) such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), systemic sclerosis, inflammatory myositis and Sjögren's syndrome. Here, we review the main data regarding the opportunity to target type I IFNs for the treatment of IMIDs. Type I IFNs and their downstream pathways can be targeted pharmacologically in several manners. One approach is to use monoclonal antibodies against IFNs or the IFN-receptors (IFNARs, such as with anifrolumab). The downstream signaling pathways of type I IFNs also contain several targets of interest in IMIDs, such as JAK1 and Tyk2. Of these, anifrolumab is licensed and JAK1/Tyk2 inhibitors are in phase III trials in SLE. Targeting IFN-Is for the treatment of SLE is already a reality and in the near future may prove useful in other IMIDs. IFN assays will find a role in routine clinical practice for the care of IMIDs as further validation work is completed and a greater range of targeted therapies becomes available.

Anifrolumab: first biologic approved in the EU not restricted to patients with a high degree of disease activity for the treatment of moderate to severe systemic lupus erythematosus

INTRODUCTION

Type 1 interferons (IFNs) play a crucial role in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and various type I IFNs targeting therapeutic approaches have been developed. Anifrolumab, a monoclonal antibody that binds to the subunit 1 of the type I IFN receptor, has acquired considerable interest and has entered different clinical human trials willing to evaluate its efficacy and safety.

AREAS COVERED

This review summarizes the data obtained in phases 1, 2, and 3 clinical trials of anifrolumab for SLE patients. A focus is made on data of clinical efficacy and safety obtained in MUSE, TULIP-1 and TULIP-2 trials.

EXPERT OPINION/COMMENTARY

Anifrolumab is a promising therapeutic option for patients with SLE, currently authorized for moderate-to-severe SLE. Extensive real-world use is now going to generate data required to gain experience on the type of patients who benefit the most from the drug, and the exact positioning of anifrolumab in the therapeutic plan.

Burden of systemic lupus erythematosus in clinical practice: baseline data from the SLE Prospective Observational Cohort Study (SPOCS) by interferon gene signature

OBJECTIVE

The longitudinal Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Prospective Observational Cohort Study (SPOCS) aims to assess SLE disease course overall and according to type I interferon 4 gene signature (IFNGS). Here, we describe SPOCS patient characteristics by IFNGS and baseline disease activity.

METHODS

SPOCS (NCT03189875) is an international study of patients with SLE according to Systemic Lupus International Collaborating Clinics (SLICC)/American College of Rheumatology (ACR) criteria. Enrolled patients from 135 centres in 8 countries were followed biannually for ≤3 years from June 2017 to November 2022. Baseline demographics, disease characteristics, organ system involvement/damage and flares were analysed descriptively according to SLE Disease Activity Index-2000 score (SLEDAI-2K <10/≥10) and IFNGS status (high/low).

RESULTS

The study population (n=823) was 93.2% female, with mean (SD) age 45.3 (13.9) years and 11.1 (9.2) years since diagnosis; 52.4% had baseline SLICC/ACR Damage Index score ≥1. Patients with SLEDAI-2K scores ≥10 (241 of 584, 41.3%) vs <10 were younger (mean 42.8 (13.7) vs 46.6 (14.2) years; nominal p=0.001), had shorter SLE duration (10.4 (8.6) vs 12.4 (9.6) years; nominal p=0.012) and more severe flares (12.9% vs 5.3%; nominal p=0.001). IFNGS-high patients (522 of 739, 70.6%) were younger than IFNGS-low patients at first SLE manifestation (30.0 (12.7) vs 36.8 (14.6) years; nominal p<0.001). Proportions of IFNGS-high patients differed according to race (nominal p<0.001), with higher proportions among Asian (83.3%) and black (86.5%) versus white patients (63.5%). Greater proportions of IFNGS-high versus IFNGS-low patients had haematological (12.6% vs 4.1%), immunological (74.4% vs 45.6%) or dermal (69.7% vs 62.2%) involvement.

CONCLUSIONS

We identified key characteristics of patients with high disease activity and/or elevated type I IFN signalling, populations with SLE with high unmet needs. Baseline SLEDAI-2K ≥10 was associated with shorter disease duration and more severe flares. IFNGS-high patients were younger at diagnosis and had distinct patterns of organ involvement, compared with IFNGS-low patients.

2022 EULAR points to consider for the measurement, reporting and application of IFN-I pathway activation assays in clinical research and practice

BACKGROUND

Type I interferons (IFN-Is) play a role in a broad range of rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases (RMDs), and compelling evidence suggests that their measurement could have clinical value, although testing has not progressed into clinical settings.

OBJECTIVE

To develop evidence-based points to consider (PtC) for the measurement and reporting of IFN-I assays in clinical research and to determine their potential clinical utility.

METHODS

EULAR standardised operating procedures were followed. A task force including rheumatologists, immunologists, translational scientists and a patient partner was formed. Two systematic reviews were conducted to address methodological and clinical questions. PtC were formulated based on the retrieved evidence and expert opinion. Level of evidence and agreement was determined.

RESULTS

Two overarching principles and 11 PtC were defined. The first set (PtC 1-4) concerned terminology, assay characteristics and reporting practices to enable more consistent reporting and facilitate translation and collaborations. The second set (PtC 5-11) addressed clinical applications for diagnosis and outcome assessments, including disease activity, prognosis and prediction of treatment response. The mean level of agreement was generally high, mainly in the first PtC set and for clinical applications in systemic lupus erythematosus. Harmonisation of assay methodology and clinical validation were key points for the research agenda.

CONCLUSIONS

IFN-I assays have a high potential for implementation in the clinical management of RMDs. Uptake of these PtC will facilitate the progress of IFN-I assays into clinical practice and may be also of interest beyond rheumatology.

Assessment of type I interferon response in routine practice in France in 2022

An European Alliance of Associations for Rheumatology task force recently recommended specific points to consider for exploring type I interferon pathway in patients, highlighting the lack of analytical assays validated for clinical routine. We report here the French experience on a type I interferon pathway assay that has been set up and used routinely since 2018 in Lyon, France.

Molecular signature of neutrophil extracellular trap mediating disease module in idiopathic inflammatory myopathy

The rarity and heterogeneity of idiopathic inflammatory myopathy (IIM) pose challenges for researching IIM in affected individuals. We analyzed integrated transcriptomic datasets obtained using muscle tissues from patients with five distinct IIM subtypes to investigate the shared and distinctive cellular and molecular characteristics. A transcriptomic dataset of muscle tissues from normal controls (n = 105) and patients with dermatomyositis (n = 89), polymyositis (n = 33), inclusion body myositis (n = 121), immune-mediated necrotizing myositis (n = 75), and anti-synthetase syndrome (n = 18) was used for differential gene-expression analysis, functional-enrichment analysis, gene set-enrichment analysis, disease-module identification, and kernel-based diffusion scoring. Damage-associated molecular pattern-associated pathways and neutrophil-mediated immunity were significantly enriched across different IIM subtypes, although their activities varied. Interferons-signaling pathways were differentially activated across all five IIM subtypes. In particular, neutrophil extracellular trap (NET) formation was significantly activated and correlated with Fcγ R-mediated signaling pathways. NET formation-associated genes were key for establishing disease modules, and FCGRs, C1QA, and SERPINE1 markedly perturbed the disease modules. Integrated transcriptomic analysis of muscle tissues identified NETs as key components of neutrophil-mediated immunity involved in the pathogenesis of IIM subtypes and, thus, has therapeutically targetable value.