Effect of transpulmonary pressure on airway closure in immature and mature rabbits

Oxygen and mechanical stretch in the developing lung: risk factors for neonatal and pediatric lung disease

Chronic airway diseases, such as wheezing and asthma, remain significant sources of morbidity and mortality in the pediatric population. This is especially true for preterm infants who are impacted both by immature pulmonary development as well as disproportionate exposure to perinatal insults that may increase the risk of developing airway disease. Chronic pediatric airway disease is characterized by alterations in airway structure (remodeling) and function (increased airway hyperresponsiveness), similar to adult asthma. One of the most common perinatal risk factors for development of airway disease is respiratory support in the form of supplemental oxygen, mechanical ventilation, and/or CPAP. While clinical practice currently seeks to minimize oxygen exposure to decrease the risk of bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD), there is mounting evidence that lower levels of oxygen may carry risk for development of chronic airway, rather than alveolar disease. In addition, stretch exposure due to mechanical ventilation or CPAP may also play a role in development of chronic airway disease. Here, we summarize the current knowledge of the impact of perinatal oxygen and mechanical respiratory support on the development of chronic pediatric lung disease, with particular focus on pediatric airway disease. We further highlight mechanisms that could be explored as potential targets for novel therapies in the pediatric population.

Models to understand contractile function in the airways

Although the role of contractile function in the airways is controversial, there is general consensus on the importance of airway smooth muscle (ASM) as a therapeutic target for diseases characterized by airway obstruction, such as asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Indeed, the use of bronchodilators to relax ASM is the most common and effective practice to treat airflow obstruction. Excessive pathologic bronchoconstriction may originate from primary alterations of ASM mechanical function and/or from the effects exerted on ASM function by disease processes, such as inflammation and remodeling. An in depth knowledge of the potentially multiple mechanisms that distinctively regulate primary and secondary alterations in ASM contractile function would be essential for the development of new therapeutic approaches aimed at preventing the occurrence or reducing the severity of bronchoconstriction. The present review discusses studies that have addressed the mechanisms of altered ASM contractile function in models of airway hyperresponsiveness. Although not comprehensively, in the present review, animal models of intrinsic airway hyperresponsiveness, normal ontogenesis, and allergic sensitization are analyzed in the attempt to summarize the current knowledge on regulatory mechanisms of ASM contractile function in health and disease. Studies in human ASM and the need for additional models to understand contractile function in the airways are also discussed.

Age differences in cholinergic airway responsiveness in relation with muscarinic receptor subtypes

Children seem more susceptible to increased airway reactivity than adults. Such an age-dependent discrepancy in airway reactivity may involve different airway smooth muscle functions. Therefore, we compared the in vivo and in vitro responsiveness of airway smooth muscles between two age groups of animals. Rats of 6 and 21 weeks old were challenged in vivo with acetylcholine (ACh) infused intravenously and airway resistance (R(aw)) was measured. Tracheal muscle was also isolated and the isometric force developed to ACh or KCl was measured. Furthermore, the level of genes encoding muscarinic receptor subtypes (M(1-3)) and acetylcholinesterase (AChE) expressed in the tracheal muscle was determined by RT-PCR. In results, the basal R(aw) was similar in the two age groups. The R(aw) at each ACh dose was significantly greater in young rats than older rats (p<0.05, n=22-27). Tracheal muscles from young rats were more sensitive to ACh than older rats (p<0.05, n=20-21), while receptor-independent muscle contraction to KCl was greater in older rats (p<0.05, n=10-19). Genes encoding AChE, M(2) and M(3) muscarinic receptors were more highly expressed in the tracheal muscles from young than older rats (p<0.05, n=4-6). In conclusion, airway smooth muscle in young rat is more sensitive to cholinergic stimulation in vivo and in vitro compared to older rats, which may be due to a higher expression of M(2) and M(3) muscarinic receptors in airway smooth muscle.

Measuring end-expiratory lung volume and pulmonary mechanics to detect early lung function impairment in rabbits

We investigated whether end-expiratory lung volume (EELV) or lung mechanical parameters are more sensitive for the detection of a compromised gas exchange during bronchoconstriction and after surfactant depletion. EELV was determined via SF(6) multiple breath wash-outs in mechanically ventilated rabbits while a positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) of 1, 3 or 7 cm H(2)O was maintained. Airway resistance (R(aw)) and parenchymal elastance (H) were estimated from the pulmonary input impedance measured at each PEEP level by means of forced oscillations. Measurements were repeated during i.v. methacholine (MCh) infusions and following lung injury induced by saline lavage. MCh induced marked elevations in R(aw), with no significant change in EELV or H at any PEEP. After lavage, the severity of hypoxia was reflected systematically in significant decreases in EELV at all PEEP levels (-42+/-13%, -26+/-4%, and -18+/-5% at 1, 3 and 7 cm H(2)O, respectively), whereas compromised gas exchange was not associated with consistent changes in the mechanical parameters at a PEEP of 7 cm H(2)O (20+/-9% and 14+/-9% in R(aw) and H, respectively; p=0.2). We conclude that R(aw) is the only sensitive indicator for the detection of a compromised lung function during MCh infusions, whereas the estimation of EELV is necessary to follow the progression of a lung injury when a high PEEP level is applied.

Maturational changes in airway smooth muscle shortening and relaxation. Implications for asthma

Greater airway responsiveness in healthy juveniles is considered a factor in the higher asthma prevalence at a young age compared with adults. Several studies on the contractile response of airway smooth muscle (ASM) from birth to adulthood have addressed the hypothesis that a maturation of ASM plays a role in juvenile airway hyperresponsiveness. Maturation of distinct ASM properties, i.e. force generation, shortening, and relaxation, has been reported, although the majority of the studies have focused on maturation of maximum force and/or sensitivity to contractile agonists. However, in most animal species maturation of the ability to generate force does not correlate with maturation of airway responsiveness. Ontogenesis of ASM shortening has been less extensively studied and the existing reports emphasize an increase during maturation of tissue passive forces opposing shortening. ASM spontaneous relaxation has been very minimally investigated. We have recently demonstrated that the ability of ASM to spontaneously relax during stimulation is sharply reduced in juvenile airway tissue. It remains to be determined the role of these ASM properties in the onset of childhood asthma and whether specific alterations are induced by the occurrence of obstructive airway diseases in young individuals.

Understanding airway pathophysiology with computed tomograpy

Conventional pulmonary function tests are limited in the mechanistic insight that they can provide by the fact that they can only provide average measures of lung function. For example, a measurement of decreased expiratory flow assessed with conventional spirometry could result from narrowed large airways, narrowed small airways, closed airways, altered elasticity, or regional heterogeneities in parenchyma or airways. To examine specific mechanisms and pathology in the airways, a method is required that can actually look at specific individual airways. Over the past decade, several more direct methods of assessing specific mechanisms and structural alterations in normal airways and airway pathology in asthma have become available for such purposes. One such method is high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT), a method that allows the study of multiple individual airways during either contraction to closure or relaxation in real time, as well as changes in airway size with changes in lung volume. Although other imaging modalities have the potential to image airways in vivo, none presently has the convenience and the accessibility coupled with the resolution required to visualize the parenchymal airways in vivo. Although HRCT may never be widely utilized for routine measurements or screening, because of radiation exposure, cost issues, and a limited ability to follow changes over extended time periods, the method has distinct and unique advantages in quantifying the behavior of airways in vivo. In this mini-review, we focus on these capabilities of HRCT by briefly reviewing highlights of experimental results from several canine and human studies.

Comparison of elastic properties and contractile responses of isolated airway segments from mature and immature rabbits

Immature rabbits have greater maximal airway narrowing with bronchoconstriction in vivo compared with mature animals. As isolated immature lungs have a lower shear modulus, it is unclear whether the greater airway narrowing in the immature lung is secondary to less tethering between the airways and the lung parenchyma or to differences in the mechanical properties of the mature and immature airways. In the present study, we compared the mechanical properties of fluid-filled, isolated, intraparenchymal airway segments of the same generation from mature and immature rabbits. Stimulation with ACh resulted in greater airway narrowing in immature than mature bronchi. The immature bronchi were more compliant, had a lower resting airway volume, and were more collapsible compared with the mature bronchi. When the airways were contracted with ACh under isovolume conditions, the immature bronchi generated greater active pressure, and they were more sensitive to ACh than were mature bronchi. Our results suggest that maturational differences in the structure and function of the airways in the absence of the lung parenchyma can account for the greater maximal narrowing of immature than mature airways in vivo.

Postnatal alveolar development of the rabbit

Previous studies of alveolarization have used rats or lambs; however, neither closely reflects human alveolar development. We characterized alveolar development in rabbits (n = 3-7 /group) at 28 days gestation (dg) to 9 mo to determine whether they followed the human pattern more closely. The right lung was made up of 30% alveolar and 50% duct space at 28 dg to 3 days and of 50 and 30%, respectively, at 14 days to 9 mo. Tissue fraction and alveolar wall thickness decreased by 40% 28 dg to birth. At birth, approximately 4.5% of the number of alveoli seen at 9 mo were present, with alveolar number increasing progressively well into adulthood. The rate of alveolar formation was high around birth, decreasing progressively with age. Alveolar volume increased more than twofold (28 dg to birth) and continued to increase postnatally to 16 wk. Surface fraction decreased by 17% (28 dg to 3 days), after which it remained uniform. Our findings suggest that the timing of onset of alveolarization in humans and rabbits is similar and that rabbits may be used to model postnatal influences on alveolar development.

Computational model of airway narrowing: mature vs. immature rabbit

Immature rabbits have greater maximal airway narrowing and greater maximal fold increases in airway resistance during bronchoconstriction than mature animals. We have previously demonstrated that excised immature rabbit lungs have more distensible airways, a lower shear modulus, and structural differences in the relative composition and thickness of anatomically similar airways. In the present study, we incorporated anatomic and physiological data for mature and immature rabbits into a computational model of airway narrowing. We then investigated the relative importance of maturational differences in these factors as determinants of the greater airway narrowing that occurs in the immature animal. The immature model demonstrated greater sensitivity to agonist, as well as a greater maximal fold increase in airway resistance. Exchanging values for airway compliance between the mature and immature models resulted in the mature model exhibiting a greater maximal airway response than the immature model. In contrast, exchanging the shear moduli or the composition of the airway wall relative to the airway size produced relatively small changes in airway reactivity. Our results strongly suggest that the mechanical properties of the airway, i.e., greater compliance of the immature airway, can be an important factor contributing to the greater airway narrowing of the immature animal.

Bronchoprotective and bronchodilatory effects of deep inspiration in rabbits subjected to bronchial challenge

The effect of deep inspiration (DI) on airway responsiveness differs in asthmatic and normal human subjects. The mechanism for the effects of DI on airway responsiveness in vivo has not been identified. To elucidate potential mechanisms, we compared the effects of DI imposed before or during induced bronchoconstriction on the airway response to methacholine (MCh) in rabbits. The changes in airway resistance in response to intravenous MCh were continuously monitored. DI depressed the maximum response to MCh when imposed before or during the MCh challenge; however, the inhibitory effect of DI was greater when imposed during bronchoconstriction. Because immature rabbits have greater airway reactivity than mature rabbits, we compared the effects of DI on their airway responses. No differences were observed. Our results suggest that the mechanisms by which DI inhibits airway responsiveness do not depend on prior activation of airway smooth muscle (ASM). These results are consistent with the possibility that reorganization of the contractile apparatus caused by stretch of ASM during DI contributes to depression of the airway response.

Relationship of airway responsiveness with airway morphometry in normal and immunized rabbits

Airway responses to chemical stimuli occur over a wide range of concentrations, with overlap between severe, moderate and mild asthmatic groups and with normal healthy individuals. Mathematical modelling has suggested that relative thickness of the airway wall may account for this range of responsiveness. We have investigated whether in vivo airway responsiveness varies as a function of airway wall thickness in terms of airway smooth muscle area in normal and immunized New Zealand White (NZW) rabbits. Airway responsiveness to inhaled methacholine (MCh) was determined in vivo under neuroleptanalgesia. Subsequently, ex vivo responsiveness to MCh (pD(2)=-log EC(50)) of isolated bronchi from the same animal was established. Smooth muscle area per mm basement membrane (SM/mmBM) was also measured morphometrically in the tested bronchi and the findings related to in vivo and ex vivo responsiveness. We found no relationship between airway responsiveness in vivo and pD(2)values in either immunized or control rabbits. In both control and immunized rabbits, no correlation was found between SM/mmBM and in vivo airway responsiveness. Only in immunized animals with a PCA titre >0, was there a significant correlation (=-0.5986, P<0.05) between SM/mmBM and pD(2). We conclude that airway smooth muscle area per se is not the sole contributor of airway responsiveness in vivo in normal rabbits.

Respiratory mechanics and lung development in the rat from early age to adulthood

The purpose of the present study was to establish how the dependence of respiratory mechanics on lung inflation changes during development. We studied seven groups of rats from 10 days to 3 mo of age at five levels of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) from 0 to 7 hPa (1 hPa = 0.1 kPa approximately 1 cmH(2)O). At each PEEP level, we measured respiratory system resistance and elastance at both 0.9 and 4.8 Hz to partition the mechanical properties into its airway and tissue components. Elastance increased more rapidly with PEEP in the younger animals, which we interpret as reflecting a more pronounced strain stiffening of the younger parenchyma. However, the decrease in airway resistance with PEEP was more pronounced in the older animals. Morphometric analysis showed that mean tissue density decreased and total alveolar surface area increased with age. Our data suggest that the mechanical interdependence between airways and parenchyma is weaker in very young animals compared with mature animals. This may play a role in the hyperresponsiveness of immaturity.

Size distribution of recruited alveolar volumes in airway reopening

In 11 isolated dog lung lobes, we studied the size distribution of recruited alveolar volumes that become available for gas exchange during inflation from the collapsed state. Three catheters were wedged into 2-mm-diameter airways at total lung capacity. Small-amplitude pseudorandom pressure oscillations between 1 and 47 Hz were led into the catheters, and the input impedances of the regions subtended by the catheters were continuously recorded using a wave tube technique during inflation from -5 cm H(2)O transpulmonary pressure to total lung capacity. The impedance data were fit with a model to obtain regional tissue elastance (Eti) as a function of inflation. First, Eti was high and decreased in discrete jumps as more groups of alveoli were recruited. By assuming that the number of opened alveoli is inversely proportional to Eti, we calculated from the jumps in Eti the distribution of the discrete increments in the number of opened alveoli. This distribution was in good agreement with model simulations in which airways open in cascade or avalanches. Implications for mechanical ventilation may be found in these results.

Effect of transpulmonary pressure on airway diameter and responsiveness of immature and mature rabbits

We previously demonstrated that airway responsiveness is greater in immature than in mature rabbits; however, it is not known whether there are maturational differences in the effect of transpulmonary pressure (Ptp) on airway size and airway responsiveness. The relationship between Ptp and airway diameter was assessed in excised lungs insufflated with tantalum powder. Diameters of comparable intraparenchymal airway segments were measured from radiographs obtained at Ptp between 0 and 20 cmH(2)O. At Ptp > 8 cmH(2)O, the diameters were near maximal in both groups. With diameter normalized to its maximal value, changing Ptp between 8 and 0 cmH(2)O resulted in a greater decline of airway caliber in immature than mature airways. The increases in lung resistance (RL) in vivo at Ptp of 8, 5, and 2 cmH(2)O were measured during challenge with intravenous methacholine (MCh: 0.001-0.5 mg/kg). At Ptp of 8 cmH(2)O, both groups had very small responses to MCh and the maximal fold increases in RL did not differ (1.93 +/- 0.29 vs. 2.23 +/- 0.19). At Ptp of 5 and 2 cmH(2)O, the fold increases in RL were greater for immature than mature animals (13.19 +/- 1.81 vs. 3.89 +/- 0.37) and (17.74 +/- 2.15 vs. 4.6 +/- 0.52), respectively. We conclude that immature rabbits have greater airway distensibility and this difference may contribute to greater airway narrowing in immature compared with mature rabbits.

Mechanical properties of the tracheal mucosal membrane in the rabbit. I. steady-state stiffness as a function of age

Airway responsiveness is exaggerated in infancy and declines with maturation. These age-related differences (R.S. Tepper, T. Du, A. Styhler, M. Ludwig, and J.G. Martin. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 151: 836-840, 1995; R.S. Tepper, S.J. Gunst, C.M. Doerschuk, Y. Shen, and W. Bray. J. Appl. Physiol. 78: 505-512, 1995; R.S. Tepper, J. Stevens, and H. Eigen. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 149: 678-681, 1994) could be due to changes in the smooth muscle, the lung, and/or the airway wall. Folding of the mucosal membrane can provide an elastic load (R.K. Lambert, J. Appl. Physiol. 71: 666-673, 1991), which impedes smooth muscle shortening. We hypothesized that increased stiffness of the mucosal membrane occurs during aging, causing an increased mechanical load on airway smooth muscle and a decrease in airway responsiveness. Forty female New Zealand White rabbits between 0.75 and 35 mo of age were studied. Rectangular mucosal membrane strips oriented both longitudinally and circumferentially to the long axis of the trachea were dissected, and the stress-strain relationships of each strip were tested. The results showed that the membrane was stiffer in the longitudinal than in the circumferential direction of the airway. However, there was no significant change with age in either orientation. We conclude that the mechanical properties of the airway mucosal membrane did not change during maturation and were not likely to influence age-related changes in airway responsiveness.

Changes in viscoelastic properties of rat lung parenchymal strips with maturation

The lung extracellular matrix changes rapidly with maturation. To further our understanding of the mechanisms underlying lung tissue mechanics, we studied age-related changes in mechanical properties in lung parenchymal strips from baby (10-15 days old), young ( approximately 3 wk old), and adult ( approximately 8 wk old) rats. Subpleural strips were cut and suspended in a fluid-filled organ bath. One end of the strip was attached to a force transducer and the other to a servo-controlled lever arm. Measurements of force (F) and length (L) were recorded during sinusoidal oscillations of various amplitudes and frequencies. Resistance modulus (R) and elastance modulus (E) were estimated by fitting the equation of motion to changes in stress (T) and stretch ratio (lambda). Hysteresivity (eta) was calculated as follows: eta = (R/E)2pif, where f is frequency. Slow-cycling T-lambda curves were measured by applying a constant slow length change. Finally, quasi-static T-lambda curves were measured as stress was increased from 0 to 6 kPa and back to 0 kPa in stepwise increments. Our results showed that lung tissue from immature rats was stiffer and less hysteretic than tissue from more mature animals. In addition, tissue from baby animals behaved in a manner compatible with an increased vulnerability to plastic change.

Comparison of the shear modulus of mature and immature rabbit lungs

Maximal airway narrowing during bronchoconstriction is greater in immature than in mature rabbits. At a given transpulmonary pressure (PL), the lung parenchyma surrounding the airway resists local deformation and provides a load that opposes airway smooth muscle shortening. We hypothesized that the force required to produce lung parenchymal deformation, quantified by the shear modulus, is lower in immature rabbit lungs. The shear modulus and the bulk modulus were measured in isolated mature (n = 8; 6 mo) and immature (n = 9; 3 wk) rabbit lungs at PL of 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 cmH(2)O. The bulk modulus increased with increasing PL for mature and immature lungs; however, there was no significant difference between the groups. The shear modulus was lower for the immature than the mature lungs (P < 0.025), progressively increasing with increasing PL (P < 0.001) for both groups, and there was no difference between the slopes for shear modulus vs. PL for the mature and the immature lungs. The mean value of the shear modulus for mature and immature rabbit lungs at PL = 6 cmH(2)O was 4.5 vs. 3.8 cmH(2)O. We conclude that the shear modulus is less in immature than mature rabbit lungs. This small maturational difference in the shear modulus probably does not account for the greater airway narrowing in the immature lung, unless its effect is coupled with a relatively thicker and more compliant airway wall in the immature animal.

Greater airway narrowing in immature than in mature rabbits during methacholine challenge

It has been demonstrated that methacholine (MCh) challenge produces a greater increase in lung resistance in immature than in mature rabbits (R. S. Tepper, X. Shen, E. Bakan, and S. J. Gunst. J. Appl. Physiol. 79: 1190-1198, 1995). To determine whether this maturational difference in the response to MCh was primarily related to changes in airway resistance (Raw) or changes in tissue resistance, we assessed airway narrowing in 1-, 2-, and 6-mo-old rabbits during intravenous MCh challenge (0.01-5.0 mg/kg). Airway narrowing was determined from measurements of Raw in vivo and from morphometric measurements on lung sections obtained after rapidly freezing the lung after the MCh challenge. The fold increase in Raw was significantly greater for 1- and 2-mo-old animals than for 6-mo-old animals. Similarly, the degree of airway narrowing assessed morphometrically was significantly greater for 1- and 2-mo-old animals than for 6-mo-old animals. The fold increase in Raw was highly correlated with the degree of airway narrowing assessed morphometrically (r2 = 0.82, P < 0.001). We conclude that the maturational difference in the effect of MCh on lung resistance is primarily caused by greater airway narrowing in the immature rabbits.