Response properties of visual cortical neurons in cats reared in stroboscopic illumination

Perception of Coherent Motion in Infantile Nystagmus Syndrome

Purpose

Research on infantile nystagmus syndrome (INS) and motion perception is limited. We investigated how individuals with INS perform coherent motion tasks. Particularly, we assessed how the null position affects their performance.

Methods

Subjects with INS and controls identified the direction of coherent motion stimuli (22 subjects with INS and 13 controls) in a two-alternative forced-choice design. For subjects with INS, testing was done at the null position and 15 degrees away from it. If there was no null, testing was done at primary gaze position and 15 degrees away from primary. For controls, testing was done at primary gaze position and 20 degrees away from primary. Horizontal and vertical motion coherence thresholds were determined.

Results

Subjects with INS showed significantly higher horizontal and vertical motion coherence thresholds compared with controls at both gaze positions (P < 0.001). Within the INS group, for 12 subjects with INS who had an identified null position, no differences in coherence thresholds were found between their null and 15 degrees away from it (P > 0.05).

Conclusions

Coherent motion perception was impaired in subjects with INS. The null position did not significantly influence motion coherence thresholds for either horizontal or vertical motion.

Linking Neuronal Direction Selectivity to Perceptual Decisions About Visual Motion

Psychophysical and neurophysiological studies of responses to visual motion have converged on a consistent set of general principles that characterize visual processing of motion information. Both types of approaches have shown that the direction and speed of target motion are among the most important encoded stimulus properties, revealing many parallels between psychophysical and physiological responses to motion. Motivated by these parallels, this review focuses largely on more direct links between the key feature of the neuronal response to motion, direction selectivity, and its utilization in memory-guided perceptual decisions. These links were established during neuronal recordings in monkeys performing direction discriminations, but also by examining perceptual effects of widespread elimination of cortical direction selectivity produced by motion deprivation during development. Other approaches, such as microstimulation and lesions, have documented the importance of direction-selective activity in the areas that are active during memory-guided direction comparisons, area MT and the prefrontal cortex, revealing their likely interactions during behavioral tasks.

Unsupervised experience with temporal continuity of the visual environment is causally involved in the development of V1 complex cells

Unsupervised adaptation to the spatiotemporal statistics of visual experience is a key computational principle that has long been assumed to govern postnatal development of visual cortical tuning, including orientation selectivity of simple cells and position tolerance of complex cells in primary visual cortex (V1). Yet, causal empirical evidence supporting this hypothesis is scant. Here, we show that degrading the temporal continuity of visual experience during early postnatal life leads to a sizable reduction of the number of complex cells and to an impairment of their functional properties while fully sparing the development of simple cells. This causally implicates adaptation to the temporal structure of the visual input in the development of transformation tolerance but not of shape tuning, thus tightly constraining computational models of unsupervised cortical learning.

An early phase of instructive plasticity before the typical onset of sensory experience

While early experience with moving stimuli is necessary for the development of direction selectivity in visual cortex of carnivores, it is unclear whether experience exerts a permissive or instructive influence. To test if the specific parameters of the experienced stimuli could instructively sculpt the emergent responses, visually naive ferrets were exposed to several hours of experience with unusual spatiotemporal patterns. In the most immature ferrets, cortical neurons developed selectivity to these patterns, indicating an instructive influence. In animals that were 1–10 days more mature, exposure to the same patterns led to a developmentally-typical increase in direction selectivity. We conclude that visual development progresses via an early phase of instructive plasticity, when the specific patterns of neural activity shape the specific parameters of the emerging response properties, followed by a late phase of permissive maturation, when sensory-driven activity merely serves to enhance the response properties already seeded in cortical circuits.

Brain circuits exhibit different amounts of plasticity over different developmental stages. Here authors show that there is a transition of the influence of spatiotemporal patterns, from instructive to permissive, around the time of the onset of visual experience.

Optogenetic spatial and temporal control of cortical circuits on a columnar scale

Many circuits in the mammalian brain are organized in a topographic or columnar manner. These circuits could be activated-in ways that reveal circuit function or restore function after disease-by an artificial stimulation system that is capable of independently driving local groups of neurons. Here we present a simple custom microscope called ProjectorScope 1 that incorporates off-the-shelf parts and a liquid crystal display (LCD) projector to stimulate surface brain regions that express channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2). In principle, local optogenetic stimulation of the brain surface with optical projection systems might not produce local activation of a highly interconnected network like the cortex, because of potential stimulation of axons of passage or extended dendritic trees. However, here we demonstrate that the combination of virally mediated ChR2 expression levels and the light intensity of ProjectorScope 1 is capable of producing local spatial activation with a resolution of ∼200-300 μm. We use the system to examine the role of cortical activity in the experience-dependent emergence of motion selectivity in immature ferret visual cortex. We find that optogenetic cortical activation alone-without visual stimulation-is sufficient to produce increases in motion selectivity, suggesting the presence of a sharpening mechanism that does not require precise spatiotemporal activation of the visual system. These results demonstrate that optogenetic stimulation can sculpt the developing brain.

Binocular input coincidence mediates critical period plasticity in the mouse primary visual cortex

Classical studies on the development of ocular dominance (OD) organization in primary visual cortex (V1) have revealed a postnatal critical period (CP), during which visual inputs between the two eyes are most effective in shaping cortical circuits through synaptic competition. A brief closure of one eye during CP caused a pronounced shift of response preference of V1 neurons toward the open eye, a form of CP plasticity in the developing V1. However, it remains unclear what particular property of binocular inputs during CP is responsible for mediating this experience-dependent OD plasticity. Using whole-cell recording in mouse V1, we found that visually driven synaptic inputs from the two eyes to binocular cells in layers 2/3 and 4 became highly coincident during CP. Enhancing cortical GABAergic transmission activity by brain infusion with diazepam not only caused a precocious onset of the high coincidence of binocular inputs and OD plasticity in pre-CP mice, but rescued both of them in dark-reared mice, suggesting a tight link between coincident binocular inputs and CP plasticity. In Thy1-ChR2 mice, chronic disruption of this binocular input coincidence during CP by asynchronous optogenetic activation of retinal ganglion cells abolished the OD plasticity. Computational simulation using a feed-forward network model further suggests that the coincident inputs could mediate this CP plasticity through a homeostatic synaptic learning mechanism with synaptic competition. These results suggest that the high-level correlation of binocular inputs is a hallmark of the CP of developing V1 and serves as neural substrate for the induction of OD plasticity.

Effects of gestational length, gender, postnatal age, and birth order on visual contrast sensitivity in infants

To investigate effects of visual experience versus preprogrammed mechanisms on visual development, we used multiple regression analysis to determine the extent to which a variety of variables (that differ in the extent to which they are tied to visual experience) predict luminance and chromatic (red/green) contrast sensitivity (CS), which are mediated by the magnocellular (M) and parvocellular (P) subcortical pathways, respectively. Our variables included gestational length (GL), birth weight (BW), gender, postnatal age (PNA), and birth order (BO). Two-month-olds (n = 60) and 6-month-olds (n = 122) were tested. Results revealed that (1) at 2 months, infants with longer GL have higher luminance CS; (2) at both ages, CS significantly increases over a approximately 21-day range of PNA, but this effect is stronger in 2- than 6-month-olds and stronger for chromatic than luminance CS; (3) at 2 months, boys have higher luminance CS than girls; and (4) at 2 months, firstborn infants have higher CS, while at 6 months, non-firstborn infants have higher CS. The results for PNA/GL are consistent with the possibility that P pathway development is more influenced by variables tied to visual experience (PNA), while M pathway development is more influenced by variables unrelated to visual experience (GL). Other variables, including prenatal environment, are also discussed.

Effects of transient and prolonged flashing light stimulation on the cytochrome oxidase module system in layer IV of the primary visual cortex of kittens

Cytochrome oxidase spots in layer IV of field 17 of the primary visual cortex were studied in kittens aged 33, 49, and 93 days, stimulated with a light flashing at a frequency of 15 Hz. The kittens of one group received stimulation from the moment of eye opening until euthanasia (prolonged stimulation); other groups received stimulation for eight days starting from ages 26, 42, or 85 days (transient stimulation), again until euthanasia. Both types of stimulation were found not to alter the geometrical characteristics of cytochrome oxidase spots, but led to significant increases in the contrast of spots located in the splenial gyrus. Increases in spot contrast in the lateral gyrus occurred only after prolonged stimulation to age 93 days or after transient stimulation from age 26 days to age 33 days. Thus, stimulation of kittens of different ages with a light flashing at a frequency of 15 Hz led to structural-metabolic changes in the primary visual cortex. These changes were apparent to different extents in areas of the cortex responsible for central and peripheral vision. This may be explained, firstly, by the predominant activation of the Y conducting channel of the visual system and, secondly, by the increase in dominance of the contralateral input to the primary visual cortex.

Greater losses in sensitivity to second-order local motion than to first-order local motion after early visual deprivation in humans

We compared sensitivity to first-order versus second-order local motion in patients treated for dense central congenital cataracts in one or both eyes. Amplitude modulation thresholds were measured for discriminating the direction of motion of luminance-modulated (first-order) and contrast modulated (second-order) horizontal sine-wave gratings. Early visual deprivation, whether monocular or binocular, caused losses in sensitivity to both first- and second-order motion, with greater losses for second-order motion than for first-order motion. These findings are consistent with the hypothesis that the two types of motion are processed by different mechanisms and suggest that those mechanisms are differentially sensitive to early visual input.

Better perception of global motion after monocular than after binocular deprivation

We used random-dot kinematograms to compare the effects of early monocular versus early binocular deprivation on the development of the perception of the direction of global motion. Patients had been visually deprived by a cataract in one or both eyes from birth or later after a history of normal visual experience. The discrimination of direction of global motion was significantly impaired after early visual deprivation. Surprisingly, impairments were significantly worse after early binocular deprivation than after early monocular deprivation, and the sensitive period was very short. The unexpectedly good results after monocular deprivation suggest that the higher centers involved in the integration of global motion profit from input to the nondeprived eye. These findings suggest that beyond the primary visual cortex, competitive interactions between the eyes can give way to collaborative interactions that enable a relative sparing of some visual functions after monocular deprivation.

The time course of psychophysical end-stopping

This study measured the time course of psychophysical end-stopping and compared it with the time course of masking. For a 10' D6 target on an 18' D6 pedestal, two abutting end-zone masks (each 13.5' long) covering the filter end-zones reduce masking. This facilitatory 'end-stopping' effect was measured over a range of exposure durations and stimulus onset asynchronies (SOAs). We found that psychophysical end-stopping has a delayed onset which is around 70-100 ms after stimulus onset, in contrast to masking which is robust immediately after stimulus onset, suggesting intracortical feedback processes in the generation of psychophysical end-stopping. The development course of psychophysical end-stopping is relatively long and lasts for approximately 150-200 ms after stimulus onset, in contrast to that of masking which lasts for approximately 100-150 ms. Our results also showed that end-stopping occurs only when the center mask and the end-zone masks have sufficient temporal overlap, possibly indicating that the feedback process for generating end-stopping is triggered by the activation of the spatial filter center by the center mask. These results are in tune with current knowledge of intracortical feedback modulating activities of receptive fields, and have been incorporated into our model to describe the temporal dynamics within end-stopped spatial filters.

Strobe rearing reduces direction selectivity in area 17 by altering spatiotemporal receptive-field structure

Strobe rearing reduces direction selectivity in area 17 by altering spatiotemporal receptive-field structure. J. Neurophysiol. 80: 2991-3004, 1998. Direction selectivity in simple cells of cat area 17 is linked to spatiotemporal (S-T) receptive-field structure. S-T inseparable receptive fields display gradients of response timing across the receptive field that confer a preferred direction of motion. Receptive fields that are not direction selective lack gradients; they are S-T separable, displaying uniform timing across the field. Here we further examine this link using a developmental paradigm that disrupts direction selectivity. Cats were reared from birth to 8 mo of age in 8-Hz stroboscopic illumination. Direction selectivity in simple cells was then measured using gratings drifting at different temporal frequencies (0.25-16 Hz). S-T structure was assessed using stationary bars presented at different receptive-field positions, with bar luminance being modulated sinusoidally at different temporal frequencies. For each cell, plots of response phase versus bar position were fit by lines to characterize S-T inseparability at each temporal frequency. Strobe rearing produced a profound loss of direction selectivity at all temporal frequencies; only 10% of cells were selective compared with 80% in normal cats. The few remaining directional cells were selective over a narrower than normal range of temporal frequencies and exhibited weaker than normal direction selectivity. Importantly, the directional loss was accompanied by a virtual elimination of S-T inseparability. Nearly all cells were S-T separable, like nondirectional cells in normal cats. The loss was clearest in layer 4. Normally, inseparability is greatest there, and it correlates well (r = 0.77) with direction selectivity; strobe rearing reduced inseparability and direction selectivity to very low values. The few remaining directional cells were inseparable. In layer 6 of normal cats, most direction-selective cells are only weakly inseparable, and there is no consistent relationship between the two measures. However, after strobe rearing, even the weak inseparability was eliminated along with direction selectivity. The correlated changes in S-T structure and direction selectivity were confirmed using conventional linear predictions of directional tuning based on responses to counterphasing bars and white noise stimuli. The developmental changes were permanent, being observed up to 12 yr after strobe rearing. The deficits were remarkably specific; strobe rearing did not affect spatial receptive-field structure, orientation selectivity, spatial or temporal frequency tuning, or general responsiveness to visual stimuli. These results provide further support for a critical role of S-T structure in determining direction selectivity in simple cells. Strobe rearing eliminates directional tuning by altering the timing of responses within the receptive field.

Rectification nonlinearity in cortical end-stopped perceptive fields

End-stopped perceptive fields associated with line targets were demonstrated previously with length and width Westheimer functions. In this study we investigated rectifying non-linearity in these perceptive fields to examine whether they directly reflect the organization of cortical receptive fields. Specifically, we reversed the polarity of parts of the background field associated with a specific perceptive field sub-region and examined threshold changes in corresponding length or width Westheimer functions. Results showed full-wave rectification in end-stopping and half-wave rectification in center summation and flank-inhibition preceding linear summation in end-stopped perceptive fields. Half-wave rectification in center summation and surround-inhibition preceding linear summation was also found in circular perceptive fields associated with spot targets. These results are inconsistent with direct links between perceptive fields and cortical receptive fields. Rather they suggest that these perceptive fields are likely the second-order fields formed by pooled non-linearly rectified outputs from cortical receptive fields.

Cortical end-stopped perceptive fields: evidence from dichoptic and amblyopic studies

Psychophysical length and width spatial interactions associated with a line target were measured in normal observers dichoptically and in observers with naturally acquired amblyopia to investigate the neural locus of end-stopped perceptive fields. Results show (1) interocular transfer of psychophysical end-stopping, flank-inhibition, and length and width summation; and (2) severe, but significantly different, loss of end-stopping and flank-inhibition in the central visual fields of amblyopic eyes. Together, these results suggest a cortical basis for end-stopped perceptive fields, and that psychophysical end-stopping and flank-inhibition are a consequence of distinct cortical inhibition. The damaging effects of amblyopia on end-stopping and flank-inhibition are weaker and less different from each other under transient conditions. Our results provide further evidence supporting the suggestion that end-stopped perceptive fields are the psychophysical analogs of cortical end-stopped receptive fields.

Associative synaptic plasticity in hippocampus and visual cortex: cellular mechanisms and functional implications

Synchronous pre- and postsynaptic neuronal activity results in long-term potentiation (LTP) of excitatory synaptic transmission in the hippocampus and the neocortex. Induction of this form of potentiation requires calcium influx mediated by NMDA receptors. Experimental evidence is reviewed for induction of long-term depression (LTD) of synaptic transmission in the hippocampus in vitro and neocortical neurons in vivo, when the discharge of the postsynaptic neuron is temporally decorrelated from the presynaptic stimulation. Homosynaptic LTD induced by low frequency tetani in the hippocampus in vitro requires NMDA receptor activation and a moderate calcium influx. The role of postsynaptic calcium as a key parameter in the encoding of temporal contiguity of neural activity and its possible implications in the formation of engrams during specific learning tasks are discussed.

A reduction in the number of directionally selective neurons extends the spatial limit for global motion perception

Dynamic random-dot targets were used to study neural mechanisms underlying motion perception. Performance of cats with severely reduced numbers of cortical directionally selective neurons (reduced DS) was compared to that of normal animals. We assessed the spatial properties of the residual motion mechanism by measuring direction discriminations at various dot displacements. At small displacements, reduced DS cats' motion integration thresholds for opposite direction discrimination were nearly normal. At larger displacements, their thresholds surpassed those of normal cats and their upper displacement limit (dmax) was increased by 0.35 deg. The accuracy of direction discrimination was reduced at small displacements, but at larger displacements direction difference thresholds of reduced DS cats approached or surpassed those of normals. These data were compared to the performance of humans who showed an extension of dmax for peripherally viewed targets. The data support the hypothesis that expansion in spatial scale of the motion mechanism may contribute to extension of dmax. Additional support for this hypothesis is provided by a modified direction discriminating line-element model. The model also suggests that changes in sampling of motion mechanisms in the reduced DS system may play a role.

Early sensory determinants of locomotor speed in adult cats: II. Effects of strobe rearing on vestibular functions

Cats raised under stroboscopic illumination are known to exhibit oculomotor and visuomotor deficits, but little is known about their locomotor abilities. Four strobe-reared cats with intact labyrinths were tested in a locomotor test involving various walking surfaces and various illumination conditions. Apart from their general slowness under all the experimental conditions, these strobe cats showed no special deficit on narrow rails, which indicates that their dynamic balancing abilities were normal. In these subjects, the decrease in the use of kinetic visual cues was roughly compensated for by an increase in the use of position cues. When tested after chronic bilateral labyrinthectomy, the strobe-reared cats' locomotor speeds were identical to those of control labyrinthectomized cats, except on wide platforms involving orientation towards a visual goal. These results show that in the absence of motion-vision, vestibular control of dynamic balance can mature normally, but they suggest that other aspects of locomotion involving the processing of vestibular and kinesthetic inputs may be impaired.

Experimental myopia in cats reared in stroboscopic illumination

Spectacle refraction of eyes of strobe-reared animals was compared to that of normal cats. Strobe reared cats were found to be significantly more myopic than normal cats.

Stimulus contrast and visual cortical lesions

Intact animals can make fine orientation discriminations over a wide range of contrasts. After ablation of area 17 deficits in orientation discrimination are observed only at low contrast. The relevance of this finding for the design of sensitive ablation experiments is discussed.

Activity sharpens the regenerating retinotectal projection in goldfish: sensitive period for strobe illumination and lack of effect on synaptogenesis and on ganglion cell receptive field properties

The regenerating optic nerve of goldfish first reestablishes a rough retinotopic map on the contralateral tectum and then sharpens it. Disruption of visual activity, either by blocking activity with intraocular tetrodotoxin (TTX; Schmidt and Edwards, 1983) or by synchronizing activity with strobe illumination (Schmidt and Eisele, 1985), disrupts the sharpening process: the map is correctly oriented but the multiunit receptive fields at each point average 25-40 degrees in diameter. In order to test whether strobe and TTX interfere with the same mechanism, we have tested whether their sensitive periods are the same, and whether strobe, like TTX treatment, does not affect either ganglion cell receptive field properties or synaptogenesis. In parallel studies, we exposed fish to 2 weeks of either strobe illumination or intraocular TTX beginning at various times after crush and determined via electrophysiological recordings that the periods of sensitivity were nearly identical. There was no effect of either treatment during the first 2 weeks (before the fibers arrive at the tectum), maximal disruption of sharpening between 14 and 50 days (the period of rapid synaptogenesis), decreasing disruption between 50 and 125 days, and no effect beyond that point or in the normal projection. In addition, long strobe exposures of up to 142 days produced no greater disruptions than shorter 2-3-week exposures, indicating no cumulative effect. The reestablishment of synaptic transmission in tectum, assayed by recording field potentials elicited by optic nerve shock, was not affected by stroboscopic illumination. Finally, individual ganglion cells, recorded intraretinally following long-term strobe exposure, had receptive fields that were normal both in size and in their characteristic responses to light-on, to light-off, or to both on and off. These findings support the hypothesis that strobe-like TTX prevents retinotopic refinement by preventing the correction of errors initially made by the ingrowing optic axons (Schmidt et al., 1988).

The development of orientation and direction selectivity in the rabbit visual cortex

The postnatal development of orientation and direction selectivity of single cells was examined in the primary visual cortex of rabbits. The percentage of cells which were orientation-selective reached adult levels by day 30, whereas the proportion of cells which were direction-selective did not reach adult levels until day 60. Differences in the time course of development of orientation and direction selectivity, together with data previously reported on differences in the effects of deprivation on orientation and direction selectivity, suggest that (1) different mechanisms underly the organization of orientation and direction selectivity and (2) the critical periods for the effects of deprivation on orientation and direction selectivity reflect the different time course of the normal development of these two response properties.

Developmentally induced loss of direction-selective neurons in the cat's lateral suprasylvian visual cortex

Single-cell recordings were carried out in the posteromedial lateral suprasylvian (PMLS) visual cortex of cats reared in an environment illuminated by 8-Hz stroboscopic flashes. These cats had a reduced proportion of direction-selective cells (8%) compared to PMLS cortex of normal cats (79%). Other receptive-field properties and ocular dominance of the neurons appeared normal. These results have implications for understanding the mechanisms of PMLS-cortex development and for interpreting behavioral studies of strobe-reared cats.

Effects of stimulus speed on direction discriminations

Difference thresholds for the direction of movement of moving isotropic dot patterns were measured over a wide range of stimulus speeds. These measurements were made in human subjects, in normal cats and in visually deprived cats with abnormalities in neuronal directional response. For all subjects, direction thresholds were inversely related to stimulus speed at low drift rates. Above a "critical speed", direction thresholds were independent of stimulus speed. Between group differences in critical speed parallel differences in visual acuity and absolute thresholds for direction of motion. However, asymptotic direction thresholds appear to be unrelated to acuity and motion detection thresholds. It is argued that the basis for the differences in asymptotic direction thresholds between the groups are differences in properties of directional mechanisms.