Involvement of the caudal medulla in negative feedback mechanisms triggered by spatial summation of nociceptive inputs

Understanding central mechanisms of acupuncture analgesia using dynamic quantitative sensory testing: a review

We discuss the emerging translational tools for the study of acupuncture analgesia with a focus on psychophysical methods. The gap between animal mechanistic studies and human clinical trials of acupuncture analgesia calls for effective translational tools that bridge neurophysiological data with meaningful clinical outcomes. Temporal summation (TS) and conditioned pain modulation (CPM) are two promising tools yet to be widely utilized. These psychophysical measures capture the state of the ascending facilitation and the descending inhibition of nociceptive transmission, respectively. We review the basic concepts and current methodologies underlying these measures in clinical pain research, and illustrate their application to research on acupuncture analgesia. Finally, we highlight the strengths and limitations of these research methods and make recommendations on future directions. The appropriate addition of TS and CPM to our current research armamentarium will facilitate our efforts to elucidate the central analgesic mechanisms of acupuncture in clinical populations.

Hypoalgesia to pressure pain in referred pain areas triggered by spatial summation of experimental muscle pain from unilateral or bilateral trapezius muscles

Animal and human experimental studies have suggested the importance of spatial summation in the nociception processing and in the activation of descending inhibition. However, the relationship between the areas (size) of muscles stimulated and the recruitment of descending inhibition has not been addressed. Consequently, we tested whether bilateral versus unilateral injection of hypertonic saline into trapezius muscles caused hypoalgesia to pressure pain (pressure pain thresholds, PPTs) in the local pain areas (the trapezius muscles) and the referred pain areas (the posterolateral neck muscles). Two groups of volunteers participated. One group received a unilateral injection (one injection) and the other group bilateral injections (two injections). In the bilateral group, hypertonic saline was injected in one trapezius first, and 45 s later, while pain was still present from the first injection, a second injection was performed into the contralateral trapezius muscle. The saline-evoked time to maximal pain was significantly shorter after the second injection than after the first injection. More subjects developed referred pain after the bilateral compared with the unilateral injection. In the referred pain areas, the PPTs 7.5 and 15 min after the second injection were significantly increased compared with the first injection, while no changes in the PPT were observed in local and referred pain areas after unilateral injection. This suggests that the induction of descending inhibition was triggered by spatial summation during the later phase of experimentally induced muscle pain. The present experimental model might be used for further investigation of descending inhibition related to the spatial characteristics of nociceptive stimuli in humans.

Chronic morphine increases Fos-positive neurons after concurrent cornea and tail stimulation

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the present study was to examine the effect of chronic morphine exposure on diffuse noxious inhibitory controls in a large population of neurons throughout the medullary dorsal horn, as assessed using immunocytochemistry for c-Fos protein.

BACKGROUND

Overuse of medications, including the opioids, to treat migraine headache can lead to progressively more frequent headaches. In addition, chronic daily headache sufferers and chronic opioid users both lack the inhibition of pain produced by noxious stimulation of a distal body region, often referred to as diffuse noxious inhibitory controls.

METHODS

In urethane anesthetized rats, Fos-positive neurons were quantified in chronic morphine and vehicle-treated animals following 52°C noxious thermal stimulation of the cornea with and without the application of a spatially remote noxious stimulus (placement of the tail in 55°C water).

RESULTS

When compared to chronic morphine-treated animals that did not receive the spatially remote noxious stimulus, chronic morphine-treated animals given corneal stimulation along with the spatially remote noxious stimulus demonstrated a 163% increase (P < .05) in the number of Fos-positive neurons in the superficial laminae of the medullary dorsal horn and a 682% increase (P < .01) in deep laminae that was restricted to the side ipsilateral to the applied stimulus. In contrast, no significant difference was found in Fos-like immunoreactivity in vehicle-treated animals given concurrent cornea and tail stimulation or only cornea stimulation in either superficial or deep laminae.

CONCLUSIONS

It is proposed that an increase in descending facilitation and subsequent loss of diffuse noxious inhibitory controls contributes to the development of medication overuse headache.

Treating pain with pain: supraspinal mechanisms of endogenous analgesia elicited by heterotopic noxious conditioning stimulation

While being exposed to an intensive tonic pain stimulus at one area of the body, another phasic pain stimulus applied to a remote site is perceived as less painful. The neurophysiological basis for this "pain inhibits pain" phenomenon has been presumed to be an activation of the spino-bulbo-spinal mechanism termed "diffuse noxious inhibitory controls." However, several additional mechanisms such as an activation of the descending pain control system may contribute to this observation. Here we investigated the underlying supraspinal mechanisms of "heterotopic noxious conditioning stimulations" (HNCS), representing this specific experimental constellation. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging and behavioral recordings in combination with a modified cold-pressor task and phasic painful stimuli, and investigated the contribution of endogenous opioids to this mechanism using the opioid antagonist naloxone in a double-blind crossover design. HNCS led to marked endogenous analgesia and this effect correlated positively with the perceived intensity of the tonic painful stimulus. Furthermore, HNCS was paralleled by reduced blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) responses in classical pain-responsive regions. Conversely, HNCS led to tonic BOLD increases in subregions of the anterior cingulate cortex. The strength of functional coupling between the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex and key structures of the descending pain control system was enhanced during HNCS, which correlated positively with the individual endogenous analgesia during HNCS. These effects were in part reversed by naloxone, speaking for the contribution of endogenous opioid neurotransmission to this mechanism. Taken together, these results demonstrate a substantial contribution of higher-order brain regions to the phenomenon of hypoalgesia during HNCS. Functional magnetic resonance imaging shows how the human brain is involved in heterotopic noxious conditioning and reveals active supraspinal pain modulatory mechanisms during dual pain stimulation.

Filling-in, spatial summation, and radiation of pain: evidence for a neural population code in the nociceptive system

The receptive field organization of nociceptive neurons suggests that noxious information may be encoded by population-based mechanisms. Electrophysiological evidence of population coding mechanisms has remained limited. However, psychophysical studies examining interactions between multiple noxious stimuli can provide indirect evidence that neuron population recruitment can contribute to both spatial and intensity-related percepts of pain. In the present study, pairs of thermal stimuli (35 degrees C/49 degrees C or 49 degrees C/49 degrees C) were delivered at different distances on the leg (0, 5, 10, 20, 40 cm) and abdomen (within and across dermatomes) and subjects evaluated pain intensity and perceived spatial attributes of stimuli. Reports of perceived pain spreading to involve areas that were not stimulated (radiation of pain) were most frequent at 5- and 10-cm distances (chi(2) = 34.107, P < 0.0001). Perceived connectivity between two noxious stimuli (filling-in) was influenced by the distance between stimuli (chi(2) = 16.756, P < 0.01), with the greatest connectivity reported at 5- and 10-cm separation distances. Spatial summation of pain occurred over probe separation distances as large as 40 cm and six dermatomes (P < 0.05), but was maximal at 5- and 10-cm separation distances. Taken together, all three of these phenomena suggest that interactions between recruited populations of neurons may support both spatial and intensity-related dimensions of the pain experience.

Raphe magnus neurons help protect reactions to visceral pain from interruption by cutaneous pain

Suppression of reactions to one noxious stimulus by a spatially distant noxious stimulus is termed heterotopic antinociception. In lightly anesthetized rats, a noxious visceral stimulus, colorectal distension (CRD), suppressed motor withdrawals but not blood pressure or heart rate changes evoked by noxious hindpaw heat. Microinjection of muscimol, a GABA(A) receptor agonist, into raphe magnus (RM) reduced CRD-evoked suppression of withdrawals, evidence that RM neurons contribute to this heterotopic antinociception. To understand how brain stem neurons contribute to heterotopic antinociception, RM neurons were recorded during CRD-elicited suppression of hindpaw withdrawals. Although subsets of RM neurons that were excited (on cells) or inhibited (off cells) by noxious cutaneous stimulation were either excited or inhibited by CRD, on cells were inhibited and off cells excited by an intracerebroventricularly administered opioid, evidence that the nociception-facilitating and -inhibiting functions of on and off cells, respectively, are predicted by the cellular response to noxious cutaneous stimulation alone and not by the response to CRD. When recorded during CRD-elicited antinociception, RM cell discharge resembled the pattern observed in response to CRD stimulation alone. However, when hindpaw withdrawal suppression was incomplete, RM cell discharge resembled the pattern observed in response to heat alone. We propose that on cells excited by CRD facilitate responses to CRD itself, which in turn augments excitation of off cells that then act to suppress cutaneous nociception. RM cells may thereby contribute to the dominance of quiet recuperative reactions evoked by potentially life-threatening visceral stimuli over transient somatomotor activity elicited by less-injurious noxious cutaneous stimuli.

The effect of trigeminal nociceptive stimulation on blink reflexes and pain evoked by stimulation of the supraorbital nerve

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of painful conditioning stimuli on pain and blink reflexes to supraorbital nerve stimulation. Electromyograph activity was recorded bilaterally from the orbicularis oculi muscles in 13 normal participants in response to low (2.3 mA) and high-intensity (18.6 mA) electrical stimulation of the left supraorbital nerve before, during and after the application of ice to the left or right temple or immersion of the left hand in ice-water for 60 s. The pain evoked by the high-intensity electrical stimulus was greater during painful conditioning stimulation of the ipsilateral temple than during the recovery period afterwards, and was greater than during painful conditioning stimulation of the contralateral temple. These findings imply that spatial summation of nociceptive signals across different divisions of the trigeminal nerve can heighten pain. However, painful conditioning stimulation, particularly to the right temple, strongly suppressed the R2 component of the blink reflex to the low-intensity stimulus, and also suppressed R2 to the high-intensity stimulus. Thus, an inhibitory influence (e.g. diffuse noxious inhibitory controls) appeared to mask ipsilateral segmental facilitation of R2 during ice-induced headache. This finding contrasts with recent electrophysiological evidence of trigeminal sensitization in migraine.

The medullary dorsal reticular nucleus enhances the responsiveness of spinal nociceptive neurons to peripheral stimulation in the rat

Single-unit spinal recordings combined with application of glutamate into the medullary dorsal reticular nucleus were used to assess the action of this nucleus upon deep dorsal horn neurons in rats. Injection of high glutamate concentrations (10 and 100 mm) induced a dramatic and long-lasting increase of the responses of wide-dynamic range neurons to electrical stimulation of the sciatic nerve in the noxious range, without affecting ongoing discharges. Post-stimulus time histograms revealed that this increase concerned the post-discharge, but not A- or C-fibre-mediated responses, which remained unchanged independently of the stimulation frequency applied. The onset of the glutamate-induced response enhancement occurred with a concentration-dependent time delay and developed slowly until its maximum. These data indicate that the medullary dorsal reticular nucleus exerts a facilitating action upon deep dorsal horn wide-dynamic range neurons by enhancing their capacity to respond to peripheral stimulation through prolongation of their discharge. This action is accompanied by the strengthening of wind-up of deep dorsal horn wide-dynamic range neurons, hence providing a plausible substrate for chronic pain states. These results are in agreement with previous behavioural studies suggesting a pronociceptive role for the dorsal reticular nucleus [Almeida et al. (1996) Brain Res. Bull., 39, 7-15; Almeida et al. (1999) Eur. J. Neurosci., 11, 110-122], and support the involvement of a reverberating circuit, previously described in morphological studies [Almeida et al. (1993) Neuroscience, 55, 1093-1106; Almeida et al. (2000) Eur. J. Pain, 4, 373-387], which probably operates only at a certain threshold of activation.

Psychophysical and EEG responses to repeated experimental muscle pain in humans: pain intensity encodes EEG activity

Clinical pain is often characterized by repetitive and persistent occurrence in deep structures, but few studies investigated repetitive tonic pain in humans. To determine cerebral responses to repetitive tonic pain, psychophysical responses, and electroencephalographic (EEG) activation to five trials of repeated tonic muscle pain induced by hypertonic saline were examined and analyzed in 13 male subjects. The study was composed of two experimental sessions performed in separate days. Five sequential injections of hypertonic saline (5.8%) were used to induce repeated muscle pain in the left forearm, and five sequential injections of isotonic saline (0.9%) acted as control. Visual analogue scales (VAS) for pain intensity and 32-channels EEG activities were recorded simultaneously. Five trials of relatively stable muscle pain were induced by intramuscular injections of hypertonic saline, but no evident pain was induced by the injections of isotonic saline. Significant decreases in alpha-1 and -2 activities in posterior part of the head were found during repeated muscle pain in comparison with non-pain. In comparison with baseline, alpha-1 and -2 activities reduced significantly during the first two trials, and gradually resumed in the following three trials of muscle pain. However, beta-2 activity increased consistently throughout the five trials of muscle pain compared to baseline. Alpha-1 activity was negatively, but beta-2 activity was positively correlated to the pain intensity and pain area on the skin. Throughout five injections, the reduction of alpha-1 activity was contrary to the changes of pain intensity. These results indicates that pain-related EEG activities were encoded by the pain intensity. The thalamo-cortical system and descending inhibitory neuronal networks may be involved in the regulation of pain intensity.

The whole body receptive field of dorsal horn multireceptive neurones

Multireceptive neurones are found in the spinal dorsal horn and may be projection neurones and/or interneurones for polysynaptic reflexes. The cutaneous receptive field of a multireceptive neurone exhibits a gradient of sensitivity with the centre responding to any mechanical stimulus, including hair movements and light touch, while the periphery responds only to noxious stimuli. These neurones also receive signals from viscera, muscles and joints. This convergence of inputs means that multireceptive neurones are continuously capturing all the information from both the interface with the external environment (the skin) and the internal milieu (the viscera, muscles, etc.). This information constitutes a 'basic somaesthetic activity' that could help the somatosensory system build a 'global representation of the body'. In addition to be seen as a global entity, the output of multireceptive neurones should be understood in dynamic terms since the size of the peripheral fields of the individual neurones may change, as a result of the plasticity of both excitatory and inhibitory segmental processes. Furthermore, the activity of these neurones can be inhibited from most of the remaining parts of the body via supraspinal mechanisms. These diffuse noxious inhibitory controls (DNIC) are triggered by peripheral A delta- and C-fibres, involve brain structures confined to the caudal-most part of the medulla including the subnucleus reticularis dorsalis (SRD) and are mediated by descending pathways in the dorsolateral funiculi. A painful focus that both activates a segmental subset of neurones and inhibits the remaining population can seriously disrupt this basic activity, resulting in the distortion of the body representation in favour of the painful focus, which becomes pre-eminent and (relatively) oversized.

Spatial summation of pain processing in the human brain as assessed by cerebral event related potentials

To understand spatial summation of pain processing in the brain, we investigated the cerebral evoked responses to non-painful and painful contact heat stimulation (70 degrees C/s fast onset; intensity 2,4,6, corresponding to the individual's non-, slight and moderate pain) comparing one (1s) vs. two spots (2s) in 11 subjects while electroencephalographic signals were recorded. Significant spatial summation effects were shown only for the pain levels. For moderate pain, global field power examination isolated two peak activations for the vertex (Cz) N550 and P750 components. The single dipole modelling identified as likely the supplementary motor area, SMA area-6 source for N550, and posterior cingulate area-23 for P750. These source components showed a significantly faster (41.2 ms) latency and a shift in location from dorsal to ventral SMA of N550 toward cingulate area-31 between the 1s and 2s conditions. The temporal and spatial shift during spatial summation may reflect speeding up of the limbic affective reaction and prefrontal cognitive preparation in impending aversion and is deemed essential for integration of bodily sensations, such as pain.

Spatial encoding properties of subnucleus reticularis dorsalis neurons in the rat medulla

The effect of spatial summation, produced by noxious thermal stimuli, was investigated on medullary Subnucleus Reticularis Dorsalis (SRD) neurons of anaesthetized rats. Neurons with 'whole body' receptive fields were excited by a random sequence of thermal stimuli involving four different surface areas of a hindpaw (1.9, 4.8, 7.5 and 18 cm(2)). The responses of SRD neurons progressively decrease when the area of noxious stimulation exceeded 4.8 cm(2). The shape of the stimulus-response curve closely match the shape of dorsal horn convergent neurons, previously recorded under similar experimental conditions. These results suggest that, with respect to spatial encoding properties, SRD neurons are driven by the same supraspinally-mediated inhibitory mechanisms as dorsal horn convergent neurons.

Wind-up of spinal cord neurones and pain sensation: much ado about something?

Wind-up is a frequency-dependent increase in the excitability of spinal cord neurones, evoked by electrical stimulation of afferent C-fibres. Although it has been studied over the past thirty years, there are still uncertainties about its physiological meaning. Glutamate (NMDA) and tachykinin NK1 receptors are required to generate wind-up and therefore a positive modulation between these two receptor types has been suggested by some authors. However, most drugs capable of reducing the excitability of spinal cord neurones, including opioids and NSAIDs, can also reduce or even abolish wind-up. Thus, other theories involving synaptic efficacy, potassium channels, calcium channels, etc. have also been proposed for the generation of this phenomenon. Whatever the mechanisms involved in its generation, wind-up has been interpreted as a system for the amplification in the spinal cord of the nociceptive message that arrives from peripheral nociceptors connected to C-fibres. This probably reflects the physiological system activated in the spinal cord after an intense or persistent barrage of afferent nociceptive impulses. On the other hand, wind-up, central sensitisation and hyperalgesia are not the same phenomena, although they may share common properties. Wind-up can be an important tool to study the processing of nociceptive information in the spinal cord, and the central effects of drugs that modulate the nociceptive system. This paper reviews the physiological and pharmacological data on wind-up of spinal cord neurones, and the perceptual correlates of wind-up in human subjects, in the context of its possible relation to the triggering of hyperalgesic states, and also the multiple factors which contribute to the generation of wind-up.

Mu- and delta-opioid receptor mRNAs are expressed in spinally projecting serotonergic and nonserotonergic neurons of the rostral ventromedial medulla

The rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM) is an important mediator of the supraspinal component of opioid antinociception. Previous studies have suggested that activation of the cloned mu- and delta-opioid receptors (MOR1 and DOR1 respectively) in the RVM produces the antinociception mediated by spinally projecting neurons. In the present study, we investigated the expression of mRNA encoding either MOR1 or DOR1 in the RVM of rats. In addition, we examined quantitatively the expression of MOR1 and DOR1 mRNAs in spinally projecting RVM neurons including serotonergic (5HT) cells by using in situ hybridization, immunocytochemistry, retrograde tract-tracing, and the physical disector. Brainstem neurons were labeled in 14 male Sprague-Dawley rats by applying Fluoro-Gold (FG) topically to the dorsal surface of the lumbosacral spinal cord. Five-micrometer-thick cryostat sections were cut and in situ hybridization was performed by using full-length cRNA probes labeled with 35S-UTP. We found that 43% of RVM projection neurons expressed MOR1 mRNA and 83% of RVM projection neurons expressed DOR1 mRNA. Of 192 retrogradely labeled cells in the RVM, 51 cells (27%) were immunoreactive for 5HT. Of this population, half appeared to be labeled for the mRNA encoding MOR1 and over three-fourths appeared to be labeled for the mRNA encoding DOR1. Thus, we conclude that bulbospinal neurons express MOR1 and DOR1; moreover, MOR1 and DOR1 are expressed by significant proportions of 5HT neurons projecting to or through the dorsal spinal cord.