Ammonia-Oxidizing Archaea (AOA) Play with Ammonia-Oxidizing Bacteria (AOB) in Nitrogen Removal from Wastewater

Advanced Technologies for Nitrogen Removal and Recovery from Municipal and Industrial Wastewater

Nitrogen pollution poses significant environmental challenges, contributing to eutrophication, soil acidification, and greenhouse gas emissions. This study explores advanced methods for nitrogen removal and recovery from municipal and industrial wastewater, with a focus on biological, chemical, and physical processes. Key processes, such as nitrification-denitrification and emerging technologies like shortcut nitrogen pathways, were analyzed for their efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and environmental benefits. This review highlights the integration of innovative techniques, including membrane systems and ammonia stripping, with traditional approaches to enhance nitrogen management. Emphasis is placed on optimizing operational conditions, such as pH, temperature, and carbon-to-nitrogen ratios, to achieve high removal rates while minimizing energy consumption and environmental impact. These findings underline the critical role of interdisciplinary strategies in addressing the challenges of nitrogen pollution and promoting sustainable wastewater management.

Transcriptional and molecular simulation analysis of the response mechanism of anammox bacteria to 3,4-dimethylpyrazole phosphate stress

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) and nitrification are two vital biological pathways for ammonium oxidation, pivotal in microbial nitrogen cycling. 3,4-Dimethylpyrazole phosphate (DMPP) is commonly used as inhibitors in agricultural soils to reduce nitrogen losses from farmland, while whether it affect anammox is an open question. Acute inhibition tests revealed that 53.5 mg·L-1 DMPP caused 50 % reduction in anammox bacteria. After 36 days of prolonged exposure to 5 mg·L-1 DMPP, the ammonium(nitrite) removal rate of endnote decreased from 78.39(94.78) to 13.57(15.28) mgN·gVSS-1·d-1. Additionally, the abundance of Ca. Kuenenia decreased from 36.5 % to 6.06 %. Transcriptomic analysis revealed that the mRNA levels of ammonium transport genes (amt_1 and amt_4), and hydrazine synthase (hzs) were significantly downregulated. Molecular docking simulations indicated that DMPP bound with ammonium transport and hydrazine synthesis. This interaction hindered the transcriptional levels of genes encoding ammonium transporters and hzs. The study has guiding value to reduce the nitrogen loss involved in anammox bacteria in agricultural soils under the application of DMPP.

Distinct Patterns of Antibiotic Sensitivities in Ammonia-Oxidising Archaea

Ammonia-oxidising archaea (AOA) are important microorganisms contributing towards the nitrogen flux in the environment. Unlike archaea from other major phyla, genetic tools are yet to be developed for the AOA, and identification of antibiotic resistance markers for selecting mutants is required for a genetic system. The aim of this study was to test the effects of selected antibiotics (hygromycin B, neomycin, apramycin, puromycin, novobiocin) on pure cultures of three well studied AOA strains, 'Candidatus Nitrosocosmicus franklandianus C13', Nitrososphaera viennensis EN76 and Nitrosopumilus maritimus SCM1. Puromycin, hygromycin B and neomycin inhibited some but not all tested archaeal strains. All strains were resistant to apramycin and inhibited by novobiocin to various degrees. As N. viennensis EN76 was relatively more resistant to the tested antibiotics, a wider range of concentrations and compounds (chloramphenicol, trimethoprim, statins) was tested against this strain. N. viennensis EN76 was inhibited by trimethoprim, but not by chloramphenicol, and growth recovered within days in the presence of simvastatin, suggesting either degradation of, or spontaneous resistance against, this compound. This study highlights the physiological differences between different genera of AOA and has identified new candidate antibiotics for selective enrichment and the development of selectable markers for genetic systems in AOA.

Thaumarchaeota from deep-sea methane seeps provide novel insights into their evolutionary history and ecological implications

BACKGROUND

Ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) of the phylum Thaumarchaeota mediate the rate-limiting step of nitrification and remove the ammonia that inhibits the aerobic metabolism of methanotrophs. However, the AOA that inhabit deep-sea methane-seep surface sediments (DMS) are rarely studied. Here, we used global DMS metagenomics and metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) to investigate the metabolic activity, evolutionary history, and ecological contributions of AOA. Expression of AOA-specific ammonia-oxidizing gene (amoA) was examined in the sediments collected from the South China Sea (SCS) to identify their active ammonia metabolism in the DMS.

RESULTS

Our analysis indicated that AOA contribute > 75% to the composition of ammonia-utilization genes within the surface layers (above 30 cm) of global DMS. The AOA-specific ammonia-oxidizing gene was actively expressed in the DMS collected from the SCS. Phylogenomic analysis of medium-/high-quality MAGs from 18 DMS-AOA indicated that they evolved from ancestors in the barren deep-sea sediment and then expanded from the DMS to shallow water forming an amoA-NP-gamma clade-affiliated lineage. Molecular dating suggests that the DMS-AOA origination coincided with the Neoproterozoic oxidation event (NOE), which occurred ~ 800 million years ago (mya), and their expansion to shallow water coincided with the Sturtian glaciation (~ 713 mya). Comparative genomic analysis suggests that DMS-AOA exhibit higher requirement of carbon source for protein synthesis with enhanced genomic capability for osmotic regulation, motility, chemotaxis, and utilization of exogenous organic compounds, suggesting it could be more heterotrophic compared with other lineages.

CONCLUSION

Our findings provide new insights into the evolutionary history of AOA within the Thaumarchaeota, highlighting their critical roles in nitrogen cycling in the global DMS ecosystems. Video Abstract.

Sudden sulfamethoxazole shock leads to nitrite accumulation in microalgae-nitrifying bacteria consortia: Physiological responses and light regulating strategy

Antibiotic shock may potentially impact the performance of promising microalgae-nitrifying bacteria consortia (MNBC) processes. This study investigated physiological behaviors of MNBC under sulfamethoxazole (SMX) shock (mg/L level) and verified a light regulating strategy for improving process performance. Results showed that SMX shock did not affect ammonium removal but caused nitrite accumulation, resulting from combined effects of excessive reactive oxidative species (ROS) production, inhibited microalgal photosynthetic activity, upregulated expressions of amoA and hao, and downregulated expression of nxrA. Moreover, high ammonium concentration aggravated nitrite accumulation and reduced ammonium removal owing to significantly reduced dissolved oxygen (DO). Increasing light intensity enhanced microalgal photo-oxygenation and promoted expressions of all nitrification-related genes, thus improving ammonium removal and alleviating nitrite accumulation. A central composite design coupled with response surface methodology (CCD-RSM) further demonstrated the negative impacts of SMX shock and high ammonium on MNBC and the effectiveness of the light regulation in maintaining stable process performance. This study provides theoretical basis for physiological responses and regulatory strategy of the MNBC process facing short-term antibiotic shock.

Nitrogen and sulfur cycling and their coupling mechanisms in eutrophic lake sediment microbiomes

Microorganisms play important roles in the biogeochemical cycles of lake sediment. However, the integrated metabolic mechanisms governing nitrogen (N) and sulfur (S) cycling in eutrophic lakes remain poorly understood. Here, metagenomic analysis of field and bioreactor enriched sediment samples from a typical eutrophic lake were applied to elucidate the metabolic coupling of N and S cycling. Our results showed significant diverse genes involved in the pathways of dissimilatory sulfur metabolism, denitrification and dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA). The N and S associated functional genes and microbial groups generally showed significant correlation with the concentrations of NH4+, NO2- and SO42, while with relatively low effects from other environmental factors. The gene-based co-occurrence network indicated clear cooperative interactions between N and S cycling in the sediment. Additionally, our analysis identified key metabolic processes, including the coupled dissimilatory sulfur oxidation (DSO) and DNRA as well as the association of thiosulfate oxidation complex (SOX systems) with denitrification pathway. However, the enriched N removal microorganisms in the bioreactor ecosystem demonstrated an additional electron donor, incorporating both the SOX systems and DSO processes. Metagenome-assembled genomes-based ecological model indicated that carbohydrate metabolism is the key linking factor for the coupling of N and S cycling. Our findings uncover the coupling mechanisms of microbial N and S metabolism, involving both inorganic and organic respiration pathways in lake sediment. This study will enhance our understanding of coupled biogeochemical cycles in lake ecosystems.

Wastewater treatment from a science faculty during the COVID-19 pandemic by using ammonium-oxidising and heterotrophic bacteria

During and after the pandemic caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus, the use of personal care products and disinfectants increased in universities worldwide. Among these, quaternary ammonium-based products stand out; these compounds and their intermediates caused substantial changes in the chemical composition of the wastewater produced by these institutions. For this reason, improvements and environmentally sustainable biological alternatives were introduced in the existing treatment systems so that these institutions could continue their research and teaching activities. For this reason, the objective of this study was to develop an improved culture medium to cultivate ammonium oxidising bacteria (AOB) to increase the biomass and use them in the treatment of wastewater produced in a faculty of sciences in Bogotá, D.C., Colombia. A Plackett Burman Experimental Design (PBED) and growth curves served for oligotrophic culture medium, and production conditions improved for the AOB. Finally, these bacteria were used with total heterotrophic bacteria (THB) for wastewater treatment in a pilot plant. Modification of base ammonium broth and culture conditions (6607 mg L-1 of (NH4)2SO4, 84 mg L-1 CaCO3, 40 mg L-1 MgSO4·7H2O, 40 mg L-1 CaCl2·2H2O and 200 mg L-1 KH2PO4, 10% (w/v) inoculum, no copper addition, pH 7.0 ± 0.2, 200 r.p.m., 30 days) favoured the growth of Nitrosomonas europea, Nitrosococcus oceani, and Nitrosospira multiformis with values of 8.23 ± 1.9, 7.56 ± 0.7 and 4.2 ± 0.4 Log10 CFU mL-1, respectively. NO2- production was 0.396 ± 0.0264, 0.247 ± 0.013 and 0.185 ± 0.003 mg L-1 for Nitrosomonas europea, Nitrosococcus oceani and Nitrosospira multiformis. After the 5-day wastewater treatment (WW) by co-inoculating the three studied bacteria in the wastewater (with their self-microorganisms), the concentrations of AOB and THB were 5.92 and 9.3 Log10 CFU mL-1, respectively. These values were related to the oxidative decrease of Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), (39.5 mg L-1), Ammonium ion (NH4+), (6.5 mg L-1) Nitrite (NO2-), (2.0 mg L-1) and Nitrate (NO3-), (1.5 mg L-1), respectively in the five days of treatment. It was concluded, with the improvement of a culture medium and production conditions for three AOB through biotechnological strategies at the laboratory scale, being a promising alternative to bio-augment of the biomass of the studied bacteria under controlled conditions that allow the aerobic removal of COD and nitrogen cycle intermediates present in the studied wastewater.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13205-024-03961-4.

Ultrastructural insights into cellular organization, energy storage and ribosomal dynamics of an ammonia-oxidizing archaeon from oligotrophic oceans

Introduction

Nitrososphaeria, formerly known as Thaumarchaeota, constitute a diverse and widespread group of ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) inhabiting ubiquitously in marine and terrestrial environments, playing a pivotal role in global nitrogen cycling. Despite their importance in Earth's ecosystems, the cellular organization of AOA remains largely unexplored, leading to a significant unanswered question of how the machinery of these organisms underpins metabolic functions.

Methods

In this study, we combined spherical-chromatic-aberration-corrected cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET), scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) to unveil the cellular organization and elemental composition of Nitrosopumilus maritimus SCM1, a representative member of marine Nitrososphaeria.

Results and Discussion

Our tomograms show the native ultrastructural morphology of SCM1 and one to several dense storage granules in the cytoplasm. STEM-EDS analysis identifies two types of storage granules: one type is possibly composed of polyphosphate and the other polyhydroxyalkanoate. With precise measurements using cryo-ET, we observed low quantity and density of ribosomes in SCM1 cells, which are in alignment with the documented slow growth of AOA in laboratory cultures. Collectively, these findings provide visual evidence supporting the resilience of AOA in the vast oligotrophic marine environment.

Archaea: current and potential biotechnological applications

Archaea are microorganisms with great ability to colonize some of the most inhospitable environments in nature, managing to survive in places with extreme characteristics for most microorganisms. Its proteins and enzymes are stable and can act under extreme conditions in which other proteins and enzymes would degrade. These attributes make them ideal candidates for use in a wide range of biotechnological applications. This review describes the most important applications, both current and potential, that archaea present in Biotechnology, classifying them according to the sector to which the application is directed. It also analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of its use.

Delineation of the complex microbial nitrogen-transformation network in an anammox-driven full-scale wastewater treatment plant

Microbial-driven nitrogen removal is a crucial step in modern full-scale wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), and the complexity of nitrogen transformation is integral to the various wastewater treatment processes. A full understanding of the overall nitrogen cycling networks in WWTPs is therefore a prerequisite for the further enhancement and optimization of wastewater treatment processes. In this study, metagenomics and metatranscriptomics were used to elucidate the microbial nitrogen removal processes in an ammonium-enriched full-scale WWTP, which was configured as an anaerobic-anoxic-anaerobic-oxic system for efficient nitrogen removal (99.63%) on a duck breeding farm. A typical simultaneous nitrification-anammox-denitrification (SNAD) process was established in each tank of this WWTP. Ammonia was oxidized by ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB), archaea (AOA), and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB), and the produced nitrite and nitrate were further reduced to dinitrogen gas (N₂) by anammox and denitrifying bacteria. Visible red anammox biofilms were formed successfully on the sponge carriers submerged in the anoxic tank, and the nitrogen removal rate by anammox reaction was 4.85 times higher than that by denitrification based on ¹⁵N isotope labeling and analysis. This supports the significant accumulation of anammox bacteria on the carriers responsible for efficient nitrogen removal. Two distinct anammox bacteria, named "Ca. Brocadia sp. PF01" and "Ca. Jettenia sp. PF02", were identified from the biofilm in this investigation. By recovering their genomic features and their metabolic capabilities, our results indicate that the highly active core anammox process found in PF01, suggests extending its niche within the plant. With the possible contribution of the dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) reaction, enriching PF02 within the biofilm may also be warranted. Collectively, this study highlights the effective design strategies of a full-scale WWTP with enrichment of anammox bacteria on the carrier materials for nitrogen removal and therefore the biochemical reaction mechanisms of the contributing members.

A new strategy for the enrichment of ammonia-oxidizing archaea in wastewater treatment systems: The positive role of quorum-sensing signaling molecules

Ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) play an important role in natural nitrogen cycle, but are difficult to be enriched in wastewater treatment systems. In this experiment, under ambient temperature and high dissolved oxygen, different types of acyl-homoserine lactones (C₆-HSL, C₈-HSL, C₁₀-HSL, C₁₄-HSL and 3-oxo-C₁₄-HSL) were added to five wastewater nitrification systems to achieve AOA enrichment. Results showed that AOA couldn't be detected in the blank group without the addition of signaling molecules, while the AOA could be detected in all the reactors with the addition. The enrichment effect of AOA was not obvious with added 100 or 200 nmol/L signaling molecules, while the enrichment effect was both obvious with added C₈-HSL of 400 nmol/L and C₁₀-HSL of 800 nmol/L. And relative abundance of AOA increased from undetected in the control group to 1.10 % and 0.96 %, respectively. The exogenous signaling molecules may provide new view for AOA enrichment in wastewater treatment systems.

Selection, Identification and Functional Performance of Ammonia-Degrading Microbial Communities from an Activated Sludge for Landfill Leachate Treatment

The increasing amounts of municipal solid waste and their management in landfills caused an increase in the production of leachate, a liquid formed by the percolation of rainwater through the waste. Leachate creates serious problems to municipal wastewater treatment plants; indeed, its high levels of ammonia are toxic for bacterial cells and drastically reduce the biological removal of nitrogen by activated sludge. In the present work, we studied, using a metagenomic approach based on next-generation sequencing (NGS), the microbial composition of sludge in the municipal wastewater treatment plant of Porto Sant'Elpidio (Italy). Through activated sludge enrichment experiments based on the Repetitive Re-Inoculum Assay, we were able to select and identify a minimal bacterial community capable of degrading high concentrations of ammonium (NH₄⁺-N ≅ 350 mg/L) present in a leachate-based medium. The analysis of NGS data suggests that seven families of bacteria (Alcaligenaceae, Nitrosomonadaceae, Caulobacteraceae, Xanthomonadaceae, Rhodanobacteraceae, Comamonadaceae and Chitinophagaceae) are mainly responsible for ammonia oxidation. Furthermore, we isolated from the enriched sludge three genera (Klebsiella sp., Castellaniella sp. and Acinetobacter sp.) capable of heterotrophic nitrification coupled with aerobic denitrification. These bacteria released a trace amount of both nitrite and nitrate possibly transforming ammonia into gaseous nitrogen. Our findings represent the starting point to produce an optimized microorganisms's mixture for the biological removal of ammonia contained in leachate.

Integrating conventional nitrogen removal with anammox in wastewater treatment systems: Microbial metabolism, sustainability and challenges

The various forms of nitrogen (N), including ammonium (NH₄⁺), nitrite (NO₂^-), and nitrate (NO₃^-), present in wastewaters can create critical biotic stress and can lead to hazardous phenomena that cause imbalances in biological diversity. Thus, biological nitrogen removal (BNR) from wastewaters is considered to be imperatively urgent. Therefore, anammox-based systems, i.e. partial nitrification and anaerobic ammonium oxidation (PN/anammox) and partial denitrification and anammox (PD/anammox) have been universally acknowledged to consider as alternatives, promising and cost-effective technologies for sustainable N removal from wastewaters compared to nitrification-denitrification processes. This review comprehensively presents and discusses the latest advances in BNR technologies, including traditional nitrification-denitrification and anammox-based systems. To a deep understanding of a better-controlled combining anammox with traditional processes, the microbial community diversity and metabolism, as well as, biomass morphological characteristics were clearly reviewed in the anammox-based systems. Explaining simultaneous microbial competition and control of crucial operation parameters in single-stage anammox-based processes in terms of optimization and economic benefits makes this contribution a different vision from available review papers. The most important sustainability indicators, including global warming potential (GWP), carbon footprint (CF) and energy behaviours were explored to evaluate the sustainability of BNR processes in wastewater treatment. Additionally, the challenges and solutions for BNR processes are extensively discussed. In summary, this review helps facilitate a critical understanding of N removal technologies. It is confirmed that sustainability and saving energy would be achieved by anammox-based systems, thereby could be encouraged future outcomes for a sustainable N removal economy.

Comammox bacteria predominate among ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms in municipal but not in refinery wastewater treatment plants

Comammox bacteria have proved to be one dominant and significant ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms (AOMs) in municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), however, it still remains unknown about their abundance and diversity in industrial WWTPs. In this study, activated sludge samples from 8 municipal WWTPs and 6 industrial WWTPs treating refinery wastewater were taken and analyzed using qPCR and amoA gene sequencing. Intriguingly, quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) results suggested that comammox bacteria had a higher numerical abundance compared with ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) in municipal WWTPs but did not in refinery WWTPs. Moreover, comammox amoA sequences obtained from high-throughput sequencing were retrieved from all the 8 municipal samples but only 1 industrial sample. Further phylogenetic analysis revealed that N. nitrosa cluster accounted for as high as 79.56% of the total comammox affiliated sequences, which was the most numerically abundant comammox species in municipal WWTPs. This study provided new insights into the abundance and diversity of comammox bacteria in the biological nitrification process in municipal and refinery wastewater treatment systems.

Influence of Leguminous Cover Crops on Soil Chemical and Biological Properties in a No-Till Tropical Fruit Orchard

South Florida’s agricultural soils are traditionally low in organic matter (OM) and high in carbonate rock fragments. These calcareous soils are inherently nutrient-poor and require management for successful crop production. Sunn hemp (SH, Crotalaria juncea) and velvet bean (VB, Mucuna pruriens) are highly productive leguminous cover crops (CCs) that have shown potential to add large quantities of dry biomass to nutrient- and organic-matter-limited systems. This study focuses on intercropping these two CCs with young carambola (Averrhoa carambola) trees. The objective was to test the effectiveness of green manure crops in providing nutrients and supplementing traditional fertilizer regimes with a sustainable soil-building option. Typically, poultry manure (PM) is the standard fertilizer used in organic or sustainable production in the study area. As such, PM treatments and fallow were included for comparison. The treatments were fallow control (F), fallow with PM (FM), sunn hemp (SH), SH with PM (SHM), velvet bean (VB), and VB with PM (VBM). Sunn hemp and VB were grown for two summer growing seasons. At the end of each 90-day growing period, the CCs were terminated and left on the soil surface to decompose in a no-till fashion. The results suggest that SH treatments produced the greatest amount of dry biomass material ranging from 48 to 71% higher than VB over two growing seasons. As a result, SH CCs also accumulated significantly higher amounts of total carbon (TC) and total nitrogen (TN) within their dry biomass that was added to the soil. Sunn hemp, SHM, and FM treatments showed the greatest accumulation of soil OM, TC, and TN. Soil inorganic N (NH₄⁺ + NO3− + NO2) fluctuated throughout the experiment. Our results indicate that generally, VB-treated soils had their highest available N around 2 months post termination, while SH-treated soils exhibited significantly higher N values at CC termination time. Sunn hemp + PM (SHM)treatments had highest soil N availability around 4 months after CC termination. Soil enzyme activity results indicate that at CC termination, SHM exhibited the highest levels of β-1-4- glucosidase and β-N-acetylglucosaminidase among all treatments. Overall, SH, SHM, and FM treatments showed the greatest potential for supplementing soil nutrients and organic matter in a no-till fruit production setting.

Granular indigenous microalgal-bacterial consortium for wastewater treatment: Establishment strategy, functional microorganism, nutrient removal, and influencing factor

Granular indigenous microalgal-bacterial consortium (G-IMBC) system integrates the advantages of the MBC and granular activated sludge technologies, also with superior microalgal wastewater adaptation capacity. In this review, the concept of IMBC was firstly described, followed by its establishment and acclimation strategies. Characteristics and advantages of G-IMBC system compared to other IMBC systems (i.e., attached and floc IMBC systems) were then introduced. Moreover, the involved functional microorganisms and their interactions, as well as nutrient removal mechanisms were systematically and critically reviewed. Finally, the influencing factors including wastewater characteristics and operation factors were discussed. This study aims to provide a comprehensive up-to-date summary of the G-IMBC system for sustainable wastewater treatment.

Review of Nitrification Monitoring and Control Strategies in Drinking Water System

Nitrification is a major challenge in chloraminated drinking water systems, resulting in undesirable loss of disinfectant residual. Consequently, heterotrophic bacteria growth is increased, which adversely affects the water quality, causing taste, odour, and health issues. Regular monitoring of various water quality parameters at susceptible areas of the water distribution system (WDS) helps to detect nitrification at an earlier stage and allows sufficient time to take corrective actions to control it. Strategies to monitor nitrification in a WDS require conducting various microbiological tests or assessing surrogate parameters that are affected by microbiological activities. Additionally, microbial decay factor (Fm) is used by water utilities to monitor the status of nitrification. In contrast, approaches to manage nitrification in a WDS include controlling various factors that affect monochloramine decay rate and ammonium substrate availability, and that can inhibit nitrification. However, some of these control strategies may increase the regulated disinfection-by-products level, which may be a potential health concern. In this paper, various strategies to monitor and control nitrification in a WDS are critically examined. The key findings are: (i) the applicability of some methods require further validation using real WDS, as the original studies were conducted on laboratory or pilot systems; (ii) there is no linkage/formula found to relate the surrogate parameters to the concentration of nitrifying bacteria, which possibly improve nitrification monitoring performance; (iii) improved methods/monitoring tools are required to detect nitrification at an earlier stage; (iv) further studies are required to understand the effect of soluble microbial products on the change of surrogate parameters. Based on the current review, we recommend that the successful outcome using many of these methods is often site-specific, hence, water utilities should decide based on their regular experiences when considering economic and sustainability aspects.

Nitrate Water Contamination from Industrial Activities and Complete Denitrification as a Remediation Option

Freshwater is a scarce resource that continues to be at high risk of pollution from anthropogenic activities, requiring remediation in such cases for its continuous use. The agricultural and mining industries extensively use water and nitrogen (N)-dependent products, mainly in fertilizers and explosives, respectively, with their excess accumulating in different water bodies. Although removal of NO3 from water and soil through the application of chemical, physical, and biological methods has been studied globally, these methods seldom yield N2 gas as a desired byproduct for nitrogen cycling. These methods predominantly cause secondary contamination with deposits of chemical waste such as slurry brine, nitrite (NO2), ammonia (NH3), and nitrous oxide (N2O), which are also harmful and fastidious to remove. This review focuses on complete denitrification facilitated by bacteria as a remedial option aimed at producing nitrogen gas as a terminal byproduct. Synergistic interaction of different nitrogen metabolisms from different bacteria is highlighted, with detailed attention to the optimization of their enzymatic activities. A biotechnological approach to mitigating industrial NO3 contamination using indigenous bacteria from wastewater is proposed, holding the prospect of optimizing to the point of complete denitrification. The approach was reviewed and found to be durable, sustainable, cost effective, and environmentally friendly, as opposed to current chemical and physical water remediation technologies.

Changes in Ammonia-Oxidizing Archaea and Bacterial Communities and Soil Nitrogen Dynamics in Response to Long-Term Nitrogen Fertilization

Ammonia oxidizing archaea (AOA) and bacteria (AOB) mediate a crucial step in nitrogen (N) metabolism. The effect of N fertilizer rates on AOA and AOB communities is less studied in the wheat-fallow system from semi-arid areas. Based on a 17-year wheat field experiment, we explored the effect of five N fertilizer rates (0, 52.5, 105, 157.5, and 210 kg ha^-1 yr^-1) on the AOA and AOB community composition. This study showed that the grain yield of wheat reached the maximum at 105 kg N ha^-1 (49% higher than control), and no further significant increase was observed at higher N rates. With the increase of N, AOA abundance decreased in a regular trend from 4.88 × 10⁷ to 1.05 × 10⁷ copies g^-1 dry soil, while AOB abundance increased from 3.63 × 10⁷ up to a maximum of 8.24 × 10⁷ copies g^-1 dry soil with the N105 treatment (105 kg N ha^-1 yr^-1). Application rates of N fertilizer had a more significant impact on the AOB diversity than on AOA diversity, and the highest AOB diversity was found under the N105 treatment in this weak alkaline soil. The predominant phyla of AOA and AOB were Thaumarchaeota and Proteobacteria, respectively, and higher N treatment (N210) resulted in a significant decrease in the relative abundance of genus Nitrosospira. In addition, AOA and AOB communities were significantly associated with grain yield of wheat, soil potential nitrification activity (PNA), and some soil physicochemical parameters such as pH, NH₄-N, and NO₃-N. Among them, soil moisture was the most influential edaphic factor for structuring the AOA community and NH₄-N for the AOB community. Overall, 105 kg N ha^-1 yr^-1 was optimum for the AOB community and wheat yield in the semi-arid area.

Efficacies of Nitrogen Removal and Comparisons of Microbial Communities in Full-Scale (Pre-Anoxic Systems) Municipal Water Resource Recovery Facilities at Low and High COD:TN Ratios

At a low COD:TN ratio (≤5) in influent, maintaining a longer HRT (≥9 h) and longer SRT (≥30 d) are suggested to improve higher N removal efficiency in case of operation at low DO (Dissolved oxygen) level (0.9 ± 0.2 mg-O2/L). However, in case of operation at high DO level (4.0 ± 0.5 mg-O2/L), short HRT (1 h) and typical SRT (17 d) make it possible to achieve nitrogen removal. On the other hand, at a high COD:TN ratio (≥8.4), a typical HRT (9–15 h), SRT (12–19 d), and DO level (1.3–2.6 mg-O2/L) would be applied. Microbial distribution analysis showed an abundance of AOA (Ammonia-oxidizing archaea) under conditions of low DO (≤0.9 mg-O2/L). Nitrosomonas sp. are mostly found in the all investigated water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs). Nitrosospira sp. are only found under operating conditions of longer SRT for WRRFs with a low COD:TN ratio. In comparison between abundances of Nitrobacter sp. and Nitrospira sp., abundances of Nitrobacter sp. are proportional to low DO concentration rather than abundance of Nitrospira sp. A predominance of nosZ-type denitrifiers were found at low DO level. Abundance of denitrifiers by using nirS genes showed an over-abundance of denitrifiers by using nirK genes at low and high COD:TN ratios.

Biochemistry shapes growth kinetics of nitrifiers and defines their activity under specific environmental conditions

Is it possible to find trends between the parameters that define microbial growth to help us explain the vast microbial diversity? Through an extensive database of kinetic parameters of nitrifiers, we analyzed if the dominance of specific populations of nitrifiers could be predicted and explained. We concluded that, in general, higher growth yield (Y_XS) and ammonia affinity (a⁰_NH3) and lower growth rate (µ_max) are observed for ammonia‐oxidizing archaea (AOA) than bacteria (AOB), which would explain their considered dominance in oligotrophic environments. However, comammox (CMX), with the maximum energy harvest per mole of ammonia, and some AOB, have higher a⁰_NH3 and lower µ_max than some AOA. Although we were able to correlate the presence of specific terminal oxidases with observed oxygen affinities (a⁰_O2) for nitrite‐oxidizing bacteria (NOB), that correlation was not observed for AOB. Moreover, the presumed dominance of AOB over NOB in O₂‐limiting environments is discussed. Additionally, lower statistical variance of a⁰_O2 values than for ammonia and nitrite affinities was observed, suggesting nitrogen limitation as a stronger selective pressure. Overall, specific growth strategies within nitrifying groups were not identified through the reported kinetic parameters, which might suggest that mostly, fundamental differences in biochemistry are responsible for underlying kinetic parameters.

Improving Nitrogen Use Efficiency in Aerobic Rice Based on Insights Into the Ecophysiology of Archaeal and Bacterial Ammonia Oxidizers

The abundance and structural composition of nitrogen (N) transformation-related microbial communities under certain environmental conditions provide sufficient information about N cycle under different soil conditions. This study aims to explore the major challenge of low N use efficiency (NUE) and N dynamics in aerobic rice systems and reveal the agronomic-adjustive measures to increase NUE through insights into the ecophysiology of ammonia oxidizers. Water-saving practices, like alternate wetting and drying (AWD), dry direct seeded rice (DDSR), wet direct seeding, and saturated soil culture (SSC), have been evaluated in lowland rice; however, only few studies have been conducted on N dynamics in aerobic rice systems. Biological ammonia oxidation is majorly conducted by two types of microorganisms, ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) and ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB). This review focuses on how diversified are ammonia oxidizers (AOA and AOB), whose factors affect their activities and abundance under different soil conditions. It summarizes findings on pathways of N cycle, rationalize recent research on ammonia oxidizers in N-cycle, and thereby suggests adjustive agronomic measures to reduce N losses. This review also suggests that variations in soil properties significantly impact the structural composition and abundance of ammonia oxidizers. Nitrification inhibitors (NIs) especially nitrapyrin, reduce the nitrification rate and inhibit the abundance of bacterial amoA without impacting archaeal amoA. In contrast, some NIs confine the hydrolysis of synthetic N and, therefore, keep low NH₄ ⁺-N concentrations that exhibit no or very slight impact on ammonia oxidizers. Variations in soil properties are more influential in the community structure and abundance of ammonia oxidizers than application of synthetic N fertilizers and NIs. Biological nitrification inhibitors (BNIs) are natural bioactive compounds released from roots of certain plant species, such as sorghum, and could be commercialized to suppress the capacity of nitrifying soil microbes. Mixed application of synthetic and organic N fertilizers enhances NUE and plant N-uptake by reducing ammonia N losses. High salt concentration promotes community abundance while limiting the diversity of AOB and vice versa for AOA, whereas AOA have lower rate for potential nitrification than AOB, and denitrification accounts for higher N₂ production. Archaeal abundance, diversity, and structural composition change along an elevation gradient and mainly depend on various soil factors, such as soil saturation, availability of NH₄ ⁺, and organic matter contents. Microbial abundance and structural analyses revealed that the structural composition of AOA was not highly responsive to changes in soil conditions or N amendment. Further studies are suggested to cultivate AOA and AOB in controlled-environment experiments to understand the mechanisms of AOA and AOB under different conditions. Together, this evaluation will better facilitate the projections and interpretations of ammonia oxidizer community structural composition with provision of a strong basis to establish robust testable hypotheses on the competitiveness between AOB and AOA. Moreover, after this evaluation, managing soils agronomically for potential utilization of metabolic functions of ammonia oxidizers would be easier.

Bacterial Community Structure and Dynamic Changes in Different Functional Areas of a Piggery Wastewater Treatment System

Chemicals of emerging concern (CEC) in pig farm breeding wastewater, such as antibiotics, will soon pose a serious threat to public health. It is therefore essential to consider improving the treatment efficiency of piggery wastewater in terms of microorganisms. In order to optimize the overall piggery wastewater treatment system from the perspective of the bacterial community structure and its response to environmental factors, five samples were randomly taken from each area of a piggery’s wastewater treatment system using a random sampling method. The bacterial communities’ composition and their correlation with wastewater quality were then analyzed using Illumina MiSeq high-throughput sequencing. The results showed that the bacterial community composition of each treatment unit was similar. However, differences in abundance were significant, and the bacterial community structure gradually changed with the process. Proteobacteria showed more adaptability to an anaerobic environment than Firmicutes, and the abundance of Tissierella in anaerobic zones was low. The abundance of Clostridial (39.02%) and Bacteroides (20.6%) in the inlet was significantly higher than it was in the aerobic zone and the anoxic zone (p < 0.05). Rhodocyclaceae is a key functional microbial group in a wastewater treatment system, and it is a dominant microbial group in activated sludge. Redundancy analysis (RDA) showed that chemical oxygen demand (COD) had the greatest impact on bacterial community structure. Total phosphorus (TP), total nitrogen (TN), PH and COD contents were significantly negatively correlated with Sphingobacteriia, Betaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria, and significantly positively correlated with Bacteroidia and Clostridia. These results offer basic data and theoretical support for optimizing livestock wastewater treatment systems using bacterial community structures.

Nitratation in pilot-scale bioreactors fed with effluent from a submerged biological aerated filter used in the treatment of dog wastewater

Nitrification is a biochemical process that allows oxidation of ammonium ion to nitrite, and nitrite to nitrate in a system. Aerobic processes, such as use of submerged biological aerated filter (SBAF), enable nitrification. However, some variables that are entirely unavailable or not available at the required concentration range may hamper the process. In this study, nitratation under high dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations was evaluated in laboratory-scale bioreactors containing 10% inoculum (0.5 kg kg^-1) fed with affluent from a SBAF that receive the sewage generated from washing the bays of a dog kennel. The following variables were monitored over time: ammoniacal nitrogen (12.44-29.62 mg L^-1), nitrite (0.28-0.54 mg L^-1), nitrate (1.75-3.55 mg L^-1), pH (8.11 ± 0.62), temperature (21.61 ± 1.24°C) and DO (9.69 ± 0.36 mg L^-1). Quantification of nitrifying bacteria by the multiple tube technique showed the value of 1.4 × 10¹² MPN mL^-1for ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and 9.2 × 10¹⁴ MPN mL^-1 for nitrite-oxidizing bacteria. These values were higher than those found in a synthetic medium, which can be explained by the greater availability of ammonium and nitrite in the effluent. By the extraction of genomic DNA, and PCR, with specific primers, the presence of the AmoA (Ammonia monooxygenase) gene for AOB and of the Nitrobacter was detected in the bioreactor samples. By PCR-DGGE, the sequenced bands showed high similarity with denitrifying bacteria, such as Pseudomonas, Limnobacter, Thauera, Rhodococcus, and Thiobacillus. Thus, the saturation of dissolved oxygen in the system resulted in improvement in the nitratation step and allowed detection of bacterial genera involved in the process.

Two-Stage Anaerobic Codigestion of Crude Glycerol and Micro-Algal Biomass for Biohydrogen and Methane Production by Anaerobic Sludge Consortium

Optimization of factors affecting biohydrogen production from the codigestion of crude glycerol and microalgal biomass by anaerobic sludge consortium was conducted. The experiments were designed by a response surface methodology with central composite design. The factors affecting the production of hydrogen were the concentrations of crude glycerol, microalgal biomass, and inoculum. The maximum hydrogen production (655.1 mL-H2/L) was achieved with 13.83 g/L crude glycerol, 23.1 g-VS/L microalgal biomass, and 10.3% (v/v) inoculum. The hydrogenic effluents obtained under low, high, and optimal conditions were further used as substrates for methane production. Methane production rates and methane yield of 868.7 mL-CH4/L and 2.95 mL-CH4/L-h were attained with the effluent produced under optimum conditions. The use of crude glycerol and microalgal biomass as cosubstrates had an antagonistic effect on biohydrogen production and a synergistic effect on methane fermentation. The two-stage process provided a more attractive solution, with a total energy of 1.27 kJ/g-VSadded, than the one-stage process.

Recent advancements in the biological treatment of high strength ammonia wastewater

The estimated global population growth of 81 million people per year, combined with increased rates of urbanization and associated industrial processes, result in volumes of high strength ammonia wastewater that cannot be treated in a cost-effective or sustainable manner using the floc-based conventional activated sludge approach of nitrification and denitrification. Biofilm and aerobic granular sludge technologies have shown promise to significantly improve the performance of biological nitrogen removal systems treating high strength wastewater. This is partly due to enhanced biomass retention and their ability to sustain diverse microbial populations with juxtaposing growth requirements. Recent research has also demonstrated the value of hybrid systems with heterogeneous bioaggregates to mitigate biofilm and granule instability during long-term operation. In the context of high strength ammonia wastewater treatment, conventional nitrification-denitrification is hampered by high energy costs and greenhouse gas emissions. Anammox-based processes such as partial nitritation-anammox and partial denitrification-anammox represent more cost-effective and sustainable methods of removing reactive nitrogen from wastewater. There is also growing interest in the use of photosynthetic bacteria for ammonia recovery from high strength waste streams, such that nitrogen can be captured and concentrated in its reactive form and recycled into high value products. The purpose of this review is to explore recent advancements and emerging approaches related to high strength ammonia wastewater treatment.

Long-Term Low Dissolved Oxygen Operation Decreases N2O Emissions in the Activated Sludge Process

Nitrous oxide (N₂O) is an important greenhouse gas and a dominant ozone-depleting substance. Nitrification in the activated sludge process (ASP) is an important N₂O emission source. This study demonstrated that a short-term low dissolved oxygen (DO) increased the N₂O emissions by six times, while long-term low DO operation decreased the N₂O emissions by 54% (P < 0.01). Under long-term low DO, the ammonia oxidizer abundance in the ASP increased significantly, and thus, complete nitrification was recovered and no NH₃ or nitrite accumulated. Moreover, long-term low DO decreased the abundance of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) by 28%, while increased the abundance of ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) by 507%, mainly due to their higher oxygen affinity. As a result, AOA outnumbered AOB with the AOA/AOB amoA gene ratio increasing to 19.5 under long-term low DO. The efficient nitrification and decreased AOB abundance might not increase N₂O production via AOB under long-term low DO conditions. The enriched AOA could decrease the N₂O emissions because they were reported to lack canonical nitric oxide (NO) reductase genes that convert NO to N₂O. Probably because of AOA enrichment, the positive and significant (P = 0.02) correlation of N₂O emission and nitrite concentration became insignificant (P = 0.332) after 80 days of low DO operation. Therefore, ASPs can be operated with low DO and extended sludge age to synchronously reduce N₂O production and carbon dioxide emissions owing to lower aeration energy without compromising the nitrification efficiency.

Insights into the microbial diversity and structure in a full-scale municipal wastewater treatment plant with particular regard to Archaea

Due to limited description of the role and diversity of archaea in WWTPs, the aim of the study was to analyze microbial community structures and diversities with particular regard to Archaea in the samples taken from different stages of the full-scale municipal wastewater treatment plant and effluent receiving water (upstream and downstream discharge point). Our study was focused on showing how the treatment processes influenced the Eubacteria and Archaea composition. Alpha and Beta diversity were used to evaluate the microbial diversity changes in the collected samples. Proteobacteria was the largest fraction ranging from 28% to 67% with 56% relative abundance across all samples. Archaea were present in all stages of WWTP ranged from 1 to 8%. Among the Archaea, two groups of methanogens, acetoclastic (Methanosarcina, Methanosaeta) and hydrogenotrophic methanogens (Methanospirillium, Methanoculleus, Methanobrevibacter) were dominant in the technological stages. The obtained results indicate that the treated wastewater did not significantly affect eubacterial and archaeal composition in receiving water. However, differences in richness, diversity and microbial composition of Eubacteria and Archaea between the wastewater samples taken from the primary and secondary treatment were observed.

Low-Temperature Adapted Nitrifying Microbial Communities of Finnish Wastewater Treatment Systems

In this study, the microbial community of nitrifying activated sludge adapted to Finnish climate conditions was studied to clarify the microbial populations involved in low-temperature nitrification. Microbial community analysis of five full-scale wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) showed several differences compared to WWTPs from other countries with a similar climate. In particular, very low abundance of ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AOBs) (altogether ˂ 0.25% of total community) as well as typical NOBs (˂0.35%) and a high abundance of orders Cytophagales and Micrococcales was observed in all Finnish WWTPs. To shed light on the importance of autotrophic and heterotrophic nitrifying processes, laboratory studies of activated sludge were carried out with a presence of and a lack of organic carbon in wastewater at 10 ± 1 °C. Two different sludge retention times (SRTs) were compared to determine the effect of this operational parameter on low-temperature nitrogen removal. The important role of previously reported Candidatus Nitrotogaarctica for nitrite oxidizing in cold climate conditions was confirmed in both full-scale and laboratory scale results. Additionally, potential participation of Dokdonella sp. and Flexibacter sp. in nitrogen removal at low-temperatures is proposed. Operation at SRT of 100 days demonstrated more stable and efficient nitrogen removal after a sharp temperature decrease compared to 14 days SRT.

Riparian land-use systems impact soil microbial communities and nitrous oxide emissions in an agro-ecosystem

Riparian buffer systems (RBS) are considered a best management practice (BMP) in agricultural landscapes to intercept soil nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) leaching and surface runoff into aquatic ecosystems. However, these environmental benefits could be offset by increased greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, including nitrous oxide (N₂O). The main sources of N₂O in soil are linked to processes which are mediated by soil microbial communities. These microorganisms play crucial roles in N-cycling and in the reduction of nitrate to N₂, and N₂O gases. This study was conducted to determine the abundance and diversity of microbial communities and functional genes associated with N-cycling and their influence on N₂O emissions in different riparian land-use: undisturbed natural forest (UNF), rehabilitated site (RH), grass buffer (GRB), and an adjacent agricultural land (AGR). Soil was sampled concurrently with N₂O emissions on July 13, 2017. DNA was extracted and used to target key N-cycling genes for N-fixation (nifH), nitrification: (amoA), and denitrification (nirS, nirK, and nosZ) via quantitative PCR, and for high throughput sequencing of total bacterial and fungal communities. Non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) was used to examine microbial community composition and indicated significant differences in bacterial (p < 0.001) and fungal (p < 0.0085) communities between sites. Bacterial abundance differed significantly (p = 0.0005) between RBS and AGR sites with the highest populations occurring in the UNF (2.1 × 10¹⁰ copies g^-1 dry soil), and lowest in AGR (5.3 × 10⁹ copies g^-1 dry soil). However, the AGR site had the highest ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) abundance, indicating that nitrification is highest at this site. The abundance of the nosZ gene was highest in RH and GRB demonstrating the capacity for complete denitrification at these sites, lowering measured N₂O. These results suggest N-cycling microbial community dynamics differ among RBS and are influencing N₂O emissions in the sites investigated.

Nitrous oxide production from wastewater treatment: The potential as energy resource rather than potent greenhouse gas

Nitrous oxide (N₂O), produced from wastewater treatment, is a potent greenhouse gas and has become a global concern in recent years. However, N₂O has also been commonly used as a powerful oxidant for energy generation. As such, an increasing effort has been devoted to explore the energy potential of N₂O from wastewater treatment processes recently. Nevertheless, the holistic knowledge on energy recovery from nitrogen in wastewater is still lacking for facilitating its further development. Striving for sustainable wastewater treatment, this review paper aimed to give the up-to-date status on several essential aspects regarding the N₂O recovery as an energy resource rather than emission as a greenhouse gas, including energy production via N₂O decomposition, main biotic N₂O production sources, the potential bioprocesses used for N₂O recovery, and the possible N₂O harvesting strategies. We then put forward perspectives for N₂O recovery and future challenges to improve our understanding of the energy generation, microbial processes involved and harvesting approaches in order to potentially achieve sustainable wastewater treatment via N₂O recovery.

Nitrous oxide production by ammonia oxidizers: Physiological diversity, niche differentiation and potential mitigation strategies

Oxidation of ammonia to nitrite by bacteria and archaea is responsible for global emissions of nitrous oxide directly and indirectly through provision of nitrite and, after further oxidation, nitrate to denitrifiers. Their contributions to increasing N₂ O emissions are greatest in terrestrial environments, due to the dramatic and continuing increases in use of ammonia-based fertilizers, which have been driven by requirement for increased food production, but which also provide a source of energy for ammonia oxidizers (AO), leading to an imbalance in the terrestrial nitrogen cycle. Direct N₂ O production by AO results from several metabolic processes, sometimes combined with abiotic reactions. Physiological characteristics, including mechanisms for N₂ O production, vary within and between ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) and bacteria (AOB) and comammox bacteria and N₂ O yield of AOB is higher than in the other two groups. There is also strong evidence for niche differentiation between AOA and AOB with respect to environmental conditions in natural and engineered environments. In particular, AOA are favored by low soil pH and AOA and AOB are, respectively, favored by low rates of ammonium supply, equivalent to application of slow-release fertilizer, or high rates of supply, equivalent to addition of high concentrations of inorganic ammonium or urea. These differences between AOA and AOB provide the potential for better fertilization strategies that could both increase fertilizer use efficiency and reduce N₂ O emissions from agricultural soils. This article reviews research on the biochemistry, physiology and ecology of AO and discusses the consequences for AO communities subjected to different agricultural practices and the ways in which this knowledge, coupled with improved methods for characterizing communities, might lead to improved fertilizer use efficiency and mitigation of N₂ O emissions.

Role of heterotrophic aerobic denitrifying bacteria in nitrate removal from wastewater

With the increase in industrial and agricultural activities, a large amount of nitrogenous compounds are released into the environment, leading to nitrate pollution. The perilous effects of nitrate present in the environment pose a major threat to human and animal health. Bioremediation provides a cost-effective and environmental friendly method to deal with this problem. The process of aerobic denitrification can reduce nitrate compounds to harmless dinitrogen gas. This review provides a brief view of the exhaustive role played by aerobic denitrifiers for tackling nitrate pollution under different ecological niches and their dependency on various environmental parameters. It also provides an understanding of the enzymes involved in aerobic denitrification. The role of aerobic denitrification to solve the issues faced by the conventional method (aerobic nitrification-anaerobic denitrification) in treating nitrogen-polluted wastewaters is elaborated.

Methane and nitrous oxide emission from different treatment units of municipal wastewater treatment plants in Southwest Germany

We measured the atmospheric emission rates of methane (CH₄) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) in two wastewater treatment plants in Southwest Germany, which apply different treatment technologies. Dissolved gas concentrations and fluxes were measured during all processing steps as well as in the discharge receiving streams. N₂O isotopocule analysis revealed that NH₂OH oxidation during nitrification contributed 86–96% of the N₂O production in the nitrification tank, whereas microbial denitrification was the main production pathway in the denitrification tank in a conventional activated sludge (CAS) system. During wastewater treatment using a modified Ludzack-Ettinger system (MLE) with energy recovery, N₂O was predominantly produced by the NO₂^- reduction by nitrifier-denitrification process. For both systems, N₂O emissions were low, with emission factors of 0.008% and 0.001% for the MLE and the CAS system, respectively. In the effluent-receiving streams, bacterial denitrification and nitrification contributed nearly equally to N₂O production. The CH₄ emission from the MLE system was estimated as 118.1 g-C d^-1, which corresponds to an emission factor of 0.004%, and was three times lower than the emission from the CAS system with 0.01%.