Sensitizing capacity and residual allergenicity of hydrolyzed cow's milk formulae: results from a murine model

Effects of enzymatic hydrolysis on the allergenicity of natural cow milk based on a BALB/c mouse model

Cow milk allergy is one of the most prevalent food allergies worldwide, particularly in infants and children. To the best of our knowledge, minimal research exists concerning the antigenicity of cow milk (CM). This study was performed to evaluate the allergenicity of enzymatically hydrolyzed cow milk (HM) in a BALB/c mouse model. The mice were randomly divided into 5 groups (n = 12/group), which were sensitized with phosphate-buffered saline, CM, and HM (Alcalase-, or Protamex-, or Flavorzyme-treated cow milk; Novo Nordisk; AT, PT, FT, respectively), respectively, using cholera toxin as adjuvant on d 0, 7, 14, 21. On d 28, the test mice were orally challenged with phosphate-buffered saline, CM, and HM (AT, PT, or FT) alone. Anaphylactic symptoms were monitored in the mice. Antibody, cytokine, histamine, and mouse mast cell protease-1 (mMCP-1) levels were measured using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays. In addition, the numbers of T helper (Th)1 and Th2 cells, as well as the proportions of CD4⁺CD25⁺Foxp3⁺ Treg cells, in mouse spleens were detected using flow cytometry. Statistical significance was determined by one-way ANOVA. The results revealed significant differences between CM- and HM-challenged mice. Among these, the clinical scores of HM-challenged mice (AT, 1.50; PT, 2.00; FT, 1.92) were lower than those of CM-challenged mice (positive control, 2.83), but body weight and temperature of HM-challenged mice were higher than those of CM-challenged mice. In addition, significant reductions of allergen-specific IgE, IgG, histamine, and mMCP-1 were showed in HM-challenged mice, especially for histamine, ranging from 171.42 ng/mL to 214.94 ng/mL. Remarkable reductions of IL-4, IL-5, and IL-13 levels, as well as elevations of interferon-γ and IL-10 levels in the spleens of HM-challenged mice were also detected. Moreover, the number of Th2 cells decreased in the HM-challenged mice, to 2.36% (AT), 1.79% (PT), and 4.03% (FT), respectively, whereas the numbers of Th1 cells (AT, 6.30%; PT, 6.70%; FT, 6.56%) and the proportions of CD4⁺CD25⁺Foxp3⁺Tregs (AT, 8.86%; PT, 9.21%; FT, 9.16%) increased significantly. Our findings indicate that exposure to HM was sufficient to induce a shift toward a Th1 response, thereby reducing potential allergenicity. Importantly, these results will lay a theoretical foundation for the development of hypoallergenic CM products.

Partially Hydrolysed Whey Has Superior Allergy Preventive Capacity Compared to Intact Whey Regardless of Amoxicillin Administration in Brown Norway Rats

Background

It remains largely unknown how physicochemical properties of hydrolysed infant formulas influence their allergy preventive capacity, and results from clinical and animal studies comparing the preventive capacity of hydrolysed infant formula with conventional infant formula are inconclusive. Thus, the use of hydrolysed infant formula for allergy prevention in atopy-prone infants is highly debated. Furthermore, knowledge on how gut microbiota influences allergy prevention remains scarce.

Objective

To gain knowledge on (1) how physicochemical properties of hydrolysed whey products influence the allergy preventive capacity, (2) whether host microbiota disturbance influences allergy prevention, and (3) to what extent hydrolysed whey products influence gut microbiota composition.

Methods

The preventive capacity of four different ad libitum administered whey products was investigated in Brown Norway rats with either a conventional or an amoxicillin-disturbed gut microbiota. The preventive capacity of products was evaluated as the capacity to reduce whey-specific sensitisation and allergic reactions to intact whey after intraperitoneal post-immunisations with intact whey. Additionally, the direct effect of the whey products on the growth of gut bacteria derived from healthy human infant donors was evaluated by in vitro incubation.

Results

Two partially hydrolysed whey products with different physicochemical characteristics were found to be superior in preventing whey-specific sensitisation compared to intact and extensively hydrolysed whey products. Daily oral amoxicillin administration, initiated one week prior to intervention with whey products, disturbed the gut microbiota but did not impair the prevention of whey-specific sensitisation. The in vitro incubation of infant faecal samples with whey products indicated that partially hydrolysed whey products might confer a selective advantage to enterococci.

Conclusions

Our results support the use of partially hydrolysed whey products for prevention of cow’s milk allergy in atopy-predisposed infants regardless of their microbiota status. However, possible direct effects of partially hydrolysed whey products on gut microbiota composition warrants further investigation.

Design, quality, safety and efficacy of extensively hydrolyzed formula for management of cow's milk protein allergy: What are the challenges?

Cow's milk protein allergy (CMPA) is one of the most common food allergies in infancy. Clinical food allergy guidelines recommend an extensively hydrolyzed formula (EHF) as the first-line treatment in nonbreastfed infants with CMPA. Designing and commercializing EHF poses both technical and regulatory challenges. Each manufacturing step, from sourcing of raw materials to release of the final product, needs to be managed in accordance with comprehensive quality systems. To avoid cross-contamination via externally sourced ingredients, suppliers should be carefully selected based on quality requirements. Strict zoning of the manufacturing areas according to contamination risk and air flow control are effective strategies to prevent accidental allergen contamination. Furthermore, dedicated manufacturing lines for hypoallergenic products are used to prevent potential cross-contamination from other products produced on the same line. The enzymatic hydrolysis, heat treatment and ultrafiltration used are specific to each manufacturer. Consequently, EHF are a heterogenous group of products with differences in the molecular weight profile of peptides, content of residual immunogenic cow's milk allergens, and residual in-vitro allergenicity. These differences are likely to affect clinical efficacy and safety. As not all commercialized EHF products have undergone formal testing in the laboratory and clinical trials, there is a need to develop guidelines for minimum technical and regulatory requirements for EHF products, including validated assays for ongoing quality control. Clinical trials assessing new EHF products for their hypoallergenicity and ability to support normal growth remain the definitive proof of efficacy and safety in infants and young children with CMPA.

Ingestion of partially hydrolyzed whey protein suppresses epicutaneous sensitization to β-lactoglobulin in mice

BACKGROUND

Epicutaneous sensitization to food allergens can occur through defective skin barriers. However, the relationship between oral tolerance and epicutaneous sensitization remains to be elucidated. We aimed to determine whether prior oral exposure to whey proteins or their hydrolysates prevents epicutaneous sensitization and subsequent food-allergic reaction to the whey protein, β-lactoglobulin (β-LG), and investigated the underlying mechanisms.

METHODS

BALB/c mice were given whey protein concentrate (WPC), two kinds of partial whey protein hydrolysate (PWH1 or PWH2), or extensive whey protein hydrolysate (EWH) in drinking water for 21 days. The mice were then epicutaneously sensitized with β-LG on tape-stripped skin. Sensitization was assessed by basophil activation tests and by measuring the level of serum β-LG-specific antibodies and cytokines secreted from β-LG-restimulated spleen and mesenteric lymph node (MLN) cells. Development of an allergic reaction was assessed by monitoring body temperature and by measuring mast cell protease-1 level in plasma after the β-LG oral challenge. Activated T-cell population among β-LG-restimulated MLN cells was also analyzed.

RESULTS

In mice fed with WPC, PWH1, or PWH2, sensitization and the development of an allergic reaction were totally reduced. The acceleration of cytokine release from the spleen and MLN cells or T-cell activation was not evident after β-LG restimulation. In EWH-fed mice, a suppressive effect, though milder than that in WPC-, PWH1-, or PWH2-fed mice, was observed during the development of the allergic reaction.

CONCLUSIONS

Prior oral exposure to partially hydrolyzed whey protein prevents epicutaneous sensitization and subsequent allergic response to β-LG in mice.

Infant milk formulas differ regarding their allergenic activity and induction of T-cell and cytokine responses

Background

Several hydrolyzed cow's milk (CM) formulas are available for avoidance of allergic reactions in CM‐allergic children and for prevention of allergy development in high‐risk infants. Our aim was to compare CM formulas regarding the presence of immunoreactive CM components, IgE reactivity, allergenic activity, ability to induce T‐cell proliferation, and cytokine secretion.

Methods

A blinded analysis of eight CM formulas, one nonhydrolyzed, two partially hydrolyzed (PH), four extensively hydrolyzed (EH), and one amino acid formula, using biochemical techniques and specific antibody probes was conducted. IgE reactivity and allergenic activity of the formulas were tested with sera from CM‐allergic patients (n = 26) in RAST‐based assays and with rat basophils transfected with the human FcεRI, respectively. The induction of T‐cell proliferation and the secretion of cytokines in Peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) culture from CM allergic patients and nonallergic individuals were assessed.

Results

Immune‐reactive α‐lactalbumin and β‐lactoglobulin were found in the two PH formulas and casein components in one of the EH formulas. One PH formula and the EH formula containing casein components showed remaining IgE reactivity, whereas the other hydrolyzed formulas lacked IgE reactivity. Only two EH formulas and the amino acid formula did not induce T‐cell proliferation and proinflammatory cytokine release. The remaining formulas varied regarding the induction of Th2, Th1, and proinflammatory cytokines.

Conclusion

Our results show that certain CM formulas without allergenic and low proinflammatory properties can be identified and they may also explain different outcomes obtained in clinical studies using CM formulas.

Food Allergens: Is There a Correlation between Stability to Digestion and Allergenicity?

Food allergy is a major health problem in the Western countries, affecting 3-8% of the population. It has not yet been established what makes a dietary protein a food allergen. Several characteristics have been proposed to be shared by food allergens. One of these is resistance to digestion. This paper reviews data from digestibility studies on purified food allergens and evaluates the predictive value of digestibility tests on the allergenic potential. We point out that food allergens do not necessarily resist digestion. We discuss how the choice of in vitro digestibility assay condition and the method used for detection of residual intact protein as well as fragments hereof may greatly influence the outcome as well as the interpretation of results. The finding that digests from food allergens may retain allergenicity, stresses the importance of using immunological assays for evaluating the allergenic potential of food allergen digestion products. Studies assessing the allergenicity of digestion products, by either IgE-binding, elicitation or sensitizing capacity, shows that digestion may abolish, decrease, have no effect, or even increase the allergenicity of food allergens. Therefore, the predictive value of the pepsin resistance test for assessing the allergenic potential of novel proteins can be questioned.

Characterization of the Immunogenicity and Allergenicity of Two Cow's Milk Hydrolysates--A Study in Brown Norway Rats

Hypoallergenic infant formulas based on hydrolysed milk proteins are used in the diet for cow's milk allergic infants. For a preclinical evaluation of the immunogenicity and allergenicity of new protein ingredients for such hypoallergenic infant formulas as well as for the investigation of which characteristics of hydrolysates that contribute to allergenicity, in vivo models are valuable tools. In this study, we examine the immunogenicity and allergenicity of two hydrolysates in a Brown Norway (BN) rat model, using i.p. dosing, which allows for the use of small quantities. Intact BLG, hydrolysed BLG and a hydrolysed whey product suitable for use in extensively hydrolysed formulas were thoroughly characterized for protein chemical features and administered to BN rats by i.p. immunization with or without adjuvant. Sera were analysed for specific IgG and IgE for evaluation of sensitizing capacity, immunogenicity and antibody-binding capacity. For evaluation of eliciting capacity a skin test was performed. The study showed that the hydrolysates had no residual allergenicity, lacking the capacity to sensitize and elicit reactions in the BN rats. Dosing with or without adjuvant induced a large difference in immunogenicity. Only antibodies from rats sensitized to intact BLG with adjuvant were able to bind the hydrolysates, and the whey-based hydrolysate only showed immunogenicity when dosed with adjuvant. This study showed that hydrolysates can be evaluated by an i.p. animal model, but that the choice of in vitro tests used for evaluation of antibody responses may greatly influence the result as well as may the use of adjuvant.

Immunomodulatory potential of partially hydrolyzed β-lactoglobulin and large synthetic peptides

The immunomodulatory potential of fragments derived from the cow's milk allergen bovine β-lactoglobulin (BLG) was assessed in a mouse model of oral tolerance (OT) [Adel-Patient, K.; Wavrin, S.; Bernard, H.; Meziti, N.; Ah-Leung, S.; Wal, J. M. Oral tolerance and Treg cells are induced in BALB/c mice after gavage with bovine β-lactoglobulin. Allergy 2011, 66 (10), 1312-1321]. Native BLG (nBLG) and chemically denatured BLG (lacking S-S bridges, dBLG), products resulting from their hydrolysis using cyanogen bromide (CNBr) and some synthetic peptides, were produced and precisely characterized. CNBr hydrolysates correspond to pools of peptides of various sizes that are still associated by S-S bridges when derived from nBLG. nBLG, dBLG, and CNBr hydrolysate of nBLG efficiently prevented further sensitization. CNBr hydrolysate of dBLG was less efficient, suggesting that the association by S-S bridges of peptides increased their immunomodulatory potential. Conversely, synthetic peptides were inefficient even if covering 50% of the BLG sequence, demonstrating that the immunomodulatory potential requires the presence of all derived fragments of BLG and further supporting the use of partially hydrolyzed milk proteins to favor OT induction in infants with a risk of atopy.

Acute allergic skin response as a new tool to evaluate the allergenicity of whey hydrolysates in a mouse model of orally induced cow's milk allergy

Hypoallergenic milk formulae are used for cow's milk allergic infants and may be a good option for infants at risk. Clinical studies have shown that the protein source or the hydrolysis methodology used may influence the effectiveness in infants stressing the importance of adequate pre-clinical testing of hypoallergenic formulae in an in vivo model of orally induced cow's milk allergy. This study was undertaken to introduce a new read-out system to measure the residual allergenicity of whey hydrolysates on both the sensitization and challenge phase of orally induced cow's milk allergy in mice. Mice were sensitized orally to whey or a partial whey hydrolysate (pWH) to measure the residual sensitizing capacity. To predict the residual allergenicity of hydrolysates, whey allergic mice were challenged in the ear with pWH, extensive whey hydrolysate or an amino acid-based formula. An acute allergic skin response (ear swelling at 1 h), whey-specific serum antibodies, and local MCP-1 concentrations were measured. In contrast to whey, oral sensitization with pWH did not result in the induction of whey-specific antibodies, although a minor residual skin response to whey was observed after challenge. Skin exposure to whey hydrolysates showed a hydrolysation dependent reduction of the acute allergic skin response in whey allergic mice. In contrast to whey, skin exposure to pWH did not enhance tissue MCP-1 levels. The acute allergic skin response in mice orally sensitized to cow's milk proteins reveals a new pre-clinical tool which might provide information about the residual sensitizing capacity of hydrolysates supporting the discussion on the use of hypoallergenic formulae in high risk children. This mouse model might be a relevant model for the screening of new hypoallergenic formulae aimed to prevent or treat cow's milk allergy.

Gastrointestinal food allergy: new insights into pathophysiology and clinical perspectives

Adverse reactions to food that result in gastrointestinal symptoms are common in the general population; while only a minority of such individuals will have symptoms due to immunologic reactions to foods, gastrointestinal food allergies do exist in both children and adults. These immune reactions are mediated by immunoglobulin E-dependent and -independent mechanisms involving mast cells, eosinophils, and other immune cells, but the complexity of the underlying mechanisms of pathogenesis have yet to be fully defined. Knowledge of the spectrum of adverse reactions to foods that affect the digestive system, including gastrointestinal food allergy, is essential to correctly diagnose and manage the subset of patients with immunologically mediated adverse reactions to foods. Potentially fatal reactions to food necessitate careful instruction and monitoring on the part of health care workers involved in the care of individuals at risk of anaphylaxis. New methods of diagnosis and novel strategies for treatment, including immunologic modulation and the development of hypoallergenic foods, are exciting developments in the field of food allergy.

T cell recognition pattern of bovine milk alphaS1-casein and its peptides

T cell recognition patterns of CAS1_Bovin, its limited hydrolysis, oxidized, reduced/alkylated, cyanogen bromide cleavage fractions and synthetic peptides were examined. Thirteen overlapping peptides covering the intact molecule, with chain lengths varied between 17 and 20 AA, were prepared by f-moc SPPS. In addition, six CNBr-cleavage fragments were obtained and extensively purified using RP/HPLC. Likewise, chemically modified derivatives and limited pepsin hydrolysate, were performed and the specificities were confirmed. Stimulation of PBMC and TCL cultures by the intact CAS1_Bovin molecule, synthetic peptides and modified derivatives were screened by [methyl-3H] thymidine incorporations. PBMC phenotype was performed by flow cytometry and the mean CD4+/CD8+ ratio of freshly prepared PBMC was compared with the ratio following specific CAS1_Bovin stimulation. CD4+ phenotypes (TH1/, TH2 and TH0) were assigned by assay of four marker cytokines IL-4, IL-6, IL-10 and IFN-gamma. Five CNBr fragments and seven of the thirteen tested peptides were recognized by specific TCL. The most reactive epitopes of CAS1_Bovin comprised seven motifs namely: peptides Cas 1-18, Cas 16-35, Cas 67-85, Cas 91-110, Cas 136-155, Cas 152-169 and Cas 166-183. The stimulation range for the seven peptides was 1058-2383 cpm. Stimulation for the CNBr fragments were, respectively, 8670, 5808, 3324, 5465, 2255 and 321 cpm. Cytokine assay showed that CD4+ TH2 phenotype was dominant for half the number of patients, while TH1 solely or combined TH0 were represented in the other four cell culture filtrates. The T cell reactive epitopes described and their antibodies will be useful tools for methods in progress for the detection of masked casein epitopes encompassed in processed food. In conclusion, T cell recognition pattern of CAS1_Bovin was examined using extensively purified synthetic peptides and CNBr fragments. Five large and seven small peptides were clearly recognized. Peptides of chain length less than six AA were left unrecognised. CD4+ TH2 phenotype was the most dominant TCL subpopulations found in atopic patients while CD4+ TH1 was representative in the non-IgE mediated type IV hypersensitivity.

Hypoallergenic formulas: are they really hypoallergenic?

BACKGROUND

Central to the management of cow's milk allergy in infancy is the complete elimination of cow's milk protein from the infant's diet for a variable period of time. The principal part of this approach is to provide nutrition for the child by means of hypoallergenic feeding formulas. Although a number of formulas are indeed marketed as hypoallergenic, it is not known with certainty how hypoallergenic they really are. A variety of ways of testing for hypoallergenicity have been developed, including the use of in vivo and in vitro animal model systems, chemical analyses, and patient studies, which are the ultimate test.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the present report was to review the various ways of testing sensitizing capacity of infant feeding formulas for the treatment of children with cow's milk allergy.

DATA SOURCES

English language articles were selected from PubMed, as were selected abstracts that would have immediate, practical clinical implications. The review focuses on themes related to animal models, chemical analysis, and clinical testing and clinical studies of intolerance to hydrolysates.

RESULTS

Sensitizing capacity can be tested first in animal models either by in vivo or in vitro techniques. Although the information gained is valuable for preliminary evaluation, such techniques are intrinsically artificial. Second chemical analyses indicate that absence of larger peptides greater than 1,500 Da provides a critical industrial cutoff point. Third clinical effectiveness in child patients is of paramount importance.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present review demonstrate that extensively hydrolyzed formulas are usually effective, but recently intolerance to hydrolysates has been observed. However, use of amino acid-based formulas free of antigens is highly effective in such infants.