Copper supplementation has no effect on markers of DNA damage and liver function in healthy adults (FOODCUE project)

Comprehensive review on toxic heavy metals in the aquatic system: sources, identification, treatment strategies, and health risk assessment

Heavy metal pollution in water sources has become a major worldwide environmental issue, posing a threat to aquatic ecosystems and human health. The pollution of the aquatic environment is increasing as a result of industrialization, climate change, and urban development. The sources of heavy metal pollution in water include mining waste, leachates from landfills, municipal and industrial wastewater, urban runoff, and natural events such as volcanism, weathering, and rock abrasion. Heavy metal ions are toxic and potentially carcinogenic. They can also buildup in biological systems and cause bioaccumulation even at low levels of exposure, heavy metals can cause harm to organs such as the nervous system, liver and lungs, kidneys and stomach, skin, and reproductive systems. There were various approaches tried to purify water and maintain water quality. The main purpose of this article was to investigate the occurrence and fate of the dangerous contaminants (Heavy metal and metalloids) found in domestic and industrial effluents. This effluent mixes with other water streams and is used for agricultural activities and other domestic activities further complicating the issue. It also discussed conventional and non-conventional treatment methods for heavy metals from aquatic environments. Conclusively, a pollution assessment of heavy metals and a human health risk assessment of heavy metals in water resources have been explained. In addition, there have been efforts to focus on heavy metal sequestration from industrial waste streams and to create a scientific framework for reducing heavy metal discharges into the aquatic environment.

Re-evaluation of the existing health-based guidance values for copper and exposure assessment from all sources

Copper is an essential micronutrient and also a regulated product used in organic and in conventional farming pest management. Both deficiency and excessive exposure to copper can have adverse health effects. In this Scientific Opinion, the EFSA 2021 harmonised approach for establishing health-based guidance values (HBGVs) for substances that are regulated products and also nutrients was used to resolve the divergent existing HBGVs for copper. The tightly regulated homeostasis prevents toxicity manifestation in the short term, but the development of chronic copper toxicity is dependent on copper homeostasis and its tissue retention. Evidence from Wilson disease suggests that hepatic retention is indicative of potential future and possibly sudden onset of copper toxicity under conditions of continuous intake. Hence, emphasis was placed on copper retention as an early marker of potential adverse effects. The relationships between (a) chronic copper exposure and its retention in the body, particularly the liver, and (b) hepatic copper concentrations and evidence of toxicity were examined. The Scientific Committee (SC) concludes that no retention of copper is expected to occur with intake of 5 mg/day and established an Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) of 0.07 mg/kg bw. A refined dietary exposure assessment was performed, assessing contribution from dietary and non-dietary sources. Background copper levels are a significant source of copper. The contribution of copper from its use as plant protection product (PPP), food and feed additives or fertilisers is negligible. The use of copper in fertilisers or PPPs contributes to copper accumulation in soil. Infant formula and follow-on formula are important contributors to dietary exposure of copper in infants and toddlers. Contribution from non-oral sources is negligible. Dietary exposure to total copper does not exceed the HBGV in adolescents, adults, elderly and the very elderly. Neither hepatic copper retention nor adverse effects are expected to occur from the estimated copper exposure in children due to higher nutrient requirements related to growth.

Critical Review of Exposure and Effects: Implications for Setting Regulatory Health Criteria for Ingested Copper

Decades of study indicate that copper oral exposures are typically not a human health concern. Ingesting high levels of soluble copper salts can cause acute gastrointestinal symptoms and, in uncommon cases, liver toxicity in susceptible individuals with repeated exposure. This focused toxicological review evaluated the current literature since the last comprehensive reviews (2007-2010). Our review identified limitations in the existing United States and international guidance for determining an oral reference dose (RfD) for essential metals like copper. Instead, an alternative method using categorical regression analysis to develop an optimal dose that considers deficiency, toxicity, and integrates information from human and animal studies was reviewed for interpreting an oral RfD for copper. We also considered subchronic or chronic toxicity from genetic susceptibility to copper dysregulation leading to rare occurrences of liver and other organ toxicity with elevated copper exposure. Based on this approach, an oral RfD of 0.04 mg Cu/kg/day would be protective of acute or chronic toxicity in adults and children. This RfD is also protective for possible genetic susceptibility to elevated copper exposure and allows for background dietary exposures. This dose is not intended to be protective of patients with rare genetic disorders for copper sensitivity within typical nutritional intake ranges, nor is it protective for those with excessive supplement intake. Less soluble mineral forms of copper in soil have reduced bioavailability as compared with more soluble copper in water and diet, which should be considered in using this RfD for risk assessments of copper.

Antibacterial and Biocompatible Titanium-Copper Oxide Coating May Be a Potential Strategy to Reduce Periprosthetic Infection: An In Vitro Study

BACKGROUND

Periprosthetic infections are devastating for patients and more efficacious preventive strategies are needed. Surface-modified implants using antibacterial coatings represent an option to cope with this problem; however, manufacturing limitations and cytotoxicity have curbed clinical translation. Among metals with antibacterial properties, copper has shown superior in vitro antibacterial performance while maintaining an acceptable cytotoxicity profile. A thin film containing copper could prevent early biofilm formation to limit periprosthetic infections. This pilot study presents the in vitro antibacterial effect, cytotoxicity, and copper ion elution pattern of a thin film of titanium-copper oxide (TiCuO).

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

(1) Do titanium alloy (Ti6Al4V) discs coated with a thin film of TiCuO reduce Staphylococcus epidermidis biofilm and planktonic cell density compared with uncoated discs? (2) Do Ti6Al4V discs coated with a thin film of TiCuO affect normal human osteoblast viability compared with untreated cells? (3) Is copper ion concentration generated by coated discs lower than previously published copper ion concentrations that cause 50% toxicity in similar human cell lines in vitro (TC50)?

METHODS

Ninety Ti6Al4V discs (12.5 mm diameter; 1.25 mm thick) were used in this study. Seventy-two Ti6Al4V discs were coated with a thin film of either titanium oxide (TiO) or TiCuO containing 20%, 40%, or 80% copper using high-power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS). Eighteen Ti6Al4V discs remained uncoated for control purposes. We tested antibacterial properties of S epidermidis grown on discs in wells containing growth medium. After 24 hours, planktonic bacteria as well as biofilms removed by sonication were quantitatively cultured. Annexin/Pi staining was used to quantify in vitro normal human osteoblast cell viability at 24 hours and Day 7, respectively. Copper elution was measured at Days 1, 2, 3, 7, 14, and 28 using an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer to analyze aliquots of culture medium. Copper ion concentration achieved at 24 hours was compared with previously published TC50 for gingival fibroblast, a phenotypically similar cell line with available data regarding copper ion exposure.

RESULTS

Discs coated with TiCuO 80% copper showed greater biofilm and planktonic cell density reduction when compared with other tested compositions (analysis of variance [ANOVA]; p < 0.001). Discs coated with TiCuO 80% copper showed mean biofilm and planktonic cell density of 4.0 log₁₀ (SD = 0.4) and 5.7 log₁₀ (SD = 0.2). Discs coated with TiCuO 80% showed a mean difference in biofilm and planktonic cell density of 2.5 log₁₀ (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.9-3.1 log_10; p < 0.001) and 1.2 (95% CI, 0.6-1.8; p < 0.001), respectively, when compared with uncoated discs. Normal human osteoblast viability did not differ among all groups at 24 hours (ANOVA; p = 0.2) and Day 7 (ANOVA; p = 0.7). Discs coated with TiCuO 80% copper showed a mean difference (95% CI) in relative cell viability (%) at 24 hours and Day 7 of 31.1 (95% CI, -19.4 to 81.7; p = 0.4) and -5.0 (95% CI, -7.8 to 17.9; p = 0.9), respectively, when compared with untreated cells. For all TiCuO-coated discs, copper ion elution peaked at 24 hours and slowly decreased in a curvilinear fashion to nearly undetectable levels by Day 28. Discs coated with TiCuO 80% copper showed mean copper ion concentration at 24 hours of 269.4 µmol/L (SD = 25.2 µmol/L) and this concentration was lower than previously published TC50 for similar human cell lines at 24 hours (344 µmol/L, SEM = 44 µmol/L).

CONCLUSIONS

This pilot study demonstrates a proof of concept that a thin-film implant coating with TiCuO can provide a potent local antibacterial environment while remaining relatively nontoxic to a human osteoblast cell line. Further research in an animal model will be necessary to establish efficacy and safety of this technique and whether it might be useful in the design of implants.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

A thin film coating with TiCuO demonstrates high antibacterial activity and low cellular cytotoxicity to human osteoblasts in vitro. Taken together, these properties represent a potential strategy for preventing periprosthetic infection if further work in animal models can confirm these results in vivo.

Mussel-inspired deposition of copper on titanium for bacterial inhibition and enhanced osseointegration in a periprosthetic infection model

Periprosthetic infection represents one of the most devastating complications in orthopedic surgeries.

Dietary copper and human health: Current evidence and unresolved issues

Although copper (Cu) is recognized as an essential trace element, uncertainties remain regarding Cu reference values for humans, as illustrated by discrepancies between recommendations issued by different national authorities. This review examines human studies published since 1990 on relationships between Cu intake, Cu balance, biomarkers of Cu status, and health. It points out several gaps and unresolved issues which make it difficult to assess Cu requirements. Results from balance studies suggest that daily intakes below 0.8 mg/day lead to net Cu losses, while net gains are consistently observed above 2.4 mg/day. However, because of an incomplete collection of losses in all studies, a precise estimation of Cu requirements cannot be derived from available data. Data regarding the relationship between Cu intake and potential biomarkers are either too preliminary or inconclusive because of low specificity or low sensitivity to change in dietary Cu over a wide range of intakes. Results from observation and intervention studies do not support a link between Cu and a risk of cardiovascular disease, cognitive decline, arthritis or cancer for intakes ranging from 0.6 to 3mg/day, and limited evidence exists for impaired immune function in healthy subjects with a very low (0.38 mg/day) Cu intake. However, data from observation studies should be regarded with caution because of uncertainties regarding Cu concentration in various foods and water. Further studies that accurately evaluate Cu exposure based on reliable biomarkers of Cu status are needed.

An exposure-response curve for copper excess and deficiency

There is a need to define exposure-response curves for both Cu excess and deficiency to assist in determining the acceptable range of oral intake. A comprehensive database has been developed where different health outcomes from elevated and deficient Cu intakes were assigned ordinal severity scores to create common measures of response. A generalized linear model for ordinal data was used to estimate the probability of response associated with dose, duration and severity. The model can account for differences in animal species, the exposure medium (drinking water and feed), age, sex, and solubility. Using this model, an optimal intake level of 2.6 mg Cu/d was determined. This value is higher than the current U.S. recommended dietary intake (RDI; 0.9 mg/d) that protects against toxicity from Cu deficiency. It is also lower than the current tolerable upper intake level (UL; 10 mg/d) that protects against toxicity from Cu excess. Compared to traditional risk assessment approaches, categorical regression can provide risk managers with more information, including a range of intake levels associated with different levels of severity and probability of response. To weigh the relative harms of deficiency and excess, it is important that the results be interpreted along with the available information on the nature of the responses that were assigned to each severity score.

Essentiality and toxicity in copper health risk assessment: overview, update and regulatory considerations

Copper (Cu), an essential element required as a cofactor and/or structural component of numerous metalloenzymes, is uniquely positioned as a case study for issues associated with the essential metals health risk assessment, because of its extensive database. Essential elements pose distinct challenges when establishing regulatory guidelines because too little as well as too much intake can produce adverse health consequences and the dose-response curve is roughly U-shaped. Thus, conventional health risk assessment paradigms do not apply to essential elements; the dose-response assessment needs to define an acceptable range of oral intake (AROI) which prevents deficiency by meeting nutritional requirements while avoiding toxicity due to high intakes. The conceptual framework for this type of risk assessment includes consideration of biological processes that are unique to essential elements-homeostasis, basal and normative nutritional requirements, bioavailability, and nutrient-nutrient interactions. In this paper, the Cu database on physiology, deficiency, and excess is briefly reviewed in order to establish the range of potential health hazards associated with varying levels of intake. Issues discussed include the (1) development of suitable dose-response methodologies, including appropriate dose and response metrics, for Cu; (2) categorization of severity of response and functional significance; (3) use of endpoints of similar severity and functionality for deficiency and excess in dose-response assessment; (4) development of valid biomarkers for subclinical effects, exposures and susceptibilities. Guideline values for Cu intake have been established by nutritional and toxicologic regulatory or advisory boards. Although regulators are more concerned with the potential human toxicity arising from excessive Cu intake, the preponderance of evidence suggests that deficiency is more of a public health concern than excess.

Methods of assessment of copper status in humans: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

The assessment of dietary adequacy of copper is constrained by the absence of recognized copper status biomarkers.

OBJECTIVES

The objectives were to systematically review the usefulness of copper status biomarkers and identify those that reflected changes in status over > or =4 wk.

DESIGN

The methods included a structured search on Ovid MEDLINE, EMBASE (Ovid), and Cochrane databases to October 2007, followed by the use of formal inclusion/exclusion criteria, data extraction, validity assessment, and meta-analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 16 studies (288 participants) were included in the review, with data on 16 possible copper biomarkers. All of the included studies were small and at high risk of bias. Data for serum copper suggested its value as a biomarker, reflecting changes in status in both depleted and replete individuals, although these changes were smaller in the latter. Total ceruloplasmin protein is related to copper status but reflects changes in highly depleted individuals only. Erythrocyte superoxide dismutase and urinary deoxypyridinoline are not useful biomarkers, but there were insufficient data to draw firm conclusions about plasma, erythrocyte, and platelet copper; leukocyte superoxide dismutase; erythrocyte, platelet, and plasma glutathione peroxidase; platelet and leukocyte cytochrome-c oxidase; total glutathione; diamine oxidase; and urinary pyridinoline. The paucity of data prevented detailed subgroup analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite limited data, serum copper appears to be a useful biomarker of copper status at the population level. Further large studies with low risk of bias are needed to explore the effectiveness of other biomarkers of copper status and the relation between biomarker responsiveness, dose, and period of supplementation.